ABSTRACT
FORPOLICYPURPOSESLOOKINGATHOWORWHETHERTHEDATAINTHEACCOUNTSPROVIDE THEANSWERS!STHEDISCUSSIONTHERESUGGESTSALTHOUGHSOMEQUESTIONSCANBE ANSWEREDDIRECTLYBYMEANSOFTHEACCOUNTSTHEACCOUNTSDATASERVEASONLYONE AMONGMANYINPUTSINTOMORECOMPLEXANALYSESUSEDTOTACKLEKEYPOLICYQUES TIONS4HEACCOUNTSDATAHELPWITHTHEPOLICYQUESTIONSESPECIALLYWHENTHEYSHOW HOWTHEMONETARYEXPENDITURESARETIEDTOTHEPHYSICALMEASURESOFPOLLUTIONBUT THEYAREBYNOMEANSSUFlCIENTONTHEIROWNTORESOLVEALLOFTHEM 0UBLICDEBATEONENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONUSUALLYFOCUSESAROUNDONEFUNDA
MENTALISSUECANWEAFFORDIT+NOWINGHOWMUCHWEARENOWSPENDINGTOPROTECT THEENVIRONMENTISONEOFTHEKEYELEMENTSUSEDTOANSWERTHATQUESTION"ECAUSE EXPENDITURESONENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONAREMARKETEDˆTHATISACTUALLYBOUGHT ANDSOLDˆTHEYARECAPTUREDWITHINTHECONVENTIONAL3.!4HECHALLENGEISTOIDEN TIFYWHICHEXPENDITURESSHOULDBECONSIDEREDENVIRONMENT RELATEDANDWHICH SHOULDNOTANDTHENTOPRESENTTHEMINTHESAMEFORMATUSEDSEVERALTIMESINPREVI OUSCHAPTERSTHESUPPLYANDUSETABLES-ANYROWSANDCOLUMNSOFTHE354SCANBE DISAGGREGATEDTODISTINGUISHEXPENDITURESTHATAREENVIRONMENT RELATEDFROMTHOSE THATARENOTINDUSTRIESGOODSANDSERVICESSUPPLIEDGOODSANDSERVICESPURCHASED BYUSERSGOVERNMENTEXPENDITURESHOUSEHOLDEXPENDITURESTAXESANDSOON -UCHOF THEDETAILEDWORKONPOLLUTIONPREVENTIONEXPENDITURESHASBEEN
DEVELOPEDTHROUGH%UROSTATINITSDESIGNOFTHE%UROPEAN3YSTEMFORTHE#OLLECTION OF%CONOMIC)NFORMATIONONTHE%NVIRONMENT3%2)%% %UROSTAT 3%2)%%IS PARTOFTHEBROADER%UROPEANSYSTEMFORENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTINGANDALSOHAS BEENINTEGRATEDINTOTHEREVISED3%%!4HISSYSTEMˆORATLEASTPORTIONSOFITˆHAS
RIENCEHASGONEINTORElNINGIT 4HE3%2)%%COVERSTWOBROADlELDSOFACTIVITYPROTECTIONOFTHEAMBIENTENVI
RONMENTANDMANAGEMENTOFNATURALRESOURCES)TCANALSOINCLUDEPROTECTIONOF HUMANSETTLEMENTSAGAINSTNATURALDISASTERSSUCHASmOODSANDBLIZZARDS)NPRAC TICEHOWEVERMUCHMOREWORKHASBEENDONEONEXPENDITURESTOPROTECTTHEAMBI ENTENVIRONMENTFROMPOLLUTIONTHANONTHEOTHERAREAS4HISISLARGELYBECAUSE POLLUTIONISAMOREIMPORTANTCONCERNTHANNATURALRESOURCESMANAGEMENTINTHE %UROPEANCOUNTRIESTHATDEVELOPEDTHESYSTEM4HEFOCUSOFTHISCHAPTERISINTHE SAMEAREAWHICHISREFERREDTOAS%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION%XPENDITURE!CCOUNTS %0%! 4HESEACCOUNTSINCLUDETHREEKINDSOFEXPENDITURESMANUFACTUREOFPROD UCTSWHOSEPURPOSEISENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONPURCHASESOFTHOSEPRODUCTSAND EXPENDITURESTOCLEANUPENVIRONMENTALDAMAGEAFTERITHASOCCURRED
!KEYISSUEINACCOUNTINGFORENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONISTHEDISTINCTIONBETWEEN THECOSTSINCURREDTOPREVENTHARMTOTHEENVIRONMENTANDTHECOSTSIMPOSEDBY HARMTOTHEENVIRONMENT3OMEOFTHESEIMPOSEDCOSTSENTAILACTUALEXPENDITURES ANDCANTHEREFOREBEIDENTIlEDINMARKETDATAWHEREASOTHERSDONOTENTAILIDENTI lABLEMARKETEXPENDITURES4HISDISTINCTIONHASNOTALWAYSBEENCLEARINTHEENVI RONMENTALACCOUNTINGLITERATUREANDTHETERMINOLOGYUSEDTODESCRIBETHEDIFFER ENTTYPESOFCOSTSHASCHANGEDOVERTIME 4HECOSTSOFPREVENTINGENVIRONMENTALHARMAREMARKETED4HEYINCLUDESUCH
EXPENDITURESASFACTORYINVESTMENTSTOlLTERWASTECATALYTICCONVERTERSINCARS ANDTHEDIFFERENCEINCOSTBETWEENLEADEDANDUNLEADEDGASOLINE4HEYCANALSO BEINTERPRETEDASINCLUDINGTHECOSTSOFCLEANINGUPPOLLUTIONONCEITHASOCCURRED 4HELOGICFORTHISISTHATLEAVINGCONTAMINATIONINTHEENVIRONMENTWILLCAUSEFUR THERENVIRONMENTALHARMINTHEFUTUREFOREXAMPLEGROUNDWATERMAYBECONTAM INATEDBYCHEMICALSLEACHINGTHROUGHSOILORAQUATICLIFEMAYBEKILLEDBYWATER POLLUTION 4HECOSTSIMPOSEDBYPOLLUTIONMAYBEEITHERMARKETEDORNONMARKETED4HE
MARKETEDCOSTSINCLUDESUCHITEMSASHEALTH CARECOSTSANDFORGONEWAGESIFPOL LUTIONCAUSESILLNESSORCLEANINGOFBUILDINGSIFPOLLUTIONDEGRADESTHEIRFACADES 4HEYALSOINCLUDEINTERMEDIATEANDlNALCONSUMPTIONWHOSEPURPOSEISTOPROTECT PEOPLEORPRODUCTIONFROMPOLLUTIONSUCHASDRINKING WATERTREATMENTWHICHISA MAJORINDUSTRYTYPICALLYCONSIDEREDTOBERELATEDTOENVIRONMENTALHEALTH -UCHOFTHEHARMIMPOSEDBYPOLLUTIONISNOTMARKETEDALTHOUGHITISREALIT
DOESNOTBRINGABOUTDIRECTEXPENDITURESANDTHEREFORECANNOTBETRACKEDTHROUGH MARKETDATA4HISCATEGORY INCLUDESPAINANDSUFFERINGRATHER THANTHEMEDI CALCOSTSANDFORGONEINCOME ASARESULTOFILLNESSLOSTRECREATIONOPPORTUNITIES BECAUSEOFWATERPOLLUTIONECOSYSTEMHARMSUCHASFORESTDESTRUCTIONBYACIDRAIN ANDSOON 4HE3%%!DISTINGUISHESAMONGTHESETYPESOFCOSTSUSINGSEVERALTERMS
0ARAGRAPHDElNEShMAINTENANCECOSTSvASTHOSETHAThWOULDHAVEBEENINCURRED IFTHEENVIRONMENTHADBEENUSEDINSUCHAWAYASNOTTOHAVEAFFECTEDITSFUTURE
PREVENTIONCOSTSARETERMEDhCOSTSCAUSEDvANDTHERESULTINGHARMISCALLEDhCOSTS BORNEv,ATERINTHESAMECHAPTERTHEHANDBOOKREFERSTOTHEINDUSTRYTHATSELLS THEPROTECTIONEQUIPMENTANDSERVICESAShPRODUCTIONACTIVITIESPRODUCINGENVI RONMENTALPROTECTIONSERVICESvANDTOTHECOSTSIMPOSEDAShREPERCUSSIONCOSTSv 4HETERMShMAINTENANCECOSTSvhCOSTSCAUSEDvANDhCOSTSBORNEvHAVEBEENMOST WIDELYPICKEDUPINSUBSEQUENTLITERATUREANDAPPLICATIONS 4HOUGHTHE3%%!IDENTIlESTHESECATEGORIESOFCOSTSITDOESNOTCONSIS
TENTLYMAINTAINTHEDISTINCTIONSAMONGTHEM&OREXAMPLEPARAGRAPHSAYSTHAT IFACCOUNTANTSAREINTERESTEDINTHEENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFECONOMICACTIVITIES THEYSHOULDAPPLYTHEhCOSTSCAUSEDvAPPROACHh%NVIRONMENTALIMPACTSvAPPAR ENTLYISBEINGUSEDINTHISCONTEXTTOREFERTOINDUSTRIALEXPENDITURESTOPREVENT POLLUTIONRATHERTHANTOTHEHARMCAUSEDBYTHATPOLLUTION!TTIMESTHISAMBIGU ITYHASGIVENTHEIMPRESSIONTHATTHEAUTHORSOFTHE3%%!BELIEVEDTHATTHE COSTSIMPOSEDBYPOLLUTIONCOULDBEESTIMATEDONTHEBASISOFTHECOSTSREQUIRED TOPREVENTIT4HISISNOTTHECASE2ATHERhCOSTSCAUSEDvTELLUSTHEEXPENDITURES ALREADYINCURREDTOPREVENTSOMEPOLLUTIONANDhCOSTSBORNEvTELLUSHOWMUCH BENElTCOULDBEDERIVEDFROMFURTHEREXPENDITURESTOPREVENTTHEPOLLUTIONTHAT STILLREMAINS4HEREISNOREASONTOEXPECTTHETOTALOFEXPENDITURESALREADYINCURRED TOBEEQUALTOBENElTSTHATCOULDBEDERIVEDFROMADDITIONALEXPENDITURES
4HEREVISED3%%!DISTINGUISHESPREVENTIONCOSTSFROMCOSTSIMPOSEDBYENVI RONMENTALHARMMORECLEARLYTHANTHE3%%!DROPPINGTHETERMINOLOGYhCOSTS CAUSEDvANDhCOSTSBORNEvANDTHEIMPLICATIONTHATCOUNTRIESMAYCHOOSEBETWEEN THEMBASEDONDATAAVAILABILITY)NTHEIRPLACEITUSEShDEFENSIVEEXPENDITURESvTO DESCRIBECOSTSACTUALLYINCURREDTOAVOIDDAMAGETOTHEENVIRONMENTINCLUDING COSTSCLASSIlEDASENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONEXPENDITUREASWELLASADMINISTRA TIVECOSTSOFRESOURCEMANAGEMENT4HEREVISED3%%!CONSIDERSPOTENTIALCOSTS THATMIGHTBEINCURREDTOAVOIDFURTHERENVIRONMENTALDAMAGEASTHECOST BASED APPROACHTOPUTTINGAMONETARYVALUEONENVIRONMENTALDEGRADATION4HISISIN CONTRASTWITHTHEBENElT BASEDAPPROACHWHICHESTIMATESTHEBENElTTHATWOULD BEDERIVEDFROMAVOIDINGTHATDAMAGEˆWHICHISTHESAMEASTHECOSTSIMPOSED BYTHEDAMAGE4HE3%%!USEShDAMAGE AFFECTEDACCOUNTINGENTRIESvANDhDAMAGE BASEDVALUATIONADJUSTMENTSvTOREFERTOCHANGESINTHECONVENTIONALACCOUNTSTO CAPTURETHEHARMIMPOSEDBECAUSEOFENVIRONMENTALDEGRADATION5NLIKETHE VERSIONTHEREVISED3%%!ISVERYCLEARABOUTTHEDISTINCTIONSAMONGTHESEMEA SURESANDTHATTHEREISNOREASONFORANYOFTHEMTOBEEQUALTOEACHOTHER
)NORDERTOORGANIZEMONETARYDATAONENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONTHEACCOUNTS NEEDAWAYTODElNEWHICHACTIVITIESARECONSIDEREDTOBEhENVIRONMENTALvAND WHICHARENOT4HISISDONEBASEDONTHEIRPURPOSE4HEYMUSTBEUNDERTAKENPRI MARILYINORDERTOPROTECTTHEENVIRONMENTACTIVITIESTHATHAPPENTOBENElTTHE ENVIRONMENTBUTAREUNDERTAKENFOROTHERREASONSARENOTCONSIDEREDENVIRON MENTAL4HISOBVIOUSLYCREATESCONSIDERABLEGRAYAREASINCLASSIlCATION&OREXAM PLEINVESTMENTSINENERGYEFlCIENCYTHATAREMADEFORTHElNANCIALPAYOFFARENOT CONSIDEREDENVIRONMENTALEVENTHOUGHTHEYALSOWILLREDUCEEMISSIONSOFGREEN
HOUSEGASESANDOTHERAIRPOLLUTANTS)FHOWEVERTHESAMEINVESTMENTSWEREMADE INRESPONSETOGOVERNMENTREQUIREMENTSTOREDUCEEMISSIONSTHEYWOULDBECLAS SIlEDASENVIRONMENTALEVENIFTHEYWEREALSOPROlTABLE3IMILARLYEXPENDITURES ONRECYCLINGTHATAREMADEINORDERTOREDUCEWASTEARECLASSIlEDASENVIRONMENTAL WHEREASTHOSETHATAREMADEFORTHESAVINGSDERIVEDFROMREUSEOFMATERIALSARENOT CLASSIlEDASENVIRONMENTALINPURPOSE !SELSEWHEREINTHEACCOUNTSASPECIALCLASSIlCATIONSYSTEMHASBEENDESIGNED
TODETERMINEWHATSHOULDBECONSIDEREDhENVIRONMENTALvANDTOORGANIZE THE INFORMATIONTHATISINCLUDED!CTIVITIESWHOSEPRIMARYPURPOSEISENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTIONAREREFERREDTOASCHARACTERISTICACTIVITIES4HEIROUTPUTSTYPICALLYARE SERVICESRATHERTHANGOODSANDARETERMEDCHARACTERISTICPRODUCTS4HEYMAYBE IDENTIlEDINTHEREVERSEORDERASWELLCHARACTERISTICPRODUCTSMAYBEIDENTIlED lRSTANDTHEACTIVITIESCLASSIlEDBASEDONTHEIROUTPUT#HARACTERISTICACTIVITIESARE ORGANIZEDACCORDINGTOTHE#LASSIlCATIONOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!CTIVITIES #%0! WHOSEOVERALLSTRUCTUREISSHOWNIN4ABLE 4HISISANALTERNATIVECLASSIl CATIONSYSTEMFORINDUSTRIALACTIVITIESBASEDONTHEUSETOWHICHTHEIRPRODUCTSARE PUTRATHERTHANONTHEPRODUCTSTHEMSELVES 4HE#%0!INCLUDESACTIVITIESTOPREVENTPOLLUTIONANDTOCLEANITUPONCEITHAS
OCCURREDˆNOTABLYTHEDECONTAMINATIONOFSOILSURFACEWATERANDGROUNDWATER INCATEGORY4HE#%0!DOESNOTHOWEVERINCLUDEACTIVITIESTHATAREARESPONSE TOPOLLUTIONRATHERTHANAWAYTOPREVENTITNORDOESITINCLUDEANYOFTHEHARM IMPOSEDBYPOLLUTION
#LASSIFICATIONOF %NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION !CTIVITIES
0RODUCTS5SEDFOR%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION 4HEENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTSADDRESSENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONPRODUCTSASWELLAS ACTIVITIESALTHOUGHTHEYHAVENOCLASSIlCATIONSYSTEMEQUIVALENTTOTHE#%0!3EV ERALDIFFERENTKINDSOFPRODUCTSFALLWITHINTHISAREA
N 4HEOUTPUTSOFENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONACTIVITIESARETERMEDCHARACTERISTIC PRODUCTSANDAREUSUALLYSERVICES
N #ONNECTEDPRODUCTSAREGOODSRATHERTHANSERVICES WHOSEPRIMARYPURPOSEIS ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONSUCHASCATALYTICCONVERTERSINCARSTRASHMANAGE MENTSUPPLIESANDSEPTICTANKS
N !DAPTEDPRODUCTSARETHOSETHATAREUSEDFORTHESAMEPURPOSEASEQUIVALENT ORDINARYPRODUCTSBUTAREBOTHLESSHARMFULTOTHEENVIRONMENTˆEITHERINUSE ORINDISPOSALˆANDMOREEXPENSIVE'OODEXAMPLESARELEAD FREEGASOLINEAND THEADDITIONALINVESTMENTCOSTINANEWPLANTTOMAKEITLESSPOLLUTING/NLYTHE DIFFERENCEINCOSTBETWEENTHEADAPTEDPRODUCTANDTHEEQUIVALENTORDINARYONE WOULDBEINCLUDEDINTHE%0%!4HISISSOMETIMESCALLEDTHEEXTRA COSTCRITERION FORCONSIDERINGPRODUCTSTOBEENVIRONMENTAL)NADDITIONTHENETCOSTOFTHE EXPENDITUREMUSTBEPOSITIVEIFAhGREENvPRODUCTCOSTSLESSTHANANEQUIVALENT ORDINARYONEITISNOTCONSIDEREDTOENTAILANENVIRONMENTALEXPENDITURE4HIS ISCALLEDTHENET COSTCRITERION
4HESETHREEKINDSOFENVIRONMENTALPRODUCTSAREGROUPEDTOGETHERUNDERTHE LABELSPECIlCPRODUCTS!LTHOUGHINTHEORYTHEDISTINCTIONBETWEENSPECIlCPROD UCTSANDONESUNRELATEDTOTHEENVIRONMENTMAYBECLEARINPRACTICEITISNOTCLEAR ATALL0RODUCTSINTENDEDFORENVIRONMENTALPURPOSESAREREGULARLYUSEDTOMEET OTHERNEEDS7HOHASNEVERlLLEDABIGPLASTICTRASHBAGWITHCLOTHESORBLANKETS FORMOVINGORSTORAGE-OREIMPORTANTMANYPRODUCTSAREINTENDEDFORUSEEITHER FORENVIRONMENTALORFOROTHERPURPOSESPIPESHARDWAREOFlCESUPPLIESVEHICLES ANDSOON&ORTHESEREASONSNODElNITIVELISTORCLASSIlCATIONOFENVIRONMENTAL PRODUCTSEXISTS )NADDITIONTOTHESECLASSIlCATIONDIFlCULTIESANOTHERSIGNIlCANTPROBLEMOCCURS
INTHEIDENTIlCATIONOFENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONPRODUCTSORACTIVITIES7HENAN OLDFACTORYMUSTBEGINCONTROLLINGITSPOLLUTIONITDOESSOWITHhEND OF PIPEvTECH NOLOGYWHICHISEASYTODISTINGUISHFROMTHEPRODUCTIVETECHNOLOGYWITHWHICHTHE PLANTWASBUILT7HENNEWFACTORIESAREBUILTHOWEVERTHEYOFTENAREDESIGNEDIN NEWWAYSTOAVOIDGENERATINGPOLLUTIONINTHElRSTPLACE7ITHSUCHTECHNOLOGYIT ISNOTPOSSIBLETODISTINGUISHTHECOSTSOFPOLLUTIONCONTROLFROMOTHERCOSTSOFTHE FACTORY!SARESULTTHEWHOLECONCEPTOFENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONEXPENDITURES ORENVIRONMENTALACTIVITIESORPRODUCTSCANBECOMESOMEWHATMEANINGLESS
4HESTANDARDINDUSTRIALCLASSIlCATIONSYSTEM)3)#INCLUDESSEVERALCATEGORIESTHAT TYPICALLYPRODUCEENVIRONMENTALPRODUCTS!SACONVENIENTSHORTHANDTHISGROUP OFINDUSTRIESISDESCRIBEDASTHEENVIRONMENTINDUSTRY)TINCLUDESRECYCLINGSOLID WASTEHANDLINGWASTEWATERTREATMENTANDSOON4HEDESCRIPTIONOFTHEENVIRON
MENTINDUSTRYINTHEREVISED3%%!SPECIlESTHEDIVISIONSINTHE)3)#CLASSIlCATION SYSTEMTHATARECONSIDEREDTOBEENVIRONMENTALINPURPOSE4HE)3)#ISAFOUR LEVEL HIERARCHICALSYSTEM%ACHCATEGORYISASSIGNEDANUMBERWITHONETOFOURDIGITS DEPENDINGONITSLEVELINTHEHIERARCHY#ATEGORIESATTHETWO DIGITLEVELAREREFERRED TOASDIVISIONSAT THE THREE DIGIT LEVELASGROUPSANDAT THE FOUR DIGIT LEVELAS CLASSES!S4ABLE SHOWSALLOFSOMEDIVISIONSAREPARTOFTHEENVIRONMENTINDUS TRYBUTONLYSPECIlCGROUPSORCLASSESWITHINOTHERDIVISIONSAREINCLUDED 4HEENVIRONMENTALACTIVITIESINAGIVENENTERPRISEMAYCONSTITUTEITSPRIMARY
ACTIVITYTHEONETHATPRODUCESMOSTREVENUE ITSSECONDARYACTIVITIESBY PROD UCTSTHATITSELLSTOOUTSIDECUSTOMERS ORITSANCILLARYACTIVITIESINTERNALACTIVITIES NECESSARYFORTHEOPERATIONOFTHEBUSINESS -ANYENVIRONMENTALACTIVITIESARE UNDERTAKENBYGOVERNMENTANDOTHERPUBLICAGENCIESPARTICULARLYTHOSEWITHIN
)3)##ATEGORIES4HAT )NCLUDE!SPECTSOFTHE %NVIRONMENT)NDUSTRY
THEACCOUNTSBASEDONINPUTCOSTSRATHERTHANREVENUESBECAUSETHEPUBLICSECTOR OFTENDOESNOTGENERATEREVENUE )DEALLYTHEACCOUNTSWOULDTREATPRIMARYANDSECONDARYACTIVITIESOFASINGLE
ENTERPRISEAS IF THEYWERESEPARATEENTERPRISES4HISWOULDHOWEVER REQUIREA LEVELOFCOMPLEXITY IN THECOMPANIESACCOUNTINGSYSTEMSNOTOFTENAVAILABLE 4HEYWOULDHAVETODISTINGUISHNOTONLYBETWEENTHEREVENUESFROMPRIMARYAND SECONDARYACTIVITIESBUTALSOAMONGALLTHEINPUTCOSTSINCLUDINGLABORANCILLARY ACTIVITIESCAPITALFORMATIONTAXESOPERATINGSURPLUSANDSOON4HISISCLEARLYVERY DIFlCULT)NPRACTICEAVARIETYOFESTIMATIONTECHNIQUESAREUSEDTOSEPARATESEC ONDARYPRODUCTIONOFENVIRONMENTALACTIVITIESFROMPRIMARYPRODUCTIONOFOTHER GOODSORSERVICES 4HEENTERPRISESOWNENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONACTIVITIES SUCHASCLEANING
THEPLANTOPERATINGANDMAINTAININGPOLLUTIONCONTROLEQUIPMENTANDDEALING WITHGOVERNMENTREGULATORSCANEITHERBECARRIEDOUTIN HOUSEORBECONTRACTED OUTTOSPECIALIZEDlRMSFORWHICHTHEYAREPRIMARYORSECONDARYACTIVITIES)FTHEY AREUNDERTAKENINTERNALLYTHEYAREANCILLARYACTIVITIES)NTHISCASETHEIRCOSTSARE ASSIGNEDTOTHEINDUSTRYINWHICHTHEENTERPRISESPRIMARYACTIVITYISCLASSIlEDAND ARENOTSEPARATELYIDENTIlED)FONTHEOTHERHANDTHEYARECONTRACTEDOUTTHEY AREINTERMEDIATECONSUMPTIONANDSHOWUPINTHEACCOUNTSOFTHECONSUMINGAND PRODUCINGSECTORS 4ODETERMINETHETOTALAMOUNTSPENTONENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONITISNEC
ESSARYTOQUANTIFYTHESEEXPENDITURESWHETHERTHEYAREANCILLARYORCONTRACTED OUT4HISMEANSlNDINGAWAYTODISAGGREGATEANCILLARYEXPENDITURESINGENERAL ANDENVIRONMENT RELATEDANCILLARYEXPENDITURESINPARTICULARFROMOTHERENTER PRISEEXPENDITURES&ORANALYTICALPURPOSESˆASWHENTHEDATAAREUSEDTOMODEL THECOSTSOFENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONTOTHEECONOMYˆITISHELPFULIFALLENVIRON MENTALPROTECTIONEXPENDITURESCOULDBETREATEDTHESAMEWAYWHETHERTHEYARE ANCILLARYORCONTRACTEDOUT)FTHEDATAAREAVAILABLETOCLEARLYIDENTIFYTHEANCILLARY EXPENDITURESTHEYMAYBEhEXTERNALIZEDvORTREATEDASIFTHEYWEREINTERMEDIATE CONSUMPTIONTHATWASCONTRACTEDOUT4HISHASNOIMPACTONVALUEADDEDOROTHER ACCOUNTINGAGGREGATESBUTDOESMAKEITPOSSIBLETOTREATTHEANCILLARYACTIVITIESASIF THEYHADBEENDONEBYSEPARATEENTERPRISESWHOSEPRIMARYACTIVITYISENVIRONMEN TALPROTECTION
4HESUPPLYANDUSETABLESALSOMAYBEUSEDTODISTINGUISHENVIRONMENTALTAXESAND SUBSIDIESFROMTHEBROADERSETOFTAXESAPPLIEDBYGOVERNMENTS.OTEHOWEVER THATTHETERMENVIRONMENTALTAXESISREGULARLYUSEDANDSOMETIMESCONFUSED IN TWOWAYS&IRSTITMAYREFERTOTAXESASSESSEDONABASETHATHASIMPLICATIONSFOR THEENVIRONMENTSUCHASGASOLINEUSEORCARBONEMISSIONS)NADDITIONTORAISING REVENUESSUCHTAXESAREINTENDEDTOREDUCETHEUSEOFPOLLUTINGPRODUCTSBYRAISING THEIRPRICE4HESEARESOMETIMESREFERREDTOAShGREENTAXESv4HEYWOULDBECAP TUREDINTHE354ASTAXESONPRODUCTIONORUSEOFPRODUCTS %NVIRONMENTAL TAXESALSOMAY REFER TO TAXESWHOSE REVENUESAREDEDICATED
TOENVIRONMENTALEXPENDITURES!TAXONCARBONEMISSIONSFOREXAMPLEMIGHT
!LTHOUGHTAXESDEDICATEDTOENVIRONMENTALEXPENDITURESTYPICALLYALSOSEEMTOBE GREENTAXESNOLINKNECESSARILYEXISTSBETWEENTHEBASEONWHICHTHETAXISLEVIED ANDTHEPURPOSETOWHICHITISPUT)NPARTICULARAGOODCASECANBEMADETHATREVE NUESFROMGREENTAXESSHOULDGOINTOGENERALREVENUESSOTHATOTHERTAXESONDESIR ABLEACTIVITIESSUCHASEMPLOYMENTCANBEREDUCED4HISSTRATEGYISSOMETIMES REFERREDTOBYTHOSEWHOADVOCATEITAShTAXINGBADSNOTGOODSv4AXESDEDICATEDTO SPECIlCUSESAREOFTENDESCRIBEDASBEINGhEARMARKEDv 4HEFOCUSINMOSTENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTINGISONENVIRONMENTALTAXESINTHE
lRSTSENSE%UROSTATAND/%#$HAVEDEVELOPEDACLASSIlCATIONSYSTEMANDMETH ODOLOGYTOACCOUNTFORTHEM%UROSTAT 4HEYDElNEENVIRONMENTALTAXESTO INCLUDEALLTAXESASSESSEDONABASERELATEDTOTHEENVIRONMENTWHETHERTHEMOTI VATIONFORTHETAXISPRIMARILYTOGENERATEREVENUEORTOCREATEADISINCENTIVETOCON SUMETHEGOODS4HEYORGANIZESUCHTAXESINTOFOURBROADCATEGORIESBASEDONTHE PRODUCTONWHICHTHEYAREASSESSEDENERGYPOLLUTANTEMISSIONSTRANSPORTATION ANDNATURALRESOURCES4HISSYSTEMWHICHHASBEENIMPLEMENTEDBYANUMBEROF %UROPEAN5NIONCOUNTRIESPROVIDESDATAINGREATERDETAILTHANISAVAILABLEINTHE CONVENTIONAL3.!4HE3.!CLASSIlESTAXDATAINTOTHREECATEGORIESTAXESRELATED TOPRODUCTIONANDPRODUCTSTAXESONINCOMEANDCAPITALTAXES-OSTENVIRONMEN TALTAXESRELATETOPRODUCTIONANDPRODUCTS4HESEAREFURTHERDIVIDEDINTOTHREE SUBCATEGORIESTAXESONPRODUCTSEXCEPTFORVALUEADDEDTAX6!4 OTHERTAXESON PRODUCTIONEXCEPTFOR6!4AND6!43UBSIDIESONPRODUCTSANDPRODUCTIONFOLLOWA SIMILARCLASSIlCATION4AXlGURESARESOMETIMESSHOWNONANETBASISINTHISCON TEXTNETMEANSTHATTHESUBSIDYGIVENISNETTEDOUTOFTHETAXCOLLECTED4HUSTHE ENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTINGSYSTEMMAKESITPOSSIBLETOSEPARATETHETAXPAYMENTS ANDSUBSIDIESBYTYPEANDBYINDUSTRYWHICHPERMITSANALYSISOFTHEIMPACTSOFTHE TAXSYSTEMONINDUSTRYANDOUTPUT !NhENVIRONMENTALSUBSIDYvINTHISCONTEXTMAYBEUNDERSTOODASANEGATIVETAX
4HATISITISAPAYMENTTOAUSERTOINDUCEHIMORHERNOTTOACTINAWAYTHATWILL BEHARMFUL%NVIRONMENTALSUBSIDIESAREORGANIZEDINTOTHESAMEFOURCATEGORIES ASTAXESENERGYPOLLUTIONTRANSPORTANDNATURALRESOURCES)NSOMEINSTANCESTHE SUBSIDIESARElNANCEDFROMEARMARKEDENVIRONMENTALTAXESBUTOFTENTHESUBSI DIESAREPROVIDEDOUTOFGENERALREVENUESNOTFROMASPECIlCTAXDEDICATEDFORTHAT PURPOSE 3UBSIDIESDESIGNEDTOFURTHERSOCIALGOALSUNRELATEDTOTHEENVIRONMENTCANALSO
HAVEANEFFECTONTHEENVIRONMENT&OREXAMPLESUBSIDIESINTENDEDTOIMPROVETHE ECONOMICWELL BEINGOFlSHINGCOMMUNITIESARESOMETIMESCONSIDEREDTOLEADTO OVERlSHINGANDCONSEQUENTDEPLETIONOFTHERESOURCEBASE
4HESUPPLYANDUSETABLEFRAMEWORKMAYBEUSEDTOPRESENTDATAONDIFFERENTCOM PONENTSOFTHE%0%!4ABLE PROVIDESANEXAMPLEOFAN354FORENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTIONPRODUCTS)TSHOWSTHESAMEGENERALFRAMEWORKASINEARLIERCHAPTERS BUTWITHTHEDISTINCTIONSBETWEENENVIRONMENTALANDOTHERPRODUCTSHIGHLIGHTED 4HETABLEPRESENTEDHERELACKSSOMECOLUMNSSHOWNINTHEPREVIOUS354SBECAUSE
5SEOF%NVIRONMENTAL'OODSAND3ERVICES
3UPPLYAND5SE4ABLE FOR%NVIRONMENTAL
0ROTECTION%XPENDITURES
EXPANDSOTHERSINORDERTOPROVIDEADDITIONALDETAIL
4HESUPPLYANDUSETABLESARETHEBASISFORCALCULATINGANAGGREGATEESTIMATEOF NATIONALEXPENDITUREONENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION.%%0 ORTHETOTALAMOUNTOF NATIONALRESOURCESTHATAREALLOCATEDTOPROTECTINGTHEENVIRONMENT5NFORTUNATELY ANUMBEROFADJUSTMENTSAREREQUIREDTOGOFROMTHE354TO.%%03OMEPRODUCTS OFTHEENVIRONMENTINDUSTRYAREINFACTNOTUSEDFORENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION WHILESOMENONENVIRONMENTALGOODSANDSERVICESAREUSEDFORTHATPURPOSE)TIS ALSONECESSARYTOKNOWEXACTLYWHEREANDHOWTHECOSTSOCCURTHEINCREASEINA PRODUCERSPRICESTOCOVERENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONMAYNOTBETHESAMEASTHE ADDITIONALCOSTBURDEN&OR.%%0TOBEANALOGOUSTO'$0OROTHERAGGREGATEMEA SURESITISIMPORTANTNOTTODOUBLECOUNTINPUTGOODSTHEREFORETHEESTIMATECAN NOTINCLUDEBOTHTHEINCREASEINCOSTSINCURREDBYTHEPRODUCERANDTHEINCREASEIN PRICEPAIDBYTHECONSUMER )NADDITION.%%0ADDSSUBSIDIESTODOMESTICINDUSTRYANDTRANSFERSTOOTHER
COUNTRIESFORENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION)NDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESSUBSIDIESPLAYAN IMPORTANTROLEINAGRICULTUREBOTHBENElTINGANDHARMINGTHEENVIRONMENT&OR EXAMPLEINTHE5NITED3TATESMANYSTATESOFFERFARMERSREDUCEDTAXESASANINCEN TIVEFORCONSERVINGSHORELINEVEGETATIONTHATPREVENTSRUNOFFWHILENATIONALSUB SIDIESFORGRAINPRODUCTIONLEADTODEPLETIONOFLANDTHATISMORESUITEDTOGRAZING THANTOCULTIVATION)NTERNATIONALTRANSFERSFORENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONARESIGNIl CANTINMUCHOFTHEDEVELOPINGWORLDWHEREFOREIGNAIDOFTENHASAMAJORENVIRON MENTALCOMPONENT4HEYAREALSOAFACTORWITHINTHE%UROPEAN5NIONANDBETWEEN THE%5ANDPROSPECTIVENEWMEMBERSALBEITAMUCHLESSIMPORTANTONE4HESEARE ADDEDTO.%%0FORTHEDONORCOUNTRYANDSUBTRACTEDFROMITFORTHERECIPIENTCOUN TRYBECAUSEITISTHEDONORTHATACTUALLYMAKESTHEEXPENDITURE .%%0CANTHUSBECALCULATEDASFOLLOWS
THElNALANDINTERMEDIATECONSUMPTIONOFENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONGOODSAND SERVICESBYRESIDENTUNITSOTHERTHANTHOSEOFTHEENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONPRO DUCERSTHEMSELVES
PLUSCAPITALFORMATIONONENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONGOODSANDSERVICES PLUSCAPITALFORMATIONONOTHERPRODUCTSUSEDFORENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION PLUSANYSPECIFIC TRANSFERSBYRESIDENTUNITNOTCAPTURED IN3TEPPLUSANY lNANCINGPROVIDEDTOTHE2/7
LESSANYRECEIVEDFROM2/7
4HERESULTINGMEASUREGIVESANOVERALLPICTUREOFHOWMUCHANDWHATSHARE OFTHENATIONALECONOMYGOESTOPROTECTINGTHEENVIRONMENT!LTHOUGHTHISISAN INTERESTINGINDICATORBOTHFORCOMPARISONACROSSCOUNTRIESANDTOOBSERVETRENDS OVERTIMEASWITHALLSUCHINDICATORSITMUSTBEUSEDWITHCAUTION.OhRIGHTvLEVEL ORSHAREOFENVIRONMENTALEXPENDITUREEXISTSSOTHISMEASUREALONEWILLNOTTELLUS WHETHERWEARESPENDINGENOUGHTOOLITTLEORTOOMUCH)NTERNATIONALCOMPARI SONSCERTAINLYWILLATTRACTINTEREST4HEDIFFERENCESCOULDMEANMANYTHINGSHOW
ONECOUNTRYHASAHEAVIERCONCENTRATIONOFPOLLUTINGINDUSTRYTHANANOTHERAND THEREFOREMUSTSPENDMORETOPREVENTPOLLUTIONORPERHAPSTHATONECOUNTRYCOM BATSPOLLUTIONMOREEFlCIENTLYTHANANOTHER&OLLOWINGASINGLECOUNTRYOVERTIME WILLRAISESIMILARQUESTIONS!COUNTRYSEXPENDITUREORTHESHAREOFITSEXPENDITURE INTOTALINCOMECOULDDROPBECAUSEITHASSLACKEDOFFONENVIRONMENTALPROTEC TION!LTERNATELYINTHEEARLYYEARSOFITSPROGRAMITMAYHAVEMADEMAJORINVEST MENTSTOUPGRADEEXISTINGFACTORIESANDNOWISPAYINGONLYTHEOPERATINGCOSTSOF THOSEINVESTMENTS"ETTERYETITMAYNOWBEREPLACINGTHEOLDPOLLUTINGFACTORIES WITHNEWONESTHATHAVEINTEGRATEDPOLLUTIONCONTROLUSINGTECHNOLOGYTHATACTU ALLYREDUCESTHECOSTSALTOGETHERSOITHASNOIDENTIlABLEENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION EXPENDITURES/RITCOULDNOWBEIMPORTINGDIRTYPRODUCTSANDLETTINGTHEWORLD SUFFERWORSEPOLLUTIONWHILEHAVINGREDUCEDTHEPOLLUTIONITGENERATESDIRECTLY !STHISWEALTHOFINTERPRETATIONSUGGESTSASINGLEINDICATORISRARELYSUFlCIENTTO
UNDERSTANDWHATISHAPPENINGINTHEECONOMY-EASURESSUCHASNATIONALEXPEN DITUREONPOLLUTIONCONTROLMUSTBECOMBINEDWITHARICHERSETOFDATAONBOTHTHE ECONOMYANDTHEENVIRONMENTINORDERTODRAWINFORMEDCONCLUSIONS
"ECAUSEPUBLICDEBATEONTHEENVIRONMENTOFTENCENTERSAROUNDWHETHERWECAN AFFORDTOPROTECTITTHEENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTSPLACEAMAJOREMPHASISONEXPEN DITURESACTUALLYINCURREDTOPROTECTTHEENVIRONMENTORTOCOPEWITHENVIRONMENTAL HARM4HEACCOUNTSTRACKDEFENSIVEEXPENDITURESWHICHINCLUDETHOSETOPREVENT POLLUTIONANDTHOSETOMANAGENATURALRESOURCES!CTIVITIESWHOSEPURPOSEISTO PROTECTTHEENVIRONMENTARETERMEDCHARACTERISTICACTIVITIESANDAREORGANIZEDIN THEACCOUNTSUSINGTHE#LASSIlCATIONOF%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!CTIVITIES#%0! 4HEOUTPUTOFCHARACTERISTICACTIVITIESISCHARACTERISTICPRODUCTSWHICHAREGENER ALLYSERVICES'OODSUSEDPRIMARILYFORENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONARETERMEDCON NECTEDPRODUCTSTHOSEAVAILABLEINENVIRONMENTALLYPREFERABLEVERSIONSAREKNOWN ASADAPTEDPRODUCTS4HEACCOUNTSSIMILARLYIDENTIFYTHEENVIRONMENTALINDUSTRYAS THOSE)3)#CATEGORIESPRODUCINGCHARACTERISTICCONNECTEDORADAPTEDPRODUCTS ANDCATEGORIZEASENVIRONMENTALTAXESANDFEESTHOSEDESIGNEDTOCREATEINCENTIVES FORGREATERENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION 5SINGTHESECLASSIlCATIONSYSTEMSTHEENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTSPRESENTMON
ETARYDATAONENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONANDNATURALRESOURCEMANAGEMENTWITHIN THEFRAMEWORKOFTHESUPPLYANDUSETABLES4HISPROVIDESTHEBASISFORCALCULATING .ATIONAL%XPENDITUREON%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION.%%0 WHICHGIVESASENSEOF THESHAREOFTHEECONOMYDEVOTEDTOTHEENVIRONMENT!LTHOUGHTHISISANINTEREST INGMEASUREITMUSTBEUSEDWITHCAUTIONASCHANGESOVERTIMECANBEINTERPRETED INMANYDIFFERENTWAYS
