ABSTRACT
DATA4HEFOLLOWINGDISCUSSIONREFERSTO4ABLE IN#HAPTERWHICHPRESENTSTHE SUPPLYANDUSEOFRESIDUALS4HESUPPLYTABLETHEUPPERPORTIONOF4ABLE COVERS THEMOSTOBVIOUSSETOFISSUESWHOISEMITTINGWHAT)NPRACTICETHETABLESOFTEN AREPRESENTEDDIFFERENTLYSUCHASWITHINDUSTRIESLISTEDDOWNTHELEFTSIDEANDPOL LUTANTSACROSSTHETOPBUTEITHERWAYTHISISTHECOREOFTHEBASICRESIDUALSSUPPLY TABLE4HECENTRALCORESHOWSRESIDUALSTHATGOFROMTHEECONOMYINTOTHEENVIRON MENTINTHECOURSEOFPRODUCTION4HEGOVERNMENTCOLUMNSHOWSRESIDUALSFROM ACTIVITIESTHATOFTENARECARRIEDOUTBYTHEPUBLICSECTORSUCHASSEWAGETREATMENT ANDSOLIDWASTEMANAGEMENT4HEHOUSEHOLDSCOLUMNSHOWSRESIDUALSSUCHAS TRASHDISPOSALANDAUTOMOBILEEMISSIONS4HEIMPORTSANDEXPORTSCOLUMNSHOWS INTERNATIONALmOWSOFRESIDUALSORTRANSBOUNDARYPOLLUTIONINTOANDOUTOFTHE COUNTRYITISDISCUSSEDINGREATERDETAILLATERINTHISCHAPTER "ECAUSEMOSTRESIDUALSARESIMPLYDUMPEDINTHEENVIRONMENTRATHERTHAN
USEDINTHEECONOMYTHEUSETABLEFORRESIDUALSISMUCHMORELIMITEDTHANTHESUP PLYTABLE2ESIDUALSARETREATEDASINPUTSINTOAFEWSECTORSOFTHEECONOMYNOTA BLYRECYCLINGANDWASTEWATERTREATMENT2ESIDUALEXPORTSAREEMISSIONSRESULTING FROMECONOMICACTIVITYBYRESIDENTUNITSTHATENDUPINANOTHERCOUNTRYRESIDUAL IMPORTSAREEMISSIONSFROMANOTHERCOUNTRYSECONOMICACTIVITYTHATENDUPWITHIN THENATIONALBOUNDARIES4HEYMAYRESULTFROMCROSS BOUNDARYmOWSWHICHBLOW ORmOWACROSSTHEBORDERINAIRORWATER ,ANDlLLSAREHANDLEDINADISTINCTWAYINTHESUPPLYTABLEFORRESIDUALS4HEYARE
RESIDUALSRETAINEDINTHEECONOMYFORANEXTENDEDPERIODOFTIME/NEWAYTOALLOW FORTHISINACCOUNTINGTERMSISTOCONSIDERTHEMTOBEAFORMOFCAPITALINVESTMENT 4HESOLIDWASTEDEPOSITEDINTHEMISTREATEDASAUSEOFRESIDUALSASINPUTINTOCAPI TALFORMATION4HELEACHATETHATSEEPSOUTOFTHELANDlLLˆTOBEPIPEDOUTINAPROP ERLYMANAGEDLANDlLLORTOCONTAMINATETHEGROUNDINUNMANAGEDDUMPSˆISA RESIDUALDISCHARGEDBYTHECAPITALASSETTHELANDlLL
2ESIDUALSAREALLOCATEDTOTHEECONOMICACTIVITYDIRECTLYRESPONSIBLEFORDISCHARGING THEM&OREXAMPLESUPPOSEACHEMICALPLANTMANUFACTURESCLEANINGmUIDSANDIN THEPROCESSITDISCHARGESASMALLQUANTITYOFCHEMICALSINTOARIVER!CANDYFAC TORYPURCHASESTHECLEANINGmUIDSTOCLEANITSMACHINERYINBETWEENBATCHESTHAT ISINTERMEDIATECONSUMPTION4HECANDYFACTORYEMITSPOLLUTANTSINTOTHEATMO SPHEREINTHECOURSEOFMAKINGCHOCOLATES4HECHOCOLATESARESOLDTOPEOPLEWHO EATTHEMANDDISCARDTHEWRAPPERSINTHESTREET4HEDISCHARGESINTOTHERIVERARE ALLOCATEDTOTHECHEMICALINDUSTRYTHEAIRPOLLUTANTSTOFOODPROCESSINGANDTHE WRAPPERSINTHESTREETTOlNALCONSUMPTIONBYHOUSEHOLDS 4HISMAYALLSEEMOBVIOUSBECAUSEITISCONSISTENTWITHTHEDISCUSSIONOFTHE
NATIONALINCOMEACCOUNTS)TISIMPORTANTHOWEVERBECAUSETHEULTIMATECAUSE OFALLOFTHISPOLLUTIONISTHEFACTTHATPEOPLEEATCHOCOLATES4ODETERMINEHOWTHE INDIVIDUALˆORORGANIZATIONORCOUNTRYˆCANUSEHISORHEROWNCONSUMPTION DECISIONSTOAFFECTTHEQUALITYOFTHEENVIRONMENTTHEPOLLUTIONGENERATEDBYTHE
ERSOFTHOSEPRODUCTSNOTTOTHEIRMANUFACTURE 4HEINPUTnOUTPUTTABLESIN#HAPTER4ABLES AND CANSHEDSOME
LIGHTONTHISISSUE)NTHESIMPLECASEOFESTIMATINGTHEEMISSIONSDIRECTLYATTRIBUT ABLETOAGIVENSECTORTHEEMISSIONSCOEFlCIENTFORTHATSECTORFROMTHEBOTTOMOF 4ABLE ISSIMPLYMULTIPLIEDBYTHESECTORSOUTPUT4HEOVERALLIMPACTONEMIS SIONSOFACHANGEINlNALDEMANDINCLUDINGTHERESULTINGINCREASESINEMISSIONS FROMTHEINDUSTRIESSELLINGINPUTGOODSISESTIMATEDUSINGTHEFULL) /FRAMEWORK INATHREE STEPPROCESS&IRSTTHE) /MODELISUSEDTOCALCULATEHOWANINCREASE INlNALDEMANDAFFECTSTHEOUTPUTOFALLSECTORSTHROUGHOUTTHEECONOMY3ECOND THEEMISSIONSCOEFlCIENTFOREACHINDUSTRYATTHEBOTTOMOF4ABLE ISMULTIPLIED BYTHEINCREASEINOUTPUTFROMTHATINDUSTRY4HIRDTHERESULTSFROMTHESEPARATE INDUSTRIESARESUMMEDTOCALCULATETHETOTALINCREASEINEMISSIONSRESULTINGFROM THEINCREASEINDEMANDASIN4ABLE /FCOURSEONEINDIVIDUALWOULDNOTBUILDAN) /SYSTEMSIMPLYTOASSESSTHE
IMPACTSOFHISORHEROWNCONSUMPTIONBUTINTHEORYITCOULDBEDONE4HEACCU RACYWITHWHICHTHISCOULDBEDONEDEPENDSONHOWlNELYDISAGGREGATEDTHEDATA INTHE354AREANDHOWACCURATETHECONVERSIONTOAN) /TABLEISITISNOTLIKELY THATYOUCOULDACTUALLYTELLONEKINDOFCANDYFROMANOTHERUSINGTHE) /DATA4HIS GENERALAPPROACHDOESHOWEVERALLOWTHEIDENTIlCATIONOFTHEPOLLUTIONIMPACTS OFSPECIlCCONSUMPTIONPATTERNS!MUCHMORESOPHISTICATED) /ANALYSISWOULD BEREQUIREDTOSHEDLIGHTONTHEINTERNATIONALDIMENSIONSOFOURCONSUMPTIONPAT TERNS4HISWOULDREQUIREACCESSTOCOMPARABLE) /TABLESFORTHECOUNTRIESFROM WHICHWEIMPORTWITHWHICHWEWOULDDETERMINEHOWMUCHPOLLUTIONOURIMPORTS CAUSETOTHEEXPORTINGCOUNTRIES4HISMAYBEIMPORTANTIFWEARECONCERNEDABOUT hEXPORTINGPOLLUTIONvBYIMPORTINGHIGHER POLLUTIONGOODSANDMANUFACTURINGONLY CLEANPRODUCTSATHOME
4HEACTUALCALCULATIONOFRESIDUALSFROMDIFFERENTKINDSOFECONOMICACTIVITYRELIES ONARANGEOFTECHNIQUES)DEALLYTHERESIDUALSDISCHARGEDFROMEACHPROCESSWOULD BEMEASUREDDURINGPRODUCTION!SARULEHOWEVERTHISISTOOEXPENSIVEORSIMPLY NOTTECHNOLOGICALLYFEASIBLE-OREOVERIFANENTERPRISEPRODUCESSEVERALDIFFERENT PRODUCTSINANINTEGRATEDPRODUCTIONORAGRICULTURALPROCESSITISIMPORTANTTOBE ABLETODISTINGUISHAMONGTHEM3IMPLYMEASURINGWHATCOMESOUTTHESMOKE STACKWOULDNOTALLOWTHAT )NSOMECASESRESIDUALSDATACOMEFROMSELF REPORTINGBYPRODUCERS4HE53
4OXICS2ELEASE)NVENTORY42) ADATABASECOMPILEDFROMINFORMATIONSUBMITTED BYENTERPRISESISAMAJORSOURCEOFDATAONTOXICCHEMICALRELEASESDURINGPRODUC TION4HISKINDOFDATAHASOBVIOUSLIMITATIONSASPRODUCERSMAYHAVEANINCEN TIVETOMINIMIZETHEIRREPORTEDEMISSIONS-OREOVERSUCHSYSTEMSTYPICALLYREQUIRE REPORTINGOFEMISSIONSONLYOVERACERTAINTHRESHOLDANDTHEREFOREDONOTCAPTURE LOWLEVELSOFRESIDUALSTHATMAYCOMBINEACROSSENTERPRISESTOHAVESIGNIFICANT ENVIRONMENTALIMPACTS )NAFEWCASESSPECIALIZEDSURVEYSARECONDUCTEDTODETERMINETHEQUANTITYOF
RESIDUALSGENERATED4HISISPARTICULARLYCOMMONFORSOLIDWASTEWHICHORDINARILY
SOLIDWASTEISCOLLECTEDANDMANAGEDEFFECTIVELYSURVEYSOFTHESOLIDWASTEMANAGE MENTINDUSTRYCANPROVIDECOMPREHENSIVEDATAONTHEQUANTITYOFWASTEGENERATED ANDHOWITISTREATEDALTHOUGHNOTNECESSARILYITSINDUSTRIALSOURCES )NCOUNTRIES WHERESOLIDWASTEISSIMPLYDUMPEDINTHEENVIRONMENTHOWEVERSURVEYSOFTRASH COLLECTIONCOMPANIESWILLNOTPROVIDEACOMPLETEPICTUREOFTHEGENERATIONOFSOLID WASTEORITSENVIRONMENTALIMPACT -OREOFTENEMISSIONSAREESTIMATEDBASEDONACOMBINATIONOFTECHNIQUES
DEPENDINGONTHEPROCESSINVOLVEDANDTHESECONDARYDATASOURCESAVAILABLE)N SOMECASESENGINEERINGKNOWLEDGEOFTHEPRODUCTIVEPROCESSTHEINPUTSUSEDAND THEMATERIALSCONTAINEDINTHEOUTPUTCANBEUSEDTOESTIMATETHERESIDUALSFROM MANUFACTURING7HENAPLANTBURNSFUELFORENERGYRATHERTHANUSINGELECTRICITYOR NONPOLLUTINGENERGYSOURCESSUCHASHYDROPOWERDATAONTHEFUELTYPEANDCOM BUSTIONPROCESSCANBEUSEDTOESTIMATETHEEMISSIONSFROMCOMBUSTION 4HISKINDOFESTIMATIONISRELATIVELYSTRAIGHTFORWARDTHOUGHSTILLNOTEASY IN
ENGINEEREDPRODUCTIONPROCESSESWHEREALLTHEDETAILSABOUTINPUTSANDTECHNOLOGY AREKNOWN)TISMUCHHARDERFORNATURALPROCESSESLIKEAGRICULTURE4HEQUANTITYOF AGRICULTURALRUNOFFDEPENDSINPARTONTHEQUANTITYOFFERTILIZERORPESTICIDEPUTON THElELDSWHICHISKNOWNHOWEVERWHETHERTHOSECHEMICALSAREABSORBEDINTOTHE PLANTSARElLTEREDINTOTHESOILORRUNOFFINTOTHEWATERDEPENDSONOTHERVARIABLES THATAREHARDERTOQUANTIFYANDALMOSTIMPOSSIBLETOPREDICTSUCHASSOILSTRUCTURE ANDCHEMICALCOMPOSITIONTOPOGRAPHYANDWEATHER&ORTHISREASONALTHOUGH MANYCOUNTRIESHAVEFAIRLYGOODDATAONINDUSTRIALANDTRANSPORTEMISSIONSNONE HAVESYSTEMATICDATAONAGRICULTURALRUNOFF )NPRACTICEMOREWORKHASGONEINTOESTIMATINGAIRPOLLUTANTEMISSIONSTHAN
INTOOTHERRESIDUALS4HISISTHERESULTOFACOMBINATIONOFFACTORS&IRSTOVERTHE PASTFEWDECADESAIRPOLLUTIONRATHERTHANOTHERENVIRONMENTALCONCERNSHAS DRIVENTHEINTERESTINBUILDINGENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTSINMANYOFTHEDEVELOPED COUNTRIESTHATHAVEDONETHEMOSTWORKINTHISAREA3ECONDESTIMATIONOFWATER POLLUTIONPOSESTECHNICALCHALLENGESNOTPOSEDBYAIRPOLLUTION&ORPOINT SOURCE EMISSIONSTHEQUALITYOFTHEINTAKEWATERAFFECTSTHEQUALITYOFTHEDISCHARGESANDIT CANBEDIFlCULTTODIFFERENTIATEPOLLUTANTSTHATWEREINTHEWATERTOBEGINWITHFROM THOSEADDEDBYAPARTICULARPROCESS%STIMATINGPOLLUTIONDUETORUNOFFOFSTORM WATERANDIRRIGATIONWATERISTECHNICALLYDIFlCULTASTHEINPUTSTOTHEPROCESSARE NOTCONTROLLEDTHEWAYFACTORYPROCESSESARE4HIRDWHILEFARMINGISACKNOWLEDGED TOBEAMAJORSOURCEOFPOLLUTIONINSOMECOUNTRIESITISPOLITICALLYMOREDIFlCULT TOCONTROLAGRICULTURALPOLLUTIONTHANFACTORYEMISSIONS7HILETHEDEVELOPMENT OFFACTORY STYLEANIMALHUSBANDRYOPERATIONSHASCHANGEDTHEETHOSSURROUND INGAGRICULTUREININDUSTRIALCOUNTRIESFARMINGISSTILLOFTENREGARDEDASASOCIALLY DESIRABLEWAYOFLIFETHATPROTECTSLANDFROMDEVELOPMENTRATHERTHANASIGNIlCANT SOURCEOFWATERANDAIRPOLLUTION-OREOVERINSOMECOUNTRIESAGRICULTURALLOBBY GROUPSAREPOLITICALLYVERYSTRONGANDHAVEKEPTTHEIRINDUSTRYOFFTHEAGENDAFOR POLLUTIONCONTROL#ONSEQUENTLYINADDITIONTOTHETECHNICALPROBLEMSOFESTIMAT INGAGRICULTURALRUNOFFTHEDEMANDFORTHEDATAHASBEENLOWERTHANDEMANDFOR AIREMISSIONSDATA 4HECURRENTFOCUSONCLIMATECHANGEHASFURTHERINCREASEDDEMANDFORAIREMIS
SIONSDATAPARTICULARLYFROMCOMBUSTION!FORTUITOUSSETOFCIRCUMSTANCESHAS COMBINEDTOMAKEITRELATIVELYEASYTOMEETTHISDEMAND4HEENERGYCRISESOFTHE
OUTOFCONCERNTHATTHEIRECONOMIESMIGHTBEDERAILEDBYTHEPRICEORUNAVAILABIL ITYOFFUELFORBOTHPRODUCTIONANDTRANSPORTATION!SARESULTTIMESERIESDATAON ENERGYUSEAREMOREREADILYAVAILABLETHANMANYOTHERKINDSOFDATA!SCONCERN ABOUTCLIMATECHANGEHASGROWNTHESEDATAHAVEBEENUSEDTOESTIMATEGREENHOUSE GASEMISSIONS4HISISDONEUSINGEMISSIONSCOEFlCIENTSTHATINDICATETHEQUANTITY OFSPECIlCPOLLUTANTSRELEASEDWHENAKNOWNQUANTITYOFASPECIlCFUELISBURNED UNDERSPECIlEDCONDITIONS#OMBININGTHESEDATAWITHTHEENERGYACCOUNTSDATAON FUELCONSUMPTIONMAKESITRELATIVELYEASYTOESTIMATEEMISSIONSFROMENERGYCOM BUSTIONBYSECTOR4HISGOESFORBOTHFACTORYSTATIONARYSOURCE ANDVEHICLEMOBILE SOURCE EMISSIONS4HE53%NVIRONMENTAL0ROTECTION!GENCYHASDEVELOPEDA SERIESKNOWNASTHE!0 COEFlCIENTSWHICHAREUSEDFORTHISPURPOSEINTHE5NITED 3TATESANDOFTENAREBORROWEDBYOTHERCOUNTRIESASWELL53%0! 4HECALCULATIONOFVEHICLEEMISSIONSRAISESAPARTICULARTECHNICALPROBLEMIN
BUILDINGTHISPORTIONOFTHEACCOUNTS-ANYCOUNTRIESHAVEAGOVERNMENTDEPART MENTRESPONSIBLEFORENVIRONMENTALSTATISTICSWHICHESTIMATESAIRPOLLUTANTEMIS SIONS&ROMBOTHANENGINEERINGANDAREGULATORYPERSPECTIVEITISLOGICALTOBEGIN BYDISTINGUISHINGBETWEENSTATIONARYANDMOBILESOURCEEMISSIONSANDTHENRElN INGTHECLASSIlCATIONFROMTHERE&ORTHEACCOUNTSHOWEVERMOBILESOURCEEMISSIONS MUSTBEALLOCATEDTOTHEINDUSTRYTHATPRODUCESTHEMNOTTOTHECLASSOFVEHICLE !NADDITIONALCOMPLICATIONARISESHERE)FAFURNITURECOMPANYPURCHASESAmEET
OFTRUCKSANDMAKESITSOWNDELIVERIESTHETRUCKEMISSIONSAREALLOCATEDTOTHEWOOD PRODUCTSINDUSTRY)FHOWEVERITCONTRACTSWITHATRUCKINGCOMPANYTOPICKUPAND DELIVERTHEFURNITURETHENTHEEMISSIONSAREALLOCATEDTOTHETRANSPORTATIONINDUS TRY4HISMAYSEEMUNSATISFACTORYBUTITISCONSISTENTWITHTHEPRINCIPLEDISCUSSED ABOVERESIDUALSFROMTHEPROVISIONOFINTERMEDIATEPRODUCTSAREALLOCATEDTOTHE INDUSTRYPROVIDINGTHEPRODUCTNOTTHEONEPURCHASINGIT4RUCKINGISANINTERME DIATEINPUTTOTHEFURNITURECOMPANYASWERETHECLEANINGmUIDSPURCHASEDBYTHE CANDYFACTORYALBEITINTHISCASEASERVICERATHERTHANAGOOD3OTHOSETRANSPOR TATIONEMISSIONSMUSTBEALLOCATEDTOTHETRUCKINGCOMPANYNOTTOTHEFURNITURE MANUFACTURER7HENTHEFURNITURECOMPANYBUYSITSOWNmEETTHISISCATEGORIZEDAS OWNTRANSPORTOROWNACCOUNTTRANSPORTANDISCONSIDEREDTOBEANANCILLARYACTIV ITYTHEEMISSIONSARECLEARLYTHERESPONSIBILITYOFTHEFURNITURECOMPANY
4HE3%%!DESCRIBESRESIDUALSAShTHEINCIDENTALANDUNDESIREDOUTPUTSFROMTHE ECONOMYWHICHGENERALLYHAVENOECONOMICVALUEANDMAYBERECYCLEDSTORED WITHINTHEECONOMYORMOREUSUALLYATPRESENT DISCHARGEDINTOTHEENVIRONMENTv PARAGRAPH 3EVERALELEMENTSOFTHISDESCRIPTIONAREKEY!RESIDUALMUSTHAVE NOMONETARYVALUEANDMUSTNOTBETHEPURPOSEOFPRODUCTIVEACTIVITY2ESIDU ALSMUSTALSOBEACTUALLYORPOTENTIALLYDETRIMENTALTOTHEENVIRONMENT4HUSFOR EXAMPLECLEANWATERRETURNEDTOARIVERINMODESTQUANTITIESAFTERUSEINSOME PRODUCTIONPROCESSWOULDNOTBECONSIDEREDARESIDUALIFITCAUSEDNOHARMTOTHE DOWNSTREAMENVIRONMENT2ESIDUALSMAYGOINTOAIRWATERORSOILWHEREPOSSIBLE THEACCOUNTSDISTINGUISHAMONGTHETHREE3EE4ABLE FORALISTOFDIFFERENTCLAS SIlCATIONSOFRESIDUALS
/NETRICKYISSUEWITHRESIDUALSISDISTINGUISHINGAMONGSEVERALDIFFERENTOUTPUTS OFPRODUCTIONBASEDONHOWTHEYAREDISPOSEDOF
N /UTPUTSTHATAREDUMPEDINTOTHEENVIRONMENTAREINDEEDRESIDUALS N )FANEWUSE FORA RESIDUAL ISDISCOVEREDAND THEENTERPRISECANNOWSELL IT INSTEADOFDUMPINGITTHERESIDUALBECOMESASECONDARYPRODUCT&OREXAMPLE IFAMININGCOMPANYUSEDTODUMPROCKSBUTNOWSELLSTHEMTOALANDSCAPERTHE COMPANYBECOMESASECONDARYPRODUCEROFLANDSCAPINGMATERIALSINSTEADOFA DISPOSEROFRESIDUALROCK4HISCHANGEREmECTSTHEPRICECRITERIONSHOWNIN4ABLE THEIDEATHATRESIDUALSCANNOTHAVEANYMONETARYVALUE"ECAUSETHEROCKS NOWHAVEMONETARYVALUETHEYCANNOLONGERBECLASSIlEDASRESIDUALSANDARE CONSIDEREDPRODUCTSINSTEAD
N 3OMERESIDUALSAREGATHEREDFORTREATMENTOFF SITESUCHASINSEWAGETREATMENT PLANTS!FTERTREATMENTASMALLERANDLESSHARMFULQUANTITYOFMATERIALISDIS CHARGEDINTOTHEENVIRONMENT4HISHASLEDTOADISTINCTIONBETWEENNETAND GROSSRESIDUALS.ETRESIDUALSAREANALOGOUSTOlNALPRODUCTTHEYAREWHATACTU ALLYGETDISCHARGEDINTOTHEENVIRONMENT'ROSSRESIDUALSWOULDBEANALOGOUSTO THESUMOFINTERMEDIATEANDlNALPRODUCTSTHEYINCLUDEBOTHRESIDUALSONTHEIR WAYTOFURTHERTREATMENTANDTHOSEDISCHARGEDINTOTHEENVIRONMENT)NTERME DIATERESIDUALSATERMNOTACTUALLYUSEDINTHE3%%! WOULDBETHOSETHATARE INPUTSINTORECYCLINGORWASTE PROCESSINGPLANTS
N 2ESIDUALSALSOINCLUDEDISSIPATIVELOSSESTHEMATERIALSTHATmOWINTOTHEENVI RONMENTASARESULTOFABRASIONLEACHINGANDOTHERGRADUALPROCESSES4HEY AREGENERALLYTHERESULTSOFlNALCONSUMPTIONDRIVINGGRADUALLYABRADESTIRES RAINFALLCAUSESPAINTANDOTHERCHEMICALSTOLEACHOFFBUILDINGSANDFENCESAND SOON,EACHINGALSOCANRESULTFROMANYECONOMICACTIVITYTHATPUTSPRODUCTS ONTHESOILORUNDERGROUNDSUCHASAGRICULTURELANDlLLSORPOORLYMAINTAINED UNDERGROUNDSTORAGETANKS
N 3OMETIMESMATERIALSAREACCIDENTALLYDUMPEDINTHEENVIRONMENTASINTRUCK INGACCIDENTSORSHIPPINGSPILLS4HOSEACCIDENTSARECONSIDEREDTOBEmOWSOF RESIDUALSFROMTHEECONOMYTOTHEENVIRONMENT)FASUBSEQUENTCLEANUPEFFORT
#LASSIFICATIONOF2ESIDUALS
mOWOFRESIDUALSFROMTHEENVIRONMENTTOTHEECONOMYˆASOMEWHATPECULIAR NOTIONBUTAPRACTICALWAYTOHANDLETHATKINDOFmOW
N (IDDENmOWSARETHEMOVEMENTSOFMATERIALSTHATSTAYWITHINTHEENVIRONMENT SUCHASOVERBURDENROCKANDEARTHMOVEDFORMINING4HESEARENOTCONSIDERED TOBERESIDUALSINTHE3%%!THOUGHTHEYARETRACKEDINMATERIALmOWACCOUNTS -&!S
4HEPRICECRITERIONMAYAPPEARTOOFFERASIMPLEWAYTODISTINGUISHRESIDUALS FROMSECONDARYPRODUCTIONBUTITCANBEDIFlCULTTOIMPLEMENT&ORTHISREASON LISTSOFPRODUCTSTHATTYPICALLYAPPEARINWASTESTREAMSAREOFTENUSEDTOCLASSIFY RESIDUALSINSTEAD4HE3%%!OFFERSAPOSSIBLECLASSIlCATIONFORRESIDUALSBASEDON THESYSTEMDEVELOPEDBY%UROSTATINTHE3%2)%%)TISORGANIZEDBYENVIRONMENTAL MEDIUMlRSTDISTINGUISHINGAMONGDISCHARGESINTOAIRWATERANDLANDANDONLY SECONDARILYCONSIDERINGWHATISBEINGDISCHARGED4HISISPRACTICALFORGETTINGAN OVERVIEWOFTHEIMPACTSOFPOLLUTIONONDIFFERENTENVIRONMENTALMEDIABUTITCAN CAUSEPROBLEMSWHENTHESAMEPRODUCTISDISCHARGEDINTOSEVERALMEDIA
4HETREATMENTOFINTERNATIONALmOWSOFRESIDUALSINTHEACCOUNTSRAISESAFEWPAR TICULARISSUES/NEPERTAINSTOTHERESIDENCEOFTHETRANSPORTCOMPANIESENGAGEDIN INTERNATIONALSHIPPING!SDISCUSSEDIN#HAPTERAPRODUCTIVEACTIVITYISCONSID EREDRESIDENTWHEREVERITHASALONG TERMPHYSICALBASEEVENIFITSHEADQUARTERSIS ELSEWHERE%NTERPRISESINTHETRANSPORTATIONSECTORAREMORELIKELYTHANOTHERSTO ENGAGEINECONOMICACTIVITYINCOUNTRIESWHERETHEYARENOTRESIDENTASTHEYMAY OPERATEVEHICLESORVESSELSTHATDISCHARGEEMISSIONSANYWHEREINTHEWORLD4HE EMISSIONSAREALWAYSALLOCATEDTOTHECOUNTRYOFRESIDENCEOFTHECOMPANYCARRYING OUTTHEACTIVITYIRRESPECTIVEOFWHERETHEYOCCUR%MISSIONSTHATOCCURININTERNA TIONALWATERSORAIRSPACEALSOWILLBEATTRIBUTEDTOTHECOUNTRYOFRESIDENCEOFTHE COMPANYTHATOWNSTHESHIPSORPLANES 4HIS ISDIFFERENTFROMTHETREATMENTOFEMISSIONSINNATIONALENVIRONMENTAL
STATISTICSSYSTEMS&ORENVIRONMENTMINISTRIESTHEISSUEOFCONCERNISHOWMUCH ISDISCHARGEDINTOTHEAIRORWATERWITHINTHECOUNTRYITDOESNTMATTERWHERETHE POLLUTERSAREFROM4HISMEANSTHATNATIONALDATAONEMISSIONSMUSTBEADJUSTED BEFORETHEYCANBEUSEDTOBUILDENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTINGSYSTEMS4HE3%%! PRACTICEALSODIFFERSFROMMAJORINTERNATIONALCONVENTIONSPARTICULARLYTHEPRAC TICESOFTHE)NTERGOVERNMENTAL0ANELON#LIMATE#HANGE)0## 4HE)0##TRACKS EMISSIONSOFGREENHOUSEGASESWORLDWIDE)NITSDATASYSTEMSEMISSIONSOCCURRING WITHINACOUNTRYAREATTRIBUTEDTOTHATCOUNTRYANDEMISSIONSININTERNATIONALAIR ORWATERSARENOTATTRIBUTEDTOANYCOUNTRY4HE+YOTO0ROTOCOLALSOHASNOREDUC TIONTARGETSFORINTERNATIONALEMISSIONS .ATIONALEMISSIONSDATAFROMTHEENVI RONMENTALACCOUNTSWILLTHEREFORENOTBESTRICTLYCONSISTENTWITHTHOSEDEVELOPED BYTHE)0##4HEDEGREEOFDIFFERENCEDEPENDSONTHESIZEOFTHECOUNTRYANDTHE IMPORTANCEOFTHEIRINTERNATIONALmEETS 4HESEINCONSISTENCIESMAYSEEMSILLYITWOULDBESIMPLERIFALLMAJORDATASYS
TEMSFOLLOWEDTHESAMECLASSIFICATIONCONVENTIONS%ACHSYSTEMHOWEVERHAS
LARNEEDSTHATTHATSYSTEMISDESIGNEDTOMEET%NVIRONMENTALSTATISTICSAREDEVEL OPEDTOUNDERSTANDWHATISPUTTINGPRESSUREONTHENATIONALENVIRONMENTWHEREAS ENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTSAREDEVELOPEDTOUNDERSTANDTHELINKSBETWEENTHEECON OMYANDENVIRONMENTALPRESSURE4HOSEAREDIFFERENTNEEDSANDTHEYCALLFORDIF FERENTDATASTRUCTURES2ATHERTHANARGUEFORSTANDARDIZATIONITISMOREPRAGMATIC TOBEAWAREOFTHEDIFFERENCESANDTOBECAREFULTORESPECTTHEMINDEVELOPINGOR USINGEACHSETOFDATA )NTERNATIONALTOURISMALSORAISESPARTICULARPROBLEMSINACCOUNTING4HETOUR
ISMINDUSTRYINGENERALISDIFlCULTTOACCOUNTFORBECAUSEITISHARDTOSPECIFYWHICH TRAVELHOTELANDRESTAURANTEXPENDITURESARElNALCONSUMPTIONEGVACATIONS ANDWHICHAREINTERMEDIATECONSUMPTIONEGBUSINESSTRIPS 4HERESIDUALSISSUES ARENARROWER4OURISMGENERATESRESIDUALSFROMTRANSPORTANDITGENERATESSOLID WASTEESPECIALLYWHENPEOPLEVISITPRISTINEAREASANDLEAVETRASHBEHIND)TALSO CREATESDEMANDFORNATURALRESOURCESFOREXAMPLEINTERNATIONALTOURISTSIN3PAIN ACCOUNTFORASIGNIlCANTSHAREOFDEMANDFORWATER&ORTHEMOSTPARTTHESALEOF SERVICESTOTOURISTSISUNDERTAKENBYRESIDENTUNITSTOUROPERATORSHOTELSGOVERN MENTSRUNNINGNATIONALPARKS SOTHERESIDUALSmOWFROMTHENATIONALECONOMYTO THENATIONALENVIRONMENT7HENFOREIGNTOUROPERATORSPURCHASEGASOLINEINTHE NATIONALECONOMYTHEIREMISSIONSARECONSIDEREDTOBENATIONALBECAUSETHEGASO LINEPURCHASEWASPARTOFTHENATIONALECONOMY4HEONLYEMISSIONSCONSIDEREDTO COMEFROMNONRESIDENTENTERPRISESARETRANSPORTEMISSIONSWHENTHEGASOLINEWAS PURCHASEDBEFORECROSSINGTHEBORDER4HISOBVIOUSLYISDIFlCULTTOMEASUREAND THEAMOUNTSPROBABLYARESMALL)NMANYCASESTHEREFORECOUNTRIESSIMPLYASSUME THATSUCHEMISSIONSFROMTRIPSCROSSINGTHEBORDERINEACHDIRECTIONWILLBALANCE EACHOTHEROUTANDTHEYIGNORETHEMINTHEACCOUNTS 3OMEWHATSIMILARISSUESARISEWITHRESPECTTOEMISSIONSFROMOTHERNONRESIDENT
ACTIVITIES4HESEINCLUDEEMISSIONSFROMFOREIGNENCLAVESSUCHASEMBASSIESAND MILITARYBASESWHICHARECONSIDEREDTOBERESIDENTINTHECOUNTRYOFORIGINRATHER THANTHECOUNTRYOFLOCATION"YANDLARGEEMBASSIESPROBABLYDONOTGENERATE MUCHPOLLUTIONANDTHEYMAYBALANCEEACHOTHEROUTIFTHENATIONALCOUNTRYHAS ASMANYEMBASSIESOVERSEASASFOREIGNEMBASSIESONITSOWNSOIL-ILITARYBASES MAYBEAMORESIGNIlCANTISSUE4HEYPROBABLYDONOTCANCELEACHOTHEROUTAND THEYCOULDBESIGNIlCANTSOURCESOFEMISSIONSIFFOREXAMPLETHEYINCLUDEAIRPORTS )DENTIFYINGTHESEEMISSIONSMAYBEPARTICULARLYIMPORTANTFORTHECOUNTRYOFLOCA TIONWHICHWILLWANTTOSHOWCLEARLYTHATTHESEEMISSIONSDONOTRESULTFROMITS OWNECONOMICACTIVITY 4RANSBOUNDARYmOWSOFRESIDUALSARECAPTUREDINTHERESIDUALmOWACCOUNTSAS
PARTOFIMPORTSANDEXPORTS4HEYCANBEHARDTOMEASUREBUTAREVERYIMPORTANT FORPOLICYPURPOSES&ORANUMBEROFCOUNTRIESIMPORTEDPOLLUTIONISASIGNIlCANT CAUSEOFPOORDOMESTICAIRQUALITY4OTHEEXTENTTHATTHEYCANQUANTIFYIMPORTED RESIDUALSTHESECOUNTRIESCANUSETHISINFORMATIONININTERNATIONALNEGOTIATIONSTO ADDRESSTHEPROBLEM3IMILARLYDATAONEXPORTEDRESIDUALSMAYBEUSEDBYOTHER COUNTRIESTOPRESSURETHEHOMECOUNTRYTOSOLVEITSPOLLUTIONPROBLEMSANDSTOP HARMINGITSNEIGHBORS !NOTHER INTERNATIONAL ISSUEOF IMPORTANCECONCERNSHOWTOACCOUNTFORTHE
EMISSIONSCAUSEDINTHERESTOFTHEWORLDBYPRODUCTIONTHEREFOREXPORTTOTHE NATIONALECONOMY&ROMTHENATIONALACCOUNTINGPERSPECTIVEBECAUSETHEPRODUC
THENATIONALACCOUNTS#ITIZENSOFSOMECOUNTRIESHOWEVERARECONCERNEDTHATTHE STRUCTUREOFTHEIROWNECONOMIESORTHEIRATTEMPTSTOLIMITPOLLUTIONHAVESIMPLY RESULTEDINTHEEXPORTOFTHEEMISSIONSENGENDEREDBYTHEIRCONSUMPTIONTOCOUN TRIESWITHWEAKERENVIRONMENTALCONTROLS4HUSALTHOUGHTHECOUNTRYWITHTHE TOUGHERENVIRONMENTALLAWSAPPEARSTOBECLEANERTHEGLOBALENVIRONMENTMAYBE WORSEOFF4HECAPACITYTOQUANTIFYTHATIMPACTSOMETIMESREFERREDTOASENVIRON MENTALLEAKAGEISIMPORTANTINORDERTOASSESSTHEIMPACTSOFDOMESTICCONSUMP TIONPATTERNSONPOLLUTIONINTHERESTOFTHEWORLD4HISISANALOGOUSTOTHEISSUE DISCUSSEDUNDER7HO$OESTHE0OLLUTINGEARLIERINTHISCHAPTERCONCERNINGDIRECT ANDINDIRECTATTRIBUTIONOFRESIDUALSINORDERTOEVALUATETHEIMPACTOFAPARTICU LARCONSUMPTIONPATTERNONTHEOVERALLECONOMY4HISCASEISINTERNATIONALRATHER THANDOMESTICHOWEVERANDTHECONCERNISTHEIMPACTONOTHERECONOMIESRATHER THANOUROWN#HAPTERLOOKSATTHESTRATEGIESTHATMIGHTBEUSEDTOQUANTIFYTHIS EXPORTEDPOLLUTION
4HERECYCLINGANDWASTEMANAGEMENTINDUSTRIESPOSETRICKYISSUESINACCOUNTING BUTTHEYARECLEARLYOFCONSIDERABLEINTEREST4HESEINDUSTRIESARETHEONLYUSERSOF RESIDUALSINTHESUPPLYANDUSETABLES&ORTHEMOSTPARTTHOSERESIDUALSARETREATED ASREGULARINPUTmOWSINTORECYCLINGANDWASTEMANAGEMENTWHILETHERECYCLED MATERIALANDWASTE PROCESSINGSERVICESTHATCONSTITUTETHEOUTPUTOFTHOSESECTORS AREPARTOFTHEREGULARmOWOFGOODSANDSERVICESPRODUCEDBYTHEECONOMY ,ANDlLLSAREDEALTWITHSOMEWHATDIFFERENTLYHOWEVER4HEYARETREATEDASAKIND
OFCAPITALFORMATIONWHICHUSESRESIDUALSASANINPUTTOLANDORTOlLLUPQUARRIES ANDCLAYPITS4HELEACHATEANDMETHANEEMITTEDBYTHELANDlLLARECONSIDEREDTO BERESIDUALSFROMCAPITALRATHERTHANFROMCURRENTECONOMICACTIVITY4HISCLASSIl CATIONAPPLIESONLYTOPROPERLYMANAGEDSANITARYLANDlLLSHOWEVERWASTEDEPOS ITEDINANUNMANAGEDDUMPISSIMPLYTREATEDASRESIDUALSDEPOSITEDONLANDNOT ASAFORMOFCAPITALFORMATION,ANDlLLSUSEINPUTSOTHERTHANRESIDUALSOFCOURSE INCLUDINGSIGNIlCANTINVESTMENTSINEQUIPMENTTODRAINTHELEACHATEANDCAPTURE THEMETHANE &ROMANENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONSTANDPOINTRECYCLINGANDWASTEMANAGE
MENTRAISESEVERALISSUES
N (OWMUCHWASTEISBEINGGENERATEDINOURPRODUCTIONPROCESSES!LLELSEBEING EQUALWEWOULDLIKEOURPRODUCTIONTOBECOMEMOREEFlCIENTOVERTIMESOTHAT WEGENERATELESSWASTEFROMTHESAMEAMOUNTOFOUTPUT
N (OWMUCHOFOURWASTEDOWERECYCLE2ECYCLINGISOFINTERESTFORTWODISTINCT REASONSBECAUSEITLEAVESUSWITHLESSMATERIALTODISPOSEOFINTHEENVIRONMENT ANDBECAUSEITALLOWSUSTODEPENDLESSONNEWEXTRACTIONFROMTHEENVIRON MENT4HEACCOUNTSIDEALLYSHOULDSHOWBOTHOFTHESETRENDSANDRELATETHEMTO THEQUANTITYOFOUTPUT
N (OWMUCHOFOURPRODUCTIONUSESRECYCLEDINPUTSRATHERTHANNEWLYEXTRACTED MATERIALSANDDOESTHISLEADTOADECREASEINEXTRACTION)FRECYCLEDMATERIALS DONOTREPLACENEWEXTRACTIONTHENTHESECONDPURPOSEOFRECYCLINGISNOTBEING
ININPUTGOODS
N )SRECYCLINGENVIRONMENTALLYEFlCIENTORDOESITCONSUMEMOREINPUTSENERGY FOREXAMPLE THANDOESPRODUCTIONOFNEWMATERIALS
4HEACCOUNTSWILLPROVIDEANSWERSTOSOMEBUTNOTALLOFTHESEQUESTIONS$ATA ONTHEmOWOFNETRESIDUALSSHOWHOWMUCHWASTEISDISPOSEDOFINTHEENVIRON MENTASDISTINGUISHEDFROMTHEAMOUNTTHATFLOWSINTOTREATMENTORRECYCLING PLANTS/NECANTRACKTHISOVERTIMEANDCOMPAREITWITHOVERALLOUTPUTTOGETA SENSEOFTHEhENVIRONMENTALEFlCIENCYvOFPRODUCTIONLOOKINGATTHERESIDUALSPER UNITOFOUTPUT)TISHOPEDTHATTHISALSOSIGNIlESGREATERECONOMICEFlCIENCYIN MATERIALSUSEFOREXAMPLEITMAYMEANTHATPRODUCTIONPROCESSESHAVECHANGED TOMAKEBETTERUSEOFTHEINPUTSORTHATMATERIALSTHATWEREONCEBEINGDISPOSED OFARENOWSOLDTOSECONDARYMARKETS)FSOTHENVALUEADDEDSHOULDRISEASlRMS CONSUMELESSINPUTSORRECEIVEMOREREVENUEATTHESAMELEVELOFPRIMARYOUTPUT /NTHEOTHERHANDINCREASEDhENVIRONMENTALEFlCIENCYvCOULDLEADTODECREASED VALUEADDEDˆIFFOREXAMPLECOLLECTIONCOSTSAREGREATERTHANTHESAVINGS)FTHE ACCOUNTSAREDETAILEDENOUGHITMAYBEPOSSIBLETOOBSERVETHESECHANGESANDLINK THEMTOCHANGESINRESIDUALSOFTENHOWEVERTHEREMAYBETOOMUCHNOISEINTHE DATATOACTUALLYCONNECTCHANGESINRESIDUALSWITHOTHERCHANGES 4HEACCOUNTSSHOULDSHEDSOMELIGHTONHOWMUCHWERECYCLERELATIVETOOUT
PUTANDTONETRESIDUALS4HEPRIMARYSOURCEOFINFORMATIONWILLBEPORTIONSOFTHE SUPPLYANDUSETABLESTHATSPECIlCALLYPERTAINTOTHERECYCLINGSECTORWHICHIS)3)# CODE4HESEWILLSHOWTHEQUANTITYOFRECYCLINGCOMPANIESINTERMEDIATECON SUMPTIONˆHOWMUCHMATERIALTHEYRECYCLEFROMOTHERINDUSTRIES)FTHEDATAARE SUFlCIENTLYDETAILEDTHETABLESALSOMAYREVEALWHICHMATERIALSTHEYTAKEIN)FNOT THECOMPANYSPRIMARYPRODUCTIONDATASHOULDGIVESOMESENSEOFTHISKNOWING THATACOMPANYPRODUCESSTEELORPAPERPULPFOREXAMPLESHOULDGIVEAREASON ABLEIDEAOFWHATMATERIALSITISRECYCLING$ATAONTHERECYCLINGINDUSTRYFREQUENTLY COMEFROMSPECIALIZEDSURVEYSCARRIEDOUTFORTHEENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTSASTHIS INFORMATIONOFTENISNOTAVAILABLEFROMSECONDARYSOURCES /THERSOURCESOFDATAWITHINTHEACCOUNTSMAYBELESSUSEFULONTHISISSUE$ATA
FORINDUSTRIESDISCHARGINGRESIDUALSMAYNOTSHEDMUCHLIGHTONRECYCLINGFORSEV ERALREASONS)FTHESEINDUSTRIESSELLUNWANTEDMATERIALSTORECYCLINGCOMPANIESIT WILLSHOWUPINTHEACCOUNTSASSECONDARYPRODUCTRATHERTHANRESIDUALSORWASTEOF ANYSORT)FTHEYSELLSCRAPTOANOTHERINDUSTRYTHATCANUSEITDIRECTLYˆFOREXAMPLE THEMININGCOMPANYTHATSELLSWASTEROCKTOALANDSCAPERˆITWILLSHOWUPNEITHER ASWASTEFORTHEMININGCOMPANYNORASINPUTFORTHERECYCLINGSECTOR)FACOM PANYRECYCLESINTERNALLYWITHINITSOWNPLANTITWILLNOTSHOWUPINTHEACCOUNTSAT ALLALTHOUGHITISSTILLVALIDRECYCLING4HUSTHEACCOUNTSDATAWILLPROVIDEALOWER BOUNDONHOWMUCHISRECYCLEDBUTWILLNOTFULLYCOVERTHEISSUE 4RACKINGTHEUSEOFRECYCLEDINPUTSANDTHEEXTENTTOWHICHTHEYREPLACEPRI
MARYEXTRACTIONISALSODIFlCULTFROMTHEACCOUNTS0RODUCTSˆBOTHINPUTSAND OUTPUTSˆARECLASSIlEDUSINGTHE#ENTRAL0RODUCT#LASSIlCATION#0# SYSTEM4HIS SYSTEMDOESNOTDISTINGUISHPRODUCTSMADEWITHRECYCLEDMATERIALFROMPRODUCTS MADEWITHNEWMATERIALTHUSFOREXAMPLEITISNOTPOSSIBLETODIRECTLYDETERMINE THESHAREOFRECYCLEDPULPINTOTALPULPUSEDFORPAPERPRODUCTIONORTHESHAREOF RECYCLEDPAPERINTOTALPAPERCONSUMPTIONFROMTHISCLASSIlCATIONSYSTEM
RESIDUALSTHERECYCLINGINDUSTRYANDSUBSEQUENTPRODUCTSALSOCANNOTBEDIRECTLY LINKED!LTHOUGHEDUCATEDGUESSESMAYBEPOSSIBLEFORSOMEPRODUCTSFOROTH ERSSUCHASCHEMICALSPLASTICSORGLASSITMAYBEMUCHHARDERTOLINKRESIDUALS TOPRODUCTSMANUFACTUREDUSINGRECYCLEDMATERIALS2EGARDINGTHEIMPACTOFRECY CLINGONEXTRACTIONOFPRIMARYPRODUCTTHELINKSAREPROBABLYEVENHARDERTOSHOW UNLESSTHEYAREQUITELARGE)FFOREXAMPLETHEPAPERRECYCLINGINDUSTRYCOULDMEET ASIGNIlCANTPORTIONOFNATIONALDEMANDFORPAPERPULPANDPAPERACCOUNTEDFOR ALARGESHAREOFTHEDEMANDFORFORESTPRODUCTSTHENONEPERHAPSCOULDOBSERVEA DECLINEINDEMANDFORFORESTPRODUCTSASTHEYWEREREPLACEDBYRECYCLEDPULP)N MOSTCASESHOWEVERQUANTITIESANDSHARESARELIKELYTOBESMALLENOUGHTHATTHE NOISEINTHEDATAWOULDBEGREATERTHANTHEIMPACTSONEMIGHTSEEKTOOBSERVE
0HYSICALDATAONRESIDUALSHAVEBEENUSEDINANUMBEROFCOUNTRIESTODEVELOP SIMPLEMEASURESSHOWINGTHEIMPACTSOFDIFFERENTINDUSTRIESONTHEENVIRONMENT 4HESEINDICATORSWHENLOOKEDATINCONJUNCTIONWITHMONETARYDATAONENVIRON MENTALPROTECTIONMAYSHEDSOMELIGHTONTHECOST EFFECTIVENESSOFOURENVIRON MENTALPOLICIES
/NESYSTEMOFINDICATORSINVOLVESENVIRONMENTALTHEMEMEASURESTHATCOMBINE SEVERALRESIDUALmOWSTODERIVECOMPOSITEINDICATORSOFCERTAINKINDSOFENVIRONMEN TALIMPACTS4HESETHEMEINDICATORSAREWEIGHTEDSUMSOFTHEEMISSIONSOFDIFFER ENTPRODUCTSTHATALLCONTRIBUTETOTHESAMEPROBLEM4HUSFOREXAMPLETHEGLOBAL WARMINGTHEMECONVERTSEMISSIONSOFCARBONDIOXIDEMETHANEANDNITROUSOXIDE TOCARBONDIOXIDEEQUIVALENTSORGLOBALWARMINGPOTENTIALEXPRESSINGTHEIMPACT OFEACHPOLLUTANTINTERMSOFHOWMUCHCARBONDIOXIDEWOULDCAUSEANEQUIVALENT AMOUNTOFHARM4HECOEFlCIENTSUSEDTOCONVERTOTHERPOLLUTANTSTO#/EQUIVA LENTSARESTANDARDONESROUTINELYUSEDBYTHE)0##ANDOTHERORGANIZATIONS 4HE.ETHERLANDSHASBEENAMAJORUSEROFENVIRONMENTALTHEMESWHICHARE
BUILTINTOTHE.!-%!STRUCTURE4HEIRACCOUNTSTRACKlVETHEMESGREENHOUSEGAS EMISSIONSOZONEDEPLETIONEUTROPHICATIONACIDIlCATIONANDWASTEGENERATION 4HEOZONEDEPLETIONTHEMEISCALCULATEDBASEDONEMISSIONSOFCHLOROmUOROCAR BONSANDHALONSCONVERTINGEACHCHEMICALTOITSEQUIVALENTIN#&# APARTICU LARFORMOFCHLOROmUOROCARBON BASEDONITSOZONE DEPLETINGPOTENTIAL3IMILAR APPROACHESAREFOLLOWEDTOSTANDARDIZEANDAGGREGATETHEIMPACTSOFGROUPSOF RESIDUALSONEUTROPHICATIONANDACIDIlCATION4HEWASTEINDICATORISASIMPLESUM OFTHEKILOGRAMSOFWASTEEMITTEDBYALLINDUSTRYSECTORSWITHOUTDISTINGUISHING BETWEENHARMLESSANDHAZARDOUSWASTES 4HE$UTCHTHEMEINDICATORSAREUSEDASATOOLINDEVELOPINGANDTRACKINGTHE
COUNTRYSFOUR YEARLYNATIONALENVIRONMENTALPOLICYPLANS3OMEOFTHEMACTUALLY PREDATETHE.!-%!BYASMUCHASADECADE4HECOUNTRYHASSETTARGETSFOREACH THEMEANDREGULARLYREPORTSTHEIRPROGRESSINMOVINGTOWARDTHOSETARGETS-IN ISTRYOF(OUSING3PATIAL0LANNINGANDTHE%NVIRONMENT 4HEREPORTINGDATA
THENEWSPAPERSUPONRELEASEMUCHLIKETHEMAJORECONOMICINDICATORS-OREOVER BECAUSETHEACCOUNTSSHOWTHECONTRIBUTIONOFEACHSECTORTOTHETHEMEINDICATORS THEUNDERLYINGDATACANBEUSEDTOmAGTHEINDUSTRIESWHERETHEGREATESTREDUCTIONS ARENEEDEDASSESSTHEEFFECTIVENESSOF INDIVIDUAL INDUSTRYPOLLUTION REDUCTION STRATEGIESANDSHOWWHEREADDITIONALWORKISSTILLNEEDED !GGREGATINGTHETHEMESINTOASINGLEENVIRONMENTAL INDEXPOSESANARRAYOF
PROBLEMS3IMPLYSUMMINGTHETHEMESPROVIDESAMEASURETHATHASNOINTRINSIC MEANING3OMEEMISSIONSCONTRIBUTETOSEVERALTHEMESSOTHEYAREDOUBLE COUNTED INASIMPLESUMOFTHEINDICATORS!LTHOUGHNOTINHERENTLYMEANINGFULAUNIlED INDEXCOULDPROVIDEAUSEFULTIMESERIESFORQUICKLYASSESSINGHOWWELLACOUNTRYIS MEETINGNATIONALENVIRONMENTALGOALS"UTTHATRAISESTHEQUESTIONOFWHETHERALL THEMESSHOULDBEVALUEDEQUALLYORWHETHERINFACTAWEIGHTEDSUMOFTHETHEME MEASURESWOULDBEMOREAPPROPRIATE4HECHOICEOFWEIGHTSWOULDHAVETOREmECT NATIONALPOLICYPRIORITIESSPECIFYINGWHICHOFTHEDIFFERENTENVIRONMENTALCONCERNS WASMOSTIMPORTANT4HEESTABLISHMENTOFSUCHPRIORITIESFALLSWITHINTHEPURVIEW OFPOLITICIANSRATHERTHANSTATISTICIANSANDISLIKELYTODIFFERACROSSCOUNTRIES 4HETHEMEINDICATORSONTHEIROWNMAYBEˆANDINSOMECOUNTRIESAREˆUSED
TOMEASURENATIONALPROGRESSONENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONORTOSETTARGETSFOR NATIONALPOLICY#ONSIDEREDINCONJUNCTIONWITHDATAONPOLLUTIONCONTROLEXPEN DITURETHEYOFFERAMORECOMPLEXPICTUREOFWHATACOUNTRYISACCOMPLISHING&OR EXAMPLESUPPOSETWOCOUNTRIESAREBOTHMAKINGSTEADYPROGRESSTOWARDTHEIRTAR GETSBUTONEISDOINGSOATMUCHLOWERCOSTTHANTHEOTHER4HISOBSERVATIONALONE WILLNOTEXPLAINTHEDIFFERENCESBETWEENTHEMBUTITWILLSUGGESTASETOFQUESTIONS TOASKINORDERPERHAPSTOLEARNHOWONECOUNTRYCANACHIEVEITSGOALSATLOWER COSTTHANTHEOTHER
!NEXTENSIONOFTHISSYSTEMINVOLVESUSINGINDUSTRYECONOMICANDENVIRONMENTAL INDICATORSTOGETASENSEOFEACHSECTORSCONTRIBUTIONBOTHTOTHEECONOMYANDTO ENVIRONMENTALPROBLEMS.ORWAYHASDONETHISCALCULATINGEACHSECTORSCONTRIBU TIONANDCOMPARINGITTOSIXNATIONALECONOMICMEASURES(ASSAND3ORENSEN
N SHAREOFLABORUSEMEASUREDINHOURSHOURSUSEDINTHATINDUSTRYDIVIDEDBY TOTALHOURSUSEDINTHEECONOMY
N SHAREOFNATIONALENERGYCONSUMPTION N SHAREOFVALUEADDED N PERCENTCONTRIBUTIONTOAGLOBALWARMINGCOMPOSITEMEASURE N PERCENTCONTRIBUTIONTOANACIDIlCATIONCOMPOSITEMEASUREAND N PERCENTCONTRIBUTIONTOACOMPOSITEMEASUREOFNONMETHANEVOLATILEORGANIC CHEMICALSWHICHINCLUDEGASOLINEFUMESFUMESTHATESCAPEWHENOILISTRANS FERREDTOSTORAGETANKSANDSIMILARhESCAPEDvCOMPOUNDS
%ACHOFTHESEMEASURESWASCALCULATEDFORSIXINDUSTRIESˆMININGANDMANUFAC TURINGPRIMARYINDUSTRIESELECTRICITYOILANDGASEXTRACTIONTRANSPORTATIONAND OTHERSERVICESˆASWELLASFORHOUSEHOLDSANDFORTHEGOVERNMENT)TISTHEINTER INDUSTRYCOMPARISONSTHATAREINTERESTING-ININGANDMANUFACTURINGCONTRIBUTE
OFENERGYANDCONTRIBUTEMORETHANOFGLOBAL WARMINGEMISSIONS4RANSPORTA TIONCONTRIBUTESLESSTHANOFBOTHLABORANDVALUEADDEDBUTMORETHANOF ACIDIlCATIONANDABOUTOFGLOBALWARMING4HEGOVERNMENTSERVICESSECTORON THEOTHERHANDCONTRIBUTESABOUTOFEMPLOYMENTANDOFVALUEADDEDBUT LESSTHANOFGLOBALWARMINGANDNEGLIGIBLEAMOUNTSOFTHEOTHERTWOENVIRON MENTALTHEMES !TlRSTGLANCEINDICATORSLIKETHESESEEMTOSUGGESTTHATINORDERTOMINIMIZE
IMPACTSONTHEENVIRONMENTWHILEREMAININGECONOMICALLYHEALTHYCOUNTRIES SHOULDCONCENTRATEGROWTHEFFORTSONSECTORSWITHLARGECONTRIBUTIONSTOEMPLOY MENTANDVALUEADDEDBUTSMALLCONTRIBUTIONSTOENERGYUSEANDTHEENVIRONMENTAL MEASURES!MOMENTSTHOUGHTWILLSUFlCETOREALIZETHATTHISISMUCHTOOSIMPLIS TICHOWEVER3OMEINDUSTRIESSUCHASOILANDGASEXTRACTIONAREOFNECESSITYGOING TOHAVEGREATERENVIRONMENTALIMPACTTHANMOSTSERVICESECTORSMININGCANNOTFAIL TOHAVEANIMPACTONTHEENVIRONMENT4HECOUNTRYISLIKELYTONEEDTHEPRODUCTS OFSUCHINDUSTRIESWHETHERORNOTTHEACTIVITIESOCCURWITHINITSOWNECONOMY)FIT MINIMIZEDTHEECONOMICROLEOFTHOSEINDUSTRIESITWOULDSIMPLYIMPORTTHEPROD UCTSINSTEADANDEXPORTTHEPOLLUTIONTHEYENTAIL4RANSPORTATIONSIMPACTSAREEVEN MOREDRAMATIC)NPARTTHISISBECAUSETHE.ORWEGIANDATAINCLUDEEMISSIONSFROM INTERNATIONALSHIPPINGANDTHECOUNTRYISAHAVENFORSHIPREGISTRATIONTHUSTHESE lGURESINCLUDEMORETHANDOMESTICTRANSPORT)TCLEARLYWOULDBEABSURDHOWEVER TOTHINKTHATACOUNTRYCOULDBENElTITSECONOMYANDENVIRONMENTBYhEXPORTINGv ITSTRANSPORTATIONSECTORASTHATACTIVITYISLARGELYLOCATION DEPENDENT )NDICATORSLIKETHESETHEREFOREMUSTBEUSEDWITHCONSIDERABLECARE4HEYARE
INTERESTINGBECAUSETHEYGIVEAVERYCLEARANDCOMPREHENSIBLEPICTUREOFTHEECO NOMICANDENVIRONMENTALROLESOFDIFFERENTSECTORSOFTHEECONOMY4HEPOLICYPRE SCRIPTIONSTHATMIGHTRESULTFROMTHEMAREMUCHLESSCLEAR!TTEMPTINGTOELIMINATE THESECTORSTHATCONTRIBUTEMORETOhBADSvTHANTOhGOODSvDOESNOTMAKESENSE 5SINGTHEINDICATORSASAWAYTOIDENTIFYSECTORSDESERVINGADDITIONALATTENTIONIN THEDESIGNOFFUTUREENVIRONMENTALPOLICYMAYBEMOREREALISTIC4HATADDITIONAL ATTENTIONHOWEVERWOULDHAVETORELYONMUCHMORECOMPREHENSIVEDATAABOUT THEACTIVITIESOF EACH SECTORAND THEOPPORTUNITIES TO REDUCE ITS ENVIRONMEN TALIMPACTS3IMILARLYTHESEDATAARETOOCRUDETOUSEINTRACKINGTHEPROGRESSOF EACHSECTOROVERTIMEBECAUSETHATALSOMUSTRELYONMOREDETAILEDINFORMATION -OREOVEREVENTHOUGHONESECTORMAYAPPEARMUCHWORSETHANANOTHERBYTHESE MEASURESINFACTTHEIDENTIlCATIONOFTARGETSECTORSFORFUTUREENVIRONMENTALPOL ICYSHOULDTAKEINTOCONSIDERATIONTHECOST EFFECTIVENESSOFPOLLUTION REDUCTION OPTIONSINEACHINDUSTRYRATHERTHANNECESSARILYFOCUSINGWHEREPOLLUTIONISHIGH EST4HESEPROBLEMSALLSUGGESTTHATALTHOUGHSUCHSIMPLEINDICATORSAREINTEREST INGTHEYAREOFLIMITEDUSEASPOLICYTOOLSANDMUSTBESUPPLEMENTEDWITHAMUCH RICHERUNDERSTANDINGOFTHESITUATIONBEFORETHEYCANBEUSEFUL
4HEPHYSICALmOWACCOUNTSUSETHESUPPLYANDUSETABLEFORMATTOMONITORmOWSOF RESIDUALSINTOTHEECONOMYANDTHEIROCCASIONALREUSEINTHERECYCLINGANDWASTE MANAGEMENTINDUSTRIES4HEINPUTnOUTPUTFORMATOFTHEACCOUNTSCANBEUSED
FULLPHYSICAL) /TABLES$ATAONTHEQUANTITYOFRESIDUALSGENERATEDBYASPECIlC INDUSTRYCOMEFROMANUMBEROFSOURCESACTUALMEASUREMENTESTIMATESBASEDON KNOWNFEATURESOFTHEPRODUCTIONPROCESSSELF REPORTINGBYINDUSTRYOREMISSIONS COEFlCIENTSBORROWEDFROMINTERNATIONALLYRESPECTEDSOURCESSUCHASTHE53%0!S !0 COEFlCIENTSFORVEHICLEEMISSIONS 4HEDElNITIONOFRESIDUALSFORINCLUSIONINTHEENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTSPOSES
SPECIALTECHNICALPROBLEMS"ECAUSERESIDUALSAREDElNEDTOHAVENOMONETARY VALUEMATERIALSRECAPTUREDFROMTHEWASTESTREAMANDSOLDFORREUSEARECLASSIlED DIFFERENTLYFROMMATERIALSDISCHARGEDINTOTHEENVIRONMENT3O CALLEDDISSIPATIVE LOSSESANDACCIDENTALSPILLSARECONSIDEREDTOBERESIDUALSWHEREASMATERIALSTHAT ARESIMPLYMOVEDINTHECOURSEOFECONOMICACTIVITYSUCHASMINETAILINGSARENOT CLASSIlEDASRESIDUALS)NTHEACCOUNTSINTERNATIONALRESIDUALmOWSAREASSIGNEDTO THECOUNTRYOFRESIDENCEOFTHECOMPANYGENERATINGTHEMNOTTOTHECOUNTRYWHERE THEYACTUALLYOCCURAPRACTICETHATDIFFERSFROMTHETREATMENTOFPOLLUTIONDATAIN MOSTENVIRONMENTALSTATISTICSSYSTEMS4HEACCOUNTSSHEDSOMELIGHTONTHEUSE OFRECYCLEDMATERIALHOWEVERBECAUSEOFDIFFERENCESBETWEENTHECLASSIlCATIONOF RESIDUALSANDTHATOFPRODUCTSITISNOTPOSSIBLETOFULLYTRACKRECYCLINGTHROUGHTHE ACCOUNTS !NUMBEROFCOUNTRIESHAVEDEVELOPEDPOLLUTIONINDICATORSBASEDONTHEPHYSI
CALACCOUNTS4HE$UTCHREGULARLYCALCULATEASETOFENVIRONMENTALTHEMEINDICATORS INCLUDINGGLOBALWARMINGANDMEASURESOFWATERQUALITY4HE.ORWEGIANSUSEPHYS ICALACCOUNTSDATATOCALCULATEINDICATORSABOUTSPECIlCSECTORSCOMPARINGEACH SECTORSCONTRIBUTIONTOTHEECONOMYWITHITSIMPACTONTHEENVIRONMENT7HILE ONEMUSTUSECAUTIONINDRAWINGCONCLUSIONSFROMTHESEMEASURESTHEYPROVIDEAN INTERESTINGPERSPECTIVEONLINKSBETWEENTHEECONOMYANDTHEENVIRONMENT
