ABSTRACT
NUMBEROFDIFFERENTISSUES4HEONETHATHASRECEIVEDTHEMOSTATTENTIONBOTHINTHE CRITICISMSOFTHE3.!ANDINACTUALIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHEACCOUNTSISTHEDEPLETION OFNATURALRESOURCESTOADJUSTFORTHEFACTTHATNOTALLREVENUEDERIVEDFROMTHEIRSALE SHOULDBETREATEDASINCOME!SEXPLAINEDIN#HAPTERINORDERFORINCOMETOBE SUSTAINABLETHECAPITALBASEFROMWHICHITISDERIVEDMUSTBEMAINTAINED2ESOURCE ACCOUNTSPROVIDEAWAYTODETERMINEHOWMUCHWEAREDEPLETINGOURNATURALCAPI TAL4HEYPROVIDETHEFRAMEWORKFORTRACKINGOURUSEOFNATURALRESOURCESVALUING RESOURCESTOCKSANDCHANGESINSTOCKSANDTHUSPUTTINGAVALUEONSOMEOFTHEADDI TIONALCHANGESINTHEVALUEOFCAPITALTHATMUSTBESUBTRACTEDFROMINITIALESTIMATES OFINCOMEINORDERTOOBTAINAMEASUREOFSUSTAINABLEINCOME )NADDITIONTOTRACKINGNATURALCAPITALTHEENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTSCANDISAG
GREGATERESOURCE RELATEDECONOMICACTIVITYMUCHASTHEYDISAGGREGATEENVIRON MENTALPROTECTIONEXPENDITURESANDTHEENVIRONMENTSECTORTOCAPTUREINFORMA TIONABOUTPOLLUTION-ANYECONOMICUSESOFNATURALRESOURCESDONOTPASSTHROUGH MARKETSANDTHEREFOREDONOTSHOWUPINTHECONVENTIONALACCOUNTS4HESEINCLUDE THEUSEOFENVIRONMENTALSERVICESSUCHASWASTEABSORPTIONANDTHEVALUEPEO PLEPLACEONTHEEXISTENCEOFRESOURCESEVENIFTHEYRECEIVENODIRECTBENElTFROM THEM4HEYALSOINCLUDEBOTHTHEmOWSANDTHESTOCKSOFENVIRONMENTALFUNCTIONS SUCHASTHECARBONSEQUESTRATIONSERVICESOFFORESTS"OTHTHE3.!AND3%%!ASSET ACCOUNTSCAPTURETHEUSEOFMINERALSANDOFTIMBERFROMFORESTS4HE3%%!BUTNOT THE3.!RECORDSTHEDEPLETIONOFTHESEASSETSINTHEmOWACCOUNTS.EITHERTHE3.! NORTHE3%%!CAPTURESWASTEASSIMILATIONORCARBONSEQUESTRATION4HESETOPICSARE
RESOURCEACCOUNTS
!LTHOUGHTHEMEANINGOFTHETERMNATURALRESOURCESMAYSEEMSELF EVIDENTFOR ACCOUNTINGPURPOSESAMOREPRECISEDElNITIONISESSENTIAL!SDISCUSSEDIN#HAPTER THE3.!DElNESASSETSUSINGAFEWKEYCRITERIA4HEYMUSTBEOWNEDANDTHEIR OWNERSMUSTDERIVEECONOMICBENElTFROMHOLDINGORUSINGTHEM4HEYMAYEITHER BESYNTHETICORGROWNATURALLY3YNTHETICASSETSARETERMEDPRODUCEDECONOMIC ASSETSTHOSETHATGROWNATURALLYARETERMEDNONPRODUCEDECONOMICASSETS.ONPRO DUCEDECONOMICASSETSINCLUDESUCHTHINGSASLANDMINERALDEPOSITSORPRIMARY FORESTANDTHEYMUSTBEPRIVATELYOWNEDANDAVAILABLEFORECONOMICUSE4HEYDO NOTHOWEVERINCLUDEWILDRESOURCESTHATCANNOTBEOWNEDSUCHASOCEANlSHER IESORPUBLICLYHELDRESOURCESTHATCANNOTBEHARVESTEDSUCHASFORESTSINNATIONAL PARKS4HISDElNITIONISTERMEDTHEASSETBOUNDARYANYTHINGTHATFALLSWITHINITIS COVEREDINTHENATIONALACCOUNTS 4HE3%%!EXPANDSTHEASSETBOUNDARYOFTHE3.!BYRELAXINGTHEREQUIREMENT
THATASSETSMUSTBEOWNEDALLOWINGCOMMONOWNERSHIPRATHERTHANINSISTINGON INDIVIDUALOWNERSHIPANDBYINCLUDINGENTITIESTHATDONOTPROVIDEANYDIRECTECO NOMICBENElT4HUSFOREXAMPLENONPRODUCEDASSETSINTHE3%%!INCLUDEBOTH FORESTSTHATAREOWNEDANDFISHINTHESEATHATARENOT4HE3%%!ALSOEXPANDS THECONCEPTOFASSETSTOINCLUDEECOSYSTEMSWHICHAREOFTHREETYPESTERRESTRIAL AQUATICANDATMOSPHERIC)NCORPORATINGECOSYSTEMSINTOTHEACCOUNTSASASSETS RATHERTHANBYLOOKINGATCHANGESINTHEIRQUALITY ISDIFlCULTHOWEVERESPECIALLY FORTHEATMOSPHEREBECAUSEASTOCKCONCEPTOFTENHASNOMEANINGANDEVENmOWS ARETOODIFlCULTTOQUANTIFYANDVALUE!SEXPLAINEDIN#HAPTERSTHROUGHHOW EVERSOMEASPECTSOFTHEDEGRADATIONOFENVIRONMENTALASSETSARECOVEREDBYSYS TEMSTHATACCOUNTFORPOLLUTION)NADDITIONTHE3%%!CREATESACATEGORYOFINTAN GIBLEENVIRONMENTALASSETSWHICHINCLUDEEMISSIONSPERMITSTRANSFERABLELICENSES TOEXPLOITNATURALRESOURCESSUCHAS FISHANDOTHERNONPRODUCEDITEMS4HESE OFTENHAVEECONOMICVALUEANDAREAKEYELEMENTOFENVIRONMENTALMANAGEMENT ALTHOUGHTHEYARENOTPROVIDEDBYTHEENVIRONMENTITSELF
4HE3%%!ASSETACCOUNTSTAKETHEGENERALFORMSHOWNIN4ABLE ASIMPLERVER SIONOFWHICHAPPEAREDAS4ABLE 4HEOPENINGSTOCKISTHEQUANTITYOFTHEASSET ORITSVALUEATTHEBEGINNINGOFTHETIMEPERIOD)DEALLYASSETACCOUNTSWOULDBE CALCULATEDEACHYEARLIKETHE3.!)NPRACTICETHEDIFlCULTYOFCOLLECTINGDATAABOUT NATURALRESOURCESMAYMANDATETHATTHEYBECALCULATEDLESSFREQUENTLY-OREOVER NOTALLOFTHEITEMSMAKESENSEFORALLRESOURCESTHE8SINTHETABLEINDICATEWHICH ITEMSCANBECALCULATEDFOREACHRESOURCETYPE4HESTARTINGSTOCKINAGIVENTIME PERIODISTHESAMEASTHECLOSINGSTOCKFROMTHEPREVIOUSTIMEPERIODTHECLOSING STOCKISCALCULATEDANDTHENSIMPLYCARRIEDOVERTOTHENEXTYEAR
'ENERAL3TRUCTUREOFTHE 3%%!!SSET!CCOUNTS
ANDTHE3%%!ASSETCLASSIlCATIONSEXCEPTFORECOSYSTEMINPUTS.ONBIOLOGICALPRO DUCEDASSETSINCLUDETHENONlNANCIALASSETSCOVEREDBYTHE3.!EXCEPTFORLAND MINERALDEPOSITSANDBIOLOGICALASSETS"IOLOGICALASSETSAREDIVIDEDINTOCULTIVATED ORPRODUCED ANDNONCULTIVATED0RODUCEDBIOLOGICALRESOURCESARECOVEREDBYTHE 3.!ASWELLTHEYINCLUDEAGRICULTURALPRODUCTIONPLANTATIONFORESTRYlSHFARMING ANDOTHERCULTIVATEDBIOLOGICALRESOURCES.ONPRODUCEDBIOLOGICALRESOURCESGROW INTHEWILDRATHERTHANBEINGTHEPRODUCTOFCULTIVATION4HEQUESTIONOFHOWTO DIFFERENTIATEBETWEENPRODUCEDANDNONPRODUCEDBIOLOGICALRESOURCESISTAKENUP IN#HAPTERONFORESTACCOUNTING-INERALSANDENERGYHAVERECEIVEDEXTENSIVE ATTENTIONINTHEENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTSANDAREDISCUSSEDINDETAILIN#HAPTER ONSUBSOILASSETS4HESTOCKSANDmOWSOFTHESEASSETSARESHOWNINTHE3.! BUTTHECHANGESARERECORDEDONLYINTHEOTHERCHANGESINASSETSACCOUNTSANDNOT INTHEmOWACCOUNTS3OMEASPECTSOFLANDANDSOILACCOUNTINGARECOVEREDBYTHE 3.!BUTTHEENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTSBUILDONTHIS7ORKHASBEENDONEONWATER INTHEENVIRONMENTALACCOUNTSBUTTHISISCONSIDERABLYMOREDIFlCULTTHANOTHER RESOURCESANDLESSPROGRESSHASBEENMADEINTHISAREA&ISHERIESLANDANDWATER ARECOVEREDIN#HAPTER%NVIRONMENTALASSETSSUCHASCLEANAIRANDBIODIVERSITY ARENOTINCLUDEDINTHISTABLEATALL 4HECATEGORIESOFCHANGESLISTEDDOWNTHELEFT HANDSIDEOFTHETABLEAREBASED
ONTHE3.!ACCUMULATIONANDASSETACCOUNTS4HESHADEDAREACHANGESASARESULT OFTRANSACTIONSISIDENTICALTOTHE3.!4HENONSHADEDENTRIESOTHERTHANOPEN INGSTOCKANDCLOSINGSTOCKAPPEARINTHE3.!INTHEhOTHERCHANGESvACCOUNT4HE 3%%!EXPLORESWHETHERSOMEOFTHESEMAYBEMOVEDTOTHESHADEDAREAANDSO CHANGETHECONVENTIONALMACROECONOMICINDICATORS 4HEDEPLETIONOFNATURALCAPITALISCLASSIlEDINTHEhOTHERCHANGESvACCOUNT&OR
RENEWABLERESOURCESTHISCOULDBEFURTHERDISAGGREGATEDINTOSUSTAINABLELEVELS OFUSEANDUSEBEYONDTHESUSTAINABLELEVELTHELATTERWOULDBETHEDEPLETIONOF THEASSET&ORNONRENEWABLESSUCHASMINERALSNOUSEWILLBEREPLACEDNATURALLY WITHINATIMEFRAMERELEVANTTOECONOMICACCOUNTING 4HECATEGORIESFORENVIRONMENTALADDITIONSTOANDDEDUCTIONSFROMSTOCKARE
MODIlCATIONSOFTHOSEWITHINTHECONVENTIONALASSETACCOUNTSFORADDITIONSAND DEDUCTIONS4HEYAREBROADENEDTOINCLUDEPHYSICALASSETSTHATHAVENOMONETARY VALUEBUTSHOULDNEVERTHELESSBETRACKEDINTHEPHYSICALACCOUNTS4HEYALSOCAP TURECHANGESINTHEQUALITYOFNATURALASSETSASARESULTOFDEGRADATIONONTHELINE FORRECLASSIlCATIONSASARESULTOFQUALITYCHANGE4HECATEGORYFORDISCOVERIESHAS BEENTHESUBJECTOFSOMEDISPUTEINRECENTYEARS4HEDEBATECONCERNSWHETHERNEW DISCOVERIESSHOULDBECONSIDEREDARETURNONINVESTMENTINEXPLORATIONANDTHERE FORECATEGORIZEDWITHTRANSACTIONSINTHEPRODUCTIONACCOUNTORALUCKYAPPEAR ANCESUCHASANUNEXPECTEDOILSTRIKEWHICHDOESNOTSHOWUPINTHEPRODUCTION ACCOUNT4HISISDISCUSSEDFURTHERIN#HAPTER 4HECATEGORIESFOROTHERCHANGESAREUSEDINTHE3.!TOHELPEXPLAINDIFFERENCES
BETWEENOPENINGANDCLOSINGSTOCKLEVELS"ECAUSETHEYARENOTTHERESULTOFTRANS ACTIONSHOWEVERTHEYDONOTAFFECTANYOFTHEOTHERmOWACCOUNTSORTHEMACROECO NOMICVARIABLES4HELINEFORCATASTROPHICLOSSESWOULDINCLUDETHOSEDUETOmOODS ORLANDSLIDESALTHOUGHTHESEMAYINFACTBETHERESULTOFHUMANUSEOFTHEENVIRON MENTRATHERTHANPURELYNATURALEVENTS 4HISCATEGORYALSOINCLUDESCHANGESINTHE VALUEOFTHEENTIRESTOCKOFANASSETWHENTHEMARKETPRICEOFTHEASSETCHANGES)F
LESSPERUNITTHANTHEOPENINGSTOCKWAS3UCHCHANGESPOSEPARTICULARPROBLEMS FORSUBSOILASSETSWHOSEPRICESONWORLDMARKETSCANBEVERYVOLATILELEADINGTO HUGESWINGSINTHESTOCKVALUESINTHEASSETACCOUNTS
4HEASSETACCOUNTSMAYBEPHYSICALMONETARYORBOTH!NYRESOURCEACCOUNTING SYSTEMMUSTBEBASEDONACOREOFPHYSICALDATAABOUTTHERESOURCES3OMECOUN TRIESHAVESTOPPEDTHEREWHILEOTHERSHAVEGONEONTOBUILDMONETARYACCOUNTSAS WELL4HEADVANTAGESOFMONETARYACCOUNTSARECLEARTHEYMAYBECOMBINEDWITH OTHERMONETARYDATAINTHE3.!FORANALYTICALPURPOSESWHEREASTHEOPPORTUNITIES TODOTHISWITHPHYSICALACCOUNTSARELIMITED 4HEDISADVANTAGESOFMONETARYACCOUNTSESSENTIALLYAREROOTEDINTHEDIFlCULTY
OFVALUINGNATURALRESOURCES3OMETIMESTHISISFAIRLYSTRAIGHTFORWARDFOREXAMPLE THEVALUEOFRESOURCESHARVESTEDORMINEDORlSHED DURINGAGIVENYEARCANEASILY BECALCULATEDBASEDONMARKETDATA0UTTINGAMONETARYVALUEONTHESTARTINGSTOCK OFANASSETSUCHASTIMBERORIRRIGATIONWATERISDIFlCULTHOWEVER6ALUINGTHESTOCK OFANECOSYSTEMSERVICETHATISNOTMARKETEDSUCHASCARBONSEQUESTRATIONORHABI TATFORAQUATICECOSYSTEMSISEVENMOREDIFlCULT 4HEhREVALUATIONDUETOPRICECHANGEvITEMINTHEASSETACCOUNTSISAPARTICULAR
PROBLEMINMONETARYACCOUNTING4HEPRICESOFNATURALRESOURCESSUCHASTIMBER OILANDMINERALSCANmUCTUATEWIDELYINRESPONSETOOTHERCHANGESINTHEECON OMY!LTHOUGHAFEWSALESATEXTREMEPRICESWILLCORRECTLYREmECTTHEmUCTUATIONOF THEMARKETIFTHOSEPRICESAREUSEDTOREVALUETHEENTIRESTOCKTHERESULTINGlGURES CANBESOERRATICASTOTOTALLYDISTORTECONOMICANALYSISUSINGTHEDATA4HISCANBE ANARGUMENTAGAINSTALLMONETARYVALUATION!LTERNATELYVOLATILEASSETVALUESCAN BESMOOTHEDOUTBYVALUINGEACHYEARSSTOCKBASEDONANAVERAGEOFMARKETPRICES FROMSEVERALPRECEDINGYEARS4HEECONOMICJUSTIlCATIONFORTHISAPPROACHISTHAT INVESTORSINRESOURCEASSETSBASETHEIRDECISIONSNOTONASINGLEPRICEBUTONA TRENDINPRICESOVERTIME 4HEANALYSTSORACCOUNTANTSFOCUSONSTRONGVERSUSWEAKSUSTAINABILITYWILLALSO
INmUENCETHECHOICEBETWEENMONETARYANDPHYSICALACCOUNTS!SDISCUSSEDIN #HAPTERSTRONGSUSTAINABILITYCANBEUNDERSTOODASTHEPREMISETHATTHEmOWOF SERVICESFROMTHEPHYSICALRESOURCEBASEMUSTBECONSERVED4HISGENERALLYMEANS THATTHEPHYSICALSIZEOFTHEASSETSUCHASAFORESTORlSHERYMAYNOTDROPOVER TIME7EAKSUSTAINABILITYINCONTRASTISTHEPREMISETHATTHEINCOMEmOWSFROMA COUNTRYSOVERALLCAPITALBASEINCLUDINGMANUFACTUREDANDHUMANASWELLASNATU RALCAPITALSHOULDNOTDECLINE)FTHEMOSTEFlCIENTWAYTOPRESERVEOVERALLINCOME ISTOSELLTREESORMINERALSANDPUTTHEPROCEEDSINTOEQUALLYORMORE PROlTABLE INVESTMENTSININDUSTRYOREDUCATIONTHATISACCEPTABLEACCORDINGTOSUPPORTERS OFWEAKSUSTAINABILITYSOLONGASINCOMEINTHEFUTUREWILLBEATLEASTASHIGHAS INCOMETODAY 4HELINKBETWEENCONCEPTSOFSUSTAINABILITYANDTHECHOICEBETWEENPHYSICAL
ANDMONETARYASSETACCOUNTSISFAIRLYSIMPLE0HYSICALACCOUNTSPROVIDETHEBASIS FORTRACKINGWHETHERACOUNTRYISACHIEVINGSTRONGSUSTAINABILITYWITHOUTANYNEED TOVALUERESOURCEASSETSORmOWSOFNONMARKETEDGOODSORSERVICES)NCONTRAST
TALSTOCKSANDmOWSTODETERMINEWHETHERINCOMEISREMAININGCONSTANT
,INKBETWEEN!SSET!CCOUNTSAND#URRENT!CCOUNTS 4HEQUESTIONOFHOWTOCALCULATETHEDEPLETIONOFNATURALASSETSWITHINTHEACCOUNT INGFRAMEWORKISRELATEDTOTHELINKBETWEENTHEASSETACCOUNTSANDTHECURRENT ACCOUNTS)NTHE3.!INCREASESINSTOCKASARESULTOFHUMANACTIVITYAREPARTOFOUT PUT#ONSUMPTIONOFlXEDCAPITALˆORDEPRECIATIONITEM+INTHE3.!CODESˆIS SUBTRACTEDFROMGROSSDOMESTICPRODUCTTOCALCULATENETDOMESTICPRODUCT 4WODISTINCTQUESTIONSHAVEARISENINAPPLYINGTHESEGENERALPRINCIPLESTONATURAL
RESOURCES4HElRSTCONCERNSWHICHINCREASESINSTOCKAREATTRIBUTABLETOHUMANACTIV ITYANDWHICHTOLUCKORNATURALGROWTH4HISDISTINCTIONISSIGNIlCANTBECAUSETHE ADDITIONSTOSTOCKDUETOHUMANACTIVITYCOUNTERBALANCEECONOMICUSEOFTHEASSET LEADINGTOHIGHERNETDOMESTICPRODUCT4HEECONOMYAPPEARSHEALTHIERIFALLINCREASES INSTOCKAREADDEDINTHANIFINCREASESNOTDUETOHUMANACTIVITYAREEXCLUDED 4HESECONDISSUEARISESBECAUSETHEECONOMICDEFINITIONOFDEPRECIATION IS
DISTINCTLYDIFFERENTFROMTHATOFTHE3.!)NECONOMICSDEPRECIATIONCAPTURESTHE CHANGEINTHEVALUEOFTHEASSETFROMTHEBEGINNINGTOTHEENDOFTHETIMEPERIOD IRRESPECTIVEOFTHECAUSEOFTHATCHANGE)NCONTRAST3.!DEPRECIATIONCAPTURES ONLYTHEVALUEOFCHANGESINTHEASSETTHATAREATTRIBUTABLETOHUMANACTIVITYORTO CHANGESINMARKETPRICES7EREECONOMICDEPRECIATIONTHEBASISFORCALCULATING 3.!DEPRECIATIONITWOULDINCLUDEALLOFTHEELEMENTSINTHEASSETACCOUNTINCLUD INGCHANGESDUETOHUMANACTIVITYNEWDISCOVERIESNATURALGROWTHNATURALDISAS TERSANDCATEGORYSHIFTSASWELLASREVALUATIONASARESULTOFPRICECHANGES 4HESTRUCTUREOFTHEASSETACCOUNTSPRESENTEDIN4ABLE MAKESTHEDIFFERENCES
BETWEENTHESETWOCONCEPTSOFDEPRECIATIONCLEAR3.!DEPRECIATIONISTHEVALUE+ INTHETABLETHECONSUMPTIONOFlXEDCAPITAL%CONOMICDEPRECIATIONINCONTRAST ISTHEDIFFERENCEINVALUEBETWEENTHESTARTINGSTOCKANDTHECLOSINGSTOCK!PURELY ECONOMICAPPROACHTOACCOUNTINGWOULDTRANSFERTHATVALUETOTHEPRODUCTION ACCOUNTSTOCALCULATENETVALUEADDEDRATHERTHANTRANSFERONLYTHECONSUMPTION OFlXEDCAPITAL3EE4ABLE TOREVIEWTHESTRUCTUREOFTHEPRODUCTIONACCOUNT 4HETWODEPRECIATIONlGURESMAYBEUSEFULFORDIFFERENTPURPOSES)FTHEDATA
AREBEINGUSEDINECONOMICANALYSISITISIMPORTANTTOUSEECONOMICDEPRECIA TIONBECAUSE3.!DEPRECIATIONWILLBECONCEPTUALLYINCORRECT)FHOWEVERTHEDATA AREBEINGUSEDTOPROVIDEINDICATORSFORINTERNATIONALCOMPARISONSORTOCALCULATE ADJUSTED'$0INTHE3%%!SYSTEMTHENITISESSENTIALTOUSETHE3.!DEPRECIATION lGURE&ORTUNATELYIFASSETACCOUNTSAREAVAILABLEITISFAIRLYSIMPLETOCALCULATE BOTH3.!DEPRECIATIONANDECONOMICDEPRECIATION4HECRUCIALPOINTSTHEREFORE ARETOBEEXPLICITABOUTWHICHlGUREISBEINGUSEDANDTOBESURETOUSETHEAPPRO PRIATEVALUEFORTHECONTEXT
-ETHODSFOR6ALUING!SSETSAND$EPLETION 4HREEMETHODSARECOMMONLYUSEDTOVALUEASSETSANDDEPRECIATIONINTHERESOURCE ACCOUNTSNETPRESENTVALUENETPRICEAND%L3ERAFYORUSERCOST%ACHISDISCUSSED INTURNINTHISSECTION
4HENETPRESENTVALUE.06 METHODISTHECORRECTONEFORASSETVALUATIONACCORD INGTOECONOMICTHEORY)THASSTRINGENTDATAREQUIREMENTSHOWEVERANDFORCESTHE ANALYSTTOMAKESENSITIVEASSUMPTIONSABOUTTHEAPPROPRIATEDISCOUNTRATE4HIS METHODISBASEDONTHEIDEATHATTHEVALUEOFANASSETISDETERMINEDBYTHEINCOME THATCANBEDERIVEDFROMITINTHEFUTURE)TISNOTSIMPLYTHESUMOFTHEFUTUREPAY MENTSTHEYMUSTBEDISCOUNTEDBACKTOTHEPRESENTUSINGADISCOUNTRATETHATIS USUALLYCLOSETOTHEPREVAILINGINTERESTRATE4HENEEDTODISCOUNTARISESBECAUSEA SUMOFMONEYINHANDTODAYISWORTHMORETHANTHESAMEAMOUNTPROMISEDFOR NEXTYEAR4HECASHINHANDCOULDBEINVESTEDANDNEXTYEARITWILLBEWORTHTHE SAMEAMOUNTPLUSTHEINTERESTITEARNSORTHERETURNONTHEINVESTMENT3IMILARLY MONEYPROMISEDFORNEXTYEARISWORTHLESSNOWITISREDUCEDBYTHEINTERESTTHAT WOULDBEEARNEDIFTHISYEARSCASHWEREINVESTED4HUSINHANDWOULDBEWORTH NEXTYEARATAINTERESTRATEANDITWOULDBEWORTH INTWOYEARS3IMILARLYWORKINGBACKWARD RECEIVEDNEXTYEARWOULDBEWORTHNOWAS ANDRECEIVEDTWOYEARSFROMNOWWOULDBEWORTHTODAY 4OESTIMATETHENETPRESENTVALUEOFANASSETCALCULATETHEPRESENTVALUEOF
THEFUTUREINCOMESTREAMOVERTHEENTIRELIFEOFTHEASSETANDSUMTHOSEVALUES)N MATHEMATICALNOTATIONTHISISWRITTENAS
.06 2 R T T
)NTHISEQUATION3THE'REEKLETTERSIGMA ISASUMMATIONSIGN4HEEQUATION FOLLOWINGTHESIGMAISESTIMATEDFORVALUESOFTWHICHSTANDSFORTIMERANGINGFROM INTHECURRENTYEARTONTHELIFESPANOFTHEASSET)NEACHYEARTHEDISCOUNTED VALUEOFTHEINCOMEWILLBETHATYEARSGROSSINCOMEFROMTHEASSET2TDISCOUNTED BYTHEINTERESTRATER4HISISSIMPLYTHEEQUIVALENTOFWHATAPPEAREDINTHEEXAM PLEABOVEWHERERECEIVEDAYEARFROMNOWISWORTH AND RECEIVEDINTWOYEARSISWORTH %CONOMICDEPRECIATIONWOULDTHENBETHECHANGEINNETPRESENTVALUEOVERONE
TIMEPERIOD.OTETHATTHISISNOTSIMPLYTHERETURNINTHElRSTYEARALTHOUGHTHAT VALUEISOFTENUSEDTOESTIMATEDEPRECIATION%XPANDINGTHEFORMULAABOVEFORTIME TANDTHENTIMETSHOWSWHYTHISISSO4HENETPRESENTVALUETHISYEARTIMET IS
.06 2 R 2
R 2
¥ §¦
µ ·¶
¥ §¦
µ ·¶
¥ §¦
µ ·¶
%XPANDINGTHESAMEFORMULAFORNEXTYEARTIMET TOESTIMATEWHATTHEASSET WILLBEWORTHAYEARFROMNOWGIVES
.06 2 R 2
R 2
¥ §¦
µ ·¶
¥ §¦
µ ·¶
¥ §¦
µ ·¶
2T
3UBTRACTINGTHESECONDFORMULAFROMTHElRSTANDDOINGABITOFALGEBRASHOWSTHAT THECHANGEINVALUEBETWEENTIMETANDTIMETIS
.06 .06 2 R R .06T T T T
4HEEXPRESSIONONTHELEFT HANDSIDEOFTHEEQUATIONISEQUALTOTHEDECLINEINTHE VALUEOFTHEASSETORDEPRECIATION4HEGROSSINCOMEPRODUCEDBYTHEASSETINONE YEAR2TISMORETHAN.06Tn.06T4HEDIFFERENCE;RR =.06TISTHEINCREASE INVALUEOFTHESUBSEQUENTYEARSINCOMESTREAMSBYVIRTUEOFTHEFACTTHATTHEYARE NOWONEYEARCLOSERTOTHEPRESENT)FTHEVALUEOFTHEASSETDOESNOTDECLINEˆIN OTHERWORDSWHENTHEREISNODEPRECIATIONANDTHELEFTSIDEOFTHISEQUATIONIS ZEROˆTHENTHEASSETISBEINGUSEDSUSTAINABLYANDTHEINCOMEINAGIVENYEARAND THERETURNONTHEASSETAREIDENTICAL )NORDERTOESTIMATENETPRESENTVALUETHEANALYSTMUSTKNOWWHATTHEFUTURE
INCOMESTREAMWILLBEFROMTHERESOURCE4HISDEPENDSONHARVESTINGRATESANDON DOMESTICORWORLDPRICESBOTHOFWHICHmUCTUATEINRESPONSETOARANGEOFEXOGE NOUSFACTORS)TALSODEPENDSONTHETOTALSIZEOFTHESTOCKANDINTHECASEOFRENEW ABLESITSGROWTHRATE4OTALSTOCKCANBEDIFlCULTTOMEASUREANDHARDERTOVALUE 'ROWTHRATESWILLDEPENDONUNPREDICTABLEFACTORSSUCHASWEATHEROTHERENVIRON MENTALCHANGESORTHEHARVESTINGOFOTHERCOUNTRIESESPECIALLYFORlSHERIES )N ADDITIONTHERESULTSAREHIGHLYSENSITIVETOTHECHOICEOFDISCOUNTRATEANDPLAU SIBLEARGUMENTSUSUALLYCANBEMADEFORARANGEOFDIFFERENTRATESINANYONECON TEXT"ECAUSEOFALLTHESEUNCERTAINTIESANALYSTSOFTENAVOIDTHENETPRESENTVALUE METHODWHENVALUINGRESOURCEASSETS
4HENETPRICEORNETRENT METHODCALCULATESTHEVALUEOFTHEASSETANDITSDEPRE CIATIONUSINGTHERETURNINTHEPRESENTYEAR4HISISTHEORETICALLYCORRECTONLYUNDER QUITERESTRICTIVEASSUMPTIONSWHICHARESETFORTHLATERINTHISSECTION)TISMUCHSIM PLERTHANTHENETPRESENTVALUEMETHODHOWEVERANDISTHEREFOREUSEDOFTENDESPITE THEFACTTHATTHERESTRICTIONSDETERMININGWHENITISCORRECTARENOTLIKELYTOHOLDIN PRACTICE!PPLYINGTHISMETHODTHEVALUEOFTHEASSETISDETERMINEDASFOLLOWS
STOCKVALUEQUANTITYNETPRICEPERUNITSOLDTHATYEAR
4HENETPRICEPERUNITISDElNEDAS
NETPRICEMARGINALREVENUEPRICE nMARGINALCOSTOFEXTRACTION
4HEEXTRACTIONCOSTINTURNISCALCULATEDAS
COST INTERMEDIATECONSUMPTION LABORCOSTS NORMALRETURNTOlXEDCAPITAL DEPRECIATIONOFTHEASSETIFANY
$EPRECIATIONOFTHEASSETIFTHEREISANYISESTIMATEDAS
DEPRECIATIONINTIMETNETPRICEINTIMETQUANTITYEXTRACTEDINTIMET
THERATHERRESTRICTIVEASSUMPTIONTHATEITHERTHEDISCOUNTRATEISTHESAMEASTHE INCREASEINTHENETPRICEOFTHEASSETORTHEVALUEOFTHEASSETDOESNOTCHANGEˆIN OTHERWORDSNODEPRECIATION&ORRENEWABLERESOURCESTHEDISCOUNTRATEMUSTBE THESAMEASTHENETGROWTHRATEFORTHEASSET4HEEQUATIONSUSEDTOEXPLAINTHE TWOMETHODSCANBEUSEDTOILLUSTRATEWHATTHISASSUMPTIONMEANSINTERMSOFNET PRESENTVALUE)FTHEVALUEOFTHESTOCKISEQUALTOTODAYSPRICETIMESTHEQUANTITY INEXISTENCETHENTHEDISCOUNTEDVALUEOFEACHYEARSINCOMEINTHEFUTUREISEQUAL TOTHISYEARSINCOME)FTHISYEARSINCOMEISANDTHEINTERESTRATEISTHEN NEXTYEARSINCOME2WILLBE2WILLBE ANDSOON4HUSTHERETURNONTHEASSETISRISINGATTHEDISCOUNTRATESOTHEDIS COUNTEDVALUEISCONSTANT!NASSETCOULDBEMINEDORHARVESTEDATEXACTLYTHERATE THATDRIVESUPTHEVALUEOFWHATISLEFTATTHISRATEBECAUSEOFSCARCITY4HISISCON SIDEREDTHEOPTIMALECONOMICRATEOFEXTRACTIONBECAUSEITMAXIMIZESTHENETPRES ENTVALUEOFTHEASSET4HISREVEALSNOTHINGABOUTWHETHERTHISRATEOFEXTRACTIONIS OPTIMALFROMANENVIRONMENTALPERSPECTIVEHOWEVER !RESOURCEMANAGEDINTHIS WAYISSAIDTOFOLLOWTHE(OTELLINGRULEAFTER(AROLD(OTELLINGTHEECONOMISTWHO DEVELOPEDTHISTHEORY!UTYAND-IKESELLn !LTHOUGHTHEASSUMPTIONTHATASSETSAREMANAGEDACCORDINGTOTHE(OTELLING
RULEISUNREALISTICTHENETPRICEMETHODNEVERTHELESSISOFTENAPPLIEDBECAUSEIT AVOIDSMANYOFTHEDIFlCULTIESOFCALCULATINGNETPRESENTVALUE)TISNOTNECESSARY TOPROJECTFUTUREASSETPRICESREVENUEOREXTRACTIONCOSTS)TALSOISNOTNECESSARY TOASSUMEALIFETIMEFORTHEASSETORTOCHOOSEADISCOUNTRATEFORESTIMATINGTHE PRESENTVALUEOFTHEFUTUREINCOMESTREAM-OREOVERTHEIDEAOFPROJECTINGFUTURE PRICECHANGESINORDERTOCALCULATENETPRESENTVALUESTHOUGHACCEPTABLEFORECO NOMICANALYSISISNOTINACCORDWITHEITHER3.!ORCOMMERCIALACCOUNTINGPRIN CIPLES&ORALLTHESEREASONSMOSTACCOUNTINGPROJECTSWHILERECOGNIZINGTHATNET PRESENTVALUEISTHETHEORETICALLYCORRECTWAYTOCALCULATEASSETVALUEUSETHENET PRICEMETHODINSTEAD 4HENETPRICEISTHESAMEASTHEUNITRENTDERIVEDFROMUSEOFTHERESOURCEFOR
THISREASONTHISMETHODISSOMETIMESCALLEDTHENETORCURRENT RENTRATHERTHAN THENETPRICEMETHOD2ESOURCERENTISDElNEDBYECONOMISTSASTHEINCOMEFROM HARVESTINGOREXTRACTINGARESOURCENETOFALLINPUTCOSTSANDNETOFTHENORMAL RETURNTOlXEDCAPITAL2ENTBEINGNETOFALLINPUTCOSTSISNOTARETURNTOANYINVEST MENTORLABORNORDOESITHAVEANYTHINGTODOWITHPAYMENTSONALEASE2ATHERIT ISVALUETHATACCRUESTOTHERESOURCESIMPLYBECAUSEITISSCARCEANDPEOPLEAREWILL INGTOPAYMOREFORACCESSTHANTHECOSTOFPROVIDINGIT 4HEVALUEOFRENTHASARANGEOFPOLICYAPPLICATIONSSOTHEQUESTIONOFHOWTOCAL
CULATEITWARRANTSADDITIONALATTENTION)TPOSESSEVERALTECHNICALDIFlCULTIES/NEIS THATMARGINALCOSTDATAFREQUENTLYARENOTAVAILABLEANDACCOUNTANTSUSEAVERAGE COSTTOESTIMATENETPRICE4HEMAGNITUDEANDDIRECTIONOFTHEDISTORTIONCAUSEDBY USINGAVERAGEINSTEADOFMARGINALCOSTDEPENDSONTHEINDUSTRY7HEREECONOMIESOF SCALEEXISTAVERAGECOSTWILLEXCEEDMARGINALCOSTSONETPRICEWILLBETOOLOWANDTHE ASSETANDITSDEPRECIATIONWILLBEUNDERVALUED)FHOWEVERCOSTSINCREASEWITHOUT PUTASMAYBETHECASEWHERETHELEAST COSTRESOURCESAREMINEDORHARVESTEDlRST THENNETPRICEWILLBETOOHIGHANDTHEASSETANDITSDEPRECIATIONWILLBEOVERVALUED !LTHOUGHDATAONINTERMEDIATECONSUMPTIONANDLABORMAYBEAVAILABLEFROM
THENATIONALINCOMEACCOUNTSTHEYMAYNOTBEDISAGGREGATEDSUFlCIENTLYTOALLOW
ARELIKELYTOBEAVAILABLEFORTHElSHINGINDUSTRYASAWHOLERATHERTHANBYSPECIES ASINDIVIDUALBOATSCATCHMANYDIFFERENTSPECIES4HEASSETISTHESTOCKOFANINDI VIDUALSPECIESRATHERTHANALLlSHCOMBINEDSOITMAYBENECESSARYTODEVELOPA RULEOFTHUMBTOALLOCATEINPUTCOSTSTOSPECIES )NSOMECASESINDUSTRYWIDEDATAMAYBEAVAILABLEANDAPPROPRIATEBUTCAN
NOTBEUSEDBECAUSEDOINGSOWOULDVIOLATETHECONlDENTIALITYOFTHEINDUSTRIES INVOLVED4HISISTHECASEFORMINERALACCOUNTSIN.AMIBIAWHERETHEINDUSTRYIS SOCONCENTRATEDTHATRELEASEOFDATAONINTERMEDIATECONSUMPTIONWOULDVIOLATE TRADECONlDENTIALITY)N#ANADACONSIDERABLEINTERESTHASBEENEXPRESSEDREGARD INGUSEOFTHEENERGYACCOUNTSDATATOANALYZETHEPROVINCIALECONOMICIMPLICA TIONSOFMEETINGTHECOUNTRYSTARGETSUNDERTHE+YOTO0ROTOCOL4HISCANBEDONEAT THENATIONALLEVELBUTIN!LBERTATHEMARKETESSENTIALLYCONSISTSOFONELARGECOM PANYSODATACANNOTBERELEASEDATTHEPROVINCIALLEVELWITHOUTDIVULGINGCONlDEN TIALINFORMATION %STIMATING THECAPITALCOMPONENTOF THE INPUTCOSTˆRETURN TOCAPITALPLUS
DEPRECIATIONˆPOSESADDITIONALPROBLEMS$EPRECIATIONISESTIMATEDBASEDONTHE REPLACEMENTCOSTOFTHEPRODUCEDCAPITALSTOCKUSEDINTHEINDUSTRY.OTETHATTHIS PERTAINSTOTHEMACHINERYUSEDINHARVESTINGOREXTRACTION)TSHOULDNOTBECON FUSEDWITHTHEDEPLETIONOFTHENATURALASSETITSELF 4HERETURNTOPRODUCEDCAPI TALCANBEESTIMATEDINONEOFTWOWAYS/NEISTOUSETHERATEOFRETURNELSEWHERE INTHEECONOMYWHICHASSUMESTHATTHECAPITALPUTINTOTHISSECTORWOULDBEPUT ELSEWHEREIFTHERETURNHEREWERELOWERSOTHESAMERATEOFRETURNISAPPLICABLE 4HEOTHERISTOUSETHEANNUALIZEDCOSTOFPURCHASINGTHECAPITALSTOCKUSEDINTHE RESOURCEINDUSTRYTHISMAYBEESTIMATEDUSINGTHEINTERESTRATEONBONDSORTHE RETURNONSHARESINTHEINDUSTRY "OTHOFTHESEAPPROACHESCANLEADTHEACCOUNTSTOSHOWTHEAPPARENTANOMALY
OFNEGATIVERENTSSUGGESTINGTHATPRODUCERSARENOTCOVERINGTHEIRCOSTS7ERETHIS THECASEORWEREITCONSISTENTLYTHECASEITWOULDBEDIFlCULTTOEXPLAINWHYPRO DUCERSSTAYINBUSINESS3EVERALEXPLANATIONSAREPOSSIBLE/NEMAYBETHATTHEIR CAPITALCOSTSAREINFACTFULLYPAIDOFFSOTHEYDONOTNEEDANYRETURNONTHEMIN ORDERTOEARNRENTS)NTHE3.!CAPITALISNEVERFULLYPAIDOFFUNTILITISSCRAPPEDBUT INTHEREALWORLDITCANBESOREAL WORLDDATAMAYSHOWNEGATIVERENTS!NOTHER POSSIBILITYISTHATGIVENTHELONGTIMEFRAMEINSOMERESOURCE BASEDINDUSTRIESTHE SIGNIlCANTmUCTUATIONSINWORLDPRICESANDTHEDIFlCULTYOFREALLOCATINGCAPITALIN THESHORTTERMPRODUCERSAREACCEPTINGNEGATIVERENTSINSOMEYEARSASLONGASTHE LONG TERMAVERAGEISPOSITIVE4HISISRELATEDTOTHEHIGHCOSTOFREOPENINGMINES ONCETHEYARESHUTPRODUCERSMAYPREFERTOACCEPTLOSSESINSTEADIFTHEYEXPECT THEMTOBEOFSHORTDURATION!THIRDPOSSIBILITYISTHATAPOLICYDECISIONHASBEEN MADETOKEEPCERTAINACTIVITIESGOINGEVENTHOUGHTHEYARENOTPROlTABLEINORDER TOPROJECTJOBSREDUCEINTERNATIONALDEPENDENCEORACHIEVEOTHERSOCIALGOALS
4HEUSERCOSTOR%L3ERAFYMETHODFORASSETVALUATIONDERIVESFROMANEFFORTTODIS TINGUISHTHESHAREOFINCOMEINREVENUEWHENREVENUERESULTSFROMEXPLOITATION OFANONRENEWABLEASSET%L3ERAFY 4HEMETHODWASDEVELOPEDINRESPONSE TOTHERISINGREVENUEOFOIL RICHCOUNTRIESINTHESWHENANALYSTSSOUGHTTO
INCOMEACCOUNTS 4HECONCEPTUNDERLYINGTHISMETHODISTHATSALEOFNONRENEWABLERESOURCES
INVOLVESPERMANENTLYUSINGUPANASSETWHICHREDUCESFUTUREINCOME GENERATING CAPACITY)NORDERTOENSURETHATINCOMEINFUTURETIMEPERIODSWILLBETHESAMEAS INCOMEINTHEPRESENTPERIODTOENSUREWEAKSUSTAINABILITYTHATIS SOMEPORTION OFTHISYEARSREVENUEˆTHEUSERCOSTˆWOULDHAVETOBEREINVESTEDINOTHERPROlT ABLEVENTURES4HEREMAINDERCOULDTHENBETREATEDASINCOMEANDCONSUMEDTHIS YEAR4HEPROBLEMTHEREFOREISTODETERMINEWHATPORTIONOFTHISYEARSREVENUE SHOULDBEREINVESTEDGIVENTHATTHERESTMAYBECONSIDEREDhTRUEINCOMEv !SDESCRIBEDBY%L3ERAFYTHESHAREOFINCOMEINREVENUEISDElNEDBYTHEFORMULA
8 2 R N
WHERE
8 TRUEINCOME 2 REVENUENETOFEXTRACTIONCOSTSTHISISTHESAMEASRENTORINCOME R DISCOUNTRATEAND N LIFEOFTHEASSETATTHISYEARSEXTRACTIONRATEOREXISTINGSTOCKDIVIDEDBY
THISYEARSEXTRACTION
4HUSTHESHAREOFREVENUETHATSHOULDBEREINVESTEDIS
8 2 R N
4HISFORMULATIONASSUMESTHATEXTRACTIONWILLCONTINUEATTHISYEARSRATEANDTHAT NETREVENUEWILLBECONSTANTOVERTHELIFETIMEOFTHERESOURCE)FREVENUEDOESIN FACTCHANGEFROMYEARTTOYEARTTHEACCOUNTANTUSESTHENEWlGURETOESTIMATE DEPRECIATIONINTHATYEAR)NANYGIVENYEARHOWEVERUSERCOSTANDTRUEINCOME ESTIMATESAREBASEDONTHEASSUMPTIONOFCONSTANTFUTURERECEIPTS %L3ERAFYARGUES THAT THE FIGURE FOR TOTAL INCOMEDERIVEDUSING THE FORMULA
2R NSHOULDBEENTEREDINTHENATIONALINCOMEACCOUNTSASTHEINCOMEFROM MINERALEXTRACTIONINPLACEOFTHETOTALNET REVENUE2WHICHISNOWCOUNTEDAS INCOME4HISWOULDBEDONEWHETHERORNOTANYSHAREOF2ACTUALLYWASREINVESTED 4HUSINHISVIEW'$0SHOULDBEADJUSTEDTOREmECTHIShTRUEINCOMEvFROMMINERAL EXTRACTIONINSTEADOFNETREVENUE )NPRACTICETHE%L3ERAFYAPPROACHHASNOTBEENUSEDINTHISWAY-OSTECONO
MISTSANDNATIONALINCOMEACCOUNTANTSDONOTAGREEWITH%L3ERAFYSVIEWTHATONLY THETRUEINCOMESHOULDBETREATEDASINCOMEINTHEACCOUNTS)NSTEADTHENETREV ENUEISUSUALLYCOUNTEDASINCOMEAND2n8THEAMOUNTTOBEREINVESTEDORUSER COSTISTREATEDASTHEDEPLETIONOFTHENATURALASSET4HISISSUBTRACTEDFROM'$0 ALONGWITHCONVENTIONALDEPRECIATIONTODERIVEANENVIRONMENTALLYADJUSTED.$0 !LTHOUGH%L3ERAFYEXPLICITLYDISAGREESWITHTHISAPPROACH%L3ERAFY ITIS WIDELYUSEDTOVALUETHEDEPRECIATIONOFNONRENEWABLEASSETSINENVIRONMENTAL ACCOUNTINGSYSTEMSANDISREFERREDTOASTHE%L3ERAFYMETHOD /NEADVANTAGEOFTHISMETHODISTHATITSDATAREQUIREMENTSARERELATIVELYSIMPLE
MAKINGITPOSSIBLETOCALCULATEmOWSWITHOUTHAVINGTOESTIMATETHEVALUEOFSTOCKS 7ITHINFORMATIONONTHISYEARSEXTRACTIONANDNETREVENUETHETOTALPHYSICAL SIZE
ASSUMPTIONSUNDERLYINGTHEFORMULAˆTHATREVENUEANDTHEEXTRACTIONRATEWILL REMAINCONSTANTˆAMOUNTTOANASSUMPTIONABOUTTHEVALUEOFTHESTOCKASWELL BECAUSEVALUEISSIMPLYTHEPRESENTVALUEOFTHEFUTURESTREAMOFRECEIPTS
4HECHAPTERTHUSFARHASCONSIDEREDONLYHOWTOBUILDASSETACCOUNTSFORNATURAL RESOURCES!FULLACCOUNTINGFORNATURALRESOURCESWOULDALSOPLACETHEMINTHECUR RENTACCOUNTSANDCOULDADDRESSTHEIMPACTSOFEXTERNALITIESONBOTHTHESTOCKAND mOWOFNATURALRESOURCES3OMEOFTHESEmOWSAREMARKETEDSOTHEYAREALREADY CAPTUREDINTHECONVENTIONALACCOUNTSALTHOUGHNOTDISAGGREGATED4HERESTARE NOTMARKETEDANDASEXPLAINEDINTHESECTIONTITLED7HAT#OSTS$OES0OLLUTION )MPOSEIN#HAPTERENVIRONMENTALFUNCTIONSTHATARENOTTHESUBJECTOFMARKET TRANSACTIONSARECAPTUREDBYNEITHERTHE3.!NORTHE3%%!
