The Transmission of Jihad to the West

ONLYCULTURALCONNECTION7HENTHEYDOSPEAKITMANYHANDLETHE REGIONALLANGUAGESOFTHEIRPARENTSINASUPERlCIALMANNERBUTAREIN GENERALUTTERLYUNABLETOREADORWRITEIT!RABICDIALECTSAREDIFFERENT FROMTHEWRITTENFUSHAH !RABICOFTHE+ORAN/NTHEWHOLETHE GAPBETWEEN-IDDLE%ASTERNRELIGIOUSLEADERSAND%UROPEAN-USLIM YOUTHISDEEPANDTHELATTERLEARNABOUT)SLAMTHROUGHMEANSOTHER THANOFlCIALMOSQUES4HISISNOTTHECASEFORSELF PROCLAIMEDIMAMS ANDCHARISMATICLEADERSOFSMALLCULTICGROUPSTHATPROCLAIM*IHADAS THEMAINGOALOF)SLAM

-OST%UROPEAN-USLIMSINVOLVEDIN*IHADISMINTHE7ESTHAVE ARATHERRUDIMENTARYLEVELOF)SLAMICKNOWLEDGEUNLIKEMANYOFTHEIR COUNTERPARTSINTHE-USLIMWORLDWHOKNOWMUCHMOREABOUT!LLAHS RELIGION*IHADISTPEOPLEINTHE7ESTARETHEMOREEASILYRADICALIZEDAS THEIRKNOWLEDGEOF)SLAMANDITSTRADITIONSARESKETCHYEVENNONEXIS TENT)N&RENCHPRISONSMOSTOFTHEINMATESMORETHANPERCENT WHO CLAIMEDTOBEFOLLOWERSOF!LLAHSRELIGIONWEREUNABLETORECITEDAILY PRAYERSIN!RABICOREVENTOPERFORMTHERITUALSOFPURIlCATIONWOZOU BEFORETHEDAILYPRAYERSSALAT ACCORDINGTOTHERELIGIOUSPRESCRIPTIONS 4HEIR)SLAMICCULTUREWASALMOSTNIL4HEYHADVAGUENOTIONSABOUT THEPROHIBITIONSAGAINSTALCOHOLPREMARITALSEXANDEATINGPORKAND RELIGIOUSLYNONAUTHORIZEDMEATHARAM ASWELLASABOUTWOMENSVEILING ANDAFEWOTHERTOPICSRELATEDTO)SLAMBUTOTHERWISETHEYKNEWLITTLE ABOUTIT"ESIDESTHEIRLIMITEDRELIGIOUSKNOWLEDGEADEEPRESENTMENT TOWARDGLOBALSOCIETYWASTHEIRCOMMONDENOMINATOR

&OR THOSE INDIVIDUALS FROM THE POOR SUBURBS OR GHETTOES OF &RANCEAND%NGLANDHATREDTOWARDSOCIETYANDIGNORANCEOF)SLAM MAKE*IHADISMINANAPPARENTPARADOXEASIER IT ISENOUGHTHATA FEWEXALTEDINDIVIDUALSBRANDISH*IHADAGAINSTINlDELSINORDERTOlND ANATTENTIVEEARAMONG THEMh)NlDELvEQUALS%UROPEANS &RENCH %NGLISH$UTCHETC WHOTREAT-USLIMSINARROGANTDOWNGRADING STIGMATIZING)SLAMOPHOBICANDSOMETIMESRACISTWAYS(YPER SECULAR %UROPEHASMADERELIGIONANDINPARTICULAR)SLAM EVENLESSUNDER STANDABLETOSECOND ANDTHIRD GENERATION-USLIMSWHOAREFORTHE MOSTPARTCULTURALLYUPROOTEDEVENAMONGPARTOFTHE-USLIMMIDDLE CLASSES4HEIRPARENTSORGRANDPARENTSWHOSERELIGIONWASRITUALISTIC HADNOCAPACITYTOIMPARTITTOTHEIROFFSPRING&ORTHISREASONNEW GENERATIONSRECEIVEVERYLITTLE)SLAMICEDUCATIONTHROUGHTHEFAMILY ANDEVENLESSTHROUGHTHESCHOOLSYSTEM4HEYARELEFTTOTHEMSELVES FULLOFRANCORTOWARDSOCIETYANDWITHLITTLECAPACITYTOGRASP)SLAMIC CULTURE OR HISTORY IN ITS RELIGIOUS AND CULTURAL DIVERSITY4HEY ARE GULLIBLEPREYFORTHElRSTCOMERWHOEQUATES)SLAMWITH*IHADTAKING REVENGEAGAINSTASOCIETYWHERE-USLIMSAREDESPISEDORATBESTIGNORED ANDAREMOSTLYSECOND CLASSCITIZENS

%VENTHOSE%UROPEANCOUNTRIESTHATONCEHADASENSEOFRELIGION %NGLAND)TALYAND'ERMANYFOREXAMPLE HAVEBEENDEEPLYSECULAR IZEDINTHELASTTWODECADES.EW%UROPEANGENERATIONSARELOOKING FORANEWSENSEOFRELIGIONBUTTHEIRMIND SETISONTHEWHOLEMUCH MORESECULARTHANTHATOF!MERICANSINGENERAL/NEMAJORDIFFERENCE BETWEEN%UROPEANAND!MERICANhWHITEv-USLIMSIS THAT-USLIM !MERICANSAREMOSTLYMIDDLE CLASSWHILETHEIR%UROPEANCOUNTERPARTS ARETYPICALLYFROMWORKING CLASSBACKGROUNDS

)N&RANCEWHERETHEHIGHESTNUMBEROF-USLIMSLIVEINASINGLE 7EST%UROPEANCOUNTRYBETWEENFOURANDlVEMILLION ANDWHERETHE PROPORTIONOF-USLIMSTOTHEGLOBALPOPULATIONISONEOFTHEHIGHEST AROUNDPERCENT THEPROBLEMOFRELIGIONISEVENMOREACUTEBECAUSE OFTHELAÆCIT£SYSTEM4HERIGIDSEPARATIONOFCHURCHANDSTATEPREVENTS THESTATEFROMGIVINGANYDIRECTHELPTO-USLIMSGENERALLYLOWERCLASS ORLOWERMIDDLECLASS !HYPER SECULARPUBLICISOPPOSEDTOTHEhVIS IBILITYvOF)SLAMINTHEPUBLICSPHERETHE)SLAMICSCARFISCONSIDERED ANICONOF&UNDAMENTALISMBYALARGEMAJORITYOFCITIZENS-OREOVER THEPROBLEMOFPOORSUBURBSBANLIEUES MAKESh!RABSvTHE&RENCHOF .ORTH!FRICANORIGIN SECOND CLASSCITIZENSINTHOSEGHETTOES

7ITHIN THESE SUBURBS ANUNDERGROUND ECONOMY TAKES SHAPE THATREPRESENTSLARGElNANCIALASSETSANESTIMATEDNINETYBILLIONEUROS AYEARAROUNDPERCENTOFTHE&RENCH'$0/RGANIZEDNETWORKS WITHINGANGSOPERATEINPOORSUBURBS4HECAÆDShBIGSHOTSv INTHE SUBURBSOF0ARIS,YON-ARSEILLE4OULOUSE"ORDEAUXAND3TRASBOURG ARETHENEWlGURESOFLOCALMAlAS&ORMENIALJOBSMANYYOUNGMEN OFTHEBANLIEUESAREHIREDWORKINGNOTONLYWITHDRUGSBUTWITHALL TYPESOFPRODUCTSILLEGALLYIMPORTEDMAINLYTHROUGHTHESOUTHERNPORT OF-ARSEILLEBUTALSOTHROUGHMANYOTHERBORDERCITIESIN&RANCE!S MANYASlVEMILLIONPEOPLELIVEINTHEPOORSUBURBSANDTHEIRLIVELI HOODISINPARTDETERMINEDBYTHIShPARALLELECONOMYv

)NTHESESUBURBSTHENUMBEROFLOWER INCOMEPEOPLEWHOPAY NOTAXESISMORETHANPERCENTOFTHEPOPULATIONCOMPAREDTO PERCENTIN&RENCHCITIES4HERATEOFJOBLESSNESSISMORETHANDOUBLE THENATIONALAVERAGE4WENTYPERCENTOFCHILDRENINPOORSUBURBSHAVE HEALTHPROBLEMSANDTHEGAPBETWEENTHECITIESANDTHEIRPOORSUBURBS HASLARGELYINCREASEDINTHEPASTDECADE4HESCHOOLSYSTEMPARADOXI CALLY INCREASESTHESEGREGATIONEFFECTTHROUGHTHESTIGMATIZATIONOF THELOCALSCHOOLSWHICHCHILDRENOFPOORDISTRICTSATTENDWITHAHIGH RATEOFFAILURE5RBANSEGREGATIONINTURNPACKSINJOBLESSANDLESS EDUCATEDPEOPLE)NTHEGHETTOESATYPICALSLANGDEVELOPSANDSOCIAL CONTROLISIMPOSEDTHROUGHETHNICITYANDGROUPCONTROL

)NFACTPOORSUBURBSBANLIEUESCIT£SZONESSENSIBLESANDMORE RECENTLYGHETTOES ARESPECIlCTO&RANCEINMANYRESPECTS)N'ERMANY

MOSTOFTHESECOND ANDTHIRD GENERATIONMIGRANTSOF4URKISHORIGIN LIVEINOLDWORKING CLASSDISTRICTSBUTARENOTASSEGREGATEDFROMTHE TOWNANDTHECITYASINHABITANTSOFTHEBANLIEUESIN&RANCE4HE4URKISH ORIGINOF'ERMANMIGRANTSMAKESTHEMMORECOMMUNITY CENTERED WITH SOCIAL BONDSBETWEEN THEMEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITYBEING PRESERVEDANDCOOPERATIONAMONGTHEMBEINGMUCHSTRONGERTHAN AMONG.ORTH!FRICAN&RENCHINTHEBANLIEUES#ONTRARYTO&RENCH .ORTH!FRICANSOR%NGLISH0AKISTANISOR"ANGLADESHIS'ERMAN4URKS HAVENOCOLONIALPASTTHATWOULDHEIGHTENTHEIRSENSEOFINFERIORITY &RENCHOF!LGERIANDESCENTAREUNEMBEDDEDFROMTHEIRCOMMUNITIES ANDTHEIRFAMILIESHAVETYPICALLYBEENMOREDISBANDEDTHANTHEIR4URK ISHCOUNTERPARTS4HESAMEHOLDSTRUEINREGARDTO*IHADISTACTIVITIES 4URKISHCOMMUNITIESINTHE7ESTAREMORE&UNDAMENTALISTINTHEIR CREEDTHANTHEOTHERSPARTICULARLY!LGERIANSBUTTHEREARENTNOTABLE *IHADISTACTIVITIESAMONGTHEMCONTRARYTO.ORTH!FRICANCOMMUNI TIESIN&RANCEANDMOREGENERALLY%UROPEIN3PAINTHE-OROCCAN COMMUNITYANDIN%NGLANDAND)TALYASWELL AND0AKISTANICOMMU NITIESIN%NGLAND"ANLIEUESTHATAREPERIODICALLYSETABLAZEIN&RANCE PARTICULARLYINBUTALSOINWITHTHOUSANDSOFCARSBURNED EACHYEAR DONOTSEEMANY4URKISHYOUTHINVOLVEDTHEIRMAINACTORS BEING.ORTH!FRICANSBLACKSANDSOME&RENCHMIDDLE CLASSYOUTH WHOTAKEPARTINTHEDESTRUCTIONASIFTHEYWEREFESTIVITIES

/NTHEWHOLEBANLIEUESAREA&RENCHPECULIARITYRELATEDTOTHE HIGH CONCENTRATION OF POOR PEOPLE THE SEGREGATION PROCESS AND THESUBJECTIVERELATIONTOTHECOLONIALPASTINTHEDAILYLIFEOFYOUNG h!RABSv 3OMEOF THESE GHETTOES ARE THEATERS OF RADICALIZATION AND *IHADISM3OMELIKE,YONSAND0ARISSSUBURBSHAVEALONGHISTORY OFRADICALIZATIONlRSTINTHENAMEOFTHEIRSECULARCLAIMTOCITIZEN SHIPANDTHENINTHENAMEOF)SLAM4HE*ACOBINCENTRALIZEDNATURE OFTHE&RENCHSTATEMAKESITSIDENTIlCATIONASTHECHIEFENEMYEVEN EASIERTHANINTHEFEDERALSYSTEMIN'ERMANYORINTHE%NGLISHPOLITI CALSYSTEMWHERECONSIDERABLEDEGREESOFAUTONOMYAREGRANTEDTO COMMUNITIES

)NTHEBANLIEUESYOUNGMALESARECAUGHTUPBETWEENTHREEPOSSI BILITIESBEINGNOONEECONOMICALLYEXCLUDEDANDSOCIALLYSTIGMATIZED PARTICIPATINGINTHEUNDERGROUNDECONOMYANDADOPTINGMIDDLE CLASS LIVINGSTANDARDSRISKINGPRISONTERMSANDALIFEBEHINDBARSASRECIDI VISTSANDBECOMING-USLIM'ENERALLYSPEAKINGADOPTING)SLAMASA WAYOFLIFEANDARELIGIONHASAMODERATINGEFFECTONTHEYOUNG-US LIMSWHOLEARNMORALATTITUDESTOWARDSOCIETYTHROUGH!LLAHSRELIGION EGPROHIBITIONSONSTEALINGANDDRINKINGALCOHOL )NAMINORITYOF CASES)SLAMIZATIONHASBEENSYNONYMOUSWITHRADICALIZATION)SLAM HASBEENCOMBINEDWITHTHEUNDERGROUNDECONOMYFORTHESAKEOF

*IHADINSOMECASES4HEhNORMALvIDENTITYOFTHEYOUNGPEOPLEMORE ANDMORECAUGHTUPBETWEENMAlASANDAGGRESSIVEPOLICE HASBEEN TOADOPTAVINDICTIVEATTITUDETOWARDSOCIETYALLMENINUNIFORMARE REJECTEDlRElGHTERSASWELLASBUSDRIVERSANDPOLICEOFlCERS THE IDENTITYISMOSTLYCIRCUMSCRIBEDWITHINTHEDISTRICTOREVENTOTINY PARTSWITHINTHEDISTRICTˆSOMETIMESJUSTAFEWBLOCKSINAQUARTIER 4HENORMSARE THATOF THEhGHETTOvANDSMALLGANGS IMPOSETHEIR RULESˆATLEASTATNIGHT

)SLAMIC FUNDAMENTALISM ANDWITHIN A TINYMINORITY )SLAMIC RADICALISMAREDEVELOPINGASRESPONSESTOASITUATIONTHESEYOUNGMEN PERCEIVEASHOPELESS4HEIRONLYPLAUSIBLEOPTIONSAREEITHERDEVIANCEBY PARTICIPATIONINTHEUNDERGROUNDECONOMYORSELF ENCLOSUREINARIGID IDENTITYWITHINCLOSE KNIT)SLAMICGROUPSTHATHAVEALIFEOFTHEIROWN WITHMODERATINGEFFECTSONTHECONDUCTOFTHEIRMEMBERSREDUCING VIOLENCEHELPINGTHEMBEATPEACEWITHTHEIRIDENTITYCURBINGCONSUM ERISMANDTHEDESIRETOBEPARTOFTHECONSUMERSOCIETYANDSOFORTH 3TILLWITHINTHE&UNDAMENTALISTFRAMEWORKTHEREAREAWIDEVARIETYOF ATTITUDESTHATDEVELOPINREACTIONTOTHEUTTERLYSECULARENVIRONMENT &ORSOMEOFTHESEBORN AGAIN-USLIMS!LLAHSRELIGIONISMOREATTRACTIVE BECAUSEPEOPLESEEITASDANGEROUS)SLAMICRADICALISMINTHISSENSEIS INPARTTHERESULTOFASOCIALPROCESSINWHICHVICTIMIZATIONhTHEREIS NOFUTUREv ISCOMBINEDWITHTHEATTRACTIONOFARADICALRELIGIOUSVIEW THATREJECTSSOCIETYASIMPURE&UNDAMENTALISM ORlGHTSITASBEING AGAINST)SLAM*IHADISTS 6ICTIMIZATIONISCONTRADICTEDBYREALITYSIZE ABLEMINORITIESOFh!RABSvSUCCEEDINTHEIRSOCIALANDECONOMICLIFE ANDBECOMEMIDDLE CLASS&RENCHEVENTHOUGHMANYOFTHEMHAVEA LOWER MIDDLE CLASSBACKGROUND"UTTHISDOESNOTPREVENTTHEMAJORITY OFMALEh!RABSvFROMPOORGHETTOESTOCONSIDERTHEMSELVESWITHOUT AFUTURE6ICTIMIZATIONCLOSESEVENTHENARROWENTRYINTOSOCIETYBY DISCOURAGINGANYATTEMPTATINTEGRATIONWITHINTHELARGERSOCIETY

4HECASEOFTHE&RENCH*IHADISTSMOSTLYOFTHELOWERCLASSESOR THELOWERENDOFTHEMIDDLECLASSESCANBEEXTENDEDTO3PAINAND %NGLAND )N THECASEOF THE3PANISHCELL THAT COMMITTED THE TRAIN BOMBINGSOF-ARCHTHEMAJORITYBELONGEDTOTHELOWEROR LOWER MIDDLECLASSESANDHADALOWLEVELOFEDUCATION-OSTOFTHEM WERE FROM.ORTH!FRICA MOSTLY-OROCCO THEMAJORITY OF THEM RESIDINGLEGALLYIN3PAIN

*IHADIST.EO 5MMAORTHE0OLITICSOF6ICTIMIZATION

&UNDAMENTALIST ANDHYPER &UNDAMENTALIST CIRCLES IN%UROPEHAVE DEVELOPEDAVIEWOFTHE5MMATHATISVERYDIFFERENTFROMTHATHELD

BYTRADITIONAL)SLAMICCOMMUNITIES4HE&UNDAMENTALIST5MMAISA COMMUNITYBASEDONTHEIDENTITYOFCULTURALLYUPROOTEDPEOPLEWHOSE RELIGIOUSSOCIALIZATIONISNOTACHIEVEDWITHINTHEFAMILYBUTTHROUGH &UNDAMENTALISTASSOCIATIONSTHATPROVIDETHERELIGIOUSEDUCATIONTHAT ISOTHERWISELACKING2ELIGIONSERVESTOINSTILLAMORALCODEOFCONDUCT INTHEPEOPLEWHOHAVENOTINTERNALIZEDTHEETHICALCODEOFSOCIETY THROUGHTHESCHOOLSYSTEMANDTHEFAMILY

&ORMANY YOUNGPEOPLE )SLAM IS A SUBSTITUTE FOR THE FAILING %UROPEANSECULARCODEOFETHICS)NTHISRESPECTRE )SLAMIZATIONOF SECOND ANDTHIRD GENERATION-USLIMMIGRANTSMAKESMOSTOFTHEM BETTER CITIZENS LAW ABIDINGOUT OF RESPECT FOR THEIR RELIGION RATHER THANFEAROF SECULAR LAWS&ORA SECONDGROUP)SLAMISAMEANSOF LEGITIMIZINGVIOLENTOPPOSITIONTOGLOBALSOCIETY-ANYYOUNGMENOF THESEPOORDISTRICTSGENERALIZETHEIMAGEOFTHEIRVICTIMIZATIONTOALL OFHUMANITY4HEYCOMMISERATEWITH0ALESTINIANYOUTHSUFFERINGTHE EFFECTSOFTHEIRUNEQUALlGHTAGAINSTTHE)SRAELIARMYBYCOMPARINGIT TOTHEIROWNSUFFERINGASh!RABSvIN&RENCHGHETTOES4HESAMEHOLDS FORh0AKISvSECOND ORTHIRD GENERATION%NGLISHOF0AKISTANIORIGIN WHODENOUNCE THEMISDEEDSOF%NGLISH SOCIETY ANDPOLICE AGAINST THEMBYREFERRINGTOTHEILLTREATMENTOF+ASHMIRISATTHEHANDSOF THE )NDIANARMY6ICTIMIZATIONOF THE SELF EXTENDS THE FRONTIERSOF SUFFERINGTOOTHER-USLIMSCONSIDEREDASOPPRESSEDMEMBERSOFTHE GLOBAL)SLAMIC5MMA

6ICTIMIZATION BRINGS-USLIMS TOGETHERWITHIN AN IMAGINARY COMMUNITYWHERESUFFERINGISTHEPARAMOUNTFEATURE"OSNIA)RAQ !FGHANISTAN0ALESTINE#HECHNYAETC$ISAFFECTEDYOUTHEXTENDTHEIR OWNMENTALAGONYTOOTHERPARTSOFTHEWORLDTHEIRTASKBEINGFACILITAT EDBY46ANDTHE)NTERNETWHICHBROADCASTVIVIDLY-USLIMSUNEQUAL lGHT4HERELATIONSHIPWITHTHISNEO 5MMAISNOTAhCOLDvONEASIT USEDTOBEAMONGPEOPLEWITHINTHEHIERARCHICTRADITIONAL5MMA &UNDAMENTALISTSINTHENEO 5MMACREATEINTHEIRIMAGINARYWORLD EGALITARIANCOMMUNITIESWHERE-USLIMSSUFFERFROMTHEMISCHIEFOF 7ESTERNERSTHROUGHILLEGITIMATEDOMINATION4HISNEO 5MMAISON THEOTHERHANDCHARACTERIZEDBYTHELACKOFANYCULTURALSPECIlCITY )TISSOLELYAhRELIGIOUSvCOMMUNITYDEVOIDOFANYPECULIARCULTURE ANDREPRODUCINGINIDEALTERMSTHE5MMAOFTHE0ROPHETINWHICH 0ERSIANS3ALMANTHE0URETHElRST0ERSIANCONVERTTO)SLAM !RABS SLAVESTHE%THIOPIAN"ILAL ANDMENANDWOMENLIVEDINHARMONY

(AVINGNOSPECIlCCULTURETHENEO 5MMAISABOVEALLCULTURES TRANSCENDINGTHEMALLDISCONNECTINGTHERELIGIOUSNORMSANDDUTIES FROMANYCULTURALSETTINGANDREJECTINGTHOSEFEATURESIMPOSEDON %UROPEAN-USLIMSBYTHEIRHOSTCOUNTRIES4HE%UROPEANCULTURES INWHICHTHEYGREWUPAREILLEGITIMATEBECAUSETHEYARETHEMEANS

OFSTIGMATIZATIONRATHERTHANINTEGRATION-OSTOFTHEh!RABSvTHAT IS&RENCHOF.ORTH!FRICANORIGIN IN&RANCEANDh0AKISv%NGLISH OF0AKISTANIORIGIN IN"RITAINDONOTMASTERTHE LANGUAGEOFTHEIR PARENTSAND SPEAK INSTEAD%NGLISHOR&RENCHWITHAN IDENTIlABLE ACCENT4HENEWCULTUREHASBECOMEFORTHEMASTIGMARATHERTHAN ABRIDGETOTHEIRFELLOWCITIZENSANDTHEYEXPRESSTHEIRPAINTHROUGH MUSICTHUSAVOIDINGPHYSICALVIOLENCEBYTRANSCENDINGANDSUBLIMAT INGITINARTˆNEW&RENCHRAPORHIP HOPINWHICHVERBALVIOLENCEIS FREQUENT2AIAMIXTUREOF!LGERIANAND&RENCHMUSICOR"RITHOP THE"RITISHVERSIONOFHIP HOPGIVINGBIRTHTONEWTYPESOFREGGAE ACCOMPANIEDBYBREAKDANCING3OMETIMESTHEVERYSAMEMUSICIS PUTATTHESERVICEOF*IHAD4HE/UTLANDISHA$ENMARK BASED-US LIM RAP CREW THATHASBEENGAININGWORLDWIDE FAME IS COMPOSED OFA-OROCCANA(ONDURANANDA0AKISTANI4HEYHAVEPRODUCED MILITANTSONGSAMONGWHICHISh'UANTANAMOvINWHICHTHEYDE NOUNCETHE!MERICANWARIN)RAQ4HEYPRACTICEAhSYMBOLIC*IHADv &URTHERMORESOMELOWER MIDDLE CLASS-USLIMSJOINEXCLUDEDYOUTH INTHEIRPAINTHROUGHPSYCHOLOGICALIDENTIlCATIONALTHOUGHTHEYARE ECONOMICALLYINTEGRATED4HEYLEADGROUPSOFFRAGILEYOUTHTO*IHAD USINGALLCULTURALMEANSATTHEIRDISPOSALWRITINGMUSICORSPORTS FORTHEPROMOTIONOFHOLYWAR

!NOTHERCHARACTERISTICOFNEO 5MMAISITSTRANSNATIONALOUTLOOK DISTINCTFROMTHECUSTOMARY5MMA.EO 5MMAISATBESTAMINOR ITYPHENOMENONAMONG-USLIMSINTHE7EST*IHADISTNEO 5MMAIS TRIUMPHANTANDCONQUERINGINITSREPRESENTATIONOFITSRELATIONSHIP WITHOTHERRELIGIONS(YPER &UNDAMENTALISTSSHARETHISFEATUREASWELL (IZBU4AHRIR IN%NGLAND INTENDS TO CREATE A CALIPHATEWORLDWIDE WITH%NGLANDBECOMINGA-USLIMCOUNTRYINTHEFUTURE)TSPOLICIES TOACHIEVETHISGOALAREPEACEFULCONTRARYTOTHE*IHADISTSBUTOTHER WISETHEINTENTSANDPURPOSESARETHESAME(YPER &UNDAMENTALISTS ASWELLAS*IHADISTSSEEKWORLDCONQUESTTHEFORMERCHOOSINGTOPLAY THEDEMOCRATICROLETHELATTERREJECTINGPEACEFULWAYSANDPROMOTING VIOLENT*IHADASTHEONLYWAYTOACHIEVETHATEND

*IHADISTNEO 5MMA ISPURITANICAL TO THEEXTREME4RADITIONAL 5MMAREJECTEDCONSUMPTIONOFALCOHOLANDINVOLVEMENTINUSURY RIBA LENDINGWITH INTEREST RATES ORGAMBLINGBUT TOLERATED THOSE PRACTICES INPRIVATEUNDERTHEHEADINGh!LLAHCOVERSUPTHEFAULTSv 3ATTARALUYUB *IHADISTSINTENDTOPENETRATEDEEPLYINTOBELIEVERS SOULSANDIMPOSEONTHEMFROMWITHINRELIGIOUSCOMMANDMENTS ANDPROHIBITIONS)NTHISRESPECTTHEYAREMOREhMODERNvSINCETHEY REFERTOTHEFAITHFULSCONSCIENCEANDORDAINSTRICTOBEDIENCETOTHE INTERDICTIONSDECREEDBY!LLAH,IKEMANYEXTREMISTMOVEMENTSIN THE7ESTTHEYDONOTHAVETHETOLERANCEOFTRADITIONALGROUPS4HEY

REJECTCOMPROMISEANDMODERATIONANDCALLITJAHILIYAGODLESSNESS -ORERESTRICTIVEHOLISTICANDPURITANICALTHANCUSTOMARY-USLIMS *IHADISTSlGHTFORAN)SLAMTHATISNOTEMBEDDEDINDIASPORACULTURE ANDTHEREFOREDENIESITS7ESTERNORIGIN4HEIRRELIGIONISADOUBLEDE NIALPUTINTOASACREDIDIOMTHEYREJECTTHECULTUREOFMIGRANTFAMILIES ASWELLASTHATOFTHE7ESTERNWORLDINSEARCHOFANEWIDENTITYTHAT lNDSITSCALLINGINANAGONISTICUNIVERSALISMEXTENDEDTOTHEENTIRE WORLD7ORLD*IHADISWORLDIDENTITY

.EO 5MMAPOLITICIZES )SLAM TO THE EXTREME ENCOMPASSING JURIDICALLEGISLATIVEANDEXECUTIVEPOWERS"ESIDESTHE0ROPHETSRULE IN-EDINAn ANDTHOSEOFTHE&OUR7ELL 'UIDED#ALIPHS THE-USLIMWORLDHASNEVERBEENPOLITICALLYUNIlEDORSTRICTLYRULED ACCORDINGTO!LLAHSLAWS4HEIDEAOFANEXCLUSIVELY)SLAMICRULESHARED BY3HIITERADICALSTHE6ELAYAT&AQIHOF+HOMEINI AND3UNNI*IHADISTS (AKIMIYABY-AWDUDIANDLATER1UTB ISARATHERLATEPHENOMENON LINKEDTOTHEMODERNIZATIONOF-USLIMSANDINREACTIONTOSECULARIZA TIONWITHIN-USLIMCOUNTRIESWHERESOCIALCHANGEOCCURREDWITHOUT DEMOCRATIZATION(AKAMIYAASWELLAS6ELAYAT&AQIHAREALSOINSPIRED BYTHEEXAMPLEOFTHEVERYSAMEDESPOTICGOVERNMENTSWITHSECULAR LEADERSIN-USLIMCOUNTRIESWHICHIMPOSEDAMOREAUTOCRATICRULE ON)SLAMICSOCIETIESTHANTHETRADITIONALONESWHICHWEREMOREIN ACCORDANCEWITHTHECOMMUNITYANDGENERALLYMORERESPECTFULTOWARD ITSCUSTOMSEVENTHOSEPREDATING)SLAM

-ODERNSTATESBEIT!TATÓRKS4URKEY2EZA3HAHS)RANMILITARY 0AKISTANAND!LGERIAOR.ASSERS%GYPT HAVEDEEPLYINmUENCED-USLIM RADICALSINTHEIRCONCEPTIONOFTHENEW)SLAMICGOVERNMENTINWHICH GOVERNORSHAVEALMOSTABSOLUTEPOWERINTHENAMEOF)SLAMTHEYARE CALLEDEMIRSIMAMSANDCALIPHSBYTHE*IHADISTSAND&AQIH)SLAMIC REVOLUTIONARYLEADERAND6ALI&AQIHBYRADICAL3HIITES 4HEOCRATIC RULEPROPOSEDASANALTERNATIVETOSECULARRULEINTHE-USLIMWORLD ISINCONTINUITYWITHTHE*ACOBINAUTOCRACYOFDESPOTICGOVERNMENTS &ASCIST GOVERNMENTS IN%UROPEBETWEEN THE TWO7ORLD7ARS ALSO INSPIRETHEM&ASCIST%UROPEANPOLITICALPARTIESINSPIREDTHESECULAR "ATHISTPARTIESIN3YRIAAND)RAQANDTHEYINTURNLEFTTHEIRIMPRINT ONTHE)SLAMICRADICALSWHOFOUGHTTHEM

4HENEO 5MMADOESNOTMEANARETURNTO)SLAMICTRADITIONBUT INGENERALITREPRESENTSAREGRESSIVEBUTMODERNREJECTIONOFSECULAR MODERNITYINTHENAMEOFAMYTHICALTRADITIONLARGELYREINVENTED)T REPRODUCESMANYBIASESOFAUTHORITARIANSECULARGOVERNMENTSINTHE -USLIMWORLDACCENTUATINGSOMEOFTHEMWHILEINTENTONRE )SLAMIZ ING THROUGH VIOLENCE-USLIM SOCIETIES THAT HAVE BEEN FROM THEIR PERSPECTIVEATTHEMERCYOFTHE7ESTANDLEDASTRAYBYhDEPRAVEDv SECULARIZERS)NTHE7ESTERNWORLD*IHADISTSPUSHTOWARDASYSTEMTHAT

NOTONLYPUTSANENDTOTHERULEOFh#RUSADERSvBUTALSOCONVERTSTHEM TO)SLAMSOASTOIMPOSE!LLAHSRELIGIONALLOVERTHEWORLD*IHADISM INTENDSASWELLTORE )SLAMIZE-USLIMDIASPORASDE )SLAMIZEDBYTHEIR SOJOURNINTHE7EST

)NMANY%UROPEANCOUNTRIESTHERATEOFSECULAR-USLIMSINTHE SECONDANDTHIRDGENERATIONSISMOVINGCLOSERTOTHATOFOTHERGROUPS WITHTHEEXCEPTIONOFAMINORITYOF&UNDAMENTALISTGROUPSWHICH EXISTALSOWITHINOTHERRELIGIONSIN%UROPE %VENTHOUGHFORSOME SOCIOLOGISTS-USLIMSAREASPECIlCCASEIN%UROPEANDDONOTSECULAR IZEALONGSIDEMAINSTREAM%UROPEANTRENDS*IHADISTSINGENERALREGARD THEEVOLUTIONOF-USLIMSIN%UROPEANDTHE5NITED3TATESASLEADING THEMASTRAYOF)SLAMPERVERTINGTHEMTHROUGHARAMPANTSECULARIZA TIONˆTHUSBRINGINGCORE-USLIMSCLOSERTO7ESTERNERSDULLINGTHEIR SENSEOFHOLYWARANDPREPARINGTHEMAJORITYOFTHEFAITHFULFORPEACE FULCOEXISTENCEWITH7ESTERNUNBELIEVERS4HENEO 5MMAPRESCRIBES ATASKTOBRINGDIASPORA-USLIMSBACKTOTHEGENUINEFAITHANDPUSH THEMTOWARD*IHADAGAINSTTHE7EST)NTHISRESPECTTHENEO 5MMAS IDENTITYISEXCLUSIVEOFANYOTHER

)NTHETRADITIONAL-USLIMWORLDRELIGIOUSIDENTITYEXISTEDSIDE BYSIDEWITHETHNICTRIBALANDREGIONALIDENTITIES!LTHOUGH)SLAM EXCLUSIVELY PROMOTES RELIGIOUS IDENTITY THIS NEVER HAPPENED IN ITS HISTORY4RIBALALLEGIANCETHESO CALLEDASABIYAWASDEPICTEDBYTHE )SLAMICGRANDFATHEROFSOCIALSCIENCES)BN+HALDUNn AS THEDECISIVEELEMENTINTHEFORMATIONOFEMPIRESIN)SLAM)NTHELATE NINETEENTHANDTWENTIETHCENTURIESNATIONALISMSUPERSEDEDRELIGIOUS IDENTITYBUTITSFAILUREIN-USLIMCOUNTRIESRESULTEDINTHERESURGENCE OF )SLAMIC RADICALISMˆTHIS TIME AS AN EXCLUSIVE IDENTITYMAKING )SLAMIC FAITH THE SOLEGROUND FORANY LEGITIMATECLAIMSOFPOLITICAL BELONGING4HEMONOPOLIZINGOF)SLAMIC IDENTITYONEOFTHEMAIN FEATURESOF-USLIM&UNDAMENTALISMAND*IHADISMISINFACTATHEO CRATICVERSIONOFNATIONALISMEXTENDEDTOTHEENTIRE)SLAMIC5MMA ASWELLASARELIGIOUSREACTIONAGAINSTTHEVIOLENCEEXERTEDBYHARSH SECULARIZATIONFROMABOVEAGAINST-USLIMCULTURES&OREXAMPLETHE CASEOF)RANSFORCEDUNVEILINGOFWOMENBY2EZA3HAHINTHES BECAMEONEOFTHESIGNSOFTHE0AHLAVIDYNASTYSANTI )SLAMICNATURE AMONGITSOPPONENTS

!CCORDINGTOTHE*IHADISTSTOREALIZETHENEO 5MMA-USLIMS HAVETOINDULGEINVIOLENCEAGAINST7ESTERNERSEVENIFTHEYAREBORN ANDRAISEDTHERE)N*IHADISTATTACKSIN-ADRIDINAND,ONDON INANDTHATWOULDHAVEBEENTHECASEIN'ERMANYINIF THEBOMBSHADEXPLODED THENUMBEROFTHOSEKILLEDTHROUGHINDIS CRIMINATEEXPLOSIONSWASSOHIGHASTORAISETHEQUESTION(OWCOULD THEYKILLTHEIROWNFELLOWCITIZENS4HEANSWERISTHAT*IHADISTSREJECT

THEIR%UROPEANCITIZENSHIPANDBECOMEINVOLVEDINANEO 5MMATHAT ISEXCLUSIVEOFSUCHCITIZENSHIP/THERCITIZENSBECOMETHEIRENEMIES ANDSPILLINGTHEIRBLOODIFITSERVESTHEIRCAUSEISNOTONLYTOLERATED BUT ALSO COMMENDED THROUGH THIS RADICAL INTERPRETATIONOF )SLAM *IHADISTS DONOT SYMPATHIZEWITH PEOPLE OUTSIDE THE NEO 5MMA WHICHTHEYARESUPPOSEDTOCREATEBYBEINGSELF PROCLAIMEDVANGUARDS OFTHEWORLD*IHAD

!NOTHER FEATURE OF THE NEO 5MMA IS ITS EXTENSION THROUGH MODERNFORMSOFCOMMUNICATIONTOTHEENTIREWORLD"EFOREMOD ERNIZATIONNEWSWOULDNOTREACH-USLIMSFORMONTHSANDSOMETIMES EVEN YEARS EACH REGION BEINGDE FACTO SEPARATED FROM THE OTHERS EVENWITHIN-USLIMEMPIRES!TTHETIMEOFCOLONIZATIONNEWSWAS SPREADTOTHEMODERNWORLDBYJOURNALISTSANDTHETELEGRAPHBUTTHE -USLIMWORLDWASSTILLMARGINALIZEDBECAUSEMOST-USLIMSCOULDNT READ"EGINNINGINTHESTHENUMBEROF-USLIMSBEINGSCHOOLED ANDlNDINGTHEIRWAYINTOTHEUNIVERSITIESBEGANTOSWELL7ITHTHE PROLIFERATIONOFSCHOOLSANDMODERNUNIVERSITIESINTHE)SLAMICWORLD INTHEFOLLOWINGDECADES-USLIMSHAVENEVERBEENASWELLEDUCATED ANDAWAREOFTHEWORLDASTHEYARETODAY

4HENEO 5MMAISTHECONSCIOUSNESSOFTHE-USLIMCOMMU NITYEXTENDEDTOTHEFURTHESTFRONTIERSOF)SLAMTHROUGHRADICALIZED GROUPS4HENOTIONOFTHEWORLDWIDE-USLIMCOMMUNITYISNOLON GERANABSTRACTONECONlNEDTOTHESACREDTEXTSORTHE+ORAN)THAS BECOMEABODYOFBELIEVERSBASEDONTHEAWARENESSOFNEW-USLIM &UNDAMENTALISTSAND*IHADISTS3OMEONELIKETHESOLDIERANDTHEYOUNG INTELLECTUAL5YAYRIKILLEDBY3AUDIFORCESINSTREETlGHTSINSEES THISREALITYCLEARLYREFERRINGTOITSDIFFERENTPARTSFARFROMEACHOTHER THROUGHDIFFERENTREGIONSANDCONTINENTS

)NTHISTIMEOFWEAKNESSINWHICHWECURRENTLYlNDTHE5MMAFROM THE+UFR;HERETIC=DICTATORSINCHARGEOVERTHEIRAFFAIRSTOTHESITUATION IN0ALESTINEWHERE*EWSHOLDSWAYOVER-USLIMSANDWHEREWESEE THEDAILYSLAUGHTEROFOURBROTHERSTOTHESITUATIONIN!FGHANISTAN WHERE#HRISTIANSHAVETAKENAUTHORITYKILLINGTHOUSANDSOFINNOCENT -USLIMSˆTHUSREVEALINGTHEIRTRUEANIMOSITYANDHATREDTOWARD THERELIGIONOF)SLAMANDITSPEOPLEˆTOTHE!THEISTIC2USSIANSAND THEIRAUTHORITYOVER-USLIM#HECHNYATOTHEWORSHIPPERSOFTHE COW;THATIS(INDUS=ANDTHEIRCRIMESCOMMITTEDAGAINST-USLIMS IN)NDIAAND+ASHMIRTOTHECAPTIVITYOF-USLIMCHILDRENATTHE HANDSOF$ISBELIEVERSˆAND THERE IS NO CHANGEORPOWER EXCEPT THROUGH!LLAH ITHASNOWBECOME INCUMBENTUPON-USLIMS TO RETURNTOTHE3HARIAH;)SLAMICRULINGSANDGUIDANCE=OFTHEIR,ORD ANDTOKNOWWHATDUTIES(EHASPRESCRIBEDUPONTHEM)TISKNOWN

THATKNOWLEDGEPERTAININGTOMATTERSOF3HARIAHISANOBLIGATION UPONALL-USLIMS,IKEWISETOACTUPONTHISKNOWLEDGETOOISAN OBLIGATION*IHADISONEOFTHERULINGSTHATHASESCAPEDTHEMINDOF -USLIMSSOMUCHSOTHATSOMEOFTHEMHAVEEVENFORGOTTENTHAT THEREISSOMETHINGKNOWNAS*IHADIN)SLAMWHILSTOTHERSWHOTALK ABOUT*IHADAREUNAWAREABOUTITSJURISPRUDENCE

&ORTHElRSTTIMEINTHEIRHISTORY-USLIMSHAVEBECOMECON CRETELYAWAREOFTHEIRBELONGINGTOTHESAME5MMAEXTENDINGTOALL CONTINENTSMAINLYTHROUGHMODERNCOMMUNICATIONSINTHEHANDSOF AMINORITYOFRADICALIZEDBELIEVERS4HELATTEREXPLOIT-USLIMSMALAISE BYEMPHASIZINGTHEIRMEMBERSHIPINTHEWORLDWIDENEO 5MMADE lNEDASAhSUFFERING5MMAvATPERPETUALWARWITHUNBELIEVERS)TIS THROUGH*IHADISTSTHAT-USLIMSHAVEMASSIVELYBECOMECONSCIOUSOFA UNIVERSAL)SLAMICCOMMUNITYTHATCANACTGLOBALLYMAINLYTHROUGHVIO LENCE0REVIOUSLYTHEIRSENSEOFBELONGINGWASABSTRACTANDWEAKENED THROUGHTRIBALANDREGIONALALLEGIANCES)FWECOMPARETHEDECLARATION OF*IHADBYTHE/TTOMAN3ULTANINTHE&IRST7ORLD7ARAGAINSTTHE !LLIES5NITED+INGDOM&RANCEANDTHE5NITED3TATES ANDITSVERY LIMITEDRESULTSINMOBILIZING-USLIMSEVENTHOUGHTHE'ERMANGOV ERNMENTMADEAGREATEFFORTTOSPREADITALLOVERTHE-USLIMWORLD WITHTHEMUCHMORESUCCESSFUL*IHADISTACTIVISMNOWADAYSWECLEARLY SEETHEDIFFERENCESBETWEENTHETRADITIONAL5MMAANDTHENEO 5MMA 4ODAYMOST-USLIMSHAVEACCESSTOTHEMEDIAANDTHEYAREALSOBET TEREDUCATEDTRIBALANDETHNICDIVISIONSARENOTASPOWERFULASINTHE PAST AND THE SENSEOFBELONGING TO THE SAME-USLIMCOMMUNITY MISTREATEDANDATTACKEDBYTHE7ESTISMUCHMOREPOWERFULTHAN EVER.OWBELONGINGTOTHENEO 5MMAISSUBJECTIVELYWITHINREACHAND OBJECTIVELYACHIEVABLEMAINLYINADESTRUCTIVEMANNER*IHADISMISTHE EXPRESSIONOFTHENEWIMAGINEDGLOBAL)SLAMICCOMMUNITYPOLITICIZED WORLDWIDE4HISTYPEOFMOVEMENTEVOLVESONLYINTHE)SLAMICWORLD THEREISNOSIMILARMOVEMENTIN#HRISTIANITYORANYOTHERUNIVERSAL BODYTHATWOULDBRINGSUCHAVISIONSOCLOSETOITSWORLDWIDESYMBOLIC EXPRESSIONMAINLYTHROUGHVIVIDIMAGESOFhAPOCALYPSENOWv

4HE2OLEOF(UMILIATION

4HEMAJOR SYMBOLIC INGREDIENT OF *IHADISM IS THEPREVALENCE OF A SUBCULTUREOFINDIGNITYANDINTERNALIZEDHUMILIATIONAMONGALARGE MAJORITYOF-USLIMS4HE*IHADISTINTELLECTUAL5YAYRISUMMARIZESIT ELOQUENTLYh-USLIMSAREATWARTODAY7HATDISTINGUISHESOURTIME FROMOTHERTIMESISTHEHUMILIATIONANDTHECONTEMPTSUFFEREDBYTHE 5MMAWHICHWASUNHEARDOFINTHEPAST!TTHESAMETIME-USLIMS

AREINASTATEOFLETHARGYANDANEMIAWAHN INSTEADOFMOBILIZING ANDlGHTINGAGAINSTTHISHUMILIATION4HEREISA3AYINGOFTHE0ROPHET ATTRIBUTINGANEMIATOTHELOVEOFTHISWORLDANDTHEAVERSIONOFDEATH )NANOTHERVERSIONOFTHESAME3AYINGITISTHEAVERSIONAGAINSTlGHT INGQITºL THATISUNDERSCORED.OWADAYSTHISISTHEDEADLYILLNESSOF WHICHTHE-USLIMWORLDSUFFERSv

"ESIDESITSMILITARYANDPOLITICALDIMENSIONSHUMILIATIONHAS ADEEPCULTURALASPECTUNDERLINEDBY5YAYRI RELATED TO-USLIMS HONORh;-USLIM=WOMENOF@YESTERDAYBROUGHTUPMENWHOBE CAMEMASTERSOFTHEREALMSOF$ISBELIEVERSBUT;-USLIM=WOMENOF @TODAYBREEDMENWHOARESLAVESTOWORSHIPPERSOFCOWSTONETREE AND#ROSS ;#HRISTIANS= AND ARE HUMILIATED BY THEMv7OMENS BEHAVIORVILIlES-USLIMMENWHOKOWTOWTOWORSHIPPERSOFTHE COWS IN )NDIA AND OTHER HERETICAL COUNTRIESWITHWHICH-USLIM GOVERNMENTSHAVEESTABLISHEDDIPLOMATICANDECONOMICTIES STONE "UDDHISTSIN4HAILANDANDELSEWHERE ANDTHE#ROSS#HRISTIANS 4HEREMEDYPROPOSEDBY5YAYRIISTHEREADINESSTODIEINANALL OUT WAR INITIATEDBY THE7EST4HEOCCURRENCEOF THEWORDhHUMILIA TIONvINTHE*IHADISTDISCOURSEISVERYFREQUENT3TILLHUMILIATIONIS NOTAMONOLITHICCATEGORYANDTHEREISAMAJORANTHROPOLOGICALAND POLITICALDIFFERENCEBETWEENHUMILIATIONINTHE-USLIMWORLDAND HUMILIATIONIN%UROPE

/NECANDISTINGUISHTHREEMAJORKINDSOFHUMILIATION4HElRST TYPEPHYSICALANDINDEPENDENTOFCULTUREISRELATEDTODIRECTVIOLENCE 4HEPHYSICALMISTREATMENTOF#HECHNYANSBYTHE2USSIANS+AHSMIRIS BYTHE)NDIANSOR0ALESTINIANSBYTHE)SRAELISARECASESINPOINTNOTED BYMANY-USLIMSINTHE-USLIMWORLDANDEVENIN%UROPE"ODY SEARCHESORCOLLECTIVEPUNISHMENTSAGAINSTTHEPOPULATIONENGENDER ASENSEOFDIRECTANDINTOLERABLEHUMILIATION4HESAMEHOLDSTRUE IN)RAQBY!MERICANANDLESSOFTEN"RITISHSOLDIERSEGATTHE!BU 'HRAIBPRISONDURINGTHElRSTYEARSOFTHE)RAQIWAR 4HEFACTTHAT THOSEWHOIMPOSETHISTYPEOFHUMILIATIONAREhOCCUPYINGFOREIGNERSv EXPONENTIALLYINCREASESITSEFFECT/BVIOUSLYTHEFEELINGACCOMPANYING THISFORMOFHUMBLINGISNOTSPECIlCALLY)SLAMIC"UTTHESENTIMENTOF ABASEMENTISTRANSLATEDINTOARELIGIOUSFRAMEWORKINlDELSDEMEAN -USLIMSANDAREDISRESPECTFULOF!LLAHSRELIGION

7HEN-USLIMSWERENOTMODERNIZEDTHISATTITUDEWASINTER PRETEDASMUTUALMISTREATMENTIMPOSEDBYENEMIESAGAINSTEACHOTHER .OWTHATMODERNIZATIONHASCHANGED-USLIMSMENTALFRAMEWORK VIOLENCEBYAFOREIGNENEMYMILITARILYSUPERIORANDRELIGIOUSLYDIF FERENTENTAILSANOTHERCONSEQUENCETHEENEMYNOTONLYINTENDSTO VANQUISH-USLIMSBUTWANTSTODESTROY)SLAMITSELFWITHTHEAIMOF UPROOTING!LLAHSRELIGIONˆNOTSIMPLYTOlGHTAGAINSTSPECIlCGROUPS OF-USLIMS4HISATTITUDEPARADOXICALLYISLESSCHARACTERISTICOFTHE

PEOPLEWHOAREEXPOSEDTODIRECTHUMILIATIONINTHEIRCONFRONTATION AGAINST OCCUPYING ARMIES 0ALESTINIANS#HECHNYANS )RAQIS+ASH MIRIS ANDMOREOFTENSEENAMONGOTHER-USLIMSWHOTHROUGHNEW MEDIAANDCOMMUNICATIONNETWORKS INTERPRETTHISHUMILIATIONAS INTENDEDTOUPROOT-USLIMSFROMTHEFACEOFTHEEARTH(UMILIATION BECOMESVICARIOUSITISFELTANDINTERNALIZEDBYPROXYˆBY-USLIMS ALLOVERTHEWORLD

2ADICALIZATIONOCCURSTHROUGHTHEENCOUNTEROFTHISSECONDKIND OFHUMILIATIONHUMILIATIONBYPROXYAMONGTHOSE%UROPEAN-USLIMS WHOLIVEINSITUATIONSOFSTIGMATIZATION!MONGTHEMSOMEGROUPS DEVELOP A SUBCULTURE OF SELF ESTRANGEMENT AND INDIGNITY2ACISM REMNANTSOFCOLONIALPREJUDICEAND)SLAMOPHOBIAACTIVELYCONTRIBUTE TOTHISFEELINGBYPROVIDINGITWITHOBJECTIVESUPPORT4HESE-USLIMS BELIEVETHATTHEYAREREJECTEDASCITIZENSANDEVENBELIEVETHATTHEYARE CONSIDEREDINFERIORHUMANBEINGS!DEEPSENSEOFSELF VICTIMIZATION DOMINATES THEM AND THEIR FEELING OF DISAFFECTEDNESS IS INTENSIlED BY SPATIAL SEGREGATION GHETTOES INPOOR SUBURBS ORPOORDISTRICTS ANDTHEIRHISTORICALBACKGROUNDTHEIRPARENTSIMMIGRATEDASMENIAL WORKERSANDTHEYBELONGEDTOFORMER%UROPEANCOLONIESWITHTHE NOTABLEEXCEPTIONOFTHE4URKS %UROPESRACISMCERTAINLYEXISTSBUT ISNOTASABSOLUTEASTHISVISIONOFSELF VICTIMIZATIONIMPLIESIFONLY BECAUSEPARTOFTHEVERYSAMEPOPULATIONSUCCEEDSWITHALOTOFPAIN INJOININGTHEMIDDLECLASSES4HESUBCULTUREOFINTERNALIZEDINDIGNITY RESULTS INANABYSMALSENSEOFHELPLESSNESSANDLACKOFSELF ESTEEM WITHVICTIMIZATIONLEADINGTOWITHDRAWALINTOTHEIMAGINARYWORLD OFESTRANGEMENT

)SLAMINITSEXTREMISTVERSIONINVERTSTHEVECTOROFVICTIMIZATION &ROMTHEPREDICAMENTOFAVICTIMTHENEW*IHADISTACTORINTENDSTO TRANSFORMTHEOTHERTOAVICTIM(EBREAKSDOWNTHEBARRIERSOFCON lNEMENTINTOINDIGNITYDECLARINGTHEOTHERINHUMAN$EATHLOOMS LARGEINTHISMETAMORPHOSIS4HE%UROPEANhINlDELvISHUMILIATEDBY THE*IHADISTWHOIMPOSESONHIMTHEULTIMATEORDEALCONFRONTATION WITHDEATH4HE%UROPEANBECOMESINFERIORBECAUSEHEFEARSDEATH UNLIKETHE-USLIMWHOISFEARLESSANDACCEPTSDEATHASAMARTYR4HE FORMERISACOWARDWHEREASTHELATTERISVALIANT$EATHTRANSFORMSTHE -USLIMSSITUATIONFROMhSLAVEvTOhMASTERv4HE7ESTERNERISSUPERIOR MILITARILYANDECONOMICALLYHEISINFERIORWHENCONFRONTINGTHETEST OFDEATH!BSOLUTEVICTIMIZATIONISSUBDUEDBYREDUCINGTHEOTHERTO THESITUATIONOFABSOLUTEVICTIM7ITHINTHISFRAMEWORKMARTYRDOM INITSSYMBOLICMEANINGISTHEPROCESSOFMOVINGTHEVICTIMIZEDTO THEENVIEDPOSITIONOFVICTIMIZER4HISTRANSFORMATIONCONFERSANEW DIGNITYANDASENSEOFPRIDETHATARETHEOPPOSITEOFTHEFORMERINDIG NITYANDLOWSELF REGARD

(UMILIATEDANDCONTEMPTUOUSOFHIMSELFBEFOREHISRELIGIOUS METAMORPHOSISTHENEW*IHADISTBECOMESTHESUBJECTWHOIMPOSES SYMBOLICHUMILIATIONONOTHERS IN THENAMEOFHIS FAITHWITHIN A CONTEXTMARKEDBYADEEPANTAGONISMTOWARDSOCIETY(UMILIATIONIS THEMOREINTENSIlEDASDISAFFECTED-USLIMSBELIEVETHATTHEIRQUALMS ARETHESAMEASTHOSEOFTHE0ALESTINIANS+ASHMIRISOR#HECHNYANS 7EWITNESSANIMAGINARYCONSTRUCTIONOFAGLOBALDE CONTEXTUALIZED HUMILIATIONTHEHUMILIATIONOFTHEFORMER0ALESTINIANS+ASHMIRIS #HECHNYANSETC HASNOTHINGTODOWITHTHATOFTHEGHETTOYOUTHIN &RANCEOR%NGLAND3TILLTHEIMAGINATIONOFTHENEO 5MMABUILDSUP THISTYPEOFABASEMENTANDPOSTULATESANEQUIVALENCEBETWEENTHESE DIFFERENTEXPERIENCES4HERESULTONCE*IHADISMISINTERNALIZEDISAN ALL OUTWARAGAINSThDISBELIEVERSv

!THIRDTYPEOFHUMILIATIONISNOTABLYDIFFERENTFROMTHETWO OTHERS THE DIRECT AND THE VICARIOUS AND SUPPOSES SOME ROOTS IN )SLAMIC CULTURE )N THEHISTORY OF )SLAM THE RELATIONSHIPWITH THE h0EOPLEOFTHE"OOKv#HRISTIANSAND*EWS ANDTHOSEWHOHAVETIES TOMONOTHEISM:OROASTRIANS HASBEENCONmICT RIDDEN!LATE+O RANICTEXTENJOINS-USLIMSTOCOERCEBOTHTHESEGROUPSSOTHATTHEY AGREETOPAYANINDIVIDUALTAXJIZYAH hWITHHUMILIATIONv 4HE STATUSOFTHEDHIMMI#HRISTIANSAND*EWSUNDER-USLIMPROTECTION ANDRULE WASINFERIORIN-USLIMEMPIRESANDTHEIRRELATIONSHIPWAS BASEDON THE SYMBOLIC REITERATIONOF HUMILIATION SO AS TO REMIND THEMOFTHESUPERIORITYOF)SLAM-ODERN*IHADISTSHAVEBORROWED THISTENETFROMHISTORICAL)SLAMANDAIMATHUMILIATINGhINlDELSvIN THENAMEOFTHESUPERIORITYOF!LLAHSRELIGIONTOALLOTHERS/NCEBE COMING*IHADISTSTHEFORMERVICTIMIZED-USLIMSEMBODYTHISIDEAL OFHISTORICAL)SLAMWITHINTHE#HRISTIANWORLD)TSAPPLICATIONOUTOF THE)SLAMICCONTEXTDOESNOTSEEMTOTHEMAMAJOROBSTACLEBECAUSE HUMILIATINGTHE7ESTERNERISATTHESAMETIMECHANGINGTHEPOSITION OFTHEDOMINATEDINTOTHATOFTHEDOMINANT

4HESEDIFFERENTTYPESOFHUMILIATIONAREEMBEDDEDINASUB CULTUREOFVICTIMIZATIONTHATJUSTIlESALLEXCESSESINRESPONSETOTHE INTOLERABLEINJUSTICEAGAINSThDOWNTRODDENv-USLIMS-ORAL ISSUES BECOMEINSIGNIlCANTFOR*IHADISTSWHOCANCAUSEMASSIVEDEATHSIN THENAMEOFA LOFTY )SLAMIC IDEALDISCONNECTED FROM ITSHISTORICAL BACKGROUND*IHADISMINTHISSENSEISTHERESULTOFTHEMASSIVEDIS SOCIATIONOFTHECULTURESEMBEDDEDMORALCODEFROMRELIGIONINTE GRALLYSUPPORTEDBYGLOBALMEDIACOVERAGEOF-USLIMHUMILIATION THEIMAGESOF3EPTEMBERAREPARTANDPARCELOFTHESYMBOLICWAR AGAINSTTHEhARROGANT7ESTvBYTHESELF PROCLAIMEDKNIGHTSOF!LLAH

WHODEMEANTHEINlDEL/CCIDENTASMUCHTHROUGHTHEIRDEEDSAS THROUGHIMAGES

4HE6IEWSOF-USLIM0RISONERSIN%UROPE

)N STATEMENTS BY-USLIMPRISONERS IN%UROPE IT IS CLEAR THAT THE HUMILIATIONTHEYFEELINDAILYLIFEEXTENDSFROM%UROPETOTHE5NITED 3TATES4HESEPRISONERSINTERPRETEDTHE3EPTEMBERATTACKSINFEW DISTINCTWAYS

"ENAMARAGETWENTY SIXBELIEVESTHAT3EPTEMBERHASBEEN FALSELYATTRIBUTEDTO-USLIMSBYTHEMEDIACONTROLLEDBY*EWS3TILL HUMILIATIONPLAYSASIGNIlCANTROLEINHISMIND4HISEVENTHUMILIATED THE5NITED3TATESWHICHHUMILIATES-USLIMSALTHOUGH"ENAMARHAS COMPASSIONFORTHEINNOCENTPEOPLEWHODIEDINTHE4WIN4OWERSh)TIS THEMEDIAESPECIALLYHERE/N46THEYSAYITSTHE)SLAMISTS;WHOHAVE COMMITTEDTHE3EPTEMBERATTACKS=WITHOUTTHESLIGHTESTPROOF"IN ,ADENISANIDOLASTARFORTHEYOUNGPEOPLEATTHEMOMENTBECAUSE OFTHEMEDIA"UTTHE!MERICANSDESERVEIT4HEYTHINKTHEYRULETHE WORLD4HEYHAVEBEENHUMILIATED.OBODYISATANYBODYSBECKAND CALL"UTITSNOTGOODFORTHEINNOCENTPEOPLEWHODIED)TWOULD HAVEBEENBETTERIFTHEATTACKSHADTARGETEDTHEGOVERNMENT;BUILD INGS=!NDALLTHATCOMESFROM)SRAELAND0ALESTINE4HE*EWSCONTROL THEMEDIAANDTHEJUDICIARY7ELLTHEYDOWHATTHEYLIKEv

/MARAGE TWENTY lVEEXPLAINS THE3EPTEMBERKILLINGSAS THEREACTIONAGAINST!MERICANSKILLINGINNOCENTPEOPLEPARTICULARLY THE0ALESTINIANS

9OUSHOULDNTKILLINNOCENTPEOPLE4HE!MERICANSDOTHATTOTHE 0ALESTINIAN,IBERATION/RGANIZATIONANDIN!FGHANISTAN4HEYSELL THEIRTANKSTOTHE)SRAELISTOKILLTHE0ALESTINIANS"IN,ADENDOESNT DOALLTHATFORMONEY(ESALREADYRICH4HE!MERICANSMAKEPEOPLE HATETHEMWITHTHEIRPOLICIESANDWHAT"IN,ADENDIDWASNOTGOOD BUTHEISPAYINGTOO)TISBETTERTOATTACKTHEGOVERNMENT4HE53 DOESSERIOUSTHINGSINSECRETEVERYWHERE!LLTHESEPEOPLEHAVETO BEWOKENUPSOTHATTHEYWILLCOMETOKNOWTHEWHOLETRUTHAND MAYBETHEGOODIESAREREALLYTHEBADDIESORWORSESTILL4HEYLEFT THE-USLIMSIN"OSNIATODIEJUSTFORMONEY4HENWHENPEOPLEOF .ORTH!FRICANDESCENTGOTO!FGHANISTAN)SAYITISNORMAL9OUNG PEOPLE;-USLIMSIN&RANCE=DONTHAVEPLANSANYMORE4HEYDONT HAVEANYTHINGANYMORE4HEREAREPEOPLEWHOCOMETORECRUIT THEM4HEYAREGOODTALKERSANDPROMISETHINGSANDOFFTHEYGO 4HEYSACRIlCETHEMSELVES)TISRELIGION7EAREATTACKED7EHAVE

TOSTRIKEBACK4HEYARESLOWLYKILLINGUS!SMALLPARTOFITISRELI GIONBUTITISMOSTLYTHEANGERINSIDETHEMTHATMAKESTHESEYOUNG PEOPLELEAVEANDSACRIlCETHEIRLIVESIN!FGHANISTAN4HE46STIRS UPTHEHATRED4HEYSHOWTHEINJUSTICEEVERYDAYPOLITICIANSWHO ARENEVERIMPRISONEDDREADFULPICTURESANDITSNOTGOOD

4HE TWODIMENSIONS THE INTERNAL LIFE OF-USLIMS IN%UROPE AND THEEXTERNALLIFEOF-USLIMSADVERSELYAFFECTEDBY!MERICANPOLICIES ARETHUSJOINTLYANALYZED)N&RANCEMANYYOUNGh!RABSvSINCERELY ARECONVINCEDTHATTHEYHAVENOFUTUREANDHITHERTOTHEYHAVENO PLANS4HEYSEEIMAGESOF-USLIMSON46ANDTHEYAREEXPOSEDTO )SLAMISTRECRUITERS4HEYFEELTHATTHE!MERICANSAREhSLOWLYvKILLING -USLIMSEVERYWHERE4HEYGOTO!FGHANISTANWHERETHEYCANlGHT THEM!LTHOUGH/MARBELIEVESTHAT"IN,ADENSHOULDHAVEATTACKED GOVERNMENTBUILDINGS IN THE5NITED3TATES INSTEADOF CIVILIANSHE UNDERSTANDS!L1AEDASLINEOFCONDUCTIFNOTENTIRELYAPPROVESOFIT /MARDOESNOTDENYTHAT"IN,ADENMASTERMINDEDTHE3EPTEMBER ATTACKS(ElNDSTHEMATLEASTPARTIALLYLEGITIMATE(UMILIATION ISNOTDIRECTLYMENTIONEDBUTIMPLIEDWITHREFERENCESTOTHEFEELING OFBEINGhSLOWLYvKILLEDBYTHE7ESTERNERSTHE5NITED3TATESISTHE SYMBOLOFTHE7EST ANDTHEFACTTHAThYOUNGPEOPLEvAEUPHEMISM FOR&RENCH-USLIMSINTHEPOORSUBURBS HAVENOFUTURE

.ABIL AGE THIRTY ONE BELIEVES THAT THERE IS A DEEP RELATION BETWEENTHEHUMILIATIONFELTBYTHE-USLIMSANDTHE3EPTEMBER ATTACKS(EPARTICULARLYHASINMINDTHEPLIGHTOF-USLIMSAROUND THEWORLD4HEHUMILIATIONBYPROXYTHATHEFEELSINTHEIRSTEADISFOR HIMTHEKEYTOTHEATTACKSh)TISINJUSTICEWHICHISTHECAUSEOFTHESE ATTACKS)CANUNDERSTANDTHEKAMIKAZE0ALESTINIANS)WOULDNTDO THATBUT)UNDERSTANDTHEMANDTHEGUILTYONESARETHOSEWHOPUSHED THEMTODOTHAT!SFARASTHEATTACKSIN!MERICAARECONCERNED) AMSORRYFORTHEINNOCENTWHODIEDBUTITISAGOODTHINGTHATTHE !MERICANSWEREHUMILIATEDTHEINJUSTICEWHICHEXISTSIN0ALESTINE IN)RAQIN0AKISTANIN!FGHANISTANWONTCONTINUEFORLONG'ODWILL SEETOITv

4HECOMMONTHREADINTHESEINTERVIEWSISPRIMARILYTHE0ALES TINIANHUMILIATIONASIF"IN,ADENHADACTEDONTHEIRBEHALF.ABIL EXPRESSESTHEGENERALOPINIONONTHISMATTERADDINGTOITHISHATREDOF *EWSh&ORMETHEMOSTIMPORTANTTHINGIS0ALESTINE4HEREHAVE BEENTOOMANYMASSACRES&RANKLY)HATETHE*EWSˆITISJUSTTOOMUCH ALLTHAT"UT)LIVENEAR"ELLEVILLEIN0ARIS)TISA*EWISHAREAAND)HAVE *EWISHFRIENDSBUTWHEN)GETOUT;OFPRISON=)LLDITCHTHEMv

(UMILIATIONSPITERANCORANDRESENTMENTARETHEMAINCOM PONENTSOFTHISATTITUDETOWARDTHE5NITED3TATESANDMOREGENERALLY

THE7EST4HECOMBINATIONOFABASEMENTASA SECOND CLASSCITIZEN WITHNO FUTURE AMISTREATED VICTIMIZED-USLIM IN%UROPE WITH APROJECTIONONTOTHE7ESTTHROUGH!MERICATHE5NITED3TATESRE PRESSING-USLIMSINTHE-IDDLE%ASTANDELSEWHERE GIVESBIRTHTOAN IMAGINARY/CCIDENTATWARWITH)SLAM4HISSYMBOLICCONSTRUCTIONIS ATTHEROOTOFTHETACITSUPPORTTHATMANY-USLIMSBETHEYSECULAR IZEDORDEVOUTGIVETO*IHADISM)TSSUBSTRATEIS!MERICANPOLICYIN THE-IDDLE%AST

(UMILIATIONCANREACHPARANOIDDIMENSIONSWHENCOUPLEDWITH THEREBIRTHOFTHEINDIVIDUALTHROUGHHISADHESIONTO!LLAHSRELIGION !BROKENIDENTITYTHATlNDSHEALINGTHROUGH)SLAMANTAGONIZESTHE 7ESTERNERWHOINSULTSTHE-USLIMSSACREDFAITH!POEMWRITTENBY -OHAMMED"OUYERITHEASSASSINOFTHE$UTCHlLMDIRECTOR4HEO VAN'OGHWHOWASCRITICALOF)SLAMANDITSSUPPOSEDMISTREATMENTOF WOMENGIVESSOMECLUESTOTHISKINDOFRADICALISM"OUYERICOMPOSED HISPOEMh)NBLOEDGEDOOPTv$RENCHEDIN"LOOD IN$UTCHˆHISCOM MANDOF!RABICBEINGSKETCHYˆANDHADITINHISPOCKETWHENHEWAS ARRESTEDBYPOLICEJUSTAFTERHISMURDEROUSACTIN.OVEMBER

3OTHISISMYlNALWORD 2IDDLEDWITHBULLETS "APTIZEDINBLOOD !S)HADHOPED )AMLEAVINGAMESSAGE &ORYOUTHElGHTER 4HETREEOF4AWHIDISWAITING 9EARNINGFORYOURBLOOD %NTERTHEBARGAIN !ND!LLAHOPENSTHEWAY (EGIVESYOUTHE'ARDEN )NSTEADOFTHEEARTHLYRUBBLE 4OTHEENEMY)HAVESOMETHINGTOSAY 9OUWILLSURELYDIE 7HEREVERINTHEWORLDYOUGO $EATHISWAITINGFORYOU #HASEDBYTHEKNIGHTSOF$%!4( 7HOPAINTTHESTREETSWITHRED &ORTHE(YPOCRITES)HAVEONElNALWORD 7ISH$%!4(ORHOLDYOURTONGUEANDSIT $EARBROTHERSANDSISTERSMYENDISNIGH "UTTHISCERTAINLYDOESNOTENDTHESTORY

.EITHERh*IHADvNORhMARTYRDOMvAPPEARSINTHEPOEMBUT"OUYERI IMPLIESBOTH4HENOTIONOFAhBARGAINvWITH!LLAHTODIEIN(ISPATH ANDINEXCHANGEENTERTHEINNUMERABLEGARDENSOFPARADISEISPARTOF THETRADITIONALNOTIONOFMARTYRDOMDEVELOPEDBYSCHOLARSACCORDING TOTHE+ORAN(EIMAGINESHIMSELFRIDDLEDWITHBULLETSALREADYDEAD SIMILARTOTHEHOPESOFTHE)RANIAN3HIITEMARTYRSOF"ASSIJ3UNNI 0ALESTINIANMARTYRSANDMARTYRSOF!L1AEDA4HETRADITIONALPURE INTENTIONNIYYA THATWOULDJUSTIFYENTERINGPARADISEUPONONESHOLY DEATHISUNDERLINEDHEREASINTRADITIONAL)SLAM4HEIMAGEOFTHETREE OF4AWHID)SLAM WAITINGTOBESPRINKLEDBYTHEBLOODOFTHEMARTYR ALSOAPPEARSINTHECLASSICALMARTYRDOMLITERATUREOFTHE)RANIAN"ASSIJ THE0ALESTINIANSUICIDEBOMBERSANDMANYOTHER*IHADISTCANDIDATES FORHOLYDEATH(EREFERSTOTHEENEMYWHOMHETHREATENSWITHDEATH HISEXECUTIONBEINGTHETASKOFTHEhKNIGHTSOFDEATHvTHE-USLIM COMBATANTSOFHOLYWARMUJAHEDEEN 4HEPOTENTIALMARTYRWISHES TODIEANDTOIMPOSEDEATHONTHEADVERSARIESOF)SLAMTHISDEATH CENTEREDACTIONCHARACTERIZINGTHEIRRELATIONSHIP(EALSOWISHESDEATH ONTHEFAKE-USLIMSTHEh(YPOCRITESv

4HISPOEMWRITTENBYA-USLIMWHOSERETURNTORELIGIONBARELY DATESBACKTOADECADEPREVIOUSISSIMILARTO*IHADISTLITERATURE4HE TWO-USLIMWORLDMARTYRDOM LITERATURE AND%UROPEAN *IHADIST PAMPHLETSANDPOETRYUSETHESAMETHEMESIDEASMETAPHORSAND MOTIVES4HEYAIMATGOINGBEYONDANYSPECIlCNATIONALORCULTURAL FRONTIER4HEYREFUSEANYEMBEDDINGINASPECIlCCULTUREORSOCIETY TRANSCENDINGALLCULTURESTOWARDTHEATTAINMENTOFACULTURELESSRE LIGION THAT CROSSES ALL BOUNDARIES+ILLING THOSEWHO INSULT!LLAHS RELIGIONORITS0ROPHETSABB BECOMESARELIGIOUSDUTYTHATHASTOBE ACCOMPLISHEDBYTHE-USLIMASAPERSONALASSIGNMENTFARDHEYN IN CONTEMPTOFHUMAN MADELAW

"YINSULTING)SLAM4HEOVAN'OGHSLURSNOTONLY!LLAHBUT ALSOALLTHOSEWHOBELIEVETHATHEINTENDSTOHUMILIATETHEMTWICE -USLIMS ARE ALREADY IN THE HUMILIATED POSITION OF A DOMINATED FORMERLYCOLONIZEDPEOPLEWITHASTRANGLEDIDENTITYTORNBETWEEN TWO IMPOSSIBILITIES FEELING%UROPEAN &RENCH%NGLISH$UTCH OR BELONGINGTOTHECOUNTRYOFTHEIRPARENTSORGRANDPARENTS-OROCCO !LGERIA4UNISIA0AKISTAN 4HESEPEOPLEBELONGTONOWHEREANDTHEIR IDENTITYISNOTONLYDIVIDEDBUTBROKEN)SLAMHEALSTHEWOUNDOFTHIS PAINFULSPLITIDENTITYBYUNIFYINGITTHROUGHFOCUSINGONASINGLEISSUE ABIDINGBY!LLAHSLAWS#RITICIZING)SLAMISINTOLERABLYHUMILIATING SINCEITRECALLSTHEPREDICAMENTOFDENYINGONESIDENTITYINSULTING !LLAHSFAITHSENDSTHEBORN AGAIN-USLIMBACKTOHISFORMERSITUATION

OFNONIDENTITY(UMILIATIONREACHESPARANOIDLEVELSTHATCANHARDLY BEATTAINEDOTHERTHANINSECTARIANCLOSE KNITGROUPS

*IHADIST"ORN !GAIN-USLIMSAND#ONVERTS

*IHADISMINITS!L1AEDAVERSIONISTHElRSTTRULYTRANSNATIONALMOVE MENTWITHIN INTERNATIONAL TERRORISM!MONG ITSMEMBERS VARIOUS NATIONALITIES ARE PRESENT ANDMANYHAVEMULTIPLE CITIZENSHIPS AS %UROPEANS.ORTH!FRICANS-IDDLE%ASTERNERS!FRICANS)NDONESIANS !MERICANS#ANADIANSETC

/NEOFTHEEFFECTSOFTHE3EPTEMBERBOMBINGSISTHESEDUC TIONEXERTEDBY!LLAHSRELIGIONONMANYPEOPLEPARTICULARLYAMONG ETHNICMINORITIESINTHE7ESTANDIN,ATIN!MERICAAMONGINDIGENOUS PEOPLE4HERETURNTOh-OORISH3PAINv)SLAMIC3PAINBEFORETHE2E CONQUISTAACHIEVEDIN ISPARTOFTHEMYTHOFTHE-USLIMSAND SHAREDBYSOMEINDIGENOUSPEOPLEIN,ATIN!MERICA4HEYBELIEVETHAT #HRISTIANSIN3PAINDEFEATED-USLIMSINTHESAMEWAYASTHE3PANISH VANQUISHEDNATIVESIN3OUTH!MERICA4HESAME#ATHOLIC3PANISH REGIMECONQUERED,ATIN!MERICAANDVANQUISHED-USLIMS-OORS IN3PAIN"OTH-USLIMSANDINDIGENOUSPEOPLEWEREVICTIMSBOTH SHAREDTHELOTOFTHEUNJUSTLYDEFEATED4HISINDUCESWHATISCALLEDhTHE OTHER3EPTEMBEREFFECTvAMONGTHECONVERTEDASWELLASMEMBERS OFSOMEETHNICMINORITIESINTHE5NITED3TATESAND%UROPE!LTHOUGH IT ISDIFlCULT TOMEASURE THEEXTENTOF THEPHENOMENON THEREHAS PROBABLYBEENA TEMPORARY INCREASE IN THENUMBEROFCONVERSIONS TO)SLAMINBOTHTHE5NITED3TATESAND%UROPE2EFERENCESTO*OS£ 0ADILLA THESO CALLEDhDIRTYBOMBERvAND2ICHARD2EIDhTHESHOE BOMBERvBOTHCONVERTS TO)SLAMANDBOTHOFETHNICMINORITIES IN THE7ESTBECOMEICONIC

4HE hDOWNTRODDENv ARE ESPECIALLY ATTRACTED TO THIS BRAND OF )SLAM SYMBOLICALLY CONTESTING THEHEGEMONYOF THE hWHITEMANv "LACKS,ATINOS.ATIVE!MERICANS ANDEVEN3OUTH!SIANMINORI TIESSEEIN)SLAMTHEONLYEFFECTIVEREVENGEAGAINSTANARROGANT7EST AFTERTHEFALLOFTHE3OVIET5NION,ATIN!MERICANCONVERTSCONSIDER THEMSELVESCULTURALDESCENDANTSOFTHE-OORS4HISKINDOFIMAGINARY RELATIONSHIPISONEOFTHERESULTSOFCULTURALGLOBALIZATION)NTHESAME FASHIONAS&RENCH BORN!RABSBUILDUPIMAGINARYlLIATIONSWITH!F RICAN!MERICANSINTHEIRMUSICANDINTHEIRATTITUDESTOWARDhWHITEv &RENCHTHEYSOMETIMESCALLTHEMSELVEShGRAYv;GRIS=INCOMPARISON TOhWHITEv&RENCHAND"LACKSIN&RANCE ,ATINOCONVERTSDISPLAYA DElANTATTITUDETOWARDTHE7ESTBYEXPRESSINGTHEIRPRIDEIN3EPTEMBER PERFORMEDONTHEIRBEHALFBY"IN,ADEN

!MONG%UROPEAN*IHADISTSTWOCATEGORIESAREPARAMOUNTBORN AGAIN-USLIMSANDCONVERTS3OMETIMESTHEIRCASESARENOTDISSIMILAR 0ARTICULARLY IN&RANCEMANY YOUNG SECOND AND THIRD GENERATION PEOPLEOF.ORTH!FRICANDESCENTHAVEBEENBROUGHTUPINTOTALIG NORANCEOF)SLAM4HEIRRETURNTOITISSOMEHOWBETWEENTHEhBORN AGAINvANDTHEhCONVERTv

!MONG THE CONVERTS TO RADICAL )SLAMMANY TURN TO!LLAHS RELIGIONTOlGHTAGAINSTTHEIMPERIALIST7EST4HEYAREUSUALLYTORN BETWEENMULTIPLEIDENTITIES4HECASEOF#HRISTIAN'ANCZARSKI-USLIM NAME!BU)BRAHIM ISAGOODEXAMPLE&RENCHJURIDICALAUTHORI TIESINDICTEDHIMFORHISINVOLVEMENTINTHEATTACKONASYNAGOGUE IN$JERBA4UNISIA IN INWHICH TWENTY ONE TOURISTSWERE KILLED(EWASBORNININ0OLANDMOVEDTO'ERMANYWITHHIS PARENTSACQUIRED'ERMANCITIZENSHIPANDMARRIEDANDHEANDHIS WIFECONVERTEDTO)SLAM(ESPENTTIMEIN!FGHANISTANAND"OSNIA BECAMEACOMPUTEREXPERTWASCLOSETO"IN,ADENANDACCORDING TOSOME*IHADISTSARRESTEDGAVEINSULININJECTIONSTO"IN,ADEN(E BECAMEANIMPORTANTPERSONWITHIN!L1AEDA)NSPITEOFTHEFACT THAT!L1AEDASLEADERSHIPWAS!RABICPEOPLELIKE'ANCZARSKIREACHED HIGH LEVELPOSITIONS

(IS PROlLE IS NOT EXCEPTIONAL ROAMINGBETWEEN%UROPE AND THE-USLIMWORLDMULTICULTURALHEISONETYPEOF%UROPEAN*IHAD ISTCONVERTWHOENGAGESINAWARAGAINSTTHE7ESTINTHENAMEOFAN ANTI IMPERIALIST)SLAM4HEOTHERTYPEISTHE&RENCHOR%NGLISH*IHADIST WITHLITTLECULTURALKNOWLEDGEOF!LLAHSRELIGIONWHOGETSINVOLVED INHOLYWARTOTAKEREVENGEAGAINSTTHE7ESTWHEREHESUFFERSSTIGMA FROMHISNON %UROPEANCOLONIALBACKGROUND

/NECANTRYTOHAVEINSIGHTSINTOTHEMIND SETOFCONVERTSAND BORN AGAINSWITHINTHE*IHADISTMOVEMENTWHOAREFROMALLWALKSOF LIFEBYEXAMININGTHEIRBIOGRAPHIES

4HEFATEOF7ILLIE"RIGITTEA*IHADISTCONVERTISAGOODCASESTUDY (EWASBORNININ0OINTE Í 0ITREINTHE#ARIBBEANISLANDOF 'UADALOUPEA&RENCHOVERSEASTERRITORYAGETHIRTY EIGHTIN(E CONVERTEDTO)SLAMANDTOOKTHENAMEOF!BDEL2AHMANLIKEALMOST ALLCONVERTSWHOCHOOSEA-USLIMNAMETOMARKTHEIRNEWSYMBOLIC BIRTHTO)SLAM (ECAMEINTOCONTACTWITHRADICAL-USLIMSIN&RANCES POORSUBURBS)NHETRAVELEDTO9EMENANDTHENMADEAJOURNEY TO0AKISTANWHEREHESPENTMANYMONTHSINATRAININGCAMPINTHE 0UNJAB6ALLEY(ECAMEBACKTO&RANCEWHEREUPUNTILHESU PERVISEDTHETRAININGOFVOLUNTEERSWHOWANTEDTOGOTO!FGHANISTAN (EWENTTO!FGHANISTANAFTERTHE3EPTEMBERATTACKSANDFOUGHT AGAINST!MERICANFORCESTHERE(ETHENWENTTO!USTRALIAPROBABLYTO STUDYHOWTOBLOWUPANUCLEARREACTORIN,UCAS(EIGHTS!3ENEGALESE

FRIENDIN!USTRALIAINTRODUCEDHIMTOHISFUTUREWIFEAN!USTRALIAN WHOCONVERTEDTO)SLAM)TWASHISTHIRDMARRIAGE(EWASDEPORTED FROM!USTRALIATO&RANCEONCHARGESOFSTAYINGILLEGALLYIN!USTRALIA (EWASPROSECUTEDIN&RANCEFORHAVINGPROVIDEDCOUNTERFEITIDENTITY CARDSTOTHEASSASSINSOFTHE#OMMANDANT-ASUDIN!FGHANISTANTWO DAYSBEFORETHE3EPTEMBERATTACKS

"RIGITTES CASE LIKE THATOFMANY*IHADISTCONVERTS REVEALS THE DIVERSITYOFTHECONTACTSWITHDIFFERENTCOUNTRIESANDCULTURESTOWHICH CONVERTSAREEXPOSEDˆTHEEXISTENTIALEXPERIENCESTHEMARRIAGESAND FRIENDSHIPSWITHPEOPLEOFOTHERCULTURES"RIGITTEMARRIEDAN!USTRALIAN WOMANANOTHER*IHADISTHADA"OSNIANANDA*APANESESPOUSEBOTH CONVERTEDTO)SLAMUNDERHISINmUENCE THEVARIETYOFCOUNTRIESAND EVENCONTINENTSTHEYWENTTO!USTRALIA!FGHANISTAN0AKISTANAND &RANCEAMONGOTHERSINTHECASEOF"RIGITTE 4HESECONVERTSLOOKFOR ADVENTUREFORASTRINGENTFAITHTOWHICHTHEYCANDEVOTETHEIRLIVESAS DEDICATEDREVOLUTIONARYADEPTSCOMBININGPERSONALFAITHANDSOCIAL ANTI IMPERIALIST COMMITMENT4HEIR ANTI IMPERIALIST REVOLUTIONARY STANCEBORROWSMANYCONSERVATIVEFEATURESINPARTICULARINRELATIONTO WOMENBASEDONMANSSUPERIORITYINTHENAMEOFPATRIARCHAL)SLAM)N THEIRCASE)SLAMCOMBINESTHERIGIDITYOFTHEFAITHWITHAMALE CENTERED SEXUALETHICTHEYCANHAVEUPTOFOURWIVES ANDANTI IMPERIALISM

#ONVERT*IHADISTSPLAYASIGNIlCANTROLEIN*IHADISTGROUPSWHICH WELCOMETHEMPARTLYBECAUSEAS7ESTERNERSTHEYATTRACTLESSATTENTION THANNATIVE-USLIMSPARTLYBECAUSETHEMEDIAFOCUSONTHEMANDGIVE THEIRORGANIZATIONASYMBOLICWEIGHTANDPARTLYBECAUSETHEYARETHE PROOFOFTHELEGITIMACYOF*IHADSINCEASFORMER#HRISTIANSORSECULAR PEOPLETHEYWITNESSTOTHERIGHTEOUSNESSOF*IHAD4HEMEDIADEVOTE ALOTOFATTENTIONTOTHEMOUTOFFASCINATIONMIXEDWITHHORROR

/NEEXAMPLEISTHE!USTRALIANh*IHADI*ACKvAFORMERTAXIDRIVER (ISREALNAMEIS*OSEPH*ACK4ERRENCE4HOMAS(EWASTHIRTY THREE YEARSOLDINHEHADCONVERTEDTO)SLAMATTHEAGEOFTWENTY THREE(ECHOSETHENAMEh*IHADvWHICHISNOTUNCOMMONAMONG 3UNNI!RABSANDPOINTSTOTHEFACTTHAT*IHADBEARSAPOSITIVEMEAN INGIN)SLAMCONTRARYTOITSCONNOTATIONINTHE7EST(EMARRIEDA -USLIMWOMANOF!FGHANORIGIN!SARADICALIZEDCONVERTHEWENT TO!FGHANISTANIN-ARCHTOlGHTONTHESIDEOFTHE4ALIBAN(E METTHEREWITH!L1AEDALEADERSINCLUDING"IN,ADEN(EWASARRESTED ATTHE+ARACHIAIRPORTANDEXTRADITEDTO!USTRALIAIN.OVEMBER BEFOREBEINGINDICTEDFORTERRORISTACTIVITIES(EWASCONDEMNEDBUT FORLACKOFEVIDENCETHE#OURTRESCINDEDTHEJUDGMENT4HE!USTRALIAN JUSTICESYSTEMSTILLSUBMITSHIMTOMANYRESTRICTIONS

4HE FRONTIERSBETWEENORGANIZEDCRIMEAND *IHADISMARENOT WATERTIGHT,IONEL$UMONTISACASEINPOINT(EWASBORNIN

ONEOFTHEYOUNGESTAMONGEIGHTCHILDRENOFAMODEST#ATHOLICFAMILY IN4OURCOINGA&RENCHTOWNCLOSETOTHE"ELGIANBORDER(ElNISHED SECONDARYSCHOOLANDMADEHISMILITARYSERVICEIN$JIBOUTIWHEREHE WASVOLUNTARYPERSONNELIN3OMALIA(EWASINDIGNANTABOUT7ESTERN POLITICS INTHATREGIONANDONCEBACKIN2OUBAIXHEHAUNTEDTHE &UNDAMENTALISTMOSQUE$AWA(ECONVERTEDTO)SLAMINAND TOOKTHENAMEOF"ILALOR!BU(AMZA

)NHEWASTHELEADEROFAGROUPOFTENTHUGSFROM2OUBAIX hTHEGANGOF2OUBAIXvWHOHADCOMMITTEDHALFADOZENARMEDROB BERIESAGAINSTSUPERMARKETSBANKSANDVANSTRANSPORTINGFUNDSIN THEREGION4HEGROUPKILLEDADRIVERANDWOUNDEDTHREEPOLICEMEN ANDAN ESCORT FOR THE FUNDS TRANSPORTATION!RMEDWITHGRENADES MACHINEGUNSANDAROCKETLAUNCHERTHEYSHOTATTHOSEWHOBLOCKED THEIRWAY )N-ARCH THEPOLICEATTACKED THEHOUSE INWHICH MANYMEMBERS OF THE GROUP LIVED4HEY DIDNOT SURRENDER FOUR DIEDSERIOUSLYBURNEDANDTWOWEREGRIEVOUSLYWOUNDED"ELGIAN GENDARMESKILLEDANOTHERMEMBEROFTHEGANGDURINGAGUNlGHT!LL THEMEMBERSOFTHEGROUPHADFOUGHTAGAINSTTHE3ERBSIN"OSNIA WITHINTHERANKSOF THEh3OLDIERSOF)SLAMv)N THE$AYTON !CCORDSHADDIVIDED"OSNIA (ERZEGOVINAINTOTWOENTITIES*IHADISTS HADTOLEAVETHECOUNTRY

)N$UMONTWASARRESTED FORANARMEDATTACKANDCON DEMNED TO TWENTYYEARS IMPRISONMENT IN"OSNIABUTHEESCAPED PRISONIN-AYGOINGTO-ALAYSIATHEN)NDONESIA4HEREHEWAS ASSISTEDBYTHE*AMAA)SLAMIYAANORGANIZATIONINVOLVEDINTHE"ALI *IHADISTATTACKSINWHENMORETHANTWOHUNDREDPEOPLEDIED (ETHENWENTTO*APAN(ELIVEDTHEREFROM*ULYTO3EPTEMBER WITHHISSECONDWIFEA'ERMANOF0ORTUGUESEORIGINWHOHAD CONVERTEDTO)SLAM(EROAMEDBETWEEN3INGAPORE-ALAYSIAAND 4HAILANDGETTINGINTOUCHWITHOTHER*IHADISTS(EWASARRESTEDIN -UNICH'ERMANYIN3EPTEMBER&ORHISINVOLVEMENTINTHE 2OUBAIXMURDERSHEALREADYWASCONDEMNEDTOTHIRTYYEARSIMPRIS ONMENTBYA&RENCHTRIBUNALIN

$UMONTSCASEASINMANYOTHERSDISPLAYSTHEINCREDIBLEMIXTURE OFCULTURESASA&RENCHMANHEBECOMESA-USLIMMARRIESA"OSNIAN THENA'ERMANANDMOVESBETWEEN*APAN3INGAPORE-ALAYSIA)NDO NESIAAND"OSNIAENDINGUPIN'ERMANY 4HISISAGENERATIONTHATIS CAUGHTUPBETWEENMANYCULTURESANDCOUNTRIESWITH)SLAMBECOMING AMEANSTOTRANSCENDALLTHESECULTURESBYSUBORDINATINGTHEMTOA SACREDTRANSCULTURALIDENTITYTHATGOESBEYONDADISORIENTINGWORLD 4HESE-USLIMSAREMULTICULTURALMULTILINGUALLIVINGINAGLOBALIZED SOCIETYBUTIDENTIFYINGWITH)SLAMINPARTBECAUSETHEYDONOTACCEPT THE hGREY ZONEvCREATEDBYCULTURAL RELATIVISM THE TRANSITION FROM

MULTIPLEIDENTITIESTONOIDENTITYATALLISFREQUENT BUTALSOBECAUSE THEYSEENOALTERNATIVETO7ESTERNHEGEMONYINTHEPOST 3OVIETERA OTHERTHANRADICAL)SLAM

4HE SAMEPATTERN ROUGHLYHOLDS FOR ANOTHERMEMBER OF THE 2OUBAIXGANG#HRISTOPHE#AZE)NHISlFTHYEAROFMEDICALSTUDIES HEWENTTO"OSNIAFORHUMANITARIANREASONS(ECONVERTEDTORADICAL )SLAM)N:ENICARUMORSHADITTHATHEHADKILLEDANDTORTURED3ERBS /NCEBACKIN&RANCEHEPUSHEDHISFRIENDSTOJOIN*IHADISTGROUPS !FTERTHEENDOFTHEWARIN"OSNIAALONGWITH$UMONTANDOTHER FRIENDSMAINLYOF.ORTH!FRICANORIGINHEFOUNDEDTHEGANGOF2OU BAIX(EWASINTOUCHWITH!BU(AMZATHERADICALIMAMOF&INSBURY 0ARKWHOPROBABLYSENTHIMMONEYFROM,ONDON(EWASCONNECTED ASWELLTO&ATAH+AMELA&RENCH#ANADIANOF!LGERIANDESCENTWHOSE NETWORKWASCONNECTEDTO"IN,ADENSCAMPSIN!FGHANISTAN

4HEMULTINATIONALMULTICULTURALMULTILINGUALTIESANDNETWORKS ARETHERETOMAKEOUTOFTHESECONVERTSCITIZENSOFANEWWORLDIN WHICHTHEIRFAITHINAREVOLUTIONARY)SLAMSUPERSEDESALLCULTURESAND NATIONALPOLITICS)NITSNAMETHEYDECLAREOPENWARONTHE7EST4HE ANTI IMPERIALISTDIMENSIONOF)SLAMISPARAMOUNT)TSCAPACITYTOGIVE SENSEBEYONDANYDOUBTTOTHISlGHTINTHENAMEOF!LLAHMAKESIT THEMOSTCOMPREHENSIVEIDEOLOGYSATISFYINGEXTREMELEFTANDEXTREME RIGHTASPIRATIONSINANAGEOFSKEPTICISMANDSUSPICION)SLAMISALLAT ONCEAVISIONOFHOLINESSANDADOCTRINEOFSACREDWAR)TCASTSDOUBT OUTOFTHEMINDSOFTHEVERYSAMEPEOPLEWHOWEREBROUGHTUPAND EDUCATEDWITHINTHE7ESTERNWORLDOFDEMOCRACYCRITICISMANDhRE mEXIVITYvWHEREDOUBTANDUNCERTAINTYAREMAJORHALLMARKSOFTHE CULTURE4HEIRBELIEFINTHERELIGIONOF!LLAHMAKESDOUBTIMPOSSIBLE SKEPTICISMSINFULANDTHEREJECTIONOFTHE7ESTIRREFUTABLE)NTHIS RESPECT!LLAHSRELIGIONASSUMESANEWROLEMUCHBEYONDITSTRADI TIONALGARBOFUNSOPHISTICATEDANDUN MODERNAPPEARANCE)TSROLEIS ANALTERNATIVETOTHELINGERINGDOUBTANDSKEPTICISMINLATEMODERNITY INTHENAMEOFATRANSCULTURALIDEALOFUNIVERSALITY6IOLENCEISSEENAS ANANTIDOTETOTHE7ESTERNDIFFUSECULTUREOFNONVIOLENCEANDLEGAL ITYBASEDONhHYPOCRISYvANDhDUALITYvSOFTNESSANDDEMOCRACYON THEONESIDEBRUTALITYANDTHERULEBYANELITEOFIDOLWORSHIPPERS ONTHEOTHER

4HECASEOF(ERV£ $JAMEL,OISEAUISNOTEWORTHY(EISONEOF THElRSTCONVERTSWHOATTAINEDMARTYRDOMTHROUGH*IHADINTHE4ORA "ORA-OUNTAINSOF!FGHANISTANWHEREHEDIEDIN$ECEMBER TRYING TO ESCAPE!MERICANBOMBARDMENTS(ERV£,OISEAUBECAME $JAMELSINCEHISRETURNTO)SLAMASABORN AGAIN-USLIM(EWAS BORNIN0ARISIN-ARCHINTHEPOPULARDISTRICTOF"ELLEVILLEOF AFATHERFROM+ABYLIE!LGERIAANDA&RENCH#ATHOLICMOTHER(IS

PARENTSDIVORCEDWHENHEWASlVEANDHISFATHERDISAPPEAREDFROM SIGHT,OISEAUGREWUPINIGNORANCEOF)SLAMUNTILHISTWENTIES(ElRST JOINED4ABLIGHTHEMULTINATIONAL&UNDAMENTALISTANDPIETISTMOVE MENTTHATISDEEPLYROOTEDIN&RANCEANDHEWASEXPOSEDTO3ALAlST INmUENCETHROUGH.ORTH!FRICANMENTORS(EWENTTO3AUDI!RABIA WHEREHESEEMSTOHAVEMET3ALMANAL!WSAHTHESPIRITUALFATHEROF MANY3AUDI*IHADISTS/NHISRETURNFROM-ECCAINTHE&RENCH )NTELLIGENCE2ENSEIGNEMENTS'£N£RAUX ARRESTEDHIM(EWASFREED PENDINGTRIAL!TTHEBEGINNINGOFHEWENTTO,ONDONLATERmEW TO,AHOREANDFROMTHEREWENTTO!FGHANISTAN!YEARLATERHISDEAD BODYWASFOUNDIN4ORA"ORA

(ISCASEISAKINTOTHATOF:ACARIAS-OUSSAOUIINMORETHANONE RESPECT(EISBETWEENWHATMIGHTBECALLEDTHEBORN AGAIN-USLIM ANDTHECONVERT)NBOTHCASESPARENTSDIDNOTPROVIDETHEIRCHILDREN WITHANY)SLAMICCULTURE)NSTEADTHESEMENFOUND)SLAMTHROUGHRADI CALSTHEIRhCONVERSIONvBEINGANIMAGINARYRETURNTO)SLAMARUPTURE WITHCULTURALROOTLESSNESS4HEYBECAMETHEPREYOF*IHADISTPREACHERS WHOEASILYENROLLEDTHEMINTHEHOLYWARAGAINSTTHE7ESTTOWARD WHICHTHEYBOREAGRUDGEFORHAVINGFOUNDTHEMSELVESBETWEENTWO WORLDSINNEITHEROFWHICHTHEYFELTATHOME)N&RANCE-OUSSAOUIFELT HEWASAhDIRTY!RABvANDIN-OROCCOAhDIRTY&RENCHMANvTHESAME HOLDINGTRUEFORMANY.ORTH!FRICANSIN&RANCEEVENAMONGTHOSE RESULTINGFROMMIXEDMARRIAGES4HISISALSOTHECASEFORTHE%NGLISH OF0AKISTANIORIGININTHE5NITED+INGDOMWHOWIELDADENIEDDUAL IDENTITYNEITHER%NGLISHNOR0AKISTANI

)SLAMOPERATESALSOAGAINSTTHEDISORGANIZATIONOFDAILYLIFEAND THEMANYUNHEALTHY ENTICEMENTS TOWHICH PEOPLE ARE EXPOSED IN MODERNLIFELIKEDRUGORALCOHOLADDICTION4HE#OURTAILLERBROTHERS ARESYMPTOMATICAMONG*IHADISTCONVERTS$AVIDALIAS$AOUDHIS )SLAMICNAME ANDHISYOUNGERBROTHER*£R¯MEALIAS3OULEIMAN WERE THESONSOFAPORKBUTCHEROFASMALLTOWNCLOSETO!NNECY&RANCE 4HETWOBROTHERSLIVEDINAN!RABENVIRONMENTANDWEREEXPOSED TOTHEINmUENCEOFh&RENCH!FGHANSvMAINLY&RENCHOF.ORTH!F RICANDESCENTWHOWENTTOlGHTIN!FGHANISTANAGAINSTTHEFORMER 3OVIET5NIONANDTHENRETURNEDHOMEWITHTHEIRMINDSETON*IHAD 4HEYAPPEARTOHAVEKNOWN+AMEL$AOUDIWHOWASINDICTEDFOR HISINVOLVEMENTINTHEATTEMPTTOBLOWUPTHE!MERICANEMBASSYIN &RANCEIN

*£R¯MEWASARRESTEDIN2OTTERDAMWITHFALSEPAPERSANDAMA CHINETOFABRICATECREDITCARDS4HEELDER$AVIDHADTAKENACCOUNTING CLASSES4HISYOUNGSECULAR#ATHOLICWASADRUGADDICT(ELEFT&RANCE FOR'REAT"RITAINBUTDURINGHISTIMEIN"RIGHTONHEMET0AKISTANIS WHOACQUAINTEDHIMWITHRADICAL)SLAM(EOFlCIALLYCONVERTEDTOTHIS

RELIGIONWENTASSIDUOUSLYTOTHEMOSQUEANDBEGANEARNESTLYLEARNING !RABIC)NTHEMEANTIMEHEMADETRIPSTO0AKISTANAND!FGHANISTAN HISEXPENSESBEINGCOVEREDBY*IHADISTSIN0AKISTAN4HEREHESAIDHE OVERCAMEHISFEELINGOFBEINGLOSTANDCLUELESS(EFOLLOWEDMILITARY TRAININGAT"IN,ADENSCAMPSIN!FGHANISTAN"ETWEENAND HESPENTAROUNDNINEMONTHSINTHEBRIGADESOF"IN,ADEN(EMADE THETRIPTO3PAINMANYTIMES(EWENTTO0ESHAWAR$JALALABADAND +ABULBEFOREJOININGTHETRAININGCAMPSIN+HOSTWHEREHELEARNED HOWTOUSEWEAPONS

)NHISTESTIMONYTOTHE&RENCHTRIBUNALIN-ARCHHEDE SCRIBEDHISFEELINGTOWARD#HRISTIANITY

4HE*UDGE9OURPARENTSARE#ATHOLICS $AVID9ES BUT ) DIDNOTPRACTICE )lND CHURCHES COLD AND LUGUBRIOUS *UDGE7HY;DIDYOUCHOOSE=)SLAM $AVID)HADLOTSOFPROBLEMSWITHALCOHOLANDDRUGS)NEEDED ARELIGION

!FTER RETURNING TO"RIGHTON HEWENT TO-OROCCOWHEREHE TOOK +ORANICLESSONSATASCHOOLCLOSETO3HEIKH9ASSINETHELEADEROFTHE &UNDAMENTALISTMOVEMENT!L!DLWAL)HSANE*USTICEAND#HARITY 4HENHEWENTTO3PAINWHEREA3YRIANVETERANOFTHE"OSNIANWAR HOSTEDHIM4HEREHEMET*AMEL:OUGAMWHOWASLATERINDICTEDFOR HISPARTICIPATIONINTHE-ADRIDBOMBINGSOF/N/CTOBER :OUGAMWASCONVICTEDOFCHARGESOFMURDERAND CHARGESOFATTEMPTEDMURDERANDRECEIVEDASENTENCEOFYEARS INPRISON $AVIDWASARRESTEDIN3EPTEMBERIN(OLLAND)N-AY HEWASCONDEMNEDIN&RANCETOFOURYEARSIMPRISONMENTFOR HISINVOLVEMENTWITHTHEh!FGHANNETWORKv

(ISCASE IS SIMILAR TO THATOFMANYOTHER%UROPEANCONVERTS DEVOIDOFCULTURALBENCHMARKSEXPOSEDTODRUGSANDADDICTIONS&OR THEM)SLAMHASATWOFOLDMEANINGITTAKESTHEMAWAYFROMALIFEOF ADDICTIONANDLOSSOFPURPOSEONTHEONEHANDANDGIVESTHEMONTHE OTHERAMORALROLEINWORLDHISTORYASNEWACTORSINHOLYWAR4HEIR lGHTFORGOODAGAINSTEVILMAKESTHEMNEWKNIGHTSOFANOBLECAUSE MAINLYAGAINSTAWICKED7ESTWHERETHEYHAVEBEENATALOSSTOlND ASENSETOTHEIRLIVESANDAJUSTIlCATIONFORTHESOCIALANDECONOMIC INJUSTICESWORLDWIDE

2ICHARD2EIDALIAS!BDEL2AHIMCOMBINESMANYFEATURESOFA STIGMATIZEDANDDERELICTINDIVIDUAL(EWASBORNININ"ROMLEY SOUTHOF,ONDONTOAN%NGLISHMOTHERANDA*AMAICANFATHER(E HADADIFlCULTCHILDHOODANDADOLESCENCESPENDINGMANYYEARSIN

JAILFORVARIOUSOFFENSES(ECONVERTEDTO)SLAMINTHE&ELDHAM9OUNG /FFENDERS0RISON(EWASAPPROACHEDBYMEMBERSOF!L1AEDAAT THE"RIXTONMOSQUEONEOFTHEMAJORPLACESINSOUTH,ONDONWHERE IDEOLOGICAL*IHADISMmOURISHEDANDAPLACEHEHAUNTEDASSIDUOUSLY "EFOREHISATTEMPTATEXPLODINGTHEPLANEON$ECEMBERHE WENTTO!MSTERDAMAND0ARIS(ISTRACESHAVEBEENFOUNDIN%GYPT )SRAEL4URKEY0AKISTANANDPROBABLY!FGHANISTAN

)NHISCASEWEARECLOSETOAMODELOFPLURALISTICCULTUREWITH )SLAMSERVINGASANANTI 7ESTERNIDEOLOGYTHISDIMENSIONSUPERSEDING THESTRICTLYRELIGIOUSRITUALISTICONEASINTHECASEOFMANY7ESTERN CONVERTS7ITHIN7ESTERNCIVILIZATIONMANYTURNAGAINSThOCCIDENTAL ARROGANCEvDECLARINGWARONITINTHENAMEOFANIDEOLOGYTHATWAS NOTUPTONOWNATIVETOTHE7EST*IHADISMACHIEVEShINDIGENIZATIONv INTHE7ESTBYBLENDINGLEFTISTRIGHTISTAND)SLAMICTHEMESINTOANEW RADICALISM4HISDIRECTLYCONTRADICTSTHEhCLASHOFCIVILIZATIONSvTHEORY PROPOUNDEDBY3AMUEL(UNTINGTONSINCETHESEYOUNGCONVERTSOR BORN AGAIN-USLIMS BELONG TO7ESTERN CIVILIZATIONBUT DEVELOP A HOSTILEATTITUDETOWARDITFORSOCIALANDEXISTENTIALREASONS)SLAMISAN IMAGINARYhANTI 7ESTERNvIDEOLOGYTHEYHOLDTOFORLACKOFANYOTHER ALTERNATIVEITISATTRACTIVETOTHEMFORANOTHERREASONASWELLITISFOR THERESTORATIONOFTHEhNATURALvORDERTHEHIERARCHYBETWEENMANAND WOMAN CHILDAND FATHERGOODANDEVIL HOMOSEXUALITYBEING THE EVIL ETC4HEREACTIONARYATTITUDETOWARDWOMENANDMANYOTHER MORALISSUESlNDSANOUTLETINTHISNEO )SLAMICTENETTHATBECOMES A SUBSTITUTE FOR THEOLD EXTREME RIGHT IDEOLOGIES!NTI 7ESTERNISM CANBETRIGGEREDASARESULTOFHUMANITARIANWORKDONEINA-USLIM COUNTRYTHECASEOFTHEMEMBERSOFTHEGANGOF2OUBAIX )TCANBE DUETORELATIONSWITH-USLIMRADICALSTHE"RIXTONMOSQUEANDTHE &INSBURY0ARKIN%NGLAND ORBERELATEDTOASPECIlCTYPEOFURBAN ISMTHEBANLIEUESIN&RANCEWHERETHEREISASIMMERINGREJECTIONOF &RENCHPOLITICSANDCULTURE

4HECASEOF*ASON7ALTERSREVEALSTHESIGNIlCANCEOFTHE)NTERNET TOTHENEW*IHADISTGROUPS4HE7EBFACILITATESCONNECTIONSBETWEEN MEMBERSBUTWEAKENS THEMASWELL SINCE THE TRACES CAN EASILYBE FOLLOWEDBYINTELLIGENCEORGANIZATIONS7ALTERSWASBORNINOF ABLACK!MERICANFATHER#ARLWHOWASA53SOLDIERANDA$UTCH MOTHER4HEMARRIAGEENDEDINWHEN#ARLLAPSEDINTOALCOHOL ISMMOVEDOUTOFHISHOMEDISTRICTANDLOSTHISJOB(EBEGANSPEND INGTIMEWITH-USLIMSHEMETBYCHANCEANDCONVINCEDHISTWOSONS *ASONAND*ERMAINETOCONVERTTO)SLAMASWELLIN"OTHBEGAN STUDYINGTHE+ORANANDWEREOUTRAGEDBYTHEFATEOFTHE0ALESTINIANS AND#HECHNYANS!FTER3EPTEMBER*ASONWHOUSEDTOBEPROUDOF HIS!MERICANORIGINSBEGANHATINGTHE5NITED3TATES4HETWOBROTHERS

RADICALIZEDPUSHINGTHEIRMOTHERANDSISTERTOCONVERTANDTOADOPT THEVEILANDSUBMITTO)SLAMICNORMS4HEFATHERREMAINEDFARFROM RADICALIZATIONANDDIDNOTAPPROVEOFHISSONS)SLAMISM*ASONCHANGED HISNAMEANDBECAME*AMAL*ERMAINEWASCALLED.ORDIN

"EGINNINGIN*ASONCAMEINCONTACTWITH*IHADISTSTHROUGH THE)NTERNETSPECIlCALLYWITHAYOUNG$UTCHMANOF-OROCCANORIGIN 3AMIR!ZZOUZWHOWASARRESTEDIN5KRAINETRYINGTOENTER#HECHNYA ANDEXTRADITEDTO(OLLAND!TTHESAMETIMEANOTHERGROUPOFBORN AGAIN-USLIMSANDCONVERTSUSEDTOGATHER INACYBERCAF£CLOSETO 2OTTERDAMANDIN!MSTERDAMATTHEHOUSEOF-OHAMMED"OUYERI 4HEYWEREMEMBERSOFTHESO CALLED(OFSTADGROUP4HEONLINECHATS ANDE MAILSAMONG*ASON3AMIRANDOTHERSWEREANIMMENSEHELPTO THEPOLICEINDETECTINGTHEOTHERMEMBERSOFTHEGROUPANDEVENTUALLY ARRESTINGTHEM*ASONMADEATLEASTTWOJOURNEYSTO0AKISTAN)NTHE lRSTONEHELEARNEDHOWTOUSEGRENADESANDA+ALASHNIKOVANDOTHER MACHINEGUNS0AKISTANI AUTHORITIES ALERTEDBY$UTCH INTELLIGENCE CLOSELYFOLLOWEDHISSECONDSTAYIN0AKISTANIN$ECEMBER:ACARIA 4AYBIA-OROCCANBORNIN!MSTERDAMINANDALSOAMEMBEROF THE(OFSTADGROUPACCOMPANIEDHIM&ROM3EPTEMBERTO$ECEMBER *ASONATTEMPTEDTORECRUITNEWMEMBERSTHROUGHTHE)NTERNET SENDINGTHEMTO0AKISTAN/N.OVEMBERTHEPOLICEATTEMPTED TOPENETRATETHEGROUPSHOUSEBUT*ASONTHREWAGRENADETHATWOUNDED FOURPOLICEMEN!FTERATWELVE HOURSIEGETHEGROUPSURRENDERED

*ASONSBICULTURALORIGINSBLACK!MERICANFATHER$UTCHMOTHER THEINmUENCEOF)SLAMCONVERSIONOFTHEFATHERFOLLOWEDBYTHESONS THEROLEOFTHE)NTERNETINRECRUITMENTANDRADICALIZATIONASWELLAS THEROLEOFTHE-OROCCANRADICALIZEDGROUPSIN(OLLANDANDINMANY PARTSOF%UROPEAREQUITERELEVANTINTHISCASE

-OST*IHADISTSAREINTHEIRTWENTIESANDTHIRTIESBUTAFEWARE OLDER *ACK2OCHEWASBORN IN IN'REAT"RITAINMIGRATEDTO !USTRALIAINANDCONVERTEDTO)SLAMIN(EMARRIEDAN)N DONESIANWOMAN!L1AEDAMEMBERSAPPROACHEDHIMINAMOSQUEIN 3YDNEY(EWASPROVIDEDWITHBY+HALID3HAIKH-OHAMMAD ONEOFTHEMAINORGANIZERSOFTHE3EPTEMBERATTACKS AND2IDUAN )SSAMUDDINTHELEADEROFTHE*AMAAH)SLAMIYAIN3OUTHEAST!SIAAND ONEOFTHEPEOPLERESPONSIBLEFORTHE"ALIATTACKSINWHICH PEOPLEDIEDINCLUDING!USTRALIANS2OCHEMADETRIPSTO-ALAYSIA 0AKISTANAND!FGHANISTANUNDERTHEAEGISOF2IDUAN)SAMUDDIN!R RESTEDINBYTHE!USTRALIANAUTHORITIESHEWASACCUSEDOFBEING AMEMBEROFTHECELLTHATPLOTTEDTOBLOWUPTHE)SRAELIEMBASSYIN #ANBERRA(EWASCONDEMNEDTONINEYEARSIMPRISONMENT

0IERRE!NTOINE2OBERTWASBORNININATOWNCLOSETO3AINT ›TIENNE&RANCE(ISFATHERWASAGLASSBLOWER4HEREWERETHREESONS

INTHEFAMILY!4URKISHCOMMUNITYLIVEDAFEWKILOMETERSFURTHER ANDHECONNECTEDWITHPEOPLEINIT5NDERTHEINmUENCEOFAPROSELY TIZING4URKHECONVERTEDTO)SLAMATTHEAGEOFEIGHTEENANDBECAME 9ACOUB(EWASEAGERTOLEARNMOREABOUT!LLAHSRELIGIONANDGOT INTOUCHWITHMANY-OROCCANSAND!LGERIANSATTHELOCALMOSQUE (ETRAVELEDTOTHE4URKISHREGIONOF+ONYAWHEREHELEARNED!RABIC INA+ORANICSCHOOL(EWENTTO)RANAND!FGHANISTANMAINLYTHE +HALDENCAMPONTHEFRONTIERSOF0AKISTANITRIBALZONESANDTHEREIN HEENGAGEDINMILITARYTRAININGFORMANYMONTHSANDLEARNED HOWTODEALWITHEXPLOSIVESANDDIFFERENTTYPESOFWEAPONS(EMADE MANYTRIPSTO'ERMANY"ELGIUM3PAINAND&RANCEINDULGINGIN CONTRABANDANDSMUGGLINGACTIVITIES

)NHEWASIN4ANGIERWHEREHEMETA-OROCCANWOMAN &ATIMAWHOMHEMARRIEDANDWHOGAVEBIRTHTOTWOSONS)BRAHIM AND3ELMA,ATER ON2OBERT SETTLED IN2ICAMARIE CLOSE TO 3AINT ›TIENNE4HE COUPLE SEEMED ODD TO THE INHABITANTS HE A BLOND CONVERTSHEVEILEDINBLACKFROMHEADTOTOE(EWASACARRESELLER !LSO INHE LEFT&RANCE FOR-OROCCOTO FULLY LIVEHIS FAITH IN 4ANGIER IN AmATBELONGING TO AMOSQUE(E REGULARLYVISITED THE -OSQUE-OHAMED6ANDEXPLAINEDTHATHEWASACARSELLERIN%U ROPE(EREGULARLYVISITEDACYBERCAF£ON-AHATMA'ANDHI3TREET WHEREHEPRETENDEDTOBE'ERMAN(ERECEIVEDHISMESSAGESTHERE (ESWINDLEDSTOWAWAY-OROCCANSWHOINTENDEDTOGOTO&RANCE ILLEGALLYANDBUILTTIESWITHRACKETEERSTOOBTAINARMS

4HEARRESTOFAYOUNGCOMPUTERSPECIALIST2ACHID,ARABIBORN INWHOHADLEARNEDHOWTOUSEMOBILEPHONESASDETONATORS ANDHOWTOMIXUPCHEMICALPRODUCTSFORTHEMANUFACTUREOFBOMBS RESULTED IN THE IDENTIlCATIONOFHIS BOSS!BU!BDERRAHMAN ALIAS 0IERRE2OBERT"Y!UGUST2OBERTHADRECEIVEDMILITARYTRAINING IN!FGHANISTANANDWASNOMINATEDhEMIRvBYACLANDESTINENETWORK MADEOF*IHADISTGROUPSIN4ANGIER&EZAND#ASABLANCAIN-OROCCO (ETAUGHTMEMBERSHOWTOUSEEXPLOSIVESANDTRAINEDTHEMINTHE FORESTOF'UEZNAYA(EWASARRESTEDIN*UNEINTHEFORESTCLOSETO 4ANGIERINPOSSESSIONOFSEVEN&RENCHPASSPORTSANDWASCONDEMNED TOLIFEIMPRISONMENTBYA2ABATCOURTIN3EPTEMBER

)N2OBERTSCASETOOTHEREAREMANYJOURNEYSTODIFFERENTPARTS OF%UROPETHE-IDDLE%AST.ORTH!FRICAANDELSEWHERE(ISDESIRE TOBEAFULL mEDGED-USLIMBROUGHTHIMTOMARRYA-USLIMWOMAN WHOSHAREDHISRADICALRELIGIOUSVIEWS(EUSEDUNDERGROUNDECONOMIC ACTIVITIESOFSMUGGLINGTRAFlCKINGANDSWINDLINGTOlNANCEHIS*I HADISTINVOLVEMENT!SA&RENCHCONVERTHEACCEDEDTOHIGHLEVELS hEMIRv WITHINAN!RAB.ORTH!FRICANAND*IHADISTORGANIZATION 4HESEGROUPSAREINFACTALADDERFORTHERISEOFRADICALIZEDCONVERTS

WHOM!RAB-USLIMSGENERALLY CONSIDERWITH SUSPICION#ONVERTS CLAIMSTOLEADERSHIPAREUSUALLYREJECTEDBECAUSETHEYARECONSIDERED ADISGUISEDPERPETUATIONOFFORMERCOLONIALSUPREMACYOVER-USLIMS 4HESESUSPICIONSNOTWITHSTANDING*IHADISTGROUPSGIVECONVERTSTHE OPPORTUNITYTOACHIEVEPROMINENTPOSITIONSWITHINTHEIRNETWORKS 4HESEGROUPSAREhMODERNvINTHESENSETHATTHEYAREhMERITOCRATICv THEYGRANTTO&RENCH%NGLISHOR!USTRALIAN*IHADISTSHIGHSTATUSIN DEPENDENTOFTHEIRORIGINSANDONLYACCORDINGTOTHEIRhCAPACITIESvA CASEINPOINTISTHE0OLISH 'ERMAN -USLIM'ANCZARSKIWHOBECAME VERYCLOSETO"IN,ADEN

4HEROLEOFCHARISMATICIMAMSINRADICALIZINGYOUNGPEOPLEIS OBVIOUSINTHECASEOF9ONG+I+WON(EISA3OUTH+OREANNATURAL IZED!MERICANANDTHIRTYYEARSOLDIN(EWASBORNOF#HRISTIAN PARENTSANDCONVERTEDTO)SLAMIN(ERECEIVEDADIPLOMAFROM 6IRGINIA4ECH(ELEFTTHE5NITED3TATESFOR0AKISTANNINEDAYSAFTER 3EPTEMBERATTACKS(ERECEIVEDMILITARYTRAININGINTHECAMPSOF ,ASHKAR4AYIBAAMILITANT+ASHMIRIGROUPBASEDNEAR,AHORETHAT OPERATESAGAINST)NDIAANDISDECLAREDATERRORISTORGANIZATIONBYTHE 5NITED3TATES(EDIDALLHECOULDTOREACH!FGHANISTANTOlGHTON THESIDEOFTHE4ALIBANAGAINSTTHE5NITED3TATES(ECOULDNOTENTER THECOUNTRYHOWEVERBECAUSETHEFRONTIERWASCLOSEDAND!MERICAN FORCESHADALREADYTAKENOVER(EHADTORETURNTOTHE5NITED3TATES TOGATHERINFORMATIONFOR*IHADTHERE+WONWASTHEMEMBEROFAN INFORMALGROUPTHE*IHADISTNETWORKOF6IRGINIA

/N$ECEMBER+WONANDMANYOFHISFRIENDSSWORETO RESPONDPOSITIVELYTOTHEAPPEALOFTHEIRSPIRITUALGUIDE!LI!L 4IMMI FOR *IHAD!L 4IMMIWHOHADRECENTLYOBTAINEDADOCTORATE FROM 'EORGE-ASON5NIVERSITYINCANCERRESEARCHISA53CITIZENBORNIN 7ASHINGTON$#(ESTUDIED)SLAMICTHEOLOGYUNDERAPROMINENT 3AUDICLERIC3AFARAL (AWALIARADICAL SCHOLARCLOSETO"IN,ADEN -ANYOFAL 4IMMISSPEECHESANDWRITINGSAREPOSTEDONVARIOUS)S LAMIC7EBSITES(EDENOUNCEDTHE5NITED3TATESASh)SLAMSGREATEST ENEMYvANDINDUCEDSOMEOFHISFOLLOWERSTOTAKEUPARMSAGAINST 53FORCES

*OS£ 0ADILLA IS AN!MERICAN CITIZEN BORN IN"ROOKLYN.EW 9ORK INTOA#ATHOLICFAMILYFROM0UERTO2ICO4HEYOUNG *OS£BECAMEAJUVENILEOFFENDERASAMEMBEROFTHE,ATIN+INGSGANG ANDWASARRESTEDANDPUTINJAILMANYTIMES(EWASEVENTUALLYIN CARCERATEDFORHISINVOLVEMENTINAMURDER)NPRISONHECONVERTEDTO )SLAM,ATERONATTHE!L )MANMOSQUEIN&ORT,AUDERDALEHEMET THE0ALESTINIAN!DHAM!MIN(ASSOUNWHOPRESENTEDHIMSELFASTHE MEMBEROFACHARITYASSOCIATION"ENEVOLENCE)NTERNATIONAL&OUNDA TION4HEASSOCIATIONWASLATERACCUSEDBYTHE!MERICANGOVERNMENT

OFBEINGINVOLVEDINTERRORISTACTIVITIES0ADILLABECAMEACLOSEFRIEND OF(ASSOUNWHOWASARRESTEDIN!FTERHISCONVERSIONTO)SLAM 0ADILLAMARRIEDANEIGHTEEN YEAR OLD%GYPTIAN-USLIMANDCHOSEAN !RABNAMELIKETHEOTHERCONVERTS!BDULLAHAL-UHAJIR(EDECIDED TOCONVERTTO)SLAMAFTERADREAMINWHICHHESAWAHOLYTURBANED MANINADESERTSANDSTORM

"EGINNINGINHETRAVELEDTOMANYCOUNTRIES INCLUDING %GYPT3AUDI!RABIA!FGHANISTAN0AKISTANANDPROBABLY)RAQ0ADILLA WASARRESTEDIN#HICAGOON-AY/N!UGUSTHE WASFOUNDGUILTYOFALLCHARGESAGAINSTHIMBYAFEDERALJURYWHICH FOUNDTHATHEHADCONSPIREDTOKILLPEOPLEINANOVERSEAS*IHADAND TO FUND AND SUPPORT OVERSEAS TERRORISM )NHIS CASE AS INMANY OTHERSTHEPASSAGETHROUGHJUVENILEDELINQUENCYTHEMEETINGOFA CHARISMATICPERSONANIMAMORASTRONGPERSONALITY ANDABOVEALL lNDINGAGROUPOFPEOPLEREADYTOENGAGEINACOMMONACTIONSEEM OFPARAMOUNTIMPORTANCE

!NOTHER!MERICAN*IHADISTIS!DAM0EARLMAN'ADAHNALIASTHE EMIR9AHYA'ADAHNBORNIN(ElGUREDINAVIDEOOF!L1A EDAJUSTBEFORETHElFTHANNIVERSARYOFTHE3EPTEMBERATTACKS)N THATVIDEO!YMANAL:AWAHIRIINPERSONINTRODUCEDHIMAS!ZZAMAL !MIRIKI!ZZAMTHE!MERICAN 3PEAKINGIN%NGLISH!ZZAMCLAIMED THATTHEIGNORANCEOF)SLAMWASATTHEROOTOFTHE7ESTERNAPPROVAL OF)SRAELSMASSACRESOF0ALESTINIANSAND,EBANESE$URINGAPERIODOF FORTY FOURMINUTESHEPREACHEDABOUT)SLAMANDAMONGOTHERTHINGS HESAIDh)FTHE:IONISTCRUSADERMISSIONARIESOFHATEANDCOUNTER )SLAMCONSULTANTSLIKE$ANIEL0IPES2OBERT3PENCER-ICHAEL3CHEUER 3TEVEN%MERSONANDYESEVENTHECRUSADER IN CHIEF'EORGE7"USH WERETOABANDONTHEIRUNBELIEFANDREPENTANDENTERINTOTHELIGHTOF )SLAMANDTURNTHEIRSWORDSAGAINSTTHEENEMIESOF'ODITWOULDBE ACCEPTEDOFTHEMANDTHEYWOULDBEOURBROTHERSIN)SLAMv

(EALSOCALLEDUPON7ESTERNERSTOCONVERTTO)SLAMDENOUNC INGTHEWRONGDOINGSOF#HRISTIANITYAND*UDAISMANDPROCLAIMING THE LEGITIMACYOF!LLAHS RELIGION!ZZAMAL!MIRIKI IS THE%NGLISH TRANSLATOROFTHEMESSAGESOF!L1AEDALEADERS(EPRAISEDTHEhECHO OFEXPLOSIONSANDTHESLITTINGOFTHETHROATSOFTHEINlDELSvANDAT TACKED53FOREIGNPOLICYANDMILITARYACTIVITYPARTICULARLY IN)RAQ AND!FGHANISTAN(EPREDICTED FUTURE ATTACKS h9ESTERDAY,ONDON AND-ADRID4OMORROW,OS!NGELESAND-ELBOURNE'ODWILLING !TTHISTIMEDONTCOUNTONUSDEMONSTRATINGRESTRAINTORCOMPAS SIONv(EALSOCREATEDANELEVEN MINUTEVIDEOABOUTTHEGLORYOF!L 1AEDABROADCASTBY!"#

/N-AY'ADAHNAGAINSPOKETHROUGHANOTHERVIDEO !L 1AEDA6IDEO7ARNINGTO53BY!MERICAN!DAM'ADAHNBROADCAST

OVER THE )NTERNET )N THIS VIDEO'ADAHN LISTED SIX ACTIONS THAT THE 5NITED3TATESSHOULDTAKETOPREVENTFUTURE*IHADISTATTACKS

0ULLEVERYLASTONEOFYOURSOLDIERSSPIESSECURITYADVISORSTRAIN ERSATTACH£SOUTOFEVERY-USLIMLANDFROM!FGHANISTANTO :ANZIBAR %NDALLSUPPORTANDAIDMILITARYPOLITICALECONOMICOROTH ERWISETOTHElFTY SIX PLUSAPOSTATEREGIMESOFTHE-USLIMWORLD ANDABANDONTHEMTOTHEIRWELL DESERVEDFATE %NDALLSUPPORTMORALMILITARYECONOMICPOLITICALOROTHER WISETOTHEBASTARDSTATEOF)SRAELANDBANYOURCITIZENS:IONIST *EWS:IONIST#HRISTIANSANDTHERESTFROMTRAVELINGTOOCCUPIED 0ALESTINEORSETTLINGTHERE%VENONEPENNYOFAIDWILLBECONSIDERED SUFlCIENTJUSTIlCATIONTOCONTINUETHElGHT)MPOSEABLANKET BANONALLBROADCASTSTOOURREGION &REEALL-USLIMCAPTIVESFROMYOURPRISONSDETENTIONFACILITIES ANDCONCENTRATIONCAMPS REGARDLESSOFWHETHER THEYHAVEBEEN RECIPIENTSOFWHATYOUCALLAFAIRTRIALORNOT

(EWARNED h9OUR FAILURE TOHEEDOURDEMANDS AND THEDEMANDS OF REASONMEANS THAT YOU AND YOUR PEOPLEWILLˆ!LLAHWILLINGˆ EXPERIENCETHINGSWHICHWILLMAKEYOUFORGETALLABOUTTHEHORRORSOF 3EPTEMBER!FGHANISTANAND)RAQAND6IRGINIA4ECHv

'ADAHNS GRANDFATHERWAS AWELL KNOWN *EWISH SURGEON BUT HISPARENTSCONVERTEDTO#HRISTIANITY(EDESCRIBESHIMSELFASHAVING EXPERIENCEDAhYAWNINGEMPTINESSvSEEKINGWAYShTOlLLTHATVOIDv (EEXPLORED#HRISTIANITYBUT LATER FOUNDEVANGELICAL#HRISTIANITYS hAPOCALYPTIC RAMBLINGSv TOBE hPARANOIDv ANDHOLLOW )N AT AGESEVENTEEN'ADAHNBEGANSTUDYING)SLAMATTHE)SLAMIC3OCIETYOF /RANGE#OUNTY(ECONVERTEDTHESAMEYEAR)N'ADAHNMOVED TO0AKISTANWHEREHEMARRIEDAN!FGHANREFUGEE

)NHISCASETHEFAMILYTRADITIONOFSEEKINGONESOWNRELIGION HISEXISTENTIAL FEELINGOFEMPTINESS)SLAMASCLEARLY IDENTIFYINGTHE ENEMY!MERICA*EWSDEPRAVED-USLIMGOVERNMENTSAMONGOTH ERS AND!LLAHSRELIGIONBEINGATTHESAMETIMEANTI IMPERIALISTLEFT ISTCHARM ANDFORTHERESTORATIONOFhSANEvFAMILYANDSOCIALVALUES RIGHTISTLURE SEEMDECISIVE/NTHEOTHERHAND!L1AEDAHASGIVEN HIMAPROMINENCETHATMANIFESTSTHECAPACITYOFTHISORGANIZATION TO EXPLOITPEOPLES TALENTS ANDMERITS INDEPENDENTOF THEIR ETHNIC BACKGROUND

!NOTHER!MERICAN%ARNEST*AMES4HOMPSONBORNIN$ENVER INCONVERTEDTO)SLAMANDCHANGEDHISNAMETO5JAAMA&OR YEARS*AMES5JAAMAWASKNOWNASAPROMINENTCOMMUNITYACTIV

IST IN3EATTLE(EWROTEAT LEAST THREEBOOKSONHOWTOSUCCEED IN BUSINESSINCLUDINGONETITLED4HE9OUNG0EOPLES'UIDETO3TARTINGA "USINESS7ITHOUT3ELLING$RUGS7ASHINGTONSTATELAWMAKERSDECLARED *UNE*AMES5JAAMA$AYFORHISCOMMUNITYSERVICEAND GAVEHIMAKEYTOTHECITYOF,AS6EGASWITHA#ERTIlCATEOF3PECIAL #ONGRESSIONAL2ECOGNITION"UTACCORDINGTO53AUTHORITIESTHERE ISANOTHERSIDETO5JAAMA

$URINGATRIPTO%NGLANDIN5JAAMAMET!BU(AMZAAL -ASRITHERADICAL-USLIMCLERICWHOISSERVINGASEVEN YEARSENTENCE IN%NGLANDFOR INCITINGTOMURDERANDRACIALHATRED!LSOIN 5JAAMATRAVELEDTO!FGHANISTANWHEREHEOFFEREDHISSUPPORTTO!L 1AEDAACCORDINGTOFAMILYFRIENDS5JAAMAWASARRESTEDIN$ENVER ON*ULY(EWASACCUSEDAMONGOTHERCHARGESOFATTEMPT INGTOCREATEACAMPFORTRAININGTERRORISTSNEAR"LY/REGONBETWEEN /CTOBERAND$ECEMBER5JAAMAPLEADEDGUILTYONLYAFTERVIDEOS WEREUNCOVEREDSHOWINGHIMSITTINGNEXTTO!BU(AMZAANDTALK INGABOUT*IHAD(EWASSENTENCEDTOATWO YEARIMPRISONMENTAFTER COOPERATINGWITHTHEAUTHORITIES

!SAN!FRICAN!MERICANHEBECAMEINVOLVEDIN*IHADIST)SLAM AFTERYEARSOFLIVINGAMODERATEVERSIONOFIT4HESHIFTFROMONEVER SIONTOTHEOTHERHAPPENEDTHROUGHTHEINmUENCEOFACHARISMATIC IMAM!BU(AMZAAL-ISRI4HISCASE THATOFASUCCESSFULPERSON PUTTINGANENDTOHISSOCIALAMBITIONSINTHENAMEOFRADICAL)SLAM ISREMINISCENTOFTHE&RENCHMANOF!LGERIANORIGINWHOSTUDIEDINA PRESTIGIOUS0ARISIANUNIVERSITYANDTURNEDTOWARDRADICAL)SLAMEND INGHISPROMISINGCAREER

!NOTHEREXAMPLEIS7ADIH%L(AGEBORNININTOA#ATHOLIC FAMILYIN3IDON,EBANON(EGREWUPIN+UWAITWHEREHISFATHER WORKED FOR AN OIL COMPANY(E CONVERTED TO )SLAM AS A TEENAGER AFTERREADINGTHE+ORAN(ISFAMILYDISAPPROVEDOFHISCONVERSION ANDREJECTEDHIMBUTA-USLIMSHEIKHIN+UWAITWHOPAIDFORHIS EDUCATIONINTHE5NITED3TATESTOOKHIMINANDHEBECAMEADEEPLY RELIGIOUSYOUNGMAN)N%L(AGEMOVEDTO,AFAYETTE,OUISIANA TOATTENDCOLLEGE(ESTUDIEDURBANPLANNINGANDOBTAINEDAJOBATA DONUTSHOPWHEREMANYYOUNG!RABMENWORKED!TTHEBEGINNINGOF THE!FGHANWARAGAINSTTHE3OVIET5NION%L(AGELEFT,OUISIANAAND TRAVELEDTO0AKISTANTOENROLLINMUJAHEDEENWAR TRAININGPROGRAMS 4HOUSANDSOF YOUNG!RABMEN FROMAROUND THEWORLDmOCKED TO 0AKISTANTOHELP!FGHANSEXPELTHE3OVIETS%L(AGEWASAFOLLOWER OF3HEIKH!BDULLAH!ZZAMONEOFTHEMOSTIMPORTANT5LAMAOFTHE !RABMUJAHEDEEN FORCES"Y*ANUARY%L(AGERETURNEDTOTHE 5NITED3TATESANDUNIVERSITY,ATERTHATYEARHETRAVELEDTO!RIZONATO MARRYANEIGHTEEN YEAR OLD!MERICAN-USLIMTHETWOWEREPRESENTED

TOEACHOTHERTHROUGHANARRANGEDMARRIAGE)N-AY%L(AGE GRADUATEDANDMOVEDPERMANENTLYTO!RIZONATOSTARTFAMILYLIFE(E ANDHISWIFERETURNEDTO0AKISTANSEVERALTIMESOVERTHENEXTFEWYEARS 7HENTHEYRETURNEDTO!RIZONA%L(AGEWORKEDATSEVERALMINIMUM WAGEJOBSINCLUDINGASACITYCUSTODIAN)NHEWASGRANTED53 CITIZENSHIP

)NEARLYACCORDINGTOHISGRANDJURYTESTIMONYHEWAS CALLED TO.EW9ORK TO HELP DIRECT THE!LKIFAH2EFUGEE#ENTER A "ROOKLYN BASEDGROUPTHATRAISEDMONEYTOSUPPORTVETERANSOFTHE !FGHANWAR!CCORDINGTODOCUMENTSFROMTHE7ORLD4RADE#ENTER CASE!LKIFAHHADA4UCSONOFlCEANDCONTACTSWITHTHEMAINMOSQUE IN!RLINGTON4EXAS AND FAMILYMEMBERS CONlRMED THAT%L(AGE HADBEENINCONTACTWITHTHEGROUP)NEARLY%L(AGEMOVED HISFAMILYTO3UDANANDHEBEGANWORKINGASASECRETARYFOR/SAMA "IN,ADEN&AMILYMEMBERSSAY%L(AGEWORKEDONLYIN"IN,ADENS LEGITIMATEBUSINESSES INTHE3UDAN%L(AGEFREQUENTLYTOOKINTER NATIONALTRIPSTO%UROPEANDELSEWHEREONBUSINESSFOR"IN,ADEN )NHELEFT3UDANFOR+ENYAANDBECAMEDIRECTOROFA-USLIM CHARITYORGANIZATIONCALLED(ELP!FRICA0EOPLE+ENYANGOVERNMENT DOCUMENTSSTATETHATTHEORGANIZATIONWASDEDICATEDTOMALARIACON TROLPROJECTS(EALSOWORKEDINTHEGEMBUSINESSFOREXTRAINCOME $URINGHISTIMEIN+ENYAHESTAYEDINCONTACTWITHMEMBERSOF"IN ,ADENSINNERCIRCLE,ATERHEMOVEDBACKTOTHESUBURBANCOMMUNITY OF!RLINGTON4EXASANDSECUREDAJOBINALOCALTIRESTORE4HEFAMILY MOVEDINTOASMALLAPARTMENTNEARTHE5NIVERSITYOF4EXASANDTHE CHILDRENENROLLEDINALOCAL-USLIMSCHOOL

%L(AGESERVESLIFEIMPRISONMENTINTHE5NITED3TATESFORHISPART INTHE53EMBASSYBOMBINGS4HEFACTTHATHEWASAN!MERICAN CITIZENANDCOULDTRAVELEVERYWHEREWITHHISPASSPORTWASONEOFTHE REASONS!L1AEDAOFTENUSEDHISSERVICES)NHISCASEASINTHATOFOTHER FOREIGNERS!L1AEDAHASGIVENTHEMPROMINENTROLESGOINGBEYOND THEhETHNICvDIVISIONSOFACTIONOFMANYLOCAL*IHADISTMOVEMENTS (ETRAVELEDEXTENSIVELYINMANYPARTSOFTHEWORLDLEADINGADUAL LIFE THATOFAWORKERAND LEADEROFCHARITYASSOCIATIONSWITHIN THE 5NITED3TATESANDTHATOFA*IHADISTWHOHELPEDTHECAUSEOFTHEHOLY WAR4HEABILITYOFCONVERTSLIKEHIMTOPLAYAROLEhINBETWEENvAND TOCOMBINESOMANYDIFFERENTANDCONTRADICTORYDIMENSIONSOFTHEIR ACTIONSTESTIlESTOTHEIRUTTERMODERNITYANDTHECAPACITYOF*IHADIST ORGANIZATIONSTOADAPTTOMODERNCONDITIONSINTHENAMEOFALONG TRADITIONOFWAR MONGERING

4HECASEOF2ANDALL2OYERISEXEMPLARYOFGANGSSMALLGROUPS ORhCLIQUES(ECONVERTEDTO)SLAMININ3AINT,OUISAFTERTHE ,OS!NGELES RIOTS CAUSEDBY RACIAL TENSIONS4HENINETEEN YEAR OLD

2OYERBYCHANCEENTEREDAMOSQUEONAUNIVERSITYCAMPUSWHERE HEFOUNDAWHITEABLACKAN!RABANDA0AKISTANI4HEYBEGANTO TALKANDHEFOUNDTHATTHEYWERESIMILARPEOPLEWITHOUTANYBARRIER BETWEENTHEMLINKEDTHROUGH)SLAM3OMETHINGWASTRIGGEREDINHIM PROVOKEDBY!LLAHSRELIGION(EHADALREADYGIVENUPHIS#HRISTIAN FAITHBELIEVINGTHATTHE4RINITYWASINFACTAUNITYTHEUNIQUE'OD (ISCONTACTWITHHIS-USLIMFRIENDSPUSHEDHIMTOWARD)SLAM(E CAMETOBELIEVETHAT!LLAHCOULDSETTHEDIRECTIONOFAPERSONSLIFE (EANNOUNCEDITINANINTERVIEWPUBLISHEDONLINEIN*UNE (IS FATHERA#HRISTIAN"APTISTANDHISMOTHERA FORMER#ATHOLIC NUNBELIEVEDTHATTHEIRSONWASUNDERGOINGATRANSITIONALMYSTICAL EXPERIENCE"UT2OYERBECAMEASTEADFAST-USLIM

)NHEJOINEDTHE"OSNIANFORCESTHATFOUGHTAGAINSTTHE 3ERBSIN"OSNIA (ERZEGOVINA(ECHOSETHE)SLAMICNAMEOF)SMAIL 4HEREHERALLIEDAGROUPOF!RABCOMBATANTSWITHSOME+ASHMIRIS AMONGTHEM!FTERWARDHEWENTTO0AKISTAN(EMADEMANYTRIPS TO"OSNIAWHEREHEMETHISFUTUREWIFEWITHWHOMHERETURNEDTO THE5NITED3TATES(E JOINED#AIR THE LARGEST-USLIMASSOCIATION INTHE5NITED3TATES(EMADEATHIRDTRIPTO"OSNIAJUSTAFTERTHE 3EPTEMBERATTACKSTHISTIMEAPPARENTLYFOLLOWINGTHEADVICEOF !LI!L 4IMMIWHOADVISEDHIMTOWAGE*IHADOUTSIDETHE5NITED 3TATESFORFEAROFREPRESSIONAGAINST-USLIMSAFTER3EPTEMBER

!$ECEMBERDECISIONBYA53DISTRICTCOURTDEAL INGWITHTHEh6IRGINIAPAINTBALLvCASECONVICTED2ANDALL2OYERAND )BRAHIMAL (AMDIFORTHEIRPARTICIPATIONINWHATPROSECUTORSCALLED Ah6IRGINIAJIHADNETWORKv2OYERANDAL (AMDIRECEIVEDLONGPRISON TERMSSEVENOTHERSPLEADEDGUILTYORWERECONVICTEDINTHATCASEAND TWOWEREACQUITTED

4HECONVERSIONOF2OYER TO)SLAMIS SIMILAR TO THATOF9AHYA 'ADAHN BOTHWENT IN SEARCH OF A FAITHWITHIN A#HRISTIANWORLD WHERETHEBELIEFSYSTEMSEEMSSOMEHOWWORN OUTLOOKINGFORINTENSE SENSATIONSANDDIRECTACTION )SLAMPROVIDESA STRONGANDVIGOROUS CREEDASKINGTHEBELIEVERTOSCRUPULOUSLYABIDEBYITSRULESBREAK INGTHEhGREYZONEvANDREPLACINGITWITHADICHOTOMYBETWEEN'OD ANDEVILWHICHISNOLONGERSHAREDBYINSTITUTIONAL#HRISTIANITY4HE PASSAGEBETWEEN&UNDAMENTALIST)SLAMANDITS*IHADISTVERSIONISALSO CLEARHERE AS INOTHERCASES4HE TRIGGER IS THREEFOLD ACCORDING TO DIFFERENTGROUPSOF*IHADISTSTHE"OSNIAREPRESSIONOF-USLIMSTHE !FGHANISTANWARANDITSAFTERMATHANDNOWADAYSTHEWARIN)RAQ 4HESETHREEWORLDEVENTSHAVEINMANYCASESTRIGGEREDTHETRANSITION FROM&UNDAMENTALIST)SLAMTOITS*IHADISTVERSIONBYMANYCONVERTS !MONGTHEBORN AGAIN-USLIMSEVENTSIN!LGERIATHEMILITARYCOUP OF INCONJUNCTIONWITH7ESTERNINVOLVEMENTIN!FGHANISTAN

AND)RAQTHE%NGLISHPARTICIPATIONINTHEWARIN)RAQ HAVEPLAYED AMAJORROLE4HISPROVESTHATJOINING*IHADISMISNOTONLYRELATEDTO hIDENTITYPROBLEMSvBUTALSOLINKEDTOTHEPOLITICALANDSOCIALPROBLEMS OFTHE-USLIMWORLDWHERETHEINTERVENTIONOFFOREIGNNON -USLIM GOVERNMENTSTHE5NITED3TATESINMOSTCASES&RANCEINTHE!LGERIAN MILITARYCOUPOFn PLAYSADECISIVEROLE

3HANE+ENT IS AN!USTRALIANBORN IN IN THE SUBURBSOF -ELBOURNE(ECONVERTEDTO)SLAMWHILEHEPATRONIZEDTHEMOSQUE OF"RUNSWICKWHERETHE&UNDAMENTALISTSHEIKH-OHAMMAD/MRAN PREACHED!NOTHERPREACHER!BDUL.ACER"ENBRIKACALLED!BU"AKR FORTY SIXYEARSOLDANDTHESPIRITUALMASTEROFTHESO CALLEDhTERRORIST CELLOF-ELBOURNEvINmUENCEDHIM+ENTMARRIEDAWOMANOF4URKISH ORIGIN!BU"AKRSENTHIMINFORMILITARYTRAININGAT!L &AROTHE FAMOUS*IHADISTCAMPIN!FGHANISTANMANAGEDBY!L1AEDA)NTHE TRIALOFTHEhTERRORISTCELLOF-ELBOURNEvIN$ECEMBER+ENTWAS ALSOACCUSEDFORHISILLEGALACTIVITIESINRAISINGFUNDSBYFALSIFYINGCREDIT CARDSANDHOLD UPS)NHISCASETHEINmUENCEOFAHYPER &UNDAMENTALIST MOSQUEASWELLASACHARISMATICPREACHERSEEMSESSENTIAL

!CLOSERLOOKATTHEBIOGRAPHYOFSOMEOFTHE*IHADISTSIN%U ROPEEITHERBORN AGAIN-USLIMSORCONVERTSATTESTSTOTHEIRIDENTITY PROBLEMSANDTHEhGREYvPICTUREOFMANYSECOND ANDTHIRD GENERATION -USLIMSTHERE4HECOMPARISONWITHTHE5NITED3TATESYIELDSMANY INSIGHTS7HEREASMOST-USLIMSINTHEWORLDRECKON!MERICANPOLI CIESTOWARDTHEMASUNBALANCEDUNJUSTANDEVENREPRESSIVE!MERICAN -USLIMSUPTONOWHAVESHOWNFARFEWERCASESOFRADICALIZATIONTHAN THE%UROPEANSEVENINTERMSOFTHEIRPROPORTIONVIS Í VISNON -USLIMS INTHEIRRESPECTIVESOCIETIES4HISHASCERTAINLYTODOWITHTHESOCIAL CLASSOFTHEFORMERCOMPAREDTOTHELATTERhWHITEv!MERICAN-USLIMS AREMIDDLECLASSANDMOSTLYSHARETHE!MERICANDREAMTHEYENJOYA HIGHEDUCATIONALLEVELWHEREAS%UROPEAN-USLIMSAREMOSTLYFROM THELOWERCLASSESWITHLESSEDUCATION4HEYAREINTHEDOLDRUMSCON CERNINGTHEIROWNIDENTITYANDTHEIRINTEGRATIONWITHINTHE%UROPEAN LANDSCAPE!LTHOUGHASIZEABLEMINORITYOF%UROPEAN-USLIMSHAS REACHEDTHESTATUSOFTHEMIDDLECLASSESSTILLMANYOFTHEMAREECO NOMICALLYEXCLUDEDANDSOCIALLYMARGINALIZED4HEPLIGHTOFTHELATTER PUSHESSOMEOFTHEFORMERTOWARDRADICALIZATIONMUCHINTHESAME WAYASMANYMIDDLE CLASSPEOPLETURNEDTOTHEEXTREMELEFTMOVEMENTS IN%UROPEINTHESINTHENAMEOFTHEEXPLOITATIONOFWORKING CLASSPEOPLE4HECASEOF-OHAMMAD3IDIQUE+HANTHELEADEROFTHE ,ONDONBOMBINGSOF*ULYPROVESTHEDIFlCULTYOFINTEGRATING SECOND ANDTHIRD GENERATION-USLIMYOUTHIN%UROPE3IDIQUEWAS THERINGLEADEROFTHEBOMBINGS(EWASBORNIN,EEDSTHEYOUNGEST CHILDOFFOUR(ISFATHERWASAFOUNDRYWORKERINHISlFTIES3IDIQUEWAS

THIRTYATTHETIMEOFHISFATHERSDEATH(EHADBEENMARRIEDANDHAD ASMALLCHILD(EWORKEDASAYOUTHWORKERANDSCHOOLMENTOR4HE OTHERTWOBOMBERS3HEHRZAD4ANWEERAND(ASIB(USSAINHADKNOWN +HANTHROUGHHISYOUTHWORK4ANWEERTWENTY TWOWASWORKINGIN HISFATHERSlSHANDCHIPSHOPAFTERHAVINGCOMPLETEDATWO YEARFURTHER EDUCATIONCOURSEINSPORTSSCIENCEAT,EEDS-ETROPOLITAN5NIVERSITY (USSAINJUSTEIGHTEENWASAWAITINGRESULTSOFASERIESOFCOURSESATA LOCALCOLLEGE

4HE ROLEOF THEDISTRICT IS IMPORTANT IN"RITAINMUCH IN THE SAMEWAYASTHESO CALLEDBANLIEUESIN&RANCE4HESHABBYSITUATION OFTHE-USLIMCOMMUNITYPARTLYOF0AKISTANIORIGININTHESUBURBS OF,EEDSWASALARMINGWITHTHENUMBEROFDRUG ADDICTEDYOUTHRIS INGSTEADILY)NTHEMID SAGROUPOFSECOND GENERATIONYOUNG 0AKISTANISCALLEDTHEh-ULLAH"OYSvWITHABOUTTWENTYMEMBERS TRIEDTOINTERVENELOCALLYTOSTOPTHEADDICTION3IDIQUE+HANWASA LEADINGlGURE IN THE EFFORT h/N SEVERALOCCASIONS THEGROUPKID NAPPEDYOUNG0AKISTANIDRUGADDICTSANDWITHTHECONSENTOFTHEIR FAMILIESHELDTHEMINAmATNEARTHE7AHHABIMOSQUEON3TRATFORD 3TREETˆANDFORCIBLYCLEANSEDTHEMOFTHEIRDRUGHABITSv

!FTER3EPTEMBERTHEGROUPBECAMEMOREANDMORE RELIGIOUS )T EXPRESSEDNEW TENDENCIES ANDMORE INDIVIDUALIZATION COMPAREDTOWHATWASEXPECTEDFROM0AKISTANIS)TSMEMBERSBEGAN TOCHOOSETHEIROWNWIVESINSTEADOFSUBMITTINGTOTHECHOICEOFTHEIR FAMILIES4HEYPRIVILEGED)SLAMOVERTHETRIBALANDFAMILYTIESWITHIN THEIRDISTRICTBYREFUSINGTOMARRYTHEIRCOUSINS

3IDIQUEWASINVOLVEDINA7AHHABITYPEOF)SLAMPARADOXICALLY ITWASINAWAYMOREMODERN7HEREAS0AKISTANIIMAMSWHOMAINLY SPOKE5RDUHELDTHETRADITIONAL-USLIMMOSQUEONTHECORNERTHE 7AHHABISSPOKE%NGLISH4HEPOORQUALITYOF3IDIQUE+HANS5RDUWAS ASTUMBLINGBLOCKTOHISUNDERSTANDINGTHE0AKISTANIIMAMSPREACH ING4HESAMEPHENOMENONISTRUEIN&RANCE-OSTOFTHETRADITIONAL MOSQUESAREHELDBYIMAMSOF-OROCCANOR!LGERIANORIGINWHODO NOTSPEAKmUENT&RENCHANDWHOSEPREACHINGISIN!RABICWHICHIS NOTMASTEREDBYTHESECOND ORTHIRD GENERATION-USLIMYOUTH"Y CONTRASTINTHESTHEPREACHINGOFRADICALIMAMSWASMAINLY IN&RENCHINTINYGROUPSOREVENINSOMERADICALOR&UNDAMENTALIST MOSQUES

!NOTHERFACTABOUT3IDIQUE+HANISHISGRADUALADHERENCETO RADICAL )SLAM )NMANY OTHER CASES -OUSSAOUI IN &RANCE AND IN %NGLANDANDMANYOTHER-USLIMSORCONVERTS THESAMEFACTHOLDS TRUE4HEIDENTIlCATIONWITHTHE*IHADISTVERSIONOF)SLAMDOESNOT USUALLYHAPPENSUDDENLYBUTTHROUGHALONGPERIODOFhINCUBATIONv )N3IDIQUESCASETHECONVERSIONOFSOMEOFTHEOTHERMEMBERSOFTHE

h-ULLAHBOYSvTO*IHADIST)SLAMREINFORCEDHISBENT(EFELLINLOVE WITHAN)NDIAN-USLIMGIRLOF$EOBANDITRADITIONTHEEQUIVALENT OFTHE7AHHABIBRANDOF)SLAMIN3AUDI!RABIA ANDTHISADDEDTO THEFRICTIONWITHHISFAMILYWHOSE)SLAMWASOF"ARELVITRADITIONTHE $EOBANDIARECLOSETOTHE(ANAlSCHOOLOF3UNNISMANDDEEMTHE "ARELVISINlDELS 4HECOUPLEMETATTHEUNIVERSITYOUTSIDETHEREALM OFFAMILYINmUENCEHISWIFEWASSTUDYINGSOCIOLOGY4HEIRMARRIAGE INCUT3IDIQUEOFFFROMHISFAMILYPUSHINGHIMTOWARD)SLAMIC RADICALSWHOACTEDASASUBSTITUTEFORHISFAMILY(ISMOTHERHAD DIEDAFEWYEARSBEFOREANDHISFATHERANDHISSECONDWIFEMOVEDTO .OTTINGHAM

)NVESTIGATIONSREVEALTHAT3IDIQUEWASASSOCIATINGWITHRADICAL -USLIMSRELATEDTO!L1AEDA(EAND3HEHRZAD4ANWEERWERESENT TO0AKISTANTOLEARNBOMBMAKING)N-ARCH3IDIQUETOOKONA aAYEARJOBASAMENTORATTHELOCALPRIMARYSCHOOL4ANWEER WASALSOINVOLVEDFROMONWARDINLOCALYOUTHPROJECTSAND 3IDIQUEVISITEDHISFAMILYREGULARLY4HEOTHERMEMBEROFTHEGROUP *ERMAINE,INDSAYBORNIN*AMAICAINA#ATHOLICFAMILYBUTBROUGHT UP IN(UDDERSlELDWAS IN REGULAR CONTACTWITH+HAN SINCE LATE !RADICALPREACHER!BDULLAH!L &AISALWHOTWICEPREACHEDIN "EESTONBEFOREBEINGJAILEDFORINCITINGRACIALHATREDPROBABLYINTRO DUCEDTHEMTOEACHOTHER+HANAND4ANWEERWENTFORALONGTRIPTO 0AKISTANIN.OVEMBERANDWENTONARECONNAISSANCEJOURNEY TO,ONDONWHERETHEYMET,INDSAY3IDIQUESWIFEGAVEBIRTHINTHE SAMEYEARTOAGIRL

)NHISVIDEO SUICIDENOTEPRODUCEDBY!L1AEDA3IDIQUECRITI CIZES"RITISHFOREIGNPOLICYANDTHENADDRESSESHISCRITIQUESTO-USLIM SCHOLARS IN"RITAINh/URSO CALLEDSCHOLARSTODAYARECONTENTWITH THEIR4OYOTAS AND SEMI DETACHEDHOUSES4HEY SEEM TO THINK THAT THEIRRESPONSIBILITIESLIEINPLEASINGTHEKUFR5NBELIEF INSTEADOF!L LAH3OTHEYTELLUSLUDICROUSTHINGSLIKEYOUMUSTOBEYTHELAWOFTHE LAND0RAISEBE!LLAH(OWDIDWEEVERCONQUERLANDSINTHEPASTIF WEWERETOOBEYTHISLAW"Y!LLAHTHESESCHOLARSWILLBEBROUGHT TOACCOUNTANDIFTHEYFEARTHE"RITISHGOVERNMENTMORETHANTHEY FEAR!LLAHTHENTHEYMUSTDESISTINGIVINGTALKSLECTURESANDPASSING FATWASANDTHEYNEEDTOSITATHOMEANDLEAVETHEJOBTOTHEREALMEN THETRUEINHERITORSOFTHEPROPHETSv

3IDIQUEWASIMBUEDWITHRUDIMENTARY*IHADISTIDEOLOGYABOUT THEFACTTHATMARTYRSDONTDIEANDGOTOPARADISEOPENINGTHEWAY TOTHEIRFAMILIESANDPEOPLECLOSETOTHEMh!CCORDINGTOTHEOFlCIAL ACCOUNTOFATAROUNDAMAT+INGS#ROSSSTATIONONTHEDAY OFTHEBOMBINGShFOURMENlTTINGTHEIRDESCRIPTIONSARESEENHUGGING 4HEYAPPEARHAPPYEVENEUPHORICv)NTHECLOSINGSCENESOFTHE""#

DRAMATHATNEVERWAS*ERMAINE,INDSAYTURNSTO+HANANDSAYSh) WANTMYCHILDRENTOBEPROUDOFMEv+HANREPLIESh4HEYWILLBEv !NDASTHEFOURBOMBERSMOVETHROUGH+INGS#ROSS+HANSUDDENLY STOPSTURNSTOTHERESTOFTHEGROUPANDSAYSh4HEREARENOGOODBYES ONLYALAPSEOFTIME7EWILLSEEOURFAMILIESSOONv

3OMEINTERPRETATIONSPUTINTOQUESTIONTHE-ULLAHBOYS IM PORTANCEASWELLAS3IDIQUESLONGPERIODOFRADICALIZATION&ROMTHIS POINTOFVIEWHISRADICALIZATIONHAPPENEDMUCHLATERINRATHER THANOVERADECADE4HEINTERPRETATIONBY3HIV-ALIKASSUMMARIZED ABOVEMAINLYSTRESSES3IDIQUESIDENTITYCRISISBEINGCAUGHTBETWEEN TWO CULTURES THE PARENTSWITH THEIR TRADITIONAL )SLAM AND SECULAR SOCIETY(EIDENTIlEDWITHRADICAL)SLAMTOESCAPETHEIMPASSEOFTHIS DUALIDENTITY4HE"RITISHWARIN)RAQPLAYEDANIMPORTANTROLEINSOFAR ASITPROVEDTHEANTAGONISMOF"RITAINTO)SLAM

:ACARIAS-OUSSAOUISCASEISALSOAPERTINENTEXAMPLEINMANY RESPECTS(E IS THE YOUNGEST SONOF A-OROCCANWHOWAS VIOLENT ALCOHOLICANDPARANOID(EWASONEOFFOURCHILDRENOFTHEFAMILY TWOGIRLSANDTWOBOYS4HEFATHERWASATWO FACEDMANACCORDING TOSOMEACCOUNTSPLEASANTWITHOUTSIDERSEXTREMELYVIOLENTWITHIN THEFAMILYOFTENBEATINGHISWIFEANDCHILDRENSOMETIMESWITHAN EXTREME CRUELTY )NHIS YOUTH BEFORE BECOMING A RADICAL-USLIM -OUSSAOUIHADMANY SECULAR&RENCH FRIENDS AMONG THEMSECULAR *EWS(ISGIRLFRIENDWITHWHOMHELIVEDMANYYEARSBEFORELEAVING FOR,ONDONWASTHEDAUGHTEROFAhPIEDNOIRvA&RENCHMANFORCED TOLEAVE!LGERIAAFTERTHEWAROFINDEPENDENCE;n= (EDID NOTPRACTICE)SLAMICRITUALSBEFORELEAVING&RANCE(ISMOTHER7Al WORKEDHARDTOMAKEENDSMEETHERHUSBANDBECAMEADRUNKARD ANDWASABSENTFORLONGPERIODS3HEHADMARRIEDHIMIN-OROCCO ATTHEAGEOFFOURTEENINAMARRIAGESETTLEDBYTHEPARENTSWITHOUT HERCONSENT3HEDIVORCEDIN7AlHADTOWORKFORTHEFAMILY SUBSISTENCEANDASASINGLEPARENTSHETOOKCAREOFHERFOURCHILDREN 4HEYHADHARDTIMESBUTSHESTILLWASABLETOBUYAHOUSEONCREDIT 3HEDIDNOTGIVEANYRELIGIOUSEDUCATIONTOHERCHILDRENTHEYDIDNOT KNOWANYTHINGABOUT)SLAMANDWERETOTALLYSECULARACCORDINGTOTHE &RENCHMODEL3HETHOUGHTTHATINTEGRATIONINTOTHE&RENCHSOCIETY MEANTBREAKINGTIESWITH)SLAM

4HECHILDRENDEVELOPEDMANYPSYCHOLOGICALPROBLEMS LATE IN LIFE4HETWODAUGHTERSSUFFEREDFROMAFORMOFSCHIZOPHRENIAONE OF THEMHAVINGTOBEUNDER INTENSEMEDICALCARE4HEFATHER TOO WASPARANOIACCERTIlEDBY&RENCHDOCTORS4HEBROTHER!BD3AMAD MARRIEDACOUSININ-OROCCOWHOWASARELIGIOUS&UNDAMENTALISTAND MEMBEROFTHE!HBASHGROUPACCORDINGTOHERMOTHERCONVERTING HIMTOTHATBRANDOF)SLAM

:ACARIAS-OUSSAOUIWENTTO,ONDONINTO IMPROVEHIS %NGLISHANDGETADIPLOMAINBUSINESS4HEREHECAMEINTOCONTACT WITHRADICAL-USLIMS)NTHES,ONDONORINTHELANGUAGEOFTHE )SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISTS,ONDONISTAN WASAHOTBEDOF*IHADISMIN %UROPE"ECAUSEOF%NGLANDSLIBERALPOLICIESMANY)SLAMICRADICALS WHOCOULDNOTSTAYANYMOREIN&RANCEORINOTHER%UROPEANCOUN TRIESWENTTHEREBENElTINGFROMASAFEHAVEN-ANY.ORTH!FRICAN )SLAMISTSWENTTHEREASWELLTOESCAPEREPRESSIONIN!LGERIA4UNISIA OR-OROCCO-OUSSAOUIFELLUNDERTHEINmUENCEOFRADICAL-USLIMS WHOHELPEDHIMlNANCIALLYANDPROVIDEDHIMWITHANEWCOMMUNITY INASOCIETYWHEREHEWASALONEANDHADNOTIES7HENHEWENTBACK FORHOLIDAYSIN&RANCEHETRIEDTOCONVERTHISMOTHERANDSISTERSTOA STRICT)SLAMWITHOUTSUCCESS(IS)SLAMIZATIONMEANTHISRUPTUREWITH THE&RENCHLANGUAGEHISOLDFRIENDSANDEVENHISFAMILYINCLUDING HISMOTHERSHEHASSAID

)NHISPRECONVERSIONLIFEHEDRANKALCOHOLSMOKEDPOTHADSEX OUTSIDEMARRIAGEANDBEFRIENDEDSECULAREVENSECULAR*EWISHPEOPLE .OWHEABSTAINEDFROMALCOHOLICBEVERAGESBROKEOFFTIESWITHALLHIS FORMERFRIENDSPUTANENDTOHISRELATIONSWITHHISGIRLFRIENDANDHIS FAMILYRENEGEDHIS&RENCHIDENTITYDENOUNCED*EWSANDCHANGEDHIS APPEARANCEHEGREWALONGBEARDSHAVEDHISHEADANDPUTONTRADI TIONAL!FGHANDRESS(EWENTTO-OROCCOTOVISITHISGRANDMOTHER AND THERE THEPOLICE ARRESTEDHIM FORHIS hEXTREMISTv LOOKHEWAS RELEASEDAFTERTHEINTERVENTIONOFAFAMILYMEMBER(ISONLYRELATION WITHONEOFHISSISTERSWASACCOMPANIEDBYHISINTENSEINSISTENCEON CONVERTINGHERTOHISBRANDOF)SLAMASKINGHERTOSTAYHOMEPUT ONTHEVEILNOTWATCHTHE46READTHE)SLAMICBOOKSHEBROUGHTTO HERANDOPENUPAHALALBUSINESS

4HEEXTREMISTVERSIONOFRELIGIONPROFESSEDIN,ONDONBY)SLAMISTS AROUNDRADICALIMAMSFASCINATED-OUSSAOUIWHOFOUNDARELIGIONTHAT WASNOTCONGENIALTOTHE7ESTTREATING7ESTERNERSASEQUALSINSTEAD OFPUTTINGTHEMONAPEDESTALASFORMERCOLONIALISTSORASTHEMASTERS OF THEWORLD(IS LACKOFKNOWLEDGEOF)SLAMMADEHIMEASYPREY FOR*IHADISTSWHOPORTRAYEDhTRUE)SLAMvASALIENTOANYCOMPROMISE WITHTHE7ESTINPARTICULARINRESPECTTOTHEPOLITICALHANDLINGOFTHE -USLIMSAFFAIRSINWHICHTHELATTERWEREUNJUSTLYTREATED

)N%NGLANDONCETHERADICALIZATIONPROCESSHADPROGRESSEDTOA CERTAINDEGREE-OUSSAOUICHANGEDHISOUTLOOKHESHAVEDTHEBEARD THEhTRADITIONALvCLOTHINGGAVEWAYTOCASUALCLOTHESANDTHEFERVENCY ANDAGGRESSIVENESSOFTHEFORMERPERIODWERECAREFULLYHIDDEN4HENEW ATTITUDECANUSUALLYMEANEITHERTHATTHEINDIVIDUALHASGIVENUPHIS FORMERRIGIDRELIGIOUSBELIEFORTHATHENEEDSTOCOVERUPHIS*IHADIST IDENTITYFORTHESAKEOFESCAPINGPOLICEINVESTIGATION

-OUSSAOUISCONNECTIONTO!L1AEDASEEMSESTABLISHEDBECAUSE OFHISSTAYIN"RITAIN"EFORETHETRIBUNALIN!LEXANDRIAHEJUSTIlED TURNINGDOWNHISLAWYERFORTHEFOLLOWINGREASONINHISSOMEWHAT IMPERFECT%NGLISHh&ROMTHElRSTDAYWHEN)WASIN.EW9ORK) UNDERSTOOD THAT!MERICAWANTEDBLOOD OKAY 3O )DIDNTHAVE TO MAKEALLTHISLAWYERARGUMENT!ND)AMNOTALAWYERANYWAY!ND) WASATTACKING)TAKETHEPOSITIONTHATTHEJUDGEWASMYENEMYYOU WEREMYENEMYEVERYBODYWASMYENEMYBECAUSETHATISTHEWAYTO ASSUME)WANTTOKILLYOU)JUSTADMITTHATYOUWANTTOKILLME) WANTTOKILL!MERICANPEOPLE)BELIEVETHATEVERY!MERICANWANTS TOKILLMESOMEHOWv(ISMAJORASSUMPTIONIS THATHEWANTSTO KILL!MERICANSWITHOUTDISTINCTIONANDTHEYWANTTOKILLHIMINTHE SAMEWAY)NHISAGONISTICRELIGIOUSFEELINGWITHHISSENSEOFBEING BESIEGEDTHEREISNOROOMFORNEUTRALLETALONESYMPATHETICATTITUDES TOWARDOTHERSGLOBALLYIDENTIlEDASENEMIES4HEONLYWAYOFRELATING TOTHEMISKILLINGORGETTINGKILLEDINTHENAMEOFARADICALVERSION OF)SLAM(IShRELIGIOSITYvISDEATH CENTEREDINTHEWAYHERELATESTO HIMSELFGETTINGKILLEDBYTHEENEMY ORTOTHEOTHERSKILLINGTHEM ASENEMIESOF!LLAH

-OUSSAOUISATTITUDETOWARDTHE7ESTISINVERTEDCOLONIALISM (EBEARSINMINDCOLONIZATIONANDTHEINFERIORITYOFTHECOLONIZED THE-OROCCANSINHISCASE "YADOPTINGTHEAGONISTICVERSIONOF)S LAMHEVINDICATES-USLIMSSUPERIORITYOVERTHEPAGANSINTHENAME OF!LLAH

)MEANTHEREISTWOASPECTSOKAY(EREISONEASPECTTHAT) WOULDSAYPURELYTHEOLOGICALBASEDONMYRELIGION!NDAFTERTHERE ISMYLIFEEXPERIENCE 3OTHEOLOGICALASPECTREFERTOTHE+ORANWHOONCHAPTER6ERSE PLACETHEOBLIGATIONOFTHE-USLIMTOBETHE3UPERPOWER 3OFROMAN)SLAMICPOINTOFVIEWWEHAVETOBETHE3UPERPOWER 7EHAVETOBEABOVEYOU!NDYOUHAVETOBESUBDUED!NDYOU HAVETOPICKWORDSWHICHWECALLTHEJIZYAH3OMEPEOPLE)MEAN TRANSLATEITASATAXBUTITISNOTATAXITISATRIBUTE!FTERTHAT IT ISBECAUSE!MERICAYOUARETHE3UPERPOWERANDYOUWANTTO ERADICATEUS)SLAMYOUORACRUSADERLIKE'EORGE"USHSAID7E HAVEBEENATWARWITHTHE*EWSANDTHE#HRISTIANSFORYEARS ;SINCETHEINCEPTIONOF)SLAM=4OTHEPOINTTHAT)WILLSAYTHEWORD h#RUSADEvIN%NGLISHISBEINGUSEDASSOMETHINGONGOINGWITHOUT ANEND9OUSAY-OTHER4ERESAWASINACRUSADEAGAINSTPOVERTY IN)NDIA$OYOUUNDERSTAND#RUSADEISSOMETHINGONGOING 4HERELATIONBETWEEN-USLIMSAND*EWSAND#HRISTIANSHASALWAYS BEENATWAROKAY9OUHAVECREATEDTHE3TATEOF)SRAELTHE*EWISH

STATEOF0ALESTINE4HISCOUNTRYTOGIVEYOUAVERYSPECIlCEXAMPLE WHY)AMUPTODESTROYINGTHISCOUNTRY4HEREISNODIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE *EWISH STATE OF0ALESTINE AND(AWAII7ITHOUT !MERICATHEREISNO*EWISH3TATE!NDIFWEWANTTODESTROY THIS*EWISHSTATEANDRE ESTABLISH)SLAMWEWILLHAVETODESTROYYOU lRST

-OUSSAOUIREFERSTOTHEVERSESTHATDElNETHERELATIONSHIPBE TWEEN-USLIMSONTHEONEHAND*EWSAND#HRISTIANSONTHEOTHERIN ACOMPOUNDWAYEITHERTHELATTERSSUBMISSIONANDTRIBUTECONVERSION TO)SLAMORHOLYWAR"UTHEADDSTOTHISTRADITIONALATTITUDEANOTHER EXISTENTIALNOTIONTHE7ESTHASBEENINTENTONDESTROYING)SLAMSINCE ITSBEGINNING4HEIDEAOFTHE/CCIDENTASTHEARCHENEMYTHATWOULD NOTONLYSUBDUE-USLIMSBUTWRECKHAVOCON)SLAMISANEWONE RELATED TO THEMODERNWORLDNOTAPARTOF THE TRADITIONAL )SLAMIC PERCEPTION4HECOLONIALEXPERIENCEANDTHETRAUMAOFTHEBUILDUP OFTHE)SRAELISTATEAREAMONGTHEINGREDIENTSOFTHISEXISTENTIALEXPE RIENCEBUTATTHEROOTOFITTHEREISAFEELINGOFFAILURETHATINDUCES THEABSOLUTE*IHADANDABSOLUTEREJECTIONOFTHEOTHERASTHEENEMY 4RADITIONAL-USLIMSDIDNOTCONSIDERNON -USLIMS IN THIS RADICAL WAY&ORTHEMhPEOPLEOFTHE"OOKvWEREhIMPUREvBUTNOTABSOLUTE ENEMIES2ADICALIZATIONMEANSTHATTHEOTHERSˆNOTONLYTHENON -USLIMSBUTALSOALLTHOSE-USLIMSWHODONOTSHARETHE*IHADIST VIEWˆAREABSOLUTEDEHUMANIZEDENEMIESTOBEANNIHILATED

-OUSSAOUISFEELINGOFBEINGENCIRCLEDBYANALL POWERFULENEMY GOESBACKTOTHEOLDLEFTISTIDEAOFIMPERIALISMINTEGRATEDINTOHIS FRAMEWORKOF)SLAMh;4HEWORLD=ISORGANIZEDTOYOURGREATBENElT TOYOURONLYBENElT"ECAUSEINYOUCHANGEDFROMTHE'OLD 3TANDARDTOTHEDOLLARSTANDARD9OUHAVETHE7ALL3TREETTHE3TOCK %XCHANGEANDYOUORGANIZETRAINSPONSORINEVERYSENSEEVERYPUP PETGOVERNMENTAROUNDTHEWORLDESPECIALLYIN-USLIMCOUNTRIESAND IN!FRICANCOUNTRIES!NDTHEYAREALLYOURSLAVES BECAUSEYOUHAVE ASUPERIORMILITARYTECHNOLOGY9OUHAVEASUPERIORINTELLIGENCEYOU HAVETHEKNOW HOWANDYOUDOTHISVERYSKILLFULLY!NDEVERYTHINGIS DONEBYTHE#)!ANDYOUPRETENDNOTTOKNOWABOUTTHISv

!MERICAHASSHAPEDTHEWORLDTODOMINATEITAND)SLAMISTHE ONLYIDEOLOGYABLETOlGHTAGAINSTTHESUBMISSIONOFTHEWORLD)SLAM REPLACESTHEOLDLEFTISTIDEOLOGYTHATLOSTITSMOMENTUMWITHTHEFALL OFTHE"ERLINWALLIN0ARTICULARLYAMONGTHECONVERTSORTHE%U ROPEANBORN AGAIN-USLIMSTHISASPECTOF)SLAMICRADICALISMISHIGHLY ATTRACTIVE4HERECRIMINATIONSARETHESAMEALLTHERESPONSIBILITYIS BORNEBY!MERICABEITINTHESTREETlGHTSIN0ALESTINEORTHEWARIN "OSNIAh%VERYCHILDIN0ALESTINEISBEINGKILLEDBECAUSEOFYOU7HAT

HAPPENEDIN"OSNIAISBECAUSEOFYOU9OURUNTHESHOW9OUARETHE 5NITED.ATIONS7HEREARETHEY)N.EW9ORK4HE3ECURITY#OUNCIL WHOISSITTINGTHERE)TIS!MERICA9OUJUSTMANUFACTUREDREALITYAND YOUTALKABOUTJUSTICE(UMAN2IGHTSANDYOUSETTHEMINDOFTHE FOOL"UTYOUDIDNTSETMYMINDv4HENOTIONOFhFALSECONSCIOUS NESSvISTAKENUPHERETHISTIMEINREFERENCETO)SLAM4HEALIENATED MASSESHAVETHEIRMINDSETBYTHEIDEOLOGICALISSUESINVENTEDBYTHE 5NITED3TATESLIKEHUMANRIGHTS"UTGENUINE-USLIMSLIKEGENUINE REVOLUTIONARIESARENOTFOOLEDBYTHISMASQUERADE4HEYKNOWWHERE THEULTIMATEREALITYSTANDS

)SLAM ALLOWS ITS FOLLOWERS TO CLAIMPOWER IN THE NAME OF A RIGHTEOUSHOLISTIC CONCEPTIONAND TOCONTEST!MERICANHEGEMONY h9OUHAVEPOWERANDYOUAREGOINGTOˆYOURUNTHESHOW!ND) WANTPOWERAND)WILLRUNTHESHOWv"EFOREEMBRACING)SLAMTHE INDIVIDUALHADONLYSPECIlCANDPERSONALCLAIMS/NCEARMEDWITH THEFAITHIN!LLAHHECANCLAIMGLOBALPOWERHENOLONGERFEELSINFE RIORTOTHEDOMINEERINGELITESWHOAREUNDERTHEAEGISOFTHE5NITED 3TATES)SLAMMAKESPOSSIBLETHECLAIMOFANEWWORLDORDERTHROUGH THEBELIEFIN!LLAH

$URINGTHETRIALMEMBERSOFTHEFAMILIESOFTHEVICTIMSOF3EP TEMBERTESTIlEDANDEXPRESSEDTHEIRGRIEFANDANGUISH-OUSSAOUI WASNOTMOVEDBYTHEIRDISTRESSASHUMANBEINGS(EWASSOMUCH IMBUEDWITHHIS IDEOLOGY THATHE TOTALLYDEHUMANIZED THOSEWHO SUFFEREDPAINATTHELOSSOFTHEIRLOVEDONE(EWASTOTALLYINSENSITIVE TOTHEIRSUFFERINGSHISIDEOLOGYMAKINGCOMPASSIONIMPOSSIBLETHE SUFFERINGSOFTHEhENEMYvBEINGNOCAUSEFORSYMPATHYh!SAPERSON )lNDITDISGUSTINGTHATSOMEPEOPLEWILLCOMEHERETOSHARETHEIR GRIEF;ON3EPTEMBER=INORDERTOOBTAINTHEDEATHOFSOMEBODY ELSE;REFERRINGTOHISOWNDEATHSENTENCE=v

(EGOESFURTHEREXPRESSINGJOYATTHESPECTACLEOFTHEENEMYS WOESh7EWANTTOINmICTPAINONYOURCOUNTRY7EWANTEDˆ)AM GLADTHEYHAVERECEIVEDPAIN)AMGLADTHEIRFAMILYARESUFFERINGPAIN AND)WISHTHEREWOULDBEMOREPAINBECAUSE)ALREADYCANFORECAST AFTERTOMORROWNEXTWEEKTHEWEEKAFTERTHECHILDRENOF0ALESTINE WILLBEINPAIN4HECHILDRENOF#HECHNYAWILLBEINPAIN3OTHIS WOULDSTRIKEMETHATLOTSMOREOFYOURPEOPLEAREINPAINSOTHEYWILL SHAREINTHEPAIN"ECAUSEYOUENJOYLIFEYOUHAVESOMANYTHISAND THATOKAYBUT)WANTYOUTOSHAREINTHEPAINv

(EREWEWITNESSWHAT.IETZSCHECALLEDPURERESENTMENT3INCE ELSEWHEREPEOPLEARESUFFERINGANDSINCETHESUFFERINGISCAUSEDBY !MERICASOTHE!MERICANSSHOULDSUFFERINORDERTORESTORETHEBAL ANCE4HE#HECHNYACHILDRENWHOAREREPRESSEDBYTHE2USSIANSARE MENTIONEDHEREASANOTHERFACEOF!MERICANIMPERIALISM-ORESOTHE

FACTTHAT!MERICANSARERICHANDTHEOTHERSPOORISSEENASANOTHERSIGN OFTHEIRGUILT4HEENTIREMECHANISMISBASEDONARESENTMENT LADEN ATTITUDEANDNOTONABALANCEDVIEWOFTHEADVERSARY!LLTHEILLSOF THEWORLDAREATTRIBUTEDTO!MERICAANDTHEPROBLEMISNOTHOWTO LESSENOTHERSPAINBYLEGITIMATELYlGHTINGTHE!MERICANOR7ESTERN HEGEMONYBUTHOWTOMAKETHEENEMYSUFFERINAWAYTHATBECOMES ANENJOYMENTINITSELFFORTHOSEWHOHAVEPREVIOUSLYSUFFERED

-ANY-USLIMSEVENAMONGTHEMOSTRADICALREJECTTHISATTI TUDE)NTHEPASTATTHEINCEPTIONOFTHE)SLAMICCONQUESTTHERULERS PROHIBITEDTHEARMIESFROMHARMINGTHOSEWHODIDNOTDIRECTLYTAKE PARTINTHEWAR4HECALIPH!BU"AKRTHElRSTRULERAFTERTHE0ROPHET GAVEORDERSTOTHEARMYHESENTTOCONQUERTHENEIGHBORINGCOUNTRIES h)FYOUAREVICTORIOUSDONOTKILLNEITHERWOMENNORCHILDRENDONOT DESTROYANYTHINGDONOTCUTFRUITTREESANDDONOTCUTTHETHROATOF THECATTLEEXCEPTFORWHATYOUEAT)N3YRIATHEREARE#HRISTIANANCHO RITESLIVINGINHERMITAGESWHERETHEYPROFESS#HRISTIANITYFARFROMTHE WORLD4HEYDONOTATTACKNORTROUBLEANYONE$ONOTTROUBLETHEM ANDDONTKILLANYOFTHEMv

7ITH-OUSSAOUIWEAREWORLDSAPARTFROMTHETEMPERANCEOF THEORIGINAL-USLIMSSUPPOSEDLYTHEMODELSOFTHE*IHADISTS%VEN SOMEONELIKETHEMEDIEVALTHEOLOGIAN)BN4AYMIYAHWHOPROFESSED ARADICALVISIONOF)SLAMTHATCALLEDINTOQUESTIONTHEINTERDICTIONOF KILLING-USLIMSUNDERSPECIlCCIRCUMSTANCESWHENTHEARMYOFTHE HERETICSHAD-USLIMSINTHEIRRANKSLIKETHE-ONGOLSINTHETHIRTEENTH ANDFOURTEENTHCENTURIES DIDNOTVIEWTHESUFFERINGOFOTHERSASTHE OFF SETTINGOFONESSUFFERINGS)SLAMINTHEIRVIEWWASJUSTICEANDONE SHOULDNOTINmICTSUFFERINGSONTHEENEMYUNDERTHEPRETEXTOFHAVING SUFFEREDATHISHANDS)NTHISPERSPECTIVEhJUSTICEvMEANSAPPLYINGTHE RULESOF!LLAHINSTEADOFSEEKING3CHADENFREUDE

-OUSSAOUIS CASE ISONEOF A RADICALBORN AGAIN-USLIMWHO BECOMESA*IHADISTTHROUGHACOMPLEXWEBOFRELATIONSINWHICHTHE FOLLOWINGFACTORSPLAYAMAJORROLE

s 4HEFAMILYCRISIS(ISFATHERHADSCHIZOPHRENIAACCORDINGTO&RENCH MEDICAL DOCUMENTS AS DIDHIS TWO SISTERS TODIFFERENTDEGREES ONEUNDERCONSTANTMEDICATION 4HESINGLEPARENTFAMILYTHE OPPRESSIVEPRESENCEOFTHEVIOLENTFATHERANDTHENHISDISAPPEAR ANCEMADETHEPSYCHICSTRUCTUREOFTHEFAMILYALLTHEMOREFRAGILE -OUSSAOUISBROTHER LATEREMBRACEDA&UNDAMENTALISTBRANDOF )SLAMTHE!HBASH-OREGENERALLYTHEANTHROPOLOGICALCRISISWITHIN .ORTH!FRICANFAMILIESIN%UROPEISAFACTORINTHESOCIALPROBLEMS OFYOUNGMALES4HETRANSITIONFROMTHERIGIDLYPATRIARCHALFAMILY TOALOOSESINGLE FAMILYSTRUCTUREPARTICULARLYTRAUMATIZESTHEMALES

INANEGALITARIANENVIRONMENTOFGENDERRELATIONSFORWHICHTHEY ARENOTPREPARED4HEIDENTIlCATIONWITH*IHADIST)SLAMGRANTSTHE MALESTHEIRSUPERIORITYINGENDERRELATIONSTHEYHADLOSTIN7ESTERN SOCIETY

s 4OTALIGNORANCEOF)SLAMANDIDENTIlCATIONWITH&RENCHSOCIETY ANDITSBRANDOFSECULARISMLAÆCIT£ INASITUATIONOFCULTURALUP ROOTEDNESS-ANYOTHER%UROPEAN*IHADISTSSHARETHISFEATURETO SOMEDEGREEEVENIN%NGLAND

s 4HEFEELINGOFMALAISEFROMBEINGhIN BETWEENvWITHINAFRAME WORKTHATDIDNOTGIVEHIMTHEOPPORTUNITYTOlNDHISREALSELF -OUSSAOUIWASCAUGHTBETWEENAFRAGILESENSEOF&RENCHNESSANDA REFERENCETOHIS-OROCCANORIGINTHATWASCONSTANTLYEMPHASIZED HIS ACCENT HIS SKIN COLOR HIS!RABIC NAME THE COLONIAL PAST VIVIDLYPRESENTINSOCIETY BYTHEVERYSAME&RENCHENVIRONMENT THATWASSUPPOSEDTOINTEGRATEHIM)SLAMPROVIDEDHIMWITHAN IDENTITYTHATSOLVEDTHISINSURMOUNTABLEDUALITYHISNEWRELIGIOUS IDENTITYWASATWARWITHBOTHFRAGMENTSOFHISFORMERSPLITSELF THE-OROCCANANDTHE&RENCH

s 4HE*IHADISTENVIRONMENT IN,ONDONTHATALLOWEDHIMTOlND PEOPLEWHOCOULDCONNECTHIMTORADICALGROUPS4HISPLAYEDA MAJORROLEINHISRADICALIZATIONh,ONDONISTANvHADTHE*IHADIST INTELLECTUALSTHE*IHADISTSETTINGINAFEWMOSQUESORTHEIRENVIRON MENTAND*IHADISTNETWORKSUNIMPAIREDBY"RITISHINTELLIGENCE UNTILAFTER3EPTEMBER

s 4OTALIDENTIlCATIONWITHTHEEXTREMISTBRANDOF)SLAMIGNORINGITS CIVILIZATIONCULTUREANDHISTORY)GNORANCEOF)SLAMINTHE-US LIMDIASPORASWHEREPEOPLEBEARAGRUDGEAGAINSTSOCIETYMAKES IDENTIlCATIONWITH*IHADISMEASIER

s 4HEGENERALIZATIONOFHISHATREDOF&RANCETHECOLONIALPOWER THECOUNTRYWHEREHEWASRAISEDWITHOUTENTIRELYBELONGINGTOIT TOTHE7ESTTHROUGHRADICAL)SLAMASACATALYSTANDALEGITIMIZING INSTANCE

s 4HEDUALROLEOFTHEGLOBALIDEOLOGYOF*IHADISMTHATARTICULATES THELEFTISTCRITIQUEOFIMPERIALISM!MERICANhARROGANCEv WITHTHE RIGHTISTCRITIQUEOF7ESTERNBESTIALITYANDDEPRAVITY-OUSSAOUI CALLS!MERICANSTHEh3LAVESOF3ODOMvINONEOFHISLETTERS 4HIS DUALITYSEDUCESAWIDERANGEOFPEOPLEFROMTHOSESEEKINGSOCIAL JUSTICETOTHOSElGHTINGFORAhSANESOCIETYvWITHINTHEAMBITOF RADICAL)SLAM

4HECASEOF-OHAMMED"OUYERIISALSOWORTHMENTIONING(E WASBORNININ!MSTERDAMOF-OROCCANPARENTS!FTERlNISHING HISSECONDARYEDUCATIONHEWENTTOACOLLEGEBUTNEVEROBTAINEDA

DEGREEEVENAFTERlVEYEARSOFSTUDY)NHISYOUTHHEWASAMEMBER OFA-OROCCANSTREETGANG!FTERHISUNSUCCESSFULSTUDIESHEBEGAN WORKINGASAVOLUNTEERINANEIGHBORHOODORGANIZATIONINASUBURBOF !MSTERDAM/NTHEEXISTENTIALSIDEHISRADICALIZATIONOCCURREDAFTER THEDEATHOFHISMOTHERANDTHEREMARRIAGEOFHISFATHERREINFORCEDBY THE3EPTEMBERATTACKSANDTHEWARIN)RAQ(EBEGANTOREFUSETO SERVEALCOHOLTOCLIENTSORTOATTENDMIXED GENDERMEETINGS&INALLY HEPUTANENDTOHISACTIVITIESTHERE(EWOREA*ELLABATRADITIONAL )SLAMICGARB ANDGREWABEARD(EREGULARLYATTENDEDTHE!L4AWHEED MOSQUEWHEREHEMETWITH3AMIR!ZZOUZA RADICAL-USLIMAND OTHER)SLAMISTS7ITHTHEMHEFOUNDEDTHE(OFSTADGROUPALOOSE NETWORKOFMULTICULTURALPEOPLEWHOMETNOWANDTHENINHISmAT AMONGWHOMWERETWOBROTHERS*ASON7ALTERSALIAS!BU-UJAHIED !MRIKIOR*AMALSEEHISCASEABOVE LATERSENTENCEDTOlFTEENYEARS IMPRISONMENTANDHISBROTHER*ERMAINEWHOWASACQUITTEDBYTHE TRIBUNAL

!CCORDINGTO"OUYERIHEFULlLLEDHIS)SLAMICDUTYBYPERPETRAT INGTHEMURDEROF4HEOVAN'OGHIN.OVEMBER(ISDEEPBELIEF WAS THAT ONLY THROUGH *IHAD COULD-USLIMS COPEWITH THE7ESTS ANTAGONISMTOWARD)SLAM"OUYERISCASEDOESNOTREVEALANYDIRECT CONNECTIONTOINTERNATIONAL*IHADISTORGANIZATIONS(EANDHISFRIENDS WEREFROM!MSTERDAMALLOFTHEMWEREOF-OROCCANORIGINBESIDES TWOORTHREECONVERTSTO)SLAM(EREASINSOMEOTHERCASESONECAN SPEAKOFhHOMEGROWN*IHADISMvINCONTRASTTOTHOSEGROUPSLINKED TOOUTSIDETERRORISTORGANIZATIONS

!PART FROMBORN AGAIN-USLIMSWHO AREBORN AND RAISED IN %UROPE ONE CAN ALSOlND THOSEWHO SPENT LONG YEARS IN%UROPE UNDERWENTINTENSECULTURALINmUENCEBUTTHENVIOLENTLYREJECTEDIT ANDTURNEDTO*IHADISMFOREXISTENTIALREASONSRACISMORFEAROFLOSING ONESSOUL ORPOLITICALREASONSTHEWARIN!FGHANISTAN)RAQAMONG OTHERS 4HECASEOF3ARHANE"EN!BDELMAJID&AKHETTHEPRESUMED LEADEROFTHE-ADRIDBOMBINGSON-ARCHISACASEINPOINT (EGREWUPINAMIDDLE CLASSFAMILYIN4UNISIAANDRECEIVEDA3PANISH GOVERNMENTSCHOLARSHIPTOSTUDYECONOMICSIN-ADRIDIN(E WASASERIOUSSTUDENTOFTHE!UTONOMOUS5NIVERSITYOF-ADRIDONE OFTHEBEST3PANISHUNIVERSITIESFORECONOMICS(EWORKEDASWELLIN THEREALESTATESECTORANDWASPROlCIENTINTHATJOB!FTERAFEWYEARS HEGAVEUPHISSTUDIESANDBECAMEADEVOUT-USLIM0ROGRESSIVELYHE BECAMEAPILLAROFTHEMOSQUESTURNINGMOREANDMORERADICAL4HE WARIN)RAQANDTHEPARTICIPATIONOFTHE3PANISHGOVERNMENTINITMADE *IHADISTACTIVITYINEVITABLEFORHIM(EDIEDATTHEAGEOFTHIRTY lVE INAmATAT,EGANEASUBURBOF-ADRIDBLOWINGITUPWHENTHEPOLICE RAIDEDIT)NAVIDEOLEFTINTHERUBBLEHECOMPAREDTHEINVASIONOF

!FGHANISTANAND)RAQTOTHATOF-USLIM3PAINBYTHE#HRISTIANSAND THEEXPULSIONOF-USLIMSFROM3PAININTHESIXTEENTHCENTURY(E CLAIMEDhBLOODFORBLOODvANDhDESTRUCTIONFORDESTRUCTIONvASTHE JUSTIlCATIONFORTHE-ADRIDBOMBINGS

)SLAMBECOMESASACREDIDENTITYWHENTHEFORMERIDENTITYTHE PARENTSORTHEONETOWHICHONECLUNGBEFORELIVINGALONGTIMEIN THE7EST BECOMESFUZZYORIMPOSSIBLETOEMBODYANDTHE7ESTERN IDENTITY ISDENIEDAS IN THECASEOFMANY%UROPEAN*IHADISTSWHO FEELREJECTEDASFULLCITIZENS ORSIMPLYOUTOFREACH!NYDISRESPECT TOWARD)SLAMBECOMESAMATTEROFLIFEORDEATHFORTHESENEWZEALOTS FORWHOM)SLAMISNOTONLYARELIGIONBUTANEWIDENTITYANTAGONISTIC TOTHESOCIETIESINWHICHTHEYLIVE4HECONJUNCTIONOFMANYFACTORS ISSIGNIlCANTTHEWARSIN!FGHANISTANAND)RAQTOWHICHMANY%URO PEANCOUNTRIESPARTICIPATEDBEINGAPOLITICALCATALYSTFORTHEIRHATRED OFTHE7EST

4YPESOF*IHADIST'ROUPS

4HEREAREMANYTYPESOF*IHADISTGROUPSINTHE7EST4HElRSTISTHE CULTICONEBUILTMOSTLYAROUNDACHARISMATIClGURE!TTHEBEGIN NINGITISMOREORLESSOPENTOTHEOUTSIDEWORLDBUTTHEPSYCHOSOCIAL DYNAMICSPUSH IT TOWARDBEINGCLOSED#ERTAINEVENTSˆTRIGGERSˆ ENCOURAGETHEMEMBERSOFTHEGROUPTOACTVIOLENTLY4HETARGETCAN BESPECIlCFORINSTANCE4HEO6AN'OGHASANANTI )SLAMICPUBLIC lGUREFORTHE(OFSTADGROUP ORMOREGENERALTHEATTACKONANENTIRE SOCIETYAGOVERNMENTORALARGEGROUPASTHECASEOF!L1AEDAAT TACKINGTHE4WIN4OWERSIN.EW9ORKAHOTELIN%GYPTORIN*ORDAN KILLINGTOURISTSWORKERSANDTHEMANONTHESTREET 4HISTYPEOFCULTIC GROUPUSUALLYHASALEADERANDMOREORLESSFOLLOWSHISORDERS!FTER 3EPTEMBERTHISTYPEHASBEENINDECLINEINTHE7ESTTHOUGHNOT INTHE-USLIMWORLD

!SECONDTYPEOF*IHADISTGROUPISMADEOFFRIENDSANDhBUDDIESv 4HEREISNORIGIDHIERARCHYWITHINTHEGROUPANDTHEYACTTOGETHERIN ANINFORMALWAYWITHOUTMUCHHIERARCHY-ANYNEWGROUPSBUILDING UPIN%UROPEANDELSEWHERESEEMTOHAVESOMEKINDOFAFlNITYWITH THISTYPEWHICHISEGALITARIANFRIENDLYLOOSEANDNONHIERARCHICAL4HIS SORTOFGROUPMAINLYIDENTIlEDBY-ARC3AGEMANISSUPPOSEDNOTTO HAVEAFORMALLEADERSHIP)TISDIFlCULTTOIDENTIFYSPECIlCGROUPSTHAT ENTIRELYSATISFYTHISCATEGORY3TILLONECANSAYTHATTHISTYPEOFLOOSE GROUPBASEDONTHEAFlNITYOFTHEMEMBERSFRIENDSHIPLOCALTIESAND FAMILYRELATIONS ISONEOFTHEMAJORCOMPONENTSOFPOSTn3EPTEMBER *IHADISMATLEASTINTHE7ESTERNWORLD

!THIRDTYPEOFGROUPISMAINLYBASEDONFAMILYTIESALONGGEN ERATIONALLINKAGESSOMETIMESBRINGINGTOGETHERFATHERSSONSUNCLES COUSINSANDEVENDAUGHTERSSISTERSORWIVES4HEFAMILYGROUPCAN CONSTITUTEASUBGROUPWITHINALARGERONE4HE"ENCHELLALICELLMADE OFTHEFATHERTHREESONSANDTHEMOTHERHASBEENPARTOFAMUCHLARGER *IHADISTCELLTHESO CALLED#HECHNYANGROUPMADEOFSOMETWENTY lVE PEOPLECONVICTEDBYA&RENCHTRIBUNALIN/NEOFTHEBROTHERS -ENAD"ENCHELLALIPARTICIPATEDASANEXPERTINTHEFABRICATIONOFTHE POISONRICIN)NTHE5NITED3TATESTHEGROUPISREFERREDTOASTHEh&RENCH POISONCELLv4HESEFAMILIESAREUSUALLYMADEOFPEOPLEBELONGINGTO DIFFERENTCULTURESANDTHEYOUNGERGENERATIONISCAUGHTUPBETWEEN TWOORMORECULTURESANDWORLDS4HE"ENCHELLALIFAMILYCONSISTSOF PEOPLEOF!LGERIANNATIONALITYTHEFATHERANDONEBROTHER-EROUANE "ENAHMED ANDONE-ENADOF&RENCHCITIZENSHIP5SUALLYTHEYARE ILLATEASEEXISTINGBETWEENTWOEXTREMELYDIFFERENTWORLDS

4HE#ANADIAN CASE OF THE+HADR FAMILY EXTENDS OVER THREE GENERATIONS4HEGRANDFATHER!HMED3AÆD+HADRLEFT%GYPTINTHE SANDMIGRATEDTO#ANADAWHERETHEENTIREFAMILYSETTLED4HEY HADFOURSONSANDTWODAUGHTERS4HEFATHERTRAVELEDEXTENSIVELYTO 0AKISTANAND!FGHANISTANASAMEMBEROF!L1AEDAINTHES 4HEFAMILYMOVEDFROM#ANADATO0AKISTANIN)N0AKI STANIAUTHORITIESARRESTED!HMED+HADR(ISBROTHER/MAR+HADR RETURNEDWITHHISOTHERBROTHERSANDSISTERSTO#ANADATOSTAYWITH THEIRGRANDPARENTS/MARRETURNEDTO0AKISTANANDTHENTO!FGHANI STAN)NHEWASARRESTEDBYTHE5NITED3TATESAFTERlGHTINGTHE !MERICANS(EWAS IMPRISONED IN'UANTANAMO )N HEWAS CHARGEDWITHCRIMINALACTIVITYWITHIN!L1AEDAˆFORKILLINGA53 SOLDIER!NOTHER BROTHER!BDULRAHAMWAS ARRESTED IN+ABUL AND HANDEDOVERTOTHE!MERICANS4HEFATHERWASKILLED INTHEBATTLE AGAINSTTHE5NITED3TATESAFTERHISRELEASETHROUGHBRIBERYIN0AKISTAN ANDHISRETURNTO!FGHANISTAN

!LTHOUGHMUCH OF THE STORY IS STILL AMATTER OF CONJECTURE ONE FACT REMAINS THE FATHERHAD AN%GYPTIAN IDENTITY THE FAMILY BECAME INVOLVED IN 0AKISTAN THROUGH!L1AEDA LINKS THE FATHER TRAVELED EXTENSIVELY BETWEEN#ANADA 0AKISTAN AND!FGHANISTAN ANDTHEYOUNGERGENERATIONPARTIALLYDIDTHESAMEBELONGINGTOTHE hIN BETWEENv4HECULTURALFACTORBYITSELFCERTAINLYDOESNOTEXPLAIN THEIRINVOLVEMENTIN*IHADISTACTIVITIESBUTTHEFACTTHATTHEFATHER WASINVOLVEDPLAYEDAMAJORROLEASINTHECASEOFTHE"ENCHELLALI FAMILY4HECONmATIONOFCULTURALFACTORSANDTHElGUREHEADOFTHE FATHERFACILITATESTHEMEMBERSHIPOFTHESONSANDEVENTHEMOTHER INTHE"ENCHELLALICASE 5SUALLYIN*IHADISTCASESTHEFAMILYIGNORES THEINVOLVEMENTOFTHEIRSON7ITHINTHEMODELOFTHEFAMILYCELL

THEENLARGED*IHADIST IDENTITYATTRACTS THEYOUNGERGENERATION INA CHARACTERISTICINVERSIONUSUALLYTHESONJOINSTHE*IHADUNLIKETHE FATHERWHOISTRADITIONALLYMINDEDANDQUIETIST 4HEINVOLVEMENTOF THEYOUNGERGENERATIONSOMETIMESOCCURSINAWAYTHATISNOTALWAYS FULLYCONSCIOUS3OMEMEMBERSCLAIMTHATTHEYWEREENROLLEDIN*IHAD WITHOUTTRULYAPPRECIATINGTHEIRNEWROLEANDONCECAUGHTUPINTHE NEWSYSTEMTHEYHADALMOSTNOCHOICE

!FOURTHTYPEOF*IHADISTGROUPISMADEOFPEOPLEIDENTIFYING WITHASETOFCHARISMATICPEOPLEWHOhSHAREvTHEIRCHARISMAONEIS CHARISMATICINTHElELDOFORGANIZATIONTHEOTHERINMONEYMAKING ANDRELATINGTOTHEOUTSIDEWORLDANOTHERINTHElELDOFTECHNICALSKILLS EXPLOSIVESFOREXAMPLE 4HEREISANIMPLICITHIERARCHYWITHINTHE GROUPBUTTHEREISNOFORMALLEADER4HE*IHADISTGROUPTHATBOMBED THETRAININ-ADRIDINSEEMSTOBELONGTOTHISCATEGORY

!FTER3EPTEMBERTHEREWASNOMOREROOMFORLARGEGROUPS INTHE7EST4HESMALLGROUPSTHATFORMAROUNDASINGLEPERSONARE NOTSTRICTLYHIERARCHICALBUTTHEREISSTILLONEWHOPLAYSTHEROLEOF THERINGLEADER)NTHE&RENCHCASETHEGROUPTHATSENTITSMEMBERSIN )RAQTOlGHTTHE53ARMYHADALEADER&ARID"ENYETTOU/NEOFTHE MEMBERS"OUBAKEREL(AKIMA&RENCHMANOF4UNISIANORIGINWAS SENTTO&RANCEFROM3YRIATOBEINDICTEDASAMEMBEROFATERRORIST ORGANIZATION(ISBROTHER2EDOUANENINETEENYEARSOLDWASKILLEDIN )RAQ(EWASFROMTHENINETEENTHDISTRICTOF0ARISANDHEKNEW&ARID "ENYETTOUTHESPIRITUALLEADEROFTHEGROUPANDTHERECRUITERWHOWAS INDICTEDIN*ANUARYANDJAILEDFORORGANIZINGTHEDEPARTUREOF THEGROUPMEMBERSTO)RAQ

)NTHE7ESTERNWORLDWHERELARGE SCALE*IHADISTOPERATIONSARE BECOMINGHIGHLYIMPROBABLETHENEWCELLSSMALLINSIZEAREUSUALLY ANIMATEDBYANEWTYPEOFLEADERWHODOESNOTHOLDARIGIDLYHIERAR CHICALPOSITIONWITHINTHEGROUPBUTSTILLENJOYSASPIRITUALPRIVILEGEOF PRIMUSINTERPARESRATHERTHANANABSOLUTEPOSITIONOFANUNDISPUTED LEADER4HENEWlGUREHEADSMOREANDMORELOOKLIKETHEhLEOPARD CHIEFvOFPRIMITIVESOCIETIESWHERETHEIRPRIVILEGESARENOTSOMUCH INMAKINGDECISIONSINANABSOLUTEMANNERBUTINHAVINGADIFFUSE INmUENCEWITHINTHEGROUPTHATMAKESTHEMSLIGHTLYABOVETHEAVERAGE ANDMAKESPOSSIBLESOMECRUCIALORIENTATIONSWITHINTHEGROUP

4YPESOF*IHADIST)NDIVIDUALS

/NE CAN DISTINGUISH lVE TYPES OF *IHADIST PERSONALITIES THEMIS SIONARYTHEMACHOTHEUPHOLDEROFJUSTICETHEADVENTURERANDTHE EXISTENTIALMAN

4HEMISSIONARYSEEKSTOEXPAND)SLAMTOTHEWORLDACCORDING TOTHERELIGIOUSWRIT!MONGTHE*IHADISTSSOMEWOULDLIKETOBEHAVE ACCORDINGTOTHELETTEROFTHEHOLYTEXT4HEYlRMLYBELIEVETHAT)SLAM HASTHECALLINGOFBECOMINGUNIVERSALANDNOCOMPROMISESHOULDBE MADEONTHISMISSION4HERELATIONBETWEEN-USLIMSANDOTHERSIS ONLYTHREE FOLDEITHERTHEIRCONVERSIONTO)SLAMORTHEIRPAYINGTAXES JIZYAH OR *IHAD4HESE PEOPLE BELIEVE THAT HUMILIATION OF OTHERS THROUGHBOMBINGMAIMINGANDKILLINGISANECESSITYTOIMPLEMENT !LLAHS SENTENCE AT THE PRESENT TIME BECAUSE OF-USLIMSMILITARY INFERIORITYTOWARDTHE7EST4HISTYPEOFWARRIORINTENDSTOSPREAD )SLAMTHROUGHHOLYWARUNLIKETHE-USLIM&UNDAMENTALISTSWHO AIMATTHESAMEGOALTHROUGHPEACEFULMEANS

4HESECONDTYPEISTHEMACHO&ORHIM)SLAMRESTORESTHEFAMILY ANDSOCIALBONDSONASANEBASISACCORDINGTOMENSNEEDS!CCORD INGTOTHE+ORANAMANHASTHERIGHTTOMARRYUPTOFOURWIVESON CONDITIONOFBEINGhJUSTvTOWARDTHEMHECANIMPOSEINTHENAMEOF !LLAHhMODESTYvONWOMENANDEXERTHISAUTHORITYTOWARDCHILDREN WITHINAPATRIARCHALFAMILY)NTHE*IHADISTSMINDSTHISDIMENSION ISCONNECTEDTOANOTHERTHEREJECTIONOF7ESTERNSEXUALANDMORE GENERALLYGENDERVALUES(OMOSEXUALITYHASTOBEBANNEDASWELLAS hPORNOGRAPHYvˆTHATISTHEhNUDITYvOFWOMENTHEIRAPPEARANCEIN THEPUBLICSPHERETHEIRWORKOUTSIDETHEHOMEANDEVENSOMETIMES THEIREDUCATIONONPARITYWITHMEN!PATRIARCHALVERSIONOF)SLAM IS STILL LEGITIMATE FORMANY ORTHODOX-USLIMS ALL OVER THEWORLD AND*IHADISTSEXPLOITTHISCONVERGENCEOFTHEIRVIEWWITHTHATOFTHE &UNDAMENTALISTSANDEVENMERELYORTHODOX-USLIMSTOATTRACTTHEM #ONTRARYTO)SLAMTHESAMEPATRIARCHALVERSIONOFFAMILYANDGENDER VISIONIN#HRISTIANITYOR*UDAISMCANNOTBEANYTHINGBUTASECTARIAN ORATBESTMARGINALCONCEPTION!STRINGENTFORMOFMACHISMOIN THENAMEOFTRADITIONAL)SLAMISTHUSSHAREDBYORTHODOX-USLIMS &UNDAMENTALISTSAND*IHADISTSALIKE"UTVIOLENCEISJUSTIlEDONLYBY *IHADISTS TOOPPOSE7ESTERNCULTURE THATCONTAMINATES-USLIMS IN THE7ESTERNDIASPORASANDINTHE-USLIMWORLDTHROUGHILLEGITIMATE GOVERNMENTSWHICHARESUBSERVIENTTOTHE7EST

4HESECONDTYPEMAKESCULTURALVALUESONEOFTHEMAINREASONS FORVIOLENTLYREJECTINGTHE7ESTANDTHESPREADOF ITSVALUES TOTHE WORLD!MONG7ESTERN *IHADISTS THE FASCINATIONWITH THIS ASPECT OF )SLAMGOESHAND INHANDWITH THE hCASTRATIONv FEELINGOFMANY MENWHOHAVEEXPERIENCEDTHEhDISPOSSESSIONvOFTHEIRVIRILITYAND MANHOODBYEMANCIPATEDWOMEN)SLAMINITS&UNDAMENTALISTAND *IHADISTVERSIONSISTHEMAJORPROPONENTOFTHISTYPEOFMACHISMO BECAUSEMANY*IHADISTSCONSIDERITASTHEONLYGENUINEOPPONENTOF 7ESTERNDEPRAVITY4HISDIMENSIONOFPATRIARCHAL)SLAMISAKINTOTHE

ARCHCONSERVATIVEMOVEMENTSINTHE7ESTBUT*IHADISMMAKESVIO LENCELEGITIMATEINOTHERPERSPECTIVESASWELLALLOWINGTHEADHERENTS TOCOMBINEDIFFERENTLOGICSOFACTIONWITHINTHISFRAMEWORKWHICH #HRISTIANCONSERVATIVEGROUPSCANNOTEASILYAFFORDTOREALIZE !NTI IMPERIALISTLOGICISONEOFTHEM

4HETHIRDTYPEISTHEJUSTICESEEKER)NJUSTICEINTHEWORLDISDUE TOTHE7ESTERNANDMOREPARTICULARLY!MERICANHEGEMONY4HElGHT AGAINST IT CANNOTBEBASEDON LEFTIST IDEOLOGIES ANYMORE-USLIMS ARE THE hOPPRESSEDv MUSTADHAlN AND THE LEGITIMACYOF THElGHT AGAINST THEhOPPRESSORSv MUSTAKBIRIN IS RECOGNIZEDBY THE+ORAN -ANYDIMENSIONSOFTHEEXTREMELEFTIDEOLOGIESARECOUPLEDWITHTHE LUREOFTAKINGAhHOLYvREVENGEAGAINSTTHE7EST4HEHUMILIATIONS ENDUREDBY-USLIMSINMANYPARTSOFTHEWORLDRELATEDINAREALOR IMAGINARYWAYTO/CCIDENTALHEGEMONYMAKES*IHADIST)SLAMTHEONLY MAJORBEAREROFTHEANTI IMPERIALISTSTANDARDINTHE7ESTPARTICULARLY AMONGTHECONVERTS

4HEFOURTHTYPEISTHEADVENTURER*IHADISMHASAPLAYDIMEN SIONTHATCANBESATISlEDINMANYWAYS4HEADVENTUREINVOLVEDIN TAKINGTRIPSANDJOURNEYSALLOVERTHEWORLDUPTOAFEWYEARSAGOIT WASMUCHEASIERSINCE3EPTEMBERITHASBECOMERISKIERANDINA WAYMOREEXCITING ISONEOFTHESTIMULATINGDIMENSIONSOF*IHADISM THEADVENTUREOFMEETINGhEXTRAORDINARYvPEOPLEWHOMAKEHISTORYIS ANOTHERONE3OCIALIZATIONWITHINTHESEGROUPSTHROUGHTHE)NTERNET ORDIRECTLINKSBREATHESLIFEINTOANOTHERWISEGREYEXISTENCEUSUALLY WITHOUTANYMAJOREXCITEMENTANOTHERASPECTISTHEMULTICULTURALONE MANYPEOPLEWITHDIFFERENTBACKGROUNDSANDCULTURESMIXUPWITHIN *IHADISTGROUPS4HEYTHUSREALIZEAUNIVERSALISTICCALLINGINTHENAME OF!LLAHSFAITH4HEADVENTURERCANBEASWELLMOTIVATEDBYWHATIS INhVOGUEvANDhFASHIONvINTHESAMEWAYASMARTYRSINTHE)RANIAN REVOLUTIONWHOWEREPROUDTOFOLLOWAhMARTYRDOMFASHIONv4HEYTHUS MODERNIZEDMARTYRDOMTHROUGHTHEIDENTIlCATIONWITHTHEhVOGUEv AND)SLAMIZEDMODERNITYBYCONVERTINGTHEhFADvTOAhSACREDvACT 7ITHINTHElGUREHEADOFTHEHOLYADVENTURER*IHADISMINTEGRATESMANY DIMENSIONSOFMODERNEXHIBITIONISMFASHIONANDEMOTIONALISM

!DVENTURERSNEEDTOBECOMEhSOMEONEv THROUGHEXCITEMENT &ROMTHESTATUSOFhNOBODYvTHEYACCEDETOTHERANKOFAWORLDlGURE THROUGHTHEMEDIA4HEYREVERE"IN,ADENNOTONLYBECAUSEOFHIS ROLEASAN)SLAMIC2OBIN(OODWHOTAKESREVENGEAGAINSTTHEPOWER FULFORTHESAKEOFTHEhOPPRESSEDvBUTALSOBECAUSEOFHISSTARDOM #ONTRARY TO7ESTERN STARS HE IS A hSACRED STARv HE COMBINES THE LOGICOFSTARDOMWITHTHATOFNOBILITY5NLIKEhCHEAPv7ESTERNSTARS WHOJUSTIMITATEACTIONINTHEIRFAKEHEROISMHEDOESWHATHESAYS "IN,ADENANDOTHERlGURESOF*IHADISMBECOMEICONSFORTHEYOUNG

*IHADISTSIN%UROPEWHONEEDTOBEhSOMEBODYvSATISFYTHEIRHOPES FOR EXCITEMENT AND REALIZE THEIR DESIRE OF SURPASSING THE7ESTERN hMASTERSvWHOCOLONIZEDTHEIRFATHERSANDMARGINALIZEDTHEIRhSONSv INPOORDISTRICTS4HESENSEOFADVENTURECOMBINEDWITHTHELOGICOF REALIZINGONESSELFBYHUMILIATINGTHEhDAMNED7ESTERNERSvISPART OFTHEFASCINATIONEXERTEDBY*IHADISMONTHEMINDOFMANYYOUNG UPROOTED%UROPEAN-USLIMS4HROUGHVIOLENCEINTHENAMEOFTHE HOLYWARTHEYWOULDLIKETOSHAKETHEYOKEOFINTERNALIZEDHUMILIA TIONBYCOMBININGITWITHHYPER EXCITEMENT

)NMANY%UROPEANCOUNTRIESINSPITEOFTHEPASSINGOFMORETHAN HALFACENTURYTHECOLONIALMEMORYISSTILLATTHEBACKOFTHEIRMINDS 0ARTICULARLYIN&RANCETHE!LGERIANDRAMAOFTHEWAROFINDEPENDENCE THEDEATHSOFHUNDERDSOFTHOUSANDSANDTHEFORCEDDEPARTUREOFMORE THANONEMILLION&RENCHBORNANDRAISEDIN!LGERIAISFARFROMOVERIN THEMINDSANDHEARTSOFMANYPEOPLE)N%NGLANDACOUNTRYWITHA MULTICULTURALPOLICYETHNICMINORITIESDONOTMIXEASILYANDTHERATE OFINTERMARRIAGEISNOTHIGH4HECOLONIALPASTISPRESENTINTHEFORMOF MUTUALAVOIDANCEANDhLEAVINGAPARTv4HEPOLICIESOF"RITAINTOWARD )RAQAND!FGHANISTANANDITSSIDINGWITHTHE!MERICANGOVERNMENT FORTHEOCCUPATIONOFTHETWOCOUNTRIESFROMONWARDHASBEEN INTERPRETEDBYMANY-USLIMCITIZENSASANANTI )SLAMICPOLICYREMI NISCENTOFCOLONIALARROGANCE'ENERALLYSPEAKINGTHEANTI COLONIAL DIMENSIONOF*IHADISMIN%UROPEISNOTNEGLIGIBLEANDCONmATEDWITH THEFEELINGOFBEINGSECOND CLASSCITIZENSPREDISPOSESPARTOFTHENEW GENERATIONSTOWARDRADICALIZATIONINTHENAMEOF!LLAH

4HELASTTYPEOF*IHADISTISTHEEXISTENTIALMAN4HEDEEPCRISIS BETWEENMULTIPLEIDENTITIESREJECTEDBYTHEHOSTSOCIETIESISAMAJOR PROBLEM FOR THIS GROUP4HE hNEITHERNORv IS PARAMOUNT NEITHER !LGERIANNOR&RENCHIN&RANCETHESECONDANDTHIRDGENERATIONOF YOUTHREJECTEDFORBEINGh!RABvANDIN!LGERIAFORBEINGh&RENCHv THESAMESITUATIONHOLDINGTRUEFORTHE%NGLISH0AKISTANIS 4HISDUAL IDENTITYISINFACTADOUBLEDENIALOFIDENTITYSINCEEACHDIMENSION &RENCHNESSFOR&RANCEAND!LGERIANNESSFOR!LGERIA ISDISCARDEDBY BOTHSOCIETIES&RANCEAND!LGERIA%NGLANDAND0AKISTAN

4HESPLITSELFCANBEPUSHEDTOWARD*IHADISMTHROUGHTWOMAJOR FACTORS4HElRSTISTHEDEEPHUMILIATIONFROMNOTBEINGSEENASEQUAL TOTHEOTHERSIN7ESTERNCULTUREWHEREEQUALITYISAMAJORINGREDIENTOF COLLECTIVEIDENTITY.OTBEINGhTHESAMEvMEANSINTHEETHNIC%NGLISH GHETTOESORINTHEPOOR&RENCHBANLIEUESBEINGhINFERIORvTOTHEOTHERS 4HEREISNOSTATUSINTHEDOMINANT%UROPEANCULTUREFORTHISTYPEOF INFERIORITYCONTRARYTOTHETRADITIONALCULTURESTHATIMPOSEAHIERARCHY LIKETHE)NDIANCASTESYSTEM )NANEGALITARIANCULTURETHEFEELING OFINSURMOUNTABLEINFERIORITYISTHEMOREEXCRUCIATINGSINCEITHAS

NOLEGITIMACYANDNOLOCUSWITHINTHECULTURE2ADICAL)SLAMRESOLVES THEDILEMMABYREJECTINGBOTHOFTHEINGREDIENTSOFTHEFORMERSPLIT IDENTITYTHE&RENCHAND!LGERIANCOMPONENTSAREDECLAREDILLEGITIMATE ANDGODLESSINTHESAMEMANNERASTHE0AKISTANIAND%NGLISHONES*I HADISMINITSMODERNVERSIONINTHE7ESTISDEEPLYEGALITARIANBLACKS WHITESETHNICPEOPLEFROMALLOVERTHEWORLDBECOMEMEMBERSOFA NEWhINTERNATIONAL*IHADISMvTHATREALIZESTHROUGHTHElGHTAGAINST THE7ESTTHEVERYEGALITARIANVALUESPROMOTEDBYTHE7EST)TWASHES AWAYHUMILIATIONANDREPLACESITWITHADEEPSENSEOFPRIDEITERASES APAINFULDUALIDENTITYWITHASOLIDEVENMONOLITHICONEBASEDON RELIGIONINWHICHDOUBTISREJECTEDASANEVILCHARACTERISTICPECULIAR TOTHEhDEPRAVED7ESTERNERv

4HEEXISTENTIAL*IHADISTREALIZESHISDREAMTHROUGHTHEIDENTIl CATIONWITHHOLYWARHITHERTOHEBELONGSTOAhWARMvCOMMUNITY THENEO 5MMAINSHARPCONTRASTWITHBEFOREWHENHEBELONGEDTO NOWHEREINSOCIETIESTHATAREATBESThCOLDv4HENEO 5MMAISMORE THANWARMITIShEFFERVESCENTvANDITBRINGSMEANINGTOTHELIFEOF THEBELIEVERANDASSIGNSANIDEALTOITNAMELYTHEMERCILESSCOMBAT AGAINSTTHEARROGANT/CCIDENTWHEREIMPERIALISMGOESHANDINHAND WITHGODLESSNESSANDMORALDEPRAVITY

7OMENAND-ARTYRDOM

$URINGTHELONGWARBETWEEN)RANAND)RAQn WOMENS ROLEASMARTYRSINTHEYOUNG)SLAMIC2EPUBLICWASONLYANINDIRECTONE THEYCOULDNOTTAKEPARTINTHEWARASSOLDIERSANDMEETMARTYRDOM INTHESAMEFASHIONASMEN4HEYCOULDDIEASMARTYRSBYNURSING WOUNDEDSOLDIERSANDSUCCUMBINGUNDERTHE)RAQIBOMBINGS4HEY EVENCOULDBERECOGNIZEDASMARTYRSIFTHEYDIEDLIKEMANYMENAS ARESULTOFTHEAIRSTRIKESBY)RAQIlGHTERJETS7OMENWEREDENIED DIRECTPARTICIPATIONAShMARTYR SOLDIERSv IN"ASSIJ THEORGANIZATION THATMAINLYENROLLEDYOUNGVOLUNTEERSIN)RANALTHOUGHTHEREWASA DEMANDINTHATDIRECTIONBYMANYYOUNGREVOLUTIONARYGIRLS

)NMANYOTHERCOUNTRIESWOMENHAVEGAINEDSOMEFOOTHOLD WITHIN*IHADISTORGANIZATIONS)N#HECHNYATHEIRROLEHASBEENIMPOR TANT)N0ALESTINEANINCREASINGNUMBEROFWOMENHAVEBEENINVOLVED INSUICIDEATTACKSINRECENTYEARSWHEREASINTHE*IHADISTMOVEMENT IN*ORDAN%GYPTAND)RAQTHEREHASBEENMARGINALINVOLVEMENTOF WOMENUPTONOW"UTTHEIRROLEHASALWAYSBEENCLOSETOTHATOFTHE FOOTSOLDIERANDNOTWITHINTHELEADERSHIPOFTHESEMOVEMENTS

4HEREISAPARADOXINTHE*IHADISTMOVEMENTVIS Í VISWOMEN /NTHEONEHAND*IHADISTSDENOUNCETHEPRESENCEOFWOMENINTHE

PUBLICSPHEREANDlGHTFORTHEIRRETURNTOTHEFAMILY4HEYREJECTTHE 7ESTERNIDEAOFTHEEQUALITYOFMENANDWOMENANDPROPOSEARIGID VIEWOFTHE3HARIAHTHATREFUSESTORECOGNIZEAFORMALROLEFORWOMEN INTHEPOLITICALOREVENTHEECONOMICANDCULTURALSPHEREOTHERTHAN THATOFTHEMOTHERSISTERORWIFE"UTONTHEOTHERHANDTHEHARDFACTS OFTHEMODERNWORLDPUSH*IHADISTSTOACCEPTWITHSOMERELUCTANCE THEPARTICIPATIONOFWOMENATLEASTWITHINTHEFAMILYANDTHECITY TOSPREAD*IHADISTIDEOLOGY

!MONG THE *IHADIST IDEOLOGUES9USUF AL5YAYRIWAS ONE OF THOSEYOUNGhSOLDIERINTELLECTUALSvWHOATTACHEDAMAJORIMPORTANCE TOWOMEN)NHISWRITINGSONWOMENANDTHEIRROLEINTHE*IHADHE CALLSOUTTO-USLIMWOMENANDASKSFORTHEIRASSISTANCEINASITUA TIONWHERETHEREISAhNEWCRUSADERSWARvAGAINSTTHEWORLDOF)SLAM 5YAYRI SUMMONSWOMEN TO HELP BECAUSEMANY-USLIMS AND IN PARTICULARWOMENBELIEVETHAT*IHADSHOULDBEAVOIDEDBECAUSEITIS THEPATHTODEATHFORTHEIRFAMILY!CCORDINGTO5YAYRITHEPREDICA MENTOFTHE-USLIMSISTHEIRWILLINGNESSTOACQUIESCETOINFERIORITY ANDHUMILIATIONANDTHEIRLACKOFDETERMINATIONFOR*IHADBECAUSEOF THEIRLETHARGYANDLOVEOFLIFEINTHISWORLD4HEONLYWAYTORESOLVE THEPROBLEMISVIOLENT*IHAD

4ODAY5YAYRICONTENDSTHATWOMENASMOTHERSWIVESDAUGH TERSORSISTERSAREANOBSTACLETO*IHADSINCETHEYFORBIDTHEIRMEN TOENGAGEINTHElGHTAGAINSTTHEUNBELIEVERS/NTHECONTRARYHE ARGUESASTRUEBELIEVERSWOMENSHOULDEDUCATETHEIRCHILDRENFORTHE SAKEOF *IHAD THEYSHOULDPROTECT THE SEXUALHONOR IRDH OF THEIR MENONCETHEYCHOOSETHEPATHOF*IHADANDTHEYSHOULDBECOME MOREACTIVEINPREPARINGMENFORHOLYWARh7OMENSHOULDBECOME CONSCIOUSTHAT THElGHTBETWEEN)SLAMANDTHEPEOPLEOFDISBELIEF ISINESCAPABLE4HISISTHECONTINUATIONOFTHE#RUSADESHEADEDBY THE5NITED3TATESAGAINSTTHE-USLIMSALLOVERTHEWORLD7OMEN SHOULDIMITATETHEROLEOFTHEWOMENINTHE'OLDEN!GEOF)SLAM)N THISWARSOME-USLIMWOMENAREENTICEDTOTHERANKSOFTHEENEMY THROUGHDANCINGPROSTITUTIONSINGINGANDTHELIKE!NOTHERWAYOF BEHAVINGISTHECASEOF5MM!MARAHWHOPARTICIPATEDALSOINTHE JIHAD-ANYOTHERWOMENTOOKPARTINTHEWARSOFTHE0ROPHETBY DISTRIBUTINGWATERANDSERVINGASNURSESTOTHEWOUNDEDv

5YAYRI ASKSWOMEN TO END THEIR ROLE AS hPROSTITUTESvWITHIN THENEWSICKCULTURESPREADBYTHE7ESTWHEREDANCINGORSINGING ISGIVENPRECEDENCEOVERTHEGENUINELY)SLAMICROLEOFTAKINGPARTIN THE*IHADLIKEMANYWOMENDURINGTHETIMEOFTHE0ROPHETWHEN THEYHELPEDMENINHOLYWARh4OBECOMEGENUINE-USLIMSWOMEN SHOULDBEHAVEINTHESAMEWAYASTHOSEWHOENTEREDTHElGHTDUR

INGTHElRSTCENTURIESOF)SLAM4HEYFOUGHTSIDEBYSIDEWITHMEN NOTBECAUSEOFTHEPAUCITYOFTHELATTERBUTBECAUSEOFTHEIRLOVEFOR SACRIlCEINTHEPATHOF!LLAH!ÆCHATHEYOUNGWIFEOFTHE0ROPHET WASANEXAMPLE3HETOLDTHE0ROPHETTHATSHECHOSETHE*IHADBECAUSE THEREWASNOTHINGHIGHERTHAN*IHADINTHE+ORANv

5YAYRIDOESNOTPUSHWOMENTOBECOMEDIRECTLYINVOLVEDIN *IHADASlGHTINGSOLDIERS)NSTEADHEASKSTHEMTOACCEPTTHESACRIlCE OFTHEIRSONSHUSBANDSORFATHERSANDACTIVELYPREPARETHEMFORTHIS HOLYTASKEMULATINGTHEWOMENOFTHE'OLDEN!GEOF)SLAM7OMEN SHOULDINSTILLMENWITHTHELOVEOF*IHADANDMARTYRDOMANDMAKE THEM RENOUNCE THEIR PERSONALWORLDLY DESIRES FOR THE SAKE OF THE -USLIMCOMMUNITYh7OMENLIKEMENSHOULDACCEPTTHEULTIMATE SACRIlCEFORTHE5MMAANDRENOUNCETHEIROWNPERSONALWELFAREFOR THESAKEOFJIHAD4HE5MMAISPARAMOUNTANDTHEINDIVIDUALISONLY AMEREMEMBEROFIT4HECASEOF5MMAL3AHBAISINSTRUCTIVESEVEN OFHERSONSEMBRACEDMARTYRDOMINTHE0ROPHETSWARSANDSHESTILL WASDEVOTEDTOTHE0ROPHET)NSUMMARYGENUINE-USLIMWOMEN ENCOURAGEMENTOTAKEPARTIN*IHADANDTOACCEPTTHESACRIlCEOFTHEIR LIFEFORTHISSACREDMISSIONv

&OR5YAYRIWOMENCANBEANIMPEDIMENTINTHEWAYOF*IHAD BUTCANASWELLBEAMONGTHOSEWHOENCOURAGEMENTOENGAGEINIT 7OMENCANMAKEMENCONSCIOUSOFTHEFACTTHATTHELOVEOF*IHAD SHOULDTRUMPTHELOVEOFTHISPETTYWORLDANDITSENTICEMENTSAC CORDINGTOTHEMODELOFTHEFOREFATHERSWHODEVOTEDTHEIRLIFETOTHE 5MMAANDJOYFULLYACCEPTEDMARTYRDOMINTHISPATH

5YAYRIMAKES A CRITIQUE OFMODERN INDIVIDUALISM THAT GIVES PRIORITY TO PERSONAL ASPIRATIONS AGAINST THE HIGHER INTERESTS OF THE COMMUNITY*IHADISMIS INTHISRESPECTANTI INDIVIDUALISM,OVEOF *IHADSUPPOSESRECOGNIZINGTHEPRIORITYOFTHECOMMUNITYOVERTHE SELF3ELmESSNESSWILLINGNESSTOMAKETHEULTIMATESACRIlCEAND*IHAD GOHANDINHANDINHISVIEW

3HARIATITHEIDEOLOGUEOFREVOLUTIONARY3HIISMDEVOTESAWHOLE BOOKTOTHEROLEOFWOMENINMODERN)SLAM&ORHIMTWOMODELS AREIRRELEVANTTHETRADITIONAL)SLAMICWOMANANDTHEMODERN7ESTERN ONE(EPROPOSESATHIRDMODELTHATOF&ATIMATHEDAUGHTEROFTHE 0ROPHETANDTHEWIFEOF!LITHElRST3HIITEIMAMANDTHEFOURTH7ELL 'UIDED#ALIPH&ORHIM&ATIMA&ATEMEHIN0ERSIAN WASTHEHEROIC WOMANWHOASSISTEDBOTHTHE0ROPHETANDHERHUSBAND!LIINTHEIR ORDEALFORTHESAKEOF)SLAM4RADITIONAL-USLIMWOMENWEREDEVOID OFANYPUBLICROLECONTRARYTO&ATIMA-ODERN7ESTERNWOMENARE DEVOIDOFANYASPIRATIONFORREVOLUTIONARYFEELINGBEINGALIENATEDLIKE 7ESTERNMENBYTHEDESIRESOFTHISWORLD4HEREISNOIDEALOFREALIZING

ANEWWORLDOFJUSTICEINEITHEROFTHESEMODELS&ATIMAWASAWOMAN WHOPRESENTEDAMODELOFWOMANHOODDISTINCTFROMTHETWOOTHERS 3HARIATIISNOTCLEARABOUTTHEREALROLEOFTHISTHIRDMODELBESIDESTHE FACTTHATHEREJECTSTHETWOOTHERSBUTHISCONCEPTIONOFWOMENSROLE ISNODIFFERENTINITSKEYFEATURESFROMTHATOF5YAYRI7RITINGMORE THANTHREEDECADESLATER5YAYRICELEBRATEDTHESENSEOFABNEGATIONAND SELF SACRIlCEAMONGMENWHOAREINmUENCEDBYWOMENRENOUNCING THEPLEASURESOFTHISWORLDANDPROMOTINGTHEHEROICIDEOLOGYOFREVO LUTIONARY)SLAMBASEDONSELF SACRIlCEFORTHESAKEOFTHE5MMA

4HE EFFECTIVE ROLE OFWOMEN IN SUICIDE OPERATIONS HAS BEEN INCREASINGINTHELASTDECADEPARTICULARLYSINCE)N#HECHNYA )RAQ*ORDAN%GYPT5ZBEKISTANAND0ALESTINEWOMENHAVEPLAYEDA ROLEINSUICIDEBOMBINGS7HATMAKESTHEMATTRACTIVEFORTHEPLOTSIS THATTHEYARESEENASUNABLETOCOMMITVIOLENTACTSANDTHEYCANHIDE THEIRWEAPONSSOMETIMESAPPEARINGPREGNANTUNDERTHEIRVEILS4HE MUJAHIDATFEMININEFORMOF-UJAHIDUNTHOSEWHOMAKETHE*IHAD AREINVOLVEDINMANYCASESASSISTERSMOTHERSORWIVES4HE*ORDA NIAN3AJIDA-UBARAK!RROUSAL 2ISHAWIANDHERHUSBANDDETONATED EXPLOSIVESIN.OVEMBERINTHREEHOTELSIN!MMAN(ERHUSBAND DIEDBUTSHESURVIVEDBECAUSEOFTHEFAILUREOFTHEIGNITIONSYSTEM )N!PRILTWOWOMENIN)RAQBLEWUPTHEIRCARATACHECKPOINT ANDKILLEDTHREESOLDIERS)N3EPTEMBERAN)RAQIWOMANTOOK PARTINTHEASSASSINATIONOFJOBAPPLICANTSUNDERTHELEADERSHIPOF!L 1AEDA/THERINCIDENTSINVOLVEWOMENASSOLDIERSLIKETHE!PRIL SHOOTINGSBYTWOVEILED%GYPTIANWOMENOFATOURISTBUSIN #AIRO)NTHELATTERCASETHETWOWOMENBOTHINTHEIRTWENTIESWERE RELATEDTOAMALEACTIVIST%HAB9OUSRI9ASSIN/NEWASHISSISTER.EGAT 9ASSIN ANDTHEOTHERHISlANC£E)MANIBRAHIM+HAMIS 4HEYACTED OUTOFREVENGEFOR9ASSINSDEATHBYTHE%GYPTIANAUTHORITIES4HETWO WOMENTHENSHOTTHEMSELVES

!YOUNG5ZBEKWOMANPLAYEDAMAJORROLEINASUICIDEATTACKIN -ARCHTHENINETEEN YEAR OLD$ILNOZA(OLMURADOVADETONATED EXPLOSIVESAT4ASHKENTS#HORSU-ARKETKILLINGATLEASTFORTY SEVEN PEOPLEINCLUDINGTENPOLICEOFlCERS3HECAMEFROMAMIDDLE CLASS BACKGROUNDWASWELL EDUCATED SPOKElVE LANGUAGES AND UNLIKE THEVASTMAJORITYOF5ZBEKWOMENHADADRIVERSLICENSE)NHERCASE INTENSEMODERNIZATION IN A SOCIETYWITHOUT ANY SOCIAL ORIENTATION AFTER THE COLLAPSEOF THE3OVIET5NION AND THE ATTRACTIONOF )SLAM INITSRADICALVERSIONTHROUGHTHE)SLAMIC*IHADGROUPSEEMTOHAVE PLAYEDANIMPORTANTROLE)NTHISCASESHESEEMSNOTTOHAVEACTEDAS ASISTERORAMOTHEROREVENASAWIFEBUTASAWOMANTOOMODERNTO BEUNDERSTOODBYSOCIETYANDDEADSETAGAINSTTHESTATE

)NTHE0ALESTINIANSUICIDEATTACKS7AFA)DRISSWASTHElRSTTO ACT IN*ANUARY3HEKILLEDONE)SRAELIAND INJUREDMORE THAN AHUNDREDlFTYOTHERSINA*ERUSALEMSHOPPINGDISTRICT&OUROTHER 0ALESTINIANWOMEN COMMITTED SUICIDE ATTACKS IN THE FOURMONTHS FOLLOWING7AFA)DRISS3OMEWOMENSEEMTOHAVEBEENINVOLVEDAS hMEREWOMENvCONTRARYTOTHEGENERALRULEINWOMENSMARTYRDOM OPERATIONSWHERETHEYAREINVOLVEDASRELATIVESOFMEN4HISISTHE CASEOF(ANADI*ARADATWHODETONATEDABOMBINAN!RAB OWNED RESTAURANTIN(AIFAKILLINGNINETEENPEOPLE)NAPRERECORDEDVIDEO AIREDBY!L*AZEERAON!UGUSTSHESAIDh"YTHEPOWEROF !LLAH)HAVEDECIDEDTOBECOMETHESIXTHFEMALEMARTYRDOMSEEKER WHOWILLTURNHERBODYINTOSHRAPNELWHICHWILLREACHTHEHEARTOF EVERY:IONISTCOLONIALISTINMYCOUNTRYv

4HENATIONALISTMOTIVE ISGIVEN INAN )SLAMIC IDIOM/N THE WHOLE)SLAMICNATIONALISTMOVEMENTSLIKETHOSEIN0ALESTINE#HECH NYAOR+ASHMIRAREDIFFERENTFROMTHETRANSNATIONAL*IHADISMOF!L 1AEDA)NTHElRSTCASETHENATIONALISSUESAREVINDICATEDTHROUGH )SLAM4HESEMOVEMENTSMARKNOAFlNITYWITH!L1AEDAORTRANS NATIONAL*IHADISMINGENERALTHEYHAVENATIONALGOALSWHICHUSUALLY PRECLUDES AFlNITYWITH TRANSNATIONAL *IHADISM/NLY AMARGINAL NUMBEROFTHEIRFOLLOWERSTAKETHEPATHOFGLOBAL*IHAD

)N-USLIMSOCIETIESWOMENCANPLAYASIGNIlCANTROLEINMO BILIZINGMENIFTHEYACCEPTDEFENDINGTHEHONOROFTHE5MMABY SACRIlCINGTHEIRLIVESTHENMENSHOULDDOMOREOTHERWISETHEYARELESS THANWOMEN.OTACTINGTOSURPASSWOMENINCOURAGEANDHEROISM WOULDPUTMANSSUPERIORITYINTOQUESTION7OMENSINVOLVEMENTIN SUICIDEOPERATIONSALSOHASSOMELONG TERMIMPLICATIONSFORORTHODOX )SLAM)FWOMENDIRECTLYTAKEPARTIN*IHADTHEYWILLBEEXPOSEDTO MENWHOAREhSTRANGERSvANDWHOMACCORDINGTOTRADITIONAL)SLAM THEYSHOULDNOTMEET4HE*IHADISTMOTTOWOULDPUTINTOQUESTION SOMEOFTHETENETSOFORTHODOXYINRELATIONTOTHESEGREGATIONOFMEN ANDWOMENANDTHEIMPLICITINFERIORITYOFTHELATTERTOTHEFORMERIF WOMENCANDIELIKEMENTHEREISLITTLEGROUNDSFORCLAIMINGTHATTHEY SHOULDNOTBEEQUALTOTHEMINOTHERRESPECTS

4HEMARTYRDOMOFWOMEN CANNOT ONLY INCITEMEN TO TAKE PARTIN*IHADBUTALSOENTICEOTHERWOMENTOBECOMEMOREINVOLVED INSUICIDEOPERATIONS7OMENSMARTYRDOMTHUSHASADUALROLEIT CALLSINTOQUESTIONMENSSENSEOFHONORANDPRIDEGHEYRAIRDH AND ITPROVIDESAHEROICEXAMPLETHATOTHERWOMENCANIMITATE)NTHE MEDIAWOMENSUICIDEBOMBERSPRESENTAMORESPECTACULARCASETHEIR COVERAGEBEINGGREATERTHANTHATOFMEN4HEIRENROLLMENTIN*IHADIST OPERATIONSCANBEASWELLAQUESTFOREMPOWERMENTWITHIN-USLIM

SOCIETIESTHATAREDEEPLYPATRIARCHALEVENTHOUGHTHEIRPRIMARYAIM MIGHTNOTBETOASSERTTHEIREQUALITYWITHMEN

!MONGCONVERTSTHEREARESOMEWOMENWHOENGAGEDINHOLY WARAGAINSTTHE!MERICANSORTHEIRALLIES4HECASEOF-URIELLE$E GAUQUEISRATHEREXCEPTIONALSINCETHEREARENTMANYWOMENCONVERTS DIRECTLYINVOLVEDINGLOBAL*IHADSOFAR3HEWASAYOUNGCONVERTFROM #HARLEROI"ELGIUM/N.OVEMBERSHETRIGGEREDHEREXPLOSIVE BELTIN"AQUBA)RAQKILLINGlVEPOLICEMENANDWOUNDINGCIVILIANS &EWDAYS LATER!MERICANSKILLEDHERHUSBANDA"ELGIANCITIZENOF -OROCCANORIGIN!NOTHERCONVERT0ASCAL#RUYPENNINCKWANTEDTO COMMITASUICIDEBOMBINGWITHHISlANC£EAYOUNG!FRICANWOMAN BUTHEWASARRESTED

4HEMEDIAPLAYAROLEINTHEMOBILIZATIONOFWOMENINTHEPATH OF*IHAD.EWTECHNOLOGIESPARTICULARLYTHE)NTERNETENABLEWOMEN TOACTMOREFREELYTHANWITHINTRADITIONALSOCIALNETWORKSWHICHARE DOMINATEDBYMEN*IHADISTMEDIALIKE3AWTAL*IHADOR-INBARAL 4AWHIDURGEWOMENTOTAKEPARTIN*IHAD3AWTAL*IHADPRODUCED BY!L1AEDAIN3AUDI!RABIADEVOTESPARTOFITSEDITORIALSTOWOMEN 4HEWORKOF!L+HANSAATHENAMEOFAPRE )SLAMICFEMALEPOETWHO LOSTFOURSONSIN*IHAD EXHORTSWOMENTOTAKEPARTINHOLYWARAGAINST THEENEMIESOF)SLAM7HATKINDOFROLEISASSIGNEDTOWOMENh4HERE AREMANYWAYSA-USLIMWOMANCANPARTICIPATEIN*IHAD4HE SISTERSROLEONTHEBATTLElELDIS0ARTICIPATIONINTHEACTUALlGHTING 3UPPORTINGTHElGHTERSINTHEBATTLElELD0ROVIDINGGUARDDUTY ANDPROTECTION

4HE%VOLUTIONOFTHE'LOBAL!L1AEDAINTHE7EST

!MONGSOCIALSCIENTISTSTHEOVERWHELMINGMAJORITYAGREESTHATSINCE 3EPTEMBER!L1AEDAHASEVOLVEDINTOANORGANIZATIONWITH NEW LEADERSHIP STYLES ANDPATTERNS OF RECRUITMENT AND TRAINING )T MOUNTSITSOPERATIONSWITHINATRANSNATIONALNETWORKOFCELLSACTING ONTHE LOCAL LEVELWITHAHIGHDEGREEOFAUTONOMYANDSOMETIMES EVENINTOTALINDEPENDENCEFROMTHEFORMALLEADERSHIPOF"IN,ADEN ORAL:AWAHIRI4HISNEWSTRUCTUREISMUCHMOREADAPTABLEANDmEX IBLETHANTHECENTRALIZEDMODELOFTHEOLDLEFTISTRADICALGROUPSOFTHE SOREVENTHEHIERARCHICALSTRUCTUREOF!L1AEDAPRIORTO3EP TEMBER7HATBINDSTHEMEMBERSTOGETHERISACOMMONVISIONOF RELIGIONONESDUTIESANDAWORLDWIDECALLING4HECHANGESWITHIN THEORGANIZATIONALSTRUCTUREOF!L1AEDAHAVEBEENANALYZEDBYSOME OFTHEIRPROTAGONISTS/NTHEBASISOFTHEWRITINGSOF!L1AEDASMAIN

STRATEGISTSANDINTELLECTUALSTHEYPROPOSEADECENTRALIZEDINDIVIDUAL IZED*IHADFORTHEFUTURE

-ORE ANDMORE *IHADIST TERRORISM IN%UROPE IS A JUMBLE OF BASICALLY AUTONOMOUS RADICALIZED CELLS THATHAVE CONTACTSWITH THE OUTSIDEWORLDANDNOCENTRALORGANIZATIONALSCHEME!CCORDINGTO #OOLSAETSELF RADICALIZATIONANDSELF RECRUITMENTOFINDIVIDUALSATTHE FRINGEOFMIGRANT-USLIMCOMMUNITIESIN%UROPEISMOREIMPORTANT FOR*IHADISTRECRUITMENTTHANANYORGANIZEDNETWORKOFINTERNATIONAL RECRUITERS)RAQBEINGAPOSSIBLEEXCEPTION.ESSERAND(EGGHAM MERBELIEVETHATTHEREISNOTOP DOWNRECRUITMENTAPPARATUSBUTA hHORIZONTALRECRUITMENTvWHICHMAKES!L1AEDAMOREORGANIZEDTHAN OTHER*IHADISTGROUPS4HEREAREPEOPLEWHOFULlLLTHEROLEOFRECRUIT ERSFOR!L1AEDACREATINGAhCULTUREFORRECRUITMENTvANDMAKINGIT POSSIBLEFORMILITANT*IHADISTSTOCREATELINKSWITHPOTENTIALRECRUITS THROUGHTHEIRTIESWITHCONVERTSFRIENDSANDFAMILYMEMBERS!L 1AEDASAIMISACCORDINGTO"ARTLEYTOUSEUNCONVENTIONALTACTICSOF hINDIRECTˆNAMELYASYMMETRICWARFAREvINORDERTOPROVOKEPREVIOUSLY UNIMAGINABLEDESTRUCTIONANDSPREADFEAR

-AJOR CHANGES HAVE OCCURRED ALSO IN THE NATURE OF *IHADIST GROUPSMAINLY!L1AEDA,ARGE SCALEOPERATIONSLIKETHE3EPTEMBER ATTACKSAREHENCEFORWARDHIGHLYIMPROBABLEFORTECHNOLOGICALAND INTELLIGENCEREASONS!MERICANANDMOREGENERALLY7ESTERNGOVERN MENTSAREABLETOMONITORPHONECALLSAND)NTERNETEXCHANGESINORDER TOPREVENTPLOTS-ANYCASESOF*IHADISTPLOTSTHATHAVEBEENDETECTED ARERELATEDTOTHEQUESTIONOFHYPER SIZED*IHADISTCELLS&ROM3EP TEMBERTO.OVEMBERTHE!MERICANGOVERNMENTHAS THWARTEDSOMENINETEENTERRORISTATTACKSAGAINSTTHE5NITED3TATES

)N%NGLANDIN!UGUSTTHEATTEMPTTOBLOWUPMANYAIR PLANESENROUTETOTHE5NITED3TATESBYMIXINGUPLIQUIDSWITHINTHE AIRCRAFTFAILEDINTHESAMEWAYASOTHER*IHADISTPLOTSINSOMEOTHER %UROPEANCOUNTRIES&IFTEENPERSONSSUSPECTEDOFBEINGINVOLVEDIN THE5+ BASEDPLOTWEREARRESTED4HECOOPERATIONBETWEENTHE"RIT ISHTHE5NITED3TATESAND0AKISTANWEREESSENTIALTOPUTTINGANEND TOTHEPLOT

/N*ULYTWO,EBANESESTUDENTS9OUSSEFEL(AJDIB TWENTY ONEAND*IHAD(AMADTWENTYPLANTEDTWOSUITCASEBOMBS ABOARD'ERMANREGIONALTRAINSIN$ORTMUNDAND+OBLENZ4HEDE VICESlTTEDWITHALARMCLOCKSFORTIMERSFAILEDTODETONATE)FTHEY HADTHEYWOULDHAVECREATEDAlREBALLUPTOlFTEENMETERSWIDEAND HURLEDDEADLYSHRAPNELUPTOAHUNDREDMETERSACCORDINGTOEXPLOSIVE EXPERTS)TCOULDHAVEBEENTHEWORSTTERRORISTATTACKON'ERMANSOILIN THECOUNTRYSHISTORY5NLIKETHE!UGUSTPLOTSTHISONEWASNOT

DETECTEDBYTHEPOLICEBEFOREITTOOKPLACE)TDIDNTSUCCEEDBECAUSE OFTHETECHNICALFAILUREOFTHEIGNITIONSYSTEM4HEMAINREASONFOR THEAUTHORITIESINABILITYTOCOPEWITHTHEPLOTWASTHESHEERNUMBER OFTERRORISTSPROBABLYFEWERTHANlVE

/N *ANUARY &RENCHPOLICE ARRESTED ELEVENPEOPLE THREEOFWHOMEVENTUALLYWERECHARGEDWITHTERRORISMCONSPIRACY IN0ARISSNINETEENTHDISTRICTFORRECRUITINGYOUNG&RENCHRESIDENTSTO LAUNCHTERRORISTATTACKSIN)RAQ)TWASTHElRSTARRESTSINCETHEOPENING IN3EPTEMBEROFANINVESTIGATIONBYTHE0ARISPROSECUTORSOFlCE INTO*IHADISTSIN)RAQ&RENCHOFlCIALSSTATEDIN.OVEMBERTHAT TWENTY TWOYOUNGPEOPLEHADLEFTFOR)RAQANDATLEASTSEVENWERE KILLEDTHEREINCLUDINGTWOSUICIDEBOMBERS4HEGROUPWASSEEM INGLYIDENTIlEDFROMTHEDEMONSTRATIONOFSOMEOFITSMEMBERSAGAINST THEBANNINGOFTHEVEILIN&RENCHGOVERNMENT SPONSOREDSCHOOLSIN /THERWISEITWOULDHAVEBEENMUCHMOREDIFlCULTTODETECT THEMBECAUSEOFTHELOWNUMBEROFTHEGROUPSCOREMEMBERSAND THEIRLACKOFANYTERRORISTRECORDS

)NSUMMARYTHEKINDOF*IHADISTTERRORISMTHATISSTILLPOSSIBLE INTHE7ESTISTHEONEWITHONLYAFEWPEOPLEINVOLVEDFEWERTHAN lVEORSIXPEOPLE ORTHELONEWOLFEGTHE5NABOMBER 4HENEW AWARENESSOFTHE7ESTERNGOVERNMENTSAFTER3EPTEMBERTHELESSONS DRAWNFROMTHE-ADRIDAND,ONDONATTACKSOFANDAND THECOORDINATIONBETWEENTHEINTELLIGENCESERVICESOFTHE7ESTANDTHEIR FRIENDLY)SLAMICCOUNTRIESCOUNTERPARTSUNDERTHEAEGISOFTHE5NITED 3TATESMAKELARGE SCALEATTACKSINVOLVINGHIGHNUMBEROF*IHADISTS UNLIKELYTOSUCCEED4HISDOESNOTMEANTHATTHEIRPLOTSCOULDNOTBE DEADLYBUTTHEYPROBABLYCOULDNOTREACHTHEHIGHNUMBERSOFTHE 3EPTEMBERATTACKSUNLESSNEWTECHNIQUESWEREPUTINTOEFFECT

7HEREASLARGE*IHADISTGROUPSCANBEIDENTIlEDTHROUGHSHARED INTELLIGENCEBETWEENTHE5NITED3TATESANDOTHERALLIESANDTHEUSE OFNEWTECHNOLOGICALDEVICESTHESMALL*IHADISTCELLSAREMUCHMORE DIFlCULTTOLOCATE4HEMAJORCONCERNWITHINTHEINTELLIGENCESERVICES OFTHE7ESTISNOTLARGE SCALEGROUPSBUTSMALLADHOCONES7HAT CANHELPIDENTIFYTHEMISTHEFACTTHATRADICALIZATIONOF-USLIMSASA GENERALRULEISARATHERLENGTHYPROCESSANDNOTANEVENTOCCURRINGIN THESHORTTERM!NOTHERPOSSIBILITYISTHESO CALLEDhLONEWOLFvOPERA TIVEWHATTODOIFASINGLEPERSONAMONGTHESYMPATHIZERSORMEMBERS OFTHEDORMANTCELLSOF!L1AEDAENGAGESINATERRORISTACTIVITY3INCE HEWONTBEINTOUCHWITHANYONEHECANNOTBEDETECTED4HE*IHADIST SITESMENTIONTHISPOSSIBILITYSCOFlNGAT7ESTERNINTELLIGENCESERVICES h7HATFRIGHTENS;THE&")=ANDDEPRIVESTHEMOFSLEEPATNIGHTAND PEACEDURINGTHEDAYARETHELONEWOLVESOF!L1AEDAv

/NTHEOTHERHAND*IHADISTSAREFACINGAMAJORDILEMMA)NTHE 7ESTATTHEBACKOFMANY*IHADISTSMINDSISTHEIRDESIREFORLARGE SCALE SPECTACULARTERRORISTACTIONLIKE3EPTEMBERWITHAPOCALYPTICRESULTS ASMUCHINTERMSOFMASSKILLINGASMEDIACOVERAGE4HISOPPORTU NITYISDENIEDTOTHEM)N%UROPEALLTHOSEATTEMPTSWITHNUMEROUS PEOPLEANDLARGE SCALE*IHADISTINVOLVEMENTWERENEUTRALIZEDBYTHE SURVEILLANCE AND INlLTRATIONOF THE INTELLIGENCE ANDPOLICE SERVICES INTOTHE*IHADISTCIRCLESANDACLOSERCOOPERATIONBETWEENDIFFERENT 7ESTERNNATIONS)NTHE-USLIMWORLDPLOTSOFHIGHMAGNITUDEARE STILLPOSSIBLEALTHOUGHTHEREHASNEVERBEENASSPECTACULARATERRORIST ACTAS3EPTEMBER)N)RAQIN0AKISTANANDINSOMEOTHER-USLIM COUNTRIESSTILLMANYDOZENSANDSOMETIMESAFEWHUNDREDHAVEBEEN KILLEDINTHETERRORISTATTACKS"YMEANSOFMEDIACOVERAGEALLOVER THEWORLDTHETERRORISTACTOF3EPTEMBERHASBECOMEICONICNOT ONLYINTHE7ESTBUTALSOINTHE-USLIMWORLDANDTHEDREAMOFTHE *IHADISTSISTOREPRODUCEITINPARTICULARINTHE7ESTTOPUTONDISPLAY THEPOWERLESSNESSOFTHE!MERICANANDOTHER7ESTERNGOVERNMENTS INCOUNTERINGWORLDWIDE*IHAD

!BU-USABAL3URITHE*IHADISTINTELLECTUALMOSTVERSEDINTHE SOCIALSCIENCESPROPOSESANEWTYPEOF*IHADISMBASEDONDECENTRAL IZED SMALLNONHIERARCHICAL GROUPSOPERATING IN A TOTALLY AUTONO MOUSMANNER(ISPROPOSALAFTERTHE3EPTEMBERATTACKSANDTHE REORGANIZATIONOFTHE7ESTERNINTELLIGENCEANDMILITARYSERVICESIS AMAZINGLYMODERN(ISADVICETO*IHADISTS IS TERRIFYINGBUT INAN OTHERSENSEWOULDROBTHEMOFTHEWORLDCOVERAGEINTHEMANNEROF 3EPTEMBER4HEONLYWAY!L1AEDAnTYPE*IHADISTMOVEMENTSCAN OPERATEINTHE7ESTISTHROUGHSMALLANDDECENTRALIZEDGROUPSTHAT CANNOTACHIEVETHESAMESCALEOFDAMAGESANDKILLINGSASIN3EPTEMBER 4HEDILEMMAISTHEREEITHERKILLALIMITEDNUMBEROFPEOPLEEACH TIMEBECOMEAKINDOFhNEWSINBRIEF vINTHEMEDIAORRISKARREST ANDDETERRENCEBYLAUNCHINGALARGE SCALETERRORISTATTACK5PTONOW *IHADISTSHAVEOVERWHELMINGLYCHOSEN THE SECONDALTERNATIVEWITH FEWEXCEPTIONS4HEIRNEUTRALIZATIONBY THEPOLICE FORCESHASBEEN ALMOSTGENERALINTHE5NITED3TATES5NITED+INGDOM&RANCEAND AFEWOTHER%UROPEANCOUNTRIESSINCETHELASTATTACKIN'REAT"RITAIN IN*ULY3TILLAL3URISPROPOSALISTHEMOSTREALISTICONEFORTHE SURVIVALOF!L1AEDAnTYPEORGANIZATIONSINTHE7EST

4ABLE#ORRESPONDENCEBETWEEN*IHADISTS INTHE-USLIM7ORLDAND*IHADISTSINTHE7EST

*IHADISTS.EGATIVE!TTITUDETOWARD 2ECENT-USLIM-IGRATIONSTOTHE7EST

)NTHEWORLDOF)SLAMMIGRATIONHIJRA HASASOLIDLYRELIGIOUSMEAN INGWITHINTHE0ROPHETICTRADITION&ORTHE*IHADISTSTHEJUSTIlCATION FORTHEMIGRATIONOF-USLIMSTOTHE7ESTSHOULDBETHESAMEASTHE 0ROPHETSEXODUSFROM-ECCATO-EDINA-OHAMMADFELTTHREATENED IN-ECCAANDHEWASNTSTRONGENOUGHTOlGHTAGAINSTHISPOWERFUL OPPONENTSINTHATCITYTOPROTECTTHEFRAGILE-USLIMCOMMUNITY(E CHOSETOMIGRATETO-EDINAKNOWNATTHETIMEAS9ATHRIB WHERE HEGATHEREDSTRENGTH/NCEPOWERFULENOUGHHERETURNEDTO-ECCA

ANDCONQUEREDIT4HUSEMIGRATIONPRECEDES*IHADTOWHICHITISA PRELUDE!BDULLAH!ZZAMTHE0ALESTINIAN*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSAYS h*IHADISTHEAPOGEEOF)SLAMANDWEACCEDETOITTHROUGHEMIGRATION HIJRA THENTHEPREPARATIONIDºD THENTHEGUARDINGOFTHEFRONTIERS RIBºT THENTHECOMBATQITAL 4HEEMIGRATIONISINDISPENSABLEFOR JIHADv

%MIGRATIONTOANON -USLIMLANDISFORBIDDENFORANYREASON OTHERTHANPREPARINGFOR*IHAD4ARTUSISUMMARIZESTHISIDEAUNDER SCORINGTHEUNBREAKABLELINKBETWEENMIGRATIONAND*IHADFROMTHE )SLAMICPERSPECTIVE

4HECAUSESANDAIMSOFMIGRATIONARE 4HESAFETYOFWORSHIPANDRELIGION 4HESECURITYOFTHEPERSONIFTHEOPPRESSORSTHREATENSOME ONEWITHCERTAINDEATHANDHEHASNOPOWERTONEUTRALIZETHEMBY HIMSELF THENHESHOULDMIGRATEANDSEEKELSEWHERESECURITY FOR HIMSELFANDHISFAMILY 3TRENGTHENINGTHE-USLIMSANDWEAKENINGTHE)NlDELSONEOF THECAUSESANDAIMSOFMIGRATIONISTHEREVIVALOFTHEDUTYOF*IHAD THESTRENGTHENINGOFTHE-USLIMSANDTHEINCREASEOFTHEIRNUMBERS AGAINSTTHE)NlDELS-IGRATIONAND*IHADARETWOINSEPARABLETHINGS ANDEACHOFTHEMISTHECAUSEOFTHEOTHERANDNECESSARYTOITAND THECONTINUANCEOFEACHOFTHEMISNECESSARYTOTHECONTINUANCE OFTHEOTHER%VENIFTHESUNRISESFROMTHE7EST*IHADLASTSUP TOTHE$AYOF*UDGMENT

)NTHESECONDHALFOFTHETWENTIETHCENTURY-USLIMSMASSIVELY MIGRATEDTO%UROPEMAINLYFORECONOMICREASONSTOWORKTHEREAND EARNTHEIRLIVINGTHUSESCAPINGPOVERTYANDJOBLESSNESS4HISMASS MIGRATIONTHElRSTOFTHISNATUREIN)SLAMTONON -USLIMSOCIETIES DOESNOTFOLLOWTHE0ROPHETICMODEL)NTHESAMEWAYTHEMIGRATION OFMIDDLE CLASS-USLIMSTOTHE5NITED3TATESAND#ANADAISTOTALLY DIFFERENTFROMTHE0ROPHETICPATTERNOFMIGRATION)N%UROPEASIN !MERICA-USLIMS ARE LIVING AS AMINORITYWITHIN SECULAR THOUGH CULTURALLY#HRISTIANSOCIETIESANDTHEIREXPLICITAIMSATLEASTFORTHE OVERWHELMINGMAJORITYOF THEM ISNOT TOWAGE *IHADBUT TO LIVE PEACEFULLYWITHOTHERCITIZENSlNDINGCOMPROMISESWITHTHEHOST SOCIETIESINORDERTOLIVEACCORDINGTOTHEIRFAITH

4HENEWPATTERNOFMIGRATIONDOESNOTESCAPE*IHADISTSATTEN TION4HEYAREDEEPLYDISTURBEDBYTHEATTITUDEOFTHEMAJORITYINTHE -USLIMDIASPORAANDTHEREFOREMANYOFTHEMSTRONGLYRECOMMEND RETURNTO-USLIMCOUNTRIES,IVINGINTHEh(OUSEOF7ARvCOUNTRIES THATARENEITHERDOMINATEDBY-USLIMSNORCONVERTEDTO)SLAM MIGHT

BEACURSEINTHEWARBETWEEN)SLAMANDTHE7ESTTHE7ESTERNHER ETICSMIGHTUSETHEMAShSHIELDSvh4HELACKOFMIGRATIONFROMTHE (OUSEOF7AR;BACKTOTHE-USLIMCOUNTRIES=ENDSUPMOSTOFTHE TIMEIN-USLIMSBECOMINGSHIELDSBEHINDWHICHTHE)NlDELSPROTECT THEMSELVESWHENTHERE ISWARBETWEENTHEMANDTHE-USLIMS 4HISHAPPENEDLATELYTOTHE-USLIMSRESIDINGINTHE53ANDHAVING ACQUIREDITSNATIONALITY4HEYWEREFORCEDTOCOOPERATEWITHTHEINlDEL !MERICAN!RMYINITSOFFENSIVEAGAINSTTHE-USLIMSIN!FGHANISTAN ;INVASIONOF!FGHANISTANANDOVERTHROWOFTHE4ALIBANBYACOALITION LEDBYTHE!MERICANARMYINn=v

4ARTUSIMENTIONSTHE)SLAMICJURISPRUDENCEONMIGRATION

4HERELIGIOUSCOMMANDMENTSFORMIGRATIONAREDIVIDEDINTOFOUR KINDSNECESSARYRELIGIOUSLYPREFERREDRELIGIOUSLYFORBIDDENAND NEITHERNECESSARYNORFORBIDDENINDIFFERENT RELIGIOUSLY 4HENECESSARYMIGRATION;BACKTOA-USLIMCOUNTRY=WHENTHE -USLIMISFEARFULFORHISSAFETYANDHISRELIGIONFROMlTNAANDDEATH ANDCANNOTPUBLICLYSHOWHISRELIGIONANDCANNOTACCOMPLISHTHE RELIGIOUSOBLIGATIONS;HEHASTOEMIGRATE= s4HERELIGIOUSLYPREFERREDMIGRATION;BACKTOA-USLIMCOUN TRY=WHENTHE-USLIMCANDISPLAYHISRELIGIONINTHECOUNTRYOF HISRESIDENCEANDACCOMPLISHESTHENECESSARYRELIGIOUSACTSTHATARE IMPOSEDBY!LLAHANDITISWARRANTEDTHATHEISNOTFORCEDTOHELP THE)NlDELSINTHEIRlGHTAGAINSTTHE-USLIMSTHENTHEEMIGRA TION;BACKTOTHE-USLIMCOUNTRY=ISRELIGIOUSLYPREFERREDBUTNOT COMPULSORY s4HERELIGIOUSLYNEITHERCOMPULSORYNORPREFERREDMIGRATION THISISWHENTHE-USLIMISPOWERLESSANDHISWEAKNESSPREVENTS HIMFROMEMIGRATING s4HE;RELIGIOUSLY=FORBIDDENEMIGRATIONTHISISTHECASEWHEN ;THEEMIGRATION=RESULTS;INTHEWEAKENINGOFTHE-USLIMINTERESTS= THATCANNOTBEOTHERWISEPROMOTEDBYTHEEMIGRATIONOR;BY=THE (OUSEOFEMIGRATION7HENBEINGINTHE(OUSEOF)NlDELITYONE ISPROTECTEDFROMTHEDISSENSIONlTNA ANDCANDISPLAYHISRELIGION ACCOMPLISHTHERELIGIOUSOBLIGATIONSAND INADDITIONTOTHATHE CANCALLPEOPLETOJOIN)SLAMDAWA ;THENEMIGRATIONBACKTOTHE -USLIMCOUNTRYISFORBIDDEN=

&ORTHE*IHADISTSTHEPRESENCEOFTHE-USLIMDIASPORAINTHE 7ESTISNOTINGENERALANASSETFOR)SLAM/NTHECONTRARY-USLIMS INTHE7ESTARERUNNINGTHERISKOFLOSINGTHEIRSOULSANDGETTINGSECU LARIZED%VENIFTHEYHOLDONTOTHEIR)SLAMICIDENTITYTHEYMIGHTBE USEDBYTHE7ESTERNPOWERSAGAINSTTHE-USLIMWORLDBEITINTERMS

OFENROLLMENTINTHEARMYORELSEWHERE ORINTERMSOFBECOMING SUBMISSIVE-USLIMSINCAPABLEOF*IHAD

5NLIKETHE*IHADISTSMANY&UNDAMENTALIST-USLIMGROUPSLIKE (IZBU4AHRIRARGUETHATBYREMAININGINTHE7ESTANDNOTRETURNING TO)SLAMICCOUNTRIES-USLIMSCANPROMOTETHE)SLAMIZATIONOFTHE 7ESTANDTHEREFORETHEIRSTAYISLEGITIMATEˆEVENNECESSARYFROMTHE RELIGIOUSPOINTOFVIEW*IHADISTSUSUALLYREJECTTHISARGUMENTPOINT INGOUTTHATTHEMAJORITYOFTHE-USLIMSWHOMIGRATETOTHE7EST ARENOTPRONETO*IHAD4HESETWOATTITUDESTOWARD)SLAMINTHE7EST UNDERSCORETHEDIFFERENCESBETWEENTHE*IHADISTSWHOBELIEVEINTHE INEVITABLEANDINESCAPABLEWARWITHTHE7ESTSOASTOESTABLISH)SLAM ANDTHE&UNDAMENTALISTSWHOBELIEVETHATTHEYCANCONTRIBUTETOTHE UNIVERSALCALIPHATEBYPROMOTING)SLAMINTHE7ESTINAPEACEFULOR ATLEASTNONVIOLENT MANNER)NBOTHCASESTHEULTIMATEAIMREMAINS THEEXPANSIONOF)SLAMBUTTHEUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEMEANSTOACHIEVE THATENDISDIFFERENTINEACHCASE

!MAJOREVENTTHATTOOKPLACEINTHESECONDHALFOFTHETWENTIETH CENTURYWASTHEFORMATIONOFSIZEABLE)SLAMICDIASPORASINTHE7EST )NMANY%UROPEANCOUNTRIES)SLAMHASBECOMETHESECONDLARGEST RELIGIOUSGROUPANDIN7ESTERN%UROPETHENUMBEROF-USLIMSIS AROUNDlFTEENMILLIONBETWEENTWELVEANDEIGHTEENMILLION 4HE lRSTGENERATIONOFMIGRANTSIN%UROPEWASRELIGIOUSINTHETRADITIONAL WAYhORTHOPRAXYvRATHERTHANhORTHODOXYvSUBMITTINGTORELIGIOUS RITUALSANDRESTRICTIONSDAILYPRAYERSPROHIBITIONOFEATINGPORKOR DRINKINGALCOHOLETC RATHERTHANASKINGANYEXISTENTIALORPOLITICAL QUESTIONS ABOUT )SLAM AND IN PARTICULAR *IHAD4HE SECOND AND THIRD GENERATION-USLIMSBEGANTOASKTHEMSELVESIDENTITYQUESTIONS RELATED TO )SLAM INPARTBECAUSE THEIRNATIONAL IDENTITY IN%UROPE WASINCRISISANDTHEIRECONOMICSTATUSWASSLOWTOIMPROVE!TTHE SAMETIMEMOST%UROPEAN-USLIMSAREINmUENCEDBYSECULARTRENDS WITHIN%UROPE)N7ESTERN%UROPETHEMAJORTRENDISTHEPROGRESSIVE SECULARIZATIONOFTHEMAJORITYOF-USLIMSTHEYDONOTPRACTICETHElVE DAILYPRAYERSREGULARLYANDINFACTMANYDONOTPERFORMTHEMATALL THEUSEOFALCOHOLISSPREADINGAMONG)SLAMICYOUTHANDPREMARITAL RELATIONSHIPSAREMAKINGINROADSINTOMANY-USLIMFAMILIES3OME RESISTTHISPROCESSBUTMANYGIVEUPANDTHERESULTISINTHEEYESOF MANY&UNDAMENTALISTSAND*IHADISTSMORALDECAY

%UROPEANPRISONS HAVE A DISPROPORTIONATELY HIGHNUMBER OF YOUNGMALEUNEDUCATEDANDRELIGIOUSLYIGNORANT-USLIMS4HE LUREOF7ESTERNMORESSEDUCESMANYYOUNG-USLIMSWHOGIVEUPTHE TRADITIONALWAYOFLIFEOFTHEIRPARENTSANDGRANDPARENTSANDINDULGEIN THENEWWAYSOFTHE7ESTERNWORLDSOMETIMESWITHADEEPREMORSEIN THEBACKOFTHEIRCONSCIENCE4HERESULTISSOMETIMESABRUTALRETURN

TO )SLAMNOT TO ITS TRADITIONAL NONPOLITICAL VERSIONS BUT TO RIGID INTOLERANTVERSIONS4HESEBORN AGAIN-USLIMSPUSHTHEIRPARENTSTO RETURNTOTHEIRVERSIONOF)SLAMTHEIRSISTERSTOWEARTHESCARFANDTHEIR FATHERSTORENOUNCEALCOHOLANDTHEFAMILYTOREJECTTHESICKSEDUC TIONSOF7ESTERNLIFE4HISISTHECASEOF:ACARIAS-OUSSAOUIANDOTHER )SLAMISTSINTERVIEWEDIN&RENCHPRISONS3OMEOFTHESEBORN AGAIN -USLIMSJOINEXTREMISTGROUPSANDPOINTANACCUSINGlNGERATTHE 7EST!GAIN-OUSSAOUIlTSVERYWELLINTHISMODELNOTTOMENTION +HALED+ELKALAND-OHAMMED"OUYERI

0ARTICULARLYIN%UROPETHEANTHROPOLOGICALSTRUCTUREOF-USLIM FAMILIESHASBEENSHATTEREDMOSTLYAMONGTHEPOORANDTHEDOWN TRODDENWHOHAVENOCULTURALANDECONOMICPROTECTIONAGAINSTTHE DISLOCATIONOFTHEIRSOCIALBONDS)NMANYCASESFAMILYSTRUCTUREHAS BEEN SUBVERTED THE FATHER LEFTHOMEAND THE FAMILY IS LEDBY THE MOTHERWHOHASTOWORKANDTAKECAREOFTHECHILDRENATTHESAME TIME4HIS SITUATIONPUSHES THECHILDRENMAINLY THEBOYS TOWARD DELINQUENCY4HERESULTHASBEENAMUCHHIGHERRATEOFDEVIANCEAND CRIMEAMONGTHEMALEMEMBERSOFTHEFAMILYANDAFRAGILEANTHRO POLOGICALSTRUCTUREWITHMANYUNCONTROLLEDTENSIONSTOWARDSEXUALITY ANDMEN WOMENRELATIONSHIPSGENDEREQUALITYINTHELARGERSOCIETY VERSUSDEEPINEQUALITYWITHINTHEFAMILY ANDADEEPGRUDGEAGAINST SOCIETY4HERETURNTO)SLAMINITS&UNDAMENTALISTOR*IHADISTVERSIONS ISAWAYOFOVERCOMINGTHEUNBEARABLECONTRADICTIONSWITHOUTMEANS OF INTEGRATING INTERNAL CONmICTSWITHIN%UROPEAN COUNTRIESWHERE COLONIALPREJUDICETOWARD-USLIMMIGRANTSTHEIRCHILDRENANDTHEIR GRANDCHILDRENSTILLPREVAILS

7HATMANY RELIGIOUS-USLIMS IN%UROPE SEE IS ON THE ONE HAND THE hOBSCENE SECULARIZATIONv OF THEIR BRETHREN AND CHILDREN WHOBECOMEADDICTSCONSUMEALCOHOLDATENON -USLIMSINDULGE INNONMARITAL SEXUAL RELATIONS ANDDONOTPRACTICE THEIR ANCESTRAL RELIGIONONTHEOTHERHANDTHEYHELPLESSLYWITNESSTHELOSSOFSELF RESPECTANDDIGNITYAMONGMANYOFTHOSEhDEPRAVEDv-USLIMSWHO BECOMEPETTYTHIEVESANDOFFENDERSTHUSTRAMPLINGON)SLAMICMORAL VALUES3OMETURNTHEGRUDGETOWARDTHE7ESTERNWORLDTHATCORRUPTS -USLIMS%MBRACING)SLAMCANMEANEITHERBREAKINGOFFTIESWITHA SINFULSOCIETYANDlNDINGSOLACEWITHINACLOSE KNIT&UNDAMENTALIST GROUPORTURNINGTOA*IHADISTGROUPINORDERTOTAKEREVENGEAGAINSTA GODLESSSOCIETYTHATHASBEENINHOSPITABLETO-USLIMSANDTHEENEMY OF)SLAMINMANYPARTSOFTHEWORLD"OSNIA!FGHANISTANAND)RAQ AMONGOTHERS

*IHADIST INTELLECTUALS ANDNETWORKS ARE HAPPYWITH THIS TINY MINORITYOF RADICALIZED-USLIMSBUT THEY ARE VERY CRITICAL TOWARD THE-USLIMMAJORITYWHOGIVEUPTHE)SLAMICWAYOFLIFEANDADOPT

7ESTERN STYLEMODERNITYANDACONCILIATORYATTITUDETOWARDTHEDEVIL ISH7EST4HATISWHYINMOSTCASESWHEN-USLIMSPERISHWITHNON -USLIMSINTERRORISTATTACKS*IHADISTSJUSTIFYTHEIRDEATHOFlCIALLYAS INEVITABLEANDREGRETTABLE"UTINTHEIRMINDTHESELUKEWARM-USLIMS AREPAYINGFORTHEIRNONMILITANTATTITUDETOWARDTHE7EST4HEYREFUSE TOGOBACKTO-USLIMCOUNTRIESTOGETINVOLVEDIN*IHADANDTHEYARE SLACKINTHEIRRELIGIOUSDUTIES4HEIRDEATHWITHTHESINFUL7ESTERNERS ISNOMATTERFORREMORSEAMONGTHE*IHADISTS

4HENEW-USLIMMIDDLECLASSESIN%UROPEUNLIKETHEIR!MERICAN COUNTERPARTSARENOTEXUBERANTABOUTTHEIRACHIEVEMENTSANDHAVE AMUCHMOREDISCREETATTITUDEINLINEWITH%UROPEANCULTURE-ORE OVERASANEWMIDDLECLASSTHEYWOULDLIKETOBECOMEANONYMOUS RATHERTHANBEINGSINGLEDOUTASSUCCESSFUL-USLIMS-ANYCHOOSE TOhDISAPPEARvWITHINTHELARGERSOCIETYPARTICULARLYIN&RANCEWITH ITSCULTUREOFTOTALASSIMILATION&EWOFTHEMRESENTTHEFATEOFTHE -USLIMCOMMUNITYIN%UROPEORHAVEDEEPGUILTTOWARDTHEMAND )SLAMASSUCH4HEYAREMUCHMORERESOURCEFULANDPROlCIENTTHAN THEDOWNTRODDEN-USLIMS3OMEOFTHERESOURCEFULNEWMIDDLE CLASS -USLIMSCROSSOVERTHEFORBIDDENLINEANDJOINTHE*IHADISTGROUPS 4HEIRATTITUDETOWARDTHEIR-USLIMBROTHERS ISAKINTOTHATOFTHE RADICALLEFTISTSWHOWERESELF PROCLAIMEDLEADERSOFTHEWORKING CLASS PEOPLE4HESE*IHADISTMIDDLE CLASS-USLIMSCHOOSETOlGHTAGAINST THE7ESTINACOMBINEDSENSEOFRELIGIOUSDUTYANDPERSONALREVENGE AGAINSTASOCIETYWHEREBEINGTHESONOFIMMIGRANTSISSTILLDEGRADING ASDESCENDANTSOFTHEFORMERCOLONIES

4HECASEOF-OHAMMAD3IDDIQ+HANISTHATOFALOWER MIDDLE CLASSTEACHERBORNIN%NGLANDOF0AKISTANIPARENTSWHOBECAMEA *IHADISTANDLEDAGROUPOFTERRORISTSTOBOMBTHE,ONDONUNDERGROUND ANDBUSES:ACARIAS-OUSSAOUISCASEISOFTHESAMETYPE-USLIM MIDDLECLASSES IN%UROPESUFFERAMALAISERELATEDTOTHEDIFlCULTIES OFTHEIRUPWARDMOBILITYINRATHERRIGIDSOCIETIESINWHICHBEINGA -USLIMFROMFORMERCOLONIESISSTIGMATIZING4HELOTOFTHE-USLIM LOWERCLASSESIN%UROPEANDTHEPARTICIPATIONOFTHE%UROPEANCOUN TRIES IN THEWARAGAINST-USLIMS"RITAIN IN)RAQAND!FGHANISTAN &RANCEAND'ERMANYIN!FGHANISTANETC PUSHATINYMINORITYOF THEMTO*IHAD

*IHADISTSATTEMPTTOORGANIZETHEVERYLIMITEDNUMBEROFTHOSE -USLIMSIN%UROPEWHOOPTFORTHERADICALVERSIONOF)SLAMBUTTHEY CLEARLYSEETHATMOST-USLIMSARENOTONTHEIRSIDETHEIRLIFEIN%U ROPEGRADUALLYSECULARIZINGTHEMAJORITYANDPUSHINGSOMEMINORITIES TOWARDPIETISTIC&UNDAMENTALISTORINDIVIDUALIST)SLAMRATHERTHAN THE*IHADISTONE4HATISWHYTHEYAREMOSTLYINFAVOROFTHERETURNOF -USLIMSTO-USLIMLANDS"YCONTRAST&UNDAMENTALISTSLIKE(IZBU

4AHRIRORTHEOFFSHOOTSOF-USLIM"ROTHERHOODOR4ABLIGH BELIEVE THAT)SLAMCANTHRIVEANDEVENTUALLYBECOMETHEDOMINANTRELIGION INTHE7EST

/N THEWHOLE *IHADISTS ARE KEENLY AWARE THAT THE EXODUS OF MAINSTREAM-USLIMSTOTHE7ESTDOESNOTAIMAT*IHADUNLIKETHE (IJRAOFTHE0ROPHETWHOACCORDINGTOTHEMMIGRATEDFROM-ECCA INORDERTORETURNTOITFORCEFULLY)NTHE7ESTERNWORLDMANY*IHADIST INTELLECTUALSlNDTHEMSELVESINTHEPARADOXICALSITUATIONOFPREACH INGTHEMIGRATIONOF-USLIMSBACKTO-USLIMLANDSWHEREASTHEY ASRADICALSREMAININTHE7ESTFORFEAROFBEINGJAILEDANDTORTUREDIF THEYRETURNTOTHEIRHOMECOUNTRYINTHE-USLIMWORLD

.OTES