ABSTRACT
ASSOCIATION4ABLIQWAL$AWA.OWADAYSMOSTMAJORFORMSOF)SLAMIC &UNDAMENTALISMCANNOTBEDISCONNECTEDFROMPOLITICSATLEASTSINCE THEFOUNDINGOFTHE-USLIM"ROTHERHOODIN%GYPTANDITSOFFSHOOTS INTHE3UNNIWORLD)NTHE3HIITEWORLDSINCETHE)SLAMIC2EVOLUTION OF&UNDAMENTALISMHASALSOBEENPOLITICIZEDONLYTRADITIONALIST 3HIITESAVOIDPOLITICS
!NOTHERFEATURETHATDISTINGUISHES-USLIM&UNDAMENTALISMFROM ITS#HRISTIANCOUNTERPARTISITSRELATIONTOVIOLENCE-INORITYCURRENTSIN #HRISTIAN&UNDAMENTALISMBECOMEMOREORLESSVIOLENTINPARTICULAR INREGARDTOISSUESLIKEABORTION3TILLRECOURSETOPHYSICALVIOLENCEIS AVOIDEDINITSMAJOR&UNDAMENTALISTTRENDSWHEREASIN)SLAMTHERELA TIONTOITISATBESTAMBIVALENT)SLAMICHYPER &UNDAMENTALISTCURRENTS AREPRONETOVIOLENCETHEMOSTVIOLENTTENDENCYBEING*IHADISMWHICH CANBEIDENTIlEDASTHERADICALIZATIONOF)SLAMIC(YPER &UNDAMENTAL ISTTENDENCIES
&INALLY#HRISTIAN&UNDAMENTALISMCONSIDERSITSELFTOBEOPPOSED TOTHESECULARWORLDWHEREASMAJOR)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISMSECTS PARTICULARLY(YPER &UNDAMENTALISTSAND*IHADISTS VIEWTHEIRlGHT NOTONLYAGAINSTSECULARISMBUTALSOAGAINSThFALSEvORFAKE RELIGIONS AMONGWHICHSECULARISMISBUTONEOFTHENUMEROUSENEMIESFAKE -USLIMRULERSSPURIOUS-USLIMS#RUSADERSAND:IONISTSSECULARISM ANDNATIONALISM&ORTHEMWEAREINAWAROFRELIGIONSRATHERTHAN BATTLINGAGAINSTANONRELIGIOUSWORLDANDSECULARISMISAFAKERELIGION JUSTLIKEDEMOCRACYANDOTHERMAJORMODERNMOVEMENTS
4HREE"RANCHESOF&UNDAMENTALISM
4HENOTIONOF&UNDAMENTALISMISTOOBROADTOEXPLAINTHECOMPLEXITY OFTHE)SLAMICPHENOMENON!THREE PRONGEDDIVISIONGIVESABETTER INDICATIONOFITSCOMPLEXITY4HElRSTLEVELISMAINSTREAM&UNDAMEN TALISM-ANY&UNDAMENTALISTGROUPSINTHE-USLIMWORLDSTRONGLY BELIEVEINTHELITERALISTINTERPRETATIONOFTHE+ORANANDTHE0ROPHETIC TRADITIONBUTTHEYAREOPENTOPARTICIPATIONINTHEPLURALISTPARLIA MENTARYSYSTEMANDTHERIGHTOFTHEMAJORITYTORULE4HESEGROUPS HAVEARELIGIOUSUNDERSTANDINGOF)SLAMTHATISCONTRADICTORYTOTHEIR PRACTICE"UTTHEYLIVEWITHTHISCONTRADICTIONACCEPTINGTHEVERDICT OFTHEBALLOTANDBELIEVINGTHAT INTHE LONGRUNPEOPLETHEMSELVES WILLACCEPT)SLAMICRULE)NTHISSCENARIOIMPOSITIONOFTHEIRVERSION OFFAITHTHROUGHVIOLENCEORCOERCIONISEXCLUDEDONPRINCIPLE4HESE &UNDAMENTALISTSFOROPPORTUNISTICANDSOMETIMESIDEOLOGICALREASONS REJECTVIOLENCEINTHEIRDEALINGSWITHTHE7ESTANDDOMINANTPOLITICAL POWERSIN-USLIMSOCIETIES
4HESECONDGROUPISHYPER &UNDAMENTALIST)TACCEPTSPLAYING THEDEMOCRATICGAMEASLONGASITISINTHEMINORITYPOSITIONBUTIT ISNOTSURETHATITWILLABIDEBYTHEMAJORITYRULEIFITHOLDSTHEREINS OFPOWERTHROUGHDEMOCRATICELECTIONS)TSBASICTENETISTHAT)SLAM SHOULD RULEOVER SOCIETY BUT IT REFUSES TOUSE VIOLENCE AS AMEANS TOACHIEVETHATEND)NREALITYTHISGROUPCANHELPRADICAL)SLAMISTS INDIRECTLYORlNANCIALLYBUTTHEYREFUSETOENGAGEINDIRECTlGHTING THROUGHVIOLENCE4HE&)3IN!LGERIAWASHYPER &UNDAMENTALIST')! ITSOFFSHOOTBECAME*IHADISTAFTERTHEMILITARYCOUPTHATOUSTEDTHE &)3FROMTHEPARLAIMENTIN
4HETHIRDGROUPIS*IHADISTS4HEIRVIEWSARECLOSETOTHOSEOF HYPER &UNDAMENTALISTSBUTTHEYSTRONGLYBELIEVETHATTHEPARLIAMEN TARYGAMEORPEACEFULATTEMPTSATIMPOSING!LLAHSRULEAREDOOMED TOFAILUREANDONLYSACREDVIOLENCEWARRANTEDBY*IHADCANOVERCOME THEOBSTACLES
4HE THREE GROUPSHAVE A COMMONDENOMINATOR NAMELY THE ASPIRATIONTOBUILDUPAN)SLAMICTHEOCRACYIN-USLIMCOUNTRIESAND BEYONDTHATTHEWORLD3TILLTHECOMMONALITIESBETWEENTHEMDO NOTPREVENT THEMFROMlGHTINGEACHOTHEROREVENUSINGVIOLENCE AGAINSTEACHOTHER&UNDAMENTALISMHYPER &UNDAMENTALISMAND *IHADISMMAINTAIN AMBIVALENT RELATIONSWITH EACH OTHER5NLIKE *UDAISMAND#HRISTIANITY)SLAMHASNOTUNDERGONEALONGPROCESSOF SECULARIZATION)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISMISNOTONLYAMEANSOFLIV INGAPUREFAITHWITHINTHECLOSEDCIRCLEOFASELF PROCLAIMEDELITEBUT ALSOAMOVEMENTTHATINTENDSTOCONQUERTHEWORLDPEACEFULLYFOR THEMAJORGROUPSWITHINITTHROUGHVIOLENCEINTHECASEOF*IHADISTS )SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISMCANBEPUSHEDTOWARDHYPER &UNDAMENTAL ISMANDTHELATTERCANBECOME*IHADISTTHROUGHMANYMECHANISMS &UNDAMENTALIST CONVERTS ANDBORN AGAIN-USLIMS INDICATE THAT IN SOMECASES&UNDAMENTALISTSBECOME*IHADISTSFORMOREONCONVERTS ANDBORN AGAIN-USLIMSSEECHAPTER 4HEUTOPIAOFTHEUNIlEDAND WORLDWIDE5MMAHASTOBEREALIZEDINTHISWORLDNOTTHEOTHERAND THEREISPROJECTIONNOTTOWARDANhUNDETERMINEDvFUTUREBUTTOWARD AFUTURETOBECONSTRUEDINREALTERMSFOR)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISTS ANDHYPER &UNDAMENTALISTSALIKE
3ECULARIZATIONHASALONGWAYTOGOIN)SLAMINORDERTORENOUNCE THEACCOMPLISHMENTOFRELIGIOUSUTOPIAHEREANDNOWORINTHENEAR FUTUREMAINLYTHROUGHVIOLENCE)SLAMICHYPER &UNDAMENTALISMIS IDEOLOGICALLYCLOSETO*IHADISMALTHOUGHSTRATEGICALLYITISFARFROMIT !NOTHERFEATURETHATDISTINGUISHES&UNDAMENTALISMFROM*IHADISM ANDHYPER &UNDAMENTALISMISCLOSERTO*IHADISMINTHISRESPECT IS THATPERSONALINVOLVEMENTFOR*IHADISNOTONTHEMAINSTREAM&UNDA MENTALISTAGENDAWHEREAS*IHADISTSAREREADYTOENGAGEINDIVIDUALLY
IN VIOLENT ACTION TO ACCOMPLISH THE#ITY OF!LLAH HEREMADINAT ANNABITHE#ITYOFTHE0ROPHETTHE'OLDEN!GEOFTHERULEOFTHE 0ROPHETIN-EDINA ONEARTH
!NOTHERCHARACTERISTICOFTHE-USLIMHYPER &UNDAMENTALISTSIS THATTHEYAREANTI MODERNINAMUCHMOREACTIVEWAYTHAN#HRISTIAN FUNDAMENTALISTS4HEhNUDITYvOFWOMENTHATISTHEIRTAKINGOFFTHE VEIL ANDWOMENSINVOLVEMENTINPUBLICLIFEAREMUCHMOREhPAIN FULvTHANINTHE7ESTWHEREFEMINISTMOVEMENTSHAVEEXERTEDADEEP INmUENCE/THERFAITHSHAVEASIMILARANTI MODERNSTANCEAMONGTHEIR &UNDAMENTALISTBELIEVERS(INDUSANDEVENSOME#HRISTIANSECTSFOR EXAMPLE BUTTHEYDONOTHAVETHESAMETYPEOFUNIlEDIDEOLOGY WITHINTELLECTUALSANDRELIGIOUSINSTITUTIONSTHATWOULDENABLETHEMTO MOBILIZEASIN)SLAM)TISESSENTIALTOUNDERSTANDTHEROLEOFCULTURAL FACTORSESPECIALLYTHEEXTENTTOWHICHTHEYCONTRIBUTETOTHESTRENGTH OF&UNDAMENTALISMIN)SLAM4HEBREAKDOWNOFBARRIERSBETWEENTHE PUBLICANDPRIVATESPHERESWOMENSENTRYINTOTHEPUBLICSPHEREAND THEINmUENCEOF7ESTERNMORESON-USLIMSOCIETIESLIKETHECONSUMP TIONOFALCOHOLHOMOSEXUALITYINTHEPUBLICSPHEREANDTHEENTIRE INDUSTRYOFMOVIESTHATPROMOTEEXHIBITIONISMASANEWhFAITHv ˆALL THESEAREMUCHMOREDEEPLYWOUNDINGTOTHE)SLAMICIDENTITYTHAN OTHERFORCESLIKE#HINESECULTUREOR(INDUISM
)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISMINGENERALENCOMPASSINGHYPER &UN DAMENTALISM AND*IHADISMSHAREMANY ROOTS/NE IS THE+HARIJITE TRADITION/NEOFTHEIRMEMBERS)BN-ULJAMKILLEDTHE&OURTH#ALIPH !LIn BECAUSETHE+HARIJITESBELIEVEDTHATHEHADNOTACTED PROPERLYTOPROMOTETHE)SLAMICETHOSHEHADNOTVIOLENTLYFOUGHT THEDISSENTERS
4HESECONDSOURCEOF&UNDAMENTALISMIS7AHHABISM)DEOLOGI CALLY*IHADISMISATLEASTPARTIALLYTHEOFFSHOOTOF7AHHABISMABRAND OF)SLAMTHATFROMTHEEIGHTEENTHCENTURYONWARDPUSHEDTOWARDAN INTOLERANTCLOSEDANDLITERALISTSYSTEMOFINTERPRETATIONOFTHE+ORAN )TSUNDERSTANDINGOF)SLAMEXCLUDED3UlSMANDOTHER)SLAMICTENDEN CIESLIKE3HIISMINTHENAMEOFTHEPURITYOFTHEFAITH)NTHECOURSE OF THENINETEENTH AND TWENTIETH CENTURIES7AHHABISM SUPPLANTED )SLAMIC TRADITIONALISMAND IMPOSED ITSELF THROUGH3AUDI!RABIAAS THEMAJOR)SLAMICTRADITION*IHADISTSDENOUNCETHE3AUDIREGIMEBUT THEIRRELIGIOUSORIENTATIONISIMBUEDWITH7AHHABISMANDITSEXCLUSIVIST VIEWOF)SLAM4HEYSIMPLYPUSHITTOITSEXTREMECONSEQUENCESAND THEIRSTRATEGYISBASEDONVIOLENCEWHEREAS7AHHABISMASTHEOFlCIAL IDEOLOGYOFTHE3AUDIGOVERNMENTADVOCATESDAWAPROSELYTIZINGFOR THESAKEOF)SLAM ASITSMAINLINEOFCONDUCT3TILLOPPOSITIONTOALL hHUMAN MADEvPOLITICALANDLEGALSYSTEMSISTHEIRCOMMONDENOMI NATOR&ORTHISREASON7AHHABIHYPER &UNDAMENTALISMAND*IHADISM
ENGAGEINACLOSERELATIONSHIPIDEOLOGICALLYANDADEEPHOSTILITYSTRATE GICALLYUNLIKE#HRISTIAN&UNDAMENTALISMWHICHFORTHEMOSTPART REJECTSVIOLENCE
4HE THIRD SOURCE OF &UNDAMENTALISM IS )SLAMIC2EFORMISM WHICHBEGANASANINTELLECTUALMOVEMENTINTHE-USLIMWORLDINTHE LATENINETEENTHCENTURYWITHPEOPLELIKETHE%GYPTIANS-UHAMMAD !BDUHn AND2ASHID2IDHAn THE0ERSIAN *AMALADDINAL!FGHANIn THE)NDIAN3IR!HMED+HAN n THE)NDIAN-OHAMMAD)QBALn ANDPOLITI CALlGURESFROM.ORTH!FRICAAND4URKEY4HEYINTENDEDTOlNDOUT THEORIGINALMEANINGOF)SLAMTHEREFORETHEREFERENCETOTHE3ALAF THECLOSEFOLLOWERSOFTHE0ROPHET ANDADAPTITTOMODERNITY4HEIR ATTITUDEWASBASEDONTHEADOPTIONOF7ESTERNRATIONALISMTOPROMOTE -USLIMSOCIETIES4HEYDIDNOTREFERTOREVOLUTIONBUTTO!WAKENING OR2ENAISSANCE.AHDA ANDTHEIRMAINAIMWASTOLET)SLAMCATCH UPWITHTHE7EST4HEIRENEMYWAS)SLAMICTRADITIONALISMWHOSE MAIN CHARACTERISTICSWERE QUIETISM SCRIPTURALISM AUTHORITARIAN ISMANDCONSERVATISM4HISWASTHEIRCOMMONDENOMINATORWITH 7AHHABISM4OPROMOTETHEIRRATIONALISTAPPROACHTHEYREFERREDTO THE/RIGINOF)SLAMPURGEDFROMSUPERSTITIONANDTRADITIONALISM .AHDAFAILEDASANINTELLECTUALMOVEMENTINTHE-USLIMWORLDAND PARADOXICALLYHELPED)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISMTHROUGHITSREFERENCES TOTHE)SLAMIC'OLDEN!GEANDTOTHEPIOUS3ALAFANDTHEIRREJECTION OFMYSTICISM
)NTHECOURSEOFTHETWENTIETHCENTURY3ALAlSMRADICALIZEDAND EMBRACED%GYPTMAINLYTHROUGHTHE-USLIM"ROTHERHOOD4HISOR GANIZATIONCONSTITUTESTHEFOURTHSOURCEOF&UNDAMENTALISM)TISAN IDEOLOGICALMOVEMENTTHATBEGANWITHITSFOUNDER(ASSANAL"ANNA n ANDATTAINEDITSZENITHINTHESUNDERTHEAEGISOF 3EYED1UTBn IN%GYPTANDIN0AKISTANWITH-AWDUDI ;n= 4HISMOVEMENTWASALSOCALLED3ALAlSTINREFERENCE TOTHEDIRECTDISCIPLESOFTHE0ROPHETTHESO CALLED3ALAFAS3ALEHEEN THEPIOUSANCESTORS 3ALAlSMPITCHED*IHADASTHEPROMINENTWAY OFACHIEVING)SLAMICGOALS)TENDEDWITHTHEKILLINGOFTHE%GYPTIAN PRESIDENT!NWAR3ADATINBY,IEUTENANT+HALED)SLAMBULIA MEMBEROFTHE*IHADISTGROUP4AKlRWAL(IJRA%XCOMMUNICATION AND%XODUS ABREAKAWAYGROUPFROMTHE-USLIM"ROTHERHOOD
3AUDI!RABIAIMPORTEDTHE%GYPTIANBRANDOF3ALAlSMINTHE SBYGIVINGWIDECOVERAGETOTHEWRITINGSOFITSPROTAGONISTSAL "ANNAAND1UTBAMONGOTHERSANDBYPROVIDINGJOBOPPORTUNITIES TOMANYOFITSINTELLECTUALSLIKE!BDULLAH!ZZAMn /MAR !BDAL 2AHMANBORN IN IN%GYPT THE LEADEROF'AMAAAL )SLAMIYACONSIDEREDATERRORISTORGANIZATIONANDSERVINGALIFESEN
TENCEINTHE5NITED3TATESAND-UHAMMAD1UTBˆTHEINmUENTIAL BROTHEROF3EYED1UTBˆWHOASOFSTILLLIVEDIN3AUDI!RABIA 4HEYSERVEDASACADEMICSINTHE3AUDIKINGDOMWHICHISDOMINATED BYTHEIDEOLOGYOF7AHHABISMh)NTERMSOFTHEIRRESPECTIVEFORMA TION7AHHABISMAND3ALAlSMWEREQUITEDISTINCT7AHHABISMWAS APARED DOWN)SLAMTHATREJECTEDMODERNINmUENCESWHILE%GYPTIAN 3ALAlSMSOUGHTTORECONCILE)SLAMWITHMODERNISM7HATTHEYHAD INCOMMONIS THATBOTHREJECTEDTRADITIONAL TEACHINGSON)SLAMIN FAVOROFDIRECT@FUNDAMENTALISTREINTERPRETATIONv4HECOMBINATION OF3AUDI7AHHABISMAND%GYPTIAN3ALAlSMPRODUCEDANEWTYPEOF &UNDAMENTALISMTOWHICH*IHADISMOWESMANYOFITSMAJORIDEAS
)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISMAND(ERMENEUTICS
*IHADISMINITSINTELLECTUALANDTHEOLOGICALTRENDSISROOTEDINTHE &UNDAMENTALISTHERMENEUTICSOFTHE+ORANANDTHE0ROPHETICTRADITION 3UNNA MAINLYBASEDONTHE3AYINGSOFTHE0ROPHETHADITH 5NLIKE 0ROTESTANTISMWHICHOPENEDUPTHEREADINGOFTHE(OLY3CRIPTURESIN THE#HRISTIANWORLDIN)SLAMACONJUNCTIONOFHISTORICALINSTITUTIONAL ANDCULTURALFACTORSHASENDEDUPINhLOCKINGvTHE+ORANINTOARIGID STRAITJACKET-ANY)SLAMIC2EFORMISTSWHOHAVEATTEMPTEDTOPROPOSE NEW INTERPRETIVE FRAMEWORKS FOR THE UNDERSTANDING OF THE 3ACRED "OOKHAVEBEENEITHEREXECUTEDLIKE-AHMOUD4AHAn ORFORCEDTOmEEFORFEAROFBEINGEXECUTEDASAPOSTATESTHE%GYPTIAN .ASR!BU:EYDWASCONDEMNEDASANAPOSTATEFORHISINTERPRETATION OFTHE+ORANANDESCAPEDTO(OLLANDIN
4HEHERMENEUTICSOF THE+ORAN SEALED THROUGHCONSERVATIVE TRADITIONALISM FAVORS *IHADISTS AND&UNDAMENTALISTS ALIKE TO THE DETRIMENTOF2EFORMISTS4RADITIONALPROCEDURESAREBASEDONAFEW MOREORLESSESTABLISHEDPRINCIPLESWITHSOMEDIVERGENCEOFVIEWSON MARGINALISSUES4HEMAJORDETERMININGFACTORISTHEHISTORICALDATE OF THE VERSES )F TWOVERSES CONTRADICT EACHOTHER ANDONE VERSE IS HISTORICALLYLATERTHANANOTHERTHEMORERECENTISPRIVILEGEDOVERTHE OLDERBECAUSEITHASCOMELATERONANDINTHATRESPECTIThABROGATESv THEOTHER4HISISCALLEDTHEhABROGATINGANDABROGATEDvNASIKHMAN SUKH /THERCONSIDERATIONSLIKETHEGENERALITYORSPECIlCITYOFTHE VERSESTHEDEGREEOFTHEIRDETERMINATIONBYCIRCUMSTANCESORTHEIR UNIVERSALITY AND THEIRBEINGCOMMANDMENTSOR STATEMENTSOF FACT IMPERATIVEVERSUSINDICATIVE ALSOENTERINTOACCOUNT3INCETHESO CALLED-EDINAVERSESCAMEAFTERTHE-ECCANVERSESTHEFORMERARE SYSTEMATICALLYPRIVILEGEDOVERTHELATTER4HE-EDINAVERSESAREASA RULEMUCHMOREFOCUSEDONTHEWARIN-EDINA-USLIMSFEAREDTHE
ATTACKBYTHE-ECCANTRIBES THANTHE-ECCAN4HEREFORETHEYARE SEENASSUPERSEDINGTHELATTERWHENTHEVERSESAREINCONmICTINTERMS OF EXEGESIS4HE RULES GOVERNING THE hABROGATINGABROGATEDv VERSES SHEDLIGHTONTHEMONOPOLIZATIONOFHERMENEUTICSBYTHECONSERVA TIVEULAMA!ROUNDTWOHUNDRED+ORANICVERSESWERETHEOBJECTOF THIS RULE IN THEHIGH MEDIEVAL PERIOD4HEIR NUMBERDECREASED TO TWENTYINLATE MEDIEVALTIMESANDHASBEENREDUCEDTOSOMESEVENIN MODERNSTUDIES4HISISPARTIALLYDUETO)SLAMICSCHOLARSHIPONTHE +ORANBUTITISALSODUETOTHECLOSUREOFINTERPRETATIONANDLOCKING OFTHEUNDERSTANDINGOFTHE+ORANMAINLYBYTRADITIONALISTULAMA WHOREFUSETOOPENITTOMODERNITY
3INCETHERULEOFhABROGATIONvAPPLIESINITSTRADITIONALISTGARB *IHADISTSREFERTOTHELATE-EDINASURA2EPENTANCEWHICHWASREVEALED TO-OHAMMADUNDERCIRCUMSTANCESOFWARIN-EDINAASABROGATING OTHERVERSES THATPREACHTOLERANCEANDPEACEFULCOEXISTENCEAMONG THE0EOPLE OF THE"OOK MAINLY#HRISTIANS AND *EWS ANDWHICH WEREREVEALEDBEFORETHE2EPENTANCE4HISVERSE ISAMONGTHE HARSHESTINTHE+ORANh&IGHTTHOSEWHOBELIEVENOTIN!LLAHNORTHE ,AST$AYNORHOLDTHATFORBIDDENWHICHHADBEENFORBIDDENBY!L LAHANDHIS-ESSENGERNORACKNOWLEDGETHE2ELIGIONOF4RUTHFROM AMONG0EOPLEOFTHE"OOKUNTILTHEYPAYTHE*IZIYA;)SLAMICTAXFOR NON -USLIMSUNDERTHEPROTECTIONOF-USLIMS=WITHWILLINGSUBMIS SIONANDFEELTHEMSELVESSUBDUED;HUMILIATED=v4HISVERSEISUSEDBY *IHADISTSTODECLAREWARON#HRISTIANSAND*EWSSINCETHEYREFUSETO PAYTHESO CALLEDTAXJIZIYA 4HEREAREVERSESENJOINING-USLIMS PEACEFULCONDUCTTOWARDOTHERGROUPSANDBETWEENANDTHAT PREACHTOLERANCEANDPEACEINTHE+ORANRESPECTIVELYACCORDINGTO AUTHORIZEDINTERPRETERS(IBAT!LLAH.AHHASAND)BNAL*AWZI BUT THEYALLAREABROGATEDACCORDINGTOTHETRADITIONBYTHEVERSETHAT DECLARESWARONNON -USLIMSBECAUSETHISVERSEWASREVEALEDTOTHE 0ROPHETLATERTHANTHEOTHERS
4HELIMITATIONSPLACEDON+ORANICEXEGESISTHUSHELPSEXTREM ISTSINTHEIRlGHTAGAINSTNON -USLIMSANDREFORM MINDED-USLIMS ASWELL3INCE#ONSERVATIVESAND4RADITIONALISTSALLOVERTHE-USLIM WORLDOVERWHELMINGLYDOMINATETHEOLOGICALUNIVERSITIESORSCHOOLS ANDOFlCIALRELIGIOUSINSTITUTIONSOFLEARNINGTHESITUATIONISFAVOR ABLETO&UNDAMENTALISTSAND*IHADISTSINREGARDTOTHELEGITIMACYOF THEIRVIEW7HATHASTOBECHANGEDISTHISFACTUALMONOPOLYOFTHE CONSERVATIVESOVERTHEINTERPRETATIONOFTHE+ORANANDTHE0ROPHETIC TRADITION)NTHEORYTHEPOWEROFINTERPRETATIONISFREEIN)SLAMAND NOT DEPENDENT ON AN INSTITUTIONAL AUTHORITY BUT IN PRACTICE4RA DITIONALISTSWHOMONOPOLIZE IT ANDUNWITTINGLYGIVE ANENORMOUS ADVANTAGETORADICAL-USLIMSLOCKITUP2EFORMISTSlNDTHEMSELVES
INAPREDICAMENTOFSTRUCTURALMARGINALITYTHEIRVOICESARENOTHEARD ATTHEGRASSROOTSBECAUSETHECONSERVATIVEULAMAHAVESEIZEDPOWER SINCELONGAGO
!SWECANSEEIDEOLOGICALLYANDSOCIALLY*IHADISMISAMOVE MENTDEEPLYEMBEDDEDINTHERADICALVERSIONOF)SLAM)TISNOTONLYA SOCIALMOVEMENTBUTALSOANDMOREIMPORTANTLYANIDEOLOGICALONE )TSSTANCEONSOCIALCHANGEANDHISTORYISDIRECTEDAGAINSTMODERNITY ANDSECULARIZATIONBUTITCANNOTBESIMPLYREDUCEDTOAMOVEMENT hAGAINSTvMODERNITY)TSPROJECTFORSOCIETYISREPRESSIVEBUTITFAS CINATESMANY-USLIMS AND ITS COMPLEXITYMAKES ITPARADOXICALLY SUITABLENOTONLYFORTHE-USLIMWORLDASSUCHBUTALSOFOR%UROPE ASONEOFITSMAJORTHEATERS7ITHOUTUNDERSTANDING*IHADISMINITS DEPTHANDCREATIVITYONEUNDERESTIMATESITSSCOPEANDREACH%VEN WITHOUTTHEPRESENTCRISISWITHINTHE-USLIMWORLDITWOULDSURVIVE ALTHOUGHITWOULDNTTHRIVEASITDOESNOW)FWECALLASOCIALMOVE MENTACOLLECTIVEACTIONRESULTINGFROMTHEPREVAILINGSOCIALSITUATION ANDCLOSELYDEPENDENTONITANIDEOLOGICALMOVEMENTISMUCHMORE PROFOUNDINTHESENSETHATITHASITSCULTURALPROTAGONISTSINCONTI NUITYWITHTHEPASTITSOWNREPRESENTATIONOFSOCIALISSUESTHROUGH INTELLECTUALSANDSOCIALROOTSTHATAREMUCHMOREAUTONOMOUSVIS Í VISTHESOCIALSETTINGTHANAMERESOCIALMOVEMENT!NIDEOLOGICAL MOVEMENT IS GROUNDED IN HISTORY AND IS INSPIRED BY ITS ROOTS IN THEPAST*IHADISTMOVEMENTISOFTHISKINDIN-USLIMSOCIETIES)T ENJOYS THE SUPPORTNOTONLYOF INTELLECTUALS AND SOLDIERSBUTALSO OFTHEHYPER &UNDAMENTALIST-USLIMSANDEVENSOMEMAINSTREAM &UNDAMENTALISTSWHOAREDEEPLYCOMMITTEDTOITSIDEASINDEPENDENT OFCIRCUMSTANCES4HEPREDICAMENTOFTHE-USLIMWORLDSWELLSTHE RANKSOF*IHADISTSANDBRINGSTOITSYMPATHIZERSTHATDONOTBECOME VIOLENTTHEMSELVESBUTAREABLETOGIVEITlNANCIALANDPOLITICALLE VERAGEWITHINTHE5MMA*IHADISMRENEWSASENSEOFDIGNITYWITHIN THE-USLIMWORLDTHATHASBEENDANGEROUSLYERODEDBY%UROPEAN IMPERIALISMANDCONTEMPORARY!MERICANPOLICIESASWELLASTHECRISIS ANDDECLINEOF-USLIMSOCIETIES
)SLAMISTHEONLYMONOTHEISTICRELIGIONWITHASINGLESACREDBOOK DICTATEDBY!LLAHTOASINGLEPERSONTHE0ROPHET-OHAMMADINTWO DECADESWITH THEPROFESSED AIMOF EXPANDINGWORLDWIDE THROUGH DEEDSANDWORDS)TlNDSITSELFINTHEHUMILIATINGPOSITIONOFBEING DOMINATEDBY#HRISTIANAND*EWISHPOWERSINTHEPLACESTHATUSED TOBEPARTOFITSVERYSPHEREOFINmUENCE7HILE*UDAISMAND#HRIS TIANITYHAVEHADTHEIRSACREDBOOKSCOMPILEDTHROUGHTHEAGESTHE DOMINANTTRENDIN)SLAMICTHEOLOGYISTHEBELIEFTHATTHE+ORANHAS REMAINEDUNCHANGEDFROMITSINCEPTIONISTHEDIRECTWORDOF!LLAH ANDNOTTHEHUMANEXPRESSIONOFADIVINELYINSPIREDREVELATIONTOTHE
0ROPHET-OHAMMADTHE-UTAZILAINTHE-IDDLE!GESANDTHE)SLAMIC 2EFORMISTSNOWADAYSQUESTIONTHISTENETWHICHREMAINSDOMINANTIN THE-USLIMWORLD 4HEBELIEFTHATTHE+ORANREMAINEDUNCHANGED FROMITSREVELATIONTO-OHAMMADUPTONOWISHISTORICALLYINACCU RATEBUTMOSTBELIEVERSSTRONGLYENDORSEIT"UTTHE+ORANICTEXTWAS COLLECTEDINARELATIVELYSHORTSPANOFTIMEUNDERTHEREIGNOF&IRST #ALIPH!BUBAKRANDTHE3ECOND/MARINCOMPARISONTOTHE/LD AND.EW4ESTAMENTSWHICHWERECOMPILEDDURINGAMUCHLONGER SPANOFTIMETHE'OSPELSWEREPUTINADElNITIVEFORMDECADESAFTER THEDEATHOF#HRIST
4HESYMBOLICVALUEOFTHE+ORANTO)SLAMISBYFARSUPERIORTO THATOFTHE/LD4ESTAMENTASETOFBOOKS OREVENTHE'OSPELSTO #HRISTIANITY4HE+ORANASTHEDIRECTWORDOF!LLAHMAKESTHEISSUEOF ITSINTERPRETATION)SLAMICHERMENEUTICS AVERYSENSITIVEONE#HRIS TIANTHEOLOGYINTERJECTSBETWEENTHEHOLYTEXTANDTHESOCIALWORLDA HIERARCHICSETOFINTERPRETATIONSSOMEOFTHETEXTSARETOBEUNDER STOODMETAPHORICALLYSOMEOTHERSAREHISTORICALLYDETERMINEDSOME AREMOREIMPORTANTTHANTHEOTHERSSOMEAREALLEGORICORSYMBOLIC ETC "YCONTRAST)SLAMICHERMENEUTICSISSTILLBYANDLARGEDOMINATED BYTHEIDEATHATINTERPRETINGTHE+ORANINMETAPHORICWAYSMEANS DESECRATINGANDVIOLATINGTHE7ORDOF!LLAH4ODAYTHEOVERWHELMING MAJORITYOF2EFORMISTTHINKERSIN)SLAMARENOTFROMTHETRADITIONAL ULAMAANDTHEIRUTTERANCESAGAINSTTHETRADITIONALINTERPRETATIONOF THE+ORANICTEXTSMEETWITHSTIFFRESISTANCEFROMTHEULAMAWHOSTILL DOMINATEMAJOR )SLAMIC INSTITUTIONS IN THE-USLIMWORLD THE!L !ZHARIN%GYPTTHEMAJORRELIGIOUSINSTITUTIONSIN3AUDI!RABIATHE :EITUNAIN4UNISIATHE1OMAND.AJAFRELIGIOUSSCHOOLSINTHE3HIITE WORLDANDSOFORTH
-ODERNIZATIONANDTHE-USLIM7ORLD
)NTHE-USLIMWORLDTHERIFTBETWEEN&UNDAMENTALISTSANDPARTOF SOCIETYHASWIDENEDASWELL)NMAJORCITIESINTHE-USLIMWORLDA SIZEABLEMINORITYOFTHEPOPULATIONLEADSASECULARLIFEANDTHISISTHE VERYSAMEMINORITYTHATISMIDDLECLASSRATHERWELL OFF AND7ESTERN IZED&UNDAMENTALISTSMANYOFTHEMFROMTHELOWERMIDDLECLASSES RESENTTHISSEPARATIONBETWEENRELIGIONANDTHEEMERGINGMODERNIZED PEOPLE SEEING IT AS THE7ESTS TREACHERY AGAINST )SLAM4HE RIFT IN TERMSOFSECULARPEOPLEAND&UNDAMENTALISTSEXISTSELSEWHEREBUTIN -USLIMSOCIETIESBYANDLARGEBECAUSETHEMODERNIZATIONPROCESSWAS SOLATEMAINLYTHESECONDHALFOFTHENINETEENTHCENTURYEXCEPTFOR 4URKEYWHICHBEGANATTHEEIGHTEENTHCENTURY THEREISADEEPSENSE
OFAMBIVALENCETOWARDMODERNIZATIONANDSECULARIZATION-USLIMS WHOHAVEINSTITUTIONSOFLEARNINGRELIGIOUSSCHOOLSANDATRADITION OFJURIDICAL)SLAMAREUSUALLYABLETOMOBILIZETHESEGROUPSTOCOMBAT SECULARISMAND7ESTERNIZATION
(ISTORICALLY SECULARMOVEMENTS LEADING TO INDEPENDENCE IN !LGERIAAMONGOTHERS THEREJECTIONOF7ESTERNIMPERIALISM.ASSER IN%GYPT ORANENDTODIRECT7ESTERNINmUENCE2EZA3HAHIN)RAN FAILED TO OPENUP-USLIM SOCIETIES FROMBELOW4HEIR REAL NATURE WASSECULARANDMODERNRULEMINUSDEMOCRACY4HEIRFAILUREHELPED &UNDAMENTALISTSWHOHADANEASYTASKTOIDENTIFYMODERNITYWITH CRISISNOTWITHMAJORPROGRESS-ODERNIZINGREGIMESINTHE-USLIM WORLDHAVEBEENMOSTLYAUTHORITARIANDESPOTICAND*ACOBINCONCEN TRATINGPOLITICSINTHEHANDSOFASINGLEPERSON.ASSERIN%GYPTTHE 3HAHIN)RAN"OURGUIBAIN4UNISIA"OUMEDIENNEIN!LGERIAETC 4HEYFAILEDTOMODERNIZE-USLIMSOCIETIESOTHERTHANBYINFUSINGIN THEMASENSEOFHATREDFORDEMOCRACYPERCEIVEDASA7ESTERNFALLACY BECAUSETHEVERYSAMEDICTATORSWEREUSUALLYSUPPORTEDBYTHE7EST LIKETHE3HAHOREVEN3ADDAM(USSEINBEFOREATTACKING+UWAITIN 5NLIKETHEMTRADITIONALAUTOCRATICREGIMESBEFOREMODERN IZATIONREFERREDTO)SLAMICRULESINGENERALANDFOUNDCOMPROMISES WITHTHE-USLIMCOMMUNITIESHIERARCHIESEXPRESSINGTHEMSELVESIN ANIDIOMTHATCOULDBEUNDERSTOODBYPEOPLEORTHEIRRELIGIOUSELITES -ODERNIZINGREGIMESBECAMEAUTOCRATICTHROUGHTHEIRREFERENCETO ONEOFTWO7ESTERNMODELSCAPITALISMORCOMMUNISMANDBOTHLED TODISMALRESULTSASACONSEQUENCEOFTHEIRMEAGERACHIEVEMENTSAND THEIRDESTRUCTIONOFTHECOMMUNITYTISSUE
!SAWORLDSYSTEMCOMMUNISMUNTIL THE3OVIET INVASIONOF !FGHANISTANINWASABULWARKAGAINSTTHEEXPANSIONOF)SLAMIC RADICALISMBECAUSEITPROTECTEDAGAINSTTHE!MERICAN )SRAELIALLIANCE ANDINSOMECOUNTRIESLIKE!LGERIAITSINDUSTRIALIZATIONMODELWASSEEN ASANALTERNATIVETOCAPITALISM#OMMUNISMCOMPETEDWITH-USLIM &UNDAMENTALISTSANDPARTOFTHE-USLIMWORLDWASINmUENCEDBY ITTOTHEDETRIMENTOFTHE&UNDAMENTALISTS4HEENDOFCOMMUNISM GAVETHELATTERAMONOPOLYOVEROPPOSITIONTOTHECORRUPTANDAUTO CRATICREGIMESINTHE-USLIMWORLDASWELLASOVERTHECRITIQUEOFTHE 7EST7HERETHEPOLITICALREGIMEWASLESSAUTOCRATICANDMOREOPEN TOSOCIETY)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISMWOULDBEMUCHLESSVIOLENTAND MOREPRONETOCOMPROMISETHANELSEWHEREEG4URKEY
)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISTSANDINPARTICULAR*IHADISTSARECON VINCEDTHATTHEYARElGHTINGAGAINSTANOTHERRELIGIONAFAKEONE4HEY BELIEVETHATSECULARISMISEPITOMIZEDBYDEMOCRACYPARLIAMENTARISM HEDONISM AND INDIVIDUALISM &OR THEM THEMAJOR BATTLE IS NOT AGAINSTANONRELIGIOUSWORLDBUTAGAINSTONETHATISRELIGIOUSINITS
OWNPERVERSEWAY4HEYARECERTAINLYlGHTINGTHISWORLDOFSECULAR VALUESTOTHEUTMOSTOFTHEIRCAPACITYBUTTHEYIDENTIFYSECULARISMAS ANOTHERFAITHANDNOTASNONRELIGIOUS&ROMTHEIRPERSPECTIVETHEY ARElGHTINGWITHINARELIGIOUSUNIVERSEWHERETHERELIGIONOFTRUTH THEIRVERSIONOF)SLAM ISATWARWITHRELIGIONSOF5NTRUTHSECULARISM #HRISTIANITY)SLAMICREFORMISMAND*UDAISMAMONGOTHERS
4HE*IHADIST#RITIQUEOFTHE&UNDAMENTALIST5LAMA
4HECRITIQUEOFDEMOCRACYSEECHAPTER GOESHANDINHANDWITH THECRITIQUEOFTHOSE5LAMA)SLAMICJURISTS WHOPROMOTE2EFORM IST IDEAS AND THOSE&UNDAMENTALISTSWHO TRY TOlND COMPROMISES BETWEEN THEIR RELIGIOUS VIEWS ANDMODERN TRENDS TOWARDPOLITICAL PARTICIPATIONLIKEELECTIONSPOLITICALPARTIESETC !MONGTHELATTER 1ARADHAWI CLOSE TO THE-USLIM"ROTHERHOOD ISONEOF THEMOST PROMINENTlGURES*IHADIST5LAMAANDINTELLECTUALSCROSSSWORDSWITH HIMASTHEYDIDWITH"IN"AZTHE3AUDIRELIGIOUSAUTHORITYBEFOREHIS DEATHIN/NEOFTHEMAINCONCERNSOF&UNDAMENTALIST5LAMA ISTOAVOIDUSELESSBLOODSHEDINTHENAMEOF)SLAM/NTHECONTRARY *IHADISTSBELIEVETHATVIOLENCEISUNAVOIDABLEANDTHAT)SLAMCANNOT THRIVEWITHOUTRECOURSETO*IHADDElNEDINTERMSOFCOMBATQITAL ORKILLINGANDSUBDUINGINlDELS
4ARTUSIAMAJOR*IHADIST INTELLECTUALBELIEVESTHAT4RUTHCAN NOTBEESTABLISHEDUNLESSTHEREISVIOLENCEANDBLOODSHEDh(OWIS ITPOSSIBLETOPROMOTE*IHADWITHOUTSPILLINGASINGLEDROPOFBLOOD ;(ETHENQUOTESTHE3URA2EPENTANCEVERSE=$OYOUWANT THEDOMINATIONOFTHISRELIGIONWITHOUTSACRIlCINGASINGLEDROP;OF BLOOD=INTHEPATHOF!LLAHlSABILILLAH 4HISISASTINGYATTITUDE BEYONDANYMEASURE$OYOUSEE$OCTOR;1ARADHAWI=THEDEFENSE OFTHE2IGHTAGAINSTTHE7RONGWITHOUTSPILLINGBLOODv
&ROMTHE*IHADISTSPOINTOFVIEWVIOLENCEISTHEMAJORMEANS TOACHIEVE!LLAHSPURPOSEONEARTH4HEREISARUTHLESSWARBETWEEN RIGHTANDWRONGTHATCANNOTBEESCAPEDIFTHE-USLIMCOMMUNITY WANTSTOMAINTAINITSDIGNITYANDHONORh)FTHE5MMAWISHESDIGNITY ANDLIFE ITSHOULDENGAGEIN*IHADFORTHESAKEOF!LLAHANDTHERE ISNOALTERNATIVETOITTHAN*IHAD"EHAPPYORUNHAPPYWHOEVERIS CONCERNEDTHISISWHATHUNDREDSOFRELIGIOUSTEXTSSAYFROMTHE+O RANANDTHE4RADITIONSOFTHE0ROPHETWHICHASSERTTHEWARBETWEEN 2IGHTAND7RONGv
!NYCOMPROMISEWITHMODERNLIFEISREJECTEDINTHENAMEOF THEPURITYOFTHEFAITHANDLOYALTYTOWARDTHE7ORDOF!LLAHANDTHE 0ROPHETICTRADITION
4HE3HEIKHAND$OCTOR;1ARADHAWI=SAYSTHATTHEPRINCIPLEIN)S LAMICRULINGISBASEDONSATISFYINGPEOPLEANDTHEIRDESIRESANDTHEIR FREECHOICEANDSOON!CCORDINGTOTHISIDEASHOULDWERESPECTTHE WISHESTHECHOICESANDTHEDESIRESOFPEOPLEIFTHEYCHOOSEANOTHER RELIGIONTHAN)SLAM3HOULDWEBREAKRELIGIOUSTEXTSTHATCOMPEL USTOlGHTAGAINSTAPOSTATESEVERYWHEREONEARTHWITHOUTRESPECTING THEDESIRESANDTHEWISHESOFPEOPLEINTHATSENSE&ROMTHISPOINT OFVIEW!BU"AKR;THE&IRST#ALIPHAFTERTHE0ROPHET=ANDALLTHE COMPANIONSINARMSSAHABAH OFTHE0ROPHETWEREWRONGTOlGHT AGAINST-USAYLAMAHTHELIAR;HEPRETENDEDTOBETHE0ROPHET=AND THOSEWITHHIMAMONGTHEAPOSTATESSINCETHEYOPPOSEDTHEWISHES ANDDESIRESOFTHOSEPEOPLE
1ARADHAWIAPROMINENTMEMBEROFTHE-USLIM"ROTHERHOODISNOT AREFORMIST)SLAMICTHINKER(ISPOSITIONSAREBRANDISHEDINTHE7ESTAS RADICALINIMICALTOIT3TILL*IHADISTSSTIGMATIZEHIMANDOTHERMEMBERS OFTHE-USLIM"ROTHERHOODASNOTBEINGGENUINE-USLIMSFORLACKOF ENGAGEMENTINVIOLENT*IHAD4HEYAREACCORDINGTO*IHADISTSATBEST SPURIOUS-USLIMSSUSTAININGTHEIRINTERPRETATIONTHROUGHTHE3AYINGS OFTHE0ROPHETh4HE0ROPHETSAID7ILLCOMEOUTOFMY5MMAAGROUP OFPEOPLEWHOREADTHE+ORANALTHOUGHTHEIRREADINGISNOTVALIDAND THEIRRITUALSANDTHEIRFASTINGSARETHESAME;ASTHEOTHERS=THEYREAD THE+ORANANDBELIEVEITISTHEIRSBUTINREALITYITISAGAINSTTHEMAND THIS;READING=DOESNOTGOBEYONDTHEIRVOCALCORDS;THROAT=4HEYHAVE LEFT)SLAMINTHESAMEWAYASTHEARROWLEAVESTHEBOWv
4HEOBSESSIONWITHUNITYINALLASPECTSOF-USLIMLIFEISINCON TRADICTIONWITHMAJORTRENDSINMODERNITYWHEREDIVERSIlCATIONAND MULTIPLICITYOFCHOICESAREFUNDAMENTALASPECTSOFINDIVIDUALISMAS WELLASCOMPLEXSOCIALORGANIZATIONS*IHADISTSAREDEADSETAGAINSTTHE CULTURALANDSOCIALCONSEQUENCESOFMODERNIZATIONANDTHEYREFERTO THE/RIGINSOF)SLAMTHIS'OLDEN!GEWHEREALLHEARTSBEATATTHESAME PACETOVINDICATETHEIRlGHTTOTHEDEATHAGAINSTTHESEMAJORTRENDS NAMELYSECULARIZATIONINDIVIDUALIZATIONANDANON -ANICHEANWORLD 4HEMYTHOFUNITYWIPESOUTALLTHESEDIMENSIONSOFMODERNLIFEIN WHICH-USLIMSOCIETIESAREINEVITABLYINVOLVEDh)FWERETURNTOTHE "EGINNINGSOF)SLAMWElNDNOTHINGBUTAUNIQUECOMMUNITYUNDER AUNIQUELEADERSHIPTHE)SLAMICCOMMUNITYUNDERTHEUNIQUE)MAM THE0ROPHETANDAFTERHIMUNDERTHELEADERSHIPOFTHE7ELL 'UIDED #ALIPHS;THElRSTFOURCALIPHS=v
4OGIVELEGITIMACYTOTHEIRSTANCETHEYMAKEAPOLEMICALDISTINC TIONBETWEENTHE5LAMAOFTHE)SLAMICAWAKENING5LAMAALSAHWAH ANDTHE5LAMAOFTHEILLEGITIMATEKINGSANDRULERS5LAMAAL3ALA TIN 4HELATTERARECOMPLICITWITHILLEGITIMATERULERSWHOWORKHAND
INHANDWITH7ESTERN IDOLWORSHIPPERS TAQUT 4HISDISTINCTION MADEBYMANY*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSHASTHESAMEFEATURESIN3HIITE RADICALISM+HOMEINIDISTINGUISHEDBETWEENTHE5LAMAOFhPURELY -OHAMMEDAN)SLAMvANDTHOSEOFh!MERICAN)SLAMv3HIITEAND 3UNNIRADICALISMAREVERYCLOSETOEACHOTHERINSPITEOFTHEIRMUTUAL HATREDANDREJECTION
4HE5LAMAOFTHEILLEGITIMATERULERSAREACCOMPLICESOFTHEhEVIL 4RINITYvSALUSALKHABIS *EWS#RUSADERSAND!POSTATES#ONTRARYTO 2EFORMIST)SLAMWHICHTREATS#HRISTIANSAND*EWSASh0EOPLEOFTHE "OOKvANDTHEREFOREOFTHESAME!BRAHAMICROOTSANDUNLIKE)SLAMIC &UNDAMENTALISTSWHOENDEAVOR TOlNDCOMPROMISESWITH THE TWO OTHER!BRAHAMICRELIGIONSINTERMSOFPACIlCCOEXISTENCE*IHADISTS REJECTTHEMINSOMETIMESINSULTINGWAYSQUALIFYING#HRISTIANSAND *EWSASh"RETHRENOFMONKEYSANDSWINEvANDFUNDAMENTALIST5LAMA ASTHEPEOPLEOFAPOSTASYANDPERVERSITYZALALAH BETRAYERSOF)SLAM ANDTHEHERITAGEOFTHE0ROPHET
7HATISTHEAIMOFTHEILLEGITIMATE5LAMATHOSEWHOARESUBSERVI ENTTOTHEIDOLATROUSKINGSANDRULERSTHE5LAMAOFTHE3ALATIN 7ITHIN THEh!LLIANCEOFTHE%VILvWITHTHE5NFAITHFUL+UFFAR THE!POSTATES MURTADDIN ANDTHE(YPOCRITESMUNAlQIN THEYINTEND
TOPROVETHERELIGIOUSLEGITIMACYOF;ILLEGITIMATE=GOVERNMENTSWHO SHOULDBEFOLLOWEDNECESSARILY;BY-USLIMS=TOPROVETHERELIGIOUS LEGITIMACYOF7ESTERNOCCUPATIONANDTHEIRECONOMICANDMILITARY COLONIALINSTITUTIONSIN;-USLIM=COUNTRIESUNDERTHEPRETEXTTHAT THEYAREhPROTECTEDvMUSTAMIN BY-USLIMGOVERNMENTSBEING THEIRGUESTSTOPROVETHERELIGIOUSLEGITIMACYOFTHE:IONIST)SRAELI OCCUPATION IN THE THREEWORSHIPPING PLACES ;OF )SLAM= AND THE lRSTOFTHESACREDPLACES*ERUSALEMANDITSSURROUNDINGSANDTHE RECOGNITIONOFTHERELIGIOUSLEGITIMACYOFTHE0EOPLEOFMONKEYS ANDSWINETOPROVETHATALLTHOSEWHOPUTINTOQUESTIONTHISEVIL TRINITY;*EWS#RUSADERS-USLIM!POSTATES=ARESPREADINGDEPRAV ITYONTHEFACEOFTHEEARTHMUFSIDlLARDH BEING+HARIJITESAND HAVINGNOTHINGTODOWITH)SLAM;TOPRETENDTHAT=THOSEWHOWANT TOCALLFOR)SLAMCANDOITPEACEFULLYTHROUGHTHEELECTIONSINTOTHE )DOLATROUS0ARLIAMENTSBIRLIMANATALTAWAQIT ANDTHEIRPARTICIPA TIONINTHEGOVERNMENTINWAYSTHATARE;FROMTHEGENUINE)SLAMIC VIEW=NOTACCEPTEDBYTHEWORDOF!LLAH
4HEDENUNCIATIONOFNON *IHADIST5LAMAISNOTCONlNEDTOTHE THEOLOGICALANDINTELLECTUALREALMBUTEXTENDSTOTHESYMBOLICSPHERE 4HUSAL3URIlNDSFAULTWITH"IN"AZn THEFORMEROF lCIALRELIGIOUSAUTHORITY'RAND-UFTI IN3AUDI!RABIAFORHAVING
ENDORSEDTHE3AUDIKINGSRECEPTIONOFINSIGNIAINTHESHAPEOFACROSS FROMAFOREIGNGOVERNMENTh7HILSTTHE+ING;OF3AUDI!RABIA=HUNG THE#ROSS;THEMEDAL=ONHISCHESTANDAPPEAREDWITHITBEFORETHE WORLDWITHJOYANDPLEASUREYOU;3HEIKH"IN"AZ=JUSTIlEDANDIN TERPRETEDTHISINAGHASTLYMANNERINSPITEOFTHEEVIDENCEOFITSBEING AHERETICALACTv,IKEWISESUPPORTINGTHE!MERICANGOVERNMENTIN ITSWARTORECOVER+UWAITFROM3ADDAMSOCCUPATIONINISSEEN ASCOLLUSIONWITHINlDELSAND3AUDI!RABIASSINCONTRARYTO"IN"AZS APPROVALh7HEN#RUSADERSAND*EWISHFORCESFOUGHTINTHE'ULF7AR ;n=INCOLLUSIONWITH;THE3AUDI=SYSTEMˆOCCUPATIONOF THE COUNTRIES IN THENAMEOF THE LIBERATIONOF+UWAITˆYOU ;"IN "AZ=JUSTIlEDTHISTHROUGHAREPRESSIVEFATWAWHICHLEGITIMIZEDTHIS HORRIBLEACTTHATINSULTEDTHEDIGNITYOFTHE5MMASULLIEDITSHONOR ANDDElLEDITSSACREDVALUESGIVINGASAPRETEXTTHENOTIONOF@SEEKING THEHELPISTIANAH OFTHE(ERETICSATTIMESOFEMERGENCYNEGLECTING THERESTRICTIONSIMPOSEDONTHISNOTIONANDTHENECESSARYRELIGIOUS CONDITIONSOFITSAPPLICATIONv
&OR*IHADISTTHINKERSTHEREISANONGOINGBATTLEBETWEENARROGANT 7ESTERNERSAND-USLIMSWORLDWIDEANDTHOSEWHODELAYORHINDERIT INANYMANNERARETOBEFOUGHTAGAINST!YMANAL:AWAHIRITHEMAIN IDEOLOGUEOF!L1AEDAEXPRESSESTHIS*IHADISTCREEDINATRANSPARENT WAYh4HISDECADEOF-USLIMCOMMUNITYSHISTORYWITNESSESAHUGE CONmICTBETWEENTHEFORCESOF(ERESYAND2EVOLTAGAINST!LLAHAND DOMINATIONANDARROGANCEISTIKBAR ONTHEONEHANDAND-USLIM COMMUNITIESANDTHEIRJIHADISTVANGUARDONTHEOTHER4HISCONmICT REACHES ITS APOGEE IN THE FORTUNATE ATTACKS AGAINST.EW9ORK AND 7ASHINGTON;3EPTEMBER=ANDASACONSEQUENCETHEDECLARATION BY"USHOFANEW#RUSADERSWARAGAINST)SLAMANDWHATHECALLED THEWARON4ERRORv
)NTHECONTEMPORARYWORLDMANY-USLIMSEXPERIENCEHUMILIA TIONALACKOFCONlDENCEINTHEFUTUREANDAFEELINGOFDESPONDENCY -ODERNITYWHICHHASBEEN FORMANYSOCIETIESAPROMISEOFBETTER LIFEANDMATERIALANDINTELLECTUALPROGRESSHASBEENFORMOSTOFTHE -USLIMWORLDANAGEOFDECADENCEHISTORICALREGRESSIONDESPOTISM INBOTHITSRELIGIOUSANDITSSECULARFORMSANDECONOMICANDCULTURAL CRISIS&ROMAPASTOFGLORY-USLIMSHAVEBEENTHROWNINTOANAGE OFDECLINEONCEAWORLDPOWER)SLAMICLANDSHAVEBEENSUBJECTTO COLONIALRULEANDTHENDICTATORSHIPSTHENATIONALISTDICTATORSHIPOF .ASSERIN%GYPTTHEFASCISTDICTATORSHIPOFTHE"ATHPARTYIN3YRIA AND)RAQTHEAUTOCRATICRULEOFTHE3HAHIN)RANANDSUBSEQUENTLY THE)SLAMIC2EPUBLICSTHEOCRACYTHEMILITARYRULEIN0AKISTANETC .O)SLAMICCOUNTRYBESIDES4URKEYHASHADANOPENPOLITICALSYSTEM ANDIN4URKEYTHISHASBEENACHIEVEDATTHECOSTOFSOMERELIGIOUS
FREEDOMTHROUGHTHELAÆCIT£SYSTEMIMPORTEDFROMTHE&RENCHVERSION OFSECULARISM-OREOVERTHECREATIONOF)SRAELHASBEENATRAUMATIC EXPERIENCEINTHE-USLIMWORLDWHERETHEMAJORITYOFTHEPOPULA TIONREFUSESTORECOGNIZEITSREALITYOTHERTHANBEINGANEXCRESCENCEOF 7ESTERNANDPARTICULARLY!MERICAN IMPERIALISM!MERICANPOLITICSIN THE-IDDLE%ASTHASALSOPLAYEDAROLEINPOLARIZING-USLIMSOCIETIES AGAINSTDEMOCRATICVALUES
)SLAMIC COUNTRIESMANAGEMENT OFMODERNIZATIONHAS BEEN A FAILUREINTHEOVERWHELMINGMAJORITYOFCASESWITHSOMEEXCEPTIONS LIKE-ALAYSIA %VERYTHINGhMODERNvISTHEREFORESEENASATHREATTO PERSONALASWELLASNATIONALANDRELIGIOUSIDENTITYBYMANYEMBITTERED -USLIMS4HESUCCESSOFRADICALIDEOLOGIESIN)SLAMISNOTSOMUCHDUE TOTHELACKOFREFORMISTIDEASWITHIN!LLAHSRELIGIONTHEREAREMANY REFORM MINDED)SLAMICINTELLECTUALSOVERALMOSTALLTHE-USLIMWORLD BUTTOTHEFACTTHATMODERNITYISDEEMEDASAMENACETOTHE-USLIM WAYOFLIFEASWELLAS-USLIMSDIGNITYANDSELF RESPECTAMONGLARGE STRATASOFTHEPOPULATION4HESITUATIONSIN"OSNIA!FGHANISTAN)RAQ 0ALESTINEAND,EBANONAREONEFACTORFURTHERMOREMANY-USLIMS EXPERIENCEHUMILIATIONTHROUGHTELEVISIONCOVERAGEBY!L*AZEERAAS WELLASNATIONALMEDIATHROUGHOUTTHEWORLDWIDE)SLAMICCOMMUNITY UNDERGOINGDEFEATANDABASEMENT4HESEARETHEREASONSTHATPUSH MANY-USLIMSTOFAVORRADICALANDPESSIMISTICIDEASOVERTHOSELADEN WITHHOPEANDOPENNESSTOTHEWORLD*IHADISTINTELLECTUALSPROPOSEAN UNDERSTANDINGOFTHEPREVAILINGPREDICAMENTANDAMYTHICALSOLUTION TOITTHATINTIMESOFDEEPCRISISAREMETWITHAFEELINGOFRELIEFBY MAINSTREAM-USLIMSOCIETY
-OHAMMAD1UTBISONEOFTHOSEWHOPROPOSEAGLOOMYIN TERPRETATIONOFPRESENTTIMESANDANEXPLANATIONASTOHOWAGODLESS SOCIETYCANBESUPERIORTOGOD ABIDING-USLIMS(EDElNES7ESTERN SOCIETY AS h0ROMETHEANv THAT IS A COMMUNITY THAT DElES'OD h-ODERN0ROMETHEUSACCORDINGTO*ULIAN(UXLEY REPRESENTSCON TEMPORARY%UROPE(EDElES'OD!LMIGHTYANDSUCCEEDSINDOING IT&ROMANOTHERPOINTOFVIEWSOMEPEOPLEAREAMAZEDAT%UROPEAN SUCCESSESINSPITEOFTHEIRBEINGGODLESSKAlR ANDASKTHEMSELVES )SITTHEPERMISSIONOF!LLAHS0ROVIDENCETHATALSOPROMISES'ODLESS PEOPLEDESTRUCTIONANDANNIHILATIONv7HYAREUNBELIEVERSTHRIV INGAND-USLIMSARENT4HEANSWERISTHATPROSPERITYONEARTHISNOT RELATEDTOANYSPECIlCBELIEFh!LLAHDESTINESMANFORHISRESIDENCEAND ENJOYMENTONEARTHINTHETIMEAND(EDOESITFORALLMENBELIEVER ANDDISBELIEVERALIKEv&OR!LLAHPROSPERITYINTHISWORLDISWORTHLESS /NLYOTHERWORLDLYMERITSAREOFSIGNIlCANCEh!LLAHTHE!LMIGHTYDID NOTOFFER$ISBELIEVERSBENElTSOFEARTHLYEXISTENCEATTHEBEGINNINGBUT
DIDITTOBOTH"ELIEVERSAND$ISBELIEVERSALIKE)THASTOBESAIDTHAT THEWORLDISNOTEVENWORTHTHEWINGOFAMOSQUITOAND(EOFFERS ITTOTHE$ISBELIEVEROUTOFCONTEMPTFORHIMBUT2ESURRECTIONWILL ONLYBENElT"ELIEVERSv
4HERE ISAN INDIFFERENCETOWARD LIFE INTHISWORLDTHATMAKES SUCCESSEQUALLYACCESSIBLETOTHEBELIEVERANDTHEGODLESSCONTRARYTO THEOTHERWORLDINWHICHONLYBELIEVERSHAVEACCESSTOPARADISEh4HE 0ROPHETSAYS!LLAHOFFERSTHISWORLDTOTHOSEWHOM(ELIKESANDTHOSE WHOM(EDISLIKESBUTOFFERSTHE/THER7ORLDONLYTOTHOSEWHOM (ELIKES;4HE3AYINGOFTHE0ROPHETQUOTEDBY!HMADTHE(ADITH COMPILER=v$ESTRUCTIONOFDISBELIEVERSFOLLOWSTHEIREARTHLYSUCCESS h4HElRSTFACTISTHAT!LLAHOFFERS$ISBELIEVERSEARTHLYGOODSBEFORE DESTROYINGTHEM4HESECONDFACTISTHATWELFARETO$ISBELIEVERS THATINCLUDESTHEIRTAKINGPOSSESSIONOFTHE%ARTHANDOPENINGTHEM THEDOORSTOALLTHINGSFORALONGERORSHORTERTIMEIMPLIESTHEIRBEING DEPRIVEDOFOTHERWORLDLYMERITSANDTHEIRENDINGUPIN(ELLv
!LLAHLETSPEOPLEACTONEARTHBUT(ECANINTERVENESOMETIMES AGAINSTNATURALCAUSESINAMIRACULOUSWAYCONTRADICTINGCAUSALLINKS BETWEENEVENTS1UTBPROPOSESAFEWCASESIMPLYINGTHAT-USLIMS COULDGETTHEUPPERHANDSINCETHEYARETHOSEWHOWILLINHERITTHE %ARTHINSPITEOFTHEFACTTHATTHEYARENOTTHEMOSTPOWERFULTHEY BECOMELEADERSINANSUPERNATURALWAYTHATCANNOTBEACCOUNTEDFOR THROUGHACAUSE AND EFFECTCHAINOFEVENTS
.ATURALCAUSESDONOTACTBYTHEMSELVESBUTTHROUGHTHEWILLOF !LLAH!FEWEXAMPLES (ITLERTOOKALLTHATHUMANBEINGSCANDOTOVANQUISHTHE!LLIES ANDCHALLENGEDTHROUGHITTHEPOWEROF!LLAH!NDHESAIDTHATHIS ARMYWOULDTAKEHOLDOF2USSIAASEASILYASTHEKNIFECUTSAPIECE OFCHEESE(ESAIDTHATHEWOULDNOTCOMMITTHESAMEMISTAKES AS.APOLEONANDWOULDNOTLETITLASTUPTOTHETIMEOFFREEZETHAT KILLED.APOLEONSARMY!LLAHSWILLIMPOSEDWHATWASNOT(ITLERS WILLAND2USSIANSMADEITLASTUPTOTHETIMEOFFREEZETHATDESTROYED HISARMYASITDID.APOLEONS ;!NOTHER SET OF EVENTS IS THE FACT THAT=2USSIANS ENTERED!F GHANISTANANDTHEYWERESUREOFTHEIRVICTORYANDTHOUGHTTHATIT WOULDNOTTAKEMORETHANAFEWMONTHSTOPACIFYTHATCOUNTRY TAKINGINTOACCOUNTTHEIROVERWHELMINGSUPERIORITY INNUMBERS ANDMILITARY PREPARATION"UT THEY DID NOT TAKE INTO ACCOUNT !LLAHSWILLANDTHEYDONTBELIEVEIN!LLAHATALLTHEYONLYBELIEVE INMATERIALCAUSESANDTAKINGTHEMINTOACCOUNT THEREWASNO COMMONMEASUREBETWEENWHATTHEYPOSSESSEDANDWHAT!FGHANS
POSSESSED;INMILITARYMIGHT="UTAGAIN!LLAHSWILLWASDIFFERENT FROMTHATOF2USSIANSAND!FGHANSSUCCEEDEDINlGHTINGFORTEN COMPLETEYEARSAND2USSIANSWEREFORCEDTOLEAVE!FGHANISTANAT THEEND
$ISBELIEVERSAREUNDERTHEILLUSIONTHATTHEIRSUCCESSESWILLLEAD THEMTOTHEIRVICTORYOVER)SLAMBUT!LLAHWILLATSOMEINDElNITE TIME REVERSE THE TREND AND CONDEMN THEM TO ANNIHILATION h!LLAH LETS$ISBELIEVERSKNOWTHAT(EHADDESTINEDTHISRELIGION;)SLAM=TO TAKEHOLDOFTHE%ARTHANDTHAT$ISBELIEVERSWONTBEABLETODESTROY IT ON EARTH AS THEYWISH IN THE INNERMOSTOF THEIR CONSCIENCE 4HEYSHOULDBETAUGHTTHATCAUSESDONOTLEADTOEFFECTSBYTHEIROWN EXISTENCEIFITISNOTWITH!LLAHSWILL"UT!LLAHBRINGS$ISBELIEVERS GRADUALLY CLOSER TO THE INCENTIVES THEY TAKEˆAS A PUNISHMENT FOR THEIRDISBELIEF AND THEIR COLD SHOULDER ;TOWARD!LLAH=ˆUNTIL THEIR INCENTIVESPUTTHEMTODEATHATTHEENDv(OWISTHISPOSSIBLE"Y LURINGTHEM!LLAHDECEIVES$ISBELIEVERSINTOANEARTHLYSUCCESSTHAT ISAPRELUDETOTHEIRDEATH
4HESTRENGTHENINGOFCONTEMPORARY*AHILIYAANDTHEIRDISPOSINGOF POWERANDTHEIROPENINGOFALLDOORSCONTINUEACCORDINGTOGODLY 4RADITIONSWITHOUTOPPOSITION7ESHOULDSTILLKNOWTHATTHEREIS A DIFFERENCEˆAND EVENDIFFERENCESˆBETWEEN THE STRENGTHENING ;ENABLEMENT=THROUGH!LLAHSCONSENTBYWHICH!LLAHHELPS"ELIEVERS ANDTHESTRENGTHENINGBYLURINGTHAT!LLAHOFFERSTO$ISBELIEVERS FORTHEIRWISHOFTHISWORLDANDFORTHEIRSPENDINGMUCHEFFORTTO ACHIEVEIT!LLAHOFFERSTHEMREWARDSINTHISWORLDANDOPENSTHEM UPALLTHEDOORSTHATBELONGTOTHISTYPEOFSTRENGTHENING #ONTRARYTOGODLESSPEOPLEWHOAREENABLEDBY!LLAHSLURING GENUINE-USLIMSARESTRENGTHENEDBY!LLAHSCONSENT4HELATTER SUBSTANTIALLYDIFFERFROMTHEFORMERINTHEIRDURATION 4HElRSTDIFFERENCEISTHATSTRENGTHENINGBYLURINGISATEMPORARY ONEWHATEVERITSDURATION)TALWAYSENDSUPINDESTRUCTIONWHEREAS STRENGTHENINGBY!LLAHSCONSENTISPERMANENTEVENIFSOMETHINGIN PEOPLESMINDCHANGESANDTHEYAREBRUSHEDASIDEANDAREMOVED AWAYFROMIT"UTTHEYDONTCHANGETHEIRMINDINREACHINGTOTHIS TYPE OF ENABLEMENT TAMKIN 4HE SECONDDIFFERENCE IS THAT OPENINGALLDOORSTO$ISBELIEVERSWHENTHEYDELVEINTOSINISTHE ENABLEMENTINTOTHEMATERIALWORLDONLY4WODOORSNEVEROPENTO $ISBELIEVERSBECAUSE!LLAHFORBIDSTHEMTO$ISBELIEVERSTHEDOOROF BARAKABLESSINGHAPPINESS ANDTHEDOOROFTOMANINAHQUIETUDE PEACEOFMINDCONlDENCE 4HESETWODOORSAREEXCLUSIVELYOPEN TO-USLIMS
$ISBELIEVERSAREDENIEDETERNITYANDHAPPINESSINITSMAJORCOMPO NENTSEVENINTHISWORLD4HEYHAVEMATERIALEASEANDAFmUENCEBUT THEYLACKQUIETUDEANDBLESSING)TISACOMFORTTOSEETHATINSPITEOF THEIRECONOMICANDMILITARYMIGHTARROGANT7ESTERNERSAREDENIED HAPPINESSWHEREAS-USLIMSEVENINASITUATIONOFDESPONDENCYAND MATERIALINFERIORITYAREENABLEDBY!LLAHTOACCEPTTHEBENElTSOF(IS BLESSING4HESEFELICITOUSINGREDIENTSOFAFULlLLEDLIFEAREDENIEDTO THOSEWHODONOTEMBRACE!LLAHSRELIGION
4HEWORD"ARAKADOESNOTSIGNIFYONLYMATERIALWELFAREITISMORE INCLUSIVEANDVASTERINMEANING7EMIGHTEVENSAYTHATITISNOT MAINLYMATERIALALTHOUGHITIMPLIESIT)TISSOMETHINGINTHELIFE OFPEOPLETHATMAKESTHEMFELICITOUSPURETRANSPARENTSPIRITUAL ANDCLEANSOASTOLIGHTUPTHEMIND2EGARDINGTHE4OMANINAH PEOPLEWHOAREANXIOUSWORRIEDINSECUREANGUISHEDANDTHOSEWHO UNDERGONERVOUSBREAKDOWNFROMANXIETYDREADANDBADPREMONI TIONLOOKFORIT4HEYLOOKFOR4OMANINAH!ND!LLAHSHOWSTHEM THEDOORTHATLEADSTOIT/NLYTHROUGHTHEREMEMBRANCEOF!LLAH THEHEARTISlLLEDWITHQUIETUDE3URA2ADVERSE
-ODERNGODLESSNESS*AHILIYA CANACHIEVEWHATEVERSUCCESSIN TECHNOLOGICALANDMILITARYlELDSITWANTSITISDEVOIDOFTHESUBJECTIVE COMPONENTOFHAPPINESS THAT!LLAHPROVIDESONLY FOR(ISDEVOTED FOLLOWERS!FEELINGOFEMPTINESSCHASESPEOPLEINTHE7ESTERNCIVI LIZATIONOFDISBELIEF
7EDONTNEED TO SAY THATCONTEMPORARY*AHILIYA IN SPITEOFALL THEMEANSOFENABLEMENTTHATISATITSDISPOSALFROMTHEMILITARY POLITICALMATERIALECONOMICANDSCIENTIlCPOWERLACKSHAPPINESS LACKSTHEFELICITYTHATMANLOOKSFORINHISLIFE"OOZENARCOTICS ANDCRIMESAREONLYSIGNSOFTHELACKOFHAPPINESSANDQUIETUDEBY DINTOFANXIETYSUICIDEMADNESSANDMENTALANDNERVOUSILLNESSES "OOZELIKENARCOTICSAREATTEMPTSATESCAPINGFROMREALITY!NDWHY SHOULDPEOPLETRYTOESCAPEFROMREALITYIFTHEYWEREHAPPY !NDWHYCRIMESEXTENDANDTHEIRPROPORTIONSINCREASE "UTTHEMADGLEEINWHICHCONTEMPORARY*AHILIYAINDULGESIN MOMENTSOFEVASIONINNIGHTCLUBSCASINOSANDNIGHTSPOTSISNOT ASIGNOFBLISSBUTMUCHMOREASIGNOFITSLACKANDANATTEMPTAT ARTIlCIALCOMPENSATIONFORTHEPSYCHOLOGICALVACUUMINDUCEDBY THISLACK !NDTHISISTHESTERNPICTUREOFCONTEMPORARY*AHILIYATHATFAILS TODISGUISEHUGEFACTORIESIMMENSEMATERIALPRODUCTIONANDSKY ROCKETSREACHINGTHEMOONORTHEPLANET-ARS
4HEPROCESSOFDESTRUCTIONHASSETINILLNESSESLIKE!)$3AND CANCERANDSCOURGESLIKETHETHINNINGOFTHEOZONELAYERARETHERETO PROVEIT4HESCENARIOISTHATOF.OAHh4HEILLOMENOF!LLAHDOESNOT CEASETOREACH$ISBELIEVERSUNTILTHEIRULTIMATEDESTRUCTIONPROMISED BY!LLAHTOTHEMANDTOARROGANTPEOPLEMOSTAKBARIN !)$3;ILL NESS=ISENOUGHTOAWAKENTHEHEARTOFIGNORANTPEOPLEANDOPENUP THEIREYES)TISVIBRATINGWITHALLTHATBEARSTHEWORDINMEANINGS )TSPREADSANDTHEYAREANGUISHEDABOUTITANDAREPOWERLESSTOSTOP ITSEXPANSION!NDITISENOUGHTOMENTIONTHEHIDEOUSSPREADOF DIFFERENTCANCERS!NDITISENOUGHTOMENTIONWHATTHREATENSTHE OZONELAYERANDWHATTHREATENSTHROUGHIT;CLIMATE=CHANGEANDTHE TEMPESTLIKE.OAHSv4HEQUICKENINGPACEOFDESTRUCTIONISPERCEIVED EVENBYSOMEOF*AHILIYAINTELLECTUALSh"EFOREADECADEORTWOPEOPLE WILLBECONVINCEDTHATITISPOSSIBLEFORTHIS*AHILIYATOCOLLAPSE !NDAGROUPOF *AHILIYA THINKERSAREBEGINNING TO SEE THE SIGNSOF DESTRUCTION!LTHOUGHDESTRUCTIONMIGHTBESLOWBECAUSE*AHILIYAPUT INLOTSOFEFFORTSTOSAVEITITISNEVERTHELESSSUREv
-OHAMMAD1UTBINSISTSON!LLAHSINTERVENTIONINTHEDESTRUC TIONOFHERETICS-USLIMSEFFORTSBEINGOFLESSERIMPORTTHAN!LLAHS ACTION(ISBROTHER3EYED1UTBANDMANYOTHER*IHADISTINTELLECTU ALSINSISTMOREONHUMANINTERVENTIONAND*IHADTOACHIEVETHEVERY SAMEGOALS4HETWOSIDESFULlLLCOMPLEMENTARYROLESWHEREASACTIVIST *IHADISTSINSISTON-USLIMSMOBILIZATIONhNATURALISTv*IHADISTSSTRESS THECOMING!POCALYPSETHATWILLCAUSETHEDESTRUCTIONOFTHEARROGANT 7EST THROUGH!LLAHSWILL4HISBRINGS SOLACE TO THOSEWHODEEPLY RESENTTHEIRMARGINALROLEINTHEWORLDINASHARPDIFFERENCEWITHTHE PASTWHEN-USLIMSWEREFEAREDANDRESPECTEDFORTHEIRMILITARYAND MATERIALACHIEVEMENTS
&OROTHER*IHADISTS-USLIMSSITUATIONISRELATEDTOTHEIROWNLACK OFFAITH&AHDAL"ASHARSEESAVOIDANCEOF*IHADASTHECAUSEOF-USLIMS DECAYh*IHADISTHECAUSEOF-USLIMSGREATNESS4HEFALLOF!NDALUSIA ;IN=CANHELPUSUNDERSTANDTHEMECHANISMSOF;-USLIMS=DEFEAT )MAMAL1ORDHABI;FROM#ORDOBA=WHOLIVEDATTHATTIMEIDENTIlED THECAUSESOFDECAY THEYSHUNNEDTHECOMBAT REFUSEDTO LET THEIR BLOODBEINGSPILLEDREFUSEDTOPUTTHEIRBELONGINGSATSTAKE;FOR*IHAD= PREFERREDPEACEANDENJOYMENTINTHISWORLDWEREDEVOTEDTOHOME ANDCOUNTRY;INSTEADOF)SLAM=!LLTHISISACURSEANDPUSHESTOWARD MEANNESSLACKOFRESPECTBYTHEOTHERSFOR-USLIMSTHEIRHONORAND SEXUALDIGNITYIRDH ANDTHEDOMINATIONBYTHE+UFFAR$ISBELIEV ERS UPONTHEMv.OWADAYSLACKOFDIGNITYANDLOSSOFHONORARE PARAMOUNT AMONG-USLIMS-ANY FEEL HUMILIATEDBY!MERICANS )SRAELIS2USSIANSANDOTHERSANDAREOPPRESSEDBYTHEM4HEPLIGHT
OFTHE0ALESTINIANS)RAQISUFFERING#HECHENHUMILIATIONˆALLADDSUP TOASADPICTURE*IHADISTSEXPLOITTHISDEEPMALAISE
4HEREISAMERCILESSWARBETWEENDISBELIEVERSAND-USLIMSAND ANYPEACEBETWEENTHEMILLUSORYTHEFORMERLOOKINGFORTHEANNIHI LATIONOF-USLIMSBYEVERYMEANSh%VERYREASONABLEPERSONKNOWS THATTHE+UFFAR;'ODLESS(ERETICS=DONOTLEAVE-USLIMSINPEACEIF -USLIMSLEAVETHEMINPEACEANDTHISRELIGIOUSTRUTHANDGODLYTRA DITIONISMENTIONEDINTHE+ORAN4HEYWILLlGHT-USLIMSTHROUGH CULTURALWARINTELLECTUALWARTHROUGHWOMENANDPROPAGANDA4HEY WILL lGHT-USLIMS TODESTROY THEIR RELIGION AND TOHIT THEIR FAITH -USLIMSSHOULDBEWAREOFTHE+UFFARv
3HIITE(YPER &UNDAMENTALISTS AND4HEIR2EJECTIONOF$EMOCRACY
)N3HIISMTHESAMETENDENCIESAREVISIBLEAMONG&UNDAMENTALISTAND HYPER &UNDAMENTALIST5LAMA AND INTELLECTUALS4HEMAIN3HIITE REVOLUTIONARYINTELLECTUALSAND5LAMAWERE!LI3HARIATIn -ORTEZA-OTAHHARIn !YATOLLAH+HOMEINIn THElRSTPRESIDENTOFTHE)SLAMIC2EPUBLIC!BOLHASSAN"ANI3ADRB AND!YATOLLAH4ALEQANIn 4HESEWEREMOSTLYREVO LUTIONARYANDREACTIONARY-OTAHHARI+HOMEINI ORMESSIANICAND REVOLUTIONARY3HARIATI 3ECOND GENERATIONTHINKERSAPPEAREDINTHE SANDTHEYAREMOSTLY2EFORMISTSQUESTIONINGTHEFOUNDATIONS OF3HIITETHEOCRACY6ELAYAT&AQIHTHROUGHANOTHERINTERPRETATIONOF )SLAMTHATENDEAVORSTORECONCILE!LLAHSRELIGIONANDPOLITICALPLURAL ISM4HEYINCLUDE!BDOLKARIM3OROUSHB -OJTAHED3HABE STARIB -OHSEN+ADIVARB AND9OUSSEl%SHKAVARI B -OSTAFA-ALEKIANB AMONGOTHERS
"UT&UNDAMENTALIST THOUGHTWAS RENEWEDASWELLBYANEW GENERATIONOFCLERGYMENANDINTELLECTUALSWHOARENOTPOPULARAND AREWORKINGAShORGANICINTELLECTUALSvWITHINTHENEW3HIITETHEOC RACY )N THE YOUNGER GENERATIONS OF THESE FUNDAMENTALIST5LAMA !HMAD"EHESHTIISASIGNIlCANTlGURE&ORHIMHUMANBEINGSMUST BEUNDERTHESALUTARYBURDENOFRELIGIONSOASTOACCEPTTHEIRDUTIES TAKLIF 4HELANGUAGEOFRIGHTSHAQMAINLYUSEDBY)SLAMIC2EFORM ISTS ˆINSTEADOFDUTIESˆISNOTADEQUATETOPUTACHECKONHUMANS EGOISTIC TENDENCIES2ELIGIOUS DUTIES HAVE TO BE INTERNALIZED THE ETERNALDAMNATIONOF(ELLMUSTBEPRESENTINTHEIRMINDSTOEDUCATE GENUINE-USLIMS3ECULARISMISAGAINSTTHERELIGIONOF!LLAHANDHAS TOBEREJECTEDOUTRIGHT
!NOTHER3HIITECLERIC(AMID0ARSAISANARDENTOPPONENTOF SECULARISMWHOBELIEVESTHATTHEMODERN)SLAMICREFORMMOVEMENT ISAHIDDENWAYOFINTRODUCINGSECULARISMINTHEGUISEOF)SLAM(E VIEWSITASBEINGTOTALLYINCOMPATIBLEWITH)SLAM&ORHIMSECULARISM ISTIGHTLYBOUNDTOTHEEMERGENCEOF7ESTERNCIVILIZATIONANDCANNOT BEAPPLIEDTOTHOSESOCIETIESTHATLIVEACCORDINGTOTHESPIRITUALVALUES OF)SLAM)SLAMICSOCIETIESMUSTREJECTTHEDIVIDEBETWEENRELIGIONAND POLITICS4HEONLYLEGITIMATEWAYISTHEDOMINATIONOFTHEPOLITICAL SPHEREBY)SLAMOWINGTOTHELATTERSSACREDMISSION4HOSEWHOEN TERTAINAPRIVILEGEDRELATIONWITH)SLAM3HIITECLERGY HAVETHERIGHT TOBENElT FROMTHIS hPOWEROF THE SACREDv QOWWEYEQODSIYEH AND EXERCISE THERIGHT TORULEHAQEHAKEMIYAT OVERSOCIETY3ECULARISM DENIES)SLAMITS RIGHT TORULE5NDERSECULARISM THESE INTELLECTUALS UNDERSTANDNOTONLYTHATTHELEGALANDLEGISLATIVESPHEREHASAUTONOMY FROMTHERELIGIOUSONEBUTALSOTHATFORCESWITHINTHE)SLAMICWORLD SEEKTOOPENUPSPHERESOFFREEDOMINACCORDANCEWITH)SLAMMUCHIN THESAMEWAYAS0ROTESTANTISMDIDINTERMSOFFREEDOMOFCONSCIENCE AGAINST#ATHOLICISM!MAJORFEATUREOFSECULARISMISDEMOCRACYA SYSTEMINWHICHTHEUNSTABLELAWSMADEBYHUMANSREIGNSUPREME WITHNOSACREDPRINCIPLEPREVAILINGOVERTHEM"ETWEEN)SLAMBASED ONSTABLEDIVINELAWSANDDEMOCRACYBASEDONUNSTABLEHUMANLAWS THEREISANINSURMOUNTABLEDISCREPANCY
!LI!KBAR2ESHADISANOTHER3HIITECLERICWHOATTACKSSECULAR ISMASA7ESTERNPHENOMENONBORROWEDBY)SLAMIC2EFORMISTSAND IRRECONCILABLEWITH)SLAM/THERNEOCONSERVATIVE3HIITECLERICSSUCH AS!SQAR%HTEKARIAND!LI!KBAR+AMALIDENOUNCE7ESTERNSECULARISM BYPOINTINGOUTTHEFRAUDULENTCHARACTEROFTHESCRIPTURALBASESOF*UDA ISMAND#HRISTIANITY3INCEBOTHRELIGIONSHAVEDEVIATEDFROMTHEIR GENUINEORIGINSˆTHEYWEREFATEDTOFORSAKETHEIRFAITHTO)SLAMˆTHEY HAVEEXPERIENCEDTHROUGHOUTHISTORYTHEDEVELOPMENTOFANINTERNAL SELF DENIALTHROUGHSECULARISM4HEIRSPURIOUSNESSISTHEMAINGROUND FORTHEIRMUTUALCOOPERATIONAGAINST)SLAMTHEIRCULTURALAGGRESSION AGAINST!LLAHS RELIGION BEING BASED ON THREE PRINCIPLES IMPOSING THEIRVALUESON-USLIMSDESTROYINGTHEFUNDAMENTALSOF)SLAMAND COERCING!LLAHSRELIGIONINTORENOUNCINGITSLEGITIMATEDOMINATION OVERSOCIETYINTHENAMEOFSECULARVALUES
4HElGHTAGAINST)SLAMICVALUESISANAMBIGUOUSPHENOMENON /NTHEONEHANDITISDIRECTEDAGAINST)SLAMONTHEOTHERHANDTHIS STRUGGLEDESTROYSTHE7ESTFROMWITHINTHROUGHNIHILISM4HELATTER ISANAVATAROFSECULARISMTHATPOSTULATESTHERESEMBLANCEOF'ODTO (UMANWHICH IS IN TURN THE PHILOSOPHICAL LINCHPIN OF7ESTERN HUMANISM4HEREFOREITISANIMPOSTURETOTALKABOUTh)SLAMICHU MANISMvASTHE)SLAMIC2EFORMISTSDODIRECTLYORINDIRECTLY)SLAMIC
HUMANISMISACREEPINGATTEMPTATSECULARIZING)SLAMANDDEEPDOWN INITSPRINCIPLESITISBASEDONTHEANTI )SLAMICTENDENCIESPREVAILING INTHE7ESTERNWORLD!TTHEROOTOFDEVIANTIDEASLIKEhFREEDOMOF EXPRESSIONvLIESTHEATTEMPTATCOMBATING)SLAMBYDENYINGLEGITIMACY TOITSDIVINEVALUESANDREJECTINGITSROLEINPOLITICS
(ASAN2AHIMPOOR!ZQODI IS ANOTHER HYPER &UNDAMENTALIST 3HIITEINTELLECTUALWHODEFENDS)SLAMICTHEOCRACYAND6ELAYAT&AQIH THEGOVERNMENTOFTHE)SLAMIC*URIST AGAINSTTHOSEWHOWOULDLIKE TOPROMOTE)SLAMICDEMOCRACY&ORHIM)SLAMICTHEOCRACYISTHEONLY LEGITIMATEWAYOFAPPLYING)SLAMTOPOLITICS4HROUGHIT)SLAMEM BRACESEVENTHOSEDOMAINSOFSOCIALLIFETHATWEREMOBAHRELIGIOUSLY INDIFFERENT INTRADITIONAL-USLIMSOCIETIES)SLAMICTHEOCRACYEN COMPASSESALLTHEASPECTSOFPERSONALANDSOCIALEXISTENCEANDTHEREFORE TOTALLY)SLAMIZESSOCIETYAWAYFROMSECULARIZINGUNDERCURRENTSWITHIN THE-USLIMWORLD(E ATTEMPTS TO DE SECULARIZE-USLIM SOCIETIES THROUGH)SLAMICTHEOCRACY%VENAPPARENTLYNEUTRALACTSLIKETALKING WALKINGORWRITINGCANBEPERMISSIBLEORNOTACCORDINGTOTHERUL INGSOF)SLAMDEPENDINGONTHEINTENTIONSOFTHEBELIEVERANDTHEIR CONSEQUENCESFORTHE-USLIMCOMMUNITY!CTSBECOMEILLICITIFTHEY RESULTDIRECTLYORINDIRECTLYINTHEWEAKENINGOF)SLAMICLAW)NTHIS RESPECTEVERYVOLUNTARYACTHASAN)SLAMICPRESCRIPTION6ELAYAT&AQIH ISTHECORNERSTONEFORTHENEW)SLAMICSOCIETYWHEREEACHACTHASTOBE MEASUREDUPTHROUGHTHE)SLAMICYARDSTICK3INCE!LLAHSRELIGIONISOF DIVINEINSPIRATIONITCANNOTBEEXPOSEDTOTHEPOPULARVOTEWHICHIS THEBASISOFDEMOCRACY4HELATTERISANTI )SLAMICINITSESSENCEBECAUSE ITSUPPOSESTHESECULARIZATIONOFRELIGIONANDTHESELF DETERMINATION OFHUMANBEINGSINSOCIETY
3ADEQ,ARIJANIANOTHERCLERGYMANANDAMEMBEROFANINmU ENTIALFAMILYIN)RANREJECTSDEMOCRACYFORTHESAMEREASONSAS2A HIMPOOR!ZQODI&ORHIMDEMOCRATICREGIMESARECHARACTERIZEDBY THEPROMINENCEGIVENTOTHEARBITRARYLAWSMADEBYPEOPLE)SLAMIC SOCIETYINSHARPCONTRASTTODEMOCRATICONESGIVESABSOLUTEPRECEDENCE TOTHECOMMANDMENTSOF!LLAH4HATISWHY)SLAMCANNOTACCEPTTHE NOTIONOFCIVILSOCIETYDEFENDEDBY)SLAMIC2EFORMISTSBECAUSETHEIR PHILOSOPHICALFOUNDATIONSAREIRRECONCILABLEh)NTHE)SLAMICGOV ERNMENTACCORDINGTO6ELAYAT&AQIHTHESOURCEOFLEGITIMACYISTHE AUTHENTICITYOFTHEDUTYANDNOTTHEAUTHENTICITYOFTHEINDIVIDUAL 4HEREFOREWHILEALLTHEPILLARSOFTHE3TATEWHATEVERTHEIRSIGNIlCANCE AREIMPORTANTFORTHEEFlCIENCYOFTHESYSTEMTHEYOWETHEIRLEGITIMACY TOTHEIRDIVINEORIGINS!SFORTHOSEWHOSAYTHATINTHE)SLAMIC GOVERNMENT!LLAHHASGIVENTOTHEPEOPLETHERIGHTTOCHOOSETHEIR RULERTHATTHEYCANDOSOANDSOWITHTHEIRVOTESANDTHATTHEYMAY GIVETHEREINSOFPOWERTOANYONETHESEPEOPLEAREREFERRINGTOTHE
LIBERALDOCTRINEWHICHISNOTINACCORDWITHTHECONCEPTOF6ELAYAT &AQIHv0ILLARSOFDEMOCRACYˆNAMELYINDIVIDUALSOVEREIGNTYVOT INGBASEDONMAJORITYANDCHANGINGLEADERSHIPACCORDINGTOPOPULAR VOTEˆAREREJECTEDINTHENAMEOF)SLAMICTHEOCRACY
4HEMAJORHYPER &UNDAMENTALISTIDEOLOGUEOF3HIITERADICALISM CLOSETO*IHADISMIS!YATOLLAH-ESBAH9AZDIWHOAMONGOTHERSHAS BUILTUPANEWGROUPOFhCANDIDATESFORMARTYRDOMvISTISHHADIYUN !CCORDINGTOHIM3HIITESDIDNOTDEVELOPAPOLITICALTHEORYINTHE PASTBECAUSETHEYWEREAMINORITYOPPRESSEDBY3UNNIRULERS)NA SITUATIONOFPOLITICALOPPRESSIONTHEIRMAINCONCERNWASTOCONCEAL THEIRRELIGIOUSTENETSPERCEIVEDASDEVIANTBY3UNNICALIPHS4HUSTHEY LACKEDAPOLITICALTHEORYUNTIL!YATOLLAH+HOMEINIBROKETHEDEADLOCK ANDCONCEIVEDNOTONLYTHEPOSSIBILITYBUTALSOTHENECESSITYFROM THERELIGIOUSPOINTOFVIEW OFAN)SLAMICSTATE0OLITICALAUTHORITYIN THIS)SLAMICSTATEISVESTEDINTHE)SLAMICRULER6ALIFAQIHWHOMUST BEOBEYEDBYALLINCLUDINGTHECLERGYEVENIFTHEYAREINDISAGREE MENTWITHHIM6ALI FAQIH THUS TAKESPRECEDENCEOVER THE5LAMA EVENTHOSEWHOSERELIGIOUSKNOWLEDGE IS SUPERIORTOHIS-ESBAH 9AZDIBELIEVESTHAT)SLAMISUNDERANhALL OUTATTACKBY)NlDELSAND !RROGANTFORCES)MPERIALISTS vTHEBELIEVERSDUTYISTOBEACTIVEhIN lGHTINGTHEENEMIESOFRELIGION TAKING*IHADTO5NBELIEVERS FOES ANDASSAILANTSOF-USLIMSRIGHTSvSOAShTOESTABLISHTHE*UST)SLAMIC 3YSTEMALLOVERTHEWORLDv
!YATOLLAH+HAZALIHASADVANCEDSIMILARIDEAS&ORHIM6ELAYAT &AQIHISNOTAHUMAN MADEINSTITUTIONBUTONETHATISTHEGISTOFTHE RULEOFTHE0ROPHETANDTHEIMAMSREPRESENTINGTHERULEOF!LLAHON EARTH4HATISWHY6ELAYAT&AQIHISNOTSUBORDINATEDTOTHEVOTEOF THEPEOPLEHISGOVERNMENTBEING THE REPRESENTATIVEOF!LLAH4HE PEOPLESVOTEISNECESSARYTOIMPLEMENTHISCOMMANDMENTSNOTTO CONTESTHISCHOICES
!YATOLLAH-ESBAH9AZDIEMPHASIZESTHEAUTOCRATICNATUREOFTHE )SLAMICRULERHEUNDERSCORESTHEFACTTHATTHELEADERWHOHAPPENS TOBETHEREPRESENTATIVEJURIST6ALIFAQIH ISNOTELECTEDBYPEOPLE BUT CHOSENBY SCHOLARS OF )SLAMIC JURISPRUDENCE4HROUGH )SLAMIC THEOCRACY RELIGIONBECOMES THE SOLE SOURCEOF LEGAL CULTURAL ECO NOMICANDPOLITICALLEGITIMACYINSOCIETYEXTENDING)SLAMICRULETO ALLASPECTSOFHUMANLIFEˆUNLIKETRADITIONAL)SLAMINWHICHMANY DOMAINSBELONGEDTOTHEREALMOF#USTOMSURF ANDTOLERATEDAS SUCHWHENTHEYDIDNOTDIRECTLYCONTRADICTRELIGIOUSLAW!CCORDING TOHIMTHEGOVERNMENTOFTHE6ELAYAT&AQIHISFROMATHEOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVETHEABSOLUTERULEOFTHE)SLAMICJURISTVELAYATEMOTLAQEYE FAQIH ENTAILINGSOCIETYSSUBSERVIENCETOTHERULEOF!LLAHEMBODIED BYTHE6ALIFAQIH
)N THE SAME VEIN ANOTHER CLERIC-OHAMMAD(ADI-AREFAT OPPOSESRELIGIOUSSOCIETYTOCIVILSOCIETY)SLAMIC2EFORMISTSBRING UPTHENOTIONOFCIVILSOCIETYSOMETIMESBYADDINGTOITTHEQUALIFY INGATTRIBUTEhRELIGIOUSvTOPOINTOUTTHATTHEREISNOINCOMPATIBILITY BETWEEN)SLAMANDCIVILSOCIETYTHATISRELIGIOUSBECAUSEPEOPLEBELIEVE IN)SLAMANDNOTOUTOFTHECOERCIVENATUREOFTHE)SLAMICCREED&OR -AREFATTHETWOAREINCOMPATIBLEBECAUSECIVILSOCIETYISBASEDON HUMAN MADELAWSWHEREASRELIGIOUSSOCIETYISFOUNDEDONSACREDLAWS GROUNDEDINDIVINE2EVELATION2ELIGIONLEADSTOHAPPINESSBYFOLLOW INGITSRULESANDNOTBYSUBMITTINGTOTHEMAJORITYSCOMMANDMENTS #IVILSOCIETYSSPIRITOFSECULARTOLERANCEISALSOINCOMPATIBLEWITH)SLAM BECAUSEITSUPPOSESINDIFFERENCETORELIGIONOREVENITSSUPPRESSION INTHEPUBLICSPHERE)SLAMFROMHISPOINTOFVIEWMEANSSOCIETYS SUBMISSIONTOTHERULEOF!LLAHACHIEVEDTHROUGHTHEABSOLUTERULE OFTHE)SLAMICJURISTVELATYATEMOTLAQEYEFAQIH
)TISOBVIOUSFROMTHISVIEWPOINTTHATTHERESHOULDNTBERESPECT FORSECULARLAW)NTHECASEOFSECULARLAWTHEBASISFORTHEOBEDIENCE OFTHEINDIVIDUALISTHEPEOPLEWHEREASIN)SLAMICSOCIETYITIS!LLAHS LAWSAPPROVEDBYTHEABSOLUTE)SLAMICRULER7ESTERNCOUNTRIESGIVE ABSOLUTEPRIORITYTOSECULARLAWBECAUSETHE#HURCHHASBEENONTHE SIDEOFTHERICHANDTHEPOWERFUL)NAN)SLAMICSOCIETYTHERELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONBASEDON THE THEOCRATIC RULE OF THE )SLAMIC JURIST IS ON THESIDEOFTHEOPPRESSEDANDDOWNTRODDENMOSTADHAlN ANDlGHTS AGAINSTTHEOPPRESSORSMOSTAKBERIN ANDEVILDOERSSETAMGARAN 4HIS MAKESITUNNECESSARYANDEVENIMPOSSIBLEFORPEOPLETOLOOKFORAN ALTERNATIVE TO )SLAMIC SOCIETY IN A SECULAR ONE &OR PROPONENTS OF ABSOLUTE)SLAMICTHEOCRACYTHOSEWHODISAGREEWITHTHEIRVERSIONARE NOTGENUINE-USLIMS/PPOSITIONTO)SLAMIC2EFORMISTSCOMESCLOSE TODECLARINGTHEMHERETICSAS3UNNI*IHADISTSDO4HECLERIC-OLLA (ASANIWHOISTHEREPRESENTATIVEOFTHE6ALI&AQIHIN5RUMIYAHA TOWNINNORTHWESTERN)RANHASSAID
4HOSEWHOGO TO THEUNIVERSITIES TODECEIVE STUDENTS AREWORSE THANTHE5NITED3TATES)SRAELANDTHE(YPOCRITES;FAKE-USLIMS IN PARTICULAR THE DISSIDENT-UJAHIDEEN+HALQ POLITICAL GROUP= 9OUUNIVERSITYMEMBERSIFYOUWANT;)SLAMIC=UNITYWHYDOYOU BRINGTHISPERSONTOTHEUNIVERSITYWHOSAYSTHATFREEDOMISMORE IMPORTANT THAN )SLAM AND THE+ORAN$EATH TO THIS FREEDOM !YATOLLAH+HAZALISAIDh)LLSHOOTTHISPERSONINTHEHEADANDGET RIDOFHIMWITHTHECOUPDEGRACEv)MAM+HOMEINIANSWEREDTHE QUESTIONOFSOMEREVOLUTIONARYTRIBUNALHEADSWHODIDNOTWANTTO SENTENCEPEOPLETODEATH;(ESAID=h%VENIFTHEYAREAMILLIONOF THEM)LLORDERTHESLAUGHTEROFTHEMOVERNIGHTBYSHOOTINGTHEM
COLLECTIVELYv9OUREFORMISTS3INCEYOUKNOWTHECOMMANDMENTS OF!LIAND)MAM+HOMEINIWHATAREYOUDOING7HYAREYOU DECEIVINGYOURSELFANDPEOPLE
)N THE SAMEWAY THAT3UNNI *IHADISTSATTRIBUTE THE ILLSOF THE UNIVERSETO3HIISMSOMEOFTHE3HIITERADICALSSEEINTHE3UNNISTHE CULPRITS INTHEILLSASSAULTING)SLAM&OR!LI$AVANITHEALLIANCEOF 7ESTERN CULTURAL AGGRESSION TAHAJOME FARHANGI THE CONSPIRACYOF 7ESTERNPOWERSAND7AHHABISM)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISM3AUDI STYLE INTENDTOUNDERMINETHE)SLAMIC2EPUBLICIN)RAN
(USSEIN!BADIANAND-USA&AQIH(AQQANI TWO)RANIANHY PER &UNDAMENTALISTSTRACETHECULTURALAGGRESSIONOFTHE7ESTBACK TOFREEMASONRYWHICHTHEYSEEASHAVINGEXPOSED)RANIAN-USLIM INTELLECTUALS TODANGEROUS IDEASSUCHASNATIONALISMANDTOLERANCE 4HEYUNDERMINE)SLAMANDSOCIETY3UCHIDEASTENDTOMAKESECULAR INTELLECTUALS SUBSERVIENT TO FOREIGN INTERESTS THUSGUILTYOF TREASON TOWARD)SLAMAND)RAN
#RITIQUEOFDEMOCRACYANDITSIDEASGOESHANDINHANDWITHTHE DENUNCIATIONOFWHATFUNDAMENTALIST3HIITEIDEOLOGUESCALLhLIBERAL ISMv"YTHISNOTIONTHEYMEANAMIXTUREOFITS%UROPEANAND!MERI CANMEANINGSNAMELYUNBRIDLEDCAPITALISMANDOPENSOCIETYWITH FREEECONOMICS &OR&ATEMEH2AJABIAWOMANWHOREJECTS7ESTERN FREEDOMFORWOMENINTHENAMEOF)SLAMLIBERALISMISDEPRAVITYAND MORALCORRUPTIONFASAD ,IBERALISMINTHE7ESTWASAPERIODOFIM MORALITYTHATRESULTEDINRELINQUISHINGSPIRITUALANDSACREDVALUESWITH ARTBECOMINGTHEFOCUSOFDEVIANTSEXUALTENDENCIESPARTICULARLYIN SCULPTUREPAINTINGANDLITERATURE,IBERALFREEDOMISBASEDONSEXUAL INSTINCTS SUPERSTITIONS REPREHENSIBLE BEHAVIOR ANDMISCONCEIVED FREEDOMOFTHOUGHTALLCUTOFFFROMRELIGION3HEDISCREDITSLIBERALISM BYDENOUNCINGITSLINKSWITHCAPITALISMANDHEDONISM,OOKINGFOR PROlTTHELIBERALATTITUDEISMARKEDBYVIOLENCEEGOTISMAMBITION THEURGEFORWEALTHANDTHEPROPENSITYFORRELIGIOUSDISBELIEF)NORDER TOEARNMOREMONEYLIBERALSDONOTHESITATETOTRAMPLEUNDERFOOT ALLRELIGIOUSPRINCIPLESTHATPREVENTILLICITEARNINGS2AJABICALLSTHIS ATTITUDEEBAHIYATORDECLARINGLICITANDFREEFROMRELIGIONTHEIMMORAL ATTITUDESOFCAPITALISTS&UNDAMENTALIST5LAMAANDINTELLECTUALSUSETHIS TERMNOTONLYTODENOUNCELIBERALISMAND7ESTERN STYLECAPITALISM BUTALSOALLTHOSE)SLAMIC2EFORMISTSWHOSINCETHEEARLYSHAVE DEFENDEDTHEVIEWTHATSOCIALANDPOLITICALRELATIONSARENEUTRALFROM ARELIGIOUSPERSPECTIVEANDTHEREFOREOPENTOTHEVOTEOFPEOPLETHE RESULTSBEINGBINDINGONEVERYONE
4HISLIBERALVIEWˆTHATRELIGIONISCONlNEDTOPERSONALASPECTSOF LIFENOTAPPLICABLETOTHEMANAGEMENTOFSOCIETYANDITSPOLITICSˆPRO MOTESACCORDINGTO2AJABISOCIALDEVIANCEINTHESAMEWAYASDID
%DMUND"URKEWHODEFENDEDHOMOSEXUALSTHEREBYJUSTIFYINGTHOSE VILEACTSTHATARECONDEMNEDBYASANERELIGIOUSPERSON4HEWILDLIB ERTYOFLIBERALISMFREESTHEINDIVIDUALFROMRELIGIOUSCONSTRAINTSAND ISDETRIMENTALTOTHECOLLECTIVEWELL BEING)TGIVESBIRTHTOTOLERANCE MODARA ORTHEEQUIVALENTSOFITLIKETASAMOHORTASAHOLTERMSUSED BY)SLAMIC2EFORMISTSTODENOTERELIGIOUSTOLERANCE !CCORDINGTOSUCH NOTIONSSTATEANDSOCIETYSHOULDNOTINTERVENEORHAVEANYMORALOR DOCTRINALSENSITIVITYTOWARDTHEIDEASANDBELIEFSOFPEOPLEEVENIFTHEY AREWRONGORIMMORAL"YDEFENDINGTOLERANCELIBERALFREEDOMPRO MOTESAGODLESSHUMANDEVOIDOFMORALSENTIMENTSANDUNHINDERED INHISDESIRES2AJABIBELIEVESTHATTHEONLYWAYTOOPPOSELIBERALISM ISTHROUGH)SLAMICMOVEMENTSTHROUGHOUTTHEWORLD!BU-USAB AL3URITHEARCH ENEMYOF3HIITESHASIDENTICALVIEWSABOUT*IHADAS AWORLDWIDEMOVEMENT !CCORDINGTO2AJABI*IHADISTMOVEMENTS ARETHEMOSTAPPROPRIATEWAYOFPROMOTING)SLAMALLOVERTHEWORLD (ADITNOTBEENFORTHE3UNNICHARACTERISTICSOF!L1AEDATHATMAKES ITABHORRENTTO3HIITESSHEWOULDHAVEAPPROVEDITSANTI 7ESTERN ANTI DEMOCRATIC AND ANTI LIBERAL FEATURES INWHICH7ESTERN SEXUAL PERMISSIVENESSAND)SLAMIC2EFORMISMAREDENOUNCEDALTOGETHER
3HIITE&UNDAMENTALISMANDHYPER &UNDAMENTALISMSHAREMANY COMMONFEATURESWITHTHEIR3UNNICOUNTERPARTS3INCEA3HIITETHE OCRACYRULES)RAN3HIITE&UNDAMENTALISTSDONTHAVETOOPPOSETHE GOVERNMENT3INCE3HIITERADICALSAND3UNNI*IHADISTSREJECTANDHATE EACHOTHERTHEYCANNOTASARULEACTJOINTLY"UTTHEIRIDEOLOGIESARE VERYCLOSETOEACHOTHERANDTHEIRSOCIALACTIONCANBECOMEVIOLENT INSPECIlCCIRCUMSTANCESLIKETHEGROUPOF)STISHHADIYUNTHOSEWHO LOOKFORMARTYRDOM UNDERTHELEADERSHIPOF!YATOLLAH-ESBAH9AZDI WHOCANBEMOBILIZEDAGAINSTTHOSEWHOARESEENASENEMIESOFTHE 3HIITETHEOCRACYINTHEWORLDMAINLYTHE!MERICANGOVERNMENTBUT ALSOTHE*IHADIST3UNNIS4HETWOhENEMYBROTHERSv3UNNIAND3HIITE *IHADISTS SHAREATTHECORETHESAMEIDEOLOGYMERCILESSLYOPPOSING EACHOTHERINTHENAMEOFTHEIRMONOPOLYOVER)SLAM
4HE7EAKNESSOF3ECULAR4ENDENCIESIN)SLAM
(ISTORICALLYDIFFERENTGROUPSANDACTORSHAVECARRIEDOUTTHESECULAR IZATIONOF)SLAM
s #HRISTIANMINORITIES!RMENIANSINTHE/TTOMAN%MPIREAND)RAN INTHENINETEENTHCENTURY
s COLONIAL POWERS PARTICULARLY THE &RENCH IN!LGERIA ANDMORE EXTENSIVELY.ORTH!FRICAASWELLASTHE%NGLISHIN)NDIAANDTHEIR COLONIAL-USLIMCOUNTRIES
s THENEWSTATESANDGOVERNMENTS!TATÓRKIN4URKEY2EZA3HAHIN )RANPOSTINDEPENDENCEREGIMESLIKE"OURGUIBASIN4UNISIA
s THEOLOGICALMOVEMENTSWITHIN)SLAMINSPIREDBYTHENINTH CENTURY -UTAZILAANDBY.AHDAMOVEMENTSINTHE3UNNIAND3HIITEWORLD INTHELATENINETEENTHANDTHETWENTIETHCENTURIESAND2EFORMIST MOVEMENTSINTHECONTEMPORARY-USLIMWORLD
s CULTURAL TRENDS IMPORTED FROM THE7EST AND IN PARTICULAR THE hCULTURAL INDUSTRYv IN THE SECONDHALFOF THE TWENTIETHCENTURY ANDTHElRSTDECADEOFTHETWENTY lRSTCENTURYSECULARIZINGDAILY LIFETHROUGHMOVIES46SHOWSANDTHE)NTERNETANDSPREADING THESEDUCTIONOFINDIVIDUALISMANDCONSUMERISM
)N THENINETEENTH CENTURY AND THElRSTHALF OF THE TWENTIETH CEN TURYSECULARIZATIONRESULTEDINNEWSOCIALGROUPSSELF CONSCIOUSAND hSTRONGvBECAUSEOFTHEWEAKNESSOFTHETRADITIONALAND&UNDAMENTALIST TRENDSANDTENDENCIESIN)SLAM)NTHESECONDHALFOFTHETWENTIETH CENTURY&UNDAMENTALISTSHAVEBECOMEMOREMODERN RADICALAND AWAREOF THEIROWN STRENGTH4HEYARE JOINEDBYNEWPEOPLEWITH MODERNEDUCATIONALBACKGROUNDSMANYOFTHEMGRADUATESOFSCIEN TIlCANDENGINEERINGPROGRAMS FRUSTRATEDBYTHEEVOLUTIONOFTHE -USLIMWORLDANDSECULARNATIONALISM4HEYDENOUNCETHE7ESTAND SECULARTENDENCIESWITHIN)SLAMASCORRUPTANDDEPRAVEDANDABOVE ALL THEYBENElTFROMTHESUPPORTOFTWONEWGROUPSGENERATEDBY MODERNIZATION
/NE GROUP IS THE SO CALLED-USTADHAlN THE OPPRESSED THE DOWNTRODDEN RESULTING FROMTHEURBANIZATIONAND THEMIGRATION OFPEASANTSTOTHECITIESANDTHEINABILITYOFTHENEWGOVERNMENTSTO DEALWITHTHESOCIALISSUEOFTHESENEWMARGINALPEOPLEWHOAREECO NOMICALLYFRAGILEANDCULTURALLYUPROOTEDTHESO CALLEDHITTISTSTHOSE WHOSTAYBYTHEWALLBECAUSETHEYAREUNEMPLOYED THETRABENDISTS THOSEWHOENGAGEINILLEGALCOMMERCE IN!LGERIATHEMUSTADHAlN IN)RANANDSOFORTH3INCETHESEGROUPSBENElTMOREORLESSFROMTHE TRADITIONALFORMSOFASSISTANCETHROUGH)SLAMICCHARITYTHE)SLAMIC TAXZAKATAMONGOTHERSANDIN3HIISMKHOMS THEYAREQUICKTO DENOUNCE THENEWMODERNIZEDMIDDLE CLASSES AS7ESTERNIZED IN A DEROGATORYSENSEMOSTAQRABIN!RABICGHARB ZADEHIN0ERSIAN AND THENEWGOVERNMENTSASGODLESSTAQUTJAHILIYA INBOTHTHE3HIITE ANDTHE3UNNIWORLDS
! SECOND GROUP IS THENEW TECHNICAL SCIENTIlC PROFESSIONALS PRODUCEDBYTHEMODERNEDUCATIONALSYSTEM4HEYHAVEBEENMAR GINALIZEDBYTHEAUTOCRATICSYSTEMSIN-USLIMCOUNTRIESANDSOME OFTHEMBECOME&UNDAMENTALISTSASARESULTOFTHEIRMALAISEWITHIN THENEWWORLDWHERETHEWRONGDOINGSOFMODERNIZATIONARETANGIBLE
BUT ITS BENElTS ARE STILL IMPERCEPTIBLE TO THE LARGEMAJORITY4HEIR SCIENTIlCMIND SETDOESNOTEASILYACCEPTTHEAUTHORITARIANRULEOFTHE NEWCLIQUESINTHENAMEOFAMODERNITYTHATISALIENTOMOSTPEOPLE 4HEIRRISINGEXPECTATIONSDONOTCOPEWITHTHEDERISORYBENElTSOF MODERNIZATIONAMIDTHEDISLOCATIONOFOLDSOCIALBONDS
)NMANYCASESATHIRDGROUPTRADITIONALISTINITSCULTURALOUT LOOKANDCONSERVATIVEINITSSOCIALTENDENCIESJOINSTHEOTHERTWOIN REJECTINGMODERNITYWHICHISPERCEIVEDASDESTROYINGTHEBENElTSOF THETRADITIONTHROUGHTHERULEOFSELlSHNESSANDIRRELIGIONANDPROMOT INGUPSTARTSWHOHOLDTHEREINSOFPOWERFORTHESAKEOFPROlTEERING ANDASSISTINGTHEIROWNCLIENTELE7ITHIN3HIISMTHISGROUPCONSISTS OFCLERGYMENANDWITHIN3UNNISMOFRELIGIOUSTEACHERSANDLAWYERS COMINGOUTOFTHE)SLAMICSCHOOLS4HEYAREUNABLETOSEEMODERNITY ASTHECONSTRUCTIONOFANEWORDERINWHICHJUSTICEWOULDBEPRESERVED ANDVIOLENCEWOULDBECONTAINED
)NTHE-USLIMWORLDTHEFAILUREOFDEMOCRATIZATIONSECULAR IZATIONANDECONOMICDEVELOPMENTHAVEGIVENRISETOTHEREJECTION BYMANYMODERNIZEDGROUPSASWELLASTHETRADITIONALWHICHGOES WITHOUTSAYING OFMODERNITY)TISSEENASACHANGEFORTHEWORSE4HE ORIGINOFTHISCHANGETHE7ESTHASBECOMESYNONYMOUSWITHUTTER VIOLENCEINJUSTICEANDILLEGITIMATEDOMINATIONFORALARGESTRATAOF THEPOPULATIONWHOAREVULNERABLETOCHANGEANDUNABLETOSHIELD THEMSELVESTHROUGHTHEPOSITIVESIDESOFMODERNITYNEWJOBOPPOR TUNITIESPARTICIPATIONINPOLITICALLIFEANDEQUALITYOFALLBEFORETHE LAW !MONGTHESEGROUPSTHATTURNTO)SLAMIC&UNDAMENTALISMAS ASOLUTIONTOTHECRISISOFMODERNITYSOMElND*IHADISMASTHEBEST SOLUTION-ANYAREUPSETBYPOLITICALEVENTSTHECRISESIN"OSNIA !FGHANISTAN)RAQ0ALESTINE#HECHNYA ANDTHESESITUATIONSSERVEAS TRIGGERSFORTHEIRTRANSITIONFROM&UNDAMENTALISMTO*IHADISM
4HE SECULARIZATION TRENDWITHIN )SLAM IS THREE PRONGED&IRST ISTHEAMBIGUOUS&UNDAMENTALISTTRENDMARKEDBYTIMIDOPENINGS TOWARD THEPARLIAMENTARY SYSTEMWITHOUT EXPLICITLYGIVINGUP THE TRADITIONALRELIGIOUSTENETSRELATEDTOTHESETTINGUPOFAN)SLAMICPO LITICALSYSTEM3TILL&UNDAMENTALISTSLIKETHE-USLIM"ROTHERHOODIN %GYPTREFUSETOHAVERECOURSETOVIOLENCEFORTHESAKEOFESTABLISHING AN)SLAMICPOLITICALSYSTEMANDACCEPTTHEPARLIAMENTARYSYSTEMEVEN THOUGHTHEYMAINTAINANAMBIVALENTPOSTURETOWARDDEMOCRACYAS SUCH7HILE&UNDAMENTALISTSAREINAMINORITYPOSITIONTHEYCON TRIBUTETOTHEDIVERSITYOFTHEPOLITICALSYSTEMBUTIFTHEYACCEDETOA MAJORITYPOSITIONITISNOTOBVIOUSTHATTHEYWILLACCEPTDEMOCRATIC RULE4HEPOLITICALREGIMESINMOSTOFTHE-USLIMWORLDARETHEMSELVES NONDEMOCRATICANDTHEREFORETHEIRLEGITIMACYISALSOOPENTOQUESTION 4HEPOLITICALDEADLOCKINTHE-USLIMWORLDHELPSTHEANTI DEMOCRATIC
FORCESTOCLAIMLEGITIMACYINTHENAMEOF!LLAHOPPOSINGAhLEGITI MATEvNONDEMOCRATICRELIGIOUSVISIONTOANhILLEGITIMATEvDOMINANT NONDEMOCRATICPOLITICALSYSTEM3OMETIMESDIRECTLYBUTMOREOFTEN INDIRECTLYTHESEGROUPSSTRIVETO)SLAMIZEMODERNITYBYCHOOSINGTHOSE ASPECTSTHATARENOTIMMEDIATELYOPPOSEDTO)SLAMANDBYMOREOR LESSACCEPTINGORREJECTINGINANAMBIVALENTWAYOTHERASPECTSOFMO DERNITYFORINSTANCEWHENITCOMESTOTHEPOPULARVOTETHEYACCEPT THERESULTOFTHEBALLOTBOXWITHOUTRENOUNCINGTHEh)SLAMICvVIEWOF POLITICSINWHICHTHEPIOUSANDTHERELIGIOUSLYLEARNEDARESUPERIORTO THEOTHERS 4HISISTRUEFORTHE-USLIM"ROTHERHOODIN%GYPT(AMAS IN0ALESTINE(EZBOLLAHIN,EBANONAND(IZBU4AHRIRIN%NGLAND
! SECOND APPROACH TO SECULARIZATION IS TAKEN BY THE HYPER &UNDAMENTALISTSWHOAREIDEOLOGICALLYCLOSETO*IHADISTSRIGIDINTHEIR ATTITUDETOWARDTHERITUALSINTOLERANTOFISSUESRELATEDTOWOMENAND FREEDOMOFEXPRESSIONANDANTI 7ESTERNANDANTI DEMOCRATIC"UT THEYREJECTDIRECTVIOLENCEANDDONOTGETDIRECTLYINVOLVEDIN*IHAD 4HEIRROLEINSECULARIZING)SLAMISATBESTAMBIVALENT4HISISTHECASE OFSOME7AHHABIGROUPSIN3AUDI!RABIAANDTHELEGALBRANCHOFTHE &)3IN!LGERIAAMONGOTHERS
4HE THIRD APPROACH IS THE hNEUTRALv AND SOMETIMES hPRO DEMOCRATICv TENDENCIESMARKED BYMAINSTREAMMODERN VALUES DEFENDEDBYPARTOFTHENEWMIDDLECLASSES"UTTHISOCCURSWITHIN -USLIMSOCIETIESWHERESECULARTRENDSARESTILLSTIGMATIZEDUNLESSTHEY REINVIGORATETHERELIGIOUSVALUESLIKETHElRSTTREND ANDSTRIVETOlND ARELIGIOUSJUSTIlCATIONFORTHEIRSECULARIZATION4HESEGROUPSINTENDTO hMODERNIZEv)SLAMBYTRANSLATINGDEMOCRATICIDEASINTO)SLAMICIDIOMS FORINSTANCEBYCLAIMINGTHATDEMOCRACYISINITSGISTTHE3HURAOR THE+ORANICCONSULTATION
4HEREAREALSOGROUPSTHATACTTODE SECULARIZE-USLIMSOCIETIES /NECANDISTINGUISHAMONGTHEMATLEASTTWOGROUPS&IRSTARETHE TRADITIONALCONSERVATIVEGROUPSINCLUDINGCONSERVATIVEMERCHANTSTHE 5LAMAANDTHEIRCLIENTELEANDALLTHOSEPEOPLEWHOAREDESTABILIZED BYSOCIALCHANGEANDSEEKREFUGEINMYTHICTRADITIONS3ECONDARETHE *IHADISTSWHO INTENDTOBREAKOFF TIESWITHTHECHANGINGWORLDBY WAGINGWARAGAINSTDEMOCRACYTHE7ESTANDTHOSE-USLIMSWHODO NOTFOLLOWTHEIRCOURSEOFACTION
4HESECONDGROUPREACTSTOCULTURALMODERNIZATIONTHROUGHNON RELIGIOUSVALUESWITHINTHEWORLDOF)SLAM4HEMODERNIZINGGROUPS WHOSPEARHEADEDSECULARIZATIONWEREINTRINSICALLYhILLEGITIMATEvINTHE SECONDHALFOFTHETWENTIETHCENTURYINTHEEYESOFTHE-USLIMSIN A-USLIMWORLDMARKEDBYTHETRAUMAOFTHECREATIONOF)SRAELTHE FAILUREOFPOSTINDEPENDENCEPOLITICALREGIMESTHESETBACKSOFSECULAR POPULISM.ASSERIN%GYPT ANDMOREGLOBALLYTHEBREAKDOWNOR
MISCARRIAGEOFTHESECULARREGIMESTHE3HAHIN)RAN 4HEADVENTOF THE)SLAMIC2EVOLUTIONIN)RANINANDTHERESURGENCEOF3UNNI HYPER &UNDAMENTALISM AND RADICALISM IN THE-USLIMWORLD FROM THESONWARDINREACTIONTOTHEINVASIONOF!FGHANISTANBYTHE 3OVIET5NION REINFORCED THIS TENDENCY"ESIDES THE FEW COUNTRIES WHERESECULARGROUPSHAVEDEEPROOTSINDESPOTIC4UNISIAIN4URKEY ANDPARADOXICALLYIN)RAN INMOSTOFTHE-USLIMWORLDTHESECULAR TRENDSARE FRAGILE ANDPERCEIVEDAS hILLEGITIMATEvBY LARGENUMBERS OFTHEHYPER &UNDAMENTALISTSAND&UNDAMENTALISTSALIKEASWELLAS THE *IHADISTSWHO VIOLENTLY REJECT THEM&OR THEM SECULARIZATION HASRESULTEDINTHEDOWNFALLOF)SLAMICVALUESANDTHEDECLINEOFTHE -USLIMWORLD
&UNDAMENTALISMAND.EW3OCIAL'ROUPS
&ORMANY*IHADISTSTHECRITIQUEOFDEMOCRACYISMADEINCONJUNCTION WITHACULTURALMALAISERESULTINGFROMWOMENSTREADINGONTRADITIONS OFMODESTYANDFROMNATIONALANDSOCIALPROBLEMSTHATAUTHORITAR IANNATIONALISMHASBEENUNABLETOCOPEWITH4HEREACTIONTOTHESE FAILURESNOWEMERGESUNDERTHEGUISEOF)SLAMBECAUSEITISTHEONLY COLLECTIVEREFERENCESTILLUNTOUCHEDINITSSYMBOLICMEANINGBYTHECOR ROSIVEDISCREDITOFIDEOLOGIESWITHINMOST-USLIMSOCIETIESREINFORCING *IHADISTTENDENCIESTHATHAVEALWAYSEXISTEDINTHE)SLAMICWORLDASA TINYMINORITYPHENOMENON
4HE TRANSFORMATION OF *IHADISM FROM AMARGINAL AND SMALL MINORITYSMIND SETINTOASIGNIlCANTIDEOLOGICALMOVEMENTISRELATED TOTHEGLOBALMALAISEOF-USLIMCIVILIZATION4HEFAILUREOFSECULAR AUTOCRATIC GOVERNMENTS TO OPEN UP THEIR SOCIETIES POLITICALLY AND PROVIDEJOBOPPORTUNITIESTOMODERNIZEDANDHIGHLYEDUCATEDPEOPLE ISONEOFTHECAUSESOFTHRIVING*IHADISM3OMEOFTHEMOSTEXPOSED GROUPSˆENGINEERSANDMOREGENERALLYPROFESSIONALSWITHASCIENTIlC BACKGROUNDˆAREAMONGTHENEWGENERATIONSOF*IHADISTS4HEYHAVE HADACCESSTOHIGHEREDUCATIONMAINLYINTECHNOLOGICALlELDSWITH OUTREALJOBOPPORTUNITIESFORMOSTOFTHEM)NMUCHOFTHE-USLIM WORLDAHIGHPROPORTIONOFENGINEERSARE*IHADISTS)N%UROPETHE PICTUREDOESNOTHOLDANDPEOPLEWITHLESSEDUCATIONGETINVOLVEDIN )SLAMICRADICALISMBECAUSEOFTHEIRLACKOFOPPORTUNITIESINSOCIETY "UTONECANNOTREDUCETHEPHENOMENONTOALACKOFOPPORTUNITIES SINCEMANYENGINEERSAREINmUENCEDBYTHENEWRADICALIDEOLOGYAS WELLASBYTHEIRTECHNOLOGICALVIEWOFTHESOCIETY
/NTHEOTHERHANDENGINEERSANDSTUDENTSOFTECHNOLOGICALFAC ULTIESIN)RANARENOWADAYSATTHEHEADOFTHEMOVEMENTFORPOLITICAL
PLURALISM3HARIF4ECHNOLOGICAL5NIVERSITY!MIR+ABIR5NIVERSITY ANDSCIENCEDEPARTMENTSIN4EHRAN5NIVERSITY )N4URKEYENGINEERS AREACTIVEINNONVIOLENT)SLAMICPOLITICALPARTIES7HEREOPPORTUNITIES ARESEENASNONEXISTENTENGINEERSANDOTHERPROFESSIONALSDOCTORS SCIENTISTS MIGHTBEQUICKERTORADICALIZEBECAUSEOFTHEIRTECHNICIST FRAMEOFMINDWHICHISACCOMPANIEDBYTHESENSEOFHAVINGACALLING WITHINSOCIETY
)N-USLIMSOCIETIESWHERE*IHADISMISTHRIVINGNEWMODERNIZED GROUPSENGAGEINTHEMOVEMENTBECAUSETHEYFEELTHEYLACKAFUTURE OTHERWISEANDARENOWOFFEREDANOPPORTUNITYTOBETHEPROTAGONISTS OF)SLAMICREVIVALASWELLASTHEDISCREDITINGOFDEMOCRACYASANANTI )SLAMICSECULARIZINGTREND$EMOCRACYISEXPERIENCEDNOTSOMUCH AS THE ACTUAL POLITICAL PARTICIPATION OF ALL SOCIETY THIS HAS ALMOST NEVEROCCURRED BUTASASECULARIZINGTRENDRESULTINGINTHEDECLINE OFTHE-USLIMWORLD)NTHOSE-USLIMSOCIETIESWHEREAPOSSIBILITY MINIMALASITMAYBESEEMSTOBEOPENFORTHESEGROUPSTOIMPRINT CHANGEWITHIN SOCIETY LIKE4URKEY AND )RAN MODERNIZED GROUPS MIGHTENGAGEWITHPLURALISM4HECASESOF)RANAND4URKEYTENDTO PROVETHATTHENEWSOCIALACTORSLIKEMODERNIZEDWOMENSTUDENTS ENGINEERSANDSCIENTISTSINGENERALCANBEENROLLEDEITHERINAPLURAL ISTMOVEMENTAGAINSTTHECLOSUREOFTHEPOLITICALSCENEORINRADICAL MOVEMENTSTOTOPPLECORRUPTANDAUTOCRATICELITESTHATDONOTALLOW THEOPENINGOFSOCIETY-OBILIZATIONCANTHEREFOREOPERATEINBOTH WAYSTHROUGHMEMBERSHIPIN&UNDAMENTALISTOR*IHADISTGROUPSAND THROUGHENGAGEMENTINGROUPSlGHTINGFORPLURALISM)NBOTHCASES THESENEWSOCIALGROUPSRESULTINGFROMTHEMODERNIZATIONPROCESS BECOMEPRONETOSOCIALACTIVISM
.OTES
