The Jihadist View of Democracy

POLITICALPARTIESANDTIGHTENEDITSGRIPONSOCIETYTHROUGHREPRESSION !TTHEDAWNOFTHE)SLAMIC2EVOLUTIONOFAGAINTHECRISISOFTHE STATEINDUCEDSOMEOPENINGSBEFORETHETHEOCRATICGOVERNMENTSHUT DOWNFREEPRESSCLOSEDPOLITICALPARTIESANDGATHERINGSREPRESSEDTHE OPPOSITIONANDPUTANENDTOTHEOPENINGOFTHEPOLITICALSYSTEM4HE LATESTCASEOFPROVISIONALPOLITICALOPENINGWASTHE2EFORMISTMOVEMENT n UNDERTHEAEGISOF0RESIDENT+HATAMIWITHLIMITEDCUL TURALANDPOLITICALFREEDOM4HEADVENTOFTHE#ONSERVATIVESIN PUTANENDTOTHEPOLITICALOPENINGPROCESSONCEMORE

4HE SAMEMODEL CANBEEXTENDED TO%GYPT3YRIA ANDMOST -USLIMCOUNTRIESWITHMINORDIFFERENCES )NMOSTOF THE-USLIM WORLDWITHTHEEXCEPTIONOF4URKEY hDEMOCRATIZATIONvISTHESIGN OFACRISISINTHEPOLITICALSYSTEMANDTHESTATERATHERTHANTHEEXPRES SIONOFITSEVOLUTIONTOWARDAPLURALISTREGIME4HECONSEQUENCEIS EXTREMISMBYTHOSEWHOTRYTOEXPLOITTHEWEAKNESSOFTHESYSTEM RATHERTHANBUILDINGUPAMOREDIVERSEPOLITICALSCENE/NCETHEGOV ERNMENTOVERCOMESTHECRISISTHEDEMOCRATIZATIONPROCESSENDSAND ANEWREPRESSIONHALTSTHEPROVISIONALREFORMFORSOMETIMEUNTILTHE NEXTCRISIS%XTREMEANARCHYANDEXTREMEREPRESSIONGOHANDINHAND 4HISMODELOFTRANSITIONALDEMOCRATIZATIONANDSTABILIZEDAUTOCRACY ISTHEGENERALFEATUREOFMOSTOFTHE-USLIMWORLDPARTICULARLYTHOSE OIL RICHRENTIERSTATESWHERETHEhBLACKGOLDvGIVESTHEGOVERNMENT LEEWAYINREPRESSINGCITIZENS

)NTHELASTFEWDECADESNEWFACTORSHAVEBEENADDEDTOTHISPIC TUREWITHOUTFUNDAMENTALLYALTERINGIT/NEFACTORISTHEPRIVATIZATION ANDLIBERALIZATIONPROCESSESWITHINTHEECONOMY)NMANYPARTSOFTHE WORLDTHISHASBEENSYNONYMOUSWITHTHECONSTITUTIONOFACLASSOF INDEPENDENTENTREPRENEURSWHOBECOMEPROPONENTSOFAMOREOPEN GOVERNMENT4HISHASNOTHAPPENEDINTHEOVERWHELMINGMAJORITY OF-USLIMCOUNTRIES0RIVATIZATIONPOLICIESHAVERESULTEDINENRICHING THECLIENTELEOFTHESTATETHEMILITARYOROTHERSEGMENTSOFTHERULING ELITEWHICHHAVEUSEDITTOBECOMEMOREAFmUENTBYTAKINGADVANTAGE OFCORRUPTIONANDTRAFlCKINGINmUENCESWITHINTHESTATEAPPARATUSOR ATITSMARGIN,OWERCLASSESHAVEBEENDISPOSSESSEDOFTHEECONOMIC PROTECTIONPROVIDEDBYTHESTATETHROUGHSUBSIDIZEDPRICESFORESSEN TIALCONSUMERGOODSBREADSUGARMEATETC ANDRENTCONTROL4HEY HAVEENDUREDTHEECONOMICHARDSHIPSOFTRANSFORMATIONWITHOUTIN MOSTCASESBENElTINGFROMITSPOSITIVESIDEEFFECTSJOBCREATIONAND CONSTITUTIONOFANEWELITEDIVERSIFYINGTHEPOLITICALSYSTEMANDGIVING THEMTHEOPPORTUNITYTOEXPRESSTHEIRSOCIALASPIRATIONSINTHEPOLITICAL ARENA0OLITICALCLOSUREHASBEENCONTEMPORANEOUSWITHPRIVATIZATION ANDhLIBERALIZATIONvOFTHEECONOMY3YRIA%GYPTPOST +HOMEINI)RAN !LGERIA4UNISIAANDSOFORTH (AVINGLOSTTHESTATE CONTROLLEDSYSTEM

THATPROVIDEDTHEMWITHSOMEMEASUREOFSOCIALANDECONOMICPRO TECTIONTHEMAJORITYHASNOTWONINTHEPOLITICALORECONOMICSECTOR 4HENEWLOWERMIDDLECLASSESEMERGINGINSOCIETYSTUDENTSEDUCATED WOMENTHENEWCLASSOFENGINEERSTHENEWSMALLENTREPRENEURS ARE DEEPLYFRUSTRATEDBYTHESOCIALANDECONOMICCHANGESTHATHAVENOT ENTAILEDTHEOPENINGUPOFTHEPOLITICALSYSTEM.EW-USLIMSTATES AREMOREINSIDIOUSLYREPRESSIVEWITHINREJUVENATEDANDBETTER EDUCATED SOCIETIESINWHICHOPPORTUNITIESAREEVENSCARCERTHANBEFOREWHEN THESTATEAPPARATUSPROVIDEDALARGESTRATAOFLOWERANDLOWERMIDDLE CLASSESJOBSANDOTHERBENElTS

!NUNDERLYINGFRUSTRATIONANDAFEELINGOFBEINGhCHEATEDvARE FOUNDINMOSTOFTHE-USLIMWORLD4HISDOESNOTPROVIDEAUTOMATIC SUPPORTFOR*IHADISMBUTITATOMIZESSOCIETYANDGIVESVENTTOAHOS TILEATTITUDETOWARDTHEGOVERNMENTPROVIDINGTHEBACKGROUNDFOR *IHADISTACTIVISM)NTHESANDS)SLAMISTSWOULDNOTHAVE BEENABLETOlNDLARGESUPPORTAMONG-USLIMSBECAUSEOFTHENEW MESSAGEOFMODERNITYANDHOPEPROVIDEDBYSOCIALISTANDNATIONALIST GOVERNMENTSWHICHBROUGHTSOMEMEASUREOFSOCIALJUSTICETOTHE MASSESANDGAVEMANYPEOPLEFROMTHEMODERNIZEDSTRATATHEPARTLY ILLUSORYSENTIMENTOFHAVINGABRIGHTERFUTURE4HECOMBINATIONOF SOCIALISMANDNATIONALISMPUT)SLAMISTSONTHEDEFENSIVEREPRESSION PLAYINGITSROLEASWELL!TTHEBEGINNINGOFTHETWENTY lRSTCENTURY MOSTOFTHE!RABANDEVEN-USLIMWORLDISINTHEDOLDRUMSTHEIDE ALSOFSECULARMODERNIZATIONHAVESUBSIDEDANDNOOTHERVISIONHAS REPLACEDTHEM)NSTEADASTRONGSENSEOFBITTERNESSANDANENDURING FEELINGOFHUMILIATIONBYTHEGOVERNMENTANDTHE7ESTINALMOST EVERYRESPECTHAVEREPLACEDTHEFEELINGOFDIGNITYANDNATIONALSELF ASSERTIONOFTHEPOSTINDEPENDENCEREGIMES-USLIMSOCIETIESEARNED SOMEPRIDEFROMTHEIROPPOSITIONTOTHE7EST.ASSERS%GYPT;n =NATIONALIZEDTHE3UEZ#ANAL3YRIAS(AFEZ!SSAD;n= ASSERTED3YRIANNATIONALISMETC ANDTHEIRVICTORIOUSlGHTAGAINSTOLD COLONIALPOWERS!LGERIA4UNISIA-OROCCO $ISENCHANTMENTISNOW TOTAL4HEFEELINGOFBEINGDISPOSSESSEDOFONESPRESENTANDFUTUREIS INTENSEAMONGTHEMASSES

)NTHISCONTEXThDEMOCRACYvHASCOMETOSIGNIFYDECEPTIONBY ADUALDECEITONTHEONEHANDBY-USLIMGOVERNMENTSTHATCONCEAL THEIRAUTOCRACYINTHEGARBOFFAKEPLURALISMONTHEOTHERHANDBY THE!MERICAN GOVERNMENTWHICHDISGUISES ITS IMPOSTURE THROUGH THESUPPORTOFUNPOPULARREGIMESTHATAREITShSTOOGESv4HESENSEOF VICTIMIZATIONISSOSTRONGASTODENYTHESEGOVERNMENTSANYDEGREE OFAUTONOMYFROMTHE5NITED3TATESTHEMOSTPOWERFULREPRESENTA TIVEOF7ESTERNDOMINATIONINTHEREGION4HELATESTCASES(AMASS DEMOCRATIC ELECTIONS AND VICTORY IN *ANUARY IN 0ALESTINE

(EZBOLLAHSWINNINGOFPERCENTOFPARLIAMENTARY SEATS IN THE GENERALELECTIONOF ANDTHEOPPOSITIONOFTHE53GOVERNMENT TOBOTHCORROBORATEDTHEIDEAOF!MERICANHYPOCRISYINRELATIONTOTHE IDEOLOGYITPUBLICLYSUPPORTSASBEINGSUITABLETOTHE-USLIMWORLD NAMELYDEMOCRACY0ARAMOUNTHEREARETHEVICTIMIZATIONSENTIMENT THEECONOMICPOLITICALANDSOCIALEMBITTERMENTOFLOSTMODERNIZATION OPPORTUNITIESANDTHEDISCREDITOFTHEIDEAOFMODERNITYASEITHERUN ATTAINABLEORSIMPLYAHYPOCRITICALMEANSOFDOMINATIONBYTHE7EST )NTHISCONTEXT*IHADISTIDEOLOGYlNDSAFAVORABLEENVIRONMENTFORITS DEVELOPMENT-OST-USLIMSDONOTIDENTIFYWITHITASAREALISTICWAY OFTACKLINGGENUINESOCIALANDPOLITICALPROBLEMSONLYTHE*IHADIST MINORITYDOES BUTTHEYSEEITASASYMBOLICREVENGEAGAINSTTHE7EST ANDPARTICULARLYTHE5NITED3TATES

-USLIMSOCIETIESCRITICIZEDEMOCRACYOREVENREJECTITINPARTNOT BECAUSEOFCONCRETEEXPERIENCESBUTBECAUSEOFITSSIGNIFYINGDUPLICITY ANDDISGUISED7ESTERNDOMINATIONINAPREDICAMENTOFDEEPMISTRUST TOWARDCORRUPTNATIONALGOVERNMENTSANDVENALPOLITICALELITES$EEP VICTIMIZATIONDOESNOT ALLOWMOSTPEOPLE TO LOOK FOR REALISTIC AND PRAGMATICWAYSOFCOPINGWITHPROBLEMS4HEYTAKEREFUGEINAHO LISTICVISIONOFTHESELFANDTHEOTHERINWHICHTHEONLYWAYOFSAVING ONESHONORANDOVERCOMINGHUMILIATIONISDENIALORASELF IMPOSED CONlNEMENTINTHEIMAGINARYWORLDOFREVENGEATTHEGLOBALLEVEL4HE HOLISTICGLOBALANDMYTHOLOGICALIDEOLOGYOF*IHADISMBECOMESAWAY OFLIFEFORATINYMINORITYWHEREASITFUNCTIONSASANIMAGINARYESCAPE FORLARGEGROUPSOFPEOPLEWHOJUSTDREAMABOUTITASRETALIATIONAGAINST ANALLTOOPOWERFULENEMYTHE5NITED3TATES!LIENATED-USLIMSlND ASYMBOLICGRATIlCATIONTOTHEIRRESENTMENTAGAINSTAWORLDWITHIN WHICHTHEYBELIEVETHEYHAVENOSAY'LOBAL*IHADISAMYTHICALSOLU TIONTOAGLOBALMALAISEOFDISEMPOWERMENTINANUNJUSTWORLDWHERE -USLIMSBELIEVETHATTHEYAREDENIEDDIGNITYANDHONOR

)NTHEPASTAWARRIORSIDEOLOGYANDAMERCHANTSOUTLOOKCOM BINEDWITHAMYSTICISMDEEPLYROOTEDIN)SLAMICCULTUREBESIDESTHE LEGALORTHODOXYPROVIDEDDIVERSIlEDWAYSOFBUILDINGUP-USLIMS SELF ESTEEMINTHEWORLD#ONQUESTCOMMERCEIN)NDONESIAFORIN STANCEBETWEENTHETHIRTEENTHANDSIXTEENTHCENTURIES AND3UlSM IN#ENTRAL!SIABUTALSOIN!FRICA ASALTERNATIVESTOFORMAL)SLAMIC ORTHODOXY AND LEGALISM STRONGLY INmUENCED )SLAMIC SOCIETIES!LL THESEWAYSOFBUILDINGUPIDENTITYAREINDEEPCRISISANDTHETHRUST TOWARDMODERNITYBYNATIONALISMANDSOCIALISMAFTERINDEPENDENCE ALSOABORTEDINTHE-IDDLE%ASTAND0AKISTANINTHESECONDHALFOF THETWENTIETHCENTURY)N-USLIMSOCIETYTHEREISAPROFOUNDLOSSOF SELF CONlDENCEANDADEEPSENSEOFDISILLUSIONMENTWITHTHEWORLDAS ITISWITHTHEEXCEPTIONOF4URKEYANDTOALESSEREXTENT)NDONESIA

AND-ALAYSIA4HE*IHADISTWORLDVIEWBRINGSAGLIMMEROFHOPEASA GLOBALUTOPIAOPPOSEDTOTHECURRENTECONOMICANDPOLITICALSYSTEM THATDENIES-USLIMSANYHONORABLEPLACEINTHECONCERTOFNATIONS )TSDEATH CENTEREDCULTUREANDITSINmEXIBLECOMBATANTVIEWWHICH REJECTSOTHERSINTHENAMEOFAREPRESSIVEVERSIONOFTHERELIGIONAP PEALTOMANYWHOSEEKREFUGEINVICTIMIZATIONANDSEETHEIRIDENTITY ASAHOPELESSATTEMPTATLEADINGADIGNIlEDLIFE!NHONORABLEDEATH BECOMESASUBSTITUTEFORANUNDIGNIlEDLIFEˆANDEVENMORETHANTHAT ASHOLYDEATHISAPROMISEOFETERNALHAPPINESSINTHEAFTERLIFE

#RITICISMOFDEMOCRACYISALSOINmUENCEDBYARADICALVIEWOF REACTIONARIESANDFASCISTSINTHE7EST4HEIDEAOFTHETYRANNYOFTHE MAJORITYPUTFORWARDBY7ESTERNREACTIONARYINTELLECTUALSISREPLACED BYTHEIDOLATRYOFTHEMAJORITYWITHIN*IHADISTCIRCLES$EMOCRACYAS hMASSIlCATIONvOFCULTUREANDMORALSANDTHEALIENATIONOFTHEPEOPLE ISREPLACEDBYDEMOCRACYASALIENATING-USLIMSFROMTHEIRRELIGION 4HEIDEAOFTHEhIRRATIONALITYvOFDEMOCRACYIMPLIESTHATMASSESNEED THE)SLAMICELITENAMELYTHE*IHADIST5LAMAANDTHINKERSTOLEADTHEM ONTHERIGHTPATH$EMOCRATICOPPRESSIONAGAINSTMINORITIESSUCHAS ETHNICGROUPSANDFEMINISTSINTHESISTURNEDINTOTHENOTION OFDEMOCRACYASANOPPRESSIVERULEDIRECTEDAGAINSTTHEMINORITYOF DEVOUT-USLIMSBYABRUTISHMAJORITY$EMOCRACYASTHEAPOGEEOF SECULARIZATIONISSYNONYMOUSWITHGODLESSNESS

4HESOCIETALCONTEXTWITHIN-USLIMCOUNTRIESGIVESANUTTERLY NEGATIVEMEANING TO DEMOCRACYWITH FEW EXCEPTIONS &ORMANY PEOPLEINTHE-USLIMWORLDDEMOCRACYMEANSADISGUISEDDOMINA TIONORCHESTRATEDBYTHE7ESTTHROUGHCORRUPT-USLIMGOVERNMENTS AGAINST-USLIMSOCIETIES-USLIMSAREHOSTAGESANDCANNOTBEFREED BUTTHROUGHLEGITIMATEVIOLENCEEMBODIEDIN*IHAD$EMOCRACYISALSO DENOUNCEDASANALIENCULTURETHATSERVESASAPRETEXTFORDESTROYING )SLAMICCULTUREANDWAYOFLIFEINTHENAMEOFAHERETICALMODERNITY &ORMALASPECTSOFDEMOCRACYASMASKFORCLASSDOMINATIONORIMPERI ALISMINCOMMUNISTDOCTRINEHAVEBEENTRANSFORMEDINTOAN)SLAMIC REJECTIONOFPLURALISMEMBODIEDINTHEDOMINATIONOF-USLIMSBY SECULAR:IONISTOR#RUSADERELITES4HEFACTTHAT)SRAELISADEMOC RACY IS VIEWED AS A NEGATIVE SYMBOL IN THE-IDDLE%AST A REGIME THATOPPRESSES-USLIMSCANNOTBEALEGITIMATEONE4HEINVASIONOF !FGHANISTANAND)RAQBYTHE5NITED3TATESANDITS7ESTERNALLIESAND THEIRCLAIMTOSPREADDEMOCRACY THEREAREBRANDISHEDAGAINAS THE CLEARDOMINATIONOF-USLIMSBY!MERICANSINTHEGUISEOFPOLITICAL PLURALISM,ADENWITHVICTIMIZATIONANDADEEPRESENTMENTPARTOFTHE -USLIMWORLDACCEPTSTHESELOOSEASSERTIONSASSTRONGEVIDENCEAGAINST DEMOCRACY)NTHISCONTEXTTHETHEOLOGICALCRITIQUEOFDEMOCRACYAS 7ESTERNSECULAR#RUSADERSOR:IONISTSOPPRESSIONAGAINST)SLAMlNDS

SYMPATHETICEARSAMONGMANY-USLIMSWHODONOTCONCRETELYKNOW ANYTHINGABOUTITBESIDESTHEIREXPERIENCESOFFAILUREANDOPPRESSION BY REPRESSIVE REGIMES ANDOF CULTURAL ANDPOLITICAL DOMINATIONBY ARROGANT7ESTERNPOWERS

)NTHE-USLIMWORLDTHEPOLITICALSCENEISALSOINADEEPCRISIS 4HREE TYPESOFPOLITICALPARTIES EMERGED IN THE LASTlFTYYEARS THE SECULARNATIONALISTTHE)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISTANDTHERADICAL)SLAMIST THATWASREPRESSEDANDFROMTIMETOTIMESUBJUGATEDANDTOLERATEDBY THESTATEINITSLESSEXTREMISTFRINGES3ECULARPOLITICSWASTHEOUTCOME OFINDEPENDENCEMOVEMENTSIN.ORTH!FRICAORTHEMODERNIZATION OF THE STATE THROUGH THE RENEWALOFPOWERELITESOFMILITARYORIGIN .ASSERIN%GYPT1ADHAlIN,IBYA3ADDAM(USSEININ)RAQETC OR THEESTABLISHMENTOFFASCIST TYPEPOLITICALPARTIES"ATHINBOTH)RAQ AND3YRIA &UNDAMENTALISTPARTIESEMERGEDTODEFEND)SLAMICVALUES AGAINSTTHEBACKGROUNDOFSECULARMODERNIZATIONTHEMAJORMODELIN THE-USLIMWORLDBEINGTHE-USLIM"ROTHERHOODIN%GYPT2ADICAL )SLAMISTPARTIESAREMORERECENTANDTHEIRBIRTHISDUETOTHEFAILURE OF&UNDAMENTALISTPARTIESTODISLODGESECULARAUTOCRACIESFROMPOWER &UNDAMENTALISTPARTIESPLAYANAMBIVALENTROLETHEYAGREEWITH*IHAD ISTSONCULTURALANDPOLITICALISSUESNAMELYTHEREJECTIONOF7ESTERN IZATIONWITHINTHEFAMILYANDMOREGENERALLYINTHECIVILSPHEREON THEDESIRETOESTABLISHAN)SLAMICPOLITICALSYSTEMANDTHERETURNTO RELIGIONASTHEBASICSOURCEOFINSPIRATIONINPOLITICSSOCIETYCULTURE ANDECONOMY4HEYBELIEVETHEYCANATTAINTHISGOALTHROUGHPEACE FULMEANSANDPARTICIPATIONINTHEPOLITICALPROCESSWHEREAS*IHADISTS ARECONVINCEDTHATITCANNOTBEACHIEVEDEXCEPTTHROUGHHOLYWAR &UNDAMENTALISTPARTIESLIKETHE-USLIM"ROTHERHOOD%GYPT (IZBU 4AHRIR3YRIA AND*USTICEAND$EVELOPMENT-OROCCO THEREFOREPLAY ANAMBIVALENTROLEIN-USLIMSOCIETIESTHEYCONTESTTHEMONOPOLYOF POWERBYTHEOLDANDDISCREDITEDPOSTINDEPENDENCEELITESANDACCEPT PLAYINGTHEhDEMOCRATICvROLETHROUGHELECTIONSBUTTHEIRGOALISTO PUTANENDINADISTANTFUTURETOTHESECULARPOLITICALSYSTEMTHATIS THEINDISPENSABLEMEANSOFPRESERVINGPOLITICALPLURALISM*IHADISTS SEEKTHEENDOFPOLITICALPARTIESANDARETURNTO)SLAMICRULEBYTHE EMIRSANDTHECONSTITUTIONOFACALIPHATEINWHICHA-USLIM5LAMA OF*IHADISTLEANINGWILLRULESOCIETYINSTEADOFTHEhIGNORANTvPEOPLE WHOCONSTITUTETHEMAJORITYOFTHEPOPULATION

&UNDAMENTALISTPARTIESINTHE-USLIMWORLDCANOPENUPTHE POLITICALSCENEBUTTHEYCANALSOBECOMEANOBSTACLETODEMOCRATIZA TIONIFTHEYBECOMETHERULINGELITE4HEYAREABULWARKAGAINSTTHE MONOPOLYOFPOWERBYRULINGCASTESASLONGASTHEYAREAMINORITY WITHINTHEOPPOSITION)FTHEYACCEDETOPOWERTHEIRPATTERNOFCONDUCT ISNOTPREDICTABLEINADVANCE4HEYMIGHTADOPTTHE4ALIBANMODEL

REPRESSIVEANDREGRESSIVE ORTHE4URKISHONERESPECTFULTOWARDDE MOCRACY THEOUTCOMEBEINGDEPENDENTONTHECULTURALHISTORICAL ANDPOLITICALCONTEXT)N4URKEYTHEMILITARYARETHEBULWARKAGAINST THEABSOLUTEDOMINATIONOFRELIGIOUSPARTIES)N!FGHANISTANANDSOME OTHER-USLIMCOUNTRIESWITHAMORERECENTHISTORYOFMODERNIZATION THECOUNTERVAILINGPOWERDOESNOTNECESSARILYEXIST4HE&UNDAMENTAL ISTSHAVEANAMBIVALENTPOSITIONINRELATIONTOPOLITICALPLURALISMAND THE)SLAMICRADICALSCANOUTmANKTHEMONCETHEYHOLDPOWER

*IHADISMFEEDSONTHREEMAJOR-USLIMCOUNTRIESALLOFTHEM 53ALLIES%GYPT3AUDI!RABIAAND0AKISTAN)NALLTHREETHEPREMISES SETOUTABOVEAREVERIlEDLACKOFDEMOCRATICGOVERNMENTABSENCE OFDEMOCRATICEXPERIENCEANDACULTURALANDSOCIALENVIRONMENTIN WHICHDEMOCRACYISLADENWITHANEGATIVESYMBOLICCONTENT!CLOSED POLITICALSCENECHARACTERIZESALLOFTHESECOUNTRIESWHEREFRUSTRATIONAND DISCONTENTCANlNDNOPOLITICALSOLUTIONS!LLHAVEDEEPPOLITICALAND CULTURALPROBLEMSANDTHEIRGOVERNMENTSPROPOSENOVIABLEECONOMIC SOLUTIONSFORTHEFUTURE4HEPOLITICALSTRUCTUREISABULWARKAGAINSTANY REALOPENINGANDTHEONLYSOLUTIONCONSISTSINCO OPTINGSOME)SLAMIC &UNDAMENTALISTS TAMED IN THEPROCESS OF THEIR INTEGRATIONWITHIN THEPOLITICALSYSTEMBECOMINGTHUSPARTOFTHEESTABLISHMENTLIKEIN -OROCCO!LGERIA ORlNDINGASUBSERVIENTROLEINTHELEGISLATURELIKE %GYPT *IHADISMREINVIGORATESTHISSITUATION)NSOMECOUNTRIESSEG MENTSOFTHESTATEAPPARATUSUSUALLYPARTOFTHEINTELLIGENCESERVICES ORTHEARMYORBOTH COLLABORATEWITH*IHADISTCIRCLES!SEGMENTOF THEINTELLIGENCESERVICESˆIN0AKISTANTHE)NTER 3ERVICES)NTELLIGENCE )3) IN!LGERIATHE$£PARTEMENTDU2ENSEIGNEMENTETDELA3£CURIT£ $23 ANDIN3AUDI!RABIAPARTOFTHE3AUDI)NTELLIGENCE3ERVICEˆIS MOREORLESSCOOPERATINGWITH*IHADISTSTOVENTTHEIRRESENTMENTAGAINST THEPOLITICALSYSTEM4HECONTINUINGlGHTAGAINST*IHADISTSGIVESPOLITI CALLEGITIMACYTOTHEREGIMESINTHE7ESTASBEINGTHEONLYBULWARK AGAINSTRADICAL)SLAM4HEWARAGAINST)SLAMICTERRORISMJUSTIlESTHE CLOSUREOFTHEPOLITICALSYSTEMANDTHEINDElNITEPOSTPONEMENTOFA MOREOPENPOLITICALREGIME)NTHISSITUATIONVICTIMIZEDANDDEEPLY SUSPICIOUS-USLIMSlNDNEWREASONSTODENOUNCE!MERICANDUPLICITY 4HEPICTUREISCOMPLETEDASWELLBY!MERICANINCOHERENCEANDBIASES ANDBYALACKOFCONTINUITYIN53FOREIGNPOLICY

$EMOCRACYASTHE.EW&ALSE7ESTERN2ELIGION )MPORTEDINTOTHE,ANDOF)SLAM

4HE ATTITUDE TOWARD DEMOCRACY ISMAINLY DIVIDED AMONG THREE MAJOR)SLAMICGROUPSTHE2EFORMISTSTHE&UNDAMENTALISTSANDTHE

*IHADISTS2EFORMISTSASSERTTHATTHEREISNOINCOMPATIBILITYBETWEEN POLITICALPLURALISMAND!LLAHSRELIGION-ANYFUNDAMENTALPRINCIPLES OFDEMOCRACYAREFOUNDINTHE+ORANANDINTHE0ROPHETICTRADITIONS ACCORDINGTOTHEM

&ORTHE&UNDAMENTALISTSDEMOCRACYIN-USLIMCOUNTRIESCAN BEABLESSING-USLIMSCANGAINACCESSTOPARLIAMENTSANDTAKEHOLD OFPARTOFTHEPOLITICALPOWERTHATWOULDBEOTHERWISEDENIEDTOTHEM UNDERAUTOCRATICREGIMES4HE-USLIM"ROTHERHOODIN%GYPTANDTHEIR OFFSHOOTSINOTHER!RABCOUNTRIESACCEPTPLAYINGTHEPARLIAMENTARIAN GAMETOGAINAPOLITICALFOOTHOLDANDSPREADTHE)SLAMICFAITHWORKING AGAINSTSECULARPOLITICALTENDENCIES)NTHE7ESTCOMMONSENSEPROVES THATDEMOCRACYCANNOTBEPUTINTOQUESTIONANDTHAT-USLIMSCANNOT ACCEDETOPOWERWITHOUTACCEPTINGDEMOCRATICPREMISES4HEREFORE MANY)SLAMICGROUPSSUBSCRIBETODEMOCRACYSOASTOSPREAD)SLAM PEACEFULLYANDINTHEFUTUREGIVE-USLIMSASAYINTHEPOLITICALSYSTEM )NTHE-USLIMWORLDTHEYSEEKACOMPROMISEWITHTHEAUTHORITARIAN REGIMESTHATWOULDOTHERWISERULEAGAINSTTHEM

5NLIKE&UNDAMENTALISTS*IHADISTSAREOPPOSEDTOTHEPARLIAMEN TARYSYSTEMˆANDMOREGENERALLYTODEMOCRACYˆBECAUSEITISFROM THEIRPOINTOFVIEWANEWIDOLATRYFRONTALLYOPPOSEDTO)SLAM4HEIR ATTITUDE TOWARDDEMOCRACY IS EVENMORE ANTAGONISTIC THAN TOWARD AUTOCRATICREGIMESBECAUSETHEYPERCEIVEINTHEFORMERAMAJORTHREAT TO)SLAMWHEREASDESPOTICREGIMESINTHE-USLIMWORLDPRESENTNO IDEOLOGICALALTERNATIVETO!LLAHSRELIGION$EMOCRACYISAFORMIDABLE ENEMYENDOWEDWITHANAUTONOMOUSIDEOLOGYOFITSOWNUNIVER SALPRETENDINGTOBETHEBESTPOLITICALANDSOCIALSYSTEMANDHAVING THEREFOREAHEGEMONICVISTATHATMAKESITFROMTHE*IHADISTSPERSPEC TIVE ANEWRELIGION4HIShFAITHvPROMISESEQUALITYBEFORE THE LAW EQUALOPPORTUNITYFORALLTHEENDOFDISCRIMINATIONANDUNJUSTIlED PRIVILEGESANDAPOLITICALSYSTEMTOWHICHEVERYCITIZENCANEQUALLY PARTICIPATEHISORHERVOICEBEINGEQUALTOTHEOTHERSINDEPENDENTLY OFTHEIRRELIGION4HESETENETSARECONTRARYTOTRADITIONAL)SLAMBUT ALSOTRADITIONAL#ATHOLICISM*UDAISMANDEVEN0ROTESTANT#HRISTIAN ITY BECAUSETHEYDISREGARDRELIGIOUSBELONGINGANDTHEIMPORTANCEOF FAITHANDMOREGENERALLYTHEYDONOTTAKEINTOACCOUNTRELIGIONAS THEPILLAROFTHEPOLITICALORDER

*IHADISTSDEVOTEALARGEBODYOFLITERATURETOCOMBATDEMOCRACY 4HEYCONSIDERTHISNEWhFAITHvATERRIFYINGENEMY&OR!BU1ATADA

4HEREISNODOUBTTHATDEMOCRACYISARELIGIONANDINITSPRINCIPLE ITISARELIGIONTHATISSETAGAINSTTHERELIGIONOF!LLAHINALLRESPECTS $EMOCRACYINTRODUCESDISSENSIONAMONGALLFAITHSBETHEYCELESTIAL

OREARTHLY4HECLOSESTTOITISTHERELIGIONOF3UlSM3UlSM ISBASEDONUNITYOFEXISTENCEANDDIVERGENCEWITH)SLAMICLAWWITH RESPECT TOHUNGER ;FASTING=AND RELIGIOUS RETREAT4HOSEWHO BELIEVEINTHE3UlFAITHARE(ERETICS4HESAMEHOLDSTRUEFOR DEMOCRACYANDTHEDEMOCRATS$EMOCRATICBELIEFISTHESOVEREIGNTY OFTHEPEOPLEINLEGISLATIVEEXECUTIVEANDJUDICIALMATTERS4HIS SUPERSEDES!LLAHSSOVEREIGNTYEVENIF(ESPEAKSONTHOSEMATTERS INTHE"OOK;+ORAN=ANDTHE0ROPHETICTRADITION3OMEONEWHO ACTSTHATWAYISAHERETICANDTHEREISNODOUBTABOUTHISDISBELIEF 4HOSEWHODONOTCONDEMNHIMRELIGIOUSLYARE(ERETICSLIKEHIM UNLESSTHEYAREIGNORANTPEOPLE

!BU1ATADACOMPARESDEMOCRACYWITH3UlSM3HIISMAND*AHMI YAH&ORHIMTHISTYPEOFDISBELIEFISNOTNEWANDONLYADDSTOTHE LONGLISTOFHERETICS$EMOCRACYISARELIGIONNOTINAMETAPHORICALSENSE BUTINALITERALONEANDTHEREFORETHEWARAGAINSTITISARELIGIOUSWAR *USTAS*EWSAND#HRISTIANSWHOMHEGROUPSWITHTHEWORSTKINDOF 3HIITESSHOULDBEFOUGHTBY*IHADSOSHOULDADHERENTSOFDEMOCRACY 4HEONLYWAYTODEALWITHTHEMISTOSUBDUEORKILLTHEM

-AQDISISATTITUDETOWARDDEMOCRACYISNOTFUNDAMENTALLYDIF FERENTFROM!BU1ATADAS

4HOSEWHODESIREDEMOCRACYASARELIGIONINSUBSTITUTIONTO!LLAHS RELIGIONBECOMEHERETICALYAKFERUN $EMOCRACYISARELIGION INVENTEDIN'REECE/BVIOUSLYITISNOT!LLAHSRELIGIONANDTHEREFORE ITCANNOTBETHE4RUTHHAQ $EMOCRACYAND)SLAMCANNOTBE COMPATIBLESINCE!LLAHDOESNOTACCEPTANYTHINGBUT)SLAMAND )SLAM IS THE EXCLUSIVE!LLAHS RELIGION THAT STIPULATES LEGISLATION ANDTHECOMMANDMENTOF!LLAHALONE$EMOCRACYISAHERETICAL ANDUNFAITHFULRELIGIONTHATSTIPULATESCOMMANDMENTSANDLAWS ACCORDINGTOTHEPEOPLENOTTO!LLAHAND!LLAHTHE'RACEFULDOES NOTACCEPTTHATPEOPLEMIXUPHERESYAND)SLAMORTHEDISBELIEFAND THE5NITY;OF!LLAH=,IKEWISEASITISFORBIDDENIN)SLAMTOBE ATTHESAMETIMEA-USLIMANDA#HRISTIANORA-USLIMANDA*EW !LLAHDOESNOTACCEPTFROMSOMEONETOBEA-USLIMANDAPARTISAN OFDEMOCRACYBECAUSE)SLAMIS!LLAHSRELIGIONAND$EMOCRACYIS AHERETICALRELIGION!CCORDINGTOTHE+ORANIFSOMEONEDESIRESA RELIGIONOTHERTHAN)SLAMITWONTBEACCEPTEDFROMHIMANDHE WILLBEAMONGTHELOSERSINTHEDAYOF2ESURRECTION

$EMOCRACYISNOTMERELYAPOLITICALORGANIZATIONITISASYSTEM OFBELIEFTHATENCOMPASSESTHERELATIONTOTHE!BSOLUTE)TSKEYSTONE

ISTHERECOGNITIONTHATHUMANBEINGSCANLEGISLATEINANAUTONOMOUS MANNER4HISISINCONTRADICTIONTOTHE(OLY+ORANWHICHHASBROUGHT TOTHEWORLD!LLAHSLEGISLATIONWHICHISPERFECTANDABSOLUTE"ELIEV INGTHATHUMANBEINGSAREABLETOPROPOSEANDAPPLYHUMAN MADE LAWSISANARROGANTANDUNBEARABLEBLASPHEMYTOWARD!LLAHANDHAS TOBEREJECTEDASPUREDISBELIEF4HISATTITUDEISNOTUNLIKETHATOFTHE REACTIONARYDEFENDERSOFTHE#ATHOLIC#HURCHANDTHE/LD2EGIME AFTERTHE&RENCH2EVOLUTIONDEMOCRACYISAGAINST'ODSWILLTORULE THEWORLDACCORDINGTO(ISLAWS

$EMOCRACYMEANSPUTTING!LLAHONAPARWITHHUMANSANDTHIS ISNOTHINGBUTDISBELIEF!NYPOLITICALSYSTEMTHATENCROACHESUPON !LLAHSPRIVILEGETORULEOVERHUMANKINDISHERETICAL)NTHISRESPECT DEMOCRACYAUTOCRACYANDDICTATORSHIPAREALIKETHEYAREALLAGAINSTTHE RULEOF!LLAH)NAWAY*IHADISTSAREBLINDTOTHEDIFFERENCESBETWEEN DEMOCRACYANDDESPOTISM4HEYIMPLICITLYBELIEVETHATDEMOCRACYIS MOREDANGEROUSTHANAUTOCRACYBECAUSEOFITSSEDUCTIVEIDEOLOGYAND ITSFOREIGN7ESTERNORIGINWHICHMAKESITGLAMOROUS

$EMOCRACYISCLOSELYASSOCIATEDWITHTHEMODERNINTERNATIONAL SYSTEMEGTHE5NITED.ATIONS ANDMODERNMEDIAh4HOSERULERS WHORECOGNIZETHE5NITED.ATIONSANDTHEIRRULINGSAREINlDELSFORTHIS REASON)NTHESAMEWAYTHEAFFAIRSOFIDOLATROUS!RABSANDTHOSEOF IDOLATROUS7ESTERNERSAND%ASTERNERSAMONGTHEM#HRISTIANS"UD DHISTSCOMMUNISTS(INDUSANDTHELIKEAREHIDDENONLYTOBLIND EYES4HOSEWHOmOUT!LLAHSRELIGIONARE)NlDELS4HESAMEHOLDS FORTHOSEWHOALLOWITTHROUGHTHERADIOOR46ORELSETHROUGHTHE UNFAITHFULLICENTIOUSNEWSAGENCIESTHATPROTECTTHEMWITHTHEIRLAWS ANDARMIESv$EMOCRACYSETSFREEDOMOFFAITHANDTHESUPREMACYOF HUMAN MADELAWOVER!LLAHSLAWh4HEYBELIEVEINARELIGIONWHICH THEYPUTHIGHERTHAN!LLAHAND(ISCOMMANDMENTSANDTHEIRLAWS IMPOSEONTHEMTHEFREEDOMOFBELIEFANDTHERIGHTTOLIVEINSPITEOF THEFACTTHATTHESEAREAPOSTATESINTHERELIGIONOF!LLAHv

)NANOTHERBOOK-AQDISIDEVELOPSHISIDEASINAMOREPOLEMI CALWAY

$EMOCRACYISAHERETICALRELIGIONWITHREPREHENSIBLEINNOVATIONS )TSWORSHIPPERSPUTLEGISLATORSASGODSANDTHEIRFOLLOWERSASBE LIEVERS4HISDIRTYWORDIS'REEKANDNOT!RABICANDITISTHE INCORPORATIONOFTWOWORDSDEMOSSIGNIFYINGPEOPLEANDKRATOSTHE GOVERNMENTORTHEDOMINATIONORTHELEGISLATIONANDTHEMEANING OFTHISBYTHEVERBALTRANSLATIONISTHEGOVERNMENTOFTHEPEOPLE ORTHEDOMINATIONOFTHEPEOPLEORTHELEGISLATIONOFTHEPEOPLE !NDTHISISTHEMOSTSIGNIlCANTMEANINGOFDEMOCRACYBYITSPRO

PONENTSANDTHEYMAKEITSPRAISETOYOUTHE0EOPLEWHOBELIEVE INTHE5NITYOF!LLAH4HISISATTHESAMETIMEONEOFTHEMOST PROMINENTFEATURESOF5NBELIEFKUFR AND(ERESYSHIRK ANDTHE 7RONGBATIL THATCONTRADICTS)SLAMANDTHERELIGIONOFTHE5NITY OF!LLAHATMOST)NITSREALITYDEMOCRACYISDOMINATIONOFTHE MULTITUDEOR THEMAJORITY OF THEPEOPLE THEHIGHESTPROTECTORS OFDEMOCRACYBEINGSECULARISTSANDAFlLIATESOF THIS RELIGION "UTWHAT REMAINS IN REALITY TODAY IS THEPUBLICGOVERNMENTOF THEELITESANDTHEIRGANGSWHOARECLOSETOTHEMWITHFAMILYTIES ORTHEMOSTPOWERFULBUSINESSMENANDTHERICHESTWHOAREATTHE TOPOFTHEWEALTHANDDOMINATETHEMEDIA4HROUGHTHEMTHEY AREABLETOGETINTOUCHORCONNECTTOTHEPARLIAMENTTHEPLACEOF DEMOCRACY WHENEVERTHEYLIKEINTHESAMEWAYASTHEIRHEADTHE KINGORTHEGOVERNOR CANDISMISSTHEPARLIAMENTORGETINTOUCH WITHITWHENEVERHEWANTSANDASHEWANTS

"ORROWINGASIMPLIlEDVERSIONOFTHE-ARXISTCRITIQUEOFDE MOCRACY-AQDISIBELIEVES THATWEALTHYBUSINESSMENMAlACHIEFS ANDMEDIAPOWERHOLDERSARETHEACTUALRULERSNOTTHOSEELECTEDBY THEPARLIAMENTARYSYSTEM&ORHIMANDTHERULEOFTHEMAJORITYIS NOTHINGBUTAlGUREHEADTHATCOVERSUPTHEREALPOWERTHEMAJORITY ISTHEVICTIMOFTHERULEOFATINYMINORITYOFUNSCRUPULOUSMIGHTY PEOPLEWHOHIDETHEIRPOWERUNDERTHEGUISEOFPLURALISM)NTHIS WAYDEMOCRACYISDOUBLYILLEGITIMATEITISAGAINST!LLAHSSYSTEMAND UNTRUTHFULTOITSVERYPRINCIPLESTHERULEOFTHEMAJORITY

-AQDISISUMMARIZESHISCRITIQUEOFDEMOCRACYBYTREATINGITAS ANILLEGITIMATEOFFSHOOTOFSECULARISMWHICHINHISVIEWISNOTHING BUTAFAKERELIGIONh$EMOCRACYISTHEFRUITOFMISCHIEVOUSSECULARISM ILMANIYA ANDISITSBASTARDBECAUSESECULARISMISAHERETICALRELIGION THATINTENDSTOSEPARATERELIGIONANDLIFEORDISJOINRELIGIONFROMTHE GOVERNMENTANDTHEJUDICIARYv$EMOCRATICFREEDOMINTHISRESPECT ISNOTHINGPOSITIVEITISTRESPASSINGONONESLIMITSANDINFRINGINGONTHE LIMITSSETBY!LLAHFORCREATURESh4HISISDEMOCRATICFREEDOMFREEDOM FROMTHERELIGIONOF!LLAHANDITSLAWSANDTRESPASSINGITSBOUNDARIES BYTHEIRSTINKINGDEMOCRACYDEMOQRATIHUMALAlNA v

4HE ADVOCATES OF DEMOCRACYWITHIN-USLIM CIRCLES REFER TO MANYEVENTSWITHIN)SLAMICHISTORYTOPROVEITSLEGITIMACY-AQDISI ENUMERATESTHEMONEAFTERTHEOTHERANDREJECTSTHEMSUCCESSIVELY /NEARGUMENTPUTFORWARDBYTHE-USLIMDEMOCRATSISTHESO CALLED ATTITUDEOF9USIFTOWARDTHE0HARAOH!NOTHERONEISTHECONDUCTOF THE0ROPHETTOWARDTHEKINGOF%THIOPIA.AJASHI 4HETHIRDISTHE CLAIMTHATDEMOCRACYISNOTHINGBUT)SLAMICCOUNSELING3HURA AS

ISMENTIONEDINTHE+ORAN"UTALLTHESEARGUMENTSAREACCORDINGTO -AQDISIMEREFALLACY(EENUMERATESTHEMINDETAIL

4HElRSTFALLACY;PUTFORWARDBYTHEFOLLOWERSOF$EMOCRACY=4HE CONDUCTOF9USIFTOWARDTHE+INGOF%GYPT$IDNT9USIFTAKEUP THEPOSITIONOFAMINISTERTOWARDTHEHERETICAL+INGWHODIDNOT GOVERNACCORDINGTOWHAT!LLAHHADSENT;THE+ORAN=4HEREFORE ITISPERMITTEDTOTAKEPARTINTHEHERETICALGOVERNMENTSANDEVEN ENTERPARLIAMENTSANDHOUSESOFREPRESENTATIVESANDTHEIRLIKES ;!NSWER=4HEREFERENCETOTHISMISINTERPRETATIONFORENTERINGTHE LEGISLATIVEPARLIAMENTSANDITSJUSTIlCATIONISWRONGBECAUSETHESE HERETICALPARLIAMENTSAREBASEDONARELIGIONTHATISOTHERTHANTHE RELIGIONOF!LLAHWHEREASAT9USIF STIMETHEREWASNOSUCHRELIGION ASYET 4HE SECOND FALLACY THEY SAY THAT.AJASHI ;+INGOF%THIOPIA= DIDNOTRULEACCORDINGTOTHE7ORDOF!LLAH!FTERHECONVERTEDTO )SLAMHEREMAINEDTHESAMEUPTOHISDEATHANDNEVERTHELESSTHE 0ROPHETCALLEDHIMAGOOD-USLIMANDAFTERHISDEATHHEMADEA PRAYERBEFOREHISCORPSEANDORDEREDHISDISCIPLESTODOTHESAME 4HEANSWERISTHAT!L.AJASHIDIEDBEFORETHE+ORANWASCOMPLETELY REVEALED

-AQDISI IS QUICK TO QUOTE FROM THE+ORAN THOSE VERSES THAT DENOUNCEGODLESSUNBELIEVINGUNGRATEFULANDHERETICALMAJORITIES #ONTRARYTOEXTREME LEFTIDEOLOGIESACCORDINGTOWHICHTHEMASSES AREALIENATEDONLYBECAUSEOFTHEPREVAILINGSOCIALSYSTEMCAPITALISM EXPLOITATIONETC )SLAMICRADICALSBELIEVETHATMAJORITIESAREWRONG INPRINCIPLE ANDUNABLE TOlND THE RIGHTPATHWITHOUT A RELIGIOUS LEADER)NTRADITIONAL)SLAMTHISENTAILEDTHEPROMOTIONOFTHEhCALIPHv .OWADAYSTHISMEANSNOTHINGOTHERTHANANAUTOCRATICOROLIGARCHIC SYSTEMINWHICHTHELEADERISRIGHTAGAINSTTHEMASSESh4HELAWOF !LLAHAND(ISRELIGIONINDICATETHEDEPRAVATIONOFTHEMAJORITYAND THEIRCORRUPTIONANDTHEREFORE!LLAHRULES@4HECOMMANDMENTAC CRUESONLYTO!LLAHv

4OSUSTAINHISARGUMENTAGAINSTDEMOCRACY-AQDISIEMBARKS UPONTHEGENEALOGYOFDEMOCRACYANDITSHISTORICALBACKGROUND

$EMOCRACYINITSFORMANDCONTENTGREWUPINTHELANDOF(ERETICS AND)NlDELSANDmOURISHEDATTHESOURCEOFGODLESSNESSANDDEPRAV ITYIN%UROPEWHENTHEYSEPARATEDRELIGIONFROMLIFE4HISWORDTAKES ROOTINTHATENVIRONMENTWHICHBEARSALLTHOSEPOISONSANDDEPRAVA TIONS)NITSROOTSITHASNORELATIONTOTHELANDSOF&AITH;)SLAMIC COUNTRIES=ANDTHEREISNOTASHREDOFBELIEFORBENEVOLENCEINIT

)TCOULDNOTASSUREITSPERMANENTEXISTENCEINTHE7ESTOTHERWISE THANAFTERTHESEPARATIONOFRELIGIONANDGOVERNMENTTHERE)TDID AUTHORIZEHOMOSEXUALITYFORNICATION;SEXUALRELATIONSHIPWITHOUT MARRIAGE=ANDALCOHOLANDTHEPROMISCUITYOFTHEKINSHIPMEMBERS ANDBESIDESTHISOTHERPROSTITUTIONSOBVIOUSORHIDDEN4HEREFORE THEREISNOWAYOFPUTTINGITASEQUALTO)SLAMIC#OUNCIL3HURA UNLESSFORTWOREASONSEXCLUDINGATHIRDONEEITHERTHEDEMOCRAT ISAGODLESSMANORASTUPIDANDIGNORANTONE

0OLITICALHERESYANDDEVIANTMORESARECLOSELYINTERTWINEDDEMOCRACY ISACORRUPTPOLITICALSYSTEMTHATISROOTEDINADEPRAVEDSOCIETYOFTHE 3ODOMAND'OMORRAHTYPEWHEREMORALITYANDRELIGIOUSINTERDIC TIONSARESIMPLYIGNORED4HEASSOCIATIONOFDEMOCRACYWITHSEXUAL ANDSOCIALDEPRAVATIONARECONSTANTAMONG*IHADISTSANDTHEIRDEEP BELIEFISTHATONEISTHECONSEQUENCEOFTHEOTHERGODLESSNESSBREEDSA HERETICALPOLITICALSYSTEMTHATINTURNENCOURAGESDEPRAVITYINSEXUAL RELATIONSDESTROYINGTHEFOUNDATIONSOFFAMILY

-AQDISI VIGOROUSLYDENOUNCES THE TWOOTHER FALLACIES AS AD VANCEDBYSOME-USLIMSTHE-USLIM"ROTHERHOODANDOTHERS TO JUSTIFYTHEIRPARTICIPATIONINTHEPARLIAMENTARYSYSTEMINTHENAME OF)SLAM

4HEFOURTHFALLACYISTHEREFERENCETOTHECOOPERATIONOFTHE0ROPHET WITHTHEGROUPOF&ODHUL;AGROUP-OHAMMADFOUNDEDATTHE AGEOFTWENTY lVETOHELPTHEDOWNTRODDENBEFOREHAVINGHIS 2EVELATIONOF0ROPHETHOOD=3OMEOF THESE IDIOTS ;WHOEQUATE DEMOCRACYWITH )SLAM= REASON ABOUT THE PARTICIPATION OF THE 0ROPHETINTHEALLIANCEOF&ODHULBEFOREBEINGELECTEDBY!LLAHAS 0ROPHETSOASTOJUSTIFYTHEIRCOOPERATIONWITHHERETICALLEGISLA TIVEPARLIAMENTS ;!LLAHSAYSINTHE+ORAN=h$OYOUBELIEVEYOUARELEFTWITHOUT OBLIGATIONTOWARD!LLAH2ESURRECTION h$OYOUTHINKTHAT 7ECREATEDYOUINVAINv!L-UMINUN 3TILLINTHEDEMOCRATICRELIGIONANDITSCOMMUNITYTHEREISNO PLACEFORTHESESOLIDVERSESBECAUSETHEHUMANBEINGISHIMSELFTHE LEGISLATOR4HEYSAYYESMANISLEFTWITHOUTOBLIGATIONANDHEHAS THEABSOLUTELIBERTYTOCHOOSEANDDECIDEANDLEAVEANDIMPOSEWHAT HEWANTSTORELIGIONTHROUGHLEGISLATION!NDITISNOTIMPORTANT WHETHERTHELEGISLATIONHEINVENTEDISINAGREEMENTWITHTHE"OOK OF!LLAHORINCONTRADICTIONTOIT 4HElFTHMISINTERPRETATIONIS;BASEDONTHEFACTTHATTHEYPLAY THEDEMOCRATICGAME=FORTHEBENElTOFCALLINGTHEOTHERSTO)SLAM MASLIHA AL DAWA 4HEY SAY TO ENTER THE PARLIAMENT PRESENTS

MANY ADVANTAGES IT IS A RECORDED ADVANTAGE MASLIHAMORSILA ANDTHEYQUOTETHEINVITATIONTOFOLLOW!LLAHANDPRONOUNCETHE WORDOF!LLAH;INTHEPARLIAMENTS=ANDTHEYSAY;THROUGHTHEIR PARTICIPATIONINTHEPARLIAMENTTHEYINTENDTO=CHANGESOMEOF THOSETHINGSTHATARERELIGIOUSLYFORBIDDENMUNKIRAT ANDLESSEN THEPRESSUREONCALLING THEOTHERS ;THROUGH LEGISLATION= AND QUOTEONESHOULDNOTLEAVETHESEPLACESANDTHEPARLIAMENTSTO #HRISTIANSOR#OMMUNISTSANDTHELIKE

!GAINSTTHOSE-USLIMSWHOQUOTEOBSCUREVERSESFROMTHE+ORAN TOVINDICATETHEIRDEMOCRATICTENETS-AQDISIQUOTESTHIS+ORANICVERSE WHICHISTHEPILLAROFHISATTITUDEREJECTING)SLAMICDEMOCRACY

!LLAHSAYS(EHASSENTTOYOUTHE"OOK)NITTHEREAREVERSESWITH OUTEQUIVOCATIONTHATARETHEBASISOFTHE"OOKANDTHOSEVERSES THATCANBEINTERPRETEDINDIFFERENTMANNERS4HOSEPEOPLEWHO HAVEINTHEIRHEARTADISPOSITIONTOWARDDEPRAVATIONEMPHASIZETHE VERSESWITHEQUIVOCATIONLOOKINGFORDISSENSIONBYTRYINGTOlNDAN INTERPRETATIONFORTHEMWHILENOONEKNOWSTHEIRMEANINGBESIDES !LLAH"UTTHOSEWHOAREWELLVERSEDINSCIENCESAY7EBELIEVE EVERYTHINGINTHE"OOKISFROMOUR,ORD!L)MRAN !LLAHSHOWSTHATINREGARDTORELIGIONPEOPLEAREOFTWOKINDS 4HOSEOFSCIENCEANDSOLIDFAITHANDTHOSEOFDEPRAVATIONANDFALSE HOODWHOFOLLOWWHATISAMBIGUOUSINTHE"OOK;+ORAN=LOOKFOR ITANDENJOYITONLYOUTOFINCLINATIONTOPROMOTEDEEPDISSENSION AMONG-USLIMSlTNA

4HISVERSEISIMPORTANTTO*IHADISTSTOJUSTIFYTHEIRREJECTIONOFANY ALLEGORICORMETAPHORICALINTERPRETATIONOFTHOSE+ORANICSURASTHAT MAYIMPLYPOLITICALPLURALISM!CCORDINGTOTHEMTOINTERPRETAM BIGUOUS+ORANICSENTENCESSOASTOJUSTIFYDEMOCRACYISTRESPASSING UPONTHERULESIMPOSEDBYTHISVERSETHATPROHIBITTHEEXEGESISOFTHOSE AMBIVALENTSURAS/NESHOULDLEAVETHETASKOFGRASPINGTHEMTO!LLAH ALONERATHERTHANLOOKINGFORTHEIRCLARIlCATION4HISATTITUDEISAKIN TOTHATOFTHE#ATHOLIC#HURCHWHENITPROHIBITEDTHEREADINGOFTHE SACREDTEXTSTHATMIGHTSPREADDEPRAVITYAMONGTHEFAITHFULTHROUGH APOTENTIALLYLAXUNORTHODOX INTERPRETATION

*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSDISPARAGEDEMOCRACYNOTONLYBECAUSEOFITS GODLESSCONTENTBUTALSOASARESULTOFITSEGALITARIANVIEWOF-USLIMS ANDNON -USLIMSANDOFMENANDWOMENASWELLASITSSUPPORTFOR EQUALRIGHTSAMONGNATIONSBELIEVERSANDDISBELIEVERSALIKE-AQDISI SUMMARIZESHISCRITICISMSASFOLLOWS

4HEHERETICALCHARACTER;OFTHELEGISLATIVEBODIES=ISBASEDONLEGISLAT INGPARITYWITH!LLAHVOUCHSAlNGEQUALRIGHTSTOMENANDWOMEN WITHOUTANYDISTINCTIONABIDINGBYTHESTIPULATIONSOFTHEINTER NATIONALTREATIESANDLAWSHONORINGTHELAWSASSERTINGTHEEQUALITY ANDPEACEFULCOEXISTENCEWITHTHEHERETICALPEOPLEANDTHEIRVARIOUS GOVERNMENTSBETHEY#HRISTIANS"UDDHISTS*EWS#OMMUNISTS :OROASTRIANS )DOL WORSHIPPERS(INDUS OR OTHER OBSERVING THE RELIGIONOFTHE#HARTER;OFTHE5NITED.ATIONS=ANDITSHERETICALAR TICLESGRANTINGTHESAMERIGHTSTOOTHERRELIGIONS;WHICHSHOULDHAVE INFERIORRIGHTSCOMPAREDTO)SLAM=ACKNOWLEDGINGTHEDOMINATION ANDTHEPOLITICSOFTHEGOVERNMENTSOF)DOLATRYTAQUT DISMISSING *IHADAGAINSTTHE(ERETICSANDTHEIRVARIOUSPEOPLEANDDECLINING ANYKINDOF*IHADANDlGHTAGAINSTTHEMANDCOMMITMENTTOHELP ANDCOOPERATEWITHTHISHERETICALASSEMBLY;THE5NITED.ATIONS= ANDTHE)NTERNATIONAL)DOLATRYTAQUTALDAWLI

-AQDISIDENOUNCESSECULAR!RABREGIMESNOTSOMUCHBECAUSEOFTHEIR AUTOCRATICNATUREASFORTHEIRBEINGSECULARSUBSERVIENTTOTHE7EST FORBIDDINGPOLYGAMYANDAUTHORIZINGTHECONSUMPTIONOFALCOHOL h4HEACCEPTANCEOFCOMMUNISTIDEASDEMOCRATICIDEASAND;INGENERAL= SECULARONESBYTHE!LAWIS;AN)SLAMICSECTIN3YRIAREJECTEDBYTHE OTHERSASBEINGDEVIANT=ANDTHE"ATH;3YRIASAND)RAQSPOLITICALPAR TIESUNDERTHE!SAD(AlZANDHISSON"ASHIR AND3ADDAM(USSEIN RESPECTIVELY= THEACCEPTANCEOFTHE LEADERSHIPOF!MERICA"RITAIN AND2USSIATHEAUTHORIZATION;OFTHECONSUMPTIONOF =ALCOHOLAND THEPROHIBITIONOFPOLYGAMY;ARECLEARSIGNSOFGODLESSNESS=v(E COMBINESPOLITICALANDCULTURALFEATURESALMOSTCONSTANTLYMUCHLIKE OTHER*IHADISTINTELLECTUALS

-AQDISI DENOUNCES THE-URJIAˆTHOSE-USLIMSWHOWERE TOLERANT ANDBELIEVED THAT FAITH IS AMATTER BETWEEN A PERSON AND 'ODˆASWELLASTHOSEWHOBELIEVEDINPREDESTINATIONJAHMIYA AND THEEXTREMISTS+HARIJITES

4HE-URJIASBELIEFWASTHATONECOULDNTTREATTHEOTHERASHERETICBUT ONLYTHROUGHTHEINTERNALFAITH4HE*AHMIYA;WHOBELIEVEDTHATTHERE ISNOFREEWILLANDONEACTSDUETOCONSTRAINTSJABR=ORTHE+HARIJITES ;EXTREMISTSINTHEIRTREATINGOTHER-USLIMSASGODLESSTAKlR=4HE -URJIAOFOURTIMEMURJIAALASR FORGIVETHE4AQUTNON )SLAMIC GOVERNMENTS THE:INDIQFAKE-USLIMS ANDTHE!POSTATESTHEY BELIEVETHATREPREHENSIBLEACTIONCANNOTBESUBJECTTOTAKlR;PUBLIC DENUNCIATIONASCONTRARYTO)SLAM=BUTCANONLYBERELATEDTOTHE INTENTIONOFREJECTING)SLAM;THATCANNOTBEPROVEN=

4HEDISTINCTIONBETWEEN-USLIMSAND(ERETICSBETWEEN THE PEOPLEOF;!LLAHS=GRACIOUSNESSANDTHOSEOFTHE$EVILISBLURREDAS WELLASTHECOMMANDMENTSCONDEMNINGTHE(ERETICSTAKlR ARE NEGLECTEDBY)DOLATROUS5LAMA;WHOBEHAVELIKETHE-URJIA=

)NTHE*IHADISTENTERPRISETHETASKISTO)SLAMIZEWHATMODERNITY HASATLEASTPARTIALLYTAKENAWAYFROMRELIGIOUSRULESALLOWINGDIVERSITY INTHEMORESANDSECULARIZATIONOFPOLITICALSYSTEMS4HISLEGITIMIZES hHUMAN MADELAWSv-AQDISIANDTHEOTHER*IHADISTSTREATAS4AQUT IDOLWORSHIPPERS THOSEWHOPUTFORWARDTHESUPREMACYOFHUMAN LAWAGAINSTGOD SENT LEGISLATION"Y )SLAMIZINGMODERNITY THEYARE NOTADAPTINGITTOhINDIGENOUSvCULTURESASDOTHE)SLAMIC2EFORM ISTSOR&UNDAMENTALISTSONTHECONTRARYTHEYhDE SECULARIZEv)SLAM ANDBREAKOFFITSTIESTOMODERNITYTHUSBUILDINGUPAREGRESSIVEAND REPRESSIVEWORLDVIEWTHATISAGAINSTTHETIDEOFSOCIALCHANGE%VENIN THE-USLIMWORLDSIZEABLEMINORITIESPARTICULARLYINTHELARGECITIES ANDURBANCENTERSARESECULARIZEDORINFAVOROFANONRIGIDINTERPRETA TIONOF)SLAM

!BU-USABAL3URIENUMERATESTHEPRINCIPLESOFDEMOCRACY

4HEDEMOCRATICSYSTEMISBASEDONTHEFOLLOWINGESSENTIALPRIN CIPLES EQUALITY BETWEEN THE PEOPLE IN THE SOCIETY IN REGARD TO THEIRPOLITICALRIGHTSASBEINGELECTEDORELECTINGINTOTALDISREGARD OFRELIGIONANDFAITHETHNICRACEANDCOLORLANGUAGESCIENCEOR IGNORANCEGENDERORANYOTHERDIFFERENCETHEABSOLUTEPERSONAL FREEDOMINREGARDTOBELIEFINTERPRETATIONORACTIVITYWITHINTHE FRAMEWORKOFTHE#ONSTITUTIONORTHELAWTHATISTHEFOUNDATION OFTHISFREEDOMTHEPURSUANCEOFTHEPOLITICALDOMINATIONBYTHE PEOPLETHROUGHTHEELECTIONSANDTHECOMMANDMENTOFTHEMAJORITY TOINSTITUTETHELEGISLATIONANDTHELAWSANDTHEORGANIZATIONOFTHE THREETYPESOFPOWERTHATISLEGISLATIVEJUDICIALANDEXECUTIVE THEALTERNATIONINHOLDINGPOWERBETWEENPOLITICALGROUPSANDTHE PARTIESBASEDONELECTIONSANDTHEDOMINANCEOFTHEMAJORITY )NSPITEOFALLTHISTHEDEMOCRATICPROCESSINTHE7ESTISRELATIVE ANDACOMEDYTOTHEEXTREMEDEGREE2EALPOLITICSARESHAPEDBY THE,OBBIESWHOPRESSTHEPARLIAMENTANDTHEPOLITICALPARTIESAND AREINMOSTCASESDOMINATEDBYTHE*EWSORTHEMEMBERSOFTHE *EWISHORGANIZATIONSLIKETHE-ASONSTHEMEMBERSOFTHE#HRISTIAN RADICALORGANIZATIONSLIKETHE4RICONTINENTALANDTHEOTHERPRESSURE GROUPSMADEOFTHEMOSTIMPORTANTPOLITICALMEDIAMENWEALTHY PEOPLECAPITALISTSANDCONTEMPORARYCRIMINALMAlASWHOADAPTTHE ELECTORALCAMPAIGNSTOTHEIRGENERALPOLICIES4HEELECTORALPROCESS REMAINSINDISPENSABLEFORTHEM;TOGIVEITAPOPULARLEGITIMACY=

"RIBESANDTHOSEASSETSTHATlNANCETHEPOLITICALCAMPAIGNSPLAYA MAJORROLETOPURCHASETHECONSCIENCEANDTHEMINDOFTHEPEOPLE ANDDOMINATETHEMDURINGTHEELECTIONS4HEPROMINENCEOFTHE CANDIDATES THROUGH THE CAPITALIST SYSTEM FOLLOWS IN GENERAL THE MARKETECONOMYORTHEFREEECONOMYANDTHESOCIETYINGENERAL PUTSTHE#HRISTIANIDENTITYATTHEBASEOFTHEIMMENSEPOPULAR ITYFOUNDEDON5NBELIEFILHAD &ROM#HRISTIANITYNOTHINGELSE REMAINSBESIDESRELIGIOUSFANATICISMBOOZEPORKANDSOMETHING FROMTHERELIGIOUSLITURGY

,IKE-AQDISIAL3URISUMMARIZESTHEPRINCIPLESOFDEMOCRACY INTHEORYANDINPRACTICE,IKEMANY7ESTERNEXTREMISTSHEBELIEVES INTHECONSPIRACYOFTHEMINORITIES*EWISHLOBBIES#HRISTIANRADICALS PROMINENTMEDIAMEN RICHCAPITALHOLDERS ETC TODOMINATE THE POLITICALSYSTEMINTHENAMEOFTHEMAJORITY)NHISVIEWDEMOCRACY ISBASEDONGODLESSNESSINITSPRINCIPLESIMMORALITYANDILLEGITIMATE DOMINATIONBYTHEFEW(EADOPTSASWELLSOMEOFTHERADICALLEFT ISTCRITICISMSOFDEMOCRACYINTERMSOFTHEALIENATIONOFTHEMASSES THROUGHCONSUMERISMANDTHEDUPLICITYOFTHEPOLITICALANDECONOMIC ELITESWHOMANIPULATETHEPEOPLEh!NDTHEREALITY;OFDEMOCRACY= ISTHESOVEREIGNTYSIYADAH OFTHEPOLITICALANDCAPITALISTELITESWHO DOMINATETHEFATEOFTHEPEOPLEANDACQUIRETREMENDOUSMIGHTOUT OFTHEVAINFREEDOMANDTHELICENTIOUSNESSIBAHIYA THATBENElTS;THE MASSES=FORALIFEOFCONSUMERISM4HEYAREWELLOFFCOMPAREDTOTHE OTHERSANDTHEYLEAVETHEIRBRIDLETOTHOSEPLAYERSWHORULEOVERTHEIR DESTINYANDMOCKTHEMINTHEGUISEOFDEMOCRACYv

#ONTRARYTO-AQDISIWHOHASNTLIVEDINTHE7ESTAL3URIHAS SPENTMORETHANADECADE IN%UROPE INCLUDING&RANCE%NGLAND AND3PAIN(ISCRITIQUEOFDEMOCRATICREGIMESCONTAINSANEXISTENTIAL NOTEh)ACQUAINTEDMYSELFWITHNUMEROUSEXAMPLESANDLIVECASES OF THE FALSEDEMOCRATICPRETENSIONSDURINGMYSTAY IN%UROPE FOR MORE THAN FOURTEENYEARS THREEYEARS IN&RANCE THREE IN"RITAIN ANDTHERESTIN3PAINv3UCHALONGSTAYIN%UROPECANRESULTIN TWOTYPESOFCONSEQUENCESDIAMETRICALLYOPPOSED4HEPERSONCAN GETACQUAINTEDWITH7ESTERNCULTUREBECOMESECULARANDINTERNALIZE THESAMETYPESOFATTITUDESTOWARDSOCIALANDPOLITICALPROBLEMSAS MAINSTREAM7ESTERNERS/RHECANGETRADICALIZEDSOMEDEGREEOF )SLAMOPHOBIAWITHINTHE7ESTERNWORLD7ESTERNRACISMINDIVIDU ALISMINTERPRETEDASUTTERSELlSHNESS ANDAFEELINGOFROOTLESSNESS CANANTAGONIZEHIMAGAINSTTHE7ESTANDMAKEHIMADOPTANEX TREMISTVIEWOFTHE7ESTASAhTOTALITYvATWARAGAINSTTHE-USLIMS AND)SLAM)N%UROPETHECOLONIALPASTTHEESTABLISHMENTOFLARGE -USLIMDIASPORAS AND THE SPREAD OF )SLAMIC RADICALISM THROUGH

NEWINTELLECTUALSANDTHECRISISOFTHE-USLIMWORLDWITHITSSEQUELS THE"OSNIAN0ALESTINIAN)RAQI!FGHANAND#HECHNYAPROBLEMS AMONGOTHERS INDUCEAFEELINGOFANTAGONISMTOWARDTHE7ESTAND THE5NITED3TATESINPARTICULAR!L3URIISCONVINCEDTHATDEMOCRACY BESIDESBEING AGODLESSPRODUCTOF THE7EST THAT IS INCOMPATIBLE WITH)SLAMISCONCOCTEDBY7ESTERNINTELLIGENCESERVICESTOSUBDUE -USLIMSh"UTTHEWORSTTYPEOFDEMOCRACYISTHEONEREPRODUCED BYMISBEGOTTENDEMONSINTHE)NTELLIGENCESERVICESOFTHE7ESTAND THEIRCOLONIALCONlGURATIONOFOURCOUNTRIESFORTHESAKEOFIMPOS INGITONOURDOMINATEDPEOPLEWHOWOULDTHEREFOREFOLLOWTHEIR ORDERSWILLINGLYMOCKING THEIRWEARYMINDSBY ;GIVING THEMTHE IMPRESSIONOF =lGHTINGTHEDICTATORIALREGIMESTHEAUTOCRATICKINGS ANDINHERITEDREPUBLICSTHATARETHELASTREPREHENSIBLEINNOVATIONS OFTHEFEEBLE MINDED!RABREGIMESv

!L 3URISMAJOR TARGET AMONG THE-USLIMS ISWHAT HE CALLS hDEMOCRATIC-USLIMSv OR-USLIMDEMOCRATS THAT IS THOSEWHO BELIEVETHATDEMOCRACYAND)SLAMARECOMPATIBLEANDONECANLIVEIN A-USLIMLANDRULEDBYADEMOCRATICSYSTEMWITHOUTBEINGASINNER (EDIVIDESTHEMINTOlVECATEGORIES

$EMOCRATIC-USLIMSBELIEVEACCORDINGTOTHEIRDECLARATIONS ANDBOOKSTHATDEMOCRACYISNOTOPPOSEDTO)SLAM!NDONEGROUP SAYSTHATDEMOCRACYINCREASESOURPOSSIBILITIESANDTHEOTHERGROUP THATDEMOCRACYISTHECOMPULSORY3HURA;)SLAMICCONSULTATIONAS MENTIONEDINTHE+ORAN= $EMOCRATIC-USLIMS PROPOSE AN )SLAMIC CONCEPTION OF DEMOCRACYANDSAYTHATTHEYTRYTOCHOOSEFROMTHELATTERTHOSE PARTSTHATDONOTCONTRADICT)SLAM)TISPOSSIBLE;FROMTHEIRVIEW= TODEVELOPAPARLIAMENTARY)SLAMICJURISPRUDENCElQHBARLEMANI THATCONlGURESTHEIDEAOFAN)SLAMICDEMOCRACYTHROUGHSPECIlC RULES4HEYSEENOWRONGINADHERINGTOLEGISLATIVEPOWERTHROUGH DEMOCRACYANDDONOTCONSIDERITASINCOMPATIBLEWITH)SLAMBE CAUSETHEYDONOTACCEPTWHATTHERELIGIOUSLAWFORBIDSASITISTHE OPINIONOFhPARLIAMENTARY-USLIMSvIN*ORDAN !NDAMONGTHEM PEOPLESEENOILLTOBEINCHARGEOFTHEMINISTRIESINTHEEXECUTIVE BRANCHPRETENDINGTHAT*OSEPH;9USUF =WASINCHARGEOFAMINISTRY UNDERTHERULEOFTHE0HARAOH 4HETHIRDTYPEDECLARESTHATDEMOCRACYINITSESSENCECER TAINLYCONTRADICTS)SLAMANDSTILLTHEREISNO)SLAMICPROHIBITION TOlGHTITWITHINTHE0ARLIAMENT4HEYDONOTALLOWTHEMSELVESTO GETINTOTHEEXECUTIVEPOWERSINCEITISTHElELDTHATWASFORBIDDEN BY!LLAHBASEDONTHEPREVAILINGLAWSINTHE-USLIMCOUNTRIES 4HEYBELIEVETHATTHE)SLAMICLAWALLOWSTHEDEMOCRATICPRACTICE

WITHIN THE PARLIAMENTARYMANDATE SO AS TO DISSENTWITHIN IT 4HEFOURTHGROUPCLEARLYDECLARESTHATDEMOCRACYISDENIALOF !LLAHSLEGITIMACYKUFRBILLAH ANDTHATITSPRINCIPLESLEADTODISBE LIEFKUFR !NDOUTOFPOWERLESSNESSISTIDHAF THEYINDULGEINIT INORDERTOACCOMPLISHTHE)SLAMIC!WAKENING3AHWAH 4HEYDO NOTENTERTHE0ARLIAMENTOTHERTHANASAMAJORITYINORDERTOSTART BUILDINGUPAGOVERNMENTTHATRULESBYTHERELIGIOUSLAWSANDABRO GATESDEMOCRATICACTIONINTHE7ESTERNSENSE4HE&RONT)SLAMIQUE DE3ALUTIN!LGERIAPRACTICEDTHISMODELPARTICULARLYTHROUGHTHE DECLARATIONSOFITSRELIGIOUSLEADER!LI"ILHAJ!NDTHISISTHELEAST DEVIANTTYPEOFDEMOCRACY;INREGARDTO)SLAM=ANDTHEMOSTRARE 4HELASTTYPEDOESNOTAIMTOHOLDTHEPOWER;BELIEVINGTHAT= THEREISNOHOPE;TOIMPOSE!LLAHSRULETHROUGHDEMOCRACY=TAKING INTOACCOUNTSTHESITUATIONOFTHECOUNTRIESANDTHECOOPERATION WITHIN THE PARLIAMENTARYMANDATE IN ORDER TO ATTAIN THE2IGHT THROUGHTHATMEANS

!L3URISANALYSISOWESMUCHTOSOCIALANDPOLITICALSCIENCES(ISAIM ISTOPROVETHATTHE-USLIMDEMOCRATSCANNOTSUCCEED)NMANYCASES FROM!LGERIATO%GYPTANDELSEWHERETHEYHAVEBEENUNABLETOSHAPE THEPOLITICALLANDSCAPEACCORDINGTO)SLAM&ORHIMTHElRSTTWOOF THElVEGROUPSHEENUMERATESARENOTAUTHENTIC-USLIMSTHELASTTWO BEINGMOVEDBYAGENUINECONCERNFOR)SLAMBUTUNABLETOACHIEVE THEIRGOALSWITHINTHEGODLESSPOLITICALSYSTEM(EEXTENDSHISCRITICISM TODEMOCRACYMUCHINTHESAMEWAYAS-AQDISIDOESUNDERSCORING THEINCOMPATIBILITYBETWEENPOLITICALPLURALISMAND)SLAM

-USLIM$EMOCRATSHAVETOCOMPLYWITHANELECTIVECONSTITUTION ANDELECTORALLAWSANDTHEFOLLOWINGITEMS 4HERECOGNITIONOFTHESYSTEMSLEGITIMACYANDTHELEGITIMACY OFITSLEADERSˆTHEYMAYBEPRESIDENTSKINGSOREMIRS 4HE RECOGNITIONOF THE ;NON )SLAMIC=#ONSTITUTION THAT IS APPLIEDINTHECOUNTRYANDTHEOATHOFALLEGIANCETOITSSUPREMACY ANDTOACTINGACCORDINGTOIT 4HERECOGNITIONOFITSFUNDAMENTALPRINCIPLESFORGOVERNING WITHINTHEPREVAILINGSYSTEMANDTHEFOUNDATIONSOFITSCREATIONAS SUCH 4HERECOGNITIONOFPEOPLESEQUALITYINTHEIRPOLITICALRIGHTS INREGARDTOTHERIGHTOFCANDIDACYANDELECTIONANDVOTEWITHIN THEPARLIAMENTSETTINGASIDETHEIRRELIGIONSEXBELIEFORANYOTHER FACTOR 4HERECOGNITIONOFTHEALTERNATIONOFPOWERANDTHERIGHTOF ALLTOCOMPETEANDTOBECANDIDATESINTHEELECTIONS

4HERECOGNITIONOFTHEPRINCIPLEOFACCEPTANCEOFTHEMAJORITY DECISIONSANDTHEIRCOMINGINTOEFFECTINALAWFULMANNERSETTING ASIDETHESPECIlCPOSITIONOFTHEPERSONDURINGTHEVOTEANDITS VALUEFORTHE5MMAAFTERITSBECOMINGOPERATIONAL 4HERECOGNITIONANDSUBSCRIPTIONTOTHEELECTORALLAWINFORCE INALLITSASPECTSACCORDINGTOWHICHPOWERISGRANTED;TOTHOSEWHO HAVETHEMAJORITY=ACCORDINGTOTHERESULTS;OFTHEVOTE=

)NADDITIONPARLIAMENTSCANNOTRESISTTHEDICTATESOFTHERULERS ANDINMANYCASESSECULARCONSTITUTIONSEXCLUDEANYREALACTIONWITHIN THELEGISLATIVEBODYINFAVOROF)SLAM

2EFERENCEISMADETOTHE#ONSTITUTIONANDTHEOFlCIALTRIBUNALS CONCERNINGTHEPREVAILINGLAWSINCASEOFLITIGATIONBETWEENLEGISLA TIVEEXECUTIVEORJUDICIALPOWERSORWITHINEACHOFTHESEPOWERS ANDTHERIGHTOFTHE0RESIDENTORTHE+INGTODISMISSTHEPARLIA MENTANDTOSUSPENDTHE#ONSTITUTIONINMOSTCASES4HEREARE ALSOOTHERCONDITIONSTOWHICHTHOSEWHOTAKEPARTINTHEELECTIVE OPERATIONSSUBMITINSPECIALCASESINSPECIlCCOUNTRIESASTHEBAN ONPOLITICALPARTIESBASEDONRELIGIONASINMOSTOFTHE!RABAND )SLAMICCOUNTRIESLIKE%GYPTNOWADAYS4HESECULARNATUREOFTHE POWERINITSPRINCIPLEANDSETUPISCONSTITUTIONALLYRECOGNIZEDIN COUNTRIESLIKE4URKEYASWELLASTHEDIRECTOCCUPATION;OF-USLIM LANDSBYUNBELIEVERS=LIKE0ALESTINEAND)RAQNOWADAYS

!L3URISMAINARGUMENTISTHATWITHOUT*IHADTHEPOLITICALARENAWILL BEDOMINATEDBYGODLESSPOLITICALSYSTEMSUNDERTHEAEGISOFTHE7EST 4OBRINGGENUINE)SLAMTO-USLIMLANDSNECESSITATESTHERECOURSETO LEGITIMATEVIOLENCETHROUGH*IHAD$EMOCRATIC-USLIMSAREPRISONERS OFAPOLITICALSYSTEMWHOSELEGITIMACYTHEYAREFORCEDTORECOGNIZEBY PLAYINGPARLIAMENTARYGAMESANDWHOSEPOWERSTRUCTUREPRECLUDES ANYSIGNIlCANTINITIATIVEFORTHESAKEOF)SLAM

4ARTUSIIDENTIlESDEMOCRACYANDIDOLATRYTAQUT MUCHINTHE SAMEMANNERAS!L3URIAND-AQDISI&ORHIMTHEHISTORYOF7ESTERN DEMOCRACYISNOTTHEEMANCIPATIONFROMTHEYOKEOFDESPOTICREGIMES ITISRATHERTHEDEPLOYMENTOFAFAKETHEOCRACY4HELATTERUSURPSTHE RIGHTOF!LLAHANDATTRIBUTES IT TOHUMANSBYDEIFYING THEHUMAN BEINGLEGITIMIZINGTHEDOMINATIONOFANOTHERTYPEOFPOPEOVERTHE PEOPLENAMELYTHELEGISLATIVEASSEMBLY

$EMOCRACYACTEDTOUPROOTTHEPOLITICALDOMINATIONOFTHEPOPES OF THE #ATHOLIC #HURCHSOAS TOGIVE IT TO THE ;NEW=POPESOF

REPRESENTATIVEASSEMBLIESSETTINGTHEPRINCIPLEOFPOWERINPEOPLE ASWELLASTHEDOMINATIONOF-AN#REATURE OVER-ANANDTHE DIVINITYOF-ANOVER-AN $EMOCRACYISTHESEPARATIONOFRELIGIONAND3TATERULINGANDLIFE HUKMWALHAYAT BRANDISHINGTHEFAMOUSSLOGANGIVETO#AESAR HISDUEANDTO'OD(IS 4O'ODBELONGPRAYERSINSOMECORNERSOFTHETEMPLEANDMON ASTERYANDOTHERWISEWHATEVERBELONGSTOTHEREALMSOFPOLITICAL ECONOMICSOCIALANDLEGALLIFEANDOTHERDOMAINSOFITARENOTTHE ATTRIBUTESOF'ODBUTTHEATTRIBUTESOF#AESAR 4HEYSAY'ODDOESNTEXISTANDLIFEISONLYMATTER!NDTO THOSEWHOBELIEVEINTHE#REATOROFTHEWORLD$EMOCRACYSAYSTHIS BELIEFISYOURSBUTYOUDONTHAVETHERIGHTTOIMPOSEITONOTHERS ORFORCETHEMTOADHERETOITEVENIFTHEYOPPOSEYOUINTHATBELIEF BECAUSETHISISBASEDONTHEFREEDOMOFBELIEF

&REEDOMOFBELIEF FROMTHISVIEWPOINT IS THEDENIALOF!LLAHAND THEREFORE UNACCEPTABLE$EMOCRACY ALLOWS ALL THOSE ACTS THAT ARE FORBIDDENBY!LLAH LIKE INDULGING IN GAMES EXPLOITING THEWEAK MONOPOLIZINGECONOMICACTIVITIESANDSATISFYINGONESSEXUALDRIVES OUTSIDEANYINSTITUTIONALLWITHINASECULARRULE

!NDTHOSEWHOWANTTOEXPLOITTHEOTHERSTOMONOPOLIZEORTO GAMBLEITISTHEIRRIGHTANDNOONECANUNDERDEMOCRACYDENY THEMTHESEBECAUSETHISISBASEDONECONOMICFREEDOMFREEDOM OFPROPERTYACQUISITIONANDPROlT MAKING $EMOCRACYISTHELARGEGARMENTPEOPLEDRESSINBECAUSEITALLOWS THEMTOESCAPEFROMALLTHETIESTHATLIMITTHEIRWHIMSTHEIRSENSUAL PLEASURESANDTHEIRREPREHENSIBLEPASSIONS)TENABLESALLGROUPSTO HEADTOWARDTHEIRSEXUALDRIVESANDTHEIRWISHESBETHEYHERETICAL COMMUNITIESWHODONOTBELIEVEIN!LLAHORTHOSEWHOBELIEVEIN !LLAHBUTARESECULARALMANI ORBETHEYNATIONALISTORETHNICALLY BASED7EEVENlNDMANYLOW LEVELORHIGH LEVEL-USLIMSWHO BELIEVEINDEMOCRACYANDASKFORITTORULETHECOUNTRY

$EMOCRACY IS SEENNOT AS APOLITICAL SYSTEMBUT AS AHOLISTIC CULTUREENCOMPASSINGSOCIETYANDECONOMICSALLOUTSIDETHEREALM OFDIVINERIGHTS!SSUCHTHElGHTAGAINSTDEMOCRACYISDIRECTEDNOT ONLYTOWARDAPOLITICALSYSTEMBUTTOWARDAGLOBALDEPRAVEDCIVILIZA TIONWITHITSILLEGITIMATERELIGIOUSCREEDITSBESTIALSEXUALDRIVESITS REPREHENSIBLEhPASSIONSvANDITSCORRUPTECONOMICRULES*IHADISNOT MEANTTOBESIMPLYDEFENSIVETORECUPERATE-USLIMLANDASINTHE

TRADITIONALVIEW BUTGLOBALANDOFFENSIVEAGAINSTGENERALIZEDGODLESS NESS)TENCOMPASSESALLASPECTSOFLIFEANDINTHISWAYISATOTALWAR AGAINSTUNBELIEFANDSECULARISM

&ROMTHEPERSPECTIVEOF THE*IHADISTSDEMOCRACYANDSECULAR DICTATORSHIPSAREOFTHESAMESTUFFDENIALOF!LLAHSRULEONEARTH!S 4ARTUSIWRITESh3EYED1UTBˆ!LLAHBLESSHISSOULˆSAIDPEOPLEINALL ;POLITICAL=REGIMESONTHEEARTHHOLDONEANOTHERFORGODANDEXCLUDE !LLAH"ETHATTHEHIGHESTDEMOCRACYORTHELOWESTDICTATORSHIPIT ISTHESAMEv&REEDOMOFBELIEFISINREALITYNOTHINGBUTAPOSTASY h$EMOCRACYISBASEDONFREEDOMOFRELIGIONANDBELIEF0EOPLECAN BELIEVEINWHATTHEYWANTUNDERTHESHADOWOFDEMOCRACYANDCHOOSE THERELIGIONTHEYWANT"UTTHISISAPOSTASYORRESULTINGINAPOSTASY DIRECTEDAGAINSTTHERELIGIONOF!LLAHENDINGUPINHERESYANDTHE WORSHIPOFSOMEONEELSETHAN!LLAHv

2EFERENCETO)BN4AYMIYAHTHEMAJORHARDLINERMEDIEVALTHEO LOGIANISONEOFTHECOMMONDENOMINATORSAMONG*IHADISTSINTHEIR lGHTAGAINSTMODERNFREEDOMANDPOLITICALPLURALISMh)BN4AYMIYAH SAYSRELIGIONISOBEDIENCEANDSOMEPEOPLEOBEY!LLAHANDSOMEOTH ERSDONT4HECOMBATISNECESSARYUNTILTHEONLYRELIGIONIS!LLAHSv 0ROPONENTSOFMATERIALISMAREHERETICSANDACCORDINGTO)SLAMTHEY SHOULDBEELIMINATEDFROMTHEFACEOFTHEEARTHh)SLAMDETERMINES ITSRULINGSTOWARDTHE0EOPLEOFTHE"OOKINCLUDING:OROASTRIANSASIS PREDOMINANT;INTHETRADITIONS=INTHREEWAYSEITHER;CONVERSIONTO= )SLAMˆAND)SLAMMAKESITNECESSARYTOFOLLOWWHATWASSAIDˆORTHE RELIGIOUSTAXJIZIYAH ANDTHEYARETHEREFOREABASED;SAQIRUNSLAVISH LOWLY=OR;BESIDESTHETWOMENTIONEDALTERNATIVES=KILLINGANDlGHT ING4HOSE(ERETICSWHOSAYTHEREISNOGODBUTTHELIFEOFTHEMATTER THEYWORSHIPIDOLSANDTHEYCANBE!RABSOROTHERS)N!LLAHSRELIGION THEREISNOOTHERWAYTOTREATTHEMTHANTOKILLANDTOlGHTTHEM!LLAH SAYS&IGHTTHEMUNTILSEDITIONlTNA ENDSUPANDTHEREISNORELIGION OTHERTHAN!LLAHS!NFAL v4HEIDEAOFMUTUALUNDERSTANDING ANDPEACEFULCOEXISTENCEALTHOUGHHISTORICALLYARULEBETWEEN-USLIM ANDNON -USLIMLANDSFORCENTURIESWITHUPSANDDOWNS HASNO LEGITIMACYFROMTHE*IHADISTSPOINTOFVIEW"ESIDESTHEIRCONVERSION TO)SLAMTHEREARETWOWAYSTOCOPEWITHNON -USLIMSEITHERHU MILIATINGTHEMTHROUGHPAYINGATAX ORKILLINGTHEM

$EMOCRATICFREEDOMISNOTONLYAPOLITICALCHOICEIRRESPECTIVE OFFAITHBUTALSOFREEDOMINDEPRAVITYOBSCENITYANDLEWDNESSAND ITTRAMPLESALLTHEMORALVALUESTHATENSURETHEPERMANENCEOFTHE PATRIARCHALFAMILYh4HEYSAYDEMOCRACYDOESNOTENTERTHEPROB LEMSRELATEDTOTHEPERSONALFREEDOM/NECANBEANAPOSTATEAND HEISFREEONEDECIDESTOHAVEAGIRLFRIENDORAMISTRESSHEISFREEA

WOMANDECIDESTOBETRAYHERHUSBAND;BYTAKINGALOVER=SHEISFREE ANDTHEHUSBANDSHOULDNOTCOMPLAINv)NTHISRESPECT*IHADISTS SHARETHECONVICTIONSOFRELIGIOUSCONSERVATIVESINTHE7ESTANDMANY ANTI MODERNINDIVIDUALSWHOFEARCONTEMPORARYTHREATSTOTRADITIONAL MORALVALUESIRRESPECTIVEOFTHEIRRELIGION

!NOTHERASPECTOFDEMOCRACYTHATISUNBEARABLETO*IHADISTSIS FREEDOMOFSPEECHWHICHALLOWSDESECRATINGANDINSULTING)SLAM!L LAHTHE0ROPHETANDTHE(OLY+ORANAMONGOTHERS

$EMOCRACYISBASEDONTHEPRINCIPLEOFTHEFREEDOMOFINTERPRETA TIONANDEXPRESSIONWHATEVERITISEVENIFITINSULTSANDREVILESTHE VERYESSENCEOF!LLAH(ISBOOKSAND(IS0ROPHETS4HEREISNOTHING SACREDIN$EMOCRACYTHATWOULDBEFORBIDDENTOINSULTORTOATTACK THROUGHABOMINABLEWORDS0UTTINGINTOQUESTIONTHISPRINCIPLE MEANSPUTTINGINTOQUESTIONTHEDEMOCRATICREGIMEOFFREEDOMIN TOTALITYANDTHISMEANSUNDERMININGTHEHOLYFREEDOMSFROMTHE VIEWPOINTOF$EMOCRACYANDTHE$EMOCRATS 7HAT$EMOCRACY IN THIS RESPECT TREATS AS SACRED IS FROM THE )SLAMICVIEWPOINTDISBELIEFANDHERESYBECAUSETHEREISNOFREEDOM IN)SLAMFORMEANANDFALSEWORDSWORDSTHATCREATEDISSENTAMONG THE"ELIEVERSABOUTTHEIRRELIGIONANDPREVENTTHEVICTORYOF4RUTH WORDSTHATPROPAGATEDIVERGENCEINSTEADOFUNITYWORDSTHATDIS SEMINATEDEBAUCHERYANDWHATISFORBIDDEN

4HESECULARPOLITICALSYSTEMSEPARATINGRELIGIONANDTHESTATEISSEENBY 4ARTUSIASANOTHERDEMOCRATICFEATURETOBEREJECTEDINTHENAMEOF)S LAM!LTHOUGHFORCENTURIES-USLIMLANDSWERERULEDBYNON -USLIMS LIKETHE-ONGOLS ORRULERSTHATWERENOTTOTALLYRESPECTFULTOWARD RELIGIOUSPROHIBITIONSTHECONSUMPTIONOFWINEINTHE5MAYYADAND !BBASIDCALIPHATES 4ARTUSIJOINSTHEMINORITYOFINmEXIBLE-USLIMS WHODECLAREWARAGAINSTMODERATE-USLIMSAND THOSEWHOMTHEY TREATASHERETICS

2EPEATINGTHE*IHADISTCREEDABOUTDEMOCRACYASWORSHIPOFIDOLS ANDAFAKERELIGIONAL3URIUNDERSCORESTHEINCOMPATIBILITYBETWEEN )SLAMANDPOLITICALPLURALISM

$EMOCRACYISBASEDONTHEBELIEFTHATPEOPLEARETHEUNIQUECOM MANDERSFORTHESOLUTIONOFCONmICTSANDHOSTILITIES)FTHEREISANY CONmICTBETWEEN THE GOVERNOR AND THE GOVERNEDORBETWEEN THE LEADERSHIPANDTHEOTHERSBOTHTHREATENTOCONSULTPEOPLEANDITIS THERIGHTOFTHEPEOPLETOSOLVETHEIRCONmICTS4HISCONTRADICTSTHE PRINCIPLEOFTHE5NIQUENESSOF!LLAHWHICHSPECIlESTHATTHEULTIMATE

REFERENCEINCONmICTSISUNIQUELY!LLAH!LMIGHTY;REPRESENTEDBYTHE +ORANANDTHE0ROPHETICTRADITION3UNNA=ANDNOONEELSE

%XCLUDING RELIGION FROM THE REALMOFPOLITICS IS IGNORING THE #REATORSRIGHTOVERTHE#REATUREANDTHESUBSERVIENCEOFTHELATTER TOWARDTHEFORMER!LLAHSCOMMANDMENTSDETERMININGMANSPOLITICS h$EMOCRACYISBASEDONTHEPRINCIPLEOFTHESEPARATIONOFRELIGION AND3TATEOFPOLITICSANDLIFEWHATBELONGSTO!LLAHIS(ISAND PEOPLEARE LIKE#AESAR IN$EMOCRACY4HIS IS(ERESY IN)SLAMS COMMANDMENT STIPULATING THAT )SLAM IS RELIGIONOF 3TATE 0OLITICS RULEANDLEGISLATIONANDISMUCHWIDERINSCOPETHANRESTRICTEDONLY TORITUALSORTOTHEWALLSOFTEMPLESANDTHEREISNODOUBTTHATTHE FORMERIS(ERESYTO)SLAMv

$EMOCRATICFREEDOMISTOTALLYDIFFERENTFROM)SLAMICFREEDOM 4HELATTERIMPLIESTHATONEACCEPTS!LLAHSPROHIBITIONSANDWILLINGLY SUBMITSTOTHEMTHOSERESTRICTIONSEXTENDINGTOTHEMOSTELEMENTARY ACTSINDAILYLIFE

$EMOCRACYISBASEDONPERSONALFREEDOMANDUNDER$EMOCRACY ONECANDOWHATTHEYWANTANDPRACTICEWHATTHEYWANTIF IT IS NOTOPPOSEDTOTHEMAN MADELAWOFTHECOUNTRY4HISWORDIS OBVIOUSLYWRONGANDCORRUPTANDTOWARRANTITMEANSTODECLARE ALLOWEDWHAT!LLAHHASFORBIDDENTO#REATURES&REEDOMTOACTAS ONEWISHESANDDESIRESISAMONGTHEMORTALSINSINRELIGION &ROMTHE)SLAMICPERSPECTIVEMANSFREEDOMISBORROWEDFROM )SLAMANDISRESTRICTEDTOTHELIMITSOFRELIGIOUS LAWANDWHATIS IMPOSED THROUGH THE NECESSITIES AND OBLIGATIONS AND RELIGIOUS TRADITIONSANDITISNOTINTHE-USLIMSREALMˆINCASEHEWANTS TOREMAINWITHIN)SLAMANDITSCUSTOMSANDRULESˆTOBEFREEIN ORDERTOVIOLATE)SLAMICRESTRICTIONSITSCUSTOMSANDRULESANDTO COMMITWHATISFORBIDDEN;)N)SLAMICTRADITIONS=WElNDTHAT THEDUTIESOFTHERELIGIONAREIMPOSEDUPONTHE-USLIMANDTHEY AREPARTOFTHOSESTRICTRULESINMANSLIFE4HEYRESTRICTMANSLIFE INHOWHEEATSHOWHEDRINKSHOWHEDRESSESHOWHESLEEPSAND EVENHOWHEDEFECATESHOWHEENTERSTHE7#ATHOMEANDHOW HEEXITS INRELATIONTOTHEIMPORTANTMATTERSTHATWIELDGENERAL RULESANDTHEGENERALINTERESTFORWHICH)SLAMLEAVESNOROOMFOR THEDESIRESANDOPINIONSOFTHEPEOPLE

!NOTHER ASPECT OF DEMOCRACY THAT IS IN TOTAL DISAGREEMENT WITH )SLAM IS THE FREEDOMOF POLITICAL PARTIES IRRESPECTIVE OF THEIR RELIGIOUS TENET h$EMOCRACYPUTS AT ITS FOUNDATION THE FREEDOMOF

ORGANIZINGPOLITICALPARTIESANDGROUPSWHATEVERTHERELIGIOUSFAITH ORTHEIDEASORMORALSOFTHESEPARTIESANDGROUPS4HISFOUNDATIONIS WRONGFORTHEFOLLOWINGREASONS4HEYHAVETHERIGHTTOEXISTIN ORDERTODISSEMINATETHEIRFALSEIDEASTHEIRDEPRAVITYANDHERESYIN THECOUNTRYANDAMONGTHEPEOPLEANDTHISISINCONTRADICTIONWITH THECOMMANDMENTSANDTEXTSOFTHERELIGIOUSLAW!CCORDINGTO )BN4AYMIYAHANYGROUPOFPEOPLEWHOPUBLICLYREFUSETOABIDEBY THE,AWOF!LLAH3HARIAH RECURRENTLYBRINGUPONTHEMSELVES*IHAD UNTILTHERELIGIONOF!LLAHISAPPLIEDBYTHEMWITHTHECONSENSUSOF THE5LAMAv-USLIMSANDNON -USLIMSAREFUNDAMENTALLYUNEQUAL FROMTHEORTHODOX)SLAMICVIEW'IVINGTHELATTERTHESAMERIGHTSBY THEIRVOTESASTHEFORMERISDECLARINGWARON)SLAMh0OLITICALPLURALISM WITHINDEMOCRACYˆEQUALITYBETWEEN-USLIMSANDNON-USLIMSˆIS AGAINSTABSOLUTEARGUMENTSTHATFORBID-USLIMSTOFOLLOWNON -USLIMS ACCORDINGTOTHEVERSE@!LLAHWONTGIVE(ERETICSTHEOPPORTUNITYTO LEAD-USLIMS0LURALISMLEADSTODISUNITYANDDISSENSIONISTHE CAUSEOF!LLAHSPUNISHMENT0OLITICALELECTIONSINTHEDEMOCRATIC FASHIONAREFORBIDDENBY)SLAMBECAUSETHEYARENTCONDITIONALONTHE RELIGIOUSSTANCEOFTHEELECTORANDTHEELECTEDACCORDINGTOGENERALOR SPECIlCCOMMANDMENTSOF)SLAMv

$EMOCRACY IS BASED ON INDIVIDUALISM AND TRADITIONAL )SLAM REJECTSINDIVIDUALISMINTHENAMEOFTHE5MMAANDITSWELFARE&EAR OFINDIVIDUALISMISEMBODIEDINORTHODOX)SLAMANDISBEINGREVITAL IZEDBY*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSINTERMSOFWAGINGHOLYWARTOSAVETHE )SLAMICCOMMUNITYFROMTHEHAVOCOFDEMOCRATICEGOCENTRISM!L 3URIEXPRESSESHISVIEWSBYMENTIONINGTWO3AYINGS(ADITH OFTHE 0ROPHET

!(ADITHOF THE0ROPHET SAYS IN A SHIP THOSEWHOWERE AT THE BOTTOMRECEIVEDTHEWATERRESULTINGFROMTHEWAVES4HEYSAIDTO THEMSELVESIFWEMAKEAHOLEINTHESHIPWELLGETRIDOFTHEWATER mOWINGFROMABOVEUS4HEYDIDITANDTHEYSANKTHESHIP4HOSE ATTHELOWESTLEVELINOURTIMESTANDFORTHEPROPAGANDISTSOFDE MOCRACYWHOWOULDLIKETODIGAHOLEINTHESHIPBYTHEIRDOUBTS THEIRDESIRESANDTHEIRFALSEDEEDS 4HE5MRANIN+ORANSAYSh#LINGTOGETHERTO!LLAHSSTRING ANDDONOTSCATTERv !TRUSTWORTHY3AYINGOFTHE0ROPHETHADITHSAHIH SAYSh9OU SHOULDBETOGETHERBEWAREOFBREAKINGUPBECAUSETHE$EVILISWITH HEWHOISALONE3ATANALREADYMOVESAWAYWHENTWOPERSONSARE TOGETHERANDIFPEOPLEWISHTHEPROSPERITYOFPARADISETHEYSHOULD BETOGETHER

&ROMAL3URISPOINTOFVIEWTHETOGETHERNESSWARRANTEDBY)SLAMIS AGAINSTTHEPRINCIPLESOFDEMOCRACY)NITTHEINDIVIDUALDECIDESIN ASOVEREIGNMANNERONEVERYMATTEROFCONCERN-ULTIPLICITYOFPO LITICALPARTIESWREAKSHAVOCONTHECONSENSUSWITHINTHE5MMAAND SEVERSTHEORGANICTIESWITHINITh4HEREAREMANYCOMMANDMENTS AND TEXTS THAT ORDER THE COMMUNITY TO PRESERVE THE UNITY OF THE MINDS4HE CONSTITUTIONOF NUMEROUSPOLITICAL PARTIES IS NOTH INGBUTTHESCATTERINGANDTHEDISPERSALOFTHE-USLIMSANDINTHIS RESPECTITIS(ERESYv

!NOTHERFEATUREOFDEMOCRACYISTHERULEOFTHEMAJORITYAND THISISINTOTALCONTRADICTIONWITH!LLAHSRELIGIONh$EMOCRACYISBASED ONTHEVALIDITYOFTHEMAJORITYSSTANCEEVENIFTHEYAGREEONWHATIS RELIGIOUSLYWRONGANDUNGODLY4RUTHBEINGWHATTHEMAJORITYDECIDES ANDNOTHINGELSEv4HISPRINCIPLEISWRONGh)FTHEIRMAJORITYDOES NOTBELIEVEIN!LLAHTHEYAREHERETICALv3URA*OSEPH h!3AYING OFTHE0ROPHETSTATES@)SLAMBEGANASALONELYSTRANGERQARIB ANDWILL BEASITBEGANASALONELYSTRANGERANDTHEBLISSISWITHLONELYSTRANG ERS4HE0ROPHETSAID @5PRIGHTPEOPLEAREAMINORITYWHEREAS DISLOYALPEOPLEARENUMEROUSANDTHOSEWHOSINAREMORENUMEROUS THANTHOSEWHOOBEY!LLAH)NATRUSTWORTHY3AYINGTHE0ROPHETSAYS 0EOPLEARELIKEAHUNDREDCAMELS!MONGTHEMONLYONECANENDURE THEHARDSHIPSANDTHESUFFERINGSOFTHEJOURNEYTHATISTHERELIGION ANDTHISISTHEREASONFORTHELONELYANDTHESTRANGERNATUREQURBAH OFTHEVANGUARDSOF)SLAMWHOENDUREDSUFFERINGSANDTOOKTHEMON THEMSELVESTOLEADTHEWAYFORTHISRELIGIONv

4HEANTI MAJORITYANDANTI DEMOCRATICFEATURESOFTRADITIONAL ISTRELIGIONAREBLENDEDWITHMODERNRADICALIDEOLOGYTHEMAJORITY IS ALIENATED AND THE REVOLUTIONARY VANGUARDS DUTY IS TO AWAKEN THEMBY THEIR ACTION h2EVOLUTIONARY VANGUARDv IS CONmATEDWITH THETRADITIONALPERCEPTIONOFh-ENOF!LLAHvASAMINORITYOFhLONELY STRANGERSv4HIS COMBINATIONMAKES IT POSSIBLE TO BRING TOGETHER THOSEWHOAREDISSATISlEDWITHMODERNITYANDTHOSEWHOAREMERELY TRADITIONALALTHOUGHTHETWOGROUPSAREDISTINCTANDINMANYWAYS OPPOSEDTOEACHOTHER

!L3URIINSISTSTHATTHEMAJORITYSVIEWISGENERALLYWRONGANDTHAT ATINYMINORITYOFGENUINE-USLIMSISRIGHTh-ANYTEXTSANDWORKS UNDERSCORE THAT THEMAJORITY IS INMOSTCASESHERETICALANDWRONG DEPRAVEDANDUNTRUEANDTHATPEOPLEOFTRUTHARESCANTYWRONGDOERS ARENUMEROUSANDTHOSEWHOSINAREMORENUMEROUSTHANTHOSEWHO OBEY!LLAH4HERIGHTSTANDARDFORTHEKNOWLEDGEOFTRUTHISACCORDING TOTHEABSOLUTE4RUTHWRITTENDOWNINTHE"OOKANDTHE4RADITIONS OF THE0ROPHET ANDWHAT ITS ;GENUINE= FOLLOWERS ANDDISCIPLES SAY

!NYTHINGELSEISWRONGANDPERVERSEEVENIFMOSTOFTHEINHABITANTS OFTHE%ARTHAPPROVEITv

4HE IDEA THAT THEMAJORITY IS RIGHT ISOFFENSIVE TO THEEARSOF TRADITIONAL-USLIMSITUSEDTOBETHESAMEFORTRADITIONAL#ATHOLICS INTHEEIGHTEENTHANDNINETEENTHCENTURIES )TISATTHESAMETIME OFFENSIVETOTHEEARSOFTHOSEWHOSUFFERFROMTHECONSEQUENCESOF MODERNIZATION )T IS ALSO OFFENSIVE TO THE EARS OF THOSE FORWHOM 7ESTERNDOMINATION IS CARRIED OUT UNDER THE GUISE OF DEMOCRACY AND DEMOCRATIZATION4HISMAKES THE ALLIANCE OFMANY DIFFERENT PEOPLEPOSSIBLEUNDERTHEBANNEROFRADICAL)SLAM)TEXPLAINSASWELL THESUCCESSOFRADICAL)SLAMAFTERTHECOLLAPSEOFCOMMUNISMASTHE ONLYALTERNATIVEIDEOLOGYTOLIBERALISMINTHE-USLIMWORLDBRINGING UNDERTHESAMEBANNERREACTIONARIESLEFTISTSANDALLTHOSEWHOARE ANTI MODERNFORDIFFERENTREASONS

$EMOCRACYIShDISSENSIONvlTNAADISSENSIONFROMWITHINTHAT TENDSTODESTROYTHEUNITYOFTHE-USLIMCOMMUNITY BECAUSEOFITS ENDLESSQUARRELANDQUIBBLEAMONGTHOSEWHOPROPOSEDIFFERENTIN TERPRETATIONSOFFREEDOMANDRIGHTANDWRONGASWELLASCONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTSANDDUTIES&OR*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSTHE+ORANANDTHETRADITIONS ARETRANSPARENTUNEQUIVOCALANDENTIRELYCLEARATTHEIRCORE4HEREIS NOOTHERVALIDINTERPRETATIONTHANTHEIRSANDITISWITHINTHEREACHOF HUMANSTOHAVEATRUEANDUNQUESTIONABLEINTERPRETATIONOFTHESACRED TEXTASPROPOSEDBYTHEM4HE+ORANICSURATHATCONTRADICTTHEIRTENETS AREQUALIlEDAShAMBIGUOUSvINTHESENSETHATTHEYAREBEYONDTHE REACHOFHUMANUNDERSTANDINGANDTHEREFORESHOULDNOTBEREFERRED TOASWEHAVEALREADYSEEN4HISATTITUDEDENIESANYPLURALISMINTHE INTERPRETATIONOFTHESACREDTEXT!GAINSTDEMOCRATICUNCERTAINTYAND ENDLESSDOUBTS*IHADISMPRESENTSASETOFCLEAR CUTIDEASTHATCANBE MOTTOESFORACTION4HISISASOLACETOMANYTORMENTEDBYINlNITE DISCOURSESONWHATISGOODANDWHATISBADWHATISRIGHTANDWHAT ISWRONGWITHOUTANYCERTAINTYTOCLINGTO

!NOTHERMAJORFEATUREOFDEMOCRACYTHATMAKESITABOMINABLETO *IHADISTSISTHEEQUALITYOFRIGHTSAMONGCITIZENSIRRESPECTIVEOFTHEIR FAITH!LL*IHADISTS-AQDISIASALREADYMENTIONEDAL3URIAND4ARTUSI ASWELL AGREEONTHISISSUEh$EMOCRACYISBASEDONTHEPRINCIPLEOF EQUALITYOFTHERIGHTSANDDUTIESBETWEENALLRELIGIONSANDPEOPLEIN SOCIETYASIDEFROMTHEIRRELIGIOUSBELONGINGANDBELIEFTHEIRWAYOFLIFE ANDTHEIRMORALVALUES)N$EMOCRACYTHEMOSTHERETICALDEPRAVED ANDIGNORANTPEOPLEAREEQUALTOTHEMOSTPIOUSRIGHTEOUSANDCOG NIZANTONESINVOTINGFORTHERULEROFTHECOUNTRYANDPEOPLEASWELL ASTHEIRRIGHTSANDDUTIES4HISEQUALITYUNDOUBTEDLYCONlRMSTHEIR DEPRAVITYANDTHEIRFALSEHOODANDEXPRESSESTHEIROPPOSITIONANDTHEIR

INCOMPATIBILITYTOSOMANYSOLIDTEXTSOFTHE;)SLAMIC=RELIGION 4HOSEWHODONOTDIFFERENTIATEBETWEEN*EWS#HRISTIANSANDOTHER (ERETICSON THEONEHAND-USLIMSON THEOTHER ARE(ERETICS THEMSELVESv

)SLAMICTRADITIONISBYITSVERYNATURENONEGALITARIANINMATTERS INVOLVING-USLIMSANDNON -USLIMS2EFORMISTSANDINTHEIROWN WAY&UNDAMENTALISTS SEEKTOQUESTIONINEQUALITYBETWEEN-USLIMS ANDNON -USLIMSBYREINTERPRETING)SLAMICCOMMANDMENTS*IHADISTS OPTFORAMUCHMORERADICALATTITUDEBECOMINGEVENMOREINmEXIBLE THANTRADITIONAL)SLAMINMATTERSRELATEDTOPOLITICSANDCULTURE&OR 4ARTUSIPOLITICALPLURALISMISSETAGAINST!LLAHSRULEANDISTHEWORST ENEMYOF)SLAMh!LLAHDOESNOTALLOWSECULARPARTIESANDTHEIRLIBER TIESANDTHEYARENEITHERRECOGNIZED;BY(IM=NORLEGITIMATE4HOSE WHOATTRIBUTETHISABSOLUTE5NTRUTH;EQUALITYOFALLCITIZENS=TOTHE RELIGIONOF!LLAHANDTOWHAT!LLAHREVEALEDTO(IS0ROPHETANDOR DEREDHIMTODOCOMMITAGREATERCRIMEANDEXPRESSAMOREOBVIOUS LIETHANTHOSEWHOGIVETHEAUTHORIZATIONTOPROSTITUTIONINTHENAME OF!LLAHSRELIGIONAND(ISCOMMANDMENTACCORDINGTOVERSEOF THE3URA!L!RAF v

0OLITICALPARTIESARELIKEACURSEDDISSENSIONlTNA AMONG-US LIMS4HEY JEOPARDIZE THE5NITYOF THE )SLAMICCOMMUNITYWHICH SHOULDBETHEREmECTIONOF!LLAHSUNIQUENESS

4HESEPOLITICALPARTIESANDINPARTICULARSECULARONESINTENSIFYTHE DISSENSIONWITHINTHE5MMAJEOPARDIZEITS5NITYANDMULTIPLYITS ALLEGIANCE TODIFFERENT FACTIONSANDPARTIES THATAREANTAGONISTIC ADVERSARIALANDCAUSEHATREDAMONG-USLIMSABOUTWHAT!LLAHSENT TOTHEMASEVIDENCEOF(ISRELIGION4HISISAGAINST!LLAHSCOM MANDMENTABOUTTHEUNITYWAHDAT ANDTHECOLLECTIVECLINGINGOF -USLIMSTO(ISROPE;ALLUDINGTOh#LINGTOTHE2OPEOF!LLAHAND DONOTDISSEMINATEv3URA)MRAN=WHICHREJECTSDISSENSIONAND DIVISIONMUTUALHATREDANDANTAGONISM!CONlRMED3AYINGOF THE0ROPHETHADITHSAHIH STATESYOUHAVETOBETOGETHERANDDONT BEINFACTIONSBECAUSETHE$EVILISWITHLONELYPEOPLEANDSTRAYS AWAYFROMTWOPERSONSTOGETHERTHOSEWHODESIRETHEPLEASURESOF PARADISESHOULDSTAYTOGETHER

4HESTRESSONUNITYEVENTHEOBSESSIONWITHITASALREADYMENTIONED ISONEOFTHEMAINCHARACTERISTICSOF*IHADISTS4HEYDONTACCEPTTHE COMPLEXITYOFMODERNLIFEANDTHEYPRESENTASASOLUTIONTOTHEILLSOF MODERNITYTHERETURNTO!LLAHSRELIGIONINITSMOSTUNCOMPROMISING FORM"UTTHEIRVIEWOF)SLAMISALSOANhINTERPRETATIONvBASEDON

ANINmEXIBLEATTITUDETOWARDMODERNITYTHENOSTALGIAOFLOSTUNITYIN THE-USLIMWORLDANDTHECULTOFHEROISMEMBODIEDINTHEORIGINAL -USLIMS5NITYWITHOUT DISSENSION IS THE OPPOSITE OF DEMOCRATIC DIVERSITYANDITSMANAGEMENTOFDISSENSIONWITHINTHEINSTITUTIONAL BOUNDSPROVIDEDBYHUMAN MADECONSTITUTIONS

&OR4ARTUSIDEMOCRATICDIVERSITYISDISSENTAMONG-USLIMSAND THEIRWEAKENING4HEONLYWAYTORESTORETHEPASTGLORYANDTHEPOWER OF)SLAMISTORETURNTOITSORGANICUNITYh)NUNITYLIESPOWERANDIN FACTIONSWEAKNESS)SLAMISTHERELIGIONOFUNITYINEVERYTHING ANDITISTHERELIGIONOFHEALTHYHEARTSANDTHEIRPURITYANDRIGHTEOUS FRATERNITYANDSINCERECOOPERATIONAMONGALLTHEPEOPLEINVIRTUEOF THEUNITED5MMAANDUNITEDPEOPLE)TDOESNOTAGREEWITHPOLITI CALPARTIESANDDOESNOTACCEPTITv7HATHEPROPOSESISAUNIQUE POLITICALPARTYAKINTOTHEFASCISTSYSTEMTHATWOULDBETHEIMAGEOF 5MMASUNITYh4HEREISNOWAYOTHERTHANDISMISSINGALLPOLITICAL PARTIESANDASSEMBLE5MMASFORCESINASINGLEPARTYHIZBWºHID THAT WOULDACTTOACHIEVEITSINDEPENDENCEANDFREEDOMANDESTABLISHTHE PRINCIPLESOFTHEGENERALINTERNALREFORMISLAH 4HENITWOULDTRACE THELINESOFACTIONTOTHEPEOPLEBYORGANIZINGTHEMACCORDINGTOTHE UNITYREQUIREDBY)SLAMv

)NAWORLDBESETBYUNCERTAINTYDISMEMBERMENTOFTRADITIONAL SOCIETIESANDTHEBREAKINGOFTHEIRORGANICBONDSANDORGANIZATIONS THEOBSESSIONWITH5NITYBECOMESAPOTENTUTOPIATOELIMINATEALL THOSETRAUMATIZINGASPECTSOFMODERNLIFEINPARTICULARINTHE)SLAMIC WORLDDOMINATEDBYSECULARDESPOTICPOWERSORBYCORRUPTRELIGIOUS RULERS

)SLAMISTHERELIGIONOF5NITYINEVERYTHING!LLAHISUNIQUEIN(IS NAMESANDATTRIBUTES(ISACTSAND(ISCHARACTERISTICSANDTHERE ISNOPARTNERTO(IMNOONESIMILARTO(IM!NDTHE0ROPHET WHOCOMPELSTHEUNITYOFHISFOLLOWERSANDTHEREISNOPROPHET AFTERHIMANDTHE1IBLATHATREQUIRESTOMAKETHEUNIQUEDAILY PRAYERSINITSDIRECTIONANDTHE#OMMUNITYOFTHEREDEEMEDAND VICTORIOUS;-USLIMCOMMUNITY=THATDEMANDSITSMULTIPLICATION ASASINGLE;UNIQUE=ENTITYTHATDOESNOTBECOMEMULTIPLEWHAT EVER THEDISTANCEBETWEEN ITSMEMBERS INDIFFERENTREGIONSAND THE4RUTHHAQ THATREQUIRESTHATITSFOLLOWERSBEUNIlEDANDNOT DIVIDED)NALLTHESECASESBESIDESTHIS;THE5NITY=THEREISNOTHING BUTPERDITIONh4HEREFOREBESIDES4RUTHTHEREISNOTHINGBUTPER DITIONv3URA9UNES 0OLITICALPARTIESOPPOSEGOD ORDAINED 5NITYh2ELIGIOUSLAWORDERSUNITYANDTOGETHERNESSCOMMANDING THATONESHOULDCLINGCOLLECTIVELYTOTHENOOSEOF!LLAH;REFERENCE

TOTHE+ORANICVERSE!L5MRANVERSE=ANDTOBE#REATURESOF !LLAHASLOVINGBROTHERS$ISPERSION;BECAUSEOFPOLITICALPARTIES= BREAKSUSASMUCHASDIFFERENCE;OFOPINION=TENSIONRANCORAND OPPOSITION4HEFORMER;5NITY=ISIMPOSSIBLETOREALIZEUNDERTHE LAWSOF;POLITICAL=PARTIESv

7HATISDISTURBINGTO*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSISTHATPOLITICALPARTIES MARKTHEENDOFTHEMYTHOFAUNIlED-USLIMSOCIETY-ODERN-USLIM COUNTRIESAREBLEAKPICTURESOFWHATTHECALIPHATEUSEDTOBEATTHETIME OFITSSPLENDOR4HEYIMPUTEPRESENTWEAKNESSANDDISORGANIZATION WITHIN-USLIMSOCIETIESTOTHEIRINABILITYTOACHIEVEORGANICUNITY 4HEYSHARETHISFEELINGWITHMANYCRITICSOFMODERNITYACCORDINGTO WHOMMODERNITYPUTSANENDTOTHEhHARMONIOUSvORIGINALLIFEOF HUMANITY!CCORDINGTO*IHADISTSPOLITICALPARTIESCARRYWITHTHEM SENTIMENTSANDEMOTIONSTHATARENON )SLAMICEVENANTI )SLAMICIN THEIRDEEP LAYERS LIKEVYINGENVYINGhHATINGv COMPETING ALLOF THEMCONSIDEREDASLEGITIMATEBYTHEMh)TDOESNOTESCAPEANYONE SEEKINGTHE4RUTHTHATPOLITICALPARTIESINTHEIRFAMOUSSHAPETHEIR CONTRADICTORYPROGRAMSTHEIROBVIOUSASPIRATIONSTOPOWERANDTHE PURSUITOFPOWERANDDOMINATIONAREDESTINEDTOSPREADDISSENSION AMONGTHE-USLIMSBREAKTHEIRUNITYABASETHEIRDIGNITYANDDIVIDE THEIR SENSEOFBELONGING4HEIRDIVISIONWITHINPARTIES ANDGROUPS FARFROMEACHOTHERRESULTSINTHEIRHATINGEACHOTHERTHEIRHERITAGE BEINGHATREDANDJEALOUSYRUPTUREANDMUTUALREBUTTALANDONTOP OFITSOCIALILLNESSESTHATCAUSEDEPRAVITYANDOTHERILLSTHATNOONE MEASURESUPBESIDES!LLAHv

0OLITICALPARTIESINTRODUCETHEINDIVIDUALIZATIONOFPOLITICSINTHE SHAPEOFPERSONALAMBITIONSANDINDIVIDUALCHOICESANDTHISENDANGERS THESENSEOF5NITYWITHINTHE5MMAANDISDREADEDBY*IHADISTS)N THEIRMODERNFORM*IHADISTSARETHEMSELVESATLEASTINPARTTHERESULT OFTHEINDIVIDUALIZATIONANDFAILEDMODERNIZATIONOF-USLIMSOCIETIES BUTTHEYPOINTTOINDIVIDUALIZATIONASACURSEAGAINST)SLAMPROMOTED BYTHE7ESTINACONSCIOUSMANNERTODESTROY!LLAHSRELIGION

/NEOFTHEFEW*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSWHODONOTFRONTALLYREJECT THECONCEPTOFTHEPOLITICALPARTYIS!BU1ATADA(ESHARESMUCHCRITI CISMOFDEMOCRACYWITHOTHER*IHADISTSBUTINTRODUCESSOMENUANCES INREGARDTOPOLITICALPARTIES(EDISTINGUISHESBETWEENTHECORPORATIST ATTACHMENTTOPARTIESALASABIYATALHIZBIYAH THATISDEEPLYNEGATIVE ANDDIVISIVEANDTHESYSTEMOFPOLITICALPARTIESHIZBIYAHWATAHAZZUB THATISAWAYOFORGANIZINGSOCIETY&ORHIMCONTRARYTOOTHER*IHAD ISTSTHEREISNOORGANICNEXUSBETWEENTHETWO4HEILLSATTRIBUTEDTO POLITICALPARTIESHAVETHEIRROOTSINTHEINDIVIDUALISMFARDIYAHZATIYA

THAT ENGENDERS DIVISIONS AND ILLEGITIMATE GROUPS lRAQ NOT EVERY POLITICALPARTY(EINVERTS*IHADISTARGUMENTSBYASKINGTHEQUESTION h)SITBETTERTOSEETHE5MMAGATHERINGINATHOUSANDORGANIZATIONS ANDAPRIMARYPOLITICALPARTYOREACHONEACCORDINGTOTHEIRWHIMS ANDPASSIONSHAVINGTHOUSANDSOFPEOPLE)FTHEREARENTPOLITICALPAR TIESWONTTHEYCREATEWITHINTHEMSELVESNEWPARTIESANDNUMEROUS ORGANIZATIONSv&ORHIMACCORDINGTOTHE0ROPHEThEVERY-USLIM IS TOANOTHER-USLIM LIKEAPARTOF AUNIQUEBODYAND THEREFORE WHENANORGANOFTHEBODYSUFFERSTHEOTHERPARTSBECOMEVIGILANT ANDSUPPORTITv

(ERECOGNIZESSOME-USLIMSREJECTPOLITICALPARTIESANDOTHERS JOINTHEMWITHOUTKNOWINGWHICHATTITUDEISLEGITIMATEFROMARELI GIOUSVIEWPOINT(ISSTANCEISBASEDONTHEASSUMPTIONTHATAUNIQUE POLITICALPARTYISLEGITIMATEIN)SLAM(EJUSTIlESHISCLAIMWITHA3AY INGOFTHE0ROPHETTHATREFERSTOASMALLGROUPOFPEOPLEAMONGTHE -USLIMCOMMUNITYWHOCONTINUETOlGHTUPTOTHE$AYOF*UDGMENT CALLEDTHEhASSISTEDGROUPvTAIFAHMANSURAH 4HISGROUPWILLBETHE LEADEROFTHE-USLIMCOMMUNITYINSITUATIONSINWHICHTHEMAJORITY HASGIVENUP*IHAD)TWILLLEADTHEONLYPOLITICALPARTYTHATISALLOWED IN)SLAMTHEPARTYOF!LLAH(IZBALLAH AGAINSTALLTHEOTHERS4HIS UNIQUEPOLITICALPARTYMADEOFhVIRTUOUSvPEOPLEGIVES!BU1ATADATHE OPPORTUNITYTOLEGITIMIZEITBECAUSEITHASNOhCORPORATISTvASABIYA BIASANDCANLEAD-USLIMSTOVICTORYTHROUGHHOLYWAR4HIS*IHADIST POLITICALPARTYISVERYCLOSETOTHE#OMMUNISTOR&ASCIST0ARTYCALLED TOLEADTHERESTTHEPROLETARIATORTHE6OLK TOlNALVICTORY

!NOTHERASPECTOFDEMOCRACYTHATAROUSESTHEWRATHOFTHE*IHAD ISTSISECONOMICFREEDOM0EOPLECANEARNANDSPENDASTHEYWISH WITHOUTHAVINGTOPAY)SLAMICTAXES4HISMAKESTHEIRlNANCIALDEALINGS UNLAWFULFROMTHE)SLAMICPERSPECTIVE-OREOVERINTERESTRATESRIBA USURY AREILLICITASMUCHASISREFUSINGTOPAY)SLAMICALMSANDTAXES ZAKAT h$EMOCRACYISBASEDONTHEPRINCIPLETHATTHEREALOWNEROF THEGOODSISTHE(UMANBEINGANDTHEREFOREITISUPTOHIMTOEARN ITTHEWAYHEWISHESINTHESAMEWAYASITISUPTOHIMTOCHOOSE HOWTOSPENDITASHEDESIRESANDWISHESEVENIFTHISISPROHIBITED ANDBANNEDBYTHERELIGIONOF!LLAH4HATISWHATTHEYCALLECONOMIC FREEDOMANDFREECAPITALISM4HISISAGAINSTTHE)SLAMICRULE!LLAH ISTHEACTUALOWNEROFGOODSAND(UMANBEINGISONLY(ISDELEGATE ANDISRESPONSIBLEFORTHEMBEFORE!LLAHHOWHEEARNSTHEMHOWHE SPENDSTHEM!NDTHE(UMANBEINGIN)SLAMISNOTFREETOEARN HISLIVINGINFORBIDDENMANNERSHARAM ANDINNON AUTHORIZEDWAYS LIKEUSURYBRIBEANDOTHERPROHIBITEDWAYSv)NlNANCIALMATTERS )SLAMICRADICALSAND-USLIM&UNDAMENTALISTSAREINAGREEMENTONTHE

PRINCIPLES7HATDISTINGUISHESTHEMISTHEWAYTHEYINTENDTODEAL WITHIT&OR*IHADISTSVIOLENCEAND*IHADARETHESOLEMEANINGFULWAY OFDEALINGWITHTHEPHENOMENONWORLDWIDEWHEREASMOST)SLAMIC &UNDAMENTALISTSSEEKALTERNATIVEWAYSOFSUPERVISINGECONOMICACTIVI TIESOPENINGUPhHALALBANKINGvANDh)SLAMIClNANCESvWITHINTHE PREVAILINGINTERNATIONALBANKINGSYSTEM

&OR*IHADISTS-USLIMSAREINADEEPCRISISINTHEIRCONFRONTATION AGAINSTTHE7EST4HEUNIQUESOLUTIONISRENEWEDFAITHIN!LLAHh4HE CRISISAFFECTS-USLIMSINTHEIRCONFRONTATIONWITHTHEVICTORIOUSAND TRIUMPHANT7ESTTHATDOMINATES-USLIMCOUNTRIES;7ECANWIN=IF WEARECONlDENTINOURSELVESASBEINGUPLIFTEDBYOUR&AITHAS!LLAH EXPLAINEDITTOUS@$ONTFEELWEAKANDDONTBESADBECAUSEYOULLBE THEHIGHESTIFYOUAREABELIEVERv!GAINSTINTERNALANDEXTERNALILLS THATBESIEGE)SLAMTHEPROPOSEDREMEDYIShSUBJECTIVEvREJECTINGTHE FEELINGOFWEAKNESSWAHN ANDSADNESSANDBEINGUPLIFTEDBY)SLAM 4HEREISADEEPVOLUNTARISMINTHISPERCEPTIONOFFAITHWHICHISIN TERPRETEDINTWODIFFERENTWAYSMODERNANDTRADITIONALATTHESAME TIMEWITHOUTMAJORCONmICT)NMODERNFASHIONTHEWILLOVERCOMES ALLTHESHORTCOMINGSINREFERENCETO!LLAHBYMULTIPLYINGITSENERGY ANDPOWER)NTRADITIONALFASHION!LLAHSUSTAINSTHEWILLANDSAVESTHE BELIEVERINAMIRACULOUSWAY4HESUBJECTIVISMOFTHE*IHADISTSSATIS lESTHEREFORETWODISTINCTYETOFTENOPPOSEDCATEGORIESOFBELIEVERS TRADITIONALISTSREFERENCETOMIRACLES ANDMODERNIZEDREFERENCETO VOLUNTARISMOFTHEFAITHANDTHEINDIVIDUALBELIEFOFTHE-USLIM

&OR*IHADISTSDEMOCRACYISCLOSETOTHE!RABICWORD)BAHIYAH WHOSEMEANINGIShLICENTIOUSNESSvANDACCOMPLISHMENTOFWHATHAS BEENFORBIDDENBY!LLAH)NTHISSENSEDEMOCRACYISTHEREIGNOFBESTIAL ITYh!-USLIMISNOTALLOWEDBYRELIGIONTOUSETHEWORDDEMOCRACY INHISDISCUSSIONSINAPOSITIVEWAY4HESYNONYMTODEMOCRACY IN!RABICIS)BAHIYA;LICENTIOUSNESSLICENSELIBERTINISMDISSOLUTENESS= )BAHIYAHPROCEEDSINITSPRINCIPLEFROMTHEAUTHORIZATIONOFWHATIS PROHIBITEDBYRELIGIONLIKETHEBANNINGOFNAKEDNESSANDADULTERY SODOMYLIWAT DRINKINGALCOHOLICBEVERAGESMARRIAGEWITH THOSE WHOARENTALLOWEDTOGETMARRIEDTOSISTERSMOTHER FORBIDDING OFAPOSTASYANDRULINGACCORDINGTOOTHERNORMSTHANTHOSEOF!LLAH !LLTHATISFORBIDDENBYRELIGION4HEYAVOIDNOTHINGBUTWHATTHEIR PASSIONSANDDESIRESBANFROMTHEMORWHATTHEIR INmUENTIAL IDOLS TAWAQIT AGREETOBANv

0OLITICALPARTIESAREBASEDONTHETHIRSTFORPOWERANDGREEDAND THISISAGAINSTTHETRUE)SLAMICRULERWHOSHOULDFOLLOW!LLAHBEDIS INTERESTEDANDACCEPTPOWERWITHOUTANYGREEDh0OLITICALPARTIESˆIT IS CLEAR FROM THEIR ACTION AND ETHICSˆLOOK FOR DOMINATION EVEN

THROUGHMUTUALKILLINGANDlGHTSOASTOGETPOWERANDLEADERSHIP 4HISATTITUDEISTHEIRMAXIMUMMOTIVATIONANDTHEYCOVERITUPBY THEIR;SUPPOSED=INTENTIONSOFREFORMATIONANDTHELOVEFORCOUNSELING 3HURA 4HISDOESNOTSATISFY!LLAHTHE'REATv

$EMOCRACYSQUARESWITHTHEDESIRESOFhLOWLYPEOPLEvANDTHEIR UNHEALTHYPASSIONSRATHERTHANOFTHOSEhWHOKNOWv4HISISTHETYPI CALATTITUDEOFREACTIONARYELITESALLOVERTHEWORLDTOWARDPLURALISM )N THIS RESPECT )SLAMIC RADICALISM IS SYNONYMOUSWITH REACTIONARY TRADITIONALISM h4HEPARTIES THROUGH THEIR PUBLICATIONS AND THEIR SPECIlCMEANSSPREADTHEPOLITICSOFBADEXAMPLESANDEXPANDBASE NESSANDDEPRAVITYINTHEPUBLIC4HEYPUSHPEOPLETOLISTENTOTHEIR ACTIONS4HEIRACTION IS INACCORDANCEWITH THEPASSIONSOF THELOWLYPEOPLEv

0OLITICALPARTIESATBESTWAVERBETWEEN)SLAMANDGODLESSNESSAT WORSTTHEYCREATEADUALALLEGIANCETOTHECALIPHANDTOTHEHEADOF THEPARTY THATRESULTSINHYPOCRISYMUNAlQUNTHOSEWHOUNDERTHE GUISEOF)SLAMSPREADDISSENSIONANDDISTRUSTTOWARD!LLAH h0OLITICAL PARTIESUNDERTHE)SLAMICGOVERNMENTEDUCATE-USLIMSTOWARDDUALITY HYPOCRISYlCKLENESSDISHONESTYANDDISUNITY/NTHEONEHANDTHEY OFFERTHEIRCOMMITMENTANDTHEIRFEALTYTOTHE-USLIMRULERANDON THEOTHERHANDTOTHEPARTYANDITSLEADER!NDTHISISPECULIARTOTHE PEOPLEOF(YPOCRISYANDTOTHOSEWHOWAVERINADISHONESTWAYAS SAYS!LLAHTHE!LMIGHTY4HE7OMEN v4HISDOUBLEALLEGIANCE ISPUNISHEDIN)SLAMBYTHEEXECUTIONOFTHOSEWHOSPREADITh0AYING ALLEGIANCETOTHELEADEROFTHEPOLITICALPARTYˆWHENTHEREAL)MAM OFTHE-USLIMSEXISTSˆANDOBEYINGHIMINWHATSTIMULATESORREPELS ISWHAT)SLAMFORBIDSTOTHEUTMOSTDEGREE)TORDERSTHEMURDEROF HEWHOASKSPEOPLEFORALLEGIANCEFORHISOWNSAKEAFTERTHEGENERAL ALLEGIANCETOTHE-USLIM#ALIPHv4HE-USLIMCALIPHISHERETHE EQUIVALENTOFTHE0LATONICVIRTUOUShPHILOSOPHERKINGv4HEMAJOR PROBLEM*IHADISTSFACEISTHATTHECALIPHDOESNOTEXISTUNDERTHEPRES ENTCIRCUMSTANCES4HEYPRESENTSOLUTIONSTOTHATASWELLSEEBELOW 3TILLTHEVIRTUOUSCALIPHUNDERMODERNCONDITIONSTURNSOUTTOBE ANAUTOCRATICRULERRATHERTHANADISINTERESTEDRIGHTEOUSGOVERNOR

!L3URIPUTSFORWARDANOTHERREASONFORHISREJECTIONOFPOLITICAL PARTIESINREFERENCETOTHENOTIONOFhREPREHENSIBLEINNOVATIONvBIDA 4RADITIONALSOCIETIESDONOTLIKECHANGEINANEXPLICITMANNER#HANGE ISPERCEIVEDASUTTERLYNEGATIVECONTRARYTOMODERNSOCIETIESWHERE ITISCONSIDEREDPOSITIVEUNLESSTHECONTRARYISPROVEN)NREFERENCE TOTHEFRAMEOFMINDOFTRADITIONAL)SLAMANDTHISCANBEEXTENDED TOMANYOTHERRELIGIONSASWELL POLITICALPARTIESAREAREPREHENSIBLE INNOVATIONBIDA h4HESEPOLITICALPARTIESINTHEIRPRESENTSHAPEIN

NOVATEREPREHENSIBLYINMATTERSTHATWEREUNKNOWNTOTHEFOREFATHERS OFTHE5MMASALAFALUMMA ANDEVERYREPREHENSIBLEINNOVATIONIS PERDITIONANDEVERYPERDITIONMERITSTHElREOF(ELLv

#ONTRARYTOTHE*IHADISTTREND)SLAMIC2EFORMISTSTREATPOLITICAL PARTIESASTHEEQUIVALENTOFTHE3HURA)SLAMICCOUNSELING OR(IZBAL LAHTHE+ORANICTERMFORTHEhPARTYOF!LLAHv ORASEQUIVALENTTOTHE DIVERSITYOFTHE)SLAMICJURIDICALSCHOOLSTHEREAREFOUROFlCIALSCHOOLS INTHE3UNNIWORLDˆTHE(ANAlTHE(ANBALITHE3HAlIANDTHE -ALIKIˆWHICHTOLERATEEACHOTHER INTHEIRMINORDIFFERENCES AND THEREFORETOTALLYDISSIMILARFROMREPREHENSIBLEINNOVATION4HECRISISOF -USLIMSOCIETIESPUSHESMANYPEOPLETOPOSITIVELYCREDITTHE*IHADIST INTERPRETATIONRATHERTHANTHE2EFORMIST

*IHADISTSCONTENDTHATPOLITICALPARTIESTENDTOBEASAFEHAVEN FOR THOSE POLITICIANSWHO HAVE BEEN DISCREDITED h4HE EXISTENCE OF THEMULTITUDE OF POLITICAL PARTIESWHOSE PROGRAM AND AIMS ARE AGAINSTAUNIlEDCOMMUNITYMOJTAMAWAHID ˆEVENTHOUGHCALLED )SLAMICˆPREPARESAFERTILEGROUNDFORTHEACTIONOFTHE(YPOCRITES MUNAlQIN ANDBESIDESTHEMDEVIANT-USLIMSZANADIQEH WITHTHEIR SICKMINDANDTHEIRDANGEROUSAIMS4HEYlNDINTHESEPARTIESTHE COVERUPFORTHEIRDESTRUCTIVEACTIONSANDASECURESANCTUARYFORTHEIR PERSONSONCETHEIRSITUATIONWORSENSANDTHEIRTRUENATUREISEXPOSED TOTHEPUBLIC0OLITICALPARTIESASISOBVIOUSINTENDTODEFENDTHEIR MEMBERSPARTICULARLYIFTHEYARETHEIRLEADERSWHENTHEIRTREASONIS DISCOVEREDv

*EWS-ASONSANDOTHERGODLESSGROUPSMANIPULATEPOLITICALPAR TIES4HEYTHREATENTHESECURITYOF-USLIMSOCIETIESBECAUSETHEYMIGHT BESPIESINTHESERVICEOFFOREIGNPOWERSh"YFOLLOWINGTHEHISTORYOF MANYCONTEMPORARYPOLITICALPARTIESONElNDSMANYDANGEROUSPER SONALITIES*EWS-ASONSANDPEOPLEFOLLOWINGSECURITYORGANIZATIONSOF GODLESSREGIMESTAWAQIT WHOINlLTRATETHEMUSINGTHEANTAGONISM BETWEENTHEPARTIESTOATTAINHIGHPOSITIONSWITHINTHEIRHIERARCHIES ANDSTRAIGHTENOUTDANGERFORTHESECURITYANDTHEPEACEOFTHEGROUP ANDEVENPERHAPSTHE-USLIMCOMMUNITYASAWHOLEv

!L 3URI SUMMARIZES HIS REJECTIONOF POLITICAL PARTIES IN SEVEN POINTS

4HEPURPOSEOFPOLITICALPARTIESISASTHEYSAYTHEALTERNATIONOF POWERTHROUGHPEACEFULMEANSFOREACHPERIODANDITISLIMITED BETWEENTHEPARTIESFORABOUTlVEYEARSMOREORLESS4HISLINEOF THOUGHTISUNACCEPTABLE;FOR)SLAM=FORMANYREASONS&IRSTOFALL THISISAMODERNTHOUGHTASTRANGERTOTHEPOLITICSINRELIGIONAND )SLAMIC LAW lQH AND THOSEWHO INNOVATEWITHIN OUR RELIGION WITHOUT ITS BEING IN ACCORDANCEWITH )SLAM SHOULD BE REJECTED

3ECONDTHISTHOUGHTISFROMTHEFABRICATIONOFTHECONTEMPORARY 'ODLESSNESS JAHILIYAMUASERA AND )SLAMCOMMANDSUS TODIF FERENTIATEFROMITTODISTANCEONESELFFROMITANDNOTTOIMITATEIT INITSOPINIONSANDPRINCIPLES4HIRDTHISTHOUGHTISINCOMPATIBLE WITHTHATWHICHISFOUNDEDBYTHE)SLAMICLAWANDPOLITICSGRASPED FROMTHE"OOKANDTHE0ROPHETICTRADITIONBASEDONTHEFACTTHAT THE-USLIM3ULTANORTHE-USLIM#ALIPHCANNOTBEDISMISSEDOTH ERWISETHANFORRELIGIOUSREASONSTHATREQUIREHISREMOVALFROMOFlCE ;ANDNOTTHROUGHPERIODICELECTIONS=4HEDESIRESOFTHEPOLITICAL PARTIESANDTHEIRASPIRATIONSOUTOFTHEIRLOVEFORDOMINATIONAND THEIRCLAIMTOBESUPERIORTOTHERELIGIOUSLAWINGOVERNINGCANNOT lNDJUSTIlCATIONINRELIGION&OURTHTHISTHOUGHTENDSUPWITH THELACKOFPOLITICALECONOMICANDSOCIALSTABILITYANDTHELIKE ANDWHENTHENEWARRIVESITDESTROYSTHEOLDTHATWASBUILTBEFORE ANDTHISISOBVIOUSINTHELOFTIESTCONTEMPORARYDEMOCRACIES&IFTH THISTHOUGHTISTHECLEAROPPORTUNITYFORTHEDEVIANTANDREPREHEN SIBLYINNOVATING)SLAMICPOLITICALPARTIESTOADOPTQUEERIDEASAND GUIDELINESWHICHARERELIGIOUSLYUNFOUNDEDWITHWEAKRELIGIOUS JUSTIlCATIONS ANDFARFROMTHE0ROPHETIC4RADITION3IXTHTHIS IDEASIGNIlESCOMPETITIONBETWEENDIFFERENT)SLAMICTENDENCIESIN ORDER TO RULE THROUGH SECTARIANGROUPS CAUSING RESENTMENTAND ANIMOSITYAMONGTHE-USLIMS3EVENTH3AYINGSOFTHE0ROPHET NECESSITATETHEKILLINGOFTHOSEWHOCOMPETEWITHTHE#ALIPHOR THE TOP-USLIM RULER AND CONTESTHIS RULE AND THIS COMPLETELY DENIESLEGITIMACYTOTHISKINDOFFOREIGNIDEATHATPOLLUTESMANY OFTHECONTEMPORARYPROPAGANDAS;NAMELYTHEPERIODICCHANGEIN LEADERSHIPTHROUGHELECTIONS= )NSUMMARYTHEREISNOFREEDOMFORPOLITICALPARTIESUNDERTHE )SLAMICGOVERNMENTWHATEVERTHEIDEAANDTHEIDENTITYOFTHESE PARTIES AND THEIRNAMES-USLIMS ARENOT ALLOWED TO CONSTITUTE POLITICALPARTIESUNDERTHE)SLAMICGOVERNMENT

4HISPOWERFULPLEADINGAGAINSTPOLITICALPARTIESINPARTICULARAND THEDEMOCRATICREGIMEINGENERALISONEOFTHEMOSTPOTENTONESINTHE )SLAMICWORLD,IKEMANYOTHER*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSAL3URIPRESENTSA STRONGCASEINHISCRITIQUEOFTHEDEMOCRATICSYSTEM(EUNDERLINESTHE WEAKNESSESOFDEMOCRACYINMINUTEDETAIL3INCETHE-ARXISTCRITIQUE OF hBOURGEOIS DEMOCRACYv THIS IS ONE OF THEMOST COMPREHENSIVE THISTIMEINTHENAMEOFACONSERVATIVEEVENREACTIONARY ANDSTILL REVOLUTIONARYCONCEPTIONOFRELIGION)TOPERATESFORMANY-USLIMS *IHADISTSORNOTASACOUNTERCULTURETOTHEOFlCIALPROPAGANDAMA CHINESOFAUTOCRATICREGIMESINTHE-USLIMWORLDBETHEYSECULAROR RELIGIOUSDISCREDITEDBYTHEIRINABILITYTOIMPROVETHELOTOF-USLIMS

ANDOPENUPTOTHEMNEWVISTASOFHOPE*IHADISMOPERATESAGAINSTTHE BACKGROUNDOFDESPAIRANDBITTERNESSWITHINTHE-USLIMWORLD

!GAINSTTHEMULTIPLICITYOFTHEPOLITICALPARTIESAL3URIBRANDISHES THEUNIQUElGUREOFTHECALIPHORTHEIMAMh)NTHE)SLAMICGOVERN MENT)SLAMISCHERISHEDINITSCOMMANDMENT)NTHEIRGOVERNMENT -USLIMSCHERISHTHEIROWNMAGNIlCENCEANDTHEIROWN)MAMWHO CONCENTRATESINHIMSELFALLOFTHEMANDGIVESUNITYTOTHEIRWORDS4HEY SEEKPROTECTIONINHIMANDCOMBATBEHINDHIM;THEENEMIES=THE COMMUNITYSTANDSlRMANDTHOSEWHODEVIATEFROMITOPTFOR(ELL ANDTHOSEWHODISTANCETHEMSELVESASPANFROMITDIEASADHERENTSOF 'ODLESSNESS*AHILIYA v

)NTHENAMEOFTHECHERISHEDUNITYOFTHE-USLIMSANDTHEIR RULERAL3URIPUTSFORWARDTHEIMAMTHEUNIQUERULERWHOKNOWSBET TERTHANTHEOTHERSTHEINTERESTSOF-USLIMSANDBEHAVESACCORDINGLY 4HISISTHEDESPOTIChPHILOSOPHERKINGvORITSMODERNEQUIVALENTTHE DICTATORWHOHEADSTHEMILITARYORPOLITICALAPPARATUSOFTHESTATE )SLAMICDICTATORSHIPISTHERESULTOFTHISCONCEPTIONNOTTHEUNIlCA TIONOFTHE5MMAUNDERTHEBANNEROFAJUSTRULER4HISCONCEPTION ISMUCHCLOSERTO&ASCISMTHANTOTRADITIONAL)SLAMWHICHIDEALIZED THE4IMESOFTHE0ROPHETBUTATTHESAMETIMEUNDERLINEDITSEXCEP TIONALNATUREANDITSINACCESSIBILITYTOMORTALS(ERETHEMODELIS SUPPOSEDTOBEREALIZABLEANDTHEUNITYOFTHE-USLIMCOMMUNITY ANDITSUNIlEDLEADERSHIPUNDERTHEIMAMARETAKENFORGRANTED

4ARTUSI LIKEMANYOTHER*IHADISTSSINCERELYBELIEVESTHATTHE RULER OBEYED BY-USLIMS !MIRMUTA IS THE ONLY SALVATION FOR THEM(ECANINSPIREAWEANDFEARINTHEPOWERFULIDOLWORSHIPPERS 7ESTERNGOVERNMENTS CONTRARYTOTHEDILUTEDRULEWITHINPOLITI CALPARTIESWHICHAREASAFEHAVENFORTREACHEROUSSPIESANDOTHER MISCHIEVOUSLEADERSWHOMTHE7ESTERNPOWERSDONOTFEARATALLh) KNOWTHEREISNOTHINGTHATTHEILLEGITIMATEGOVERNMENTS;4AWAQIT PLURALOF4AQUT=FEARFROMTHE-USLIMSMORETHANTHEIRCONCERTED ACTIONWITH PRESCRIBED AIMS BECAUSE THEY KNOW THAT THIS IS THE TYPEOFACTIONTHATCANSUCCEED4HE4AQUTKNOWSTHATIFA-USLIM ACTSFORHISRELIGIONINANINDIVIDUALANDEGOISTICMANNERTHEYCAN SCOFFATHIMANDHUMILIATEHIM!NDWHENTHESAME-USLIM ONTHECONTRARYACTSFORTHESAKEOFHISRELIGIONTHROUGHHISCOM MUNITYCOLLECTIVELYANDORDERLY THE2ULERWHOMHEOBEYS!MIR MUTA ELEVATESHIMANDTHEYFEARHIM;7ESTERNGOVERNMENTS=AND OPENUP FORHIM THOUSANDSOF ACCOUNTSv!CCORDING TO4ARTUSI )SLAM CANNOT BE DISSOCIATED FROM A RULERWITH THE CHARACTERISTICS ALREADYMENTIONEDh4HEREISNORELIGIONWITHOUTA#OMMUNITY;OF BELIEVERS=NO#OMMUNITYWITHOUTARELIGIOUSRULER;IMAM=ANDNO

RELIGIOUSRULERWITHOUTOBEYING;OFTHE&AITHFUL=ANDTHESETHREEARE INDISSOCIABLEv3TILLWHATISTOBEDONEIFTHEIMAMISLACKING4HE ANSWERISCOMMONTOALL*IHADISTSTHISDOESNOTSTOP*IHADh4HE ABSENCEOFTHE)MAMOFALL-USLIMSWHOBRINGSTOGETHERTHEIRWORDS ANDGATHERSTHEMSHOULDNOTSTOPFROMTHEMARCHTOWARD*IHADIN THEPATHOF!LLAHv

(OWTOACTINTHEABSENCEOF)MAM!L3URILIKEOTHER*IHADISTIN TELLECTUALSREFERSTOTHENOTIONOFISABAHALMUMINAHNAMELYAGROUP OFDEVOUT-USLIMSWHOKEEPONWAGING*IHADATTHOSETIMESWHENTHE SITUATIONMIGHTSEEMHOPELESSTOMANY4HISGROUPSTRANGELYLOOKS LIKETHEhREVOLUTIONARYVANGUARDvASSEENBY-AQDISIh!(ADITHWITH HIGHCREDENTIALSHADITHSAHIH FROM;THESCHOLAR=-USLIMDECLARES THERECONTINUESTOEXISTAGROUPISºBAH OFMY5MMAWHOlGHTFOR !LLAHSCOMMANDMENTSANDWHOAREUNFORGIVINGTOTHEIRENEMIESAND FORWHOMITISNOTABADTHINGTOOPPOSETHEIROPPONENTSUNTILCOMES THE(OUR;$AYOF*UDGMENT=ANDTHEYENDEAVORINTHATSENSE4HE (ADITHMENTIONSTHATTHISGROUPOFlGHTINGDEVOUT-USLIMSEXISTSIN OURTIMEANDINALLTHETIMESUNTILARRIVESTHE(OUR4HISGROUPlGHTS OFNECESSITYINTHEPATHOF!LLAHv-OREGENERALLYTHEPRAISEOFTHE ABSOLUTERULERINTHENAMEOF)SLAMISCOMMONTO*IHADIST3UNNISM ASWELLASRADICAL3HIISM4HENOTIONOFTHE6ALI&AQIHDEVELOPEDBY !YATOLLAH+HOMEINIISAKINTOTHATOFTHEh)MAMORTHE#ALIPH OF THE-USLIMSv4HETWORADICALTRADITIONSALTHOUGHANTAGONISTICTO EACHOTHERINTERMSOFTHEIRRESPECTIVECLAIMON)SLAMICLEGITIMACY AREREMARKABLYCONVERGENTINTHEIRDENUNCIATIONOFDEMOCRACYAND POLITICALPLURALISM

/NEOFTHEITEMSTOWHICHAL3URIDEVOTESALONGCHAPTERISTHE CLAIMBY)SLAMIC2EFORMISTSTHATDEMOCRACYISLEGITIMATESINCE!LLAH HASAPPROVEDTHE3HURA)SLAMICCOUNCIL !L3URIVEHEMENTLYREJECTS THISIDENTIlCATIONh4OSPREADDEMOCRACYAMONGPEOPLETHEYLIETO MAKETHEMBELIEVETHAT#OUNSELINGIN)SLAMISDEMOCRACYANDTHAT THERE IS NODIFFERENCE BETWEEN THEM ANDNO CONTRADICTIONv(E ENUMERATESNINEMAJORDIFFERENCESBETWEENDEMOCRACYAND)SLAMIC COUNCIL3HURA

3HURAISAN!RABICWORDMENTIONEDBYTHE(OLY+ORANTHATOR DERSTOABIDEBYITINTHEMAJORITYOFITSQUOTESWHEREASDEMOCRACY IS7ESTERNANDDEVILISHACCORDINGTOITSBIRTHPLACEANDORIGINAND HASNOROOTSANDDOESNOTEXISTINTHE!RABICLANGUAGEANDNEITHER INTHERELIGIONOF!LLAH 3HURAISTHECOMMANDMENTOF!LLAHWHEREASDEMOCRACYIS THECOMMANDMENTOFTHEPEOPLEAND)DOLATRYTAQUT

3HURAIMPOSESTHERULEOF!LLAHALONEWHEREAS$EMOCRACY IMPOSESTHERULEOFTHEPEOPLE 3HURAISBASEDONTHEPOSITIONOFRELIGIOUSCOMPETENCEIJHI HAD WHENTHEREISNOTEXTUALREFERENCETOITWHEREASDEMOCRACY REFERSTOEVERYTHINGANDRULESOVEREVERYTHINGWHATEVERTHERELI GIOUSCOMMANDMENTSABOUTTHEM4HEREISNTFROMTHEDEMOCRATIC VIEWPOINTANYTHINGSACREDTHATCANNOTBEPUTINTOQUESTIONAND ABASEDBYTHEVOTEANDTHECHOICE;OFPEOPLE= 3HURAOBEYSTHE5LAMASPECIALIZEDANDCOMPETENTPEOPLE INRELIGIOUSMATTERSWHEREAS$EMOCRACYOBEYSALLTHECLASSESAND CORPORATIONS(ERETICS ANDPIOUS ALIKE IGNORANT ANDCOGNIZANT DEPRAVEDANDRIGHTEOUSˆANDTHEREISNODIFFERENCEBETWEENTHEM INWHATISTHERULINGANDTHE;POLITICAL=DECISION MAKING 3HURACARESTHROUGHITSASSESSMENTSABOUTWHATISTHECLOSEST TOTHETRUTHANDTHERIGHTEVENIFITISCONTRARYTOTHEMAJORITYAND THEOPINIONOFPEOPLE$EMOCRACYCARESABOUTTHEQUANTITYANDTHE TRIVIALANDWORKSWITHTHEMAJORITYEVENTHOUGHTHERESULTMIGHT BEAGAINSTTHE4RUTHANDFAVORABLETOTHE&ALSEHOOD 3HURAISACONSULTATIVEPARLIAMENTWHOSEDUTYISTOEXPRESS THEIDEASCLOSESTTOTHETRUTHACCORDINGTOTHERULINGSOFRELIGION WHEREAS$EMOCRACYPROCEEDSFROMTHELEGISLATIVEPARLIAMENTTHAT HASTHERIGHTOFDECLARINGWHATISALLOWEDANDWHATISFORBIDDEN ANDTOENACTLAWSDIFFERENTFROMTHOSEOF!LLAH 3HURADERIVESFROMTHERELIGIONOF!LLAH4OBELIEVEINITIS NECESSARYANDTOREJECTITISAPOSTASYANDEXITFROMRELIGIONWHEREAS $EMOCRACYISTHERELIGIONOFIDOLATRYBELIEFINITIS(ERESYANDITS REJECTIONISFAITHFULNESSTO!LLAH 3HURAS RULING IS NECESSARY BUT NOT COMPULSORYWHEREAS $EMOCRACYSRULINGISCOMPULSORYTHROUGHTHEVOTESOFTHEPEOPLE WHATEVERITSCHARACTERISTICSANDITSPROXIMITYORDISAFFECTIONTOWARD THE4RUTH

3URIREJECTSHISTORICALPARTICULARITYORRELATIVITYTOANYPARTOFTHE +ORAN(ISSTATEMENTSABOUT3HURAUNDERSCOREHISCOUNTER MODERN ATTITUDEHISATTEMPTAThDE SECULARIZINGvRELIGION)NREACTIONTOTHE )SLAMICREFORMISTSAND&UNDAMENTALISTSWHOENDEAVORTOSECULARIZE )SLAMTHE*IHADISTSREINSTATERELIGIOUSLAWSANDREJECTANYADAPTATION TOMODERNSOCIETY)DEOLOGICALLYTHISISANIMPORTANTTRENDINTODAYS )SLAMTHEMORESOAS-USLIMSOCIETIESHAVEBEENDEEPLYSHAKENBY POLITICALASWELLASCULTURALCHANGEINTHELASTCENTURYWITHOUTlND INGPLAUSIBLESOLUTIONSTOTHECRISISUNLIKEMANYOTHERSOCIETIESˆFOR EXAMPLE3OUTH+OREA)NDIAANDSOME3OUTH!MERICANCOUNTRIES

4URKEYBEINGTHEMAJOREXCEPTIONWITHIN-USLIMSOCIETIES-ALAYSIA AND)NDONESIABEINGINBETWEEN

$EMOCRACYDOESNOTONLYMEANREJECTIONOF!LLAHSLEGISLATIONITS CONCEPTALSOENCOMPASSESALLTHOUGHTSANDDEEDSCONDEMNEDBYTHE LAWOF!LLAH-AQDISIANDAL3URIBOTHEXCORIATEPOLITICALPLURALISMAS ASYMPTOMOFAMUCHDEEPERDISBELIEFWHEREhPROSTITUTEPARLIAMENTSv MAJALISALFAHSHA MIXEDASSOCIATIONSANDUNIVERSITIESANDMORALLY CORRUPTFASIDA FOUNDATIONSANDSCHOOLSGOHANDINHAND$EMOCRACY ISAPOLITICALSYSTEMBUTITISASWELLAPERVERTEDDEVIANTIMMORAL ANDDESTRUCTIVECULTUREANDWAYOFLIFEˆINDEEDAPERVERSERELIGION -AQDISICALLSTHEDEMOCRATICASSEMBLIEShPARLIAMENTSOFGODLESSNESS DEPRAVATIONANDREVOLTAGAINST!LLAHvMAJALISALSHIRKWALFUSUQWAL USYAN

*IHADISTSREJECTTHEIDEATHAT$EMOCRACYCORRESPONDSATLEASTIN PARTTOTHEASPIRATIONSOFTHENEWGENERATIONS%VENINTHE-USLIM WORLDPARTOFTHENEWGENERATIONSINTHELARGECITIESLONGFORAMORE OPENPOLITICALSYSTEMANDAMOREPARTICIPATORYSOCIETY4HISMAJOR INTERNALTENDENCYWITHINMOST-USLIMSOCIETIESISSEENBY*IHADISTSAS ANEXTERNALCONSPIRACYBYTHE7ESTTOIMPOSEITSLAWSONTHE-USLIM WORLDSOASTOEXTENDITSDOMINATIONTOALLASPECTSOFLIFE(AVINGFAILED TOCONVERT-USLIMSTO#HRISTIANITYTHE/CCIDENTNOWATTEMPTSTOLURE -USLIMSTHROUGHANOTHERRELIGIONNAMELYSECULARDEMOCRACYSOASTO SUBVERTTHE)SLAMICFAITHANDPREPARETHEWAYFORTHETOTALSUBMISSION OF-USLIMS$EMOCRACYISA#RUSADESETDOWNINANEWIDIOMSOAS TODECEIVETHEFOLLOWERSOF!LLAHh4HECRUSADINGDEMOCRATIC7EST DOESNOTSTOPASKING-USLIMSˆINTHESAMEFASHIONAS-ISSIONARIES DIDBEFORETHEMˆTOADOPT#HRISTIANRELIGION4HISOBJECTIVEISDIF lCULTTOACHIEVEFORTHEMANDTHEREFORETHEYASKTHEMTOADOPTTHE NEWRELIGIONTHATISTHEDEMOCRATICONEv

$EMOCRACYISREPREHENSIBLEINPRINCIPLEBUTINPRACTICEITDOES NOTEVENAPPLYTHEVERYSAMELOFTYVALUESTHATVIOLATETHERULEOF!LLAH )NFACTACCORDINGTOAL3URIASWELLASOTHERMAJOR*IHADISTINTELLECTUALS WHOADOPTTHE-ARXISTNOTIONOFALIENATIONDEMOCRACYISTHEILLEGITI MATEDOMINATIONOFTHEFEWOVERTHEALIENATEDMASSES

)NDEMOCRATICELECTIONSENTERINTOACCOUNTMANYEXTERNALFACTORS THAT ARE ILLEGAL AND IMMORAL THE RESULT BEING UNBALANCED AND IMPRECISENOTREPRESENTINGTHEREALDESIREOFTHEMAJORITYOFTHE PEOPLEASTHEYPRETENDITTHEFACTOROFWEALTHINTERVENESINTHE ELECTORALCAMPAIGNTHEFACTOROFETHNICITYANDFAMILYTIESTHEMEDIA FACTORTHEINTERVENTIONOFTHEELITESANDPOWERFULPEOPLEFORTHE SUCCESSOFAPERSONAGAINSTANOTHERONEORAPARTYAGAINSTANOTHER

PARTY$EMOCRATICELECTIONSALLOWASWELLINTERNATIONAL5NBELIEV ERSPOWERS TO INTERFERE IN THECOUNTRYSPOLITICS7HATPRECEDES POINTSOUTTHATINTHEDEMOCRATICSYSTEMEVENINTHE53ANDTHE 7ESTERNCOUNTRIESPEOPLEARENOTFREE4HEYAREPRISONERSOFMANY EXTERNALFACTORSTHATFORCETHEMTOTAKEAWAYTHATISNOTTHEONE THEYWOULDLIKETOTAKE

)N ITS ESSENCE DEMOCRACY IS DEPRAVATION AND TURNING AWAY FROMTHE RIGHTPATH )TENDSUP INDESTRUCTIONh$EMOCRACY IN ITS NATURELEADSTHEWAYTODESTRUCTIONANDTOFOLLOWITONEHASTOBEA CROOKANDDEVIATEFROMTHE;RIGHT=PATHv4HEREARENTONLYISOLATED INTELLECTUALSANDCLERICSWHOREJECTDEMOCRACYINTHENAMEOF!LLAH BUTALSOGROUPSOFCLERICSWHOSIGNSTATEMENTSTOGETHERANDWHOSE SIGNATURESBEARPRESTIGEANDWEIGHTBECAUSEOFTHEIRINVOLVEMENTIN THElGHTAGAINSTTHEAUTOCRACYOF-USLIMREGIMES4HEMEREFACTOF THEIROPPOSITIONTOTHEPREVAILINGPOLITICALSYSTEMSREGARDEDASILLEGITI MATEBYMOSTOFTHEPOPULATIONGIVESTHEMCREDIT!GROUPOF5LAMA ANDACTIVISTSIN%GYPTCALLED*AMAATAL*IHADCOMMUNITYOF*IHAD HASSIGNEDADOCUMENTh*IHAD!GAINST)DOL7ORSHIPPERS0ROPHETIC 4RADITIONS$O.OT#HANGEvWHICHSUMMARIZESTHEMAINOBJECTIONS TODEMOCRACYFROMTHE&UNDAMENTALISTPOINTOFVIEW)TBEGINSBY POINTINGOUTTHECLASSICALRADICALVIEWTHATIN)SLAMTHE4ESTIMONYTO !LLAHTHElRSTPILLAR BEGINSBYDENYINGTHEEXISTENCEOFANYOTHER GODˆWHICHMEANSWARONALLTHEIDOLSINCLUDINGDEMOCRACYTHIS ISWHATTHERADICAL-USLIMSCALL,OYALTYAND$ISAVOWALASDISCUSSED INCHAPTER &ROMTHISPERSPECTIVEHOLYWARAGAINSTIDOLSANDIDOL WORSHIPPERS IS A FOUNDINGPRINCIPLEOF )SLAM4HEMEANINGOF THE 4ESTIMONYTO!LLAHSUNIQUENESSCANNOTBEFULLYATTESTEDBUTTHROUGH *IHADAGAINSTTHEHERETICS/NTHESITUATIONIN%GYPTTHEYSUMMARIZE THEIRVIEW

4HESITUATIONIN%GYPTCANBESUMMARIZEDINFOURPOINTS 4HEGOVERNMENTISGODLESS AGROUPOFAPOSTATESARERULING OVERIT PEOPLEARELOST -USLIMYOUTHISINDISARRAY 4HElRSTPOINTISDUETOTHELACKOFRULINGACCORDINGTOTHELAWS OF!LLAHANDTHEEXISTENCEOFMIXEDLAWS;PARTIALLY)SLAMICPAR TIALLYHUMAN MADE=ATTACHEDTOTHEM 4HEMOCKINGOFTHE )SLAMICLAWISTHEWORSTBECAUSEITPOSTPONESITORGIVESPRECEDENCE TONON )SLAMICLAWSOVERIT 2ULINGTHROUGHDEMOCRACYWAS CALLEDBY-AWDUDITHEREPUBLICANRULINGANDITISTHEDEIlCATIONOF MAN)TISWELL KNOWNTHATDEMOCRACYISINCONTRADICTIONTO)SLAM INMANYRESPECTS

4HEYENUMERATEWHATWEHAVESEENOTHER*IHADISTSUTTERRECURRENTLY 4HERELEVANTPOINTHEREISTHECONCRETECASESTHEYDESCRIBEINWHICH )SLAMICLAWANDhHUMAN MADELAWvCONTRADICTEACHOTHER

)F AMANBUYS A BOTTLE OFWINE FROM SOMEWHERE AND A YOUNG -USLIMTRIESTOAPPLYTHE)SLAMICLAWh/RDERINGWHATISLAWFULAND PREVENTINGWHATISUNLAWFULvAMRBILMARUFWANAHYANALMUNKIR HEBREAKSTHEBOTTLE4HEYGOTOTHEPOLICE7HOISWRONGFROMTHE POINTOFVIEWOFTHEMAN MADELAWANDFROMTHEPOINTOFVIEWOF THE)SLAMICLAW&ROMTHE)SLAMICVIEWTHE-USLIMYOUTH;WHO BROKETHEBOTTLE=ISTOTALLYINNOCENTANDHEWHOCARRIEDITISTOBE CONDEMNEDUNDERTHEDIVINELAWDESERVINGPUNISHMENT&ROMTHE PERSPECTIVEOFTHEMAN MADELAWTHECOURAGEOUS-USLIMISGUILTY FORHAVINGTRESPASSEDONTHERIGHTSOFACITIZENTOCARRYABOTTLE;OF WINE=WHOISINNOCENTBECAUSETHETEXTOFTHELAWSTIPULATESIT (AVEYOUSEENTHATHERETICALDIABOLICTEXTOFTHELAW!ND IFACITIZENGOESTOACHEAPPLACEANDDRINKSTWOGLASSESOFWINE HOWSHOULDONETREATHIM7HATHEHASDONEISASINACCORDINGTO THE)SLAMICLAWBUTLEGALLYSPEAKINGHEISINNOCENTANDTHEREISNO PUNISHMENTACCORDINGTOTHETEXTOFTHELAW4HEMAN MADE LAWDOESNOTFORBIDTHECONSUMPTIONOFALCOHOLANDTHEREFOREWHAT ISFORBIDDEN;BY)SLAM=ISALLOWED;BYTHEMAN MADELAW= )FAMANHASSEXUALRELATIONSZINA WITHANON MARRIEDWOMAN WITHHERCONSENTTHEDEBAUCHERYOUTSIDETHECOUPLEISNOTALLOWED ANDWHATISITSTREATMENTTHROUGHTHE)SLAMICLAW4HISISASIN FORNICATIONISAMORTALSINIMPLYINGTHECRIMINALPUNISHMENT"UT ACCORDINGTOTHETEXTOFTHEMAN MADELAWTHEWOMANISINNOCENT BECAUSETHELAWDOESNOTPROHIBITSEXUALRELATIONSHIPOUTSIDETHE MARRIAGEFORANADULTWOMANIFSHEISACQUIESCENT )FAMANCHANGESHISRELIGIONFROM)SLAMTOSOCIALISMORSECULAR ISMORANYRELIGIONTHATDOESNOTCOMPLYWITH)SLAMORCONTRADICTS THERELIGIONOF!LLAHORSOMEONEMOCKSITORINSULTSTHE0ROPHET ORACCUSESHIMOFCOWARDICEWHATISTHESENTENCEBYTHE)SLAMIC LAW(EISANAPOSTATEANDHEDESERVESEXECUTION,EGALLYSPEAKING ACCORDINGTOMAN MADELAW THEREISNOTHINGAGAINSTHIMBECAUSE HEISFREEINHISSPEECHANDTHEREFORETHEREISNOPUNISHMENT

4HEPROBLEMRAISEDISNOT7ESTERNDOMINATIONORTHECORRUPTION ANDSUBSERVIENCEOFTHE)SLAMICRULERSORTHENECESSITYTODEFENDANY )SLAMICGROUP0ALESTINIANS!FGHANSORANYONEELSE BUTTHEDEFENSE OF!LLAHSLAWAGAINSTHUMAN MADELAWWHICHISFORMANY-USLIM &UNDAMENTALISTSTHEESSENCEOFDEMOCRACY4HETEXTOFTHE5LAMA

GOESONINTHESAMEFASHIONMENTIONINGWHATISHAPPENINGONADAILY BASISIN-USLIMCOUNTRIESLIKE+UWAIT%GYPTANDELSEWHEREh4HIS ;APOSTASY=HAPPENEDINTHECOUNTRYOF+UWAITWHENAPROFESSOROF SOCIOLOGY!HMADAL"AGHDADI CLAIMED THAT THE0ROPHET FELLBACK ONlGHTINGANDVIOLENCEAFTERHEFAILEDINHISCALLTOTHE(ERETICSIN -ECCAFORTHEIRCONVERSIONTO)SLAM4HEREWASNOJURIDICALSENTENCE AGAINSTHIMUNDERTHEPRETEXTOFENCOURAGINGTHEFREEDOMINVOICING RELIGIOUSLEGALOPINIONSFATWA )FAWOMANAPPEARSONTHESTAGEOFA THEATREANDSINGSDANCESORISDRESSEDINADANCINGCOSTUMEACCORDING TOTHERULESOFTHEARTISTICCORPORATIONSWHATISHERRELIGIOUSCASE)T ISAMORTALSINTHATDESERVES)SLAMICLEGALPUNISHMENTBUTWHATDOES THEMAN MADELAWSTIPULATE3HEISANARTISTFREEANDINNOCENTv 4HESE RELIGIOUS CULTURAL ISSUES RELATED TO )SLAMIC TRADITIONS OFFEND -USLIMTRADITIONALISTSAND&UNDAMENTALISTSASWELLASTHE*IHADISTS WOMENShNAKEDNESSvINTHEPUBLICSPHERETHATISINMOSTCASESTHEIR NOTCOVERINGUPTHEIRFACEANDHEADWITHAVEILHIJAB CONSUMPTION OFALCOHOLINPUBLICDElANCEAGAINSTTHERELIGIONINSULTSAGAINSTTHE 0ROPHETANDSOFORTH!LLTHESEFACTSPUBLICIZEDBYTHEMEDIADESTA BILIZEMANYDEVOUT-USLIMSWHOFEELTHAT)SLAMISTRAMPLEDONBY THENEWCULTUREMAINLYIMPORTEDFROMTHE7EST

%CONOMICPROBLEMSCOMEINTOPLAYASWELL4HEBANKINGSYS TEMBASEDONLOANSWITHINTERESTRATESISVIEWEDBYTHE5LAMAAS AUTHORIZINGhUSURYvRIBA WHICHISFORMALLYCONDEMNEDBY)SLAM )MPOVERISHEDPEOPLEIN-USLIMCITIESWHERETRADITIONALCOMMUNITY ASSISTANCEDOESNOTWORKPROPERLYANYMOREFEELTHATTHEIRECONOMIC LIFEHASDETERIORATEDASARESULTOFTHESECULARIZATIONTHATBREAKSDOWN )SLAMICPHILANTHROPYANDMUTUALAIDTHEONLYONEKNOWNBYMANY -USLIMS 3ECULAR GOVERNMENTS ARE TARGETS OF THE INCRIMINATIONS INCLUDING THE ACCUSATIONOF BREAKING )SLAMIC LAW AT THE SERVICE OF FOREIGNHERETICALPOWERS

!DDED TO THESEMOTIVATIONS RELATED TO THE RELIGIOUS SHAPING OFPUBLICLIFEANDITSBEINGCALLEDINTOQUESTIONBYNEWGENERATIONS ANDBYNEWSECULARIZINGTRENDSWITHINTHE-USLIMWORLDAREPOLITI CALFACTORSRELATEDTOTHECRITICALSITUATIONOF-USLIMSOCIETIESAND INPARTICULAR)SRAELSMILITARYSUPREMACYOVERTHE0ALESTINIANS4HE SITUATIONIN)SRAELISPERCEIVEDASTHEGENERALMODELTHROUGHWHICH THE5NITED3TATESIMPOSESITSHEGEMONYON-USLIMSBYHUMILIATING THEMONADAILYBASIS)NTHISMATTER-USLIMGOVERNMENTSAREAC COMPLICESOF!MERICA

7HATDOYOUSAYABOUT)SRAEL!CCORDINGTOTHEMAN MADELAWTHE APPROPRIATEACTIONISTHECONSULTATIONAGAINSTITANDTHEAPPROVAL OFTHEPARLIAMENTAGAINSTIT"UTACCORDINGTOTHE)SLAMICLAW

EVEN IF THERE ARE THOUSANDSOF CONSULTATIONS AGAINST IT THEY ARE WRONGBECAUSE0ALESTINEISA-USLIMLANDWRESTEDBYFORCEAND THEREISNOLEGALITYINTHEHERETICAL*EWISHGOVERNMENTSCLAIMON ITANDTHEREFORETHE;%GYPTIAN=PARLIAMENTLEGALIZESWHAT)SLAMIC LAWFORBIDS !NDWHATABOUT#AMP$AVIDTHATDECLAREDTHEENDOFTHEWAR AGAINST )SRAEL )N THE LAWOF!LLAHAND(IS0ROPHET THIS IS ABSOLUTELYWRONGBECAUSETHISATTITUDENEGATESTHEPROVENRELIGIOUS DUTYOF*IHADINTHEPATHOF!LLAHlSABILILLAH )TISOBVIOUSBYTHE CONSENSUSOFTHE5LAMATHAT*IHADIN0ALESTINEISAPERSONALDUTY ;FARDHALAYNEACHONESINDIVIDUALRESPONSIBILITYANDNOTALOOSE DUTYASWHEN-USLIMSATTACKANON -USLIMLANDSFARDHALKIFA= FOREVERY-USLIM

2ELIGIOUSMALAISECOMBINESWITHPOLITICALFRUSTRATIONRELATEDTO)SRAEL ANDTHEPOLITICALMAYHEMINOTHER-USLIMLANDSTOMOBILIZETHOSE -USLIMSWHOSUFFERFROMTHEINTERNALEVOLUTIONOFSOCIETYTOLERANCE FORALCOHOLWOMENSNEWBEHAVIORPATTERNSRELAXINGTHERELIGIOUSLAWS GOVERNINGTHEPUBLICSPHERE ANDTHOSEWHOAREMAINLYCONCERNED WITHTHEQUESTIONOFTHE0ALESTINIANNATIONANDMOREGENERALLY!RAB IDENTITY

4HECONDEMNATIONOFTHISSITUATIONISTOTALANDCATEGORICALAND DEMOCRACYISSEENASTHEMAINCULPRITh$EMOCRACYISSINAGAINST!LLAH BECAUSEITGRANTSTHERIGHTTOLEGISLATETOPEOPLEv7HATISIRONICISTHAT MOSTOFTHEMALAISERELATEDTOTHEPREVAILINGSITUATIONINTHE-USLIM WORLDISDUETOTHELACKOFDEMOCRACYPARLIAMENTSNOTBEINGELECTED DEMOCRATICALLYINMOST-USLIMCOUNTRIESANDAUTHORITARIANISMBEING THEGENERALRULE3TILLDEMOCRACYISSTIGMATIZEDANDCONDEMNEDFOR ITSSECULARNATURECALLINGINTOQUESTIONTHELAWOF!LLAH$EMOCRACY IShTRASHvACCORDINGTO4ARTUSI7HATMANY-USLIMSCONDEMNUN DERTHEHEADINGOFDEMOCRACYISTHENEWDESPOTICRULEWITHAMOCK FORMOFDEMOCRACYIN!RABCOUNTRIESOTHERWISETHEREISNOCONCRETE EXPERIENCEOFDEMOCRACYINMOSTOFTHE-USLIMWORLDTHATWOULD HAVELEDTODISAPPOINTMENTANDREJECTION)TISTRUETHATSOMEOFTHE MAJORlGURESOF*IHADLIVEDPARTOFTHEIRLIVESINTHE7ESTANDTHEY GREWDEEPLYDISILLUSIONEDBYTHEIREXPERIENCEOFDEMOCRATICRULE4HE MAJOROBJECTOFTHEIRCRITIQUEISSECULARIZATIONINTHE7ESTASTHEY WITNESSEDITINTHEIRDAILYLIFE4ARTUSIAL3URIAND!BU1ATADAHAVE LIVEDLONGPERIODSOFTHEIRLIFEINTHE7EST

4HECRITIQUEOFDEMOCRACYISMADENOTONLYBYMAJOR*IHADIST lGURESBUTALSOBYASWARMOFMIDDLE RANGEINTELLECTUALSORCLERICS WHOECHOTHESECRITICSBYAMPLIFYINGTHEMTHROUGHTHEIRPERSONALLINKS ANDGROUPAFlLIATIONANDBYPOPULARIZINGWHATTHEMAJORINTELLECTUALS

SAYINAMORESOPHISTICATEDWAY(ASSAN-OHAMED1AEDISONEOF THESEPOPULARIZERS(EBEGINSBYGIVINGASOCIOLOGICALEXPLANATION OFTHEENTICEMENTSOFDEMOCRACYINTHE-USLIMWORLDREFERRINGTO DESPOTISMANDTHEDESIRETOACHIEVETHROUGHDEMOCRACYSOMEOFTHE SOCIALGOALSTHATAREIMPEDEDBY!RABAUTOCRACIES4HISISANILLUSION FROMHISPOINTOFVIEW$EMOCRACYISINCOMPATIBLEWITH)SLAMINTHE FOLLOWINGCASESTHATAREAKINTOTHOSERAISEDBYTHE%GYPTIAN*AMAAT AL*IHADLOYALTYTO)SLAMMEANSTHEREJECTIONANDDISAVOWALOFOTHER POLITICALSYSTEMSTHE)SLAMICINJUNCTIONTOSPREADWHATISRELIGIOUSLY APPROVEDANDACTIVELYFORBIDWHATISBANNEDBY!LLAHSRELIGIONONE SHOULDFORINSTANCETHEREFOREACTPERSONALLYAGAINSTTHOSEWHOPUB LICLYDRINKALCOHOLICBEVERAGES ISCONTRARYTOTHEDEMOCRATICRULEOF LAWPROHIBITINGSUCHACTS)SLAMICRULINGONAPOSTASYTHEEXECUTION OFTHEAPOSTATE CONTRADICTSDEMOCRACYANDITSFREEDOMOFBELIEFTHE )SLAMICCOMMANDMENTTOWARDOTHERRELIGIOUSCOMMUNITIESSTIPULAT INGTHATTHEYPAYRELIGIOUSTAXESJIZIYAH CONTRADICTSTHEDEMOCRATIC EQUALITYOFCITIZENSIRRESPECTIVEOFTHEIRRELIGIONANDlNALLY)SLAMIC *IHADAGAINSTTHEENEMIESOF)SLAMCANNOTlNDANYJUSTIlCATIONWITHIN DEMOCRACY1AEDDOESNOTHAVEANYORIGINALIDEASOFHISOWNBUTHE SERVESASANAMPLIlERFORMAJOR*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSANDCLERICSBY ECHOINGTHEIRVOICESINTHE-USLIMWORLD

)N)SLAMICCOUNTRIESGOVERNMENTSTHATHAVEMONOPOLIZEDPOWER UNDERTHEHEADINGOFMODERNMOTTOESDEMOCRACYNATIONALISMSOCIAL ISMETC HAVEDONETREMENDOUSHARMTOTHECAUSEOFDEMOCRACYBY TURNING-USLIMSAGAINSTIT4HEANTAGONISTICATTITUDEOFTHE5NITED 3TATESTOWARDTHEISSUEOFDEMOCRACYIN0ALESTINE(AMASSDEMOCRATIC ELECTIONSWEREREJECTED AND,EBANON(IZBALLAHCHARACTERIZEDASA TERRORISTORGANIZATIONALTHOUGHITACQUIREDPERCENTOFTHESEATSIN THE,EBANESE0ARLIAMENT ANDTHE!MERICANPORTRAYALOF)SRAELASTHE PARAGONOF7ESTERNDEMOCRACYHAVETURNEDPARTSOFTHE-USLIMWORLD AGAINSTPLURALISM3TILLDEMOCRACYISSEENASTHECULPRITEVENWHEREIT DOESNOTEXISTLIKEINMOSTOFTHE-USLIMWORLDITISTHESYMBOLOF 7ESTERNSELF RIGHTEOUSNESS

/NEMAJORPROBLEMWITHDEMOCRACYISTHEADVENTOFCOMPLEX POLITICALSYSTEMS4RADITIONAL)SLAMDIDNOTDISTINGUISHBETWEENLEGISLA TIVEANDJURIDICALSPHERES4HEFORMERWASTHEPRIVILEGEOFTHERULER BASEDONTHEVIOLENCEOFTHOSEWHODOMINATED-USLIMSOCIETIES7ITH THEADVENTOFNATIONALISMINTHETWENTIETHCENTURYPARLIAMENTARISM BECAMEPARTANDPARCELOF-USLIMPOLITICALSYSTEMS"UTINSTEADOF CONTRIBUTINGTOITSDEMOCRATIZATIONITPROMOTEDDIFFERENTTYPESOF OLIGARCHIESWHICHWEREDISRESPECTFULOFPEOPLESVOTESTHEIRMEMBERS lNDINGTHEIRPLACEINPARLIAMENTSTHROUGHRIGGEDELECTIONSANDCLIEN TELISM&ORTHESEREASONSPARLIAMENTARISMINTHE-USLIMWORLDHASA

BADREPUTATION)SLAMICRADICALSMANIPULATETHISFEELINGOFILLEGITIMACY OFTHEPARLIAMENTSADDINGTOITTHEIROWNINABILITYTOCOPEWITHTHE DIVERSIlCATIONOFPOLITICALSYSTEMSANDTHENECESSITYTOADAPTRELIGIOUS LAWSTONEWSOCIALCONTEXTS)NSTEADTHEYINNOVATEBYAPPLYING)SLAMIC RULETOTHEENTIREPOLITICALSYSTEMDENYINGFREEDOMOFACTIONEVEN INTHOSESPHERESWHERE)SLAMICTRADITIONWASRATHERTOLERANT)NFACT TRADITIONALLYEVERYSITUATIONTHATDIDNOTCONTRADICT)SLAMBUTDIDNOT WIELDAJURIDICALCOMMANDMENTWASUSUALLYTREATEDAShCUSTOMARYv URF ANDMOREORLESSRECOGNIZEDASHARMLESS&OR)SLAMICRADICALS POLITICSSHOULDBESUBORDINATEDTOTHERULEOF!LLAHPARTICULARLYIN THELEGISLATIVESPHERE4HISNEWDOMAINWHEREHUMANSOCIETYNEEDS CODIFYINGNEWRULESINORDERTOCOPEWITHSITUATIONSTHATWERENOT ANTICIPATEDBY)SLAMICJURISPRUDENCEISTHUSANNEXEDTORADICAL)SLAM WHICHSOLVESTHEPROBLEMBYRECOURSETOFASCISTICSOLUTIONS

)NITSNEWFORMPARLIAMENTARISMPUTSINTOQUESTIONTRADITIONAL )SLAMICTENETSBECAUSEITPROMULGATEShHUMAN MADELAWSvTHATARE ALSOAPPLIEDTOTHEJUDICIALREALMWITHSECULARCONSTITUTIONSCLAIMING TOBETHEFOUNDATIONOFTHELAW4HISISWHYTHEHOSTILITYOFMANY *IHADISTJURISTSTOWARDPOLITICALPLURALISMISMUCHDEEPERTHANTOWARD DICTATORSHIPSUNDERWHICHPEOPLEAREhVICTIMSvANDTHEREFOREDONOT HAVETOGIVETHEIRAPPROVALTOTHESOCIALSYSTEMASSUCH)NDEMOCRACIES PEOPLETHEMSELVESARESUPPOSEDTOBETHESOURCEOFLEGISLATIONAND THISSCANDALIZES*IHADISTS2EFORMISTSAND&UNDAMENTALISTSTRYHARD TOlNDRELIGIOUSJUSTIlCATIONSFORPARLIAMENTARYSYSTEMSBUTRADICALS REFUSETODOSODECLARINGTHEENTIRESYSTEMPRESUMPTUOUSANDAGAINST !LLAHSPRIVILEGETOLEGISLATEANDRULE&ORTHEMTURNINGAWAYFROM THELAWOF!LLAHANDADHERINGTOhHUMAN MADELAWSvARETHECAUSE OF-USLIMSDECAYh4HESERVILITYINWHICH-USLIMSLIVEINTHEWORLD ISNOTHINGBUTTHECONSEQUENCEOFTHEIRLEAVINGTHE,AWOF!LLAHv (UMAN MADELAWIS LOWLYANDBASEDONANUNBEARABLEARROGANCE h4HE RULES AHKAM OF THE CREATURES ;OPPOSED TO THE#REATOR= ARE RUBBISHOFTHEMINDANDLITTEROFTHETHOUGHTv

.OTES