ABSTRACT
INTERESTINEXPLICITLYACCOUNTINGFORNONTIMBERFORESTPRODUCTSANDFORTHETRADE OFFSANDCOMPLEMENTARITIESAMONGTHOSEPRODUCTS)NMOSTCOUNTRIESTHECONVEN TIONALACCOUNTSINCLUDEONLYMARKETEDFORESTPRODUCTSSUCHASTIMBER4HECON VENTIONALACCOUNTSCALLFORINCLUSIONOFGATHEREDPRODUCTSSUCHASFUELWOODAND ARTISANALBUILDINGMATERIALSINSOMECOUNTRIESTHEYACTUALLYAREINCLUDEDBUTIN OTHERCOUNTRIESTHEYARENOT)NADDITIONFORESTACCOUNTSCOULDINCLUDERECREATION WATERSHEDPROTECTIONEROSIONCONTROLCARBONSEQUESTRATIONBIODIVERSITYSPECIES HABITATANDOTHERSERVICESOFVALUETOHUMANS3OMEOFTHESEARERELATIVELYEASYTO ACCOUNTFOROTHERSSUCHASBIODIVERSITYAREDIFlCULTORSOMEWOULDARGUE IMPOS SIBLETOQUANTIFYANDVALUEMEANINGFULLY-OREOVERSOMEOFTHESEPRODUCTSAND SERVICESˆFOREXAMPLERECREATIONCARBONSEQUESTRATIONANDWATERSHEDPROTEC TIONˆCANBEENJOYEDINCONJUNCTIONWITHEACHOTHERWHEREASOTHERSSUCHASTIM BERCOMPETEWITHMOSTOFTHEREST&ORESTACCOUNTSCOULDBEATOOLFORCAPTURING SOMEOFTHESERELATIONSHIPSANDFORASSESSINGTHETRADE OFFSAMONGTHEM
)NORDERTOBUILDFORESTACCOUNTSACOMPREHENSIVECLASSIlCATIONSYSTEMTHATCLARI lESTHESCOPEOFTHEEFFORTISNEEDED&IRSTITHELPSTODESCRIBEFORESTPRODUCTSTHAT MIGHTBEINCLUDEDINTHEACCOUNTS
PRODUCTSCOLLECTIVELYREFERREDTOASNONTIMBERFORESTPRODUCTS.4&0S INCLUDE RATTANGUMARABICFUELWOODSPICESFRUITSBEEPRODUCTSANDMEDICINES
N .ONMARKETEDFORESTPRODUCTS4HESEITEMSAREGATHEREDANDUSEDWITHOUTPASS INGTHROUGHMARKETS%XAMPLESINCLUDEFUELWOODANDBUILDINGMATERIALS
N #ARBONSEQUESTRATION&ORESTSSEQUESTERATMOSPHERICCARBONANDCANTHUSHELP REDUCETHETHREATOFGLOBALWARMING4HEJOINTIMPLEMENTATIONANDCARBON TRADINGPROPOSALSBEINGDEVELOPEDUNDERTHE+YOTO0ROTOCOLMAYCREATEMECHA NISMSBYWHICHINDUSTRIESAREINDUCEDTOPAYTOPROTECTFORESTSFORTHISPURPOSE BUTATPRESENTTHESESERVICESARENOTMARKETED
N 7ATERSHEDPROTECTION2AINFALLONTO FORESTS TENDS TOSEEPGRADUALLY INTO THE GROUNDRECHARGINGAQUIFERS)NCONTRASTRAINFALLONTODENUDEDLANDLEFTAFTER FORESTSARECUTOFTENRUNSOFFTAKINGLOOSESOILWITHIT4HERUSHINGWATERCAN ERODEAGRICULTURALLANDDOWNSTREAMFROMTHEFORMERLYFORESTEDAREA4HISBOTH HARMSAGRICULTURALLANDFROMWHICHSOILISTAKENANDDEPOSITSSEDIMENTINTORIV ERS)FTHEFORESTSWEREONSTEEPSLOPESLANDSLIDESCANALSORESULTWITHDEVASTAT INGIMPACTSONCOMMUNITIESFARTHERDOWNHILL4HECONTRIBUTIONOFFORESTSTOTHE PREVENTIONOFALLTHESEDISASTERSISREFERREDTOASWATERSHEDPROTECTIONSERVICES
N 2ECREATION&ORESTSAREUSED FORMANYKINDSOF RECREATIONHIKINGCAMPING HUNTINGBIRD WATCHINGSKIINGANDSOON!LTHOUGHRECREATIONALFORESTSOFTEN AREPUBLICLYOWNEDITISEASYTOSETAPRICEANDEXCLUDETHOSEWHOARENOTWILLING TOPAYFORACCESSSOTHESECANBEMARKETED
N "IODIVERSITYSUPPORT.ATURALFORESTSPROVIDEHABITATFORAWIDERANGEOFPLANT ANDANIMALSPECIES4HISSERVICEOFTHEFORESTDIFFERSFROMTHEHABITATITPROVIDES FORFOODSPECIESORMEDICINALPLANTSINTHATTHEVALUEDERIVESFROMTHEEXISTENCE OFABROADDIVERSITYOFSPECIESNOTFROMTHEPURPOSETHATANYONEOFTHOSESPE CIESSERVESTOHUMANS4HISSERVICEISAPUBLICGOODINTHATITISNOTPOSSIBLETO CONTROLACCESS-OREOVEROFTENWEDONOTEVENKNOWHOWˆORWHETHERˆTHE DIVERSITYOFTHEFORESTISOFANYBENElTTOHUMANS4HISMAKESBIODIVERSITYCON SERVATIONONEOFTHEMOSTDIFlCULTFORESTSERVICESTOVALUEORTOJUSTIFYONECO NOMICGROUNDSINTHEPOLITICALARENA
N %XISTENCEANDOPTIONVALUES-ANYPEOPLEVALUETHEFACTTHATFORESTSANDOTHER ENVIRONMENTALASSETSEXISTEVENIFTHEYDONOTEXPECTTOEVERREAPANYDIRECT PERSONALBENElTFROMTHEASSETSEXISTENCETHISISREFERREDTOASTHEASSETSEXIS TENCEVALUE0EOPLEWHOWOULDLIKETORETAINTHEOPTIONTOBENElTDIRECTLYFROM THEENVIRONMENTALASSETSINTHEFUTUREEVENIFTHEYDONOTDOSONOWALSOVALUE THESEASSETSTHISISCALLEDTHEASSETSOPTIONVALUE
$ESIGNINGACLASSIlCATIONSYSTEMTHATCAPTURESTHEFULLRICHNESSOFFORESTGOODSAND SERVICESPOSESANARRAYOFPRACTICALPROBLEMS/NEPROBLEMCONCERNSTHEUNITOF ANALYSIS!TlRSTGLANCETHISSEEMSSIMPLEFORESTSGROWONLANDANDARECOUNTEDIN HECTARESORACRES4HETREESTHEMSELVESASWELLASSOME.4&0SMAYBEMEASUREDBY USINGCOEFlCIENTSFORVOLUMEPERHECTARE4HISWORKSFAIRLYWELLFORTIMBERCARBON SEQUESTRATIONANDGOODSSUCHASRATTANORGUMARABIC)TFALLSSHORTFOROTHERFOREST GOODSANDSERVICESHOWEVER!LTHOUGHBIODIVERSITYISRELATEDTOTHEAREAOFCONTIGU
VOLUMEISMEANINGLESS!REAMIGHTBEAPARTIALMEASUREOFRECREATIONSERVICESPRO VIDEDBYFORESTSBUTTHENUMBEROFVISITORSCOULDBEAMUCHBETTERONE -EASURINGFORESTSBYAREACREATESAMORESERIOUSCONUNDRUM)TDOESNOTDEAL
WITHTHEFACTTHATONEHECTAREOFFORESTLANDCANEASILYPROVIDEMANYPRODUCTSAT THESAMETIME)FEACHOFTHOSEPRODUCTSREPRESENTEDACLASSIlCATIONCATEGORYFOR FORESTSANDWASASSIGNEDTHEFULLAREAOFTHEFORESTTHENCLEARLYTHEYCOULDNOTBE ADDEDUPINANYMEANINGFULWAY!SSIGNINGEACHPARCELTOONLYONEPRODUCTWOULD NOTWORKEITHERASMOSTPARCELSPROVIDESEVERALPRODUCTSATONCE -OSTFORESTACCOUNTINGSYSTEMSPARTIALLYADDRESSTHISISSUEBYSTRUCTURINGTHE
ACCOUNTINGANDCLASSIlCATIONFRAMEWORKSSOASTOSEPARATEFORESTSFROMTHELAND ONWHICHTHEYGROW4HISISPARTICULARLYIMPORTANTFORMONETARYACCOUNTSWHERE THEGOALISTOVALUETHEFORESTGOODSANDSERVICESSEPARATELYFROMTHELAND)NTHAT WAYITISATLEASTTHEORETICALLYPOSSIBLETOVALUEEACHGOODORSERVICESEPARATELYAND THENADDTHEMTOGETHERTOCOMEUPWITHANAGGREGATEVALUEFORTHEWHOLEFOREST RESOURCE3EPARATELYTHELANDACCOUNTSWOULDSHOWAVALUEFORTHELANDONWHICH THEFORESTSTANDSWHICHWILLVARYDEPENDINGONITSLOCATIONANDOTHERCHARACTER ISTICS)NPRACTICEHOWEVERSEPARATINGTHEVALUEOFTHELANDFROMTHATOFTHEFOREST PRODUCTSISQUITEDIFlCULTBECAUSEMARKETDATAAREOFTENINSUFlCIENTTODIFFERENTI ATETHEPRICESOFFORESTPRODUCTSFROMTHEPRICEOFTHELAND.EVERTHELESSTHE3%%! DISTINGUISHESFORESTFROMLANDINTHEFORESTACCOUNTSFOLLOWINGTHECLASSIlCATIONSOF THE3.!4HE%UROPEANFORESTACCOUNTINGSYSTEM)NTEGRATED%CONOMICAND%NVI RONMENTAL!CCOUNTINGFOR&ORESTSOR)%%!& WHICHCONSTITUTESAMAJORCONTRIBU TIONTOFORESTACCOUNTINGMETHODOLOGYDOESTHESAME%UROSTATB 4HEPROBLEMOFMULTIPLESERVICESPROVIDEDBYASINGLEAREAOFFORESTISMOREDIF
lCULTWHENVALUINGSTOCKSTHANWHENVALUINGmOWS)NTHEmOWACCOUNTSITISATLEAST THEORETICALLYPOSSIBLETOVALUEEACHGOODORSERVICESEPARATELYANDADDTHEMALLUP)F SOMETREESARECUTDURINGTHEYEARTHEYPROVIDETHEmOWVALUEOFTIMBERTHOSETHAT REMAINPROVIDETHEmOWVALUEFORCARBONSEQUESTRATIONHABITATANDOTHERNONCON SUMPTIVESERVICES4HENUMBEROFVISITORSMIGHTDETERMINETHEVALUEOFRECREATION ANDTHEQUANTITYOFGOODSCOLLECTEDINTHEFORESTCOULDGIVEABASISFORVALUING.4&0S 7HENVALUINGTHEFORESTASSETTHISISMOREPROBLEMATIC!SDISCUSSEDIN#HAP
TERTHEVALUEOFTHEASSETSHOULDBEBASEDONTHENETPRESENTVALUEOFTHEFUTURE INCOMESTREAMFROMTHEFORESTWHICHINTURNWILLDEPENDONWHICHGOODSANDSER VICESITPROVIDESINTHEFUTURE&ORPRIVATELYOWNEDFORESTSFARFROMURBANAREASFAC INGNOCOMPETINGDEMANDFORTHELANDFORAGRICULTUREORURBANGROWTHPREDICTING THEFUTUREGOODSANDSERVICESPROVIDEDMAYBERELATIVELYEASY%LSEWHEREHOW EVERFORECASTINGFUTUREMANAGEMENTPATTERNSMAYBEHARDER)NSOMERURALAREAS POPULATIONPRESSUREMAYFORCETHECONVERSIONOFFORESTSTOSMALLFARMSINOTHERS AGRIBUSINESSlRMSMAYCONVERTFORESTSTOCOFFEEOROTHERPLANTATIONS.EARGROW INGURBANAREASMARKETPRESSURESMAYFORCETHECONVERSIONOFFORESTSTORESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENTELIMINATINGALLFORESTGOODSANDSERVICESBECAUSETHERETURNSTOOTHER LANDUSESAREMOREPROlTABLE/NPUBLICLANDANDINSOMECASESEVENONPRIVATE LANDTHEFUTUREMANAGEMENTPATTERNMAYBEAMATTEROFPUBLICPOLICYˆCONSERVA TIONVERSUSLOGGINGORPROTECTINGOPENSPACEVERSUSALLOWINGURBANGROWTHˆAND THEMANAGEMENTASSUMPTIONSUNDERLYINGTHECALCULATIONOFNETPRESENTVALUECAN BEHIGHLYPOLITICAL4HEACCOUNTSDONOTDEALWITHSUCHPROBLEMSVALUINGPROP ERTYBASEDONTHEASSUMPTIONTHATCURRENTUSESWILLCONTINUEANDPRICESWILLNOT
NOTTHEWAYTHATMARKETSVALUEPROPERTY 3OMETIMESTHEDEMANDFORFORESTACCOUNTSMAYARISEPRECISELYFROMADESIRETO
ASSESSTHEVALUEOFTHEFORESTANDTHELANDUNDERIT INDIFFERENTUSES)NSUCHCASES PROSPECTIVEUSERSOF THEACCOUNTSDATAMUSTBEAWARETHATASSUMPTIONSABOUT THOSEMANAGEMENTREGIMESMUSTNECESSARILYUNDERLIETHEFORESTVALUES4HERESULT INGVALUESWILLFOLLOWFROMTHEMANAGEMENTASSUMPTIONSSEPARATEANALYTICALWORK WILLBENEEDEDTOVARYTHOSEASSUMPTIONSANDCOMPAREALTERNATEREGIMES4HISIS NOTDONEWITHINTHEENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTS
4HESTRUCTUREOFFORESTASSETACCOUNTSSHOULDFOLLOWTHEBASICASSETACCOUNTSTRUC TUREDISCUSSEDIN#HAPTERASSHOWNIN4ABLE )FALLGOODSANDSERVICESOFTHE FORESTCOULDBEACCOUNTEDFORTHISTABLEWOULDHAVEACOLUMNSHOWINGTHEASSET VALUEOFEACHGOODORSERVICEONEFORTIMBERONEFOREACH.4&0ONEFORCARBON SEQUESTRATIONANDSOON4HETOTALVALUEOFTHEFORESTWOULDBETHESUMOFTHESTOCK VALUESFOREACHOFTHECOMPONENTSERVICES4HISISVERYDIFlCULTTOIMPLEMENTASIT REQUIRESONETOGUESSTHEPACKAGEOFGOODSORSERVICESTHATACTUALLYWILLBERECEIVED FROMTHEFORESTINTHEFUTURE 4HERECLASSIlCATIONLINESINTHISACCOUNTSTRUCTUREWOULDCAPTURECHANGESOVER
TIMEINTHEGOODSANDSERVICESPROVIDEDBYTHEFOREST&OREXAMPLEACOMMERCIAL FORESTMIGHTPROVIDETIMBERCARBONSEQUESTRATIONWATERSHEDPROTECTIONANDHABI TATTOSUPPORTBIODIVERSITY)FITBECOMESAPROTECTEDAREAITSTIMBERVALUEWILLDROP TOZEROSOTHISVALUEWILLBESUBTRACTEDONTHELINEFORENVIRONMENTALDISAPPEARANCE RESULTINGFROMRECLASSIlCATIONSASARESULTOFCHANGEOFFUNCTION)TSVALUEFORRECRE ATIONWILLRISEFORTHESAMEREASONALTHOUGHNOTNECESSARILYBYTHESAMEAMOUNT
4HECURRENTACCOUNTSALSOCOULDBEADJUSTEDTOINCLUDEALLOFTHEECONOMICALLYVALU ABLEOUTPUTOFFORESTS!SDESCRIBEDINTHESECTIONON#LASSIFYING&OREST'OODSAND 3ERVICESIN4HEORYFORESTSPRODUCEAVARIETYOFPRODUCTSSOMEOFWHICHAREMARKETED ANDTHEREFOREINCLUDEDIN'$0ANDOTHERSOFWHICHARENOT!SINTHEGENERALRESOURCE CASEDISCUSSEDIN#HAPTERTHESUPPLYANDUSETABLESCOULDBEUSEDTOORGANIZE INFORMATIONABOUTFLOWSOFFORESTPRODUCTS INPUTSANDOUTPUTSOFFOREST RELATED INDUSTRIESPUBLICEXPENDITURESTOMANAGEFORESTSANDSOON4HISWOULDBEUSEFUL FORSHOWINGTHEIMPORTANCEOFFOREST BASEDACTIVITYINTHEECONOMYASAWHOLE !GAINASINTHEGENERALRESOURCECASEDATAONNONMARKETEDPRODUCTSCOULDBE
ORGANIZEDINTHESAMEWAYASTHEMARKETEDmOWS4HE)%%!&RECOGNIZESTHEIMPOR TANCEOFTHESEmOWSBUTDOESNOTRECOMMENDINCLUDINGTHEMINTHEACCOUNTS3EV ERALREASONSAREOFFEREDFORTHISCHOICELACKOFESTABLISHEDVALUATIONMETHODSDIF lCULTYINTEGRATINGNONMARKETEDPRODUCTSWITHTHEMARKETEDPRODUCTDATAOFTHE 3.!ANDALACKOFADEQUATEPHYSICALDATA4HE)%%!&RECOMMENDSEXPERIMENTA TIONWITHVALUATIONOFSOMENONMARKETEDSERVICESNOTABLYCARBONSEQUESTRATION ANDRECREATIONASWELLASPHYSICALDESCRIPTIONOFTHESESERVICESALTHOUGHTHESUG
3TRUCTUREOFTHE&OREST
GESTEDFORMATSAREMUCHLESSDETAILEDTHANTHESTRUCTUREPROVIDEDBYTHESUPPLY ANDUSETABLE%UROSTATBn 4HE3%%!TAKESANEQUALLYLIMITEDAPPROACH TONONMARKETEDFORESTPRODUCTSASITDOESNOTEXPANDTHEDElNITIONOFAPRODUCT TOINCLUDEANYNONMARKETEDGOODSORSERVICES 4HE0ESKINAPPROACHNOTSURPRISINGLYRECOMMENDSINCLUSIONOFALLNONMAR
KETED FORESTPRODUCTS FORWHICHANYONE ISWILLING TOPAY 0ESKIN 4HIS IS
0ROJECT%.2!0 ACCOUNTSTHEFORESTCOMPONENTSOFWHICHAREDISCUSSEDLATERIN THISCHAPTER.ATURES.UMBERSGOESALONGWITHTHISAPPROACHINPRINCIPLEWHILE RECOGNIZINGTHEPRACTICALDATAANDVALUATIONPROBLEMSTHATDETERRED%UROSTATFROM MAKINGTHEATTEMPT.ORDHAUSAND+OKKELENBERG .ATURES.UMBERSIDENTIlESlVETYPESOFFORESTPRODUCTSTHATSHOULDBECOVERED
INTHEmOWACCOUNTS
N TIMBER N NEAR MARKETFORESTPRODUCTSGATHEREDGOODSTHATCOULDHAVEBEENPURCHASEDIN MARKETSSUCHASFUELWOODMUSHROOMSAND#HRISTMASTREES
N RECREATION
N ENVIRONMENTALSERVICESTHATAREUSEDBYINDUSTRYSUCHASWATERSHEDPROTECTION ANDWATERSUPPLYAND
N PUBLICGOODSSUCHASCARBONSEQUESTRATIONANDBIODIVERSITY
4HEVALUEOFENVIRONMENTALSERVICESUSEDBYINDUSTRYISCAPTUREDBYTHECON VENTIONALACCOUNTSBECAUSEIFTHEYWERENOTAVAILABLEWITHOUTCOSTFROMTHEENVI RONMENTTHENINTERMEDIATECONSUMPTIONWOULDBEHIGHERANDVALUEADDEDLOWER .ATURES.UMBERSRECOMMENDSTHATTHECONTRIBUTIONOFTHESESERVICESBEDISAGGRE GATEDINTHEFORESTmOWACCOUNTSSOTHATTHEIRVALUECANBEIDENTIlEDANDATTRIBUTED TOTHEFORESTS.ATURES.UMBERSn ALSORECOMMENDSTHATPUBLICGOODSBE QUANTIlEDANDVALUEDBECAUSEOFTHEIRIMPORTANCEFORPOLICYPURPOSESALTHOUGH THISISPARTICULARLYDIFlCULT
&ORESTS TYPICALLYAREDEFINED INONEOF THREEWAYS ,UND !DMINISTRATIVE DEFINITIONSAREBASEDONWHICHPUBLICAUTHORITYHAS JURISDICTIONOVERTHELAND FOREXAMPLEFORESTSCOULDBEDElNEDTOINCLUDEhALLLANDMANAGEDBYTHE&OREST $EPARTMENTv,ANDUSEDElNITIONSCATEGORIZELANDASFORESTBASEDONHOWITISOR COULDBEUSEDSUCHAShLANDTHATISSUITABLEFORWOODPRODUCTIONANDNOTUSEDFOR OTHERPURPOSESv,ANDCOVERDElNITIONSAREBASEDONTHEVEGETATIONITSELFSUCHAS hANECOSYSTEMCHARACTERIZEDBYDENSEANDEXTENSIVETREECOVERvORhANAREAATLEAST HECTARESWITHCROWNCOVERv &ORESTSDIFFERGREATLYAROUNDTHEWORLDANDTHEUSESOFFORESTDATAVARYWIDELY
4HEAPPROPRIATEDElNITIONOFAFORESTMAYTHEREFOREBEBOTHLOCATION ANDPURPOSE SPECIlC#ONCERNSABOUTDOMESTICORINTERNATIONALDATASHARINGARGUEFORASINGLE ACCEPTEDDEFINITIONOFAFORESTHOWEVERSOTHATFORESTSTATISTICSMEANTHESAME THINGINALLCONTEXTS'LOBALLYTHISMAYHAVEEVENMOREIMPORTANCEIFFORESTCON SERVATIONBECOMESASIGNIlCANTELEMENTINSTRATEGIESTOREDUCEGLOBALWARMINGAND MEETTARGETSUNDERTHE+YOTO0ROTOCOL)NTHISCASECOUNTRIESWOULDWANTTHEIRFOR ESTACCOUNTSTOADOPTTHEINTERNATIONALLYSTANDARDIZEDFORESTDElNITIONSOTHATTHE DATACOULDBEUSEDTOANALYZETHEROLEOFFORESTINNATIONALCOMPLIANCESTRATEGIES.O SINGLEACCEPTEDSTANDARDDElNITIONOFAFORESTEXISTSFORTHISPURPOSEHOWEVER 4HE3%%!AND)%%!&DElNEFORESTQUITEBROADLYTOINCLUDELANDWITHTREECROWN
COVEROFMORETHANANDAREAMORETHANHECTARESYOUNGNATURALSTANDSAND
THATAREUNFORESTEDBECAUSEOFHUMANINTERVENTIONBUTAREEXPECTEDTOREVERTTO TREECOVER%UROSTATBn5.ETALPARAGRAPHSn
-OSTFORESTACCOUNTINGSYSTEMSAREMUCHMORELIMITEDINSCOPETHANTHEFULLLISTS OFFORESTGOODSANDSERVICESSUGGESTEDEARLIER4YPICALLYTHEYINCLUDETIMBERMAR KETED.4&0SSUCHASRATTANORCORKANDRECREATION!SIMPLIFYINGASSUMPTIONIS OFTENMADETHATEACHAREAOFFORESTISUSEDEITHERFORCOMMERCIALPURPOSESORFOR RECREATIONBUTNOTFORBOTH!REASALLOCATEDTORECREATIONˆWHICHTYPICALLYINCLUDE ALLPROTECTEDAREASˆAREASSIGNEDNOCOMMERCIALVALUEASPROVIDERSOFOTHERGOODS ORSERVICES4HESESIMPLIlCATIONSAVOIDTHENEEDTOCONSIDERCHOICESAMONGFOREST USESINASSETVALUATIONORTOQUANTIFYRELATIVELYAMORPHOUSSERVICESSUCHASHABITAT ORWATERSHEDPROTECTION 4HECONVENTIONAL3.!ADDRESSESONLYASMALLSUBSETOFFOREST BASEDGOODSAND
SERVICES)NTHE3.!ANASSETMUSTBEOWNEDANDITSOWNERMUSTBEABLETODERIVE ECONOMICBENElTFROMHOLDINGORUSINGIT4HE3.!THENDISTINGUISHESBETWEEN MANUFACTUREDASSETSWHICHITTERMShPRODUCEDECONOMICASSETSvANDNATURALLY OCCURRINGONESCALLEDhNONPRODUCEDECONOMICASSETSv#ULTIVATEDORPLANTATION FORESTSARECATEGORIZEDASPRODUCEDECONOMICASSETSNONCULTIVATEDORNATURALLY GROWINGFORESTSARENONPRODUCEDECONOMICASSETS4HEREQUIREMENTTHATTHEASSET BEOWNEDISRELATIVELYSTRAIGHTFORWARDFORFORESTSASINMOSTCASESTHEYAREOWNED EITHERBYPRIVATEENTITIESORBYTHEGOVERNMENT4HEREQUIREMENTTHATTHEOWNERBE ABLETODERIVEECONOMICBENElTFROMOWNERSHIPRULESOUTFORESTGOODSANDSERVICES THATARENOTMARKETEDHOWEVER 4HE3%%!EXPANSIONOFTHE3.!ASSETBOUNDARYRELAXESTHEREQUIREMENTTHATTHE
ASSETBEOWNEDBUTNOTTHEREQUIREMENTTHATITBEPOSSIBLETODERIVEECONOMICBEN ElTFROMIT&ORFORESTSTHISEXPANDSTHECATEGORYOFNONPRODUCEDECONOMICASSETS TOINCLUDEFORESTSTHATARENOTOWNEDBUTITDOESNOTCOVERFORESTSTHATAREOWNED 4HESENONMARKETEDGOODSANDSERVICESAREhECONOMICvASECONOMISTSWOULDUSE THETERMINTHATTHEYARESCARCEANDPEOPLEWOULDBEWILLINGTOPAYFORTHEMIFTHEY HADTO"UTBOTHTHE3.!ANDTHE3%%!USEhECONOMICvMORERESTRICTIVELYREFER RINGONLYTOTHOSEITEMSTHATAREBOUGHTANDSOLDORTHATAREBOTHSOLDINMARKETS ANDGATHERED4HEREFORENONMARKETEDFORESTGOODSANDSERVICESARENOTCAPTURED BYTHE3.!ORTHE3%%! 4ABLE SHOWSHOWFORESTSARECLASSIlEDINTHE3%%!ANDTHE%UROPEAN)%%!&
)NDIVIDUALCOUNTRIESMAYVARYTHISSOMEWHAT&OREXAMPLECOUNTRIESWHEREALL NATURALNONPLANTATION FORESTISINPROTECTEDAREASMAYRESTRUCTURETHEPRESENTA TIONSOTHATAVAILABILITYFORWOODSUPPLYISASUBCATEGORYWITHINCULTIVATEDFOREST
!LTHOUGHTHEDISTINCTIONBETWEENMANAGEDANDNATURALORCULTIVATEDANDNONCUL TIVATED FORESTSMAYSEEMSELF EVIDENTINFACTITISBOTHTRICKYANDIMPORTANT/LD GROWTHFORESTSTHATHAVENEVERBEENCUTCLEARLYARENATURALFORESTSANDPLANTATIONS
CLEARLYARECULTIVATED4HECLASSIlCATIONOFSECOND GROWTHFORESTSTHATGREWNATU RALLYAFTERAREASWERELOGGEDORCLEAR CUTISLESSOBVIOUSHOWEVER4HE3.!DElNES CULTIVATEDASSETSASTHOSEhYIELDINGREPEATPRODUCTSTHATAREUNDERTHEDIRECTCON TROLRESPONSIBILITYANDMANAGEMENTOFINSTITUTIONALUNITSv#%#ETAL 4HE%UROPEAN4EMPERATEAND"OREAL&OREST2ESOURCE!SSESSMENTDElNESTHEMAS AREAShMANAGEDINACCORDANCEWITHAFORMALORANINFORMALPLANAPPLIEDREGULARLY OVERASUFlCIENTLYLONGPERIODlVEYEARSORMORE v%UROSTATB 4HEREVISED 3%%!DElNESSEMINATURALMANAGEDFORESTSASTHOSEINWHICHhMANAGEMENTHAS SUBSTANTIALLYALTEREDTHESTRUCTUREANDECOLOGICALPROCESSESBUTINWHICHGROWTHIS STILLMAINLYANATURALPROCESSWITHNOREGULARANDCONTINUOUSHUMANINTERVENTIONv 5.ETALPARAGRAPH )NPRACTICEMANYCOUNTRIESHAVECHOSENTOCONSIDERALLOFTHEIRECONOMICALLY
PRODUCTIVEFORESTSASMANAGEDASSETS4HE%UROPEAN5NIONCOUNTRIESHAVEDONE THISINTHEIR)%%!&FRAMEWORK4HEONLYFORESTSNOTCONSIDEREDTOBECULTIVATEDARE THOSEINPROTECTEDAREASWHICHHAVENOVALUEASASOURCEOFWOOD)NOTHERCOUN TRIESSUCHASTHE0HILIPPINESTHERECLEARLYARENONCULTIVATEDFORESTSTHATARENOT MANAGEDBYPEOPLE(ERETIGHTREGULATIONSPREVENTORAREINTENDEDTOPREVENT THEIRHARVEST4HE0HILIPPINEFORESTACCOUNTSASSUMETHATNOCUTTINGTAKESPLACEIN THOSEFORESTS!LLFORESTSTHATHAVEBEENLOGGEDATLEASTONCEARECONSIDEREDTOBE MANAGEDFORESTS 4HISDISTINCTIONISIMPORTANTBECAUSEASDISCUSSEDIN#HAPTERITAFFECTSTHE
CALCULATIONOF'$0AND.$0#ULTIVATEDFORESTS LIKEOTHERCULTIVATEDBIOLOGICAL ASSETSSUCHASAGRICULTURALCROPS ARECOUNTEDINTHESAMEWAYASOTHERINVEST MENTSINPRODUCEDASSETS#ONSEQUENTLYTHEIRGROWTHISCOUNTEDASPARTOFOUTPUT INTHECURRENTACCOUNTSANDISINCLUDEDIN'$0CALCULATIONS)NCONTRASTTHEGROWTH OFNONCULTIVATEDBIOLOGICALASSETSISNOTCONSIDEREDTOBETHERESULTOFHUMANACTIV ITYANDISNOTINCLUDEDIN'$04HEDECISIONOFWHERETOCLASSIFYFORESTSANDTHE
3%%!)%%!&&OREST #LASSIFICATION
PLANTEDBYPEOPLETHEREFOREAFFECTSTHECALCULATIONOF'$0ANDMUSTBESTANDARD IZEDFORFORESTACCOUNTINGDATATOBECOMPARABLEINTERNATIONALLY
#HAPTERPROVIDEDAGENERALOVERVIEWOFTHREEMETHODSOFVALUINGRESOURCEASSETS THENETPRESENTVALUEMETHODTHENETPRICEMETHODANDTHE%L3ERAFYMETHOD4HE NETPRESENTVALUEANDNETPRICEMETHODSAREAPPLICABLETOFORESTRESOURCESWHEREAS THE%L3ERAFYMETHODWHICHISINTENDEDFORNONRENEWABLESFORTHEMOSTPARTISNOT
"OTHECONOMICTHEORYANDTHE3.!DICTATETHATFORESTSSHOULDBEVALUEDBASEDON THEIRCURRENTMARKETPRICE)FTHATISDIFlCULTTOOBSERVETHEYMAYBEVALUEDBASED ONTHEMARKETPRICESOFSIMILARASSETSTHATAREEASIERTOOBSERVE)NTHEABSENCEOF THOSEDATAORWHERETHERETURNSTOTHEASSETARERECEIVEDOVERALONGPERIODOFTIME THEASSETMAYBEVALUEDBASEDONNETPRESENTVALUEOFTHEEXPECTEDINCOMESTREAM OVERITSLIFETIME#%#ETALPARAGRAPH )NTHEREALWORLDOUTSIDEOFBOTHECONOMICTHEORYANDTHE3.!ACTUALMARKET
TRANSACTIONSFORFORESTSAREUNCOMMONSOOBSERVINGTHECURRENTMARKETPRICEIS RARELYFEASIBLE4HESALESTHATDOOCCURTYPICALLYAREOFSEVERALTYPES)NSOMECASES LANDANDTHEVEGETATIONONITARESOLDTOGETHERWITHNODISTINCTIONBETWEENTHE VALUEOFTHELANDANDTHEVALUEOFTHETREES)NOTHERCASESTHERIGHTTOHARVESTTHE TREESISSOLDTOALOGGINGCOMPANY4HESALEPRICEINTHISCASEISTERMEDTHESTUMP AGEPRICE!THIRDOBSERVEDPRICEISTHEVALUEOFTHETREESAFTERTHEYHAVEBEENCUT THESO CALLED FELLINGPRICE4HE FELLINGPRICE IS READILYOBSERVED )T IS RELATEDTO STUMPAGEPRICEBYTHEFOLLOWINGFORMULA
STUMPAGEPRICEFELLINGPRICEnCOSTSOFCUTTINGTHETREESINCLUDING RETURNONINVESTMENTORlXEDCAPITAL
)NTHEABSENCEOFGOODMARKETDATAONTHEPRICEOFFORESTASSETSTHEYSHOULDBE VALUEDASTHESUMOFTHEDISCOUNTEDFUTUREEARNINGSSTREAMFROMTHEFORESTASTHIS APPROXIMATESWHATARATIONALINVESTORMIGHTBEWILLINGTOSPENDONTHEFOREST4HIS REQUIRESACCESSTOARANGEOFDATAANDCOEFlCIENTS
N QUANTITYOFWOODTHATCANBEHARVESTEDEACHYEAR N PRICETHATWILLBEPAIDFORTHEHARVESTEACHYEAR N INPUTCOSTSTOTHELOGGERWHICHINCLUDESCOSTSOFFELLINGTHELOGSAND N ASUITABLEDISCOUNTRATEFORCALCULATINGTHEPRESENTVALUEOFTHEINCOMESTREAM
.ONEOFTHESEDATAAREEASYTOOBTAIN4HEQUANTITYOFTHEWOODMAYBEESTI MATEDBASEDONTHECURRENTAGESTRUCTUREANDSPECIESCOMPOSITIONOFTHEFOREST COMBINEDWITHKNOWLEDGEOFTHEGROWINGCYCLEOFEACHSPECIES$ATAONTHECURRENT AGESTRUCTUREANDSPECIESCOMPOSITIONOFTHEFORESTARECOLLECTEDINFORESTINVENTO RIESWHICHARECOSTLYANDUSUALLYINFREQUENT)NTHEABSENCEOFCURRENTINVENTORY
AREAVAILABLE!LTHOUGHTHESEMAYBETHEBESTDATAAVAILABLETHEYARENECESSARILY INEXACT%STIMATINGFUTUREPRICESORPRODUCTIONCOSTSISALSODIFlCULTESPECIALLYAS WOODPRICESVARYWIDELYWITHUNRELATEDANDLARGELYUNPREDICTABLEMARKETCHANGES 4HESALEPRICELESSTHEINPUTCOSTSTOTHELOGGERGIVESTHESTUMPAGEPRICEORNET PRICEOFTHEFOREST4HISISTHEINCOMEEARNEDBYTHELOGGEREACHYEAR#HOOSINGA DISCOUNTRATEISALSOFRAUGHTWITHUNCERTAINTYANDTHERESULTSAREVERYSENSITIVETO SMALLCHANGESINTHERATECHOSEN
)NRESPONSETOTHEDIFlCULTIESOFESTIMATINGNETPRESENTVALUEMANYACCOUNTING PROJECTSCHOOSETOAPPLYTHENETPRICEMETHODINSTEAD&OLLOWINGTHISAPPROACH THEVALUEOFTHEFORESTISSIMPLYTHENETPRICEORSTUMPAGEPRICE PERHECTARETIMES THEAREAOFFOREST4HENETPRICEMETHODISEQUIVALENTTOTHENETPRESENTVALUEIF THEDISCOUNTRATEISTHESAMEASTHENATURALGROWTHRATEOFTIMBER!LTHOUGHTHIS ISOFTENNOTTHECASEINPRACTICEMANYPROJECTSUSETHISMETHODANYWAYBECAUSE THEDATAREQUIREMENTSARESOMUCHSIMPLER4HEMAJORPRACTICALISSUEISOBTAINING THESTUMPAGEPRICE7HEREACTUALTRANSACTIONSDATAAREAVAILABLETHISISSTRAIGHTFOR WARDHOWEVERINPRACTICEITISUSUALLYNECESSARYTOESTIMATETHESTUMPAGEPRICE BASEDONACTUALSALESDATAFORLOGSANDESTIMATESOFTHECOSTOFFELLINGANDTRANS PORTINGTHEM
!LTHOUGHTHE%L3ERAFYMETHODISINTENDEDFORANALYSISOFNONRENEWABLERESOURCES ONEMAYARGUETHATITMAYBEAPPROPRIATETOUSETHISAPPROACHTOVALUETHEUSEOF OLD GROWTHFORESTS#OUNTRIESTHATSTILLHAVEOLD GROWTHFORESTTYPICALLYRECLASSIFYIT FROMOLD GROWTHTOSECOND GROWTHONCEANYLOGGINGHASOCCURREDTHERE4HUSINA SENSETHEOLD GROWTHFORESTISANONRENEWABLERESOURCEBECAUSEONCEITISUSEDAT ALLITNOLONGEREXISTS3UCHFORESTSERVICESASPROVIDINGHABITATFORBIODIVERSITYMAY INFACTBELARGELYLOSTIFANYLOGGINGISCARRIEDOUTINTHEOLD GROWTHFORESTANDTHEY ARETHEREFORENONRENEWABLE)FTHEACCOUNTSFACTORINTHESEKINDSOFSERVICESTHENIT WOULDBEAPPROPRIATETOUSETHE%L3ERAFYMETHODTOVALUETHEIRDEPRECIATION
4HEFOLLOWINGCASESINWHICHFORESTACCOUNTINGHASBEENUSEDILLUSTRATETHECON CEPTSDISCUSSEDINTHISCHAPTER
4HE%UROPEAN&RAMEWORKFOR)NTEGRATED%CONOMICAND%NVIRONMENTAL!CCOUNTING FOR&ORESTSOR)%%!&WASDEVELOPEDBY%UROSTATATTHEDIRECTIONOFTHE%UROPEAN #OMMISSION&OURCOUNTRIESˆ&RANCE'ERMANY3WEDENAND&INLANDˆFORMED THE%UROSTAT4ASK&ORCEON&OREST!CCOUNTINGWHICHDEVELOPEDANDTESTEDMETH ODSFORFORESTACCOUNTING4HETASKFORCEWASPARTICULARLYINTERESTEDINASSESSINGTHE
INTRACKINGTHECONSISTENCYOFTHESYSTEMWITHTHE%UROPEAN3YSTEMOF!CCOUNTS THE3.!ANDTHE3%%!%UROSTATC !LLFOURCOUNTRIESMODIlEDTHE)%%!&FORESTCLASSIlCATIONPRESENTEDIN4ABLE
7ITHINTHECATEGORYOFFORESTSAVAILABLEFORWOODONLY'ERMANYFELTTHATNATU RALFORESTSWASAUSEFULCLASSIlCATIONNONEOFTHEOTHERCOUNTRIESHADANYNATURAL FORESTSTHATCOULDBEUSEDFORWOOD)N&RANCEALLFORESTSNOTUSEDFORWOODWEREIN PROTECTEDAREAS3WEDENAND&INLANDALSOHADFORESTEDLANDTHATCOULDNOTBEHAR VESTEDECONOMICALLYBECAUSEITWASTOOREMOTETHESEFORESTSTHEREFOREWERECON SIDEREDUNAVAILABLE 4HESECHANGESLEDTHETASKFORCETOSUGGESTANALTERNATECLASSIlCATION&OREST
AVAILABLEFORWOODSUPPLYISDISAGGREGATEDINTOTHATWHICHISREGULARLYMANAGED ANDTHATWHICHHASBEENLEFTUNTENDEDFORALONGPERIODSUCHASYEARS'ROWTH OFTHEFORMERISCONSIDEREDTOBETHERESULTOFHUMANINTERVENTIONANDGROWTHOF THELATTERTOBENONPRODUCED 4HE )%%!& INCLUDES BOTH PHYSICAL ANDMONETARY ACCOUNTS 4HE PHYSICAL
ACCOUNTSCOVERSTOCKSANDmOWSOFWOODEDLANDBYAREA ANDTIMBERBYVOLUME %ACHCOUNTRYCOMPILEDASSETACCOUNTSFORTWOTIMEPERIODSLOOKINGATTHECHANGES INAREAANDVOLUMEACROSSTHEPERIODANDDISAGGREGATINGTHEMACCORDINGTOCAUSES OFCHANGE4HEDATACAMEFROMNATIONALFORESTINVENTORIES3UCHINVENTORIESGENER ALLYAREINTERMITTENTHOWEVERANDINVOLVEMUCHESTIMATION$ATAONCHANGESIN STOCKASARESULTOFDIRECTHUMANINTERVENTIONˆTREEFELLINGSANDAFFORESTATIONˆARE USUALLYAVAILABLEANNUALLYBUTDATAONNATURALGROWTHAREESTIMATED)NTHEYEARS BETWEENFORESTINVENTORIESSTOCKDATAIFAVAILABLEATALL AREESTIMATEDBASEDON ACTUALDATAFROMTHELASTINVENTORYACTUALDATAONHUMANINTERVENTIONSANDESTI MATESOFNATURALGROWTHANDOTHERNATURALCHANGES7HENTHENEXTINVENTORYIS CONDUCTEDTHENEWSTOCKlGUREREPLACESTHEESTIMATESANDASTATISTICALDISCREP ANCYlGUREMAYBEINTRODUCEDTOMOVEFROMTHEOLDESTIMATEDTIMESERIESTOTHE NEWOBSERVEDVALUE !STHESUMMARYDATAIN4ABLE SUGGESTFORESTVOLUMESHAVEGROWNSLOWLYIN
THEPERIODOFTHElRSTPILOTCOMPILATIONWHILEFORESTEDAREASHAVEREMAINEDALMOST CONSTANT$EFORESTATIONASARESULTOFTHEEXPANSIONOFURBANAREASHASBEENMORE THANOFFSETBYEXPANSIONOFFORESTSINTOFORMERLYAGRICULTURALAREASANDSOMESIG NIlCANTINCREASESHAVEOCCURREDINPROTECTEDAREAS 4HEPHYSICALACCOUNTSALSOATTEMPTTOGATHERDATAABOUTTHEQUALITYOFTHEFOREST
THROUGHCLASSESINDICATINGTHEDEGREEOFDEFOLIATION4HISISANEFFORTTOCAPTURETHE IMPACTOFACIDRAINONFORESTQUALITYINORDERTOMEASUREDEPRECIATIONOFTHEASSET DUETOEXTERNALITIESFROMHUMANACTIVITY3OFARTHISEFFORTHASBEENUNSUCCESSFUL THOUGHTHETASKFORCEISINTERESTEDINWAYSTOLINKTHISINFORMATIONTOTHEMONETARY ACCOUNTSTOUNDERSTANDTHEECONOMICIMPACTOFDECREASEDFORESTQUALITY%UROSTAT C 4HEMONETARYACCOUNTSBUILDONTHEPHYSICALACCOUNTINGDATA4HElRSTSTEP
ISTOSEPARATETHEVALUEOFLANDFROMTHEVALUEOFTHETIMBERSTANDINGONIT%ACH COUNTRYHASITSOWNMETHODFORDOINGTHIS4HE3WEDESUSEDFORESTSALESDATA TOESTABLISHASTANDARDRATIOOFLANDVALUETOTOTALREALESTATEVALUEOF4HEYAPPLY THISTOTHEENTIREAREAOFFORESTLAND4HE&INNISHACCOUNTSVALUEFORESTLANDBASED ONTHERECOMMENDATIONSOFTHE.ATIONAL"OARDOF3URVEYANDTHE&INNISH&OREST 2ESEARCH)NSTITUTEWHICHINTURNAREBASEDONPREDICTEDGROWTHSPECIESMIXLOG
GINGPATTERNSSTUMPAGEPRICESANDPRODUCTIONCOSTS4HE'ERMANSAPPLYCOEFl CIENTSFROMAHEDONICPRICEMODELFORFORESTREALESTATEIN,OWER3AXONYTODETER MINETHESHAREOFLANDINTHETOTALPRICE4HE&RENCHDATAAREBASEDONASURVEYOF THElSCALDEPARTMENTSFROMWHICHTHEYDERIVEASINGLEAVERAGEVALUEPERHECTARE FORTHEENTIRE&RENCHFORESTAREA4HE3WEDISHAND&INNISHACCOUNTSADDRESSONLY LANDAVAILABLEFORTIMBER&RANCEAND'ERMANYINCLUDELANDNOTAVAILABLEFORTIM BERPROTECTEDAREAS ASWELL 4HENEXTSTEPISTOVALUESTANDINGTIMBERANDITSDEPRECIATION3WEDEN&IN
LANDAND&RANCEALLUSESOMEFORMOFTHENETPRICEMETHODMULTIPLYINGESTIMATED STUMPAGEPRICEBYTHEVOLUMEOFTIMBER'ERMANYRELIESONTHESAMEHEDONICPRICE MODELCALIBRATEDIN,OWER3AXONYAPPLYINGTHOSEDATATOFORESTSNATIONWIDE.ONE OFTHECOUNTRIESVALUESTANDINGTIMBERTHATISNOTAVAILABLEFORWOODSUPPLY 4HEMONETARYACCOUNTSREVEALCONSIDERABLEVARIATIONINFORESTVALUESFROMCOUN
TRYTOCOUNTRYASSUGGESTEDBY4ABLE 4HEEXTENTTOWHICHTHISVARIATIONISDUE TOTHEDIFFERENTACCOUNTINGMETHODOLOGIESUSEDBYTHEFOURCOUNTRIESRATHERTHAN TOACTUALDIFFERENCESINFORESTVALUEISNOTCLEAR3EVERALMETHODOLOGICALCONCERNS COULDCONTRIBUTETOTHEWIDEVARIATION&EWACTUALFORESTLANDTRANSACTIONSAREAVAIL ABLEWITHWHICHTODISTINGUISHLANDFROMTIMBERVALUEANDTHOSETHATAREAVAILABLE MAYNOTREPRESENTTHEFORESTASAWHOLE4HUSALTHOUGHTHEHIGHER'ERMANGROWTH RATEMAYINPARTEXPLAINTHATCOUNTRYSHIGHERFORESTVALUETHE,OWER3AXONYFORESTS ONWHICHITISBASEDMAYNOTACCURATELYREPRESENT'ERMANFORESTSASAWHOLE)NTHE OTHERCOUNTRIESTHESTUMPAGEPRICESUSEDTOVALUETIMBERAREBASEDONMATUREFOR ESTSANDDONOTGIVETHEACTUALVALUEOFMIXED AGESTANDINGFORESTS )NADDITIONTOBUILDINGFORESTASSETACCOUNTSTHE)%%!&ALSODISAGGREGATESDATA
ONTHEFORESTRYANDLOGGINGSECTORSFROMTHE3.!USINGTHESUPPLYANDUSETABLE FRAMEWORK4HEMONETARYACCOUNTS TRACKOUTPUTOFDIFFERENT FORESTPRODUCTS
3UMMARY0HYSICAL !CCOUNTS$ATA)%%!& 0ILOT#OMPILATION
INTERMEDIATECONSUMPTIONGROSSVALUEADDEDGROSSCAPITALFORMATIONANDPUB LIClNANCINGOFTHEFORESTINDUSTRIES4HEPHYSICALSUPPLYANDUSETABLESPRESENT DATAONHOWEACHOUTPUTOFTHEFORESTRYSECTORISUSEDBYVARIOUSFORESTPRODUCT INDUSTRIESINCLUDINGLOGGINGSAWINGPULPANDPAPER4HEYALSOSHOWEXPORTSAND IMPORTSCAPITALFORMATIONlNALCONSUMPTIONANDSOON 4HE)%%!&PILOTAPPLICATIONSCOVERONLYFORESTISSUESTHATAREALREADYINCLUDEDIN
THECONVENTIONAL3.!4HEYDONOTTOUCHONANYNONMARKETEDGOODSANDSERVICES NORARETHEYABLETOESTIMATEDEPRECIATIONOFFORESTRESOURCESBECAUSEOFPOLLUTION 4HE#ANADIANSDORECOGNIZETHATSUCHINFORMATIONWOULDBEUSEFULBUTINLIGHTOF THEPRACTICALDIFlCULTIESTHEYCHOOSETOBEGINWITHTHERELATIVELY SIMPLERACCOUNTS FORMARKETEDPRODUCTS4HERESULTSOFFERAUSEFUL ILLUSTRATIONOF THECOMPLEXITY INVOLVEDINACTUALLYBUILDINGFORESTACCOUNTSTHATCANMEANINGFULLYBECOMPARED ACROSSCOUNTRIES
4WOENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTINGPROJECTSHAVEBEENCARRIEDOUTINTHE0HILIPPINES &ORESTSAREAKEYELEMENTOFTHE0HILIPPINEECONOMYANDENVIRONMENTSOBOTH PROJECTSGAVETHISAREAHIGHPRIORITYFROMTHESTART4HE53!)$ FUNDED%.2!0TOOK ANECONOMICAPPROACHTHE5. FUNDEDPROJECTIMPLEMENTEDTHEAPPROACHOFTHE 3%%!CALLINGITSSYSTEMTHE0HILIPPINE3%%!OR03%%! $ESPITETHEIRDIFFER ENCESINFUNDAMENTALPHILOSOPHYTHETWOPROJECTSHAVEMANYSIMILARITIES"OTH SYSTEMSBUILTACCOUNTSFORDIPTEROCARPFORESTSTHE!SIANTROPICALHARDWOODFORESTS FORWHICHTHEREGIONISKNOWNWHICHCOMPOSEABOUTOFTHECOUNTRYSFORESTED AREA%.2!0 "OTHPROJECTSLOOKEDATPINEFORESTSANDRATTAN%.2!0ALSO CONSIDEREDMANGROVESPLANTATIONFORESTSBAMBOOANDVALUATIONOFPROTECTED AREASANDWILDLIFE)TWORKEDONTHEWOODPRODUCTSINDUSTRYASWELLBUTTHATSTUDY FOCUSEDONPOLLUTIONRATHER THANRESOURCEUSE4HE03%%!BUILTPHYSICALAND MONETARYASSETACCOUNTSBUTDIDNOTLINKTHISWORKTOTHECURRENTACCOUNTS.3#" %.2!0WENTBEYONDTHEASSETACCOUNTSTOINTEGRATECONSUMPTIONOFSOME NONMARKETEDFORESTPRODUCTSANDFORESTDEPRECIATIONINTOTHECURRENTACCOUNT USINGTHE0ESKINACCOUNTINGSTRUCTURE4HEOVERALL0ESKINFRAMEWORKISPRESENTED IN#HAPTER 4HE0HILIPPINEFORESTSARECATEGORIZEDBYSPECIESFORACCOUNTINGPURPOSES$IP
TEROCARPSPINESMANGROVESPLANTATIONSANDBAMBOOARESPATIALLYSEPARATEDAND CANBEQUANTIlEDBOTHBYAREAANDBYVOLUMERATTANOCCURSWITHINOLD GROWTHFOR ESTSANDTHEREFOREISMEASUREDONLYBYVOLUME$IPTEROCARPSAREDIVIDEDINTOOLD
6ALUEOF&ORESTS
SECOND GROWTHFORESTSSHOWSIGNSOFHAVINGBEENLOGGEDINTHEPAST)NTHE GOVERNMENTIMPOSEDABANONALLLOGGINGINOLD GROWTHFORESTSANDBOTHSETSOF ACCOUNTSASSUMETHATTHEBANISFULLYENFORCEDALTHOUGHBOTHRECOGNIZETHATTHIS ISPROBABLYNOTTHECASE "OTHSETSOFPHYSICALACCOUNTSAREBASEDONTHESAME UNDERLYINGDATAFROMFORESTINVENTORIESINANDANDBOTHUSETHESAME PARAMETERSANDCOEFlCIENTSTOESTIMATENATURALGROWTHTHEEXTENTOFDESTRUCTION CAUSEDBYLOGGINGACTIVITYANDOTHERKEYTRENDS 4HE%.2!0DIPTEROCARPREPORTSSHOWDATAFROMTOTHE03%%!REPORT
SHOWSDATAFROMTO3ECOND GROWTHFORESTAREASINCREASEDSTEADILYFROM UNTILTHEMID SANDTHENBEGANTODECLINETHROUGH"ALANGUE n /LD GROWTHFORESTDECLINEDSTEADILYUPTOAFTERWHICHTHEACCOUNTS SHOWITHOLDINGSTEADYASTHEYASSUMETHATTHELOGGINGBANISINEFFECT!REASAND VOLUMEFORMANGROVESPINEANDRATTANALSOAREDECREASINGOVERTHETIMEPERIOD $ATAONBAMBOOARETOOSCATTEREDTOGIVEACLEARPICTURE 4HEPROJECTSDIFFERINTHEIRMONETARYACCOUNTS4HE03%%!USESTHENETPRICE
METHODTOVALUEFORESTRESOURCESTOCKSMULTIPLYINGSTUMPAGEVALUEBYTHEPHYSICAL DATAONOPENINGSTOCKSTOOBTAINOPENINGVALUESFORTHEASSETACCOUNTS4HESTUMP AGEVALUESFORDIPTEROCARPSWEREDERIVEDFROMASTUDYBYTHE&OREST-ANAGE MENT"UREAUOFTHE$EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAND.ATURAL2ESOURCES$%.2 UPDATEDTOREmECTCHANGESINLOGPRICES03%%!STUMPAGEVALUESFORPINECAME FROM%.2!0ANDTHOSEFORRATTANCAMEFROMAMARKETINGSTUDY4HERESULTS SHOWSTOCKSOFDIPTEROCARPSRATTANANDPINEDECREASINGINVALUEBETWEEN AND.3#" 4HE03%%!DISCUSSIONOFTHEDATAANDITSASSOCIATEDANALYSISOFPHYSICALAND
MONETARYCHANGESINTHEFORESTSHIGHLIGHTTHEDEPLETIONDUETOHARVESTINGWITHOUT INCLUDINGANYNATURALGROWTHTHATMIGHTCOUNTERTHATDEPLETION)NTHECONTEXTOF THEEARLIERDISCUSSIONABOUTMANAGEDVERSUSNATURALFORESTSTHISEXCLUSIONOFFOREST GROWTHIMPLIESTHATTHE03%%!ASSETACCOUNTSDONOTCONSIDERANYGROWTHTOBETHE RESULTOFHUMANMANAGEMENT4HEYDONOTEXPLICITLYADDRESSTHISQUESTION)NAFULL ACCOUNTINGSYSTEMTHISISSUEWOULDDETERMINEWHICHVALUESHOULDBETRANSFERRED FROMTHEASSETACCOUNTTOTHECURRENTACCOUNTASDEPRECIATION4HE03%%!DOES NOTINCLUDECURRENTACCOUNTSHOWEVERSOITISNOTCLEARWHETHERTHEYWOULDHAVE INCLUDEDNATURALGROWTHOFTHEFORESTINECONOMICGROWTHCALCULATIONS %.2!0USESTHENETPRESENTVALUEMETHODTOESTIMATETHEVALUEOFTHESTOCKS
5NFORTUNATELYBECAUSEOFTHEDIFFERENCESINTIMEPERIODCOVEREDANDMETHODOLOGI CALDIFFERENCESUNRELATEDTOTHECALCULATIONOFDEPRECIATIONITISDIFlCULTTOCOM PARETHEDATAFROMTHETWOPROJECTSDIRECTLY!NANALYTICALPAPERBY0ESKINAND DELOS!NGELES ADDRESSESTHISISSUEHOWEVERCOMPARINGTHE0ESKINAND3%%! APPROACHESUSING%.2!0DATA4HEAUTHORSUSETHE%.2!0DATATOCALCULATESTOCK VALUESDEPRECIATIONANDADJUSTEDMACROECONOMICINDICATORSUSINGAVARIETYOF METHODSSOTHATTHEDIFFERENCESINMETHODSMAYBESEENINDEPENDENTLYOFOTHER DIFFERENCESINHOWTHEUNDERLYINGDATAWEREMANIPULATED 4ABLE SHOWSTHERESULTSOFTHISANALYSISFORCHANGESINVALUETHATOCCURREDIN
)THIGHLIGHTSTHEDIFFERENCESBOTHBETWEENTHENETPRICEANDNETPRESENTVALUE METHODSANDBETWEENTHEDEPLETIONMEASURESASCALCULATEDINTHE03%%!ANDECO NOMICDEPRECIATIONASCALCULATEDBY%.2!04HEDIPTEROCARPCOMPARISONSSHOW THATECONOMICDEPRECIATIONTHE%.2!0APPROACH APPEARSTOBEMUCHHIGHER
WHENESTIMATEDUSINGTHENETPRICEMETHODTHANWHENBASEDONNETPRESENTVALUE 4HISISBECAUSETHENETPRESENTVALUEMETHODISBASEDONACTUALASSESSMENTSOFTHE OPTIMALMANAGEMENTPATTERNANDOFFACTORSTHATMAYINmUENCEHARVESTRATES)N CONTRASTTHENETPRICEMETHODSIMPLYASSUMESTHATCURRENTREVENUEANDCOSTSTRUC TUREWILLAPPLYFORHARVESTINGOFALLWOOD&ORALLFORESTRESOURCESCOMBINEDTHE 03%%!lGUREISHIGHERTHANTHE%.2!0ONEBECAUSE03%%!INCLUDESONLYDEPLETION DUETOHUMANACTIVITYWHEREAS%.2!0BALANCESTHATAGAINSTNATURALGROWTH4HUS THE%.2!0lGURESHOWSTHEDIFFERENCEBETWEENFORESTCONSUMPTIONANDGROWTH WHEREASTHE03%%!lGURESHOWSONLYFORESTCONSUMPTION 4HISDISTINCTIONWASOFSOMEIMPORTANCETOPOLICYMAKERSINTHE0HILIPPINES4HE
$%.2ISRESPONSIBLEFORSUSTAINABLEMANAGEMENTOFTHECOUNTRYSFORESTRESOURCES !LTHOUGH$%.2OFlCIALSOFTENWERENOTFULLYAWAREOFTHEMETHODOLOGICALDIFFERENCES UNDERLYINGTHE%.2!0AND03%%!lGURESTHEYOBSERVEDTHAT%.2!0SHOWEDFOREST DEPRECIATIONTOBEMUCHLOWERTHAN03%%!4HELOWERTHEDEPRECIATIONlGURETHE BETTER$%.2APPEAREDTOBEDOINGITSJOB4HEREFOREPUBLICOFlCIALSEXPRESSEDAPREF ERENCEFOR%.2!0OVER03%%!lGURESIFTHEYCOULDMAKETHECHOICE(ECHT
4HE#ANADIANFORESTRESOURCEACCOUNTSCOVERPHYSICALANDMONETARYASPECTSOF ACCESSIBLETIMBER PRODUCTIVENONRESERVEDFORESTLAND-UCHOF#ANADASFOREST LANDISNOTEASILYACCESSIBLEBECAUSEITISINROADLESSAREASINTHEFARNORTH#ONSE QUENTLYTHEACCOUNTSCOVERONLYABOUTOFTHECOUNTRYSTOTALFORESTAREAOF MILLIONHECTARES3TATISTICS#ANADAA 3TATISTICS#ANADAWHICHCOMPILES THEACCOUNTSRECOGNIZESTHEGROWINGIMPORTANCEOFTRACKINGECOSYSTEMMANAGE MENTANDFORESTHEALTHTHROUGHOUTITSFORESTSANDPLANSTOADDRESSTHOSEISSUESIN THEFUTURE 4HEPHYSICALTIMBERASSETACCOUNTS04!! AREBASEDONFORESTRESOURCEINVEN
TORYDATAPROVIDEDBYTHEPROVINCESANDTERRITORIESTOTHE#ANADIAN&OREST3ERVICE ANDAGGREGATEDINTOTHE#ANADIAN&OREST)NVENTORY"ECAUSETHEPROVINCIALANDTER RITORIALINVENTORIESARENOTCONSISTENTLYBASEDONTHESAMELANDEACHYEARTHE04!! USEDATAONVOLUMEAREAAGECLASSANDFORESTCOMPOSITIONINASIMULATION MODELTOBUILDDATAONTHEFORESTFROMTO4HEMODELSIMULATESCHANGES INTHETIMBERSTOCKTAKINGINTOACCOUNTSUCHFACTORSASFORESTlRESANDREGENERA TIONOFBURNEDAREASNATURALMORTALITYANDREGENERATIONAFTERMORTALITYHARVESTSOF CONIFEROUSANDBROAD LEAVEDTREESREFORESTATIONANDNATURALREGENERATIONOFHAR VESTEDAREASVOLUMELOSTTOLOGGINGROADSANDAGING4HESESIMULATIONSAREUSEDTO BUILDANNUALPHYSICALTIMBERRECONCILIATIONACCOUNTSWHICHSHOWCLOSINGSTOCKAS
0HILIPPINE&OREST $EPRECIATION5SING $IFFERENT-ETHODS INPESOS
THESUMOFOPENINGSTOCKPLUSNATURALGROWTHLESSHARVESTMORTALITYlRELOSSAND LOSSDUETOROADS4ABLE SHOWSTHESTRUCTUREOFTHE04!!WITHSAMPLEDATAFOR THREEYEARS 4HEMONETARY TIMBER ASSET ACCOUNTS -4!! FOCUSONESTIMATING THE RENT
RECEIVEDFROMHARVESTINGTIMBER5NLIKETHE%UROPEANAND0HILIPPINEACCOUNTS 3TATISTICS#ANADAHASDEVELOPEDITSOWNRENTESTIMATESRATHERTHANBORROWINGTHEM FROMOTHERSTUDIES)TDOESTHISBASEDONPROVINCIALDATAONPRODUCTIONANDCOSTS)T MAKESTWODIFFERENTRENTESTIMATESONEASSUMINGANORMALRETURNTOPRODUCEDOR MAN MADECAPITALANDTHEOTHERASSUMINGNORETURNTOCAPITAL5NLIKETHE%URO PEANWORKHERETHERENTESTIMATESDONOTATTEMPTTOSEPARATETHEVALUEOFTIMBER FROMTHEVALUEOFLANDTHISMAYBEBECAUSE3TATISTICS#ANADAASSUMESTHATINVERY REMOTEAREASTHELANDHASNOVALUESEPARATELYFROMTHEFORESTS 4HE-4!!USETHENETPRESENTVALUEMETHODTOESTIMATETHEVALUEOFTHETIMBER
STOCKASSUMINGFORTHEPURPOSEOFTHECALCULATIONSTHATTHECURRENTHARVESTSARE SUSTAINABLEINDElNITELY4HEYDONOTAPPLYTHENETPRICEAPPROACHFORTWOREASONS &IRST3TATISTICS#ANADAARGUESTHATTHENETPRICEAPPROACHISMOREAPPROPRIATEFOR AGROWINGFORESTWITHTHESAMENUMBEROFTREESINEACHAGECLASSWHERETHEGROWTH RATEOFTHEFORESTACTUALLYCOULDMATCHTHEDISCOUNTRATE!SEXPLAINEDIN#HAPTER THISISTHEREQUIREMENTFORCOMPLYINGWITHTHE(OTELLINGRULEUNDERWHICHTHENET PRICEANDNETPRESENTVALUEMETHODSGIVETHESAMERESULT4HE#ANADIANFORESTSDO NOTHAVEEVENAGEDISTRIBUTIONSHOWEVER-OSTOFTHEMAREALREADYMATUREFORESTS WHOSEVALUEMUSTBEDISCOUNTEDINORDERTOESTIMATEITACCURATELY-OREOVERTHE GROWTHRATEOF#ANADIANFORESTSISFURTHERDISTORTEDBYAHIGHRATEOFlRESMAKINGIT MOREDIFlCULTTOUSETHENETPRICEMETHOD 4ABLE PROVIDESSUMMARYDATAONTRENDSINTHEPHYSICALANDMONETARYASSET
ACCOUNTSBETWEENAND4HEAREACOVEREDBYFORESTSINCREASEDSLOWLYBUT STEADILYOVERTHETIMEPERIODASNATURALREGENERATIONSLIGHTLYSURPASSEDDECLINES DUETOHARVESTINGlRESMORTALITYANDROADCONSTRUCTION)NCONTRASTTHEVOLUMEOF #ANADIANFORESTSDECLINEDSTEADILYOVERTHETIMEPERIOD3TATISTICS#ANADAB EXPLAINSTHATMATUREFORESTSAREBEINGHARVESTEDANDREPLACEDBYNEWGROWTHWITHA
3TRUCTUREOFTHE#ANADIAN 0HYSICAL4IMBER!SSET !CCOUNTS!NNUAL4IMBER !REAAND#AUSESOF #HANGEHECTARES
4ABLE 4RENDSIN#ANADIAN 0HYSICALAND-ONETARY 4IMBER!SSET!CCOUNTS
HISTORICALHARVESTINGRATESWILLNOTBESUSTAINABLEASTHEMATUREFORESTSAREUSEDUP 4HETWODIFFERENTMONETARYVALUESARECALCULATEDUSINGTHENETPRESENTVALUE
METHODANDREmECTTHETWORENTESTIMATES-ONETARYVALUE)INCLUDESARETURNON CAPITALMONETARYVALUE))DOESNOT4HERETURNONCAPITALDECREASESTHEESTIMATED RENTSEARNEDBYTHEFORESTRYINDUSTRYANDTHEREFOREDECREASESTHENETPRESENTVALUEOF THERESOURCESTOCKTHUSVALUE)ISCONSISTENTLYLOWERTHANVALUE))5SINGBOTHMEA SURESHOWEVERTHEVALUEOF#ANADASFORESTSHASRISENSTEADILYOVERTHE YEARTIME PERIOD"ECAUSEFORESTAREAHASBEENMOREORLESSCONSTANTANDVOLUMEHASDECLINED THISISDUETOEITHERGENERALPRICEINmATIONORINCREASESINTHEVALUEOFTIMBER
4HEDEVELOPMENTOFFORESTACCOUNTINGMETHODSBEGINSWITHTHEDEVELOPMENTOF CLASSIlCATIONSYSTEMSANDDElNITIONS/NEISSUEISTHEUNITSINWHICHTOMEASURE FORESTSANDHOWTOSEPARATETHEVALUEOFTHEFORESTPRODUCTSFROMTHELANDONWHICH THEYGROW-OSTACCOUNTSSEPARATETHETWOMEASURINGLANDINAREAANDFORESTPROD UCTSINVOLUME&ORESTDElNITIONSMAYBEBASEDONADMINISTRATIVECLASSIlCATIONS ACTUALORPOTENTIALLANDUSEORLANDCOVER4HE%UROPEAN)%%!&ANDTHE3%%!APPLY AVERYINCLUSIVEDElNITIONOFFORESTSBASEDONDENSITYOFLANDCOVERANDMINIMUM SIZEOFFORESTPARCELS 4HE)%%!&ANDTHE3%%!FOLLOWTHEGENERALSTRUCTUREOFTHE3.!ASSETANDCUR
RENTACCOUNTSINCLUDINGITSTRANSFEROFONLYSOMECHANGESINASSETVALUETOTHECUR RENTACCOUNTSFORTHECALCULATIONOFNETINCOME)NCONTRASTTHE0ESKINAPPROACH IMPLEMENTEDINTHE0HILIPPINESSUBTRACTSALLCHANGESINASSETVALUEFROMGROSS INCOMETOGETNETINCOMEANAPPROACHCONSISTENTWITHECONOMICTHEORYBUTNOT WITHTHE3.!ORTHE3%%!!LLMETHODSRECOGNIZETHATASSETSSHOULDBEVALUEDBASED ONTHENETPRESENTVALUEOFTHEFUTURERETURNSEXPECTEDFROMTHEMALTHOUGHTHISIS OFTENAPPROXIMATEDUSINGTHENETPRICEMETHODINSTEADBECAUSEITISMUCHEASIER 4HE %UROPEAN 0HILIPPINE AND#ANADIAN EXAMPLES HIGHLIGHT THE RANGE OF
APPROACHESTHATCOUNTRIESHAVETAKEN4HEFOCUSOFTHE%UROPEANWORKISTOPILOT TESTTHE)%%!&METHODOLOGYSOTHEPARTICIPATINGCOUNTRIESHAVERELIEDONAVARI ETYOFDIFFERENTSECONDARYDATASOURCESWITHWHICHTHEYHAVEATTEMPTEDTOWORK THROUGHALLELEMENTSOFTHECOMPLEXACCOUNTINGSYSTEM)NTHE0HILIPPINESTHE .ATIONAL3TATISTICAL#OORDINATION"OARDHASATTEMPTEDASTRAIGHTFORWARDIMPLE MENTATIONOFTHE3%%!SYSTEM)NCONTRASTTHE%.2!0PROJECTBASEDINTHE $EPARTMENTOF%NVIRONMENTAND.ATURAL2ESOURCESUSEDMOREEXPERIMENTAL APPROACHESTODEVELOPANECONOMICUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEVALUEOFTHEFORESTS#AN ADAUNLIKETHEOTHERCOUNTRIESPLACEDMAJOREMPHASESONMODELINGTHEGROWTH ANDAGESTRUCTUREOFITSFORESTSANDONBUILDINGANNUALDATAWITHWHICHTOTRACK TRENDSINTHEPHYSICALANDMONETARYASSETACCOUNTS
