ABSTRACT
REGARDINGSUBSOILASSETSINGENERALANDSUBSOILASSETACCOUNTSINPARTICULAR/NE ISTHECONCERNABOUTSUSTAINABILITYINTHEMINERALSECTORANDTHEMINERALSECTORS ROLEINSUSTAINABILITYOFTHEECONOMYASAWHOLE!SECONDISTHEFEARTHATWEWILL RUNOUTOFSPECIlCRESOURCESTHATARECRUCIALTOTHEWELL BEINGOFTHEECONOMY! THIRDSLIGHTLYDIFFERENTCONCERNPERTAINSTOWHETHERSOCIETYASAWHOLEISCAPTUR INGTHERENTSFROMMINERALEXTRACTIONORWHETHERTHEYAREREMAININGINPRIVATE HANDS4HISISANIMPORTANTISSUEBECAUSEMANYPEOPLEBELIEVETHATFUNDAMEN TALLYNATURALRESOURCESBELONGTOTHESOCIETYASAWHOLEANDALTHOUGHTHOSEWHO EXTRACTTHEMAREENTITLEDTOANORMALRETURNONTHEIRINVESTMENTANYRENTSABOVE ANDBEYONDTHATRETURNSHOULDBELONGTOTHESOCIETYRATHERTHANTOINDIVIDUALS !LTHOUGHTHEACCOUNTSDONOTPROVIDESIMPLESOLUTIONSFORTHESEISSUESTHEYDO ORGANIZETHEDATAWITHWHICHTOANALYZETHEM4HEYHELPTRACKTHERATEATWHICH MINERALSAREDISCOVEREDANDUSEDSHEDDINGSOMELIGHTONTHEDEPLETIONISSUES THOUGHNOTFULLYRESOLVINGTHEM4HEYPROVIDEAFRAMEWORKFORESTIMATINGRENTAND DETERMININGTHEEXTENTTOWHICHITISCAPTUREDBYTHEGOVERNMENTFORPUBLICUSE !SMINERALSAREEXTRACTEDTHESTOCKOFASSETSAVAILABLETOTHEECONOMYFROMTHIS SOURCEDIMINISHES!TAMACROECONOMICLEVELTHEACCOUNTSSHOWTHEAMOUNTTHAT MUSTBEREINVESTEDINORDERTOPRESERVETHESAMEOVERALLLEVELOFASSETSˆTHATIS THELEVELREQUIREDFORECONOMICSUSTAINABILITY4HEYALSOCONTRIBUTETOASSESSMENT OFWHETHERTHEECONOMYISINVESTINGENOUGHTOSUSTAININCOMEALTHOUGHTHEYDO NOTSHOWWHETHERMINERALINCOMESINPARTICULARAREBEINGREINVESTED4HEDATAIN THEACCOUNTSALSOALLOWTHECALCULATIONOFRENTSFROMEXTRACTIONOFSUBSOILASSETS ASWELLASTHESHAREOFTHOSERENTSTHATCANBEUSEDTOACHIEVESOCIALAIMSRATHER THANPRIVATEONES
-INERAL3USTAINABILITY!#ONTRADICTIONIN4ERMS !T FIRST GLANCE THE CONCEPTOF SUSTAINABILITYMAY SEEM TO FORMANOXYMORON WHENPAIREDWITHNONRENEWABLERESOURCES"UTTHETERMISUSEDINANUMBEROF WAYSTHATDOMAKESENSE4HEECONOMICCONCEPTOFMINERALSUSTAINABILITYREFERS NOTTOTHEMINERALSTHEMSELVESBUTTOTHEIRCONTRIBUTIONTOTHEECONOMY!MIN ERAL BASEDECONOMYISSUSTAINABLEIFITSUSTAINSITSINCOMELEVELEVENONCEITHAS DEPLETEDITSMINERALSANDTHEYARENOLONGERADIRECTSOURCEOFREVENUE4HISMEANS THATTHECOUNTRYMUSTREINVESTSOMEPORTIONOFITSMINERALINCOMEINOTHERASSETS RATHERTHANCONSUMEIT4HEAMOUNTINVESTEDINOTHERASSETSWILLVARYDEPEND INGONAVARIETYOFECONOMICFACTORSBUTITMUSTBEENOUGHTOGENERATETHESAME LEVELOFINCOMEASISNOWAVAILABLEFROMTHEMINERALSSOTHATONCETHEMINERALSARE DEPLETEDINCOMEDOESNOTDROP !SECONDCONCEPTOFMINERALSUSTAINABILITYFOCUSESMORESPECIFICALLYONTHE
MINERALSTHEMSELVESRATHERTHANONTHEINCOMETHEYBRING!COUNTRYISCONSID EREDSUSTAINABLEWITHRESPECTTOMINERALUSEIFITCANMEETTHENEEDSSERVEDBYTHE MINERALSINDElNITELYEVENIFTHESUBSOILRESOURCESTHEMSELVESHAVEBEENDEPLETED 4HISCOULDBEDONEINTWOWAYS/NEISBYRECYCLINGMINERALSTHATHAVEALREADY BEENEXTRACTEDINCLUDINGhMININGvLANDlLLSFORMATERIALSTHATWEREDISPOSEDOFIN THEPASTBUTCOULDSTILLBEREUSED4HESECONDISBYlNDINGOTHERWAYSTOMEETTHE NEEDSTHATWEREMETBYTHEMINERALSBYDEVELOPINGNEWTECHNOLOGIESORlNDING SUBSTITUTEPRODUCTS!TACONCEPTUALLEVELTHISAPPROACHISSOMETIMESUNDERSTOOD INTERMSOFFRAMINGNEEDSDIFFERENTLYˆNOTANEEDFORGASOLINEFOREXAMPLEBUTFOR TRANSPORTATIONINGENERALORFORWAYSTOBRINGPEOPLETOGETHER!TTIMESTHISKIND OFTHINKINGhOUTSIDETHEBOXvMAYLEADTONEWWAYSOFUNDERSTANDINGPROBLEMSAND THUSTONEWSOLUTIONS)TISHARDTOPINDOWNHOWEVERTHINKINGINTERMSOFNEW TECHNOLOGIESORSUBSTITUTEPRODUCTSISMORECONCRETE /THERCONCEPTSOFMINERALSUSTAINABILITYFOCUSONEXTERNALITIESGENERATEDBYTHE
MINERALSINDUSTRY)NPARTTHISDEALSWITHTHEENVIRONMENTALIMPACTSOFEXTRACTION TRANSPORTANDPROCESSINGOFSUBSOILASSETS)TALSODEALSWITHSOCIALIMPACTSOFTHE INDUSTRYˆINPARTICULARTHEDEPENDENCETHATCANBECREATEDINMININGTOWNSTHAT HAVENOALTERNATEINCOMESOURCESANDAREEXCESSIVELYVULNERABLETOLOSSOFJOBSOR INCOME4HECONCERNHEREISHOWTODIVERSIFYTHEECONOMICBASEOFSUCHCOMMU NITIESSOTHATTHEYDONOTBECOMEGHOSTTOWNSWHENTHERESOURCESHAVEBEENFULLY EXTRACTED
3UBSOILASSETSARElXEDNATURALENDOWMENTSASOPPOSEDTOPRODUCTSMANUFAC TUREDBYPEOPLE4HERISKTHATWEMIGHTSIMPLYRUNOUTOFTHEMISTHEREFOREALWAYS APOSSIBLETHREATTOOURECONOMYANDOURWELL BEING!TANYPOINTINTIMEWEKNOW ABOUTSOMESUBSOILASSETSBUTWEHAVENOIDEAHOWMUCHMIGHTBEOUTTHERETHAT WEDONOTKNOWABOUTYETSOTHEISSUEISLADENWITHUNCERTAINTY4HISFEARRECEIVED INCREASEDATTENTIONAFTERTHEPUBLICATIONOF4HE,IMITSTO'ROWTHAREPORTTOTHE #LUBOF2OME-EADOWSETAL 4HISSTUDYCOMPAREDKNOWNRESOURCESTOCKS WITHTHERATEOFCONSUMPTIONCONCLUDINGTHATTHEWORLDWOULDEXPERIENCESEVERE SHORTAGESOFKEYMINERALSBY
ERATEDMUCHRESEARCHINTOTHESUPPLYANDCONSUMPTIONOFMINERALRESOURCES4HE lNDINGSSUGGESTTHATBOTHMINERALEXPLORATIONANDTHEQUANTITYOFMINERALSPUTON THEMARKETAREVERYRESPONSIVETOPRICES4HUSWHENSCARCITYDRIVESUPTHEPRICES ASOCCURREDDURINGTHEOILEMBARGOESOFTHESMUCHPROlTPOTENTIALLYMAYBE GAINEDBOTHFROMlNDINGMORERESOURCESANDFROMDEVELOPINGNEWTECHNOLOGIESTO EXTRACTANDPROCESSTHOSETHATAREALREADYKNOWNTOEXIST4HERESULTISANINCREASE INMINERALSBROUGHTTOMARKETANDANINCREASEINTHESIZEOFRESERVESKNOWNTO EXIST )NORDINARYNONCRISISTIMESMININGCOMPANIESTENDTOPLANUSINGASTANDARD
TIMEHORIZON&IFTEENYEARSISCOMMONINTHE5NITED3TATESOTHERTIMEHORIZONS PREVAILELSEWHEREINTHEWORLDINRESPONSETODIFFERENTPUBLICPOLICYCONSTRAINTS ANDREGULATORYREQUIREMENTS-ININGCOMPANIESINVESTINRESOURCEDEVELOPMENT ANDEXPLORATIONATALEVELTHATENSURESCONSTANTAVAILABILITYOFRESERVESFOREXTRAC TIONTHROUGHTHEENDOFTHISPLANNINGHORIZON!SARESULTTHESUPPLYOFKNOWN RESOURCESAVAILABLEFOREXTRACTIONˆTHATISRESOURCESWHOSEEXTRACTIONISlNANCIALLY ANDTECHNICALLYVIABLEˆTENDSTOBEFAIRLYCONSTANTOVERTIME4HISCONSTANTlGURE DOESNOTREVEALTHETOTALQUANTITYOFRESOURCESEXISTINGINTHEEARTHSCRUSTSOME THINGWEARENOTLIKELYTOEVERKNOW2ATHERITTELLSUSHOWMUCHISUSABLEUNDER CURRENTMARKETCONDITIONSANDWITHKNOWNTECHNOLOGY /PINIONSDIFFERFUNDAMENTALLYABOUTWHETHERWENEEDTOWORRYABOUTRUNNING
OUTOFMINERALSˆWHETHERATIMEMAYCOMEWHENEXPLORATIONCANNOLONGERGUAR ANTEETHAT YEARSUPPLY7HETHERWECONSIDERMINERALDEPLETIONTOBEASERIOUS CAUSEFORCONCERNDEPENDSONOURASSESSMENTOFTHREEISSUES!UTYAND-IKESELL
N HOWREADILYWEBELIEVEWECANSUBSTITUTEOTHERMATERIALSFORNONRENEWABLEMIN ERALSASTHEYBECOMEMORESCARCE
N HOWREADILYWEEXPECTTASTESWILLADAPTTOASCARCITYOFRESOURCESAND N WHETHERWEBELIEVETHATTECHNICALINNOVATIONWILLIDENTIFYWAYSTOGETMOREOUT OFTHERESOURCESWEHAVE
4HOSEWHOARENOTCONCERNEDABOUTRESOURCEDEPLETIONARECONlDENTTHATIF SCARCITYDRIVESUPMINERALPRICESWEWILLlNDSUBSTITUTESORDEVELOPTECHNOLOGIES THATNOLONGERREQUIREUSTODEPENDONSUBSOILASSETS4HOSEWHOARECONCERNED ABOUTDEPLETIONARENOTWILLINGTOCOUNTONTECHNOLOGYANDTHEMARKETTOSOLVETHE PROBLEMSINTHEFUTUREATLEASTNOTWITHOUTIMPOSINGOTHERSIGNIlCANTCOSTSASTHE ECONOMYMOVESAWAYFROMITSRELIANCEONMINERALS4HEIRRESPONSEISINESSENCE TOCALL FOR INCENTIVES TODEVELOPNEW TECHNOLOGIESNOW RATHER THANWAITUNTIL RESOURCEDEPLETIONDRIVESPRICESUPTOTHEPOINTWHEREMARKETFORCESMAKETECHNO LOGICALINNOVATIONlNANCIALLYWORTHWHILE %VEN IF RUNNINGOUT ISNOTA REAL RISK THENEGATIVEEXTERNALITIESOF RESOURCE
DEPENDENCECANARGUEFORTHEDESIRABILITYOFREDUCINGCONSUMPTIONANDSEEKING ALTERNATIVESTOCONVENTIONALMINERALS4HEEXTERNALITIESAREBOTHENVIRONMENTALAND POLITICAL%NVIRONMENTALIMPACTSRESULTDIRECTLYFROMEXTRACTIONOFSUBSOILASSETS ANDINDIRECTLYFROMTHEIRUSEPARTICULARLYCOMBUSTIONOFFOSSILFUELS4HEPOLITICAL CONCERNSFOCUSONTHERISKSCREATEDBYDEPENDENCEONIMPORTEDMINERALSINTHE 5NITED3TATESTHISPERTAINSINPARTICULARTODEPENDENCEON-IDDLE%ASTERNOIL4HE
PRICESHOCKSTOTHE5NITED3TATESCOMPLEXROLEIN-IDDLE%ASTERNPOLITICSWHICH MAYBEUNDERSTOODASONEFACTORINTHE3EPTEMBERATTACKS 4HESE IMPACTS LEAD TOADESIREBOTH TOREDUCECURRENTCONSUMPTIONANDTO
ACCELERATETHESEARCHFORALTERNATIVESTOFOREIGNOILSOTHATTHESHIFTTOLESSHARM FULENERGYSOURCESWILLBEMADEBEFOREITWOULDOCCURINRESPONSETOFREE MARKET FORCES)FALLTHEEXTERNALITIESOFDEPENDENCEONFOSSILFUELSCOULDBEINTERNALIZED THERESULTINGPRICEINCREASESMIGHTDRIVETHEMARKETTODEVELOPNEWTECHNOLOGICAL ALTERNATIVESNOW0OLICIESSUCHASCARBONTAXESOFTENAREPROPOSEDASASTRATEGYFOR INTERNALIZINGTHEENVIRONMENTALEXTERNALITIES3IMILARTAXESONFOSSILFUELCONSUMP TIONMIGHTBEUSEDTOINTERNALIZESOMEOFTHECOSTSOFDEPENDENCEON-IDDLE%AST ERNOILSUCHASMILITARYEXPENDITURESFORTHE'ULF7ARINTHESORTHEWARSIN !FGHANISTANAND)RAQFOLLOWINGTHE3EPTEMBERATTACKS
3UBSOILASSETSCANBEACCOUNTEDFORINTHEASSETACCOUNTS!GENERALSTRUCTUREFOR THESEACCOUNTSAPPEAREDIN#HAPTER.OTALLOFTHEENTRIESINTHATTABLEMAKE SENSEFORMINERALSHOWEVERASNATURALGROWTHISNOTRELEVANTTONONRENEWABLES -OREOVERWHENACCOUNTSAREBUILTMETHODOLOGICALANDDATACONSTRAINTSMAYLIMIT THEENTRIESACTUALLYINCLUDEDINTHEACCOUNTS4ABLE SHOWSTHEBASICSTRUCTURE OFTHEMINERALASSETACCOUNTS 7HICHSUBSOILASSETSAREINCLUDEDINTHEACCOUNTSDEPENDSONTHERESOURCES
AVAILABLEINTHECOUNTRYANDTHEIRECONOMICIMPORTANCE0HYSICALACCOUNTSOFTEN INCLUDEAWIDERSETOFASSETSTHANDOMONETARYACCOUNTSBECAUSECOUNTRIESMAY
!SSET!CCOUNTS
CHOOSETOTRACKPHYSICALSUPPLIESOFRESOURCESTHATARENOTCURRENTLYOFMONETARY VALUE !TTHENATIONALSCALETHESALEANDPURCHASEOFNONPRODUCEDASSETSWILLBALANCE
OUTBECAUSEONECOMPANYSSALEISANOTHERCOMPANYSPURCHASE4HISITEMMAY THEREFOREBEOFGREATERINTERESTINASSETACCOUNTSBUILTATTHECORPORATEORGOVERN MENTLEVELTHANINTHOSEPREPAREDFORTHECOUNTRYASAWHOLE-OREOVERINTHECASEOF SUBSOILASSETSALTHOUGHEXPLORATIONRIGHTSARESOLDTHEASSETSTHEMSELVESRARELYARE $ISTINGUISHINGBETWEENNEWDISCOVERIESANDRECLASSIlCATIONSINTHESECONDAND
THIRDSECTIONSOFTHEACCOUNTSCANBETRICKYINTHECASEOFSUBSOILASSETS#ONCEP TUALLYTHEDIFFERENCEISSTRAIGHTFORWARD)NPRACTICEHOWEVERTHECATEGORIESUSED TOCLASSIFYSUBSOILASSETSCANMAKEITDIFlCULTTOKNOWWHENANASSETSHOULDACTU ALLYBECONSIDEREDASDISCOVERED#ONSEQUENTLYTHESECATEGORIESOFENVIRONMENTAL APPEARANCEARESOMETIMESLUMPEDTOGETHERWHENACTUALLYBUILDINGACCOUNTS
7HENBUILDINGMINERALASSETACCOUNTSONEOFTHElRSTCONCERNSISWHICHSUBSOIL ASSETSSHOULDBEINCLUDED3UBSOILASSETSTYPICALLYARECLASSIlEDACCORDINGTOTHE TECHNICALANDlNANCIALFEASIBILITYOFEXTRACTINGTHEM5SINGTHESETWOCRITERIATHEY AREARRAYEDINWHATISCALLEDA-C+ELVEYBOXASSHOWNIN4ABLE 4HEFOURCOL UMNSLABELEDhDISCOVEREDRESERVESvPROVIDEDATAABOUTRESERVESATDIFFERENTLEVELS OFTECHNICALFEASIBILITYTHETWOCOLUMNSUNDERhUNDISCOVEREDRESERVESvINCLUDE DEPOSITS THOUGHT LIKELY TOEXISTBASEDONGEOLOGYBUT THATHAVENOTYETBEEN SOUGHT4HEROWSINDICATETHEDEGREEOFECONOMICVIABILITYOFTHEDIFFERENTDEPOS ITS%ACHCELLWOULDPROVIDEDATAONTHEQUANTITYOFRESERVESINTHATCLASSALTHOUGH INPRACTICEMANYCOUNTRIESDONOTHAVESUFlCIENTLYDETAILEDINFORMATIONTOCOM PLETETHECELLSFORNONECONOMICORUNDISCOVEREDRESERVES/NLYPROVENRESERVESCAN ACTUALLYBEDEVELOPEDTHEBLANKSINTHERESTOFTHEhDEVELOPEDvROWINDICATETHAT THOSECELLSCANNOTBElLLEDIN"ECAUSEITCANBEVERYEXPENSIVETOPROVETHEVIABIL ITYOFDEPOSITSlRMSUSUALLYPROVETHEEXISTENCEOFONLYARELATIVELYSMALLQUANTITY OFTHEIRHOLDINGSATATIME "OXESOFTHISTYPEARECOMMONLYUSEDFOROILANDGASANDFORMINERALSTHATARE
INSHORTSUPPLY4HEYARENOTUSEDFORSUBSOILASSETSCONSIDEREDTOBEESSENTIALLY UNLIMITEDINSUPPLYSUCHASSANDANDGRAVELASNOONEISCONCERNEDABOUTRUNNING
-C+ELVEY"OX
ASSETSBECAUSESCARCITYISNOTAMATTERFORCONCERN $IFFERENTCOUNTRIESHAVEMADEDIFFERENTCHOICESABOUTWHICH-C+ELVEYBOX
CLASSESTOINCLUDEINTHEACCOUNTS4HE3.!INCLUDESONLYPROVENRESERVESWHEREAS PHYSICALACCOUNTSFORMINERALSINTHE3%%!ALSOINCLUDEPROBABLEANDPOSSIBLE RESERVESDISTINGUISHINGAMONGTHEASSETSINEACH"ECAUSEOFTHEUNCERTAINTYASSO CIATEDWITHPROBABLEANDPOSSIBLERESERVESCOUNTRIESGENERALLYCHOOSENOTTOESTI MATEMONETARYVALUESFORTHEM)NTHATRESPECTTHEREFORETHE3%%!OFTENENDSUP FOLLOWINGTHESAMEPATHASTHE3.! 4HE53TERMINOLOGYFORCATEGORIZINGRESOURCESISDIFFERENTFROMTHATOF%UROSTAT
ORTHE3%%!.ORDHAUSAND+OKKELENBERG )NSTEADOFTHECATEGORIESSHOWN ACROSSTHETOPOF4ABLE THE53-C+ELVEYBOXCOVERSONLYWHATITCALLShIDENTI lEDRESOURCESvWHICHARETHEEQUIVALENTOFDEMONSTRATEDRESERVESIN4ABLE )DENTIlEDRESOURCESAREDIVIDEDINTODEMONSTRATEDANDINFERREDRESOURCESDEMON STRATEDRESOURCESARETHENDIVIDEDINTOMEASUREDANDINDICATED/NLYDEMONSTRATED RESOURCESAREINCLUDEDINTHEACCOUNTSANDTHEYMUSTBEPROlTABLETOEXTRACTTHUS THEYMAYBETHEEQUIVALENTOFPROVENRESERVESINTHE%UROSTATAND3%%!CLASSIlCA TIONS7HEREAShRESERVESvAPPLIESTOALLSUBSOILASSETSINTHE%UROPEANCLASSIlCATION SYSTEMINTHE53SYSTEMhRESOURCESvREFERSTOALLSUBSOILASSETSANDhRESERVESvONLY TOTHOSETHATAREINCLUDEDINTHEACCOUNTS"ECAUSEOFSUCHVARIATIONSITISIMPOR TANTTOBECLEARABOUTTERMINOLOGYWHENWORKINGONMINERALACCOUNTS /VERTIMERESERVESCANCHANGECATEGORIESWITHINTHE-C+ELVEYBOXFORANUM
BEROFREASONS#HANGESINMARKETPRICEORTHECOSTSOFEXTRACTIONWILLMOVERESERVES AMONGECONOMICCATEGORIES-OREOVERASlRMSWISHTOMAINTAINTHECONSTANT YEARKNOWNSUPPLYFORPLANNINGPURPOSESTHEYWILLCONTINUALLYGATHERINFORMATION ABOUTPOSSIBLEANDPROBABLERESERVESSOASTOMOVETHEMINTOTHEPROVENCATEGORYAS THECURRENTLYKNOWNRESERVESAREEXTRACTED3IMILARLYEXPLORATORYACTIVITYWILLMOVE SOMEHYPOTHETICALORSPECULATIVERESERVESINTOTHEDISCOVEREDCATEGORIES4HEPUB LICLYAVAILABLECORPORATEDATAUSEDTOPOPULATETHEMINERALACCOUNTSDONOTALWAYS PROVIDEENOUGHDETAILTODISTINGUISHAMONGTHESECHANGESWHICHEXPLAINSWHYTHE ACCOUNTSCANNOTALWAYSSEPARATETOTALLYNEWDISCOVERIESFROMCATEGORYCHANGES
'ENERALMETHODSFORESTIMATINGSTOCKSANDRENTSWEREDISCUSSEDIN#HAPTER 4HECASEOFSUBSOILASSETSRAISESAFEWPARTICULARPROBLEMS"ROADLYSPEAKINGTHE PROBLEMSARISEBECAUSEMINERALASSETSCANNOTBEVALUEDDIRECTLY)NSTEADTHEYARE ARESIDUALAFTERSEVERALOTHERCOSTSHAVEBEENDEDUCTEDFROMTHEMINESREVENUE #ONSIDERABLEUNCERTAINTYSURROUNDSTHEESTIMATIONOFMANYOFTHOSEOTHERCOSTS ANDTHERESOLUTIONOFEACHOFTHOSEISSUESHASIMPLICATIONSFORTHERESIDUALUSED ASAPROXYFORTHEVALUEOFMINERALS#ONSEQUENTLYUNDERSTANDINGTHEDIFlCULTYIN VALUINGMINERALSNECESSITATESTHECONSIDERATIONOFSOMEOTHERACCOUNTINGISSUES
/NEPROBLEMINESTIMATINGMINERALVALUESISTHEDIFlCULTYOFSEPARATINGTHEVALUEOF THEMINERALSTHEMSELVESFROMTHEVALUEOFTHEMANUFACTUREDCAPITALUSEDTOLOCATE
BETWEENTHESETWOBECAUSEONLYTHECHANGEINVALUEOFTHEMINERALSTHEMSELVESIS RELEVANTFORMOSTPOLICYISSUESNOTTHECONVENTIONALDEPRECIATIONOFTHEPRODUCED CAPITAL4HISWASMENTIONEDIN#HAPTERWHERETHENORMALRETURNTOPRODUCED CAPITALWASINCLUDEDINTHECOSTSOFEXTRACTIONTHATMUSTBEDEDUCTEDTOESTIMATE RENT 4HEOPERATINGSURPLUSOFTHEMININGCOMPANYˆTHATISTHEVALUEOFITSOUTPUT
LESSALLITSOPERATINGCOSTSINCLUDINGLABORˆREPRESENTSTHEINCOMEGENERATEDFROM BOTHTHEPRODUCEDCAPITALANDTHENATURALRESOURCEBEINGEXPLOITED&ROMTHIS INCOMEITISNECESSARYTODEDUCTTHEDEPRECIATIONOFBOTHTHElXEDCAPITALANDTHE NATURALRESOURCETOWORKOUTTHERETURNSTOEACH"ECAUSETHEVALUESASSOCIATEDWITH THElXEDCAPITALAREWELLKNOWNITISCOMMONTOESTIMATEARETURNTOlXEDCAPITAL USINGANESTIMATEDRATEOFRETURN4HERETURNTOTHENATURALRESOURCECANTHENBE CALCULATEDBYSUBTRACTIONANDTHISVALUEISUSEDTODETERMINETHEVALUEOFTHETOTAL STOCKOFTHERESOURCEEMPLOYINGASSUMPTIONSABOUTTHETOTALQUANTITYAVAILABLE ANDRATEOFEXTRACTION#HOOSINGTHERATEOFRETURNTOAPPLYTOlXEDCAPITALISALSO DIFlCULTMOREOVERTHERESULTINGVALUESAREHIGHLYSENSITIVETOTHECHOICEOFRATEOF RETURN4HISSETOFPROBLEMSCANADDCONSIDERABLEUNCERTAINTYTOTHEVALUATIONOF SUBSOILASSETSANDTHEIRDEPLETION !SIMILARPROBLEMWITHSUBSOILASSETSRELATESTOINTERDEPENDENTPRODUCTS-ANY
MINERALSEXIST INASSOCIATIONWITHOTHERMINERALSANDMUCHOF THE INPUTCOST APPLIESTOBOTH&OREXAMPLESILVERGENERALLYOCCURSWITHZINCANDLEADOILOFTEN OCCURSINCONJUNCTIONWITHGAS)NSOMECASESONEPRODUCTISCLEARLYCONSIDERED PRIMARYAND THEOTHERS SECONDARYBUT FOR SOMEPRODUCTS THISCANCHANGEAS PRICESANDDEMANDmUCTUATE&ORACCOUNTINGPURPOSESITISDESIRABLETOSEPARATE THEINPUTCOSTSOFEACHMINERALSOTHATRENTSCANBECALCULATEDSEPARATELY4HISCAN BEDIFlCULTTODO4YPICALLYTODIVIDETHEINPUTCOSTSAMONGPRODUCTSSOMEKIND OFSIMPLERULEMUSTBEADOPTEDSUCHASPRORATINGTHEMBASEDONTHEVALUEOFTHE OUTPUT5SESOFTHERESULTINGDATAARELIMITEDHOWEVERBECAUSEINFACTITISNOTPOS SIBLETOMAKEINDEPENDENTPRODUCTIONDECISIONSABOUTTHEPRODUCTSBASEDONTHE COSTSTRUCTURESFOREACH
4WORELATEDCONCERNSINTHECALCULATIONOFMINERALRENTSARETHETREATMENTOFEXPLO RATIONANDDECOMMISSIONINGCOSTS%XPLORATIONIMPOSESASIGNIlCANTCOSTBEFORE THEDEPOSITBEGINSTOSHOWANYREVENUES$ECOMMISSIONINGRECLAIMINGAMINESITE ORRESTORINGITTOITSORIGINALCONDITIONAFTERITHASBEENDEPLETEDIMPOSESSIGNIl CANTCOSTSAFTERTHEREVENUESTREAMHASENDED &ORBOTHOFTHESEEXPENDITURESTHEQUESTIONISWHETHERTHEYSHOULDBETREATED
ASINTERMEDIATECONSUMPTIONORASINVESTMENT4HECHOICEAFFECTSTHEVALUETHAT WILLBEESTIMATEDFORRENTATDIFFERENTTIMESANDTHUSTHEVALUEOFTHEASSETANDITS DEPLETION!SEXPLAINEDIN#HAPTERRENTISCALCULATEDASREVENUELESSINTERMEDI ATECONSUMPTIONLABORDEPRECIATIONCONSUMPTIONOFlXEDCAPITAL ANDNORMAL RETURNSTOCAPITAL)FEXPLORATIONANDDECOMMISSIONINGCOSTSARETREATEDASINTER MEDIATECONSUMPTIONLARGEDEDUCTIONSWILLBETAKENBEFORETHEREVENUEBEGINS FOREXPLORATION ANDAFTERITENDSFORDECOMMISSIONING 4HEDEPOSITWILLSHOW NEGATIVERENTSATTHOSETIMESANDRELATIVELYHIGHONESOVERITSPRODUCTIVELIFE
FORMATIONTHENTHEYAREACCOUNTEDFORASCONSUMPTIONOFlXEDCAPITALOVERTHE PRODUCTIVELIFEOFTHEDEPOSIT4HISWILLELIMINATETHELARGEINTERMEDIATECOSTSBEFORE ANDAFTERTHEPRODUCTIVELIFEOFTHEASSETREDUCINGTHECHANCESOFNEGATIVERENTSAT THOSETIMES)TWILLINCREASETHECOSTSDEDUCTEDFROMREVENUEINORDERTOCALCULATE RENTSDECREASINGTHERENTESTIMATESDURINGTHEPRODUCTIVELIFEOFTHEASSET %NVIRONMENTALACCOUNTANTSAGREETHATDECOMMISSIONINGCOSTSSHOULDBETREATED
ASCAPITALFORMATIONANDDEPRECIATEDDURINGTHELIFEOFTHEDEPOSIT%XPLORATION HASRAISEDMORECOMPLICATEDQUESTIONS4HE3.!CALLEDFOREXPLORATIONTOBE TREATEDASINTERMEDIATECONSUMPTION4HISMEANTTHATTHEACCOUNTSSHOWEDlRMS OPERATINGATALOSSWITHLARGENEGATIVERENTSWHILETHEYWEREINTHEINITIALSTAGESOF LOOKINGFORMINERALSANDPREPARINGTOEXTRACTTHEM"ECAUSETHISRANCOUNTERTO COMMONSENSEABOUTTHEMINERALINDUSTRYTHE3.!CHANGEDITCREATINGANEW CATEGORYOFINTANGIBLElXEDCAPITALASSETCALLEDhMINERALEXPLORATIONvFOREXPLORA TIONEXPENDITURES4HOSEEXPENDITURESTHENAREDEPRECIATEDOVERTIMEINTHESAME WAYASOTHERPRODUCEDCAPITAL 0RACTITIONERSOFSUBSOILASSETACCOUNTINGARENOTALLINAGREEMENTWITHTHE3.!
