ABSTRACT
EASIERTOREACHCOMPROMISESWITHCONSERVATIVERELIGIOUSAUTHORITIES RATHERTHAN2EFORMISTONESANDTHECULTOFhUNITYvBASEDONTHElRST PILLAROF)SLAMTAWHID AMONGOTHERS4HEEXTERNALREASONSARETHE NEGATIVEDIMENSIONSOFCHANGECOLONIALISMTHECREATIONOF)SRAEL THESUCCESSIVEWARSINTHE-IDDLE%ASTBETWEEN)SRAELANDTHE!RAB WORLDTHEN!L1AEDAANDTHECHAINREACTIONSCAUSEDBYIT -USLIM 2EFORMISTSARESQUEEZEDBETWEENTHEIRDESIREFORMODERNIZATIONAND THETRAUMATIZINGEFFECTSOFMODERNITY4HEYSWINGBETWEENIDENTIlCA TIONWITHTHEMODERNWORLDANDFRUSTRATIONWITHIT
4HEMODERNIZATION PERIOD IN )SLAMMAINLY FROM THE NINE TEENTHCENTURYONWARDHASGIVENBIRTHTOSECULARINTELLECTUALSWITH ANATIONALISTSOCIALISTORCOMMUNISTBENTBUTTHEMOREIMPORTANT FACTHASBEENTHEAPPEARANCEOFSECULAR-USLIMINTELLECTUALSOFTEN WITHARADICALDISPOSITIONINTHENAMEOF!LLAHBECAUSEOFTHETRAUMAS CAUSEDBYMODERNIZATION"EITAMONGTHE3HIITESAS INTHECASES OF!LI3HARIATIn *ALAL!L!HMADn THELATE !HMAD&ARDIDn ETCORINTHE3UNNIWORLDASINTHE CASESOF(ASSANAL"ANNAn 3EYED1UTBn THEAGRICULTURALENGINEER3HUKRI-USTAFA THELEADEROF THE*IHADISTGROUP4AKlRWAL(IJRAWHOSEMEMBER+HALED)SLAMBOULI KILLED THE%GYPTIAN0RESIDENT!NWAR AL3ADAT IN"IN,ADEN B AND!YMANAL:AWAHIRI B MANYOF THERADICAL INTELLECTUALSDONOTBELONGTOTHE5LAMA4HEYLEADAhNONRELIGIOUSv LIFEANDTHEIREARNINGSAREMAINLYRELATEDTOMODERNJOBS!YMANAL :AWAHIRIWASAPHYSICIAN"IN,ADENABUSINESSMAN3HARIATIA0H$ HOLDERFROMTHE3ORBONNEANDSOFORTH 4HESEPEOPLEARETHEPARA DOXICALRESULTSOFMODERNIZATIONANDSECULARIZATIONBUTTHEYREACTTO THESETENDENCIESANDREJECTTHEM4HEYARENOTUNAWAREOFMODERN LIFESINCETHEYUSUALLYAREPARTOFITHAVINGLIVEDINTHE7EST3HARIATI LIVEDMANYYEARSIN&RANCE!BU-USABAL3URI!BU1ATADA!BU (AMZAAL-ISRIANDMANYOTHERSLIVEDIN"RITAIN3PAINAND)TALY -ANYOFTHESENEWINTELLECTUALSSOMEOFWHOMGOBACKASFARASTHE SLIKE%QBAL,AHURITHE)NDIAN0ERSIAN WRITINGPOETAND&UN DAMENTALIST HAVETAKENTHESIDEOF)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISMAGAINST SECULAROR2EFORMISTTHINKERS
4HENEWGENERATIONSOF*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSARENOTHOMOGE NEOUS4HEYAREFROMALLWALKSOFLIFEANDBELONGTODIFFERENT-USLIM SOCIETIES!RAB0AKISTANI0ERSIANETC 4HEREAREMANYSCIENTISTSAND ENGINEERSAMONGTHEMASWELLASTRADITIONALPEOPLE4HEIRINTELLECTUAL PRODUCTION IS CONSIDERED LEGITIMATEBYMANY-USLIMSAROUND THE WORLDBECAUSETHEYARECONSIDEREDTOBELONGTOALINEAGEOFAN)SLAMIC TRADITIONTHATHASBEENVIBRANTTHROUGHOUTTHEHISTORYOF)SLAMWITH LARGEPERIODSOFMARGINALITYBUTWITHOUTTOTALLYDISAPPEARING4HE
FACTTHATSECULARIZATIONHASBEENLATE IN)SLAMSHISTORYMAKESTHEIR CLAIMTHEMORELEGITIMATE7ElNDAMAJORDIFFERENCEBETWEENTHE #HRISTIANWORLDWHOSEREVOLUTIONARYUTOPIANRELIGIOUSINTELLECTU ALSDISAPPEAREDINTHELATESEVENTEENTHCENTURYASCENTRALlGURESOF 7ESTERNHISTORYANDTHE-USLIMWORLDWHERETHE*IHADWASREVIVEDIN THENINETEENTHCENTURYINREACTIONTO%UROPEANCOLONIZATION!LGERIA )NDIA#AUCASUS AFTERITSECLIPSEFORMORETHANHALFAMILLENNIUMAFTER THE-ONGOLPERIODOFTHELATETHIRTEENTHANDFOURTEENTHCENTURIES
4HESECULARIZATIONTHATTOOKPLACEINTHE7ESTDIDNOTOCCURAS SUCHINTHE)SLAMICWORLD4HEADAPTATIONTODIFFERENTSITUATIONSHAP PENEDMOSTLYBYTHEMULTIPLICATIONOFSECTSANDREINTERPRETATIONOFTHE RULESWITHINESTABLISHEDSCHOOLSOFLAWFOURIN3UNNISM RATHERTHAN THROUGHTHEDIRECTMARGINALIZATIONOFTHERELIGIONINMATTERSRELATEDTO THESOCIALANDPOLITICALREALMSASITHAPPENEDINTHE/CCIDENT%VEN ATMOMENTSOFACUTECRISISASWHENINTHELATETHIRTEENTHCENTURYTHE -ONGOLSATTACKEDANDCONQUERED-USLIMLANDSANDIMPOSEDTHEIR OWNLEGALCODEKNOWNIN)SLAMASTHEh9ASAvORh9ASAQv THELEGITIMACY OFRELIGIONWASNOTPUTINTOQUESTION-ONGOLSIMPOSEDTHEIRRULESIN AVIOLENTMANNERWITHOUTANYLEGITIMACYONTHESIDEOFTHE-USLIMS 4HEYLATERCONVERTEDTO)SLAMANDFROMTHENONTHEYAPPLIED)SLAMIC LAWORACOMBINATIONOFITWITHSOMEOFTHEIROWNTRADITIONS -ANY *IHADISTSCOMPARETHEPREVAILINGSITUATIONNOWADAYSWITHTHATOFTHE -ONGOLCONQUESTOF-USLIMCOUNTRIES4HEYCONCLUDETHATTHECURRENT SITUATIONISWORSETHANTHATTIMEBECAUSE-ONGOLRULERSCONVERTED TO)SLAMANDRESTORED)SLAMICLAWANDEDUCATIONWHEREASTHE7ESTIS hDESTROYINGv)SLAMIRREPARABLYNOTONLYTHROUGHCONQUESTORPOLITI CALDOMINATIONBUTTHROUGHDISSEMINATIONOFASECULARCONSUMERIST HEDONISTIC ANDPERVERSE CULTURE THAT CUTS OFF-USLIMS FROM THEIR )SLAMICROOTSBYENTICINGOREVENBEWITCHINGTHEM
4HE-USLIMINTELLIGENTSIAISDIVIDEDINTOTHE5LAMAANDNON CLERICALS-ANYOFTHEMOSTRADICALONESAREFROMTHESECONDGROUP IN AN APPARENT PARADOXICAL FASHION ,ACKING A FORMAL INSTITUTION -USLIMCLERICSDONOTHAVETHESAMESTATUSASWITHIN#ATHOLICISMOR EVENSOMEINSTITUTIONALIZEDCHURCHESINTHE0ROTESTANTWORLD3TILL BELONGINGTO!L!ZHAR5NIVERSITYIN#AIROORTHEHIGHERINSTITUTIONS OFLEARNINGIN3AUDI!RABIAORELSEWHEREGIVESASTATUSAKINTOTHAT OFORGANIZEDCHURCHES4HENONCLERICALRADICALINTELLECTUALSAPOSTRO PHIZETHENEWSOCIALGROUPSTHATHAVEARISENOUTOFTHEDISBANDINGOF TRADITIONALBONDSNAMELYTHEPROFESSIONALSWITHHIGHEREDUCATIONAL BACKGROUNDSANDTHEDOWNTRODDEN)NTERMSOFGENDERMANYYOUNG WOMENCAUGHTBETWEENTHETRADITIONALRESTRICTIONSWITHOUTTHETRADI TIONALPROTECTIONPARTICULARLYINLARGEURBANZONESJOINTHEM4HESE NEWGROUPSABANDONEDBYANERRATICANDNONPLURALISTMODERNIZATION
AREMUCHMOREHURTTHANHEALEDBYCHANGE)SLAMICRADICALISMINITS PROMISEOFRESTORINGTHE'OD CREATEDORDERAPPEALSTOTHEM4HElGHT AGAINSTTHEGODLESSSELlSHANDHERETICALELITESANDSECULARIZEDMINORI TIESMOTIVATETHESEPEOPLEINTHESAMEWAYASTHOSEWHOHAVEGONE THROUGHMODERNEDUCATIONANDWILDURBANIZATIONBUTSEETHEMSELVES ASVICTIMSOFTHESESOULLESSCHANGES
)DEOLOGICALLY)SLAMICINTELLECTUALSCANBEDIVIDEDINTOFOURMAIN GROUPSTHEIRIDEASGRAVITATINGAROUNDAFEWMAJORTHEMESSECULARIZA TIONANDTHEQUESTIONOFITSLEGITIMACYINDIVIDUALIZATIONANDITSLIMITS DEMOCRACYAND ITS STATUSWOMENSEMANCIPATIONAND ITSMEANING APOSTASYANDITSSTATUSNEW-USLIMDIASPORASANDTHELAWSGOVERN INGTHEM*IHADANDITSNECESSITYDEVIATIONSLIKENONMARITALSEXUAL RELATIONSHOMOSEXUALITYCONSUMPTIONOFALCOHOLANDDRUGSANDTHE LIMITSOFTOLERATINGTHEMETC
4HE lRST GROUP THE2EFORMISTS STRIVE TO OPEN UP )SLAM TO MODERN TRENDSMAINLY SECULARDEMOCRATIC AND INDIVIDUALIST AND PROMOTETOLERANCEOFDIFFERENCESOFOPINIONANDRELIGIONBYREADING THE+ORANANDTHE0ROPHETIC4RADITIONACCORDINGTONEWRULES4HEY ATTEMPTTOSECURE)SLAMFORTHESPIRITUALLIFEOFBELIEVERSANDLEAVETHE PUBLICSPHERETOHUMANLAWSWHOSELEGITIMACYISGRANTEDBYTHEIR VERSIONOF)SLAM4HEYlGHTAGAINSTTHEAMBIVALENCESOF2EFORMISM THATBALLASTEDTHEMAJORTRENDSOFREFORMIN)SLAMSINCETHEENDOF THENINETEENTHCENTURY3TILLMANYAMBIGUITIESARESTILLPREVALENTAND THEYDONTDAREDIRECTLYQUESTIONMANY TRADITIONAL TENETSOF )SLAM 4HETHREEOTHERGROUPSREFERRINGTOTHEMSELVESASh3ALAlvTHATIS RESPECTFULOFTHE3ALAFTHEFOUNDINGFATHERSOFTHE)SLAMICTRADITION ARETHE&UNDAMENTALISTSTHEHYPER &UNDAMENTALISTSANDTHE*IHADISTS 4HEYAGREEINTHEIRDElNITIONOF)SLAMBUTDIFFERINTHEIRSTRATEGIES ANDTHEDEGREEOFINTOLERANCETOWARDTHEhDEVIANTv-USLIMSANDTHE NON -USLIMSASWELLASTOWARDPOLITICALPLURALISM
!LL FOURGROUPSREFERTOTHE)SLAMICPASTTOCLAIMTHEIR LEGITI MACY4HEWARAMONGTHEMINPARTICULARAMONGTHE*IHADISTSAND THEHYPER &UNDAMENTALISTSONTHEONESIDETHE2EFORMISTSANDTHE &UNDAMENTALISTSONTHEOTHERISRAGINGANDTHEYENERGETICALLYREJECT EACHOTHERINTHENAMEOFTHEIRUNDERSTANDINGOFRELIGION2EFORMISTS AND&UNDAMENTALISTS VERSUS THE *IHADISTS ANDHYPER &UNDAMENTAL ISTS OR IN THEIR STRATEGIES *IHADISTS VERSUS &UNDAMENTALISTS 4HE FACTTHATSIZEABLEMINORITIESINTHE-USLIMWORLDHAVESECULARDAILY LIVESCOMPLICATESTHEPICTURE4HELATTERHAVENOLEGITIMACYBUTTHEY DISTURB THE GLOBAL PICTURE BY INTRODUCING hDISORDERv lTNA FROM WITHIN-ANYORTHODOX-USLIMS SEE THEM AS THE4ROJANHORSE OF THE7ESTANDDEVOIDOFANYAUTONOMY4HISISOFCOURSEAMYTHICAL VIEWSINCETHESEhSECULARv-USLIMSSOMETIMESCOMPRISINGAFOURTHOR
EVENATHIRDOFTHEPOPULATIONOFLARGECITIESARETHEINTERNALPRODUCTS OFSOCIALCHANGEINTHE-USLIMWORLDRATHERTHANTHERESULTOFANY DIABOLICMANIPULATIONBYTHE7ESTFORTHESAKEOFDESTROYING)SLAM 4HESECULARIZATIONOFSIZABLEMINORITIESINTHE-USLIMWORLDDESTROYS THEHOMOGENEITYOFTHE-USLIMWORLDVIEWFROMWITHINANDMAKESIT DIFlCULTFORSTAUNCH-USLIMSTOIMPOSEANEXCLUSIVELY)SLAMICPOLITICAL ORDERWITHOUTRECOURSETOVIOLENCE&UNDAMENTALISTSBELIEVETHATTHEY CANRESTOREAN)SLAMICORDERBYWINNINGBACKSECULAR-USLIMSTHROUGH ALONG TERMPOLICYOFPERSUASION*IHADISTSARECONVINCEDTHATSECULAR -USLIMS ARENOTHINGBUT THE7ESTERNlFTH COLUMNAND THATONLY INTIMIDATIONANDVIOLENCECANFORCETHEMTOACCEPTTHERULEOF)SLAM NOTPERSUASION7ITHIN-USLIMSOCIETIESRULEDBY)SLAMICRADICALSTHE 4ALIBANIN!FGHANISTANOR3HIITETHEOCRACYIN)RAN SECULARGROUPS BECOMECULTURALLYSPEAKINGANOPPRESSEDMINORITY4HEYCANTHRIVE ECONOMICALLYBUTCULTURALLYTHEYAREDENIEDPUBLICRECOGNITIONAND AREFORCEDTOLEADTHEIRWAYOFLIFEONLYPRIVATELYCONSTANTLYFEARING REPRESSIONINTHENAMEOFRELIGION
)NRESPECTTOSOCIALANDPOLITICALISSUESSOME*IHADISTSARERADICAL WHENITCOMESTOlGHTINGINTHEPOLITICALlELDBUTTHEYAREMOREOR LESSTOLERANTREGARDINGTHETRESPASSINGOF)SLAMICRULESONALCOHOLOR ILLEGALSEXUALINTERCOURSETHISISTHECASEOF-AQDISIWHOISPOLITICALLY RADICALBUTLESSSTRINGENTVIS Í VISTHEPERSONALTRANSGRESSIONSOF)SLAMIC PROHIBITIONS 4HEMALAISEOFTHE-USLIMWORLDISAREACTIONTOTHEFACT THATREALITYHASIRRETRIEVABLECHANGEDINTHELASTCENTURYWITHTHEADVENT OFNUMEROUSNEWSOCIALGROUPSWITHNEWSUBCULTURESANDMORESBUT THEMAJORITYISATPAINSTOADMITEVENLESSTOFOLLOWTHESETRAUMATIZING CULTURALANDSOCIALCHANGES)NTHEPASTTHE)SLAMICCIVILIZATIONHAD PRESERVEDITSRELIGIOUSBELIEFSYSTEMINSPITEOFTHETORMENTSOFWORLD HISTORY4ODAYNUMEROUS*IHADISTSBELIEVETHAT!POCALYPSESHOULDBE THEFATEOF-USLIMSBEFORETHEYIMPOSEITONTHERESTOFTHEWORLD 4HEOVERWHELMINGMAJORITYOF-USLIMSSHAREADEEP SEATEDMALAISE INTHEIRDAILYLIVESPARTICULARLYWHENTHESECULARALTERNATIVETO)SLAMIC 2ADICALISMAND&UNDAMENTALISMSEEMSUNCONVINCINGTO-USLIMSWHO HAVERECENTLYEXPERIENCEDDICTATORIALSECULARREGIMESTHATGOVERNEDIN THENAMEOFNATIONALISMSOCIALISMORBOTH
4HE)SLAMIC2EVOLUTIONARY6ANGUARD
,EFTISTCURRENTSINTHESREJUVENATEDTHEIDEOLOGYOFTHEVANGUARD WHICHHASTHEDUTYTOSETTHEREVOLUTIONINMOTIONANDTOENCOURAGE THEEXPLOITEDANDALIENATEDPEOPLETOJOINTHEM)N)SLAMTHEVANGUARD THEORYPREDATESTOAVERYLARGEEXTENTTHATOF7ESTERNREVOLUTIONARIESOF
THENINETEENTHANDTWENTIETHCENTURIES3OME3AYINGSOFTHE0ROPHET POINTTOTHEFACTTHATSMALLMINORITIESOF-USLIMSWILLCARRYONTHE lGHTAGAINSTOPPRESSIONANDINJUSTICEINSPITEOFTHEAPATHYOFMAIN STREAM-USLIMS*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSAREQUICKTOUSETHESE3AYINGS OFTHE0ROPHETTOVINDICATETHEIRPOSITIONASAN)SLAMICREVOLUTIONARY MINORITYTHATRAISESTHESTANDARDOFREVOLTAGAINSTTHEIDOLSANDTHEIR WORSHIPPERSINTHENAMEOF!LLAH
4ARTUSIREFERSTOTHEMINRELATIONTOTHECONTINUATIONOF*IHAD UPTOTHEEND TIME
4HE RELIGIOUS TEXTSPOINTEXPLICITLYANDCLEARLYANDWITHOUTANY DOUBTTOTHEFACTTHAT*IHADCONTINUESALLTHETIMEUNTILTHE$AY OF*UDGMENTBETHE#ALIPHORTHE)MAMATTHEHEADOF-USLIMS ORNOT 4HE0ROPHETSAIDh4HEYDONTLEAVETHISRELIGIONINASTANDSTILL AGROUPISABAH OF-USLIMSWILLlGHTFORITUPTOTHE,AST*UDG MENTv-ENTIONEDBYTHETRUSTWORTHYCOMPILEROFTHE3AYINGSOF THE0ROPHET-USLIM 4HE0ROPHETSAIDh!GROUPTAIFAH OFMY#OMMUNITYKEEPS ONlGHTING FOR THE4RUTH APPEARING IN THE$AY OF *UDGMENTv -USLIM 3ALMABIN.UFAYLAL+INDISAID)WASSITTINGNEXTTOTHE0ROPHET ANDAMANSAID@9OUTHE0ROPHETOF!LLAHMANYPEOPLEDISMOUNT THEHORSESˆTHATISTHEYLEAVETHEMLAYDOWNWEAPONSANDSAY NOMORE*IHADTHEWARHASENDED4HE0ROPHETTURNEDHISFACE TOWARDHIMANDSAID@4HEYLIE.OWNOWTHElGHTISGOINGON ANDASMALLGROUPWITHINMYCOMMUNITYKEEPSONlGHTINGFORTHE 4RUTHAND!LLAHFRIGHTENSTHEOTHERCOMMUNITIESINTHEIRHEART ANDTHEYLIVEOUTOFTHATUNTILTHE,AST(OURv 4HE0ROPHETSAIDh!GROUPTAIFAH OFMY5MMAWILLlGHTFOR THE4RUTHLOOMINGTOTHOSEWHOAREOPPOSEDTOTHEMUNTILTHE LASTONEOFTHEMISKILLEDBYTHE$AJJAL;)SLAMIC!NTI #HRIST=v 4HE0ROPHETSAIDh!GROUPTAIFAH WILLCONTINUEv4HISAS SERTSTHEPERPETUATIONOFTHISGROUPTHATlGHTSINTHEWAYOF!LLAH THROUGHALLTHETIMESANDPLACESUNTILTHE$AYOF*UDGMENTAND WHOSE*IHADWILLNOTSTOPINANACCIDENTALWAYBYTHEABSENCEOF THE#ALIPHASINOURTIME
+HARIJITESAFTERTHEDEATHOFTHE0ROPHETANDTHENNUMEROUSSECTSAND MYSTICALGROUPSWITHIN)SLAMDURINGITSHISTORYUPTOMODERNTIMES HAVEEXPLOITEDTHISNOTIONOFAMINORITYELITEOFAUTHENTIC-USLIMSTO PROMOTE*IHADBEITTHEhSMALLER*IHADvJIHADASQAR WHICHISVIOLENT ORTHEhGREATER*IHADvJIHADAKBAR WHICHISSPIRITUAL
!CCORDINGTOTHE*IHADISTS THEIROWNVANGUARDREVOLUTIONARY GROUPISTHISTAIFAHTHISISABAHTHISMINORITY5MMAAMONGTHELARGER 5MMATHATWILLNEVEREND*IHAD4HE)SLAMICWORLDDOESNOTNEEDA NEWTHEORYOFREVOLUTIONARYVANGUARDTHETHEORYALREADYEXISTSAND HASONLYTOBEMODERNIZED4HEMODERNIZATIONCONSISTSINIDENTIFYING THECULPRITSTHEIDOLWORSHIPPERSINTHE7ESTANDTHE-USLIMRULERS DEVIATINGFROM)SLAM 4HECOREOFTHE)SLAMICTHEORYOF*IHADCAN BEEASILYMODERNIZEDANDPUTATTHESERVICEOFAREVOLUTIONARYCAUSE 4HENEW*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSHAVEBEGUNMOSTLYINTHESECONDHALF OFTHETWENTIETHCENTURYTOPERFORMTHATDUTY
4HE)CONSTHE0OPULARIZERS ANDTHE,OCAL#HARISMATIC)MAMS
.OWADAYSTHEREARETHREETYPESOF*IHADISTINTELLECTUALS 4HEICONSAREWELLVERSEDIN)SLAMICJURISPRUDENCElQH AND
REASONINWAYSTHATBEARWITNESSTOTHEIRDEEPKNOWLEDGEOFTHE)S LAMIC3UNNARELIGIOUSNORMSBEQUEATHEDBYTHETRADITION 4HEYARE PRESTIGIOUSAMONGTHEIRDISCIPLES4HEYAREHOWEVERMOSTLYh!RABSv THATISTHEIRCULTUREISOVERWHELMINGLY!RABIC4HEREAREAFEWNON !RABSAMONGTHEMLIKE3HEIKH!BDULLAHEL &AISAL*AMAICANBYBIRTH BUTLIVINGIN3TRATFORD%AST,ONDON)NTHE3HIITEWORLDPEOPLELIKE !YATOLLAH-ESBAH9AZDIARECLOSESTTOTHE3UNNI*IHADISTS4HEICONS ALSOINCLUDEPEOPLELIKE-AQDISI!BU1ATADA!BU(AMZAAL-ISRI THESO CALLED#APTAIN#OOK3HEIKH/MAR!BDEL2AHMANTHEBLIND %GYPTIAN IMPRISONED IN THE5NITED3TATES !BU-USAB AL3URI AND4ARTUSI AMONGOTHERS4HEIRWRITINGS AREQUOTED TRANSLATED ORSIMPLYSPREADBYTHEIRDISCIPLESORTHEMSELVESIN%UROPEANDTHE 7ESTERNWORLDINGENERAL4HEIRMAJORCENTERINTHE7ESTHASBEEN ,ONDONTHESO CALLED,ONDONISTAN WHERETHEYSPREADTHEIRVIEWS ANDTHOSEOFTHEIRCOLLEAGUESUPTOWITHOUTCONSTRAINT
4HEPOPULARIZERS FACILITATE THEUNDERSTANDINGOF THE ICONS COMPLEXRELIGIOUSTHOUGHT4HEIRROLEISESSENTIALIN%UROPEBECAUSE THEICONSAREUSUALLYDIFlCULTTOUNDERSTANDBYTHENEWGENERATIONSOF %UROPEAN-USLIMSWHODONOTMASTER!RABICANDNEEDTHEhTRANSLA TORSvOFCOMPLEXIDEASINTOSIMPLIlEDONES3OMEOFTHEICONSLIKE !BU1ATADAORAL3URIHAVEALSOACCOMPLISHEDTHISTASK
,OCALCHARISMATICIMAMSORINTELLECTUALSCONSTITUTETHETHIRD GROUP4HElRSTTWOGROUPSAREUSUALLYIDENTIlEDBYTHEINTELLIGENCE SERVICESIN%UROPEANDMOSTOFTHEMAREINJAILORHAVEBEENEXPELLED FROM%UROPE,OCALPEOPLEWHOTEACH*IHADAREMOREDIFlCULTTODETECT 4HEYUSUALLYOPERATEINSMALLGROUPSORCELLSANDNOTONLYIN-USLIM
DISTRICTSBUTANYWHERETHEREAREDISENFRANCHISED-USLIMYOUTHASIN THESO CALLEDBANLIEUES IN&RANCEPOORDISTRICTS IN%NGLANDOROLD WORKING CLASSDISTRICTSIN'ERMANY4HEYALSOOPERATEIN%UROPEAN PRISONSANDTHEIRMESSAGESCANBETRANSMITTEDTOTHEOTHERINMATES THROUGHPRIVATECHANNELSWHICHAREDIFlCULTTOLOCATE4HEYCANTHRIVE ASWELLIN7ESTERNINSTITUTIONSANDORGANIZATIONSLIKEUNIVERSITIESOR CHARITIES
-UCHOFTHESOCIALIZATIONOF*IHADISTSIN%UROPEISBASEDUPON THESETHREEKINDSOFINTELLECTUALSWHOhFACILITATEvTHEUNDERSTANDINGOF *IHADTOA-USLIMYOUTHDEVOIDOFTHECREDENTIALSOF!RAB-USLIMS DIRECTACCESS TO THE+ORANIC TEXT THE!RABIC INTERPRETATIONOF THE TEXTETC "ECAUSE-USLIMYOUTHIN%UROPEAREUPROOTED*IHADIST )SLAMCANMOREEASILYINDOCTRINATETHEMEXPLOITINGTHEIRFRUSTRATION ANDGRUDGESAGAINSTSOCIETY4HEYlNDANOUTLETIN*IHADWHICHTHEY INSTINCTIVELYIDENTIFYASTHEMAINTENETIN)SLAM+NOWINGLITTLEABOUT )SLAMPREDISPOSESTHEMTOESPOUSE*IHADISMASAMEANSTOlGHTAGAINST THOSEWHOHAVENOTBEENHOSPITABLETOTHEMACCORDINGTOTHEIRSELF IDENTIlCATIONASVICTIMS
4HECASEOF-OHAMMED"OUYERI THEMURDEREROF4HEOVAN 'OGHILLUSTRATESTHEOVERLAPSOFTHETHREETYPESOFINTELLECTUALS"OUYERI CONSIDEREDHIMSELFANINTELLECTUALANDINTHESO CALLED(OFSTADGROUP HEWASACENTRALlGUREhLOCALINTELLECTUALvINOURTERMINOLOGY (E TRANSLATEDSOMEOFTHEWORKSOF!BU(AMZAAL-ISRITHEMILITANT IMAMOF&INSBURY0ARK-OSQUEIN,ONDONWHICHWEREDISCUSSEDIN THEMEETINGSOFTHEGROUPMAINLYIN"OUYERISHOME)NTHISCASE !BU+HALED2EDOUANAL)SSAAFORMER3YRIANARMYOFlCERWHOINTRO DUCEDTHETHOUGHTSOFTHEFOREFATHERSOF*IHADISM3EYED1UTBAND !BULALA-AWDUDI TOTHEGROUPPLAYEDTHEROLEOFTHEPOPULARIZER !L-ISRIWHOIN"OUYERISCASEWASTHEMAJORINSPIRERPLAYEDTHE ROLEOFTHEICON!L-ISRISWORKHADBECOMEACCESSIBLETO"OUYERI THROUGH%NGLISHVERSIONSSOMEOFWHICHWERETRANSLATEDBY"OUYERI HIMSELFINTO$UTCH)NTHISPARTICULARCASETHETRIANGULARINTERACTIONS OF*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSISCLEAR
*IHADIST)SLAMBECOMESATTRACTIVETO-USLIMYOUTHIN%UROPE ASMUCHTHROUGHRADICALINTELLECTUALSWHOPROFESSITASTHROUGHTHE hPUSHFACTORvBYTHESOCIETYTHATREJECTSTHEMORDOESNOTRECOGNIZE THEMASGENUINELY%UROPEAN4HEYAREINAhNEITHERNORvPREDICAMENT %UROPEANSDONOTRECOGNIZETHEMASBEINGPARTOFTHEIRSOCIETYAND INTHEIRPARENTSCOUNTRYOFORIGINTHEYARECONSIDEREDhDIRTY&RENCH MENvhDIRTY%NGLISHMENvETC
3OMEREFORMISTINTELLECTUALSOR5LAMAINTHE7ESTENDEAVORTO ADAPT)SLAMTO7ESTERNDEMOCRACYBYREFERRINGTO)SLAMASAhMINOR
ITYRELIGIONvWITH-USLIMSHAVINGTOADAPTTOTHENEWSITUATIONBY SUBMITTINGTOTHEPREVAILINGSECULARLAWSASITUATIONPREVIOUSLYUN HEARDOF-USLIMSWEREEITHERINAMAJORITYPOSITIONORDOMINANTASA MINORITYTHROUGHCONQUEST 4HIShlQHOFTHEMINORITYvACCEPTSTHE LAWSOFANON -USLIMGOVERNMENT4HESUPREMACYOFNON -USLIM GOVERNMENTALLAWSOVER)SLAMICLAWSISSOMETHING-USLIMJURISTSHAVE BEENLOATHTOADMITINTHENAMEOFATRADITIONACCORDINGTOONEOF THEFOREFATHERSOF*IHADISM)BN4AYMIYAHTHATDICTATESTHAT)SLAMHAS TOGAINTHEUPPERHAND4HISISTACITLYAPPROVEDOFBYMANYHYPER &UNDAMENTALISTSANDTRADITIONALISTSh)BN4AYMIYAHSAYSANYGROUP OFPEOPLECONTINUOUSLYREFUSINGTOFOLLOWTHELAWOF!LLAHINAPUBLIC WAYNEED*IHADSOTHATTHEIRRELIGIONTOTALLYBECOMES!LLAHSRELIGIONv *IHADISTSDENOUNCETHEREFORMISTSATTITUDEBYREFERRINGTOTHE)SLAMIC TRADITIONTHATPROHIBITSANYCOMPROMISEONTHISISSUE
7HATISNEWAMONG*IHADISTSISTHEARRIVALINHIGHNUMBERSOFA NEWTYPEOFINTELLECTUALWHOISMORETHANTHEhINTELLECTUELENGAG£vA TERMCOINEDBYTHE&RENCHOR'RAMSCIShORGANICINTELLECTUALvCOM BININGMANYPECULIARFEATURESOF7ESTERNINTELLECTUALSANDTRADITIONAL )SLAMICTHEOLOGIANSANDTHINKERS4HEWHOLEPROCESSBEGANOFCOURSE MUCHEARLIERINTHESECONDHALFOFTHETWENTIETHCENTURYWITHTHE ADVENTOFTHENEWHYPER &UNDAMENTALISTSLIKEAL"ANNA-AWDUDI AND1UTBINTHE3UNNIWORLD3HARIATIAND+HOMEINIINTHE3HIITE 4HENOVELTYISTHEHIGHNUMBEROFTHENEW GENERATIONINTELLECTUALS ANDTHEIRCAPACITYTOUSENEWCOMMUNICATIONTECHNOLOGIESMAINLY THE)NTERNETBUTALSOVIDEOTAPESAND46 4HEYCOMBINETHEOLOGICAL ANDMILITARYSKILLSTHEYADDRESS!RABSINANEWWAYINALANGUAGE MUCHMOREACCESSIBLETOTHEMATLEASTINTHEIRJOURNALISTICWRITINGS ANDTHEYAREMOREPOLEMICALANDABLETOUSEMODERNWORDSANDSOCIAL SCIENCETERMINOLOGYINSTEADOFTHECOMPLICATEDIDIOMOFTHETRADI TIONAL5LAMAAND&UQAHATHE)SLAMICJURISTS 0EOPLELIKE*AHIMAN AL/TEIBI3HUKRI-USTAFAANDLATERON(AMIDAL!LI9USUFAL 5YARIAND!BU9AHYAAL,IBIAREORWERE MUCHYOUNGERTHAN THEOLDSCHOLARSBEINGINTHEIRTHIRTIESFORTIESANDlFTIESANDHAVING AMUCHDEEPERUNDERSTANDINGOF-USLIMYOUTHINTHE!RABWORLD
-OSTOFTHESEINTELLECTUAL WARRIORSARENOTKNOWNINTHE7EST BUTTHEIRTHEMESAREPOPULARIZEDANDTHEYARESOMEHOWWORSHIPPED ASHEROESWARRIORSOF)SLAMBYCLOSECIRCLESOF)SLAMIC5LAMAIN%U ROPEWHOSPREADTHEMEITHERDIRECTLYTOTHOSE LIVING IN,ONDON OR THROUGH LOCAL IMAMS )N THE%UROPEANPRISONS JAILED *IHADISTS ARE HIGHLY REGARDEDBYMANY-USLIM INMATES4HE ADMIRATION IS THEGREATERASMOSTOFTHE-USLIMSIN%UROPEARECONSIDEREDTOBE hNOBODYvECONOMICALLYANDCULTURALLYATBESTSECOND CLASSCITIZENS
WHEREASTHEIMPRISONED*IHADISTSARESEENASWORLDlGURES"EHAVING HEROICALLYINSPIRINGFEARIN%UROPEANSANDBECOMINGFAMOUSTHROUGH THEMEDIAARECONSIDEREDFEATSTHEYCANNOTTHEMSELVESACHIEVE4HE NEW*IHADISTWARRIORSFOLLOWINGINTELLECTUALWARRIORSBECOMEMODELS FORSOME%UROPEAN-USLIMSWHOLOOKFORREASONSTOlGHTAGAINSTSOCI ETIESTHEYHATEFORMAKINGTHEMUNWELCOME*IHADBECOMESAPATHTO ESCAPEVICTIMIZATION)TISAVINDICATIONAND*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSARE HEROICPARAGONSTHEMORESOASMANYHAVEBEENKILLEDLIKE*AHIMAN OR5YAYRI INSTREETlGHTSINTHE-USLIMWORLD
4HE0OSTMODERN*IHADIST0OPULARIZER 4HE#ASEOF,EWIS!TIYAT /LLAH
,EWIS!TIYAT /LLAHISA*IHADISTINTELLECTUALWHOHASCHOSENHISPEN NAMEFOROBSCUREREASONSHEDOESNOTEXPLAININHISBOOK0ERHAPS HEINTENDEDTOPROVETHATTHE*IHADISTMOVEMENTISNOTCONlNEDTO A SINGLENATIONBUTENCOMPASSES THEENTIREWORLD INCLUSIVEOF THE 7EST0ERHAPSHEAIMEDTOPROVETHATHEISTHE*IHADISTCOUNTERPART TO"ERNARD,EWISTHEHISTORIANOFTHE)SLAMICWORLDWHOSESTANCEON )SLAMHASBEENCONTROVERSIALINTHELASTDECADE(ISCASEISNOTEWORTHY BECAUSEHIS THOUGHT COMBINESMANY FEATURESOF THE *IHADIST ICONS WHOAREKNOWNFORTHEIR)SLAMICTHEOLOGYANDSOMETIMESSOCIALSCI ENCEKNOWLEDGEBUTHASPOSTMODERNASPECTSLACKINGINMOSTOFTHE OTHER*IHADISTS(ETHUSPOPULARIZESINACREATIVEWAYTHEIRIDEOLOGY BYMODERNIZINGTHEM(EINTEGRATESMANYDIMENSIONSOF7ESTERN MODERNITYLIKETOLERANCEOFOPPOSINGVIEWSTHECAPACITYTOARGUEIN ASTYLETHATISFARFROMTHE*IHADISTDIKTATSTYLEANDANABILITYTOARGUE FROMAGLOBALIZEDPERSPECTIVETHATISLACKINGAMONGTHETRADITIONALIST ICONSLIKE-AQDISIANDEVENTHEOTHERMAJOR*IHADISTTHINKERS)HAVE MENTIONEDINPREVIOUSCHAPTERS
!TIYAT /LLAHPUBLISHEDADIALOGUEBETWEENHIMSELFANDh!BU 9ASIRvAlCTIONALMEMBEROFA&UNDAMENTALIST)SLAMICSECTCLOSETO -USLIM"ROTHERHOODWHOBELIEVESTHAT!L1AEDAS3EPTEMBERAT TACKSHAVEDONEALOTOFHARMTOTHE-USLIMSANDTHAT*IHADSHOULD NOTBEPROMPTEDAGAINSTTHE7EST4HEDIALOGUEFORMISRATHERUNUSUAL AMONG*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSALTHOUGH-AQDISIWROTEAPAMPHLETIN WHICHHEADDRESSEDPRISONERSANDEXPLAINEDTHELEGITIMACYOFHISAC TIONS!TIYAT /LLAHISMUCHMOREMODERNINOUTLOOKSINCEHECREATES IMAGINARYCONDITIONSREALISTICALLYHEENTERSAGENTLEMANLIKEDISCUSSION RAREAMONGTHE*IHADISTS WITHA-USLIM&UNDAMENTALISTWITHOUT ANYTENDENCYTOWARDOSTRACISMORDECLARINGHIMANINlDELTAKlR (E
SHOWSSOMETOLERANCEWITHOUTATRACEOFANIMOSITYORAGGRESSIVENESS !SUMMARYOFTHISDIALOGUEISINSTRUCTIVEABOUTTHE*IHADISTSSTATEOF MINDINCOMPARISONTOTHATOFTHE&UNDAMENTALISTS
)NTHEDIALOGUETHECHARACTEROF9ASIRREPRESENTINGTHE&UNDA MENTALISTSCLAIMSTHAT*IHADCANNOTBEREDUCEDTOITSlGHTINGDIMEN SION(EDISTINGUISHESBETWEENTHEhlGHTING*IHADvJIHADALQITALI ANDTHECULTURAL*IHADJIHADALHIZARIORCIVILIZATIONAL*IHAD 4HE LATTERSHOULDBEPROMOTEDINASITUATIONWHERETHE5MMASWEAKNESS MAKESITIMPOSSIBLETOWINAMILITARYWAR!MERICASPOWERISNOTONLY MILITARYBUTMATERIALECONOMICSCIENTIlCANDINDUSTRIAL-USLIMS CANNOTMATCHIT4HECULTURAL*IHADENABLESTHE5MMATOUNIFYITS EFFORTSSPREADAWARENESSANDSATISFYITSNEEDSINDIFFERENTlELDSOF KNOWLEDGE-USLIMSLIVEATTHEMARGINSOFCIVILIZATIONANDSHOULD NOTJUMPTHEGUNLEAPINGSUDDENLYTO*IHAD&ROMTHISVIEWPOINT "IN,ADENSGOALCOULDNOTBEIMPLEMENTEDANDWASNOTREASONABLE "IN,ADENMADEAPERSONALDECISIONBASEDONAWHIMWHEREASGLOBAL DECISIONSCONCERNINGTHEUMMASHOULDBETAKENBYCOMPETENTNON PARTISAN SPECIALISTS AMONG THE THINKERS AND INTELLECTUALS-USLIMS SHOULDPUTTHEIRENERGYINTOTHROWINGOUTTHEENEMYOUTOF)SLAMIC COUNTRIESRATHERTHANlGHTING!MERICA
!TIYAT /LLAHSANSWERISTHAT)SLAMRULESTHROUGHhlGHTING*IHADv ANDTHATh"IN,ADENMAKESHISTORYCONQUERSTHEHEARTSOFTHEPEOPLE ANDBECOMESAPOLEINTHElGHTAGAINSTTHE7ESTv
9ASIR TREATS"IN,ADEN ANDHIS GROUP AS A hBANDOF INTREPID PEOPLEvMUTIHAWEREEN WHOACTRECKLESSLY!TIYAT /LLAHCLAIMSTHAT THISISPRECISELYTHEVIEWPOINTOFTHE7ESTERNMEDIA!BU9ASIRRETURNS TOTHEQUESTIONOF3EPTEMBERANDEXPRESSESTHEVIEWTHATTHEBOMB INGSWERENOTTHEDEEDSOF!L1AEDABECAUSEOFTHEIRCOMPLEXITYAND THEFACTTHATTHEYWEREBEYONDTHESCOPEOF"IN,ADEN4HISTYPEOF OPERATIONCANONLYBEEXECUTEDBY#)!-OSSADORTHELIKE4HEREFORE hTHEREARESTRONGREASONSTOBELIEVETHATTHE%VENT;3EPTEMBER=WAS NOTTHEDEEDOF"IN,ADENAND!L1AEDAv!TIYAT /LLAHRESPONDSTHAT -USLIMSAREABLETOCARRYOUTCOMPLEXOPERATIONSANDTHATDENYING THEMTHISCAPACITYMEANSUNDERVALUINGTHEIRCAPACITY$ENOUNCING CONSPIRACYTHEORIESHECHALLENGESTHEIDEATHATh!MERICAISBEHIND ALL THE ;MAJOR=EVENTSAND THAT IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO REALIZEANYTHING AGAINST ITSWISHESv!CCORDINGTO!TIYAT /LLAHTHE3EPTEMBER OPERATIONSNEEDED!LLAHSASSISTANCETOWlQRABBANI BECAUSEOFTHE lNANCIALRESOURCESNEEDEDFORTHEIRACCOMPLISHMENTTHEIRLOGISTICS ANDTHESECRECYTHATSURROUNDEDTHEMDIVULGEDBYNOONE
9ASIRRESPONDSTHAT!LLAHASSISTSOPERATIONSTHATARETOTHEPROlT OFTHE5MMAANDTHEFACTTHATTHEFOURTHPLANEWASDOWNEDWITHOUT
ATTAININGITSGOALSHOWSTHAT!LLAHDIDNOTFACILITATETHEOPERATION)N THESAMEVEINHEEXPRESSESTHEVIEWTHATTHE3EPTEMBEROPERATIONS WEREAGAINST-USLIMINTERESTSANDTHEREFORECOULDONLYBEPERFORMED BYTHE#)!ORA-OSSADTYPEOFORGANIZATION!TIYAT /LLAHANSWERS
4HE3EPTEMBEREVENTSWEREVERYPOSITIVEFORTHE-USLIMS/NE MAJORPOSITIVECONSEQUENCEOFITHASBEENTOTAKETHECOVEROFFTHE FALSEPEACEBETWEENTHE7ESTANDTHE-USLIMS4HISPEACEISNOT GENUINESINCEUNDERITSGUISETHE7ESTSUCCEEDEDINFRAGMENTING THE-USLIMWORLDINTOSMALLSTATESDIVIDINGTHEMINTOREPUBLICS THEY TRACED AND COUNTRIES OF DUNG DATES OIL AND OTHERS4HEY SUBMITTEDTHEMANDCREATEDINTHEMMILITARYBASESORSENTARMIES TOWARRANT THEIR OWNHEGEMONY OVER THEM PERPETUATING THUS THEIRDOMINATION!FTERTHATTHEYDICTATEDAFALSEPEACETOTHEM LEGALIZING THUS-USLIMS SUBMISSION AND THEIR DOMINATIONOVER THEM"IN,ADENAND!L1AEDAREJECTTHISPEACEANDADDRESSAN APPEALTOTHE-USLIMSANDCLAIMTHERIGHTFORTHEMTOTAKEHOLD OFTHEIROWNDESTINY4HATPEACEISNOTHINGBUTTHEFALSIlCATIONOF GENUINE)SLAMTADHYIFISLAMALHAQIQI WHICHDEMANDSPROSELYTIZ INGITWITHOUTTHEINTERVENTIONOFTHERULERSTHEEMIRSORTHEKINGS 7HAT!L1AEDADIDWASTOBEGINTHE*IHADINORDERTHATALLRELIGION BECOMES!LLAHSRELIGION
&OR!TIYAT /LLAH!BU9ASIRISANATIONALISTSINCEHEMAKESTHE WATANHOMECOUNTRY THECENTEROFGRAVITYOFTHE-USLIMSINTERESTS INORDERTORENOUNCE*IHAD!CCORDINGTO!TIYAT /LLAHh"IN,ADEN LOVESHISHOMECOUNTRYMORETHANYOUDOBUTTHISHOMEISNOTTHE ONEMILITARILYDEFENDEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESTOSUPPORTTHERULERSOF OILANDTHEIRGROUPS4HISISNOTAREALHOMEBUTAVASTPRISON4HE HOMEWEDEFENDISTHEONEINWHICHTHEVOICEOFJUSTICEANDTRUTH HAQ ISSUNGALLOVER4HElRSTSOILTODEFENDISTHECOUNTRYOFTHETWO SACREDMOSQUES;3AUDI!RABIA=THATOURANCESTORSDEFENDEDTHROUGH THEIRBLOODANDISNOWOCCUPIEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESv
9ASIRSUNDERSTANDINGOFTHE5NITED3TATESISNOTFUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENTFROMTHATOF!TIYAT /LLAH(ESIMPLYBELIEVESTHATh-USLIMS AREWEAKANDDOWNTRODDENMUSTADHAFUN ONALLTHEEARTHANDITIS NOTWISETOPUSHTHEMTOWARDlGHTING*IHADBEFORETHEYIMPROVETHE MEANS TODOSOv&ROMTHISPERSPECTIVE-USLIMSSHOULDADDRESS THEIRURGENTPROBLEMSTHATARERELATEDTOTHEIRGEOGRAPHYRATHERTHAN lGHTINGAGAINST ANENEMY THAT IS FAR AWAY4OWHICH!TIYAT /LLAH REJOINSTHATONESHOULDNOTDISCONNECTLOCALANDWORLDWIDEPROBLEMS !MERICANIMPERIALISMHASTOBEFOUGHTBACKWITHTHEUTMOSTENERGY
h!LLAHTHE#REATORPUTTHEOILINOURSOILANDTHE!MERICANSCAME OCCUPIEDOURLANDSANDSEPARATEDUSFROMTHERESTOFTHEWORLDVIO LENTLYORPEACEFULLY"YBEHAVINGINYOURWAYYOUAREDESECRATING)SLAM THROUGHYOURVERSION;GIVINGPROMINENCETOTHE=REGIONANDCOUNTRY ;OVER)SLAM=9OUTHUSDECEIVEWHENYOUTALKABOUTTHEWORLDWIDE )SLAM)NVITINGPEOPLEFORACIVILSOCIETY;WITHINONESOWNCOUNTRY= ISTODENYTHAT)SLAMISAWORLDRELIGIONANDISNOTRESTRICTEDTOTHE FAKEFRONTIERSBUILTUPBYTHECOLONIZERSv4OWHICH9ASIRREPLIESh) DONTDENYTHAT!MERICASUPPORTSANDHELPS)SRAELANDlGHTSAGAINST -USLIMSANDENCIRCLESTHEMINMANYWAYSANDBASESITSDOMINATION ONTHE)SLAMICRULERSANDEXTENDSITTHROUGHTHESO CALLEDINTERNA TIONALORGANIZATIONS"UTWEBELIEVETHATlGHTING!MERICAISNOTTHE PRIORITYv,EWISS REPLY IS THAT THIS INTERPRETATION IS BASEDON THE PERCEPTIONOFTHESELFASINFERIORISTISQARALDHAT ANDTHATBEHINDTHE VIEWOFTHEPRIORITYLIESTHISSELF DENIAL4HEDIFFERENCEBETWEEN9ASIR AND!TIYAT /LLAHISWHATGOALISPRIORITIZEDANDNOTINTRINSICALLYON THEESSENTIALS
9ASIRDOESNOTLOSEHISSELF CONTROLANDINSISTSONEDUCATING-US LIMSSOTHATTHEYCANhCONFRONTTHEWORLDSIMPIETYALKUFRALALAMI BYlGHTING AGAINST IT OR THROUGHPOLITICALMEANSv/NEPROBLEM RAISEDBY9ASIRISTHATIMPORTANTDECISIONSINVOLVINGTHEFUTUREOFTHE 5MMASHOULDBETAKENTHROUGHCONSULTATIONWITHTHEULAMAˆTHAT ISTHEPEOPLEWITHRELIGIOUSCOMPETENCEAHLALMASHVERA ˆAND"IN ,ADENDIDNOTSOINHISACTSAGAINST!MERICA!TIYAT /LLAHBELIEVES THATTHEDElNITIONOFhPEOPLEWITHRELIGIOUSCOMPETENCEvDOESNOT ENCOMPASSTHOSEWHODISAGREEONTHEPRINCIPLEOFMILITARY*IHAD4HOSE ULAMAWHOADVISETHEPEOPLENOTTOTAKEPARTIN*IHADSHOULDNOTBE CONSULTED9ASIRCOMESBACKTOTHEQUESTIONOF-USLIMSPROBLEMS AFTER3EPTEMBER!TIYAT /LLAHISQUICKTOPOINTTOTHEFACTTHATTHE 4WIN4OWERSDEMOLITIONSHATTEREDTHEPRESTIGEOFTHE5NITED3TATES WORLDWIDE3INCE-USLIMSAREDEVOIDOFMODERNMILITARYMEANSAND NUCLEARBOMBSTHEYHAVETOTAKETHISTYPEOFACTION-USLIMSSHOULD ALSODEALANOTHERBLOWTOTHEPRESTIGEOF!MERICAFORTHESAKEOFTHE 0ALESTINIANSANDOTHER-USLIMS3INCE!MERICAWASPOWERLESSTOPRE VENT3EPTEMBERTHISMEANSANEWMOVETOWARDEQUALITYOFPOWER WITHTHE5NITED3TATES"IN,ADENISTHECHAMPIONOFTHISREVERSALFROM DEEPINEQUALITYTOATLEASTSYMBOLICEQUALITYOFPOWER4HISENTAILSTHE ASCENSIONOF!L1AEDAASANEWCHALLENGERTO53MIGHTh!L1AEDA SETANEXPLICITGOALWITHACLEARREPRESENTATIONOFTHEMEANSTOACHIEVE IT4HENITDECIDEDEARLYTHAT!MERICAWILLBEINDIFlCULTYFACING)SLAM ASAPOWERANDALLTHEILLEGITIMATE!RABAND-USLIMGOVERNMENTSWILL BEPARALYZED IN THE FACEOF THE!MERICANWEAKNESSOR ITSBREAKING
AWAY)TISOBVIOUSTHAT!L1AEDASAIMWASSEPARATING!MERICA;FROM THE-USLIMWORLD=ORITSDESTRUCTIONORATLEASTITSBEINGFRIGHTENED FORCINGITTOGETAWAYFROMTHE)SLAMICWORLDv
9ASIRAGAINRAISESTHEQUESTIONOFTHEABILITYOF!L1AEDATOCARRY OUTTHE3EPTEMBERATTACKSWHENSOMANY-USLIMSTATESHAVEBEEN UNABLETOCARRYOUTANYSIMILARACTION!TIYAT /LLAHSANSWERISPURELY ORGANIZATIONALTHISTIMEh4HISISYOURPROBLEMWITHYOURBUREAUCRACY !L1AEDAWASABLETOSOLVETHEPROBLEMINTWOWAYSlRSTBYREJECTING THEIDEAOFAPYRAMIDALORGANIZATIONANDORGANIZATIONALRELATIONSHIP INASINGLEBODYSECONDITPUTANENDTOTHEIDEATHATBELONGINGTO THEORGANIZATIONMEANSGETTINGSEPARATEDFROMTHESOCIETY!L1AEDA ASSISTSITSMEMBERSTOlNDOUTSOLUTIONSWITHINTHESOCIETYv
9ASIRBELIEVES THATBEFOREGETTING INVOLVEDMILITARILYWITH THE 5NITED3TATES-USLIMS SHOULDBECOME STRONG IN TERMSOF CULTURE ANDCIVILIZATIONTOWHICH!TIYAT /LLAHANSWERSBACKTHATTHISSTRAT EGYISDOOMEDTOFAILURESINCE-USLIMORGANIZATIONSHAVEATTEMPTED ITINCOUNTRIESLIKE3UDAN!LGERIA4URKEYAND%GYPTWITHOUTANY SUCCESS!LLTHESEATTEMPTSBASEDONRENOUNCING*IHADANDlNDING PEACEFULWAYSOFPROMOTING)SLAMHAVEBEENDOOMEDTOFAILURE&OR !TIYAT /LLAH!L1AEDASSUCCESSISPRECISELYDUETOITSREJECTINGTHE PREVAILINGRULESANDINVENTINGNEWPATTERNSOFCONDUCTTHATCONFUSE THE!MERICANSh!L1AEDAPLAYEDANEWROLEOUTSIDETHEREALMOFTHE WELL KNOWNRULESOFTHEGAMEAND!MERICANSANDTHEOTHERSCANNOT IMAGINE IT BECAUSE THEY ARE LIKE YOU PROGRAMMED TO IMITATE THE RULESOFTHECALCULATIONSOFSTRENGTHANDWEAKNESS4HEKINDOFWAR !L1AEDAISWAGINGISCALLEDBYTHE!MERICANSASYMMETRICWARHARB QEYRALMOTEWAZIYAH !MERICAWILLBEBESETBYASTATEOFECONOMIC WEAKNESSANDDOUBTABOUTITSELF%UROPEANDTHESUPPORTERSOF!MERICA WILLRETREATFROMFEAROFBECOMINGTHEFUTURETARGETSOF!L1AEDA4HE GODLESSSYSTEMSINTHE-USLIMCOUNTRIESWILLBEPOSSIBLYTHEWEAKEST BECAUSEOFTHEWEAKNESSOFTHElRSTMASTERv
!TIYAT /LLAHBELIEVES THAT THENEWSTRATEGY SETUPBY!L1A EDAWILLTHROW!MERICAINTOANECONOMICCRISISONTOPOFACRISISOF DOUBTABOUTITSOWNPOWERANDTHISWILLINDUCE%UROPENOTTOFOLLOW !MERICALESTITBECOME!L1AEDASTARGET(ERE!TIYAT /LLAHISPURELY RATIONAL'ODPLAYSNOROLEINHISARGUMENTANDHISAIMISTOESTABLISH NEWROLESBREAKINGTHEDEADLOCKOF-USLIMSINFERIORITYTO!MERICA ANDTHE7ESTINGENERAL9ASIRQUESTIONSTHISREASONING(ESAYSh) DONT INTENDTODEFEND!MERICABUTTHISCOUNTRY ISDEMOCRATIC IT HASSOLIDINSTITUTIONSTHATCANCOPEWITHTHECHALLENGESOFANYKIND BECAUSETHEYACTACCORDINGTOSOCIALRATIONALITYANDTHEYLOOKATTHE PROBLEMSINASCIENTIlCMANNERAND)DONTBELIEVETHEYHAVEDIFlCUL TIESAWAKENINGAFTERANYATTACKv
!TIYAT /LLAHONTHECONTRARYBELIEVESTHAT!MERICASSELF CONl DENCEHASBEENSHATTEREDBY!L1AEDAANDHASNOOTHERRECOURSETHAN TOYIELDTO"IN,ADENSDEMANDSWHICHAREMANIFOLDTOSTOPSUPPORT ING)SRAELENDTHEOCCUPATIONOF)RAQEVACUATE3AUDI!RABIAANDSTOP HELPINGTHEGODLESS-USLIMGOVERNMENTSTAWAQITPLURALOFTAQUT
!FTERTHESTRATEGICDISCUSSION!TIYAT /LLAHEMBARKSONANINTEL LECTUALDEBATEABOUTTHETWOMAJORSOCIALTHEORIESIN!MERICAAFTERTHE COLLAPSEOFTHE3OVIET5NIONh4HETWOMOSTSIGNIlCANTTOPICSTHATTHE 7ESTDEVOTEDITSELFTOITAFTERTHE#OLD7ARARETHETHEORYOFTHE%NDOF (ISTORYBY&RANCIS&UKUYAMAAND3AMUEL(UNTINGTONSTHEORYOFTHE #LASHOF#IVILIZATIONS4HE3EPTEMBEREVENTSBLEWUP&UKUYAMAS THEORYABOUTTHEENDOFHISTORYANDCONlRMED(UNTINGTONSTHEORYS RIGHTNESSANDITSWRONGNESSREGARDINGITSCONCLUSIONSINCEONECAN SAYTHE7ESTERNCIVILIZATIONWONTWINANDTHEREISANEWCIVILIZATION ;)SLAM=ANDITISTHETIMEOFITSREVIVALv
.ORMALLY THEORISTS OF *IHAD EVOKE )SLAMIC THINKERS LIKE )BN 4AYMIYAORTHEIRMODERNREPRESENTATIVESLIKE-AQDISI4ARTUSIAND THEOTHERS!TIYAT /LLAHCHANGESTHEPAROCHIALISMOFTHE)SLAMICRADI CALS(EREFERSTOTHETWOMAJOR!MERICANTHEORISTSOFGLOBALCHANGE NAMELY(UNTINGTONAND&UKUYAMACONlRMINGTHEFORMERSTHEORY OFTHECLASHOFCIVILIZATIONSDECLARINGTHE7ESTSDEFEATANDTHERISE OF)SLAMREJUVENATEDBY"IN,ADENANDTHE!L1AEDACOMBATANTS WHORESTOREDTHE)SLAMICPRINCIPLEOF*IHADRESTORED)SLAMICREASON IMPLICITLYREFERRINGTOTHE&RENCHSOCIALSCIENTIST-OHAMED!RKOUN WHOWROTEABOOKONTHECRITIQUEOF)SLAMICREASON ANDRESHAPED )SLAMICPUBLICOPINIONTHROUGHITSAGENCYEG3EPTEMBER !LL THIS ISDUETOTHERETURNTO*IHADASTHEKEYSTONEOF)SLAMh*IHAD ISTHESOULOFTHEGENIUSTHATPUSHEDAGROUPOFTHEDISCIPLESWHOSE NUMBERWASATMOSTATHOUSANDASAUNIlEDCOMMUNITYTOlGHTTHE APOSTASY4HROUGHITTWOEMPIRESTHE0ERSIANANDTHE2OMANWERE FOUGHTAGAINST SIMULTANEOUSLY4HROUGHIT THECOMBATANTSOF FAITH MUJAHID OVERTHREWTHE3OVIET%MPIREANDNOW"IN,ADENMONITORS THEWARAGAINSTTHE!MERICAN%MPIREANDINLESSTHANTENYEARSTHEY HAVEBEENABLETOREDUCETOASHESITSSPLENDORv
)NHISSUBSEQUENTANALYSISOF!L1AEDASSUCCESSAGAINSTTHEBACK GROUNDOFOTHER)SLAMICORGANIZATIONSFAILURES!TIYAT /LLAHMENTIONS THETRADITIONALSINCERITYANDDEVOTIONTOWARD'ODIKHLAS ASAMAJOR COMPONENTANDTHEREADINESSTODIEASAMARTYRTRADITIONALLYCALLED UPONBY*IHADISTS BUTALSOINANEFFORTTOTHINKSTRATEGICALLYTHETWO NEWCOMPONENTSOF!L1AEDASACTION
4HElRSTISTHEINITIATIVE!L1AEDAHASBEENABLETOTAKETHEINI TIATIVEINTHEHISTORYOFTHE-USLIMSINMODERNTIMESITACTSAND
THEOTHERSREACTTOITSACTIONS!LLTHE)SLAMICMOVEMENTSASWELL ASTHE!RABGOVERNMENTSACTBYMERELYREACTINGEXCEPT!L1AEDA WHOACTSTHEREACTIONBELONGINGTOTHEOTHERS2EADINGTHEHIS TORYOFTHEWARBETWEEN!L1AEDAAND!MERICAONECANCLEARLY DISTINGUISHTHISFEATUREITIS!L1AEDATHATDElNESTHETIMINGAND THEPLACEOFACTIONAND!MERICAREACTSTOIT4HESECONDELEMENTIS SURPRISETHEBEHAVIOROF!L1AEDAOUTSIDETHEREALMOF!MERICAS THOUGHT!MERICADOESNOTTHINKTHATITSSHIPSWILLBEHITONTHE SEAFORINSTANCE!NDTHEN3EPTEMBERWASTHEAPOGEEOFTHOSE OPERATIONSANDTHE!MERICANMINDCOULDNOTGRASPHOWTHEYCOULD SUCCEEDANDINSPITEOFITTHEYSUCCEEDEDWITH!LLAHSASSISTANCE !L1AEDASCONDUCTWASBEYONDTHESCOPEOF!MERICASTHINKING CAPACITY$ICK#HENEYAND'EORGES"USHCOULDDONOTHINGBUT WARNAGAINSTTHEFUTUREDANGEROUSOPERATIONSOF!L1AEDA"ESIDES ITTHEYCOULDNOTIMAGINEEITHERITSCONTENTORITSFORM
7HATISNEWIN!L1AEDABESIDESITSNONPYRAMIDALORGANIZATION ISITSABILITYTODICTATETOTHE!MERICANENEMYITSOWNCONDITIONSAND ITSOWNLINEOFCONDUCTBASEDONSURPRISEANDTHEREFUSALTOREACT 4HISHASENTAILEDAMAJORSYMBOLICVICTORYDETHRONING!MERICAASTHE hGODDESSvFORTHERESTOFTHEWORLDh!L1AEDAPROVEDTOTHE-USLIMS THATTHEYCANBESUPERIORANDCANINNOVATEINTHOUGHTORGANIZATION ANDACTIONBEYONDTHELEVELOF!MERICASTHOUGHTWHOISAGODDESS ORBETTERSAIDTHEGODDESSOFIMPIETY ANDTECHNOLOGYFORTHERESTOF HUMANITYv"UTTHEMAJORVICTORYFOR!L1AEDAHASBEENTOSETTHE TONEINTHEWORLDMEDIADOMINATEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESBYUSING hPUBLICITYCOMMUNICATIONPOLITICSANDPUBLICRELATIONS)LOOKAT SOMEOF#..SWORDSABOUTTHEABILITYOF!L1AEDATOUSECHEMICAL WEAPONS!ND)WONDERATTHESUBJUGATIONITEXERTSONTHEMWHICH ISINACCORDANCEWITHTHE0ROPHETSWORDS)WASVICTORIOUSTHROUGH THEAWE;INTHEENEMYSHEART=AND)IMAGINETHE!MERICANSCENERY WHEREPEOPLELOOKWITHDREADANDANXIETYTHEDEATHOFTHEDOGSAND RELATEITTOOURAWESOMEPOWER4HEYAREANGUISHEDATTHESIGHTOFTHE 3HEIKH5SAMA;"IN,ADEN=v!CCORDINGTO!TIYAT /LLAH!L1AEDA CHANGEDTHEMENTALSITUATIONOF-USLIMSWHOCANNOWENVISAGETHE DESTRUCTIONOF!MERICAASAREALISTICPROJECTWHEREASBEFORE3EPTEMBER ITWASANUNREALIZABLEDREAM
#OMBININGMODERNTHOUGHTWITH)SLAMICTRADITION!TIYAT /LLAH GIVESAMODERNPICTUREOF)BN4AYMIYATHEMEDIEVAL-USLIMRADICAL THINKERh)BN4AYMIYATHREATENEDTHE+INGOF#YPRUSTHATAMONG THE-USLIMSTHEREAREGROUPSOFDEVOTEESWHOMHEDESCRIBEDASKILL INGTHEKINGSINTHEIRCOMMUNITIES!NDHEWASDISCUSSINGAFORMOF
ORGANIZATIONLIKE!L1AEDAINHISTIMEv!TIYAT /LLAHUSES&UKU YAMA(UNTINGTONAND)BN4AYMIYAASREFERENCESFORHISARGUMENT h4HEHISTORYENDSINTHESENSETHATTHEHISTORYOFTHE7ESTERNWORLD ISENDINGANDTHE7ESTERNCIVILIZATIONISBANKRUPTANDOUR)SLAMIC HISTORYOFTHE;-USLIM=%ASTBEGINSNOWTHROUGH!LLAHSASSISTANCEv (ETHUSBLENDS&UKUYAMAAND(UNTINGTONONEPREDICTINGTHEEND OFHISTORYWHICHISTHEENDOFTHE7ESTSHISTORYFROM!TIYAT /LLAH VIEW THEOTHERFORESEEINGTHECLASHOFCIVILIZATIONSWHICHMEANSTHE VICTORYOF)SLAMANDTHEDEFEATOFTHE7EST
3EPTEMBERHASINFUSEDANEWHOPEINTOTHE*IHADISTSSOULS )TISMORETHANREVENGEITISTHEDAWNOFANEWWORLDINWHICH)S LAMTAKESITSREVENGEAGAINSTANARROGANT7EST)TISTHEBEGINNING OFANEWERAINWHICH7ESTERNMILITARYMIGHTREVEALSITSIMPOTENCE AGAINST A NEW STRATEGICMODE OF ACTION THAT INVERTS THE-USLIMS WEAKNESSINTHEFACEOFAMILITARILYSUPERIOR7EST4HEDREAMOFA HEGEMONIC)SLAMASAWORLDRELIGIONISRENEWEDBYTHE*IHADISTS"UT THISDREAMISNOTSHAREDBYOTHER-USLIMSANDEVENTHOUGH9ASIR SHARES!TIYAT /LLAHSIDEASABOUTTHEDOMINEERING7ESTHEDOESNOT SHARE!TIYAT /LLAHSOPTIMISMABOUTTHEDEFEATOFTHE7ESTANDTHE EFlCIENCYOF!L1AEDAnTYPEORGANIZATIONSINBRINGINGTHE7ESTTO ITSKNEES2EALISTICALLY9ASIRBELIEVESTHAT!L1AEDASVIOLENTACTIONIS TOTHEDETRIMENTOFTHE-USLIMSALLOVERTHEWORLD
4HISIMAGINARYDIALOGUESETSTHETONEFORANEWTYPEOF*IHADIST IDEOLOGYANDINTELLECTUAL4HEREFERENCESAREASMUCHTHE7ESTERNAS THE)SLAMICINTELLECTUALS4HECLASHOFCIVILIZATIONSTHENEW*IHADIST INTELLECTUALSPROMOTEISATITSROOTANEWHYBRIDITYˆNAMELYARE SHAPINGOF*IHADINLIGHTOFMODERNIDEOLOGIES!TIYAT /LLAHISANEW TYPEOFIDEOLOGUEATEASEINTHETRADITIONAL)SLAMIClELDOFKNOWLEDGE ANDREFERENCEASWELLASMODERN7ESTERNSOCIALANDPOLITICALTHOUGHT (EISNOTWITHINTHEFRAMEWORKOFANEXCLUSIVELY)SLAMICCIVILIZATION CONTRARYTOTHEFAMOUSRADICALTHEOLOGIAN-AQDISIBUTANEWKINDOF POLITICALTHINKERUSINGREFERENCESFROMBOTHTHE7ESTANDTHE)SLAMIC WORLD THINKING STRATEGICALLY ACCORDING TONEW THEORIESOFWARFARE THEASYMMETRICWAR ELABORATINGPLANSTOSURPASSTHE!MERICANSIN THEIROWNTACTICSOFPSYCHOLOGICALWARFAREANDSETTINGNEWIDEALSFOR -USLIMSBASEDONARENEWEDVISIONOF*IHAD(ESINCERELYBELIEVES THAT!L1AEDAISABLETOSMASH!MERICANPOWERINTOPIECES(EIS UTTERLYOPTIMISTICUNLIKEOTHER-USLIMSWHOFEELOVERWHELMEDAND VICTIMIZEDBY7ESTERNDOMINATION*IHADISMOPENSUPAHORIZONOF HOPETOANEWGENERATIONOFACTIVISTSWHOARENOLONGERPSYCHOLOGICALLY OVERPOWEREDBYTHEPRESTIGEANDINVINCIBILITYOF!MERICA!GAINSTA BACKGROUNDOFDISENCHANTMENTANDPOLITICALALIENATIONINTHE-USLIM
WORLD!L1AEDAUSESDESTRUCTIVETACTICSTOMAKEHOPEONCEAGAIN POSSIBLE#ULTURALLYSPEAKING!TIYAT /LLAHISABLENDOFTHE7ESTAND THE%AST0SYCHOLOGICALLYHEISINAMERCILESSWARWITHTHE7EST
.EW7ARFARETHROUGH'LOBAL-EDIA 4HE0ROMINENCEOFTHE3YMBOLIC$IMENSION
2IGHTFROMTHEBEGINNINGMODERNTERRORISMHASBEENLINKEDTOMOD ERNTECHNOLOGYNOTONLYEXPLOSIVES.OBELINVENTEDDYNAMITEIN ANDTHE2USSIANANARCHISTSUSEDITFROMTHEENDOFTHENINETEENTH CENTURYONWARD BUTALSOCOMMUNICATION4HE2USSIAN$ECEMBRISTS ATTACKSAGAINSTTHECHIEFOFSTATESINTHEWORLDWEREAMPLIlEDBYBUR GEONINGJOURNALISMANDTHENEWTECHNOLOGYOFPHOTOGRAPHY
4HESOCIALANDREVOLUTIONARYMOVEMENTSINTHE-USLIMWORLD HAVEMADEBROADUSEOFCOMMUNICATIONTECHNOLOGIES4HE)SLAMIC 2EVOLUTION IN )RANWAS BOOSTED BY THE TECHNOLOGY OF SMALL TAPE RECORDERSANDTHEIRCASSETTESWHICHALLOWEDTHEREVOLUTIONARIESTO SPREAD THE SPEECHES OF!YATOLLAH+HOMEINI THROUGHOUT )RAN AND THEWORLDANDPUTTHEMATTHEDISPOSALOFTHEMEDIA"IN,ADENS TALKSHAVEBEENSENTTO!L*AZEERANETWORKONVIDEOTAPES4HEMOST SPECTACULARMEANSISSTILLTHETELEVISIONFORTHEPURPOSEOFPROPAGANDA ANDPUBLICITY46SALLOVERTHEWORLDPUTONDISPLAYATHOUSANDTIMES THEAPOCALYPTICIMAGESOFTHEFALLING4WIN4OWERSFORWEEKSONEND AFTER3EPTEMBER
*IHADISTSAREFASCINATEDBYTHEIMAGESOFAPOCALYPSE3INCETHEY CANNOTCONSTRUCTIVELYACCOMPLISHAGRANDIOSEDEEDTHEYAREINTENT ONDESTRUCTIVELYPERFORMINGAWE INSPIRINGACTS4HEIRMIND SETBASED ONA-ANICHEANVISIONRIGHTVERSUSWRONGGOODVERSUSBAD THEIR INCLINATIONFOROVERGENERALIZATIONEVERYTHINGISEXPLAINEDTHROUGHA RIGIDBELIEFSYSTEMTHATDENIESANYROLETOREALITYOTHERTHANCONlRMING THEIRHYPOTHESES THEIRSENSEOFMISSIONTHEYARETHEVANGUARDTHE HEROESTHESELF PROCLAIMEDREPRESENTATIVESOF4RUE)SLAM ANDTHEIR INTRANSIGENTATTITUDETOWARDTHEPRESCRIPTIONSOFRELIGIONMAKETHEM THEMOSTAPPROPRIATEPEOPLETOCARRYOUTMASSIVEDESTRUCTIONWITHOUT THESLIGHTESTGUILT4HEIRIMPATIENCEWITHTHEWORLDASITISANDTHEIR APOCALYPTICVIEWMAKETHEMTHEMESSENGERSOFDESTRUCTIONTHEMORE SOAS THEIR IDEOLOGYOPERATESASA SUBSTITUTE FORAPERSONALCODEOF ETHICSTHATPROHIBITSMURDERUNDERNORMALCONDITIONSIN!BRAHAMIC RELIGIONSALLTHERELIGIONSBESIDESTHEAPOCALYPTICSECTS
&ASCINATIONWITHDEATHANDDESTRUCTIONlNDSITSBESTOUTLETINTHE SYMBOLICDIMENSIONOFIMAGES%VENTHE4WIN4OWERSDESTRUCTIONDID NOTHAVEANYREALDIMENSIONOF!POCALYPSE4HEIRCOLLAPSEKILLED PEOPLE)NTHESAMEYEARTHETOTALNUMBEROFPEOPLEKILLEDINHIGHWAY
CRASHESINTHE5NITED3TATESWASAROUNDlFTEENTIMESHIGHER THANTHE4WIN4OWERSDEATHS7HATGIVESTHE4WIN4OWERSDESTRUCTION ITSICONICSENSEISBASEDONTHESIMULTANEITYOFTHENUMBEROFDEATHS CARACCIDENTSKILLPEOPLEEVERYDAYDISPERSEDOVERTHEYEAR THE GEOGRAPHICCONCENTRATIONOFTHEINCIDENTCARACCIDENTSOCCURINDIF FERENTPLACESWITHAFEWNUMBEROFDEADEACHTIME THEINTENTIONAL CHARACTEROFTHEKILLINGSCARACCIDENTSARELARGELYUNINTENTIONALANDARE PERCEIVEDALMOSTASAKINTONATURALDISASTERS ANDTHEVIRTUALLYRECURRENT DIMENSIONOFTHE4WIN4OWERSEXPLOSIONS4HEYWEREINTEGRATEDWITHIN !L1AEDAPROPAGANDATHATFORETOLDOTHERINCIDENTSOFTHESAMENATURE PREMEDITATEDANDPLANNEDCONSCIOUSLYITWASREVEALEDINDOCUMENTS CONlSCATEDLATERTHATMANYOTHERBUILDINGSWERETARGETS
!TANYRATEINREALTERMS3EPTEMBERWASNOTANAPOCALYPTIC EVENTBUTSYMBOLICALLYITWAS3EVERALEXPLANATIONSHAVEBEENPRO POUNDEDUNLIKE'REAT"RITAINRECURRENT.ORTHERN)RELANDBOMBINGS ANDEXPLOSIONS ITWASTHElRSTMAJORTERRORISTATTACKON!MERICAN SOIL4HEATTACKON0EARL(ARBORWASWAGEDAGAINSTAN!MERICANPORT NOTATTHElNANCIALHEARTOF-ANHATTANTHE,ONE"OMBEROROTHER TYPESOFEXTREMERIGHTINCIDENTSORVIOLENTANTI ABORTIONACTSCANNOT BECOMPAREDTO3EPTEMBEREITHERBECAUSEOFITSSHEERDIMENSIONS ANDTHEIMPLICATIONOFFOREIGNINVOLVEMENT4HE3EPTEMBERATTACKS WERESEENASAMAJORVICTORYOFTHETERRORISTSAGAINSTTHE!MERICAN SUPERPOWEREVENBYMANY!MERICANSITWASTHEOPPOSITEOFWHAT MANYPEOPLEEXPECTEDAFTERTHEFALLOFCOMMUNISMWHICHSHOULDHAVE BROUGHTWORLDPEACETHEhENDOFTHEIDEOLOGYvIMPLYINGTHEENDOF MASSIVEVIOLENCEWORLDWIDE 4HE *IHADISTS CALLEDh"LACK4UESDAYv 3EPTEMBER h"LESSED4UESDAYv)TWASTHEVICTORYOFABRANDOF )SLAMSYNONYMOUSWITHARELIGIONALIENTO7ESTERNCIVILIZATIONAND AIMEDATCOMBATINGITINABATTLETHATSHOOKTHESELF CONlDENCEOF THE!MERICANPEOPLE
4HEMAJORRESULTOFTHISSYMBOLICCATASTROPHEWASTHEQUESTFORA SCAPEGOAT4HE!MERICANPUBLICFACEDANEWENEMYSTATELESSWITHNO NORMALARMYWITHOUTAGOVERNMENTANDWITHNOMIGHTCOMPARABLE TOTHE3OVIET5NIONORFORMERENEMIESLIKE'ERMANYINTHE3ECOND 7ORLD7AR4HEIDEALSCAPEGOATBECAME3ADDAM(USSEINCHOSENBY THE"USHADMINISTRATIONANDFOLLOWEDBYMOST!MERICANMEDIA(IS BLOODYRECORDOFMASSMURDEROFTHE+URDSANDHISATTEMPTATKILLING THEFATHEROFTHE53PRESIDENTASWELLASHISINVASIONOF+UWAITIN GAVESOMELEGITIMACYTOTHECLAIMTHATHEWASINTOUCHWITH !L1AEDAWHICHPROVEDWRONGLATERON ANDTHATHEWASBUILDINGUP WEAPONSOFMASSDESTRUCTIONALSOPROVEDWRONGAFTERTHEINVASIONOF )RAQ 7ITHOUT3EPTEMBER!MERICANPUBLICOPINIONWOULDPROB ABLYNOTHAVEhBOUGHTvTHEIDEAOFATTACKING)RAQBYGROUNDFORCES 4HE6IETNAM3YNDROMEWASRUBBEDOFFBYTHE3EPTEMBERATTACKS
ONERECENTHARROWINGMEMORYWASHEDOFFANOTHERDATINGBACKTOTHE SWHICHRESULTEDINTHEREPUGNANCEOFTHE!MERICANPEOPLETO ENGAGEINMASSIVEMILITARYATTACKSAGAINSTAFARAWAYENEMY4HENEW WARWASINASENSETHESYMBOLICTRIUMPHOF!L1AEDAITFORCEDTHE ONLYSUPERPOWERINTHEWORLDTOBECOMEINVOLVEDINAREALWARIN)RAQ THATRESULTEDINANOTHERUPSURGEOF*IHADISM
4HERELATIONSHIPBETWEENTHEMEDIAANDTHE*IHADISTSISAMBIVA LENTATBEST4HEHIGHhEXPOSUREEFFECTvOF3EPTEMBERPERHAPSTHE MOSTPUBLICIZEDWORLDEVENTINTHELASTDECADEHASGIVENASYMBOLIC PROMINENCETO!L1AEDAITCOULDNEVERHAVEOTHERWISEDREAMEDOF!L 1AEDAHASDONEEVERYTHINGTOBEPUBLICIZEDTHROUGHOUTTHEWORLD)TS ATTEMPTSTOPROVOKELARGEDAMAGEANDTHEHIGHESTNUMBEROFCASUAL TIESAREPARTANDPARCELOFTHISSTRATEGY7ITHOUTTHEMEDIA!L1AEDA WOULDHAVEBEENPERCEIVEDASAMAJORTHREATBUTNOTASIMPORTANTASIT ISCONSIDEREDNOWINSPITEOFTHELOWNUMBEROFCASUALTIESITHASCAUSED INTHE7ESTINTHELASTFEWYEARS3OMESCHOLARSSPEAKOFASYMBIOTIC RELATIONSHIPANDEVENMUTUALBENElTSBETWEENTHETERRORISTSTHATARE PROVIDEDWITHAPULPITFOREXPRESSINGTHEIRVIEWSANDTHEMEDIAIN SEARCHOFSENSATIONALNEWSANDSTORIES)TISWELL KNOWNTHATTHEPRINT BUTPARTICULARLYTHEELECTRONICMEDIAARECRUCIALFORSPREADINGTERRORIST PROPAGANDA4HEINDOCTRINATIONOFMANYNEW*IHADISTSISCARRIEDOUT THROUGHTHE)NTERNET3CHOLARSSPEAKOFAPOSTn3EPTEMBER*IHAD INWHICHTHE)NTERNETCLUSTERSDIFFERENTPEOPLETOGETHERTHROUGHITS VIRTUALCOMMUNICATIONMEANSINANELECTRONIC*IHAD
!LLTHEMAJORTERRORISTGROUPSHAVE7EBSITES4HEREWERESOME TERRORISTOR TERRORIST RELATED SITES IDENTIlED IN!MONG THEMTHEGLOBAL*IHADMOVEMENTSWEREPRESENTONMORETHANDIF FERENTSITES4HEYUSETHE)NTERNETFORVARIOUSPURPOSESINCLUDING PROPAGANDAFORRECRUITMENTBUTALSOFUNDRAISINGTERRORISTTRAINING ANDINSTRUCTIONESPECIALLYEXPLOSIVEMANUALSANDBEHAVIORGUIDESTO AVOIDKINDLINGTHESUSPICIONOFINTELLIGENCESERVICES ANDOPERATIONAL PLANNINGFORATTACKSTHROUGHE MAIL/THERWAYSTHE*IHADISTSUSE THE)NTERNETINCLUDEPSYCHOLOGICALWARFAREPUBLICITYDATAGATHERING MOBILIZATION NETWORKING AND INFORMATION SHARING ANDPLANNING AND COORDINATION )N'REAT"RITAIN lVEMAJOR USES OF THE7EB BY )SLAMISTS CANBEENUMERATED INFORMATIONPROVISIONlNANCING NETWORKINGRECRUITMENTANDINFORMATIONGATHERING4HE7EBHAS BECOME THEONLINEUNIVERSITY FOR RADICALIZING-USLIMSBYOFFERING THEMACOMPREHENSIVE*IHADISTCURRICULUM
/NEOFTHETOOLSTHE*IHADISTSUSEISINTIMIDATIONANDHORRIFY ING VIDEOS PRESENTING HOSTAGES !MERICANS AMONG OTHERS MOSTLY BLINDFOLDED ASKING IN A HUMILIATINGWAY FOR HELP AND IMPLORING THEIRRESPECTIVEGOVERNMENTSTOCOMPLYWITHTHE*IHADISTSDEMANDS
IN ORDER TO SAVE THEIR LIVES(OODEDMILITANTS ARMEDWITH A+A LASHNIKOVORA SWORD ANNOUNCE THAT THEHOSTAGEWILLBEEXECUTED UNLESSTHEGOVERNMENTCOMPLIESWITHTHEIRDEMANDS%NGLISHAND SOMETIMES&RENCHORANOTHERLANGUAGE ISADDEDTOMAKETHEENTIRE MESSAGEUNDERSTANDABLETONON !RABVISITORS)NSPIRINGHORRORINTHE hUNBELIEVERSvORTOhFAKE-USLIMSvGIVESSELF CONlDENCEANDPRIDETO MANY-USLIMSALLOVERTHEWORLDWHOFEELDESPISEDMISTREATEDAND IN%UROPESECOND CLASSCITIZENSWITHNOFUTUREPROSPECTS4HEVIDEOS ARESYMBOLICOCCASIONSFORTHEMWHOlNDSOLACEINTHESUFFERINGOF THOSEWHOMAKETHEMSUFFERANDAREUSUALLYINADOMINANTPOSITION 4HEFEELINGOFHAVINGhREVENGEvTHROUGHTHECOURAGEOFTHE*IHADISTS COMFORTSMANY YOUNGMENWHO ARE NOT *IHADISTS THEMSELVES AND WOULDNOTAPPROVEOFTHEHYPER PURITANICALPOLICIESOFTHE*IHADISTS WITHINTHEIROWNSOCIETY
*IHADISTCYBERWARCANBRINGTOAMOMENTARYSTANDSTILLTHOSE7EB SITESSEENASENEMIESOF)SLAM4HE)NTERNETSITEOFTHE$ANISHDAILY *YLANDS 0OSTENWHICHOUTRAGED-USLIMSBYPUBLISHINGCARICATURESOF THE0ROPHET-OHAMMEDON3EPTEMBERWASOVERLOADEDWITH VIRUSESTHATBROUGHTITTOATEMPORARYHALT!FTERTHEPOPESREMARKS IN3EPTEMBERCALLING)SLAMAVIOLENTRELIGIONINREFERENCETOTHE WORDSOFA"YZANTINERULER*IHADISTSLAUNCHEDANEW7EBSITECALLED %LECTRONIC*IHAD)TSPURPOSEWASTOHELPORGANIZEANELECTRONICHOLY WARAGAINST7EBSITESTHATINSULT)SLAMAND)SLAMICSACREDlGURES4HE SITEWASPUBLICIZEDONESTABLISHED*IHADIST7EBSITES&URTHERMORE POSTINGSFROM!UGUSTONTHE%LECTRONIC*IHADSITECLAIMEDTHAT THEYHADSUCCESSFULLYSHUTDOWNAN)SRAELIWEBSITE4HESITEWORKS BYCOORDINATINGANDORGANIZINGITSUSERSANDSYMPATHIZERSANDOFFERS PROGRAMSFORDOWNLOADINGBYTHOSEWILLINGTOENGAGEINTHEELECTRONIC *IHAD4WOMAINPROGRAMSAREOFFEREDTHElRSTTHE%LECTRONIC*IHAD 0ROGRAM3ILVER%DITION ISUSEDFORHACKINGATTACKSANDTHESEC ONDWHENINSTALLEDPLACESATOOLBARONTHEUSERSCOMPUTERTHATCON NECTSAUTOMATICALLYTO%LECTRONIC*IHADANDACQUIRESDATACONTAINING THESPECIlCDATETIMEANDTARGETSITEFORTHEATTACK7HENTHATTIME ARRIVESTHEUSERSIMPLYHASTORUNTHElRSTHACKINGPROGRAMSELECTTHE TARGETSITETOBEATTACKEDANDTHENALLOWTHEPROGRAMTODOTHEREST 4HEKEYTOTHESEATTACKSISTHATTHEYHAVETOBEWAGEDSIMULTANEOUSLY BYMANYDIFFERENTUSERSTOOVERLOADTHETARGETSITE
*IHADONTHE)NTERNETISBEGINNINGTOGAINMOMENTUM3OME SITESPROMOTE ITANDAIMATTARGETINGSPECIlC)0ADDRESSES THATARE DEEMEDANTI )SLAMIC3INCETHENUMBEROF-USLIM)NTERNETUSERSIS CONSTANTLYONTHERISETHOSEABLETOTAKEPARTINTHE%LECTRONIC*IHAD MIGHT INCREASE ASWELL %LECTRONIC *IHAD SITES SERVE ALSO AS FORUMS FOR LEARNINGATTACKTECHNIQUES *IHADISTS LEARN INPARTICULARHOWTO
ORGANIZESYNCHRONIZEDMASSCYBERATTACKSON7EBSITESTHEYDEEMAS ANTI )SLAMIC
"ESIDESCLANDESTINEORhILLEGALvSITESTHEREARENOWADAYSLEGAL ONESWITHINTHE7ESTTHATSPREAD*IHADISTMESSAGESWITHOUTINFRINGING ONTHELAW7ESTERNMEDIADETECTSOMEOFTHEMh4ERRORISMEXPERTSAT 7EST0OINTSAYTHEREAREASMANYAS%NGLISHLANGUAGESITES;INTHE 53=OFFERINGMILITANT)SLAMICVIEWSWITH-R+HANSˆWHICHCLAIMS REGULARREADERSˆAMONGTHEMOREACTIVE7HILETHEIRREACHIS DIFlCULTTOASSESSITISCLEARFROMAREVIEWOFEXTREMISTMATERIALAND INTERVIEWSTHATMILITANTSARESEEKINGTOAPPEALTOYOUNG!MERICAN AND%UROPEAN-USLIMSBYPLAYINGONTHEIRANGEROVERTHEWARIN)RAQ ANDTHEIMAGEOF)SLAMUNDERATTACKv
/NTHEWHOLETHE)NTERNETENHANCESASENSEOFAGLOBALUNI VERSAL5MMATHROUGHITSANONYMITYANDEASYLINKSTOOTHERPEOPLE 4HECYBER5MMADOESNOTNEEDACTUALMEETINGSANDMUTUALPERSONAL KNOWLEDGE)TMAKESCOMMUNICATIONEASYONTHEBASISOFSHAREDVIEWS ANDCOMMONCONCERNSONTHESCREEN4HE*IHADIST)NTERNETBECOMESA MEANSTOACHIEVETHEGOALOFATRANSNATIONALNEO 5MMATHROUGHTHE INVOLVEMENTOF)SLAMICYOUTHWHOAREMOREAWAREOFTHEVIRTUALWORLD ANDPARTICIPATEINAPLURALITYOFCULTURES4HEYOUNGMANWHOHELPED !L1AEDAGAINACCESSTOCYBERSPACEAFTERTHEFALLOFTHE4ALIBANCODE NAMED)RHABI)RHABMEANSTERRORISMIN!RABICREFERRINGTO *AMES"OND IS9OUNIS4SOULITHETWENTY TWO YEAR OLDSONOFA-OROC CANTOURISMBOARDOFlCIALANDASTUDENTOFINFORMATIONTECHNOLOGY 4WOOFHISCOLLABORATORS7ASEEM-UGHALA"RITISH BORNGRADUATE INBIOCHEMISTRY!KA!BUTHAABIT AND4ARIQAL $AOURALAWSTUDENT BORNINTHE5NITED!RAB%MIRATESWEREONLYINTOUCHTHROUGHTHE 7EBANDSEEMNOTTOHAVEKNOWNEACHOTHERPERSONALLY4HEYWERE CONDEMNEDTOLONGPRISONTERMSINTHE5NITED+INGDOM7ITHIN THE-USLIMDIASPORASIN%UROPE*IHADIST7EBSITESBUILDUPAhWALL OFRESENTMENTvOPPOSINGINTEGRATIONANDPUSHINGTOWARDRANCORAND VIOLENCE4HEMESSAGESALSOABETOBEDIENCETO*IHADISTAUTHORITIES
)NADDITIONTOTHE)NTERNETTHEREAREOTHERMEANSBYWHICH!L 1AEDAANDASSOCIATEDGROUPSTENDTOIMPOSEASTYLEONTHEIRATTACKS INORDERTOBERECOGNIZEDASSUCHBYMASSCOMMUNICATIONSANDINTHIS WAYFORGEANIDENTITYAhBRANDv/NEMETHODISMULTIPLEATTACKS!L 1AEDAANDTHEIRBRANCHOFlCESTENDTOMAKETHEIRBOMBINGSMULTIPLE WITHINSHORTSPANSOFTIME4HE3EPTEMBERATTACKSAIMEDATTHREE DIFFERENTSITESTHE7ORLD4RADE#ENTERIN.EW9ORK#ITYTHE0ENTA GONIN!RLINGTON#OUNTY6IRGINIAANDATHIRDTARGETTHELASTAIRCRAFT CRASHEDINTOAlELDNEARTHETOWNOF3HANKSVILLEINRURAL3OMERSET #OUNTY0ENNSYLVANIA AFTER PASSENGERS ANDMEMBERS OF THEmIGHT CREWATTEMPTEDTOTAKECONTROLOFTHEIRPLANE 4HE-ADRIDBOMBINGS
AIMEDATFOURCOMMUTERTRAINSDURINGTHEPEAKOF-ADRIDSRUSHHOUR ONTHEMORNINGOF4HURSDAY-ARCH4HE,ONDONBOMB INGSPURPORTEDTODESTROYABUSANDATLEASTTWOMETROSTATIONSTHREE BOMBSONTHE,ONDON5NDERGROUNDEXPLODEDWITHINlFTYSECONDS OFEACHOTHERATINTHEMORNINGON*ULY
!NOTHERSYMBOLICDIMENSIONMANY!L1AEDAnINSPIREDATTACKS TRYTOFOLLOWISTHEELEVENTHDAYOFA#HRISTIANMONTH!FTERTHE3EP TEMBERATTACKSTHEREAREALSOTHE$JERBA4UNISIAATTACKSON!PRIL THENTHE-ADRIDBOMBINGSON-ARCHANDTHE LATESTBEINGTHE$ECEMBERBOMBINGSIN!LGIERS4HESTRIK INGFACTISTHATTHE)SLAMICDAYSARENOTTAKENASTHEYARDSTICKBUTTHE #HRISTIANONES4HELUNAR(EGIRAMONTHSAREMOSTLYSHORTERTHANTHE SOLAR#HRISTIANMONTHSBUTTHEELEVENTHDAYOFTHELATTERARECHOSEN THEREAREEXCEPTIONSLIKETHE,ONDONBOMBINGSOF*ULY TO SENDAMESSAGETOTHE7ESTERNWORLD
!NOTHERPECULIARITYOF!L1AEDATHATHASADIRECTBEARINGON THEMEDIAISTHEATTEMPTATMAKINGASPECTACLETHROUGHMAXIMIZING THENUMBEROFTHEDEAD)NTHE7EST!L1AEDASCAPACITYHASBEEN ERODEDASALREADYMENTIONEDBUT IN-USLIMCOUNTRIES ITCANSTILL MOUNTDEADLYOPERATIONSINWHICHDOZENSORMOREPEOPLEDIELIKE THE!LGERIANEXPLOSIONSINWHICHMORETHANFORTYPEOPLEDIED ANDMANYMOREWEREINJURED4HIShAPOCALYPTICvDIMENSIONOFDEATH SHOWSTHAT-USLIMSLETALONENON -USLIMSARENOTPROTECTEDANY MOREBYTHETABOOOFKILLINGTHEINNOCENTEVENINTIMESOFPEACE *IHADISTSCHANGETHENATUREOFhPEACEv&ORTHEMWEAREINTHETIMEOF ANALL OUTWARBETWEEN)SLAMANDTHEIDOLATROUSPOWERHOLDERSALLOVER THEWORLDANDTHISAPPLIESTOTHESOCIETIESINWHICHEVERYONETAKES PARTINTHEEFFORTTOSUPPRESS-USLIMSTHE7ESTASMUCHAS-USLIM COUNTRIES THEMSELVES 0EACE IS THEREFORE REJECTED/NLY TEMPORARY RESPITEHUDNA ISACCEPTABLEATTHEPRICEOFTHE7ESTSRENOUNCINGITS HOSTILEATTITUDETOWARD-USLIMS3INCETHISISNOTTHECASETHELAN GUAGEOFDEATHISTHEONLYONETOHAVELEGITIMACY)TBECOMESUNIVERSAL ANDRECOGNIZESNOBOUNDARY4OGAINCURRENCYITNEEDSTHEMEDIATO SPREADITWORLDWIDE4HEMOREHORRENDOUSTHESPECTACLETHEMORE GLORIOUSTHEACTION
)NDISCRIMINATE VIOLENCE ISMULTIPLIED AND hSACRALIZEDv BY THE AWEITINSPIRESTHROUGHTHEMEDIAWHICHARETHEINDISPENSABLETOOLS FOR*IHADISTACTION!NACTIONISMOREhSUCCESSFULvASITKILLSAHIGHER NUMBEROFTHEPEOPLEWHICHENTITLESITTOALARGERPLACEINTHEMEDIA )N THIS RESPECT!L1AEDA ISDIFFERENT FROMCLASSICAL TERRORISTSWHO USUALLYDONOTINTENDTOBLINDLYKILLORMAIMANDMAINTAINABALANCE BETWEENMATERIALDESTRUCTIONANDHUMANCASUALTY)NTHE!L1AEDA CASEDEHUMANIZATIONCOMBINEDWITHSPECTACULARACTIONAIMEDATTHE
WORLDMEDIAMAKESTHEARITHMETICOFTHEKILLEDTHEMAJORSYMBOLIC DIMENSION OF THE OPERATION4HE HEIGHTENING HORROR CONTRIBUTES TO THE SELF CONlDENCEOF THEORGANIZATIONAND ITSPRESTIGE THROUGH THEMAINLY7ESTERNCOMMUNICATIONSYSTEM'LOBALMEDIAARE THE TARGET THEYUNWITTINGLY GIVEPROMINENCE TO THE *IHADISTORGANIZA TIONTHROUGHTHEIRCOVERAGEOFTHEHORROR$OMINANT7ESTERNCIVIL CULTUREISBASEDONAVOIDANCEOFVIOLENCE*IHADISTSBELIEVETHATTHISIS SHEERHYPOCRISY"YHEIGHTENINGTHEVIOLENCETHEYAIMTOATTRACTTHE MEDIAWHICHDEPICTHORRORASACOUNTERCULTURALFACT ANDPUSHTHE !MERICANGOVERNMENTTOUSEVIOLENCESHOWINGITSOWNINABILITYTO HOLDONTOTHECULTUREOFNONVIOLENCEITPUBLICIZESASBEINGITSOFlCIAL STANCE)FITDOESNOTACTVIOLENTLYITDISPLAYSITSOWNWEAKNESSAND THEDENIALOFITSOWNMILITARYSUPERIORITY)NBOTHCASESTHE7ESTERN POWERISPUTINADOUBLEBINDEITHERACTINGVIOLENTLYNOTBEINGTRUE TOTHECULTUREOFNONVIOLENCE ORACTINGNONVIOLENTLYTHUSREVEALING ITSOWNPOWERLESSNESS
*IHADISTSTACTICSESPECIALLYPLAYAROLEINRELATIONTOTHEGLOBAL MEDIA!MONGTHETACTICSUSEDBYTERRORISTSINGENERALAND*IHADISTS INPARTICULARBOMBINGISPROMINENT)TISSPECTACULARITATTRACTSMANY PEOPLENAMELYCAMERAMENANDJOURNALISTSITKILLSINDISCRIMINATELY LARGENUMBERSOFPEOPLEANDTHETECHNIQUEISEASYTOMANIPULATE
4HEROLEOFTHEBOMBASANELEMENTOFTERRORISTSTACTICALREPERTOIRE REACHESBACKINTOTHEEARLIESTHISTORYOFMODERNTERRORISM!NARCHIST TERRORISTSADOPTEDTHEUSEOFEXPLOSIVESINTHESANDTHEATTRAC TIVENESSOFTHEWEAPONWASSYMBOLICASWELLASFUNCTIONALˆhDYNA MITEMADEALLMENEQUALANDTHEREFOREFREEv)NTHEPERIODCOVERED BYTHE2!.$ -)04DATASETSBOMBINGINCIDENTSREPRESENTTHE MAJORITYOFTERRORISTATTACKSPERCENTOFALLINCIDENTS )NMOST INDIVIDUALYEARSBOMBINGSACCOUNTFORMORETHANHALFTHETERROR ISTATTACKSEXCEPTINAND ANDHAVEREACHEDAS HIGHASPERCENTOFATTACKSIN4HEPREVALENCEOFBOMBINGS ASATACTICOFCHOICEFORTERRORISTORGANIZATIONSISREINFORCEDBYTHE MANYWAYSEXPLOSIVESCANBEUSEDANDAPPLIED%XAMINATIONOF INCIDENTSINTHEDATABASERANGEFROMTHEUSEOFSMALLLETTERBOMBS FORTARGETINGINDIVIDUALSTOLARGE SCALEVEHICLEBOMBSDESIGNEDTO PRODUCEMASSCASUALTIESANDDESTROYSTRUCTURESANDPROPERTY
3UICIDEATTACKSHAVEALSOUNDERGONESTEEPINCREASESDURINGTHE RECENTYEARS
4HISTACTICWASNOTPOPULARLYUSEDPRIORTOTHEEARLYSBUT IT RECEIVEDWIDESPREADMEDIA ATTENTION FROM THE SUICIDE
CAR BOMBING OF THE53-ARINE#ORPS BARRACKS IN ,EBANON 3UBSEQUENTLYSEVERALTERRORISTGROUPSADOPTEDTHETACTIC3UICIDE BOMBINGSHAVEBEENANEFFECTIVETACTICFORASSASSINATIONSFORAT TACKSONMILITARYTARGETSANDFORCREATINGMASSCASUALTIESANDTERROR )NADDITIONTHEDEDICATIONOFTHEINDIVIDUALSWILLINGTOSACRIlCE THEIRLIVESFORTHECAUSEOFTHEGROUPLENDSTOTHECREDIBILITYAND LEGITIMACYOFTHEGROUPINTHEEYESOFOTHERMEMBERSANDPOSSIBLE RECRUITS!SARESULTSUICIDEBOMBINGSHAVEBECOMEINCREASINGLY POPULARWITHTERRORISTGROUPSDURINGTHESANDEARLYS 4HE-)044ERRORISM+NOWLEDGE"ASEINDICATESASTEEPSPIKEIN THENUMBEROFSUICIDEINCIDENTSINRECENTYEARSWITHTHE)RAQWAR CONTRIBUTINGTOMUCHOFTHISINCREASE
'LOBALMEDIAINDUCEGLOBAL*IHADINITSSYMBOLICDIMENSION )NTHEMANEWSENSEOFVIRTUALLIFEANDDEATHDEVELOPSTHATAMPLI lESIMAGINARYREPROACHESANDMYTHICALRECRIMINATIONS4HEFRONTIERS BETWEENTHEVIRTUALANDTHEREALWORLDBECOMEFUZZYINCREASINGTHE SENSEOFVICTIMIZATIONTHATISINPARTBASEDONTHEIMAGINARYANDTHE MYTHICALCOMPARISONOFTHESELFWITHOTHER-USLIMSOUTOFCULTURAL CONTEXT4HENEWELECTRONICMEDIALARGELYFACILITATESDECONTEXTUALIZA TIONMYTHOLOGIZATIONAND FORTUITOUS IDENTIlCATIONS *IHADISMHAS BECOMETHEICONOFAMODERNANTI MODERNITYTHATBLURSTHEFRONTIERS BETWEEN LIFE ANDDEATH IN THE SAME FASHION AS THE BOUNDARIES ARE DIMMEDINTHECYBERWORLDBETWEENTHEREALANDTHEVIRTUAL
!NEWGENERATIONOF*IHADISTSISONTHERISEHARDLYSOCIALIZED THROUGHTRADITIONAL)SLAMICCHANNELSBEARINGTHEIRGRUDGEAGAINSTTHE 7ESTOR-USLIMSOCIETIESBYFOCUSINGTHEIRFRUSTRATIONSONIMAGINARY ENEMIES ACQUIRING THEIRWARRIOR CULTURE THROUGH THE )NTERNET AND VIDEOGAMESANDSEEKINGREVENGEAGAINSTAWORLDWHEREITISEASIERTO FEELLIKEAVICTIMTHANLIKEANACTORPARTICULARLYINTHE-USLIMWORLD POPULATEDWITHTYRANTSANDAUTOCRATS4HEYTURNTHEIRSPITEAGAINST !MERICATHISSYMBOLOFARROGANTSUCCESSINAWORLDWHERE-USLIMS AREMOREOFTENONTHELOSERSSIDETHANONTHEWINNERS!MERICASFECK LESSPOLICYTOWARDTHE-IDDLE%ASTCOMBINEDWITHTHESEARCHFORA SCAPEGOATFOR-USLIMSFAILURESINSOCIALANDPOLITICALDEVELOPMENT MAKESTHE5NITED3TATESTHEIDEALENEMYFORTHE*IHADISTS
.OTES
